Skip to content

Commit c078e73

Browse files
author
ddx-land-coordinator
committed
chore: add execution evidence [20260518T083105-]
1 parent 517d448 commit c078e73

5 files changed

Lines changed: 109 additions & 0 deletions

File tree

Lines changed: 4 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,4 @@
1+
{
2+
"status": "pass",
3+
"message": "no new top-level functions or methods added"
4+
}
Lines changed: 32 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,32 @@
1+
{
2+
"attempt_id": "20260518T083105-cbbc50b4",
3+
"bead_id": "ddx-e8956709",
4+
"base_rev": "2ccb7e034b5e0d19ec87e3f54b77bae83ee53b0a",
5+
"created_at": "2026-05-18T08:31:15.280428793Z",
6+
"requested": {
7+
"prompt": "synthesized"
8+
},
9+
"bead": {
10+
"id": "ddx-e8956709",
11+
"title": "code: align reconcile.go with ClosureGate specification and comment store.go:471",
12+
"description": "PROBLEM\nreconcile.go:239-243 bypasses ClosureGate via ManualClose=true but the reasoning is only documented in code comments. store.go:471 (Create-time status default) needs an explicit note that it is the single exception to the lifecycle.go lifecycle-transition rule.\n\nROOT CAUSE\nB1 will document the specification. This bead aligns the code's lifecycle enforcement to match:\n1. reconcile.go bypass is safe and documented (already there, just needs cross-reference).\n2. store.go:471 Create-time StatusOpen assignment is explicit and noted as the lone exception.\n3. All other status writes flow through transitionLifecycleInPlace + ValidateLifecycleTransition.\n\nPROPOSED FIX\n1. Add a docstring reference in reconcile.go:236 to link the bypass to TD-031 §3.1 (ClosureGate semantics).\n2. Add an inline comment at store.go:471 documenting that Create-time defaults StatusOpen and does not route through ValidateLifecycleTransition (the lone exception).\n3. Verify no other Status assignments exist outside this whitelist: {Create, transitionLifecycleInPlace, lifecycle.go, reconcile.go}.\n\nNON-SCOPE\nDo not rewrite the ClosureGate enforcement itself. Do not add new helpers or refactor transitionLifecycleInPlace.\n",
13+
"acceptance": "1. reconcile.go:236-250 references TD-031 §3.1 or equivalent spec section on ClosureGate bypass semantics.\n2. store.go:471 has a documented comment explaining Create-time StatusOpen is the single exception to ValidateLifecycleTransition.\n3. grep -n 'Status.*=' cli/internal/bead/{lifecycle,store,reconcile}.go confirms no other Status assignments outside Create/transitionLifecycleInPlace/lifecycle.\n4. cd cli \u0026\u0026 go test ./internal/bead/reconcile_test.go passes.\n5. cd cli \u0026\u0026 go test ./internal/bead/store_test.go passes (specifically Create and TestBackendConformance_TransitionMatrix tests).\n",
14+
"parent": "ddx-6e6d08f8",
15+
"labels": [
16+
"phase:6",
17+
"area:bead",
18+
"area:lifecycle",
19+
"kind:code"
20+
]
21+
},
22+
"paths": {
23+
"dir": ".ddx/executions/20260518T083105-cbbc50b4",
24+
"prompt": ".ddx/executions/20260518T083105-cbbc50b4/prompt.md",
25+
"manifest": ".ddx/executions/20260518T083105-cbbc50b4/manifest.json",
26+
"result": ".ddx/executions/20260518T083105-cbbc50b4/result.json",
27+
"checks": ".ddx/executions/20260518T083105-cbbc50b4/checks.json",
28+
"usage": ".ddx/executions/20260518T083105-cbbc50b4/usage.json",
29+
"worktree": "var/tmp/ddx-exec-wt/.execute-bead-wt-ddx-e8956709-20260518T083105-cbbc50b4"
30+
},
31+
"prompt_sha": "0fd79e974a428b637402cce4f1a91d152a0b1d1c3977f17aefc0c2b1c0b7f8d7"
32+
}
Lines changed: 19 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,19 @@
1+
<execute-bead>
2+
<instructions>
3+
You are executing one bead in an isolated DDx execution worktree. The bead&#39;s &lt;description&gt; and &lt;acceptance&gt; are the contract: every AC must be provably satisfied by a specific code, test, or file after your commit.&#xA;&#xA;## Step 0: size check&#xA;&#xA;Too big if any holds:&#xA;&#xA;- More than ~6 ACs spanning unrelated subsystems.&#xA;- AC mixes design, implementation, integration tests, and docs.&#xA;- Description names multiple feature-sized pieces.&#xA;- More than ~500 lines across ~5+ files in unrelated packages.&#xA;- If the bead description exceeds 8000 bytes, use a split-first pass.&#xA;- Auto-decomposition is capped at depth 2: root beads may split once, children once more; reject third-level splits with an explanation.