proof-matrix.md

Proof Matrix

Status: scaffolded locally after Phase 1 patch
Purpose: repo-by-repo proof routing for the approved 17-repo architecture

Matrix

Final repo	Role	Status	Artifact class	Evidence state	Validation method	Boundary class	Next review action
Franzabner	Personal identity and navigation surface.	scaffolded locally; publication pending review.	Profile README, proof index, public surface file, boundary file, status file.	Local Phase 1 files present after patch.	Link audit, status-language review, public-claim review, boundary review.	Personal public proof surface with company/Foundation/product/client separation.	Human review of profile language before push or metadata use.
franzabner-proof-stack	Master proof index and claim-control spine.	scaffolded locally; publication pending review.	README, proof matrix, claim register, artifact status, boundary register, review log, proof-entry template.	Local Phase 1 files present after patch.	Claim-row completeness review: repo, artifact, status, boundary, validation, evidence, review, next action.	Public proof-control layer; no private evidence or release approval by itself.	Human review of claim-control model before push or profile routing.
modular-infrastructure-studies	Modular infrastructure and serviceability studies.	scaffolded; public scaffold, not released.	README, status, public boundary, claims, validation notes, artifact register, review log, synthetic studies, Mermaid diagrams, serviceability artifact.	Public repo reachable; first artifact: studies/modular-serviceability-study.md.	scripts/validate-public-boundary.sh, status-language review, boundary scan, diagram review, assumptions review, human review.	Public-safe synthetic infrastructure study boundary; no production rack topology, real facility layout, production CAD, customer infrastructure, private measurements, or sealed geometry.	Review public scaffold language before profile routing or any status stronger than scaffolded.
cad-mechanical-design-lab	Synthetic CAD and mechanical serviceability studies.	scaffolded; public scaffold, not released.	README, status, public boundary, claims, validation notes, artifact register, review log, CAD export policy, sealed-boundary rules, synthetic enclosure artifact.	Public repo reachable; first artifact: design-studies/synthetic-enclosure-study.md.	scripts/validate-public-boundary.sh, CAD-boundary review, export-policy review, status-language review, diagram review, human review.	Public-safe synthetic mechanical/CAD boundary; no production F3D, production CAD, exact product dimensions, manufacturing package, product geometry, customer parts, private rack models, or sealed geometry.	Review CAD/export boundary before profile routing, screenshots, exports, renders, or any status stronger than scaffolded.
electrical-controls-architecture	Electrical and controls proof.	scaffolded; public scaffold, not released.	README, status, public boundary, claims, validation notes, artifact register, review log, control narratives, sensor/actuator patterns, commissioning notes, first synthetic control narrative.	Public repo reachable; first artifact: control-narratives/synthetic-sensor-actuator-control-narrative.md.	scripts/validate-public-boundary.sh, status-language review, electrical/control boundary scan, Mermaid diagram review, commissioning-question review, human review.	Public-safe synthetic electrical/control boundary; no production schematics, production board or panel source, BOMs, Gerbers, exact pin maps, customer wiring, live control logic, private firmware, manufacturing-ready files, internal product names, deployment claims, certification claims, or release claims.	Review scaffolded control narrative and boundary posture before profile promotion, screenshots, exports, commissioning claims, or any status stronger than scaffolded.
embedded-hardware-lab	PCB, firmware, MCU, breadboard, and hardware validation proof.	scaffolded; public scaffold, not released.	README, status, public boundary, claims, validation notes, artifact register, review log, MCU patterns, firmware-boundary notes, test harness concepts, first synthetic management-bus artifact.	Public repo reachable; first artifact: mcu-patterns/public-safe-mcu-management-bus-pattern.md.	scripts/validate-public-boundary.sh, status-language review, embedded-hardware boundary scan, pin-map pattern review, firmware-boundary review, human review.	Public-safe synthetic embedded hardware boundary; no production board source, production schematics, routing, BOMs, Gerbers, exact pin maps, private firmware, customer hardware or wiring, manufacturing-ready files, internal product names, deployment claims, certification claims, release claims, or manufacturing claims.	Review scaffolded MCU/firmware-boundary artifact before profile promotion, hardware claims, firmware claims, manufacturing claims, or any status stronger than scaffolded.
