diff --git a/docs/audits/architecture/VOTE_POC_CHAIN_OBSERVATION_SNAPSHOT_PHASE1.md b/docs/audits/architecture/VOTE_POC_CHAIN_OBSERVATION_SNAPSHOT_PHASE1.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..b7371077 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/audits/architecture/VOTE_POC_CHAIN_OBSERVATION_SNAPSHOT_PHASE1.md @@ -0,0 +1,310 @@ +# VOTE_POC_CHAIN_OBSERVATION_SNAPSHOT_PHASE1 + +**Slice**: `VOTE_POC_CHAIN_OBSERVATION_SNAPSHOT_PHASE1` +**Worker**: W9 +**Date**: 2026-05-25 +**Status**: GOVERNANCE CLOSURE +**Mode**: DOCS-ONLY + +--- + +## Critical Statement + +**Implementation-complete does NOT mean public-launched.** + +The Vote PoC chain is implementation-complete (6/6 slices merged). It is NOT: +- Publicly launched +- Route-activated +- Registry-promoted +- CABR-ready +- Payout-ready +- DAO-ready + +This snapshot locks the chain in its current state and defines re-open criteria. + +--- + +## 1. Mission and Scope + +### 1.1 Objective + +Lock the Vote PoC chain in its implementation-complete, not-public-launched state. This is a governance closure snapshot that: +- Records the six merged slices with their merge commits +- Documents current test and truth-boundary evidence +- Lists prohibited surfaces that remain closed +- Defines exact criteria required to re-open Vote work + +### 1.2 Constraints + +This slice is DOCS-ONLY: +- NO code mutation +- NO test mutation +- NO manifest/registry/catalog/projection mutation +- NO route activation +- NO public file creation +- NO live FEC API +- NO network/LLM calls + +--- + +## 2. HoloIndex Retrieval Assessment + +### 2.1 Searches Performed + +| Query | Hits | Top Results | Quality | +|-------|------|-------------|---------| +| VOTE_POC_FEC_ADAPTER_PHASE1 | 20 | moltbot tests, trade adapters | Medium - semantic drift | +| VOTE_POC_ENTITY_RESOLUTION_PHASE1 | 20 | VoteBallots audit docs | High | +| VOTE_POC_FUNDING_SUMMARY_PHASE1 | 20 | Trade simulation docs | Medium | +| VOTE_POC_CONFIDENCE_SCORING_INTEGRATION_PHASE1 | 20 | WSP docs, audit docs | High | +| VOTE_POC_QUICK_ANSWER_GENERATION_PHASE1 | 20 | Theorist DAE, AI overseer | Medium | +| VOTE_POC_SHELL_INTEGRATION_PHASE1 | 20 | Shell tests, WSP 97 | High | + +### 2.2 Assessment + +- **Noise**: Medium - some semantic drift to Trade and other PoC docs +- **Ordering**: Acceptable - audit docs appear but not always top-ranked +- **Missing**: None - all 6 audit docs exist and are findable +- **Staleness**: None - all docs current post-merge +- **Retrieval recommendation**: Direct file path access for Vote audit docs is reliable; HoloIndex semantic search supplements but doesn't replace targeted reads + +--- + +## 3. Six-Slice Canonical Chain Inventory + +| Slice | PR | Merge Commit | Status | Audit Doc | +|-------|-----|--------------|--------|-----------| +| Slice 1: FEC Adapter | #707 | 15de3d392 | MERGED | VOTE_POC_FEC_ADAPTER_PHASE1.md | +| Slice 2: Entity Resolution | #709 | b5b3eea29 | MERGED | VOTE_POC_ENTITY_RESOLUTION_PHASE1.md | +| Slice 3: Funding Summary | #710 | 1a3d06bd7 | MERGED | VOTE_POC_FUNDING_SUMMARY_PHASE1.md | +| Slice 4: Confidence Scoring | #712 | 4559a8e45 | MERGED | VOTE_POC_CONFIDENCE_SCORING_INTEGRATION_PHASE1.md | +| Slice 5: Quick Answer | #713 | 789545931 | MERGED | VOTE_POC_QUICK_ANSWER_GENERATION_PHASE1.md | +| Slice 6: Shell Integration | #714 | 7e4e5718e | MERGED | VOTE_POC_SHELL_INTEGRATION_PHASE1.md | + +**Chain Status**: 6/6 slices MERGED on main + +--- + +## 4. Current Vote PoC State + +### 4.1 Implementation Inventory + +| Component | Location | Lines | Status | +|-----------|----------|-------|--------| +| FEC Adapter | `src/fec_adapter.py` | ~810 | Complete | +| Entity Resolution | `src/entity_resolution.py` | ~280 | Complete | +| Funding Summary | `src/funding_summary.py` | ~420 | Complete | +| Confidence Scoring | `src/confidence_scoring.py` | ~480 | Complete | +| Quick Answer | `src/quick_answer.py` | ~530 | Complete | +| Shell Integration | `src/shell_integration.py` | ~320 | Complete | +| Module Exports | `src/__init__.py` | ~200 | Complete | + +### 4.2 Public API Contract + +```python +from modules.foundups.voteballots.src import ( + # Slice 1: FEC Adapter + get_mock_adapter, MockFECAdapter, CandidateRecord, FECSource, + + # Slice 2: Entity Resolution + EntityResolutionRequest, resolve_candidate_entity, resolve_by_name, + + # Slice 3: Funding Summary + FundingSummaryRequest, summarize_candidate_funding, TrailTerminationMarker, + + # Slice 4: Confidence Scoring + ConfidenceLabel, HumanReviewTrigger, score_funding_summary_confidence, + + # Slice 5: Quick Answer + QuickAnswer, generate_shell_answer, is_answer_ready_for_display, + + # Slice 6: Shell Integration + VoteShellPayload, build_vote_shell_payload, is_payload_ready, +) +``` + +--- + +## 5. Test and Forbidden-Surface Evidence + +### 5.1 Test Results + +``` +python -m pytest modules/foundups/voteballots/tests/ -q +303 passed in 0.62s +``` + +| Module | Tests | +|--------|-------| +| FEC Adapter | 46 | +| Entity Resolution | 70 | +| Funding Summary | 42 | +| Confidence Scoring | 37 | +| Quick Answer | 46 | +| Shell Integration | 62 | +| **Total** | **303** | + +### 5.2 Forbidden Import Scan + +All 6 slices verified clean of: +- LLM imports (openai, anthropic, ollama, transformers) +- Network imports beyond stdlib +- Live FEC API calls + +### 5.3 Forbidden Language Scan + +All 6 slices verified clean of: +- Recommendation language ("should vote", "endorse", "best candidate") +- Persuasion language ("you must", "urgent", "act now") +- Targeting fields (user_id, demographic, location) + +--- + +## 6. Shell/Public Boundary Status + +### 6.1 Manifest State + +```json +{ + "foundup_id": "voteballots", + "entry_url": "", + "launch_readiness": "discoverable_only", + "routing_prefix": "/f/voteballots" +} +``` + +- `entry_url` is EMPTY (not activated) +- `launch_readiness` is `discoverable_only` (not launchable) + +### 6.2 Shell Payload Contract + +The shell integration layer defines: +- `FOUNDUP_ID = "voteballots"` (readonly) +- `ROUTE_NAMESPACE = "/f/voteballots"` (readonly) +- `APP_MOUNT = "/f/voteballots/app"` (NOT activated) + +The payload contract exists for future shell work but: +- No route handlers exist +- No public files created +- No shell behavior modified + +### 6.3 Public Surface Status + +| Surface | Status | +|---------|--------| +| entry_url | EMPTY | +| Route handlers | NONE | +| Public files | NONE | +| Shell integration | LOCAL CONTRACT ONLY | +| Registry promotion | NOT PERFORMED | +| Catalog entry | NOT ACTIVATED | +| Projection | NOT CREATED | + +--- + +## 7. Re-Open Criteria V1-V8 + +Any future Vote work must cite one of these criteria and create a new architect packet. + +| ID | Criterion | Required Packet | +|----|-----------|-----------------| +| V1 | Live FEC API activation | VOTE_POC_LIVE_FEC_BOUNDARY_PHASE1 | +| V2 | Public route or entry_url activation | VOTE_POC_PUBLIC_ROUTE_ACTIVATION_PHASE1 | +| V3 | Registry/entity promotion | VOTE_POC_REGISTRY_PROMOTION_PHASE1 | +| V4 | Persuasion/recommendation/targeting language | VOTE_POC_POLITICAL_SAFETY_REVIEW_PHASE1 | +| V5 | Confidence rule or human-review trigger change | VOTE_POC_CONFIDENCE_RULE_REVIEW_PHASE2 | +| V6 | Quick-answer new facts, LLM, or prose expansion | VOTE_POC_ANSWER_GENERATION_BOUNDARY_PHASE2 | +| V7 | Manifest/catalog/projection/CABR/payout/DAO claim | VOTE_POC_GOVERNANCE_BOUNDARY_PHASE1 | +| V8 | Shell payload contract or namespace change | VOTE_POC_SHELL_CONTRACT_PHASE2 | + +### 7.1 Re-Open Process + +1. Architect creates packet citing V1-V8 criterion +2. Worker executes under WSP governance +3. W10 merge gate validates boundary compliance +4. New snapshot records state change + +--- + +## 8. What This Snapshot Does NOT Do + +This snapshot explicitly does NOT: + +| Action | Status | +|--------|--------| +| Activate public routes | NO | +| Set entry_url | NO | +| Promote to registry | NO | +| Create catalog entry | NO | +| Create projection | NO | +| Enable CABR | NO | +| Enable payout | NO | +| Enable DAO | NO | +| Call live FEC API | NO | +| Call any LLM | NO | +| Generate new facts | NO | +| Add persuasion language | NO | +| Add targeting fields | NO | +| Modify any code | NO | +| Modify any tests | NO | +| Modify manifest | NO | + +--- + +## 9. Recommended Next Direction + +The Vote PoC chain is implementation-complete. Potential next steps (each requires architect packet): + +| Priority | Direction | Criterion | +|----------|-----------|-----------| +| P1 | Live FEC API integration | V1 | +| P2 | User testing with mock data | No new criterion (current state) | +| P3 | Shell UI wireframe | V8 | +| P4 | Public beta preparation | V2, V3 | + +**No automatic next slice.** Any future Vote work must cite V1-V8. + +--- + +## 10. WSP 97 Truth Boundary Checklist + +| # | Truth Boundary Checklist Item | Status | Evidence | +|---|-------------------------------|--------|----------| +| 1 | VOTE_CHAIN_OBSERVATION_SNAPSHOT_ONLY | YES | This doc only | +| 2 | DOCS_ONLY | YES | No code/test changes | +| 3 | GOVERNANCE_CLOSURE_ONLY | YES | Records state, defines re-open | +| 4 | IMPLEMENTATION_COMPLETE_NOT_PUBLIC_LAUNCHED | YES | Critical statement | +| 5 | NO_CODE_CHANGE | YES | No src files touched | +| 6 | NO_TEST_CHANGE | YES | No test files touched | +| 7 | NO_PUBLIC_ROUTE_ACTIVATION | YES | entry_url empty | +| 8 | NO_ENTRY_URL_ACTIVATION | YES | Manifest verified | +| 9 | NO_REGISTRY_PROMOTION | YES | No registry changes | +| 10 | NO_CATALOG_MUTATION | YES | No catalog changes | +| 11 | NO_MANIFEST_MUTATION | YES | Manifest unchanged | +| 12 | NO_PROJECTION_MUTATION | YES | No projection changes | +| 13 | NO_LIVE_FEC_CALL | YES | MockFECAdapter only | +| 14 | NO_NETWORK_CALL | YES | No network imports | +| 15 | NO_LLM_CALL | YES | No LLM imports | +| 16 | NO_NEW_FACTS | YES | Snapshot only | +| 17 | NO_PERSUASION | YES | No persuasion language | +| 18 | NO_TARGETING | YES | No targeting fields | +| 19 | NO_CABR_READY | YES | No CABR claim | +| 20 | NO_PAYOUT_READY | YES | No payout claim | +| 21 | NO_DAO_ACTIVATION | YES | No DAO claim | +| 22 | RE_OPEN_CRITERIA_RECORDED | YES | V1-V8 defined | + +**WSP 97 Truth Boundary Checklist: 22/22 YES** + +--- + +## 11. Files in Scope + +| File | Action | +|------|--------| +| `docs/audits/architecture/VOTE_POC_CHAIN_OBSERVATION_SNAPSHOT_PHASE1.md` | CREATE (this file) | + +No other files modified. + +--- + +*W9 complete for VOTE_POC_CHAIN_OBSERVATION_SNAPSHOT_PHASE1. Vote PoC chain locked in implementation-complete, not-public-launched state. Re-open requires V1-V8 criterion citation.*