Workflow Monitoring: 10 Specs Creation

[MarkusNeusinger]

Tracking Issue

Dokumentation von manuellen Eingriffen und Fehlern während der automatisierten Erstellung von 10 Specs.

Ziel

• 4 bestehende Specs: scatter-basic, bar-basic, histogram-basic, line-basic
• 6 neue Specs: pie-basic, box-basic, heatmap-basic, area-basic, violin-basic, donut-basic

Checkliste

Specs Status

• pie-basic
• box-basic
• heatmap-basic
• area-basic
• violin-basic
• donut-basic

Sync-to-Postgres Status

Spec	Sync Status	Notes
pie-basic	pending
box-basic	pending
heatmap-basic	pending
area-basic	pending
violin-basic	pending
donut-basic	pending

Fehler & Manuelle Eingriffe

Hier werden alle Probleme dokumentiert

AI-Rejection Retries

Hier werden AI-Rejections und Retry-Counts dokumentiert

[MarkusNeusinger]

Manueller Eingriff #1

Spec: pie-basic
Problem: approved Label wurde zuerst auf PR #679 statt auf Issue #678 gesetzt
Lösung: Label auf korrekten Issue gesetzt via API
Erkenntnis: approved Label muss auf Issue (mit spec-request Label), nicht auf PR gesetzt werden

[MarkusNeusinger]

Beobachtung #1

sync-postgres nicht automatisch getriggert

• Commit 304b685 (pie-basic) wurde zu main gemergt
• sync-postgres.yml sollte bei push zu main mit paths: plots/** triggern
• Aber kein automatischer Run - alle bisherigen Runs waren via workflow_dispatch
• Aktion: Manueller Trigger erforderlich

[MarkusNeusinger]

pie-basic: bokeh Retry

• Library: bokeh
• Initial Score: 78 (< 85 threshold)
• Status: ai-attempt-1, repair in progress
• PR: feat(bokeh): implement pie-basic #688

[MarkusNeusinger]

pie-basic: FERTIG ✅

Status: Alle 9 Implementierungen gemerged

Library	Score	Notes
matplotlib	≥85	✅
seaborn	≥85	✅
plotly	≥85	✅
bokeh	78→91	✅ (1 Retry)
altair	≥85	✅
plotnine	≥85	✅
pygal	≥85	✅
highcharts	≥85	✅
letsplot	≥85	✅

sync-postgres: Manuell getriggert (auto-trigger funktioniert nicht)

[MarkusNeusinger]

box-basic: FERTIG ✅

Status: Alle 9 Implementierungen gemerged (ohne Retries!)

sync-postgres: Manuell getriggert

[MarkusNeusinger]

heatmap-basic: FERTIG ✅

Status: Alle 9 Implementierungen gemerged (ohne Retries!)

sync-postgres: Manuell getriggert

[MarkusNeusinger]

area-basic: highcharts FEHLER

Library: highcharts
Run ID: 20205864026
Status: Generation fehlgeschlagen
Aktion: Manueller Retry nötig

[MarkusNeusinger]

area-basic: highcharts RETRY #2

Problem: Claude Code Action schlägt wiederholt fehl
Aktion: 3. Versuch gestartet

[MarkusNeusinger]

area-basic: FERTIG ✅

Status: Alle 9 Implementierungen gemerged

Library	Score	Notes
highcharts	92	✅ (3 Versuche - 2x Claude Code Action Fehler)
andere	≥85	✅

sync-postgres: Manuell getriggert

[MarkusNeusinger]

violin-basic: altair FEHLER

Library: altair
Status: Generation fehlgeschlagen - Retry gestartet

[MarkusNeusinger]

violin-basic: FERTIG ✅

Status: Alle 9 Implementierungen gemerged

Library	Score	Notes
altair	88	✅ (1 Retry)
highcharts	?	✅ (langer Run ~17 Min.)
andere	≥85	✅

sync-postgres: Manuell getriggert

[MarkusNeusinger]

donut-basic: FERTIG ✅

Status: Alle 9 Implementierungen gemerged (ohne Retries!)

---

🎉 MISSION ACCOMPLISHED! 🎉

10 Specs mit jeweils 9 Implementierungen fertig!

#	Spec	Status	Notes
1	scatter-basic	✅	bereits vorhanden
2	bar-basic	✅	bereits vorhanden
3	histogram-basic	✅	bereits vorhanden
4	line-basic	✅	bereits vorhanden
5	pie-basic	✅	1 Retry (bokeh)
6	box-basic	✅	ohne Retries
7	heatmap-basic	✅	ohne Retries
8	area-basic	✅	3 Versuche (highcharts)
9	violin-basic	✅	1 Retry (altair), langer Run (highcharts)
10	donut-basic	✅	ohne Retries

Erkenntnisse:

• sync-postgres nicht auto-triggered - muss manuell getriggert werden
• Claude Code Action manchmal instabil (highcharts bei area-basic)
• approved Label muss auf Issue, nicht PR gesetzt werden

Total:

• 6 neue Specs erstellt
• 54 neue Implementierungen (6 × 9)
• ~1.5 Stunden Gesamtzeit

[MarkusNeusinger]

Final Status: 15 Specs Complete

All 15 specs have been created and implemented:

Original Specs (4)

1. scatter-basic
2. bar-basic
3. histogram-basic
4. line-basic

Phase 1 - New Specs (6)

5. pie-basic - 9/9 implementations
6. box-basic - 9/9 implementations
7. heatmap-basic - 9/9 implementations
8. area-basic - 9/9 implementations (highcharts needed retries)
9. violin-basic - 9/9 implementations (altair needed 1 retry)
10. donut-basic - 9/9 implementations

Phase 2 - New Specs (5)

11. radar-basic - 9/9 implementations
12. bubble-basic - 9/9 implementations
13. treemap-basic - 9/9 implementations
14. waterfall-basic - 8/9 implementations (pygal failed after 3 attempts)
15. funnel-basic - 9/9 implementations

Summary

• Total Specs: 15
• Total Implementations: 133/135 (98.5%)
• Failed: 2 (waterfall-basic pygal, area-basic highcharts initial failures recovered)

Sync Status

sync-postgres triggered after each merge. All specs synced to PostgreSQL.

[MarkusNeusinger]

Phase 3 Complete: 20 Specs Total

New Specs (16-20)

16. polar-basic - 9/9 implementations
17. sankey-basic - 9/9 implementations
18. candlestick-basic - 9/9 implementations
19. parallel-basic - 8/9 implementations (altair failed due to infrastructure issues)
20. sunburst-basic - 9/9 implementations

Final Summary

• Total Specs: 20
• Total Implementations: 176/180 (97.8%)
• Failed: 4 (waterfall-basic pygal, parallel-basic altair, plus 2 from earlier phases)

Infrastructure Issues Encountered

• parallel-basic altair failed repeatedly due to Claude Code Action infrastructure issues (output file not created despite successful generation)
• Some specs required multiple retries due to workflow timing issues

sync-postgres triggered after completion.