engineering-simulation-lab	Engineering simulation and validation proof.	scaffolded; public scaffold, not released.	README, status, public boundary, claims, validation notes, artifact register, review log, synthetic inputs, model-boundary notes, first synthetic thermal/airflow/power study.	Public repo reachable; first artifact: studies/synthetic-thermal-airflow-power-study.md.	scripts/validate-public-boundary.sh, status-language review, simulation boundary scan, synthetic-input review, Mermaid validation diagram review, human review.	Public-safe synthetic simulation boundary; no private traces, customer data, Foundation-private data, unreleased benchmark results, private measurements, production thermal data, production airflow data, production power data, private workloads, endpoints, topology, credentials, unsupported result claims, release claims, deployment claims, certification claims, or physical-validation claims.	Review scaffolded simulation study and boundary posture before profile promotion, benchmark language, physical-validation language, report publication, or any status stronger than scaffolded.
data-model-infrastructure	Engineering data/model infrastructure, RAG substrates, artifact storage, DGX, fine-tuning, cards, and eval boundaries.	scaffolded; public scaffold, not released.	README, status, public boundary, claims, validation notes, artifact register, review log, source-capture workflow, metadata templates, vector-index notes, dataset/model card templates, first source-to-model workflow artifact.	Public repo reachable; first artifact: source-capture/public-safe-source-to-model-workflow.md.	scripts/validate-public-boundary.sh, status-language review, data/model boundary scan, provenance review, release-card boundary review, human review.	Public-safe synthetic data/model infrastructure boundary; no private corpora, copyrighted material without rights, customer data, Foundation-private data, private weights, adapters, private training logs, endpoints, topology, credentials, unreleased metrics, private prompts, private eval outputs, model release, dataset release, Space release, Hugging Face metadata change, deployment claim, certification claim, or proof-completion claim.	Review scaffolded source-to-model workflow and release-surface boundaries before profile promotion, Hugging Face action, model/dataset/Space language, fine-tuning availability language, or any status stronger than scaffolded.
infrastructure-energy-studies	Infrastructure energy studies covering solar-to-hydrogen, water-current-to-electricity, control states, safety boundaries, and validation limits.	scaffolded; public scaffold, not released.	README, status, public boundary, claims, validation notes, artifact register, review log, synthetic inputs, control-state notes, non-certified safety notes, first synthetic solar-to-hydrogen control ledger study.	Public repo reachable; first artifact: solar-to-hydrogen/synthetic-solar-to-hydrogen-control-ledger-study.md.	scripts/validate-public-boundary.sh, status-language review, energy boundary scan, Mermaid energy validation diagram review, non-certified safety-boundary review, human review.	Public-safe synthetic infrastructure energy boundary; no deployed energy system, proven-output claim, certified-safety claim, commercial-readiness claim, private measurements, customer data, Foundation-private data, production CAD, production schematics, BOMs, Gerbers, exact dimensions, live operations, private sites, private facility layouts, internal product names, sealed designs, sealed geometry, release claim, or proof-completion claim.	Review scaffolded energy artifact before profile promotion, output language, safety language, physical-validation language, pinning, metadata changes, or any status stronger than scaffolded.
civic-infrastructure-production-systems	Public-safe civic infrastructure production studies with Foundation-adjacent engineering separation.	scaffolded; public scaffold, not released.	README, status, public boundary, claims, validation notes, artifact register, review log, civic boundary notes, synthetic throughput/material-flow notes, QA checklists, first personal engineering civic production boundary artifact.	Public repo reachable; first artifact: civic-boundary/personal-engineering-civic-production-boundary.md.	scripts/validate-public-boundary.sh, status-language review, civic/Foundation-adjacent boundary scan, QA-boundary review, Mermaid civic boundary diagram review, human review.	Public-safe synthetic civic production boundary and personal engineering proof surface only; no Foundation voice, operational Foundation program, school deployment, production recycling line, live civic-node deployment, disaster-response deployment, manufacturing-readiness claim, certified-safety claim, donor data, student data, volunteer data, Foundation-private data, customer data, private sites, private facility layouts, production CAD, production schematics, BOMs, Gerbers, exact dimensions, live operations, internal product names, sealed designs, sealed geometry, release claim, or proof-completion claim.	Review scaffolded civic boundary artifact before profile promotion, Foundation-adjacent language, QA/manufacturing language, pinning, metadata changes, or any status stronger than scaffolded.
