Skip to content

Commit 9d4ea37

Browse files
FoundupFoundups Agentclaude
authored
docs(voteballots): add Vote PoC chain governance closure snapshot (#715)
Locks the Vote PoC chain in implementation-complete, not-public-launched state. Records 6/6 merged slices with merge commits: - #707 FEC Adapter: 15de3d3 - #709 Entity Resolution: b5b3eea - #710 Funding Summary: 1a3d06b - #712 Confidence Scoring: 4559a8e - #713 Quick Answer: 7895459 - #714 Shell Integration: 7e4e571 Defines re-open criteria V1-V8 for future Vote work. Tests: 303 passed, entry_url remains empty. DOCS-ONLY: No code, test, manifest, or registry changes. Worker-Lane: W9 Slice: VOTE_POC_CHAIN_OBSERVATION_SNAPSHOT_PHASE1 Co-authored-by: Foundups Agent <dev@foundups.com> Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
1 parent 7e4e571 commit 9d4ea37

1 file changed

Lines changed: 310 additions & 0 deletions

File tree

‎docs/audits/architecture/VOTE_POC_CHAIN_OBSERVATION_SNAPSHOT_PHASE1.md‎

Lines changed: 310 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,310 @@
1+
# VOTE_POC_CHAIN_OBSERVATION_SNAPSHOT_PHASE1
2+
3+
**Slice**: `VOTE_POC_CHAIN_OBSERVATION_SNAPSHOT_PHASE1`
4+
**Worker**: W9
5+
**Date**: 2026-05-25
6+
**Status**: GOVERNANCE CLOSURE
7+
**Mode**: DOCS-ONLY
8+
9+
---
10+
11+
## Critical Statement
12+
13+
**Implementation-complete does NOT mean public-launched.**
14+
15+
The Vote PoC chain is implementation-complete (6/6 slices merged). It is NOT:
16+
- Publicly launched
17+
- Route-activated
18+
- Registry-promoted
19+
- CABR-ready
20+
- Payout-ready
21+
- DAO-ready
22+
23+
This snapshot locks the chain in its current state and defines re-open criteria.
24+
25+
---
26+
27+
## 1. Mission and Scope
28+
29+
### 1.1 Objective
30+
31+
Lock the Vote PoC chain in its implementation-complete, not-public-launched state. This is a governance closure snapshot that:
32+
- Records the six merged slices with their merge commits
33+
- Documents current test and truth-boundary evidence
34+
- Lists prohibited surfaces that remain closed
35+
- Defines exact criteria required to re-open Vote work
36+
37+
### 1.2 Constraints
38+
39+
This slice is DOCS-ONLY:
40+
- NO code mutation
41+
- NO test mutation
42+
- NO manifest/registry/catalog/projection mutation
43+
- NO route activation
44+
- NO public file creation
45+
- NO live FEC API
46+
- NO network/LLM calls
47+
48+
---
49+
50+
## 2. HoloIndex Retrieval Assessment
51+
52+
### 2.1 Searches Performed
53+
54+
| Query | Hits | Top Results | Quality |
55+
|-------|------|-------------|---------|
56+
| VOTE_POC_FEC_ADAPTER_PHASE1 | 20 | moltbot tests, trade adapters | Medium - semantic drift |
57+
| VOTE_POC_ENTITY_RESOLUTION_PHASE1 | 20 | VoteBallots audit docs | High |
58+
| VOTE_POC_FUNDING_SUMMARY_PHASE1 | 20 | Trade simulation docs | Medium |
59+
| VOTE_POC_CONFIDENCE_SCORING_INTEGRATION_PHASE1 | 20 | WSP docs, audit docs | High |
60+
| VOTE_POC_QUICK_ANSWER_GENERATION_PHASE1 | 20 | Theorist DAE, AI overseer | Medium |
61+
| VOTE_POC_SHELL_INTEGRATION_PHASE1 | 20 | Shell tests, WSP 97 | High |
62+
63+
### 2.2 Assessment
64+
65+
