geometry.py

"""For storing, manipulating, and measuring molecular structures"""
import itertools
import os
import re
import ssl
from collections import deque
from copy import deepcopy
import concurrent.futures

import numpy as np
from scipy.spatial import distance_matrix, distance

import AaronTools
from AaronTools import default_config as DEFAULT_CONFIG
import AaronTools.utils.utils as utils
from AaronTools import addlogger
from AaronTools.atoms import Atom, BondOrder
from AaronTools.config import Config
from AaronTools.const import (
    AARONLIB,
    AARONTOOLS,
    BONDI_RADII,
    D_CUTOFF,
    ELEMENTS,
    RADII,
    SAMBVCA_RADII,
    TMETAL,
    VDW_RADII,
)
from AaronTools.fileIO import FileReader, FileWriter, read_types
from AaronTools.finders import Finder, OfType, WithinRadiusFromPoint, WithinRadiusFromAtom, WithinBondsOf
from AaronTools.utils.prime_numbers import Primes
from AaronTools.oniomatoms import OniomAtom


COORD_THRESHOLD = 0.2
CACTUS_HOST = "https://cactus.nci.nih.gov"
OPSIN_HOST = "https://opsin.ch.cam.ac.uk"


if not DEFAULT_CONFIG["DEFAULT"].getboolean("local_only"):
    import urllib.parse
    from urllib.error import HTTPError
    from urllib.request import urlopen


@addlogger
class Geometry:
    """
    Attributes:

        * name
        * comment
        * atoms
        * other
        * _iter_idx

    """

    # AaronTools.addlogger decorator will add logger to this class attribute
    LOG = None
    # decorator uses this to set log level (defaults to WARNING if None)
    # LOGLEVEL = "INFO"
    # add to this dict to override log level for specific functions
    # keys are log level, values are lists of function names
    # LOGLEVEL_OVERRIDE = {"DEBUG": "find"}

    Primes()

    def __init__(
        self,
        structure="",
        name="",
        comment="",
        components=None,
        refresh_connected=True,
        refresh_ranks=True,
    ):
        """
        :param structure: can be a Geometry(), a FileReader(), a file name, or a
            list of atoms
        :param str name: name 
        :param str comment: comment
        :param list(AaronTools.component.Component())|None components: components list or None
        :param bool refresh_connected: usually True - determine connectivity
        
            can save time for methods that only need coordinates by using
            `refresh_connected=False`
        :param bool refresh_ranks: usually True - rank atoms, False when loading from database
            can save time for methods that only don't rely on ranks by using
            `refresh_ranks=False`
        """
        super().__setattr__("_hashed", False)
        self.name = name
        self.comment = comment
        self.atoms = []
        self.center = None
        self.components = components
        self.other = {}
        self._iter_idx = None
        self._sigmat = None
        self._epsmat = None

        if isinstance(structure, Geometry):
            # new from geometry
            self.atoms = structure.atoms
            if not name:
                self.name = structure.name
            if not comment:
                self.comment = structure.comment
            return
        elif isinstance(structure, FileReader):
            # get info from FileReader object
            from_file = structure
        elif isinstance(structure, str) and structure:
            # parse file
            from_file = FileReader(structure)
        elif hasattr(structure, "__iter__") and structure:
            for a in structure:
                if not isinstance(a, Atom):
                    raise TypeError
            else:
                # list of atoms supplied
                self.atoms = structure
                if refresh_connected:
                    # SEQCROW sometimes uses refresh_connected=False to keep
                    # the connectivity the same as what's on screen
                    self.refresh_connected()
                if refresh_ranks:
                    self.refresh_ranks()
                return
        else:
            return

        # only get here if we were given a file reader object or a file name
        self.name = from_file.name
        self.comment = from_file.comment
        self.atoms = from_file.atoms
        self.other = self.parse_comment()
        if refresh_connected:
            # some file types contain connectivity info (e.g. sd) - might not want
            # to overwrite that
            self.refresh_connected()
        if refresh_ranks:
            self.refresh_ranks()
        return

    # class methods
    @staticmethod
    def iupac2smiles(name):
        """
        convert IUPAC name to SMILES using the OPSIN web API
        
        :param str name: IUPAC name of a molecule
        :return: SMILES name of a molecule
        """
        if DEFAULT_CONFIG["DEFAULT"].getboolean("local_only"):
            raise PermissionError(
                "Converting IUPAC to SMILES failed. External network lookup disallowed."
            )
        # opsin seems to be better at iupac names with radicals
        url_smi = "{}/opsin/{}.smi".format(
            OPSIN_HOST, urllib.parse.quote(name)
        )

        try:
            smiles = (
                urlopen(url_smi, context=ssl.SSLContext())
                .read()
                .decode("utf8")
            )
        except HTTPError:
            raise RuntimeError(
                "%s is not a valid IUPAC name or https://opsin.ch.cam.ac.uk is down"
                % name
            )
        return smiles

    @classmethod
    def from_string(cls, name, form="smiles", strict_use_rdkit=False):
        """
        Converts a string input into a Geometry object
        
        :param str name: either an IUPAC name or a SMILES for a molecule
        :param str form: * "smiles" -  structure from cactvs API/RDKit
            * "iupac" - iupac to smiles from opsin API, then the same as form=smiles
        :param bool strict_use_rdkit: force use of RDKit and never use cactvs
        :return: Geometry object that matches the input name
        :rtype: Geometry
        """

        # CC and HOH are special-cased because they are used in
        # the automated testing and we don't want that to fail
        # b/c cactus is down and the user doesn't have rdkit
        # these structures are from NIST
        if name == "CC":
            return cls([
                Atom("C", coords=[0.0, 0.0, 0.7680], name="1"),
                Atom("C", coords=[0.0, 0.0, -0.7680], name="2"),
                Atom("H", coords=[-1.0192, 0.0, 1.1573], name="3"),
                Atom("H", coords=[0.5096, 0.8826, 1.1573], name="4"),
                Atom("H", coords=[0.5096, -0.8826, 1.1573], name="5"),
                Atom("H", coords=[1.0192, 0.0, -1.1573], name="6"),
                Atom("H", coords=[-0.5096, -0.8826, -1.1573], name="7"),
                Atom("H", coords=[-0.5096, 0.8826, -1.1573], name="8"),
            ])
        elif name == "HOH":
            return cls([
                Atom("H", coords=[0.0, 0.7572, -0.4692], name="1"),
                Atom("O", coords=[0.0, 0.0, 0.0], name="2"),
                Atom("H", coords=[0.0, -0.7572, -0.4692], name="3"),
            ])
        elif name == "ClC(Cl)Cl":
            return cls([
                Atom("Cl", coords=[-0.59020,  1.58610, -0.40730], name="1"),
                Atom("C",  coords=[ 0.00140, -0.00160,  0.12250], name="2"),
                Atom("Cl", coords=[-1.05120, -1.30360, -0.49820], name="3"),
                Atom("Cl", coords=[ 1.66160, -0.20470, -0.44580], name="4"),
                Atom("H",  coords=[-0.02170, -0.07610,  1.22880], name="5"),
            ])