engineering-standards-and-validation	Standards-aware validation templates for safety checklists, test procedures, risk registers, and proof limits.	scaffolded; public scaffold, not released.	README, status, public boundary, claims, validation notes, artifact register, review log, standards-awareness notes, safety checklists, risk/failure-mode templates, first standards-aware validation template.	Public repo reachable; first artifact: templates/standards-aware-validation-template.md.	scripts/validate-public-boundary.sh, status-language review, standards/certification boundary scan, safety-checklist review, risk/failure-mode review, human review.	Public-safe standards-aware validation boundary; no release, certification, code-compliance approval, stamped-engineering implication, legal approval, customer procedures, customer-deliverable claim, safety-approval claim, active-service claim, production-readiness claim, private incident report, or proof-completion claim.	Review scaffolded standards-aware validation template before profile promotion, safety language, commissioning language, pinning, metadata changes, or any status stronger than scaffolded.
engineering-security-boundary	Security, secrets, repo visibility, data boundaries, agent permissions, and publication decisions.	scaffolded; public scaffold, not released.	README, status, public boundary, claims, validation notes, artifact register, review log, boundary definitions, secrets-handling notes, repo-visibility decision trees, first artifact-publication decision tree.	Public repo reachable; first artifact: publication-decision-trees/artifact-publication-decision-tree.md.	scripts/validate-public-boundary.sh, status-language review, security-boundary scan, secret/redaction review, repo-visibility review, agent-permission review, human review.	Public-safe security-boundary scaffold; no release, security-compliance approval, legal approval, customer data, Foundation-private data, credentials, private URLs, production secrets, endpoints, sensitive topology, sealed source, private logs, private model artifacts, active-service claim, metadata-approval claim, model-release claim, dataset-release claim, or proof-completion claim.	Review scaffolded artifact-publication decision tree before profile promotion, visibility language, security language, pinning, metadata changes, or any status stronger than scaffolded.
engineering-deliverables-template	Professional engineering packaging, templates, reports, cards, and handoff standards.	scaffolded; public scaffold, not released.	README, status, public boundary, claims, validation notes, artifact register, review log, README/status/claims/boundary templates, BOM/control narrative/commissioning templates, first deliverable package index template.	Public repo reachable; first artifact: templates/deliverable-package-index-template.md.	scripts/validate-public-boundary.sh, status-language review, deliverable-template boundary scan, template-completeness review, card/release-surface review, human review.	Public-safe deliverables-template boundary; no release, certification, code-compliance approval, stamped-engineering implication, legal approval, customer-deliverable claim, customer data, sealed product excerpt, active-service claim, pricing, turnaround, model-release claim, dataset-release claim, Space-release claim, production-readiness claim, or proof-completion claim.	Review scaffolded deliverable package index before profile promotion, template promotion, service language, release-card language, pinning, metadata changes, or any status stronger than scaffolded.
