2727
2828### Why It Failed
2929
30- ** Root cause:** AWS provides DNS64 but ** NOT NAT64 **
30+ ** Root cause:** NAT64 requires NAT Gateway, which negates cost savings
3131
3232** What this means:**
3333- ** DNS64** (✅ provided): Translates DNS queries from A records to AAAA records using ` 64:ff9b::/96 ` prefix
34- - ** NAT64** (❌ NOT provided): Would translate actual IPv6 packets to IPv4 for IPv4-only services
35- - Result: Instances can resolve IPv4-only services to IPv6 addresses, but packets time out with no NAT64 gateway
34+ - ** NAT64** (✅ available via NAT Gateway): AWS NAT Gateway supports NAT64 translation when routing ` 64:ff9b::/96 ` traffic through it
35+ - ** The problem** : NAT Gateway costs ~ $32+/month base, which exceeds the ~ $18/month we'd save on public IPv4 addresses
36+ - Additionally, SSM still requires IPv4 connectivity regardless of NAT64
3637
3738** Services that broke:**
3839- ❌ AWS SSM Agent (IPv4-only): ` dial tcp [64:ff9b::392:b12]:443: i/o timeout `
@@ -93,15 +94,14 @@ network_interfaces = [
9394
9495** Waiting for AWS to provide:**
9596
96- 1 . ** Native NAT64 Service **
97- - Similar to NAT Gateway but for IPv6→IPv4 translation
98- - Would allow IPv6-only instances to reach IPv4 -only services
99- - ** This is the blocker - AWS doesn't offer this **
97+ 1 . ** SSM dual-stack endpoints ** (main blocker)
98+ - SSM, EC2 Messages, and SSM Messages currently require IPv4
99+ - Without this, managed EC2 instances cannot go IPv6 -only
100+ - NAT64 via NAT Gateway exists but costs ~ $32+/month (negates savings)
100101
101- 2 . ** Alternative: All services support dual-stack**
102- - Every AWS service with IPv6 endpoints
102+ 2 . ** Alternative: All management services support dual-stack**
103103 - Particularly: SSM, EC2 Messages, SSM Messages
104- - Currently only ECS, ECR, CloudWatch Logs, S3 support dual-stack
104+ - Currently ECS, ECR, CloudWatch Logs, S3, IAM support dual-stack
105105
106106** Self-managed workarounds we rejected:**
107107
@@ -162,13 +162,14 @@ This indicates DNS64 translation without NAT64 gateway.
162162
163163** Only attempt IPv6-only again when ONE of these is true:**
164164
165- 1 . ✅ ** AWS launches managed NAT64 service**
166- - Monitor AWS announcements for VPC NAT64 Gateway
167- - Similar to existing NAT Gateway but for IPv6→IPv4
168-
169- 2 . ✅ ** All required AWS services support dual-stack**
165+ 1 . ✅ ** SSM gets dual-stack endpoints**
170166 - Specifically need: SSM, EC2 Messages, SSM Messages with IPv6
171- - Check: https://docs.aws.amazon.com/general/latest/gr/aws-ipv6-support.html
167+ - This is the primary blocker for managed EC2 instances
168+ - Check: https://docs.aws.amazon.com/vpc/latest/userguide/aws-ipv6-support.html
169+
170+ 2 . ✅ ** NAT Gateway pricing drops significantly**
171+ - Currently ~ $32+/month base cost negates IPv4 savings
172+ - Would need to be <$10/month to make economic sense
172173
1731743 . ✅ ** Public IPv4 costs exceed $20-30/month**
174175 - At current scale (2-4 instances), savings too small
@@ -184,6 +185,17 @@ dig service-name.region.api.aws AAAA +short
184185# If returns IPv6 address, service supports dual-stack
185186```
186187
188+ ** Track AWS IPv6 progress:**
189+ - Official tracker: https://docs.aws.amazon.com/vpc/latest/userguide/aws-ipv6-support.html
190+ - AWS What's New (filter for IPv6): https://aws.amazon.com/new/
191+
192+ ** Key services to watch for IPv6-only viability:**
193+ - SSM (Systems Manager) - currently IPv4-only, this is the main blocker
194+ - EC2 Messages - currently IPv4-only
195+ - SSM Messages - currently IPv4-only
196+
197+ ** Last checked:** January 2026 - SSM still requires IPv4 connectivity
198+
187199## Rollback Summary
188200
189201** What we reverted:**
0 commit comments