        def get_cactus_sd(smiles):
            if DEFAULT_CONFIG["DEFAULT"].getboolean("local_only"):
                raise PermissionError(
                    "Cannot retrieve structure from {}. External network lookup disallowed.".format(
                        CACTUS_HOST
                    )
                )
            url_sd = "{}/cgi-bin/translate.tcl?smiles={}&format=sdf&astyle=kekule&dim=3D&file=".format(
                CACTUS_HOST, urllib.parse.quote(smiles)
            )
            s_sd_get = urlopen(url_sd, context=ssl.SSLContext())
            msg, status = s_sd_get.msg, s_sd_get.status
            if msg != "OK":
                cls.LOG.error(
                    "Issue contacting %s for SMILES lookup (status: %s)",
                    CACTUS_HOST,
                    status,
                )
                raise IOError
            s_sd_get = s_sd_get.read().decode("utf8")
            try:
                tmp_url = re.search(
                    'User-defined exchange format file: <a href="(.*)"',
                    s_sd_get,
                ).group(1)
            except AttributeError as err:
                if re.search("You entered an invalid SMILES", s_sd_get):
                    cls.LOG.error(
                        "Invalid SMILES encountered: %s (consult %s for syntax help)",
                        smiles,
                        "https://cactus.nci.nih.gov/translate/smiles.html",
                    )
                    exit(1)
                raise IOError(err)
            new_url = "{}{}".format(CACTUS_HOST, tmp_url)
            s_sd = (
                urlopen(new_url, context=ssl.SSLContext())
                .read()
                .decode("utf8")
            )
            return s_sd

        if DEFAULT_CONFIG["DEFAULT"].getboolean("local_only"):
            strict_use_rdkit = True
        accepted_forms = ["iupac", "smiles"]
        if form not in accepted_forms:
            raise NotImplementedError(
                "cannot create substituent given %s; use one of %s" % form,
                str(accepted_forms),
            )

        if form == "smiles":
            smiles = name
        elif form == "iupac":
            smiles = cls.iupac2smiles(name)

        try:
            import rdkit.Chem.AllChem as rdk

            m = rdk.MolFromSmiles(smiles)
            if m is None and not strict_use_rdkit:
                s_sd = get_cactus_sd(smiles)
            elif m:
                mh = rdk.AddHs(m)
                rdk.EmbedMolecule(mh, randomSeed=0x421C52)
                s_sd = rdk.MolToMolBlock(mh)
            else:
                raise RuntimeError(
                    "Could not load {} with RDKit".format(smiles)
                )
        except ImportError:
            s_sd = get_cactus_sd(smiles)

        try:
            f = FileReader((name, "sd", s_sd))
            is_sdf = True
        except ValueError:
            # for some reason, CACTUS is giving xyz files instead of sdf...
            is_sdf = False
            try:
                f = FileReader((name, "xyz", s_sd))
            except ValueError:
                cls.LOG.error("Error loading geometry:\n %s", s_sd)
                raise

        return cls(f, refresh_connected=not is_sdf)

    @classmethod
    def get_coordination_complexes(
        cls,
        center,
        ligands,
        shape,
        c2_symmetric=None,
        minimize=False,
        session=None,  # This parameter is unused in the method; possibly should be removed?
    ):
        """
        get all unique coordination complexes
        uses templates from Inorg. Chem. 2018, 57, 17, 10557–10567

        :param str center: - element of center atom
        :param list(str) ligands: - list of ligand names in the ligand library
                       if a ligand is None, one position will be left as a dummy atom
                       if a ligand is (None, None), it will behave as a bidentate dummy ligand
        :param str shape: coordination geometry (e.g. octahedral) - see Atom.get_shape
        :param list(bool) c2_symmetric: specify which of the bidentate ligands are C2-symmetric
                       if this list is as long as the ligands list, the nth item corresponds
                       to the nth ligand
                       otherwise, the nth item indicate the symmetry of the nth bidentate ligand
        :param bool minimize: passed to cls.map_ligand when adding ligands 

        :return: a list of cls containing all unique coordination complexes and the
            general formula of the complexes
        :rtype: list(Geometry)
        """
        import os.path

        from AaronTools.atoms import BondOrder
        from AaronTools.component import Component
        from AaronTools.const import AARONTOOLS

        if c2_symmetric is None:
            c2_symmetric = []
            for lig in ligands:
                if lig is None:
                    c2_symmetric.append(False)
                    continue
                if hasattr(lig, "__iter__") and len(lig) == 2 and lig[0] is None and lig[1] is None:
                    c2_symmetric.append(False)
                    continue
                comp = Component(lig)
                if not len(comp.key_atoms) == 2:
                    c2_symmetric.append(False)
                    continue
                c2_symmetric.append(comp.c2_symmetric())

        bo = BondOrder()

        # create a geometry with the specified shape
        # change the elements from dummy atoms to something else
        start_shape = Atom.get_shape(shape)
        start_atoms = [
            Atom(element="B", coords=coords, name="%i" % i) for i, coords in
            enumerate(start_shape)
        ]
        n_coord = len(start_atoms) - 1
        start_atoms[0].element = center
        start_atoms[0].reset()
        for atom in start_atoms[1:]:
            start_atoms[0].connected.add(atom)
            atom.connected.add(start_atoms[0])
            atom.reset()
        geom = cls(start_atoms, refresh_connected=False, refresh_ranks=False)

