diff --git a/src/libs/CardUtils.ts b/src/libs/CardUtils.ts
index 8cfa1b36d7dc..2f82b763a68c 100644
--- a/src/libs/CardUtils.ts
+++ b/src/libs/CardUtils.ts
@@ -968,12 +968,18 @@ function getCardAssignmentStartDate(isEditing: boolean | undefined, existingStar
     return isEditing ? (existingStartDate ?? format(new Date(), CONST.DATE.FNS_FORMAT_STRING)) : format(new Date(), CONST.DATE.FNS_FORMAT_STRING);
 }
 
-function checkIfNewFeedConnected(prevFeedsData: CompanyFeeds, currentFeedsData: CompanyFeeds, plaidBank?: string) {
+function checkIfNewFeedConnected(prevFeedsData: CombinedCardFeeds, currentFeedsData: CombinedCardFeeds, plaidBank?: string) {
     const prevFeeds = Object.keys(prevFeedsData);
     const currentFeeds = Object.keys(currentFeedsData);
 
+    const plaidBankFound =
+        plaidBank &&
+        currentFeeds.find((feed) => {
+            return splitCardFeedWithDomainID(feed as CompanyCardFeedWithDomainID)?.feedName === `${CONST.BANK_ACCOUNT.SETUP_TYPE.PLAID}.${plaidBank}`;
+        });
+
     return {
-        isNewFeedConnected: currentFeeds.length > prevFeeds.length || (plaidBank && currentFeeds.includes(`${CONST.BANK_ACCOUNT.SETUP_TYPE.PLAID}.${plaidBank}`)),
+        isNewFeedConnected: currentFeeds.length > prevFeeds.length || plaidBankFound,
         newFeed: currentFeeds.find((feed) => !prevFeeds.includes(feed)) as CompanyCardFeedWithDomainID | undefined,
     };
 }
diff --git a/src/pages/settings/Wallet/PersonalCards/useGetNewPersonalCard.ts b/src/pages/settings/Wallet/PersonalCards/useGetNewPersonalCard.ts
index bc7dad042f6c..10af93322ecb 100644
--- a/src/pages/settings/Wallet/PersonalCards/useGetNewPersonalCard.ts
+++ b/src/pages/settings/Wallet/PersonalCards/useGetNewPersonalCard.ts
@@ -17,14 +17,15 @@ export default function useGetNewPersonalCard() {
             prevCardListRef.current = cardList;
             return;
         }
-        const prevCardList = prevCardListRef.current;
-        const prevIds = new Set(Object.keys(prevCardList));
-        const currentIds = Object.keys(cardList);
-        const newCardIds = currentIds.filter((id) => !prevIds.has(id));
-        if (newCardIds.length > 0) {
-            for (const id of newCardIds) {
-                setNewCard(cardList[id]);
-            }
+
+        // Find the first card that is either new or has a fresh import timestamp
+        const latestChange = Object.values(cardList).find((card) => {
+            const prev = prevCardListRef.current?.[card.cardID];
+            return !prev || card.lastImportAttempt !== prev.lastImportAttempt;
+        });
+
+        if (latestChange) {
+            setNewCard(latestChange);
         }
 
         prevCardListRef.current = cardList;
diff --git a/src/types/onyx/Card.ts b/src/types/onyx/Card.ts
index 57cec8f15510..ad421678c53f 100644
--- a/src/types/onyx/Card.ts
+++ b/src/types/onyx/Card.ts
@@ -105,6 +105,9 @@ type Card = OnyxCommon.OnyxValueWithOfflineFeedback<{
     /** Last update result */
     lastScrapeResult?: number;
 
+    /** Last import attempt */
+    lastImportAttempt?: string;
+
     /** Card related error messages */
     errors?: OnyxCommon.Errors;