From cc4eedfb31690cee4fe68f70e38ef99078e4495f Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Foundups Agent Date: Mon, 25 May 2026 10:01:09 +0900 Subject: [PATCH] docs(audit): add creator/stakeholder rating simulation spec Phase 1 MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Defines simulation-only model for: - Creator FoundUps (person/channel/community/product/service) - Stakeholder classes (viewer→operator_012 taxonomy) - Creator focus allocation model - Stakeholder rating inputs - FoundUp simulated rating formula - Scenario pack S1-S8 requirements - Move2Japan relocation-concierge future scenario WSP_97 Truth Boundary Checklist: 28/28 YES (COMPLIANT) Next slice: FOUNDUP_CREATOR_STAKEHOLDER_RATING_SIM_IMPLEMENTATION_PHASE1 Slice: FOUNDUP_CREATOR_STAKEHOLDER_RATING_SIM_SPEC_PHASE1 Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 --- ...ATOR_STAKEHOLDER_RATING_SIM_SPEC_PHASE1.md | 745 ++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 745 insertions(+) create mode 100644 docs/audits/architecture/FOUNDUP_CREATOR_STAKEHOLDER_RATING_SIM_SPEC_PHASE1.md diff --git a/docs/audits/architecture/FOUNDUP_CREATOR_STAKEHOLDER_RATING_SIM_SPEC_PHASE1.md b/docs/audits/architecture/FOUNDUP_CREATOR_STAKEHOLDER_RATING_SIM_SPEC_PHASE1.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..9d79632f --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/audits/architecture/FOUNDUP_CREATOR_STAKEHOLDER_RATING_SIM_SPEC_PHASE1.md @@ -0,0 +1,745 @@ +# FoundUp Creator & Stakeholder Rating Simulation Spec - Phase 1 + +**Slice**: `FOUNDUP_CREATOR_STAKEHOLDER_RATING_SIM_SPEC_PHASE1` +**Worker**: W9 +**Date**: 2026-05-25 +**WSP References**: WSP 00, WSP 15, WSP 50, WSP 64, WSP 83, WSP 87, WSP 97, WSP 104, WSP 22 + +--- + +## 1. Mission and Scope + +### 1.1 Mission + +Define the simulation-only model for creator FoundUps, stakeholder value, focus allocation, and FoundUp rating. This spec bridges the current simulator/3V/CABR vision with the product model where a FoundUp may be a person, channel, community, product, or service. + +### 1.2 Scope Boundaries + +This slice is **SPEC/DOCS ONLY**. It does NOT: +- Implement runtime scoring +- Update the registry +- Assign tokens +- Activate CABR +- Create payouts +- Touch wallets or blockchain +- Make eligibility/investment claims + +### 1.3 Core Product Truth + +- A FoundUp is an idea/identity with a following +- Stakeholders include users, subscribers, customers, viewers, contributors, proxy agents, creators, and 0102 agents +- A person or channel can be a FoundUp +- A creator FoundUp can focus on one or more other FoundUps +- Creator focus should affect a FoundUp's simulated rating +- Stakeholder value should affect a FoundUp's simulated rating +- Token language in this phase means **simulated participation points only**, not blockchain assets +- CABR/3V language in this phase means **simulated signal only**, not production CABR execution + +--- + +## 2. HoloIndex Retrieval Assessment + +### 2.1 Queries Executed + +| Query | Results | Quality | +|-------|---------|---------| +| `FOUNDUPS_3V_ENGINE_VISION_CONCATENATION_AUDIT_PHASE1` | 0 code, 3 WSP, 5 docs | LOW - timed out, likely exists but not indexed | +| `WSP_29_CABR_Engine` | 5 code, 5 WSP, 5 docs | MODERATE - found WSP_100, WSP_18, CABR_RUNTIME_SCORING_ENGINE | +| `WSP_26_FoundUPS_DAE_Tokenization` | 5 code, 5 WSP, 5 docs | MODERATE - found WSP_100, tokenization refs | +| `Move2Japan FoundUp role audit` | 5 code, 5 WSP, 5 docs | GOOD - found MOVE2JAPAN_FOUNDUP_ROLE_AUDIT_PHASE1 | +| `FoundUp stakeholder CABR simulator fi rating` | 5 code, 5 WSP, 5 docs | GOOD - found cabr_estimator.py, fi_rating direct | +| `UnDaoDu Token Integration personal token` | 5 code, 5 WSP, 5 docs | GOOD - found UnDaoDu_Token_Integration.md | + +### 2.2 Retrieval Quality Assessment + +- **HoloIndex sentence transformer timed out** on first