        # we'll need to determine the formula of the requested complex
        # monodentate ligands are a, b, etc
        # symmetric bidentate are AA, BB, etc
        # asymmetric bidentate are AB, CD, etc
        # ligands are sorted monodentate, followed by symmetric bidentate, followed by
        # asymmetric bidentate, then by decreasing count
        # e.g., Ca(CO)2(ACN)4 is Ma4b2
        all_names = []
        alphabet = "abcdefghi"
        symmbet = ["AA", "BB", "CC", "DD"]
        asymmbet = ["AB", "CD", "EF", "GH"]
        monodentate_ligands = []
        monodentate_names = []
        symm_bidentate_ligands = []
        symm_bidentate_names = []
        asymm_bidentate_ligands = []
        asymm_bidentate_names = []

        n_bidentate = 0
        # determine types of ligands
        for i, lig in enumerate(ligands):
            name = lig
            if hasattr(lig, "name"):
                name = lig.name
            if not name and lig is not None:
                cls.LOG.warning("ligand %i has no name, results might not be correct" % (i + 1))
            all_names.append(name)
            if lig is None:
                monodentate_names.append("dummy1")
                monodentate_ligands.append(lig)
                all_names[-1] = monodentate_names[-1]
                continue
            elif hasattr(lig, "__iter__") and len(lig) == 2 and lig[0] is None and lig[1] is None:
                symm_bidentate_names.append("dummy2")
                symm_bidentate_ligands.append(lig)
                if len(ligands) == len(c2_symmetric):
                    c2 = c2_symmetric[i]
                else:
                    c2 = c2_symmetric[n_bidentate]
                n_bidentate += 1
                all_names[-1] = symm_bidentate_names[-1]
                continue
                
            comp = Component(lig)
            if len(comp.key_atoms) == 1:
                monodentate_names.append(name)
                monodentate_ligands.append(lig)

            elif len(comp.key_atoms) == 2:
                if len(ligands) == len(c2_symmetric):
                    c2 = c2_symmetric[i]
                else:
                    c2 = c2_symmetric[n_bidentate]
                n_bidentate += 1

                if c2:
                    symm_bidentate_names.append(name)
                    symm_bidentate_ligands.append(lig)
                else:
                    asymm_bidentate_names.append(name)
                    asymm_bidentate_ligands.append(lig)
            else:
                # tridentate or something
                raise NotImplementedError(
                    "can only attach mono- and bidentate ligands: %s (%i)"
                    % (lig, len(comp.key_atoms))
                )

        coord_num = len(monodentate_names) + 2 * (
            len(symm_bidentate_names) + len(asymm_bidentate_names)
        )
        if coord_num != n_coord:
            raise RuntimeError(
                "coordination number (%i) does not match sum of ligand denticity (%i)"
                % (n_coord, coord_num)
            )

        # start putting formula together
        cc_type = "M"
        this_name = center
        # sorted by name count is insufficient when there's multiple monodentate ligands
        # with the same count (e.g. Ma3b3)
        # add the index in the library to offset this
        sorted_names = sorted(set(all_names))
        comp_ndx = {x: i for i, x in enumerate(sorted_names)}

        monodentate_sorted = sorted(
            zip(monodentate_ligands, monodentate_names),
            key=lambda x: 10000 * monodentate_names.count(x[1])
            + comp_ndx[x[1]],
            reverse=True,
        )
        monodentate_ligands = [x[0] for x in monodentate_sorted]
        monodentate_names = [x[1] for x in monodentate_sorted]

        i = 0
        for j, (lig, name) in enumerate(zip(monodentate_ligands, monodentate_names)):
            if j > 0 and name == monodentate_names[j - 1]:
                continue
            cc_type += alphabet[i]
            this_name += "(%s)" % name
            if monodentate_names.count(name) > 1:
                cc_type += "%i" % monodentate_names.count(name)
                this_name += "%i" % monodentate_names.count(name)
            i += 1
        
        symm_sorted = sorted(
            zip(symm_bidentate_ligands, symm_bidentate_names),
            key=lambda x: 10000 * symm_bidentate_names.count(x[1])
            + comp_ndx[x[1]],
            reverse=True,
        )
        symm_bidentate_ligands = [x[0] for x in symm_sorted]
        symm_bidentate_names = [x[1] for x in symm_sorted]
        i = 0
        for j, (lig, name) in enumerate(zip(symm_bidentate_ligands, symm_bidentate_names)):
            if i > 0 and name == symm_bidentate_names[j - 1]:
                continue
            cc_type += "(%s)" % symmbet[i]
            this_name += "(%s)" % name
            if symm_bidentate_names.count(name) > 1:
                cc_type += "%i" % symm_bidentate_names.count(name)
                this_name += "%i" % symm_bidentate_names.count(name)
            i += 1

        asymm_sorted = sorted(
            zip(asymm_bidentate_ligands, asymm_bidentate_names),
            key=lambda x: 10000 * asymm_bidentate_names.count(x[1])
            + comp_ndx[x[1]],
            reverse=True,
        )
        asymm_bidentate_ligands = [x[0] for x in asymm_sorted]
        asymm_bidentate_names = [x[1] for x in asymm_sorted]
        i = 0
        for j, (lig, name) in enumerate(zip(asymm_bidentate_ligands, asymm_bidentate_names)):
            if i > 0 and name == asymm_bidentate_names[j - 1]:
                continue
            cc_type += "(%s)" % asymmbet[i]
            this_name += "(%s)" % name
            if asymm_bidentate_names.count(name) > 1:
                cc_type += "%i" % asymm_bidentate_names.count(name)
                this_name += "%i" % asymm_bidentate_names.count(name)
            i += 1

        # load the key atoms for ligand mapping from the template file
        libdir = os.path.join(
            AARONTOOLS, "coordination_complex", shape, cc_type
        )
        if not os.path.exists(libdir):
            raise LookupError("no templates for %s %s" % (cc_type, shape))

        geoms = []
        for f in os.listdir(libdir):
            mappings = np.loadtxt(
                os.path.join(libdir, f), dtype=str, delimiter=",", ndmin=2
            )

            point_group, subset = f.rstrip(".csv").split("_")[:2]
            # for each possible structure, create a copy of the original template shape
            # attach ligands in the order they would appear in the formula
            for i, mapping in enumerate(mappings):
                geom_copy = geom.copy()
                geom_copy.center = [geom_copy.atoms[0]]
                geom_copy.components = [
                    Component([atom]) for atom in geom_copy.atoms[1:]
                ]

                start = 0
                minimizable = []
                for lig in monodentate_ligands:
                    key = mapping[start]
                    start += 1
                    if isinstance(lig, Component):
                        comp = lig.copy()
                    elif lig is None:
                        a = geom_copy.find(key)[0]
                        a.element = "X"
                        geom_copy.change_distance(
                            geom_copy.atoms[0], a, dist=2, fix=1
                        )
                        continue
                    else:
                        comp = Component(lig)
                    d = 2.5
                    # adjust distance to key atoms to what they should be for the new ligand
                    try:
                        d = bo.bonds[bo.key(center, comp.key_atoms[0])]["1.0"]
                    except KeyError:
                        pass
                    geom_copy.change_distance(
                        geom_copy.atoms[0], key, dist=d, fix=1
                    )
                    # attach ligand
                    geom_copy.map_ligand(comp, key, minimize=minimize)
                    for key in comp.key_atoms:
                        geom_copy.atoms[0].connected.add(key)
                        key.connected.add(geom_copy.atoms[0])
                    