&#xA;&#xA;If too big, decompose:&#xA;&#xA;1. `ddx bead create` for each child (copy parent&#39;s labels and spec-id).&#xA;2. `ddx bead dep add &lt;child-id&gt; &lt;parent-id&gt;` to record edges.&#xA;3. `ddx bead update &lt;parent-id&gt; --notes &#39;decomposed into &lt;child-ids&gt;&#39;`.&#xA;4. Write `no_changes_rationale.txt` under the bead metadata `bundle` path with child IDs, then stop.&#xA;&#xA;Decomposition alone is success. Do not mix it with implementation.&#xA;&#xA;## How to work&#xA;&#xA;- Read first. If the bead names files, specs, or prior beads, read them before editing — do not guess.&#xA;- Cross-reference each AC to concrete evidence (test, file, function) before committing. If you cannot point at it, it is not done.&#xA;- Run the project&#39;s test and lint commands before committing. **Do not commit red code** — fix failures first.&#xA;- Run git/index mutations sequentially; do not use parallel tool calls for `git add`, `git commit`, or other staging/commit commands.&#xA;- Stage with `git add &lt;specific-paths&gt;`; never `git add -A` (the worktree may have unrelated WIP).&#xA;- If `lefthook run pre-commit` depends on staged files, rerun it after staging the exact commit set. A `no-staged-files` run is not acceptance evidence.&#xA;- Commit exactly once when green; conventional-commit subject ending with `[&lt;bead-id&gt;]`. Stop after the commit.&#xA;- Do not modify files outside the bead&#39;s scope.&#xA;- Current-bead lifecycle is orchestrator-owned. Do not run `ddx bead update &lt;bead-id&gt; --claim`, `ddx bead update &lt;bead-id&gt; --status &lt;status&gt;`, `ddx bead update &lt;bead-id&gt; --unclaim`, or `ddx bead close &lt;bead-id&gt;`. Step 0 still allows `ddx bead create`, `ddx bead dep add`, and `ddx bead update &lt;parent-id&gt; --notes &#39;decomposed into &lt;child-ids&gt;&#39;`.&#xA;- If you cannot finish, write `no_changes_rationale.txt` under the bead metadata `bundle` path before exiting. No commit or rationale ⇒ DDx records `no_evidence_produced`.&#xA;&#xA;## no_changes contract&#xA;&#xA;The `no_changes_rationale.txt` file under the bead metadata `bundle` path must contain one of:&#xA;&#xA;- `verification_command: &lt;cmd&gt;` — repo cwd; exit 0 closes, nonzero rejects.&#xA;- `status: open` + `reason: &lt;retryable&gt;` — open, smart retry.&#xA;- `status: proposed` + `reason: &lt;operator needed&gt;` — operator lane.&#xA;- `status: blocked` + `reason: &lt;external blocker&gt;` — blocked lane.&#xA;&#xA;No pseudo-statuses. Bare rationales and `status: needs_investigation` are rejected.&#xA;&#xA;For orchestrator decomposition, add `orchestrator_action: decompose` alongside `status: open`.&#xA;&#xA;## Reports&#xA;&#xA;Reports go under the bead metadata `bundle` path in `.ddx/executions/`. **Never write reports to `/tmp` or outside the repo**. Use a named in-repo path when given; otherwise write `&lt;short-name&gt;.md` there. Commit it with the code.&#xA;&#xA;## Mode and overrides&#xA;&#xA;DDX_MODE=bead_execution: edit code/docs for bead AC. Only broad queue-steward default is overridden; tracker, merge-policy, verification, safety stay active. Bead description/AC override CLAUDE.md, AGENTS.md, and defaults.&#xA;&#xA;## Review gate&#xA;&#xA;- The review is a gate, not an escape hatch — meet every AC in this pass.&#xA;- Address every BLOCKING `&lt;review-findings&gt;` item; do not declare `no_changes` with blocking findings open.&#xA;&#xA;## Constraints&#xA;&#xA;- Work only inside this execution worktree.&#xA;- Keep `.ddx/executions/` intact — DDx uses it as execution evidence.&#xA;- **Never run `ddx init`** — the workspace is initialized.&#xA;- Do not modify files outside the bead&#39;s named scope.&#xA;- Do not rewrite CLAUDE.md, AGENTS.md, or other instruction files unless the bead asks.&#xA;&#xA;## When the work is done&#xA;&#xA;After the commit succeeds and every AC is verified, stop. Return control to the orchestrator.
4+
</instructions>
5+
<bead id="ddx-e8956709">
6+
<title>code: align reconcile.go with ClosureGate specification and comment store.go:471</title>
7+
<description>
8+