query, indicating cold-start latency issue +- Direct reads required for primary source files +- HoloIndex successfully located secondary references and related audits +- **Recommendation**: Index work-ledger and architecture audit docs with higher priority + +--- + +## 3. Current Simulator/CABR/3V Inventory + +### 3.1 Existing Components + +| Component | File | Lines | Status | +|-----------|------|-------|--------| +| FiRating | `economics/fi_rating.py` | 491 | IMPLEMENTED | +| CABRFlowRouter | `economics/cabr_flow_router.py` | 75 | IMPLEMENTED | +| ColorTemperature | `economics/fi_rating.py` | 54 | IMPLEMENTED | +| FounderTrackRecord | `economics/fi_rating.py` | 206 | IMPLEMENTED | +| AgentProfile | `economics/fi_rating.py` | 328 | IMPLEMENTED | +| FiRatingEngine | `economics/fi_rating.py` | 477 | IMPLEMENTED | + +### 3.2 Current FiRating Dimensions + +```python +# From fi_rating.py lines 218-229 +velocity: float = 0.0 # Agent work rate (0102 execution per epoch) +traction: float = 0.0 # Market response (012 engagement) +health: float = 0.0 # Operational state (build completeness) +potential: float = 0.0 # Founder conviction (track record + signals) + +# Weights +VELOCITY_WEIGHT = 0.30 +TRACTION_WEIGHT = 0.30 +HEALTH_WEIGHT = 0.20 +POTENTIAL_WEIGHT = 0.20 +``` + +### 3.3 Gap Analysis Table + +| Concept | Current Status | Gap | +|---------|---------------|-----| +| Creator FoundUp | NOT_EXISTS | Need entity class for person/channel as FoundUp | +| Media FoundUp | NOT_EXISTS | Need entity class for content channels | +| Stakeholder Classes | PARTIAL | AgentProfile exists, no viewer/subscriber/customer classes | +| Creator Focus Allocation | NOT_EXISTS | Need model for creator focus across FoundUps | +| Stakeholder Rating | PARTIAL | traction dimension exists, no quality metrics | +| Simulated CABR | PARTIAL | cabr_flow_router.py exists, no simulation wrapper | +| Simulated 3V | NOT_EXISTS | Need V1/V2/V3 simulation model | +| Simulated Participation Points | NOT_EXISTS | Need distinct from velocity metric | + +--- + +## 4. Product Model Truth: FoundUp as Person/Channel/Community/Product/Service + +### 4.1 Entity Spectrum + +A FoundUp can represent: + +| Entity Type | Example | Primary Value | +|-------------|---------|---------------| +| Person/Creator | UnDaoDu (012's personal brand) | Intellectual property, content, expertise | +| Channel/Media | Move2Japan YouTube channel | Content library, audience, engagement | +| Community | antifaFM listeners | Shared identity, participation, advocacy | +| Product | GotJunk platform | Utility, transactions, outcomes | +| Service | Kosei AI automation | Capability delivery, efficiency gains | + +### 4.2 Current Registry Entity Types + +From `foundup_registry.schema.json`: +```json +"EntityType": { + "enum": [ + "foundup", + "platform_layer", + "infra_service", + "tool_simulator", + "external_foundup", + "skeleton_candidate", + "access_service" + ] +} +``` + +### 4.3 Proposed Simulation-Only Extensions + +The following entity classes are **simulation model only** - they do NOT modify the registry schema: + +- `creator_foundup`: Person or personal brand (e.g., UnDaoDu) +- `media_foundup`: Content channel or publication (e.g., Move2Japan channel) +- `product_foundup`: Software product or service (e.g., GotJunk, Kosei) +- `community_foundup`: Identity-driven collective (e.g., antifaFM) + +--- + +## 5. Entity Class Model (Simulation Only) + +### 5.1 Creator FoundUp + +```yaml +creator_foundup: + description: A person or personal brand that produces content or IP + attributes: + creator_id: str # Unique identifier + display_name: str # Public name + primary_platform: str # youtube, twitter, linkedin, etc. + content_domains: list[str] # Topics: ai, japan, music, etc. + audience_size_estimate: int # Follower/subscriber count + content_velocity: float # Posts per epoch + ip_portfolio_count: int # Patents, courses, products + simulated_influence_score: float # 0.0-1.0 + examples: + - UnDaoDu (012's AI/emergence IP portfolio) + - Future: Move2Japan host persona +``` + +### 5.2 Media FoundUp + +```yaml +media_foundup: + description: Content channel, publication, or media property + attributes: + media_id: str + channel_name: str + platform: str # youtube, podcast, newsletter + content_type: str # video, audio, text + audience_size: int + engagement_rate: float # 0.0-1.0 + content_library_size: int # Total pieces of content + simulated_reach_score: float # 0.0-1.0 + examples: + - Move2Japan YouTube channel + - antifaFM radio stream +``` + +### 5.3 Product FoundUp + +```yaml +product_foundup: + description: Software product or digital service + attributes: + product_id: str + product_name: str + stage: str # idea, poc, proto, mvp, launch + user_count_estimate: int + transaction_volume: float + feature_completeness: float # 0.0-1.0 + simulated_utility_score: float + examples: + - GotJunk (junk removal coordination) + - Kosei (AI content automation) + - Trade (autonomous trading) +``` + +### 5.4 Community FoundUp + +```yaml +community_foundup: + description: Identity-driven collective with shared mission + attributes: + community_id: str + community_name: str + member_count: int + activity_rate: float # Active members / total + cohesion_score: float # 0.0-1.0 + advocacy_strength: float # 0.0-1.0 + simulated_resilience_score: float + examples: + - antifaFM community + - MAGADOOM players +``` + +### 5.5 Access Service (Existing) + +```yaml +access_service: + description: YouTube monitor / stakeholder funnel (per Move2Japan audit) + attributes: + service_id: str + service_name: str + funnel_type: str # intake, conversion, retention + stakeholder_db_active: bool + state_machine_implemented: str # BC0, BC1-7, etc. + examples: + - Move2Japan (ACCESS_SERVICE per M2JRA-W9B audit) +``` + +### 5.6 Platform Layer (Existing) + +```yaml +platform_layer: + description: Infrastructure serving multiple FoundUps + examples: + - pfMALL (shell/funnel/RedDog surface) + - FAM (agent market infrastructure) +``` + +### 5.7 Infra Service (Existing) + +```yaml +infra_service: + description: Backend infrastructure component + examples: + - HoloIndex (semantic retrieval) + - Social Twin (cross-FoundUp reporting) +``` + +--- + +## 6. Stakeholder Class Model + +### 6.1 Stakeholder Taxonomy + +| Class | Description | Value Signal | Weight | +|-------|-------------|--------------|--------| +| viewer | Passive content consumer | Watch time, impressions | 0.1 | +| subscriber | Committed follower | Recurring engagement | 0.3 | +| customer | Transaction participant | Revenue, conversion | 0.5 | +| contributor | Active builder | Code, content, labor | 0.7 | +| creator | FoundUp-focused producer | Focus allocation, IP | 0.9 | +| proxy_agent | Automated participant | Task completion, compute | 0.6 | +| 0102_agent | DAE worker | Verified work output | 0.8 | +| operator_012 | Human operator | Strategic direction, governance | 1.0 | + +### 6.2 Simulation Stakeholder Schema + +```yaml +simulation_stakeholder: + stakeholder_id: str + stakeholder_class: enum[viewer, subscriber, customer, contributor, creator, proxy_agent, 0102_agent, operator_012] + affiliated_foundups: list[str] + engagement_depth: float # 0.0-1.0 + tenure_epochs: int # How long engaged + last_active_epoch: int + simulated_value_score: float # Derived from class weight + engagement +``` + +--- + +## 7. Creator Focus Allocation Model + +### 7.1 Focus Allocation Schema + +```yaml +creator_focus_allocation: + allocation_id: str + creator_id: str # Creator FoundUp ID + foundup_id: str # Target FoundUp receiving focus + focus_percent: float # 0.0-1.0 (must sum to 1.0 across all allocations) + confidence: float # 0.0-1.0 (how certain is this allocation) + evidence_source: str # content_analysis, self_reported, inferred + effective_epoch: int # When allocation became active + decay_rate: float # Per-epoch decay when inactive (0.0 = no decay) +``` + +### 7.2 Focus Aggregation Rules + +```python +def calculate_creator_focus_weight(foundup_id: str, allocations: list) -> float: + """ + Aggregate creator focus into FoundUp rating weight. + + Simulation rules: + - Sum focus_percent * creator_influence_score for all allocations targeting this FoundUp + - Apply confidence discount: effective_focus = focus_percent * confidence + - Apply decay for inactive allocations + - Cap at 1.0 (no over-amplification) + """ + total_focus = 0.0 + for alloc in allocations: + if alloc.foundup_id != foundup_id: + continue + effective = alloc.focus_percent * alloc.confidence + # Decay if inactive + epochs_inactive = current_epoch - alloc.effective_epoch + if epochs_inactive > 0: + effective *= (1 - alloc.decay_rate) ** epochs_inactive + total_focus += effective * get_creator_influence(alloc.creator_id) + return min(1.0, total_focus) +``` + +--- + +## 8. Stakeholder Rating Model + +### 8.1 Stakeholder Quality Inputs + +| Input | Description | Range | Source | +|-------|-------------|-------|--------| +| contribution_quality | Quality of work/content produced | 0.0-1.0 | CABR V3 simulation | +| consistency | Regular engagement pattern | 0.0-1.0 | Activity history | +| domain_fit | Relevance to FoundUp mission | 0.0-1.0 | Content analysis | +| verification_quality | Quality of peer verification | 0.0-1.0 | PoB simulation | +| participation_depth | Breadth of engagement types | 0.0-1.0 | Activity diversity | +| trust_safety | Absence of violations/gaming | 0.0-1.0 | Anti-Sybil signals | +| focus_alignment | Creator focus on this FoundUp | 0.0-1.0 | Focus allocation model | + +### 8.2 Stakeholder Rating Formula (Simulation) + +```python +def calculate_simulated_stakeholder_rating(stakeholder: SimulationStakeholder) -> float: + """ + Simulation-only stakeholder rating. + NOT production CABR. NOT payout-ready. + """ + weights = { + "contribution_quality": 0.25, + "consistency": 0.15, + "domain_fit": 0.10, + "verification_quality": 0.15, + "participation_depth": 0.10, + "trust_safety": 0.15, + "focus_alignment": 0.10, + } + + score = sum( + getattr(stakeholder, key, 0.5) * weight + for key, weight in weights.items() + ) + + # Apply class weight multiplier + class_weight = STAKEHOLDER_CLASS_WEIGHTS[stakeholder.stakeholder_class] + + return min(1.0, score * class_weight) +``` + +--- + +## 9. FoundUp Simulated Rating Model + +### 9.1 Rating Inputs + +| Input | Description | Source | Weight | +|-------|-------------|--------|--------| +| product_maturity | Build completeness (idea→launch) | Registry poc_status | 0.15 | +| stakeholder_activity | Active stakeholder engagement | Stakeholder model | 0.20 | +| creator_focus_weight | Aggregated creator focus | Focus allocation model | 0.15 | +| stakeholder_quality_weight | Aggregated stakeholder quality | Stakeholder rating model | 0.15 | +| simulated_cabr | CABR simulation output | CABR flow router | 0.10 | +| simulated_3v | V1+V2+V3 simulation composite | 3V simulation | 0.10 | +| launch_velocity | Progress rate per epoch | Activity delta | 0.05 | +| community_growth | Stakeholder count growth | Stakeholder delta | 0.05 | +| roadmap_execution | Milestone completion rate | Roadmap progress | 0.05 | + +### 9.2 Simulated Rating Formula + +```python +def calculate_simulated_foundup_rating(foundup: SimulationFoundUp) -> SimulatedRating: + """ + Simulation-only FoundUp rating. + + Returns SimulatedRating, NOT production FiRating. + NOT CABR-ready. NOT payout-ready. + """ + components = { + "product_maturity": get_maturity_score(foundup.poc_status), + "stakeholder_activity": get_stakeholder_activity(foundup.id), + "creator_focus_weight": calculate_creator_focus_weight(foundup.id), + "stakeholder_quality_weight": get_stakeholder_quality_aggregate(foundup.id), + "simulated_cabr": simulate_cabr_pipe_size(foundup.id), + "simulated_3v": simulate_3v_composite(foundup.id), + "launch_velocity": calculate_velocity(foundup.id), + "community_growth": calculate_growth(foundup.id), + "roadmap_execution": calculate_roadmap_progress(foundup.id), + } + + weights = { + "product_maturity": 0.15, + "stakeholder_activity": 0.20, + "creator_focus_weight": 0.15, + "stakeholder_quality_weight": 0.15, + "simulated_cabr": 0.10, + "simulated_3v": 0.10, + "launch_velocity": 0.05, + "community_growth": 0.05, + "roadmap_execution": 0.05, + } + + composite = sum( + components[key] * weights[key] + for key in weights + ) + + return SimulatedRating( + composite=composite, + components=components, + color=interpolate_color(composite), + tier=get_temperature_tier(composite), + ) +``` + +--- + +## 10. Simulation-Only Token Language + +### 10.1 Allowed Terms + +| Term | Definition | Usage | +|------|------------|-------| +| `simulated_rating` | Non-production rating score | Rating model output | +| `simulated_cabr` | CABR simulation (not production) | Pipe size simulation | +| `simulated_3v_score` | V1+V2+V3 composite simulation | 3V model output | +| `simulated_participation_points` | Engagement score (not tokens) | Stakeholder value | +| `simulated_focus_weight` | Creator focus aggregation | Focus model output | + +### 10.2 Prohibited Terms + +| Term | Why Prohibited | +|------|----------------| +| `payout-ready` | Implies production payout eligibility | +| `CABR-ready` | Implies production CABR activation | +| `verified token balance` | Implies blockchain state | +| `investable value` | Securities language | +| `dividend` | SEC-regulated term | +| `ROI` | Investment framing | +| `equity` | Securities language | +| `share` | Securities language | + +--- + +## 11. Scenario Pack Requirements (S1-S8) + +### S1: Red-Hot Creator Focuses 80% on Move2Japan + +**Setup**: +- Creator C1 with `simulated_influence_score = 0.9` +- C1 allocates 80% focus to Move2Japan FoundUp +- Move2Japan has moderate stakeholder activity + +**Expected Behavior**: +- Move2Japan `creator_focus_weight` increases significantly +- Move2Japan `simulated_rating` rises toward ORANGE/RED tier +- Rating is NOT production-affecting; visual only + +### S2: Creator Splits Focus Across Five FoundUps + +**Setup**: +- Creator C2 allocates 20% each to 5 FoundUps +- Each FoundUp has varying baseline ratings + +**Expected Behavior**: +- Each FoundUp receives partial `creator_focus_weight` boost +- No single FoundUp receives outsized benefit +- Focus dilution visible in rating deltas + +### S3: High-Subscriber Creator with Low Contribution Quality + +**Setup**: +- Creator C3 has large audience (high `audience_size`) +- C3 has low `contribution_quality` score +- C3 focuses on Product FoundUp P1 + +**Expected Behavior**: +- P1 receives `creator_focus_weight` boost (audience matters) +- P1 `stakeholder_quality_weight` remains moderate (quality discount) +- Composite rating reflects balance of reach vs quality + +### S4: Small Creator with High Stakeholder Conversion + +**Setup**: +- Creator C4 has small audience (1K followers) +- C4 has high `conversion_rate` (viewers → subscribers → customers) +- C4 focuses 100% on Community FoundUp F1 + +**Expected Behavior**: +- F1 receives strong `stakeholder_activity` signal +- `community_growth` accelerates +- High-quality small audience outperforms low-quality large audience + +### S5: Product FoundUp Has Many Viewers but Weak Contributors + +**Setup**: +- Product FoundUp P2 has 10K viewers (class weight 0.1 each) +- P2 has only 5 contributors (class weight 0.7 each) + +**Expected Behavior**: +- `stakeholder_activity` moderate (many low-weight) +- `stakeholder_quality_weight` low (few high-value) +- Rating reflects need for deeper engagement + +### S6: Multiple