                    minimizable.append(comp)

                for lig in symm_bidentate_ligands:
                    keys = mapping[start : start + 2]
                    start += 2
                    if isinstance(lig, Component):
                        comp = lig.copy()
                    elif hasattr(lig, "__iter__") and len(lig) == 2 and lig[0] is None and lig[1] is None:
                        a1, a2 = geom_copy.find(keys)
                        a1.element = "X"
                        geom_copy.change_distance(
                            geom_copy.atoms[0], a1, dist=2, fix=1
                        )
                        a2.element = "X"
                        geom_copy.change_distance(
                            geom_copy.atoms[0], a2, dist=2, fix=1
                        )
                        a1.add_bond_to(a2)

                        continue
                    else:
                        comp = Component(lig)
                    
                    for old_key, new_key in zip(keys, comp.key_atoms):
                        d = 2.5
                        try:
                            d = bo.bonds[bo.key(center, new_key)]["1.0"]
                        except KeyError:
                            pass
                        geom_copy.change_distance(
                            geom_copy.atoms[0],
                            old_key,
                            dist=d,
                            fix=1,
                            as_group=False,
                        )
                    geom_copy.map_ligand(comp, keys, minimize=minimize)
                    for key in comp.key_atoms:
                        geom_copy.atoms[0].connected.add(key)
                        key.connected.add(geom_copy.atoms[0])

                for lig in asymm_bidentate_ligands:
                    keys = mapping[start : start + 2]
                    start += 2
                    if isinstance(lig, Component):
                        comp = lig.copy()
                    else:
                        comp = Component(lig)
                    for old_key, new_key in zip(keys, comp.key_atoms):
                        d = 2.5
                        try:
                            d = bo.bonds[bo.key(center, new_key)]["1.0"]
                        except KeyError:
                            pass
                        geom_copy.change_distance(
                            geom_copy.atoms[0],
                            old_key,
                            dist=d,
                            fix=1,
                            as_group=False,
                        )
                    geom_copy.map_ligand(comp, keys, minimize=minimize)
                    for key in comp.key_atoms:
                        geom_copy.atoms[0].connected.add(key)
                        key.connected.add(geom_copy.atoms[0])


                # due to the way the atoms are ordered in the csv files,
                # monodentate ligands are first
                # this means we minimized them before any other ligands were added
                # and should do it again once everything is attached to the center
                if minimize:
                    for i in range(0, 3):
                        for comp in minimizable:
                            geom_copy.minimize_torsion(
                                comp.atoms,
                                geom_copy.atoms[0].bond(comp.key_atoms[0]),
                                geom_copy.atoms[0],
                                increment=20,
                            )
                    
                geom_copy.name = "%s-%i_%s_%s" % (
                    this_name,
                    i + 1,
                    point_group,
                    subset,
                )
                geoms.append(geom_copy)

        return geoms, cc_type

    @classmethod
    def get_diastereomers(cls, geometry, minimize=True):
        """
        Generate diastereomers of Geometry

        :param Geometry geometry: chiral structure
        :param bool minimize: performs minimize_sub_torsion on each diastereomer
        :return: list of all diastereomer_countastereomers for detected chiral centers
        :rtype: list(Geometry)
        """
        from AaronTools.finders import ChiralCenters, Bridgehead, NotAny, SpiroCenters
        from AaronTools.ring import Ring
        from AaronTools.substituent import Substituent
        
        if not isinstance(geometry, Geometry):
            geometry = Geometry(geometry)
        
        updating_diastereomer = geometry.copy()
        if not getattr(updating_diastereomer, "substituents", False):
            updating_diastereomer.substituents = []

        # we can invert any chiral center that isn't part of a 
        # fused ring unless it's a spiro center
        chiral_centers = updating_diastereomer.find(ChiralCenters())
        spiro_chiral = updating_diastereomer.find(SpiroCenters(), chiral_centers)
        ring_centers = updating_diastereomer.find(
            chiral_centers, Bridgehead(), NotAny(spiro_chiral)
        )
        chiral_centers = [c for c in chiral_centers if c not in ring_centers]

        diastereomer_count = [2 for c in chiral_centers]
        mod_array = []
        for i in range(0, len(diastereomer_count)):
            mod_array.append(1)
            for j in range(i + 1, len(diastereomer_count)):
                mod_array[i] *= diastereomer_count[j]
        
        diastereomers = [updating_diastereomer.copy()]

        previous_diastereomer = 0
        for d in range(1, int(np.prod(diastereomer_count))):
            for i, center in enumerate(chiral_centers):
                flip = int(d / mod_array[i]) % diastereomer_count[i]
                flip -= int(previous_diastereomer / mod_array[i]) % diastereomer_count[i]
                
                if flip == 0:
                    continue
            
                updating_diastereomer.change_chirality(center)

            diastereomers.append(updating_diastereomer.copy())
            
            previous_diastereomer = d

        if minimize:
            for diastereomer in diastereomers:
                diastereomer.minimize_sub_torsion(increment=15)

        return diastereomers

    @staticmethod
    def weighted_percent_buried_volume(
        geometries, energies, temperature, *args, **kwargs
    ):
        """
        Boltzmann-averaged percent buried volume
        
        :param list(Geometry) geometries: structures to calculate buried volume for
        :param np.ndarray energies: energy in kcal/mol; ith energy corresponds to ith substituent
        :param temperature: temperature in K
        :param float args: passed to Geometry.percent_buried_volume()
        :param kwargs: passed to Geometry.percent_buried_volume()
        :return: Boltzmann-weighted percent buried volume
        """
        values = []

        for geom in geometries:
            values.append(geom.percent_buried_volume(*args, **kwargs))

        rv = utils.boltzmann_average(
            energies,
            np.array(values),
            temperature,
        )

        return rv

    @classmethod
    def get_solvent(cls, solvent):
        """
        Converts the name of a solvent into a Geometry representation
        based on solvents within AaronTools libraries
        Note: list_solvents provides a str array of solvents within the libraries

