diff --git a/changelog.d/435.md b/changelog.d/435.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6de23f34a --- /dev/null +++ b/changelog.d/435.md @@ -0,0 +1 @@ +- Add a Cold Weather Payment planning docs page at `docs/book/programs/gov/dwp/cold-weather-payment-plan.md` covering the SI 1988/1724 qualifying-benefit-and-weather-event eligibility, a three-phase implementation route (expected-value -> regional weather mixing -> back-cast lookups), and the Scotland Winter Heating Payment equivalent under SSI 2023/8. diff --git a/docs/book/programs/gov/dwp/cold-weather-payment-plan.md b/docs/book/programs/gov/dwp/cold-weather-payment-plan.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..dc1af7915 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/book/programs/gov/dwp/cold-weather-payment-plan.md @@ -0,0 +1,128 @@ +# Cold Weather Payment (planned) + +```{warning} +**Not yet modelled.** The Cold Weather Payment (CWP) is a DWP payment +of **£25 per 7-day period of recorded cold weather** to qualifying +households in England, Wales and (historically) Northern Ireland. +PolicyEngine UK doesn't currently model it. This page captures the +proposed scope, tracked under +[#435](https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-uk/issues/435). + +In Scotland the equivalent benefit is the **Winter Heating Payment** +(£59.75 per qualifying household per winter, replacing CWP from +February 2023) — also not modelled. +``` + +## What CWP is + +Defined in [The Social Fund Cold Weather Payments (General) +Regulations 1988][cwp-1988] (SI 1988/1724). A household qualifies if +**all** of the following hold: + +- The address is in a postcode covered by a weather station that + recorded **7 consecutive days** at or below 0°C (forecast or + observed) in the qualifying period (1 November – 31 March). +- A member of the benunit receives one of the **qualifying benefits**: + Pension Credit; Income Support, JSA-IB, or ESA-IR (in either case + with a disability-related premium, a child under 5, or in a few + other circumstances); Universal Credit (with limited capability for + work, a disability addition, or a child under 5). + +The payment is £25 per 7-day cold period; multiple cold periods +trigger multiple payments. Outturn averages ~£100m to ~£200m/year +nationally depending on winter severity. + +## Why this is harder than other DWP benefits + +The eligibility test combines an administrative benefit check (clean +for PolicyEngine) with a **geographic weather event** (no FRS +analogue). Modelling the weather side has three plausible approaches: + +1. **Expected-value parameterisation**: a single national + `cold_weather_payments_expected_periods` parameter capturing the + long-run-average number of 7-day cold periods triggered per winter. + Multiply by `£25 × qualifying_household` to produce the expected + annual payment. Easy to implement, accurate in aggregate, wrong in + any specific winter. +2. **Regional weather mixing**: a per-region weather-event + distribution (e.g. North East has more cold periods than London on + average), parameterised from Met Office historic data. Captures the + distributional skew without forecasting any particular winter. +3. **Year-specific lookups**: tabulate the DWP-published *Cold Weather + Payment statistics* by region by year and use those as historical + inputs. Most accurate for back-cast simulations; needs ongoing + updating. + +Recommendation: **option 2 (regional mixing)** for prospective analysis +and option 3 for back-casts where the data is available. + +## Proposed scope + +### Phase 1 — qualifying-benefit gate + expected-value payment + +- New parameter `gov.dwp.cold_weather_payment.amount` = £25 (since + the scheme's inception). +- New parameter + `gov.dwp.cold_weather_payment.expected_periods_per_year` = + long-run national average from DWP CWP statistics. +- New variable `cold_weather_payment_eligible` (BenUnit, YEAR) that + fires if any benunit member receives one of the qualifying benefits + with the relevant addition / age trigger. +- New variable `cold_weather_payment` (BenUnit, YEAR) = `amount` × + `expected_periods_per_year` × `eligible`. + +This delivers a model that gets the policy-relevant slice right +(*who* qualifies for CWP and how it interacts with their other +benefits) at the cost of smoothing year-to-year weather variance. + +### Phase 2 — regional weather mixing + +Add a `gov.dwp.cold_weather_payment.expected_periods_by_region` table +parameterised from Met Office observation data, and a household-side +lookup by `region`. + +### Phase 3 — Scotland Winter Heating Payment + +Different rules and a different administration — modelled as a +separate variable: + +- `winter_heating_payment_scotland_eligible`: any benunit member on + Pension Credit + Scotland residence (the WHP qualifying-benefit + list is broader than CWP). +- `winter_heating_payment_scotland` = `amount` × `eligible` where + `amount` is the flat per-household winter payment (£59.75 in + 2023-24, uprated subsequently). + +## Data needs + +- DWP, [Cold Weather Payment statistics](https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/cold-weather-payments-statistics) — caseload and expenditure by region by winter, primary calibration source. +- DWP-published WHP statistics (Scotland) — Phase 3 calibration. +- Met Office, [UK climate historic stations](https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/research/climate/maps-and-data/historic-station-data) — Phase 2 regional expected-period parameterisation. + +The FRS gives `region` cleanly, so the geographic gate is no extra +data work for Phase 1/2. + +## Open questions + +- The qualifying-benefit list for CWP is narrower than for WHD — + specifically the disability/child-under-5 triggers within UC and the + legacy benefits. Should the eligibility be modelled as a single + composite condition variable, or as separate `_via_uc` / + `_via_legacy` / `_via_pc` flags? +- CWP averages ~£100m/year — well below most modelled benefits, but + the marginal household-level impact is meaningful for the low-income + pensioners and disabled households it targets. Worth modelling + Phase 1 even if Phase 2 doesn't follow. +- Welsh Government has occasionally topped up CWP from devolved funds. + Should the model expose a `wales_top_up` parameter for reform + analyses? + +## References + +- [The Social Fund Cold Weather Payments (General) Regulations 1988 (SI 1988/1724)][cwp-1988]. +- gov.uk, [Cold Weather Payment](https://www.gov.uk/cold-weather-payment). +- DWP, [Cold Weather Payment statistics](https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/cold-weather-payments-statistics). +- Scottish equivalent: [Winter Heating Payment (Scotland) Regulations 2023 (SSI 2023/8)](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ssi/2023/8/contents). +- Issue: [#435](https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-uk/issues/435). + +[cwp-1988]: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/1988/1724