- **Noise**: Medium - some semantic drift to Trade and other PoC docs
66+
- **Ordering**: Acceptable - audit docs appear but not always top-ranked
67+
- **Missing**: None - all 6 audit docs exist and are findable
68+
- **Staleness**: None - all docs current post-merge
69+
- **Retrieval recommendation**: Direct file path access for Vote audit docs is reliable; HoloIndex semantic search supplements but doesn't replace targeted reads
70+
71+
---
72+
73+
## 3. Six-Slice Canonical Chain Inventory
74+
75+
| Slice | PR | Merge Commit | Status | Audit Doc |
76+
|-------|-----|--------------|--------|-----------|
77+
| Slice 1: FEC Adapter | #707 | 15de3d392 | MERGED | VOTE_POC_FEC_ADAPTER_PHASE1.md |
78+
| Slice 2: Entity Resolution | #709 | b5b3eea29 | MERGED | VOTE_POC_ENTITY_RESOLUTION_PHASE1.md |
79+
| Slice 3: Funding Summary | #710 | 1a3d06bd7 | MERGED | VOTE_POC_FUNDING_SUMMARY_PHASE1.md |
80+
| Slice 4: Confidence Scoring | #712 | 4559a8e45 | MERGED | VOTE_POC_CONFIDENCE_SCORING_INTEGRATION_PHASE1.md |
81+
| Slice 5: Quick Answer | #713 | 789545931 | MERGED | VOTE_POC_QUICK_ANSWER_GENERATION_PHASE1.md |
82+
| Slice 6: Shell Integration | #714 | 7e4e5718e | MERGED | VOTE_POC_SHELL_INTEGRATION_PHASE1.md |
83+
84+
**Chain Status**: 6/6 slices MERGED on main
85+
86+
---
87+
88+
## 4. Current Vote PoC State
89+
90+
### 4.1 Implementation Inventory
91+
92+
| Component | Location | Lines | Status |
93+
|-----------|----------|-------|--------|
94+
| FEC Adapter | `src/fec_adapter.py` | ~810 | Complete |
95+
| Entity Resolution | `src/entity_resolution.py` | ~280 | Complete |
96+
| Funding Summary | `src/funding_summary.py` | ~420 | Complete |
97+
| Confidence Scoring | `src/confidence_scoring.py` | ~480 | Complete |
98+
| Quick Answer | `src/quick_answer.py` | ~530 | Complete |
99+
| Shell Integration | `src/shell_integration.py` | ~320 | Complete |
100+
| Module Exports | `src/__init__.py` | ~200 | Complete |
101+
102+
### 4.2 Public API Contract
103+
104+
```python
105+
from modules.foundups.voteballots.src import (
106+
# Slice 1: FEC Adapter
107+
get_mock_adapter, MockFECAdapter, CandidateRecord, FECSource,
108+
109+
# Slice 2: Entity Resolution
110+
EntityResolutionRequest, resolve_candidate_entity, resolve_by_name,
111+
112+
# Slice 3: Funding Summary
113+
FundingSummaryRequest, summarize_candidate_funding, TrailTerminationMarker,
114+
115+
# Slice 4: Confidence Scoring
116+
ConfidenceLabel, HumanReviewTrigger, score_funding_summary_confidence,
117+
118+
# Slice 5: Quick Answer
119+
QuickAnswer, generate_shell_answer, is_answer_ready_for_display,
120+
121+
# Slice 6: Shell Integration
122+
VoteShellPayload, build_vote_shell_payload, is_payload_ready,
123+
)
124+
```
125+
126+
---
127+
128+
## 5. Test and Forbidden-Surface Evidence
129+
130+
### 5.1 Test Results
131+
132+
```
133+
python -m pytest modules/foundups/voteballots/tests/ -q
134+
303 passed in 0.62s
135+
```
136+
137+
| Module | Tests |
138+
|--------|-------|
139+
| FEC Adapter | 46 |
140+
| Entity Resolution | 70 |
141+
| Funding Summary | 42 |
142+
| Confidence Scoring | 37 |
143+