        :param str solvent: name of the solvent to be converted
        :return: converted solvent
        :rtype: Geometry
        :raises LookupError: when input solvent is not present in libraries
        """
        BUILTIN = os.path.join(AARONTOOLS, "Solvents")
        AARON_LIBS = os.path.join(AARONLIB, "Solvents")
        for lib in [AARON_LIBS, BUILTIN]:
            if not os.path.exists(lib):
                continue
            for f in os.listdir(lib):
                name, ext = os.path.splitext(os.path.basename(f))
                if not any(".%s" % x == ext for x in read_types):
                    continue

                if name == solvent:
                    return cls(os.path.join(lib, f), name=solvent)

        raise LookupError("solvent %s not found in library" % solvent)

    @classmethod
    def ring_conformers(cls, geometry, targets=None, include_uncommon=False):
        """
        returns a list of Geometry objects with varying ring conformations
        :param Geometry geometry: structure to look for conformers of
        :param Atom targets: atoms in rings to search for conformers of (default is all rings)
        """
        import json
        
        from AaronTools.internal_coordinates import InternalCoordinateSet
        from AaronTools.utils.utils import shortest_path

        # from cProfile import Profile
        # 
        # profile = Profile()
        # profile.enable()

        normal_vseprs = {
            "linear 2": "linear",
            "bent 2 tetrahedral": "tetrahedral",
            # TODO: have a way to distiguish whether the ring is
            # in the axial-equitorial or equitorial-equitorial
            "bent 2 planar": "trigonal bipyramidal",
            "bent 3 tetrahedral": "tetrahedral",
            "t shaped": "octahedral",
            "tetrahedral": "tetrahedral",
            "sawhorse": "trigonal bipyramidal",
            "seesaw": "octahedral",
            "square planar": "octahedral",
            "trigonal pyramidal": "trigonal bipyramidal",
            "trigonal bipyramidal": "trigonal bipyramidal",
            "square pyramidal": "octahedral",
            "octahedral": "octahedral",
        }

        ring_types = dict()
        for fname in [
            os.path.join(AARONTOOLS, "ring_conformers.json"), 
            os.path.join(AARONLIB, "ring_conformers.json"),
        ]:
            if not os.path.exists(fname):
                continue
            with open(fname, "r") as f:
                these_types = json.load(f)
            ring_types.update(these_types)

        #XXX: remember to fix this when oop_type options mean anything
        ric = InternalCoordinateSet(geometry, torsion_type="all", oop_type="yes")

        if targets is None:
            targets = geometry.atoms
        else:
            targets = geometry.find(targets)

        # identify rings
        rings = []
        ring_atoms = set()
        graph = []
        ndx = {a: i for i, a in enumerate(geometry.atoms) if a in targets}
        for a in geometry.atoms:
            if a in targets:
                graph.append([ndx[n] for n in a.connected if n in targets])
            else:
                graph.append([])
        
        utils.prune_branches(graph)
        for a in range(0, len(graph)):
            # skip atoms with no valid neighbors
            if not graph[a]:
                continue
            
            # skip atoms we've already found
            if a in ring_atoms:
                continue
            
            found_ring = False
            # look for a path to each pair of neighbors
            for a2 in graph[a]:
                if found_ring and a2 in ring_atoms:
                    continue
                # copy the graph, but remove the node for this atom
                graph[a].remove(a2)
                path = shortest_path(graph, a, a2)
                if path is not None:
                    ring_atoms.update(path)
                    rings.append(path)
                    found_ring = True
                    graph[a].append(a2)
                else:
                    # this pair of atoms is not in a ring
                    # we will not need to revisit
                    graph[a2].remove(a)
            
            # if this atom is not in a ring, we will not
            # need to visit it again - remove it's connections
            # from the graph
            if not found_ring:
                for a2 in graph[a]:
                    graph[a2].remove(a)
                graph[a] = []
                utils.prune_branches(graph)

        # need to figure out reasonable torsion values
        # depending on the type of ring it is
        flexible_torsions = []
        ring_torsions = []
        torsion_options = []
        exclude_rings = []
        kinds = ["common"]
        if include_uncommon:
            kinds.append("uncommon")
        for ring in rings:
            vseprs = []
            ring_torsions.append([])
            for i in range(0, len(ring)):
                atom1 = i
                atom2 = i + 1
                if atom2 >= len(ring):
                    atom2 -= len(ring)
                group1 = i - 1
                if group1 < 0:
                    group1 += len(ring)
                group2 = atom2 + 1
                if group2 >= len(ring):
                    group2 -= len(ring)
                
                vsepr, err = geometry.atoms[ring[atom1]].get_vsepr()
                try:
                    vseprs.append(normal_vseprs[vsepr])
                except KeyError:
                    vseprs.append(vsepr)

                for torsion in ric.coordinates["torsions"]:
                    if (
                        torsion.atom1 == ring[atom1] and
                        torsion.atom2 == ring[atom2] and 
                        torsion.group1[0] == ring[group1] and 
                        torsion.group2[0] == ring[group2]
                    ):
                        flexible_torsions.append(torsion)
                        ring_torsions[-1].append(torsion)
                        break
                
                    elif (
                        torsion.atom1 == ring[atom2] and
                        torsion.atom2 == ring[atom1] and 
                        torsion.group1[0] == ring[group2] and 
                        torsion.group2[0] == ring[group1]
                    ):
                        torsion.group1, torsion.group2 = torsion.group2, torsion.group1
                        torsion.atom1, torsion.atom2 = torsion.atom2, torsion.atom1
                        flexible_torsions.append(torsion)
                        ring_torsions[-1].append(torsion)
                        break
            
            # this could probably only happen if there's a linear angle
            # in a ring
            # torsions skip linear atoms
            # e.g. allene will have H-C1-C3-H torsions
            if len(vseprs) != len(ring):
                cls.LOG.warning("ring atoms and vseprs don't match!")
                # continue
            
            for i in range(0, len(vseprs)):
                vseprs = np.roll(vseprs, 1)
                ring_torsions[-1] = np.roll(ring_torsions[-1], 1)
                ring_type = ", ".join(vseprs)
                try:
                    angles = []
                    if "common" in ring_types[str(len(ring))][ring_type]:
                        angles.extend(ring_types[str(len(ring))][ring_type]["common"])
                    if include_uncommon and "uncommon" in ring_types[str(len(ring))][ring_type]:
                        angles.extend(ring_types[str(len(ring))][ring_type]["uncommon"])

                    torsion_options.append(angles)
                    ring_torsions[-1] = ring_torsions[-1].tolist()
                    break
                except KeyError:
                    continue
            else:
                ring_torsions.pop(-1)
                exclude_rings.append(ring)
                cls.LOG.debug(
                    "unknown ring type with %i atoms and %s VSEPR pattern" % (
                        len(ring), ring_type
                    )
                )

        for ring in exclude_rings:
            rings.remove(ring)

