Skip to content

Commit 897d912

Browse files
committed
docs: update comparison table with accurate mem0 features
- Add 'Pure openmemory MCP' column to differentiate from SDK usage - Correct mem0 auto-extraction: has infer=True but requires add() call - Correct mem0 PII detection: partial support exists - Add ROT cleanup and Ebbinghaus decay rows - Add 'Key Differences' section comparing OMP vs pure openmemory - Sync changes to both Chinese and English README
1 parent 447ea4b commit 897d912

2 files changed

Lines changed: 53 additions & 10 deletions

File tree

README.md

Lines changed: 24 additions & 10 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -669,16 +669,30 @@ your-project/
669669

670670
## 🔄 与其他方案对比
671671

672-
| 特性 | OpenMemory Plus | 原生 mem0 | 手动 .env | Notion/文档 |
673-
|------|-----------------|-----------|-----------|-------------|
674-
| 自动提取 || ❌ 需手动调用 |||
675-
| 双层架构 | ✅ 项目+用户 | ❌ 仅用户级 | ❌ 仅项目级 ||
676-
| 多 IDE 共享 |||||
677-
| Git 版本控制 | ✅ 项目级 ||||
678-
| 语义搜索 |||||
679-
| 智能分类 |||||
680-
| 敏感信息过滤 |||||
681-
| 一键安装 |||||
672+
| 特性 | OpenMemory Plus | 纯 openmemory MCP | 原生 mem0 SDK | 手动 .env | Notion/文档 |
673+
|------|-----------------|-------------------|---------------|-----------|-------------|
674+
| 自动提取 | ✅ 对话结束自动触发 | ⚠️ 需 Agent 主动调用 | ⚠️ 需代码调用 add() |||
675+
| 双层架构 | ✅ 项目+用户 | ❌ 仅用户级 | ❌ 仅用户级 | ❌ 仅项目级 ||
676+
| 多 IDE 共享 ||||||
677+
| Git 版本控制 | ✅ 项目级可追溯 |||||
678+
| 语义搜索 ||||||
679+
| 智能分类 | ✅ 自动 7 类型分类 | ❌ 需手动 metadata | ❌ 需手动 metadata |||
680+
| 敏感信息过滤 | ✅ 自动阻止存储 | ⚠️ 有 PII 检测 | ⚠️ 有 PII 检测 |||
681+
| 一键安装 |`npx omp install` | ⚠️ 需手动配置 MCP | ❌ 需代码集成 |||
682+
| ROT 记忆清理 | ✅ 自动识别冗余/过时 |||||
683+
| Ebbinghaus 衰减 | ✅ 遗忘曲线模型 |||||
684+
685+
> **图例**: ✅ 完整支持 | ⚠️ 部分支持 | ❌ 不支持
686+
687+
### 关键差异说明
688+
689+
| 对比项 | OpenMemory Plus | 纯 openmemory MCP |
690+
|--------|-----------------|-------------------|
691+
| **记忆触发** | 对话结束自动提取,无需用户干预 | Agent 需主动调用 `add_memories` 工具 |
692+
| **项目上下文** | `_omp/memory/` 存储项目决策和架构 | 无项目级记忆,所有记忆混在用户级 |
693+
| **记忆分类** | 自动分类为 preferences/decisions/patterns 等 | 需手动传入 metadata 参数 |
694+
| **记忆健康** | ROT 检测 + 健康度评分 + 衰减模型 | 无,记忆只增不减 |
695+
| **IDE 配置** | 自动生成 AGENTS.md/CLAUDE.md 等 | 需手动配置每个 IDE |
682696

683697
---
684698

README_EN.md

Lines changed: 29 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -589,6 +589,35 @@ your-project/
589589

590590
---
591591

592+
## 🔄 Comparison with Other Solutions
593+
594+
| Feature | OpenMemory Plus | Pure openmemory MCP | Native mem0 SDK | Manual .env | Notion/Docs |
595+
|---------|-----------------|---------------------|-----------------|-------------|-------------|
596+
| Auto Extraction | ✅ Auto-trigger at conversation end | ⚠️ Agent must call manually | ⚠️ Requires code call add() |||
597+
| Dual-Layer | ✅ Project + User | ❌ User-level only | ❌ User-level only | ❌ Project-level only ||
598+
| Multi-IDE Sharing ||||||
599+
| Git Version Control | ✅ Project-level traceable |||||
600+
| Semantic Search ||||||
601+
| Smart Classification | ✅ Auto 7-type classification | ❌ Requires manual metadata | ❌ Requires manual metadata |||
602+
| Sensitive Info Filter | ✅ Auto-block storage | ⚠️ Has PII detection | ⚠️ Has PII detection |||
603+
| One-Click Install |`npx omp install` | ⚠️ Manual MCP config | ❌ Code integration |||
604+
| ROT Memory Cleanup | ✅ Auto-detect redundant/obsolete |||||
605+
| Ebbinghaus Decay | ✅ Forgetting curve model |||||
606+
607+
> **Legend**: ✅ Full Support | ⚠️ Partial Support | ❌ Not Supported
608+
609+
### Key Differences
610+
611+
| Comparison | OpenMemory Plus | Pure openmemory MCP |
612+
|------------|-----------------|---------------------|
613+
| **Memory Trigger** | Auto-extract at conversation end, no user intervention | Agent must call `add_memories` tool |
614+
| **Project Context** | `_omp/memory/` stores project decisions & architecture | No project-level memory, all mixed at user level |
615+
| **Memory Classification** | Auto-classify into preferences/decisions/patterns | Requires manual metadata parameter |
616+
| **Memory Health** | ROT detection + health scoring + decay model | None, memories only increase |
617+
| **IDE Configuration** | Auto-generate AGENTS.md/CLAUDE.md etc. | Manual config for each IDE |
618+
619+
---
620+
592621
## ❓ FAQ
593622

594623
<details>

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)