| Quick Answer | 46 |
144+
| Shell Integration | 62 |
145+
| **Total** | **303** |
146+
147+
### 5.2 Forbidden Import Scan
148+
149+
All 6 slices verified clean of:
150+
- LLM imports (openai, anthropic, ollama, transformers)
151+
- Network imports beyond stdlib
152+
- Live FEC API calls
153+
154+
### 5.3 Forbidden Language Scan
155+
156+
All 6 slices verified clean of:
157+
- Recommendation language ("should vote", "endorse", "best candidate")
158+
- Persuasion language ("you must", "urgent", "act now")
159+
- Targeting fields (user_id, demographic, location)
160+
161+
---
162+
163+
## 6. Shell/Public Boundary Status
164+
165+
### 6.1 Manifest State
166+
167+
```json
168+
{
169+
"foundup_id": "voteballots",
170+
"entry_url": "",
171+
"launch_readiness": "discoverable_only",
172+
"routing_prefix": "/f/voteballots"
173+
}
174+
```
175+
176+
- `entry_url` is EMPTY (not activated)
177+
- `launch_readiness` is `discoverable_only` (not launchable)
178+
179+
### 6.2 Shell Payload Contract
180+
181+
The shell integration layer defines:
182+
- `FOUNDUP_ID = "voteballots"` (readonly)
183+
- `ROUTE_NAMESPACE = "/f/voteballots"` (readonly)
184+
- `APP_MOUNT = "/f/voteballots/app"` (NOT activated)
185+
186+
The payload contract exists for future shell work but:
187+
- No route handlers exist
188+
- No public files created
189+
- No shell behavior modified
190+
191+
### 6.3 Public Surface Status
192+
193+
| Surface | Status |
194+
|---------|--------|
195+
| entry_url | EMPTY |
196+
| Route handlers | NONE |
197+
| Public files | NONE |
198+
| Shell integration | LOCAL CONTRACT ONLY |
199+
| Registry promotion | NOT PERFORMED |
200+
| Catalog entry | NOT ACTIVATED |
201+
| Projection | NOT CREATED |
202+
203+
---
204+
205+
## 7. Re-Open Criteria V1-V8
206+
207+
Any future Vote work must cite one of these criteria and create a new architect packet.
208+
209+
| ID | Criterion | Required Packet |
210+
|----|-----------|-----------------|
211+
| V1 | Live FEC API activation | VOTE_POC_LIVE_FEC_BOUNDARY_PHASE1 |
212+
| V2 | Public route or entry_url activation | VOTE_POC_PUBLIC_ROUTE_ACTIVATION_PHASE1 |
213+
| V3 | Registry/entity promotion | VOTE_POC_REGISTRY_PROMOTION_PHASE1 |
214+
| V4 | Persuasion/recommendation/targeting language | VOTE_POC_POLITICAL_SAFETY_REVIEW_PHASE1 |
215+
| V5 | Confidence rule or human-review trigger change | VOTE_POC_CONFIDENCE_RULE_REVIEW_PHASE2 |
216+
| V6 | Quick-answer new facts, LLM, or prose expansion | VOTE_POC_ANSWER_GENERATION_BOUNDARY_PHASE2 |
217+
| V7 | Manifest/catalog/projection/CABR/payout/DAO claim | VOTE_POC_GOVERNANCE_BOUNDARY_PHASE1 |
218+
| V8 | Shell payload contract or namespace change | VOTE_POC_SHELL_CONTRACT_PHASE2 |
219+
220+
### 7.1 Re-Open Process
221+
222+
1. Architect creates packet citing V1-V8 criterion
223+
2. Worker executes under WSP governance
224+
3. W10 merge gate validates boundary compliance
225+
4. New snapshot records state change
226+
227+
---
228+
229+
## 8. What This Snapshot Does NOT Do
230+
231+
This snapshot explicitly does NOT:
232+
233+
| Action | Status |
234+
|--------|--------|
235+