        # need to remove torsions that connect to these
        # rings, but that are not part of the ring
        # otherwise the changes we try to make to the
        # internal coordinates will suck, or we will
        # have to figure out how to change these torsion
        # in a way that corresponds to the changes we
        # are making to the ring torsions
        remove_torsions = []
        for t in ric.coordinates["torsions"]:
            if t in flexible_torsions:
                continue
            if (
                t.group1[0] in ring_atoms or
                t.atom1 in ring_atoms or
                t.atom2 in ring_atoms or
                t.group2[0] in ring_atoms
            ):
                remove_torsions.append(t)

        ric.coordinates["torsions"] = [t for t in ric.coordinates["torsions"] if t not in remove_torsions]
        
        unique_geoms = [geometry.copy()]
        if not torsion_options:
            cls.LOG.debug("no ring conformers could be found")
            return unique_geoms
        
        # try each 'reasonable' combination of torsions for every ring
        coords = geometry.coords
        current_q = ric.values(coords)
        combos = itertools.product(*torsion_options)
        i = 1
        for combo in combos:
            i += 1
            
            probably_useless = False
            #TODO: make finding the indices of a coordinate easier
            dq = np.zeros(ric.n_dimensions)
            visited = set()
            for j, (ring, torsions) in enumerate(zip(rings, ring_torsions)):
                print(ring)
                for t, v in zip(torsions, combo[j]):
                    print(t, v)
                for k, torsion in enumerate(torsions):
                    n = 0
                    for coord_type in ric.coordinates:
                        for coord in ric.coordinates[coord_type]:
                            if coord is torsion:
                                # if there are fused rings, there will be at least one
                                # pair of torsions with the same two middle atoms
                                # if the conformer we're trying doesn't have the same
                                # change in both of these torsions, it probably won't
                                # produce a reasonable structure
                                # so if we've seen a torsion with these middle atoms
                                # before, but the targeted change in torsional angle
                                # is different from before, we will skip
                                if (
                                    (torsion.atom1, torsion.atom2) in visited and
                                    not np.isclose(dq[n] - np.deg2rad(combo[j][k]) + coord.value(coords), 0, atol=1e-2)
                                ):
                                    probably_useless = True

                                dq[n : n + coord.n_values] = (
                                    np.deg2rad(combo[j][k]) - coord.value(coords)
                                )
                                visited.add((torsion.atom1, torsion.atom2))

                                # print("changing %s by %.1f" % (str(torsion), np.rad2deg(dq[n])))
                            n += coord.n_values
            
            # there will be at least one combination with basically no changes
            if np.linalg.norm(dq) < 1e-3:
                # print("no changes")
                continue
            
            if probably_useless:
                # print("probably useless")
                continue
            
            # try setting the torsions
            new_coords, err = ric.apply_change_2(coords, dq, convergence=1e-7)
            if (err / len(rings)) > 1e-1:
                print("significant deviation from expected torsions: %.2f" % err)
                continue
            
            # print("generated conformer")
            
            # do RMSD to make sure it's actually unique
            #XXX: RMSD sucks at this in simple test cases - consider
            # adding a variant RMSD function that checks all permutations
            # of equivalent atoms or something
            # mirroring can sometimes trick it
            ref = geometry.copy()
            ref.coords = new_coords
            ref_mirror = ref.copy()
            ref_mirror.mirror()
            for geom in unique_geoms:
                rmsd = geom.RMSD(ref, sort=True, align=True)
                if rmsd < 1e-2:
                    break
                rmsd = geom.RMSD(ref_mirror, sort=True, align=True)
                if rmsd < 1e-2:
                    break

            else:
                unique_geoms.append(ref)

        actually_unique = []
        for i, geom1 in enumerate(unique_geoms):
            geom1_mirror = geom1.copy()
            geom1_mirror.mirror()
            for j, geom2 in enumerate(unique_geoms[:i]):
                rmsd = geom1.RMSD_permute(geom2)
                if rmsd < 1e-2:
                    break
                rmsd = geom1_mirror.RMSD_permute(geom2)
                if rmsd < 1e-2:
                    break
            else:
                actually_unique.append(geom1)

        # profile.disable()
        # profile.print_stats()
        
        print(len(actually_unique))
        return actually_unique

    @staticmethod
    def list_solvents(include_ext=False):
        """
        Retrieves a list of solvents stored in AaronTools

        :param bool include_ext: Includes file extensions (.xyz) on
            each solvent when true.
        :return: string array with the names of all solvents in the libraries
        """
        names = []
        solvents = []
        BUILTIN = os.path.join(AARONTOOLS, "Solvents")
        AARON_LIBS = os.path.join(AARONLIB, "Solvents")
        for lib in [AARON_LIBS, BUILTIN]:
            if not os.path.exists(lib):
                continue
            for f in os.listdir(lib):
                name, ext = os.path.splitext(os.path.basename(f))
                if not any(".%s" % x == ext for x in read_types):
                    continue

                if name in names:
                    continue

                names.append(name)

                if include_ext:
                    solvents.append(name + ext)
                else:
                    solvents.append(name)

        return solvents

    # attribute access
    def _stack_coords(self, atoms=None):
        """
        Generates a N x 3 coordinate matrix for atoms
        Note: the matrix rows are copies of, not references to, the
            Atom.coords objects. Run Geometry.update_geometry(matrix) after
            using this method to save changes.
        """
        if atoms is None:
            atoms = self.atoms
        else:
            atoms = self.find(atoms)
        rv = np.array([a.coords for a in atoms], dtype=float)
        return rv

    @property
    def elements(self):
        """
        returns list of elements composing the atoms in the geometry
        """
        return np.array([a.element for a in self.atoms])

    @property
    def num_atoms(self):
        """
        number of atoms
        """
        return len(self.atoms)

    @property
    def coords(self):
        """
        array of coordinates (read only)
        """
        return self.coordinates()

    @coords.setter
    def coords(self, value):
        """
        set coordinates
        """
        for a, c in zip(self.atoms, value):
            a.coords = np.array(c, dtype=float)

    def coordinates(self, atoms=None):
        """
        :param list(Atom) atoms: atoms to be searched
        :return: N x 3 coordinate matrix for requested atoms
            (defaults to all atoms)
        :rtype: np.ndarray
        """
        if atoms is None:
            return self._stack_coords()
        return self._stack_coords(atoms)