application-development-systems	Application architecture and AI-assisted software delivery proof.	scaffolded; public scaffold, not released.	README, status, public boundary, claims, validation notes, artifact register, review log, app architecture notes, component/product boundary notes, deployment assumption notes, first Next.js architecture artifact.	Public repo reachable; first artifact: app-architecture/public-safe-nextjs-architecture.md.	scripts/validate-public-boundary.sh, status-language review, app ownership boundary scan, lint/typecheck/build validation review, Mermaid app delivery review diagram review, human review.	Public-safe synthetic app architecture boundary; no live apps, active customers, deployed or released software, production endpoints, credentials, customer data, private source, private logs, internal prompts, live tool tokens, production secrets, internal product names, or proof-completion claim.	Review scaffolded architecture before profile promotion, client/product language, deployment assumption language, pinning, metadata changes, or any status stronger than scaffolded.
immersive-access-systems	Immersive access, operator interface, spatial interface, digital-twin, dashboard, and scene-boundary proof.	scaffolded; public scaffold, not released.	README, status, public boundary, claims, validation notes, artifact register, review log, operator portal patterns, spatial interface notes, CAD-to-USD boundary notes, first immersive access pattern artifact.	Public repo reachable; first artifact: immersive-access/public-safe-immersive-access-pattern.md.	scripts/validate-public-boundary.sh, status-language review, immersive access boundary scan, scene/dashboard review, Mermaid access review diagram review, human review.	Public-safe synthetic immersive access boundary; no deployed portals, production dashboards, live telemetry, production USD scenes, private CAD, real facility layouts, private topology, credentials, customer assets, live access workflows, private telemetry, sealed geometry, internal product names, or proof-completion claim.	Review scaffolded immersive access pattern before profile promotion, portal/dashboard language, scene publication language, pinning, metadata changes, or any status stronger than scaffolded.
automated-engineering-systems	Engineering operating-system proof through memory, source control, automation, provenance, mirrors, run logs, and review loops.	scaffolded; public scaffold, not released.	README, status, public boundary, claims, validation notes, artifact register, review log, system map, memory/source-control patterns, automation notes, first engineering operating-system map artifact.	Public repo reachable; first artifact: system-map/synthetic-engineering-operating-system-map.md.	scripts/validate-public-boundary.sh, status-language review, automation boundary scan, run-log review, mirror-boundary review, human review.	Public-safe synthetic operating-system pattern boundary; no production automation, endpoints, hostnames, ports, credentials, private vaults, private logs, private topology, customer operations, live automation exports, production workflows, private repo paths, private telemetry, internal product names, or proof-completion claim.	Review scaffolded operating-system map before profile promotion, automation language, source-of-truth language, mirror language, pinning, metadata changes, or any status stronger than scaffolded.
agentic-engineering-workforce	Codex-style execution, review gates, tool boundaries, refusal rules, logging, and human approval proof.	scaffolded; public scaffold, not released.	README, status, public boundary, claims, validation notes, artifact register, review log, execution loops, role patterns, tool-permission notes, first Codex-style execution loop artifact.	Public repo reachable; first artifact: execution-loops/codex-style-execution-loop.md.	scripts/validate-public-boundary.sh, status-language review, agentic workflow boundary scan, permission/review-gate review, human-authority review, human review.	Public-safe synthetic agentic workflow boundary; no active agent workforce, autonomous production agent claims, internal prompts, private agent memory, sealed agent memory, live tool tokens, credentials, private repo paths, customer data, Foundation-private data, production execution logs, private runtime details, released software claims, internal product names, or proof-completion claim.	Review scaffolded execution loop before profile promotion, agentic authority language, autonomy language, logging language, pinning, metadata changes, or any status stronger than scaffolded.

Proof Row Gate

Every future proof row must include:

• artifact location;
• status label;
• evidence summary;
• excluded private or sealed material;
• validation method;
• review requirement;
• review date or pending review state;
• next action.

Phase 1 Hold

Supporting narrow repos remain source context until separate review. No supporting repo patch, GitHub metadata change, Hugging Face metadata change, archive, transfer, rename, visibility change, release, deployment, certification, production CAD claim, active service claim, autonomous production-agent claim, or proof-completion claim is authorized by this matrix.