Creators Launch One FoundUp + +**Setup**: +- Creators C5, C6, C7 each allocate 33% focus to FoundUp F2 +- Combined `simulated_influence_score` = 2.1 (capped at 1.0) + +**Expected Behavior**: +- F2 `creator_focus_weight` capped at 1.0 +- No over-amplification from multiple creators +- Rating reflects maximum creator support + +### S7: 0102 Agents Contribute Compute to a FoundUp + +**Setup**: +- 10 `0102_agent` stakeholders affiliated with FoundUp F3 +- Each contributing verified compute work + +**Expected Behavior**: +- F3 `stakeholder_activity` high (class weight 0.8) +- `simulated_cabr` increases (PoB simulation) +- Rating reflects autonomous work capacity + +### S8: Stakeholder Focus Decays When Inactive + +**Setup**: +- Creator C8 allocated 50% focus to FoundUp F4 at epoch 100 +- C8 has been inactive for 10 epochs +- `decay_rate = 0.05` per epoch + +**Expected Behavior**: +- Effective focus at epoch 110: 50% * (0.95)^10 = ~30% +- F4 `creator_focus_weight` decreases over time +- Reactivation restores focus without penalty + +--- + +## 12. Move2Japan Relocation-Concierge Future Scenario + +### 12.1 Vision + +RedDog (AI assistant in p.fMALL) assists users with Japan relocation planning: + +1. **Intent Capture**: RedDog asks 012 about move goals +2. **Knowledge Search**: Searches Move2Japan knowledge/video corpus +3. **Path Suggestion**: Suggests relocation paths (work, student, spouse, etc.) +4. **Paperwork Checklist**: Prepares document checklist +5. **Property Search**: Identifies public akiya/property sources +6. **Proxy Coordination**: Prepares proxy-agent communications for human review + +### 12.2 Future-Gated Work + +The following capabilities are **explicitly marked as future gated work**: + +| Capability | Gate Status | Reason | +|------------|-------------|--------| +| Live web scraping | FUTURE_GATED | Legal/ToS compliance review required | +| Proxy communication automation | FUTURE_GATED | Human-in-loop requirement | +| Paperwork submission | FUTURE_GATED | Legal liability, human signature required | +| Payment processing | FUTURE_GATED | Financial regulation compliance | + +### 12.3 Move2Japan Roadmap Concatenation Recommendation + +**Next Slice**: `MOVE2JAPAN_RELOCATION_CONCIERGE_ROADMAP_CONCATENATION_PHASE1` + +**Scope**: +1. Define RedDog ↔ Move2Japan knowledge integration +2. Specify BC0-BC7 base camp automation boundaries +3. Document human-in-loop gates for each relocation step +4. Design stakeholder journey from YouTube → PWA → relocation + +--- + +## 13. Terms Allowed vs Prohibited + +### 13.1 Allowed Terms + +- simulated_rating +- simulated_cabr +- simulated_3v_score +- simulated_participation_points +- simulation_model +- model_input +- scenario_parameter +- expected_behavior +- qualitative_outcome + +### 13.2 Prohibited Terms + +- payout-ready +- CABR-ready +- investment +- dividend +- securities +- equity +- share +- ROI +- verified token balance +- production CABR +- production 3V +- live economics +- real tokens +- blockchain-ready + +--- + +## 14. Next Implementation Slice Spec + +### 14.1 Slice: `FOUNDUP_CREATOR_STAKEHOLDER_RATING_SIM_IMPLEMENTATION_PHASE1` + +**Scope**: +1. Implement `SimulationStakeholder` dataclass in `simulator/economics/` +2. Implement `CreatorFocusAllocation` dataclass +3. Implement `calculate_simulated_stakeholder_rating()` function +4. Implement `calculate_simulated_foundup_rating()` function +5. Add scenario tests for S1-S8 +6. Integration with existing `FiRatingEngine` + +**Constraints**: +```yaml +SIMULATION_ONLY: true +TESTS_REQUIRED: true +NO_REGISTRY_MUTATION: true +NO_PRODUCTION_CABR: true +NO_BLOCKCHAIN: true +``` + +### 14.2 Slice: `MOVE2JAPAN_RELOCATION_CONCIERGE_ROADMAP_CONCATENATION_PHASE1` + +**Scope**: +1. Define Move2Japan as dual-role: ACCESS_SERVICE + potential MEDIA_FOUNDUP +2. Document RedDog → BC0-BC7 integration points +3. Specify human-in-loop