    # utilities
    def __str__(self):
        xyz = self.write(outfile=False)
        return xyz
        # Duplicate method; __repr__ is the same code
        # Remove?

    def __repr__(self):
        """string representation"""
        xyz = self.write(outfile=False)
        return xyz

    def __eq__(self, other):
        """
        two geometries equal if:
            same number of atoms
            same numbers of elements
            coordinates of atoms similar
        """
        if not isinstance(other, self.__class__):
            return False
        if id(self) == id(other):
            return True
        if len(self.atoms) != len(other.atoms):
            return False

        self_eles = [atom.element for atom in self.atoms]
        other_eles = [atom.element for atom in other.atoms]
        self_counts = {ele: self_eles.count(ele) for ele in set(self_eles)}
        other_counts = {ele: other_eles.count(ele) for ele in set(other_eles)}
        if self_counts != other_counts:
            return False

        try:
            self_atypes = [atom.atomtype for atom in self.atoms]
            other_atypes = [atom.atomtype for atom in other.atoms]
            self_atcounts = {at: self_atypes.count(at) for at in set(self_atypes)}
            other_atcounts = {at: other_atypes.count(at) for at in set(other_atypes)}
            if self_atcounts != other_atcounts:
                return False
        except AttributeError:
            pass

        rmsd = self.RMSD(other, sort=False)
        return rmsd < COORD_THRESHOLD

    def __add__(self, other):
        """
        adds other or other's atoms to self
        """
        if isinstance(other, Atom):
            other = [other]
        elif not isinstance(other, list):
            other = other.atoms
        self.atoms += other
        return self

    def __sub__(self, other):
        """
        subtracts other or other's atoms from self
        """
        if isinstance(other, Atom):
            other = [other]
        elif not isinstance(other, list):
            other = other.atoms
        for o in other:
            self.atoms.remove(o)
        for a in self.atoms:
            if a.connected & set(other):
                a.connected = a.connected - set(other)
        return self

    def __iter__(self):
        """
        resets the iterator of self
        """
        self._iter_idx = -1
        return self

    def __next__(self):
        """
        iterates to the next atom of self
        """
        if self._iter_idx + 1 < len(self.atoms):
            self._iter_idx += 1
            return self.atoms[self._iter_idx]
        raise StopIteration

    def __len__(self):
        """
        returns the number of atoms in self
        """
        return len(self.atoms)

    def __setattr__(self, attr, val):
        if attr == "_hashed" and not val:
            raise RuntimeError("can only set %s to True" % attr)

        if not self._hashed or (self._hashed and attr != "atoms"):
            super().__setattr__(attr, val)
        else:
            raise RuntimeError(
                "cannot change atoms attribute of HashableGeometry"
            )

    def __hash__(self):
        # hash depends on atom elements, connectivity, order, and coordinates
        # reorient using principle axes
        coords = self.coords
        coords -= self.COM()
        mat = np.matmul(coords.T, coords)
        vals = np.linalg.svd(mat, compute_uv=False)

        t = [int(v * 3) for v in vals]
        for atom, coord in zip(self.atoms, coords):
            # only use the first 3 decimal places of coordinates b/c numerical issues
            t.append(int(atom.get_neighbor_id()))
            if not atom._hashed:
                atom.connected = frozenset(atom.connected)
                atom.coords.setflags(write=False)
                atom._hashed = True
            # make sure atoms don't move
            # if atoms move, te hash value could change making it impossible to access
            # items in a dictionary with this instance as the key

        if not self._hashed:
            self.LOG.warning(
                "Geometry `%s` has been hashed and will no longer be editable.\n"
                "Use Geometry.copy to get an editable duplicate of this instance",
                self.name,
            )
            self.atoms = tuple(self.atoms)
            self._hashed = True

        return hash(tuple(t))

    def tag(self, tag, targets=None):
        """
        Adds a tag to atoms within a Geometry object

        :param str tag: tag to be added to the targets
        :param list(Atom) targets: atoms to be given the tag, defaults to all atoms
        """
        if targets is None:
            targets = self.atoms
        else:
            targets = self.find(targets)
        for atom in targets:
            atom.tags.add(tag)

    def write(self, name=None, *args, **kwargs):
        """
        Write geometry to a file

        :param str name: name for geometry defaults to self.name
        :param args: passed to FileWriter.write
        :param kwargs: passed to FileWriter.write
        """
        tmp = self.name
        if name is not None:
            self.name = name
        out = FileWriter.write_file(self, *args, **kwargs)
        self.name = tmp
        if out is not None:
            return out

    def display(self, style="stick", colorscheme="Jmol"):
        """
        Display py3Dmol viewer from Geometry

        :param str style: stick, sphere, or line (or other style supported by 3Dmol.js)
        :param str colorscheme: 3Dmol.js color scheme (see https://3dmol.org/doc/global.html#builtinColorSchemes)
        """

        def is_notebook():
            try:
                shell = get_ipython().__class__.__name__ # TODO get_ipython undefined 
                if shell == 'ZMQInteractiveShell':
                    return True   # Jupyter notebook or qtconsole
                elif shell == 'TerminalInteractiveShell':
                    return False  # Terminal running IPython
                else:
                    return False  # Other type (?)
            except NameError:
                return False      # Probably standard Python interpreter

        if is_notebook():
            try:
                import py3Dmol
                view = py3Dmol.view(
                    data=self.write(outfile=False),
                    style={style: {'colorscheme': colorscheme}},
                )
                #display labels on mouse hover using js
                view.setHoverable({},True,'''function(atom,viewer,event,container) {
                       if(!atom.label) {
                        var ndx = atom.index + 1;
                        atom.label = viewer.addLabel(
                            atom.atom + ":" + ndx,
                            {position: atom, backgroundColor: 'white', fontColor:'black'}
                        );
                       }}''',
                   '''function(atom,viewer) {
                       if(atom.label) {
                        viewer.removeLabel(atom.label);
                        delete atom.label;
                       }
                    }''')
                view.show()
            except ImportError:
                print("py3Dmol required to display 3D representations")
        else:
            print(self.write(outfile=False))

    # Simple function to convert Geometry to basic Psi4 molecule.  Expand later to
    # pass multiple fragments, etc.
    def convert_to_Psi4(self, charge=0, mult=1, fix_com=True, fix_orientation=True):
        """
        converts Geometry into Psi4 Molecule object (requires Psi4)