| Activate public routes | NO |
236+
| Set entry_url | NO |
237+
| Promote to registry | NO |
238+
| Create catalog entry | NO |
239+
| Create projection | NO |
240+
| Enable CABR | NO |
241+
| Enable payout | NO |
242+
| Enable DAO | NO |
243+
| Call live FEC API | NO |
244+
| Call any LLM | NO |
245+
| Generate new facts | NO |
246+
| Add persuasion language | NO |
247+
| Add targeting fields | NO |
248+
| Modify any code | NO |
249+
| Modify any tests | NO |
250+
| Modify manifest | NO |
251+
252+
---
253+
254+
## 9. Recommended Next Direction
255+
256+
The Vote PoC chain is implementation-complete. Potential next steps (each requires architect packet):
257+
258+
| Priority | Direction | Criterion |
259+
|----------|-----------|-----------|
260+
| P1 | Live FEC API integration | V1 |
261+
| P2 | User testing with mock data | No new criterion (current state) |
262+
| P3 | Shell UI wireframe | V8 |
263+
| P4 | Public beta preparation | V2, V3 |
264+
265+
**No automatic next slice.** Any future Vote work must cite V1-V8.
266+
267+
---
268+
269+
## 10. WSP 97 Truth Boundary Checklist
270+
271+
| # | Truth Boundary Checklist Item | Status | Evidence |
272+
|---|-------------------------------|--------|----------|
273+
| 1 | VOTE_CHAIN_OBSERVATION_SNAPSHOT_ONLY | YES | This doc only |
274+
| 2 | DOCS_ONLY | YES | No code/test changes |
275+
| 3 | GOVERNANCE_CLOSURE_ONLY | YES | Records state, defines re-open |
276+
| 4 | IMPLEMENTATION_COMPLETE_NOT_PUBLIC_LAUNCHED | YES | Critical statement |
277+
| 5 | NO_CODE_CHANGE | YES | No src files touched |
278+
| 6 | NO_TEST_CHANGE | YES | No test files touched |
279+
| 7 | NO_PUBLIC_ROUTE_ACTIVATION | YES | entry_url empty |
280+
| 8 | NO_ENTRY_URL_ACTIVATION | YES | Manifest verified |
281+
| 9 | NO_REGISTRY_PROMOTION | YES | No registry changes |
282+
| 10 | NO_CATALOG_MUTATION | YES | No catalog changes |
283+
| 11 | NO_MANIFEST_MUTATION | YES | Manifest unchanged |
284+
| 12 | NO_PROJECTION_MUTATION | YES | No projection changes |
285+
| 13 | NO_LIVE_FEC_CALL | YES | MockFECAdapter only |
286+
| 14 | NO_NETWORK_CALL | YES | No network imports |
287+
| 15 | NO_LLM_CALL | YES | No LLM imports |
288+
| 16 | NO_NEW_FACTS | YES | Snapshot only |
289+
| 17 | NO_PERSUASION | YES | No persuasion language |
290+
| 18 | NO_TARGETING | YES | No targeting fields |
291+
| 19 | NO_CABR_READY | YES | No CABR claim |
292+
| 20 | NO_PAYOUT_READY | YES | No payout claim |
293+
| 21 | NO_DAO_ACTIVATION | YES | No DAO claim |
294+
| 22 | RE_OPEN_CRITERIA_RECORDED | YES | V1-V8 defined |
295+
296+
**WSP 97 Truth Boundary Checklist: 22/22 YES**
297+
298+
---
299+
300+
## 11. Files in Scope
301+
302+
| File | Action |
303+
|------|--------|
304+
| `docs/audits/architecture/VOTE_POC_CHAIN_OBSERVATION_SNAPSHOT_PHASE1.md` | CREATE (this file) |
305+
306+
No other files modified.
307+
308+
---
309+
310+
*W9 complete for VOTE_POC_CHAIN_OBSERVATION_SNAPSHOT_PHASE1. Vote PoC chain locked in implementation-complete, not-public-launched state. Re-open requires V1-V8 criterion citation.*

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)