PROBLEM&#xA;reconcile.go:239-243 bypasses ClosureGate via ManualClose=true but the reasoning is only documented in code comments. store.go:471 (Create-time status default) needs an explicit note that it is the single exception to the lifecycle.go lifecycle-transition rule.&#xA;&#xA;ROOT CAUSE&#xA;B1 will document the specification. This bead aligns the code&#39;s lifecycle enforcement to match:&#xA;1. reconcile.go bypass is safe and documented (already there, just needs cross-reference).&#xA;2. store.go:471 Create-time StatusOpen assignment is explicit and noted as the lone exception.&#xA;3. All other status writes flow through transitionLifecycleInPlace + ValidateLifecycleTransition.&#xA;&#xA;PROPOSED FIX&#xA;1. Add a docstring reference in reconcile.go:236 to link the bypass to TD-031 §3.1 (ClosureGate semantics).&#xA;2. Add an inline comment at store.go:471 documenting that Create-time defaults StatusOpen and does not route through ValidateLifecycleTransition (the lone exception).&#xA;3. Verify no other Status assignments exist outside this whitelist: {Create, transitionLifecycleInPlace, lifecycle.go, reconcile.go}.&#xA;&#xA;NON-SCOPE&#xA;Do not rewrite the ClosureGate enforcement itself. Do not add new helpers or refactor transitionLifecycleInPlace.
9+
</description>
10+
<acceptance>
11+
1. reconcile.go:236-250 references TD-031 §3.1 or equivalent spec section on ClosureGate bypass semantics.&#xA;2. store.go:471 has a documented comment explaining Create-time StatusOpen is the single exception to ValidateLifecycleTransition.&#xA;3. grep -n &#39;Status.*=&#39; cli/internal/bead/{lifecycle,store,reconcile}.go confirms no other Status assignments outside Create/transitionLifecycleInPlace/lifecycle.&#xA;4. cd cli &amp;&amp; go test ./internal/bead/reconcile_test.go passes.&#xA;5. cd cli &amp;&amp; go test ./internal/bead/store_test.go passes (specifically Create and TestBackendConformance_TransitionMatrix tests).
12+
</acceptance>
13+
<labels>phase:6, area:bead, area:lifecycle, kind:code</labels>
14+
<metadata parent="ddx-6e6d08f8" base-rev="2ccb7e034b5e0d19ec87e3f54b77bae83ee53b0a" bundle=".ddx/executions/20260518T083105-cbbc50b4"/>
15+
</bead>
16+
<governing>
17+
<note>No governing references were pre-resolved. The bead description above is the primary contract. If it names files, specs, or prior beads, read them first. Ground decisions in repository state; do not guess.</note>
18+
</governing>
19+
</execute-bead>
Lines changed: 43 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,43 @@
1+
{
2+
"bead_id": "ddx-e8956709",
3+
"attempt_id": "20260518T083105-cbbc50b4",
4+
"base_rev": "2ccb7e034b5e0d19ec87e3f54b77bae83ee53b0a",
5+
"result_rev": "517d448bd1cb57f3bec09b36b80a02f44cb2be84",
6+
"implementation_rev": "517d448bd1cb57f3bec09b36b80a02f44cb2be84",
7+
"landed_rev": "517d448bd1cb57f3bec09b36b80a02f44cb2be84",
8+
"landed_branch": "main",
9+
"outcome": "merged",
10+
"status": "success",
11+
"detail": "success",
12+
"orchestrator_status": "success",
13+
"candidate_ref": "refs/ddx/iterations/20260518T083105-cbbc50b4/0",
14+
"cycle_trace": [
15+
{
16+
"cycle_index": 0,
17+
"attempt_id": "20260518T083105-cbbc50b4",
18+
"result_rev": "517d448bd1cb57f3bec09b36b80a02f44cb2be84",
19+
"implementer_route": {
20+
"harness": "claude",
21+
"model": "haiku"
22+
},
23+
"review_result": {},
24+
"final_decision": "success"
25+
}
26+
],
27+
"harness": "claude",
28+
"model": "haiku",
29+
"session_id": "eb-eac427ab",
30+
"duration_ms": 400083,
31+
"tokens": 10104,
32+
"cost_usd": 0.37830934999999993,
33+
"exit_code": 0,
34+
"project_root": "/Users/erik/Projects/ddx",
35+
"execution_dir": ".ddx/executions/20260518T083105-cbbc50b4",
36+
"prompt_file": ".ddx/executions/20260518T083105-cbbc50b4/prompt.md",
37+
"manifest_file": ".ddx/executions/20260518T083105-cbbc50b4/manifest.json",
38+
"result_file": ".ddx/executions/20260518T083105-cbbc50b4/result.json",
39+
"usage_file": ".ddx/executions/20260518T083105-cbbc50b4/usage.json",
40+
"rate_limit_budget": 300000000000,
41+
"started_at": "2026-05-18T08:31:15.291161479Z",
42+
"finished_at": "2026-05-18T08:37:55.374687714Z"
43+
}
Lines changed: 11 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
1+
{
2+
"attempt_id": "20260518T083105-cbbc50b4",
3+
"harness": "claude",
4+
"model": "haiku",
5+
"tokens": 10104,
6+
"input_tokens": 240,
7+
"cached_tokens": 2593281,
8+
"cache_hit_rate": 0.9999074617093905,
9+
"output_tokens": 9864,
10+
"cost_usd": 0.37830934999999993
11+
}

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)