Skip to content
Merged
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
77 changes: 77 additions & 0 deletions manuscript/narrative-review/figures/README.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,77 @@
# Figure plan — TiCS narrative review

Four figures, SVG source + 600 dpi PNG export per Cell Press image requirements. Authored in Phase 2 with `figures:svg-figure`. Each figure has a `figure-qa` report saved alongside.

## Figure 1 — Four-perspective strand map

**Purpose.** Visual scaffold of the central thesis. Show the four perspectives (psychophysics, action, language, emotion) as four converging columns, with cross-cutting horizontal bands for the 15 corpus themes. Overlap is intentional; perspectives interact at the per-shot ERSP level rather than partitioning cleanly.

**Encoding.**
- X-axis: perspective (psychophysics, action, language, emotion).
- Y-axis: 15 corpus themes from `research/synthesis/science-map.md`.
- Cell content: filled if the perspective contributes substantially to the theme.
- Annotation: arrows from psychophysics to action and emotion ("partialling enables"), arrow from language to action and emotion ("comparator of non-transfer"), arrow from emotion to action ("co-modulation").

**Source data.** Combine the four `*-ontology.md` files and `science-map.md`. No new data collection.

**Dimensions.** Single-column TiCS width (~80 mm) preferred; two-column acceptable if labels exceed single-column legibility.

**File.** `fig1_strand-map.svg`, `fig1_strand-map.png`, `fig1_strand-map_qa.md`.

## Figure 2 — Naturalness gradient with cohort overlay

**Purpose.** Place *The Present* on the naturalness gradient and overlay corpus cohort coverage. Make the developmental EEG ERSP cell visibly empty.

**Encoding.**
- X-axis: naturalness gradient (controlled gratings -> static photos -> Heider-Simmel triangles -> abstract animation [Inscapes] -> character animation [*The Present*, Pixar shorts] -> live-action film).
- Y-axis: cohort coverage (adult, adolescent, child).
- Marker per corpus card placed at intersection (size encodes number of cards, colour encodes modality: fMRI, MEG, EEG, iEEG, behavioural).
- Highlight the (child, character-animation, EEG, per-shot ERSP) cell as the empty cell of interest.

**Source data.** Combine `dataset-hierarchy.md`, `science-map.md` Theme 3, and per-strand `*-ontology.md`. Use card-level cohort age fields.

**Dimensions.** Two-column width (~170 mm) likely required to label all gradient steps.

**File.** `fig2_naturalness-gradient.svg`, `fig2_naturalness-gradient.png`, `fig2_naturalness-gradient_qa.md`.

## Figure 3 — Gap matrix

**Purpose.** Operationalise the gap analysis in a single visual. Show which corpus features are covered by which prior-effort axis (cinematic fMRI, naturalistic EEG, intracranial EEG, behavioural). Identify the uncovered cells.

**Encoding.**
- Rows: 8 named gaps from `gap-analysis.md` (child-cohort EEG ERSP at shot onsets, LLR as continuous regressor, pet-evoked affective EEG, silent-narrative ERSP, cross-strand integration, free-viewing animation EEG without eye coregistration, mu-band action observation to animated agents, frontal alpha asymmetry at sub-second timescales).
- Columns: prior-effort axes (cinematic fMRI, naturalistic scalp EEG, iEEG, behavioural).
- Cell content: filled if coverage exists, with a card-slug label; empty cell highlighted in colour.

**Source data.** `gap-analysis.md` three-column coverage table.

**Dimensions.** Two-column width.

**File.** `fig3_gap-matrix.svg`, `fig3_gap-matrix.png`, `fig3_gap-matrix_qa.md`.

## Figure 4 — Predictions table-figure

**Purpose.** Translate Section 3-6 perspective predictions into a single readable display: per perspective, which band, which topography, which latency, and which pre-registered falsification region.

**Encoding.**
- Rows: four perspectives.
- Columns: band (frequency range), topography (electrode group or IC cluster), latency (ms window), falsification region (band-and-topography rejection criterion).
- Annotation: thumbnail head schematic per row showing the topography.
- Cell content: text + colour-coded band.

**Source data.** Sections 3-6 of `manuscript.md` plus self-review F5 falsifiability region.

**Dimensions.** Two-column width.

**File.** `fig4_predictions.svg`, `fig4_predictions.png`, `fig4_predictions_qa.md`.

## Style budget

- Colourblind-safe palette throughout (Cell Press recommends Wong/Okabe-Ito or viridis).
- Sans-serif fonts (Helvetica or equivalent) at 7-9 pt for axis labels, 10-11 pt for figure titles.
- Line weight: 0.5-1.0 pt for axes, 1.5 pt for highlighted elements.
- No reliance on colour alone to convey information (use shape, label, or shading redundantly).

## Caption length budget

Cell Press allows ~150-200 words per caption (concise; rules described in figure body). Draft captions in Phase 3 manuscript writing.
Loading
Loading