gates +4. Design stakeholder journey spec + +**Constraints**: +```yaml +DOCS_ONLY: true +NO_SCRAPING_IMPLEMENTATION: true +NO_PROXY_AUTOMATION: true +NO_PAPERWORK_AUTOMATION: true +``` + +--- + +## 15. WSP_97 Truth Boundary Checklist + +| # | Truth Boundary Checklist Item | Status | Evidence | +|---|-------------------------------|--------|----------| +| 1 | FOUNDUP_CREATOR_STAKEHOLDER_RATING_SIM_SPEC_ONLY | YES | Slice header declares spec-only | +| 2 | DOCS_ONLY | YES | No code files changed | +| 3 | SIMULATION_MODEL_ONLY | YES | All formulas marked simulation-only | +| 4 | NO_RUNTIME_SCORING | YES | No runtime execution | +| 5 | NO_SIMULATOR_CODE_MUTATION | YES | No simulator src/ changes | +| 6 | NO_REGISTRY_MUTATION | YES | Registry unchanged | +| 7 | NO_SCHEMA_MUTATION | YES | Schema unchanged | +| 8 | NO_CATALOG_MUTATION | YES | Catalog unchanged | +| 9 | NO_PROJECTION_MUTATION | YES | Projection unchanged | +| 10 | NO_MANIFEST_MUTATION | YES | Manifest unchanged | +| 11 | NO_PUBLIC_SURFACE_MUTATION | YES | public/** unchanged | +| 12 | NO_TOKEN_ASSIGNMENT | YES | No token operations | +| 13 | NO_CHAIN_ACTIVATION | YES | No blockchain calls | +| 14 | NO_WALLET | YES | No wallet access | +| 15 | NO_PRODUCTION_CABR_CLAIM | YES | CABR marked simulation-only | +| 16 | NO_PRODUCTION_3V_CLAIM | YES | 3V marked simulation-only | +| 17 | NO_INVESTMENT_LANGUAGE | YES | Prohibited terms listed in Section 10.2 | +| 18 | NO_SECURITIES_CLAIM | YES | No securities language | +| 19 | NO_AUTOMATED_ELIGIBILITY_DECISION | YES | No eligibility automation | +| 20 | NO_LIVE_SCRAPING_IMPLEMENTATION | YES | Scraping marked FUTURE_GATED | +| 21 | NO_PROXY_COMMUNICATION_AUTOMATION | YES | Proxy marked FUTURE_GATED | +| 22 | NO_PAPERWORK_AUTOMATION | YES | Paperwork marked FUTURE_GATED | +| 23 | MOVE2JAPAN_RELOCATION_CONCIERGE_MARKED_FUTURE_GATED | YES | Section 12.2 gates explicitly | +| 24 | UNDAODU_PERSONAL_TOKEN_MODEL_MARKED_SIMULATION_ONLY | YES | Appendix B clarifies scope | +| 25 | CITES_CABR_AND_TOKENIZATION_WSP_DOCS | YES | References WSP_29 in Appendix A | +| 26 | NO_CABR_READY | YES | No CABR activation | +| 27 | NO_PAYOUT_READY | YES | No payout activation | +| 28 | NO_DAO_ACTIVATION | YES | No DAO activation | + +**Checklist Result**: 28/28 YES - COMPLIANT + +**Repair Note**: Removed redundant `NO_PAYOUT` row (subsumed by `NO_PAYOUT_READY`); updated to canonical 4-column format with evidence. + +--- + +## Appendix A: Referenced Documents + +| Document | Path | +|----------|------| +| WSP_29_CABR_Engine | `WSP_knowledge/src/WSP_29_CABR_Engine.md` | +| Simulator ROADMAP | `modules/foundups/simulator/ROADMAP.md` | +| FiRating | `modules/foundups/simulator/economics/fi_rating.py` | +| CABRFlowRouter | `modules/foundups/simulator/economics/cabr_flow_router.py` | +| Registry | `modules/foundups/foundup_registry.json` | +| Registry Schema | `modules/foundups/foundup_registry.schema.json` | +| Move2Japan Audit | `docs/audits/architecture/MOVE2JAPAN_FOUNDUP_ROLE_AUDIT_PHASE1.md` | +| UnDaoDu Token | `WSP_knowledge/docs/Papers/Patent_Series/UnDaoDu_Token_Integration.md` | +| Simulator INTERFACE | `modules/foundups/simulator/INTERFACE.md` | + +--- + +## Appendix B: UnDaoDu Personal Token Model Note + +UnDaoDu represents 012's personal brand and IP portfolio (WSP 58 governed). In the simulation model: + +- **Entity Type**: `creator_foundup` +- **Token Model**: Existing Solana token (`3Vp5Wuy...pump`) +- **Simulation Treatment**: Model as high-influence creator +- **Production Status**: TOKEN_EXISTS (not simulated) + +**Important**: UnDaoDu's existing token is NOT part of this simulation spec. References to UnDaoDu in simulation are for modeling creator FoundUp patterns only. The actual UnDaoDu token operates under WSP 58 and is outside simulation scope. + +--- + +*Spec completed by W9 under WSP 97 constraints. Ready for W10 merge gate.*