        :param int charge: total molecular charge
        :param int mult: multiplicity
        :param bool fix_com: whether to fix center of mass in Psi4 Molecule
        :param bool fix_coordinates: whether to fix coordinates in Psi4 Molecule
        :returns: activated Psi4 Molecule (or None if Psi4 not available)
        """

        try:
            import psi4
            import psi4.core as p4c
        except:
            return None

        mol = psi4.core.Molecule.from_arrays(
            elez = [ ELEMENTS.index(atom.element) for atom in self ],
            fix_com = True,
            fix_orientation = True,
            molecular_multiplicity = mult,
            molecular_charge = charge,
            comment = self.comment,
            geom = self.coords,
            units = 'Angstrom'
            )
        psi4.activate(mol)
        return mol 


    # quick and dirty code to display HoukMol style figures in Matplotlib
    # bond ends could be handled more elegently, but this looks fine for most molecules

    def plot(self, ax, fig, fp=40, ascale=0.5, bwidth=0.15):
        """
        displays HoukMol style molecule in Matplotlib

        :param matplotlib.pyplot.Axis ax: Matplotlib Axis object
        :param matplotlib.pyplot.Figure fig: Matplotlib Figure object:w
        :param float fp: z-value (Angstroms) for focal point for adding perspective (Default: 40)
        :param float ascale: scaling factor for covalent radii (default: 0.5)
        :param float bwidth: scaling factor for bond radii (default: 0.15)
        """

        try:
            import matplotlib.patches as patches
        except:
            self.LOG.error("Must install matplot lib")
            return None

        def intersect(atom1, atom2, fp):
            # returns intersection of line from atom1 to edge of scaled sphere for atom2
            # from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Line%E2%80%93sphere_intersection
        
            c = atom2.coords             # center of sphere
            r = RADII[atom2.element]*0.5*(fp + atom2.coords[2])/fp # radius of sphere, adjusted for perspective
            o = atom1.coords             # starting point for line
            u = atom1.bond(atom2)        # vector along line
            unorm = u/np.sqrt(np.linalg.norm(u)) # normalized vector
        
            dot = np.dot(unorm, o - c)
            delta = dot**2 - (np.linalg.norm(o - c)**2 - r**2)
        
            if delta <= 0:
                # catch cases where there is no intersection for some reason
                return c
            else:
                d = dot + np.sqrt(delta)
                return o - d*u*1.0 # adjust endpoints slightly to account for rounded capstyle



        def draw_bond(x1, y1, x2, y2, z, fp, scale, ax, bwidth=0.15):
            """
            Draw HoukMol style bond as black line with rounded ends from (x1, y1) to (x2, y2)
            width of bond is controlled by width and scaled to z-value for perspective
            """
        
            w=(bwidth*scale) * (fp + z)/fp
            ax.plot([x1, x2], [y1, y2], lw=w, color='black', solid_capstyle='round', zorder=z)

        
        # if xlim not set manually (or by first plotting some data) then I can't determine
        # the overall size of the plot until after the molecule is drawn, but I need overall size 
        # to determine scale for bond widths to plot the molecule...
        if ax.get_xaxis()._get_autoscale_on() and np.allclose(ax.get_xlim(), np.array((0, 1))):
            self.LOG.warning("You will probably need to set xlim manually or plot data first to get reasonable bond widths.")

        # get scale and size of plot set linewidths in terms of pts (1/72 inch per pt)
        xmin, xmax = ax.get_xlim()
        dx = xmax - xmin
        ymin, ymax = ax.get_ylim()
        dy = ymax - ymin
        fw, fh = fig.get_size_inches()
        bbox = ax.get_position()
        ax_width = fw*bbox.width
        scale = 72*ax_width/dx
        
        # sort atoms by z-value
        sorted_atoms = [atom for atom in sorted(self.atoms, key=lambda a: a.coords[2])]

        for atom in sorted_atoms:
            # note that I draw each bond twice to get both ends correct
            # this avoids having to do the logic of figuring out the order of
            # drawing bonds to a given atom--each atom obscures bonds originating
            # from that atom, but this is corrected when the bond is drawn
            # from the connected atom. Any way I've tried to fix this looks wrong
            # for planar molecules, which are the only ones I actually care about.
        
            for connected in atom.connected:
                endpoint = intersect(atom, connected, fp)
                draw_bond(atom.coords[0], atom.coords[1], endpoint[0], endpoint[1], atom.coords[2], fp, scale, ax, bwidth)

            atom.draw_atom(ax, fp, ascale=ascale, linewidth=0.01*scale)

    def copy(self, atoms=None, name=None, comment=None, copy_atoms=True):
        """
        creates a new copy of the geometry
        
        :param list(Atom) atoms: atoms to copy defaults to all atoms
        :param str name: defaults to NAME_copy
        :param str comment: comment to add to the copy, defaults to self's comment
        :param bool copy_atoms: passed to _fix_connectivity, defaults to True
        """
        if name is None:
            name = self.name
        if comment is None:
            comment = self.comment
        atoms = self._fix_connectivity(atoms, copy=copy_atoms)
        if hasattr(self, "components") and self.components is not None and comment is None:
            self.fix_comment()
        return Geometry(atoms, name, comment=comment, refresh_ranks=False, refresh_connected=False)

    def parse_comment(self):
        """
        Saves auxillary data found in comment line
        """
        if not self.comment:
            return {}
        rv = {}
        # constraints
        match = re.search("F:([0-9;-]+)", self.comment)
        if match is not None:
            rv["constraint"] = []
            for a in self.atoms:
                a.constraint = set([])
            match = match.group(1).split(";")
            for m in match:
                if m == "":
                    continue
                m = m.split("-")
                m = [int(i) for i in m]
                if len(m) == 2:
                    for i, j in zip(m[:-1], m[1:]):
                        a = self.find(str(i))[0]
                        b = self.find(str(j))[0]
                        a.constraint.add((b, a.dist(b)))
                        b.constraint.add((a, b.dist(a)))
                rv["constraint"] += [m]
        # active centers
        match = re.search("C:([0-9,]+)", self.comment)
        if match is not None:
            rv["center"] = []
            match = match.group(1).split(",")
            for m in match:
                if m == "":
                    continue
                a = self.atoms[int(m) - 1]
                a.add_tag("center")
                rv["center"] += [a]
        # ligand
        match = re.search("L:([0-9;,-]+)", self.comment)
        if match is not None:
            rv["ligand"] = []
            match = match.group(1).split(";")
            for submatch in match:
                tmp = []
                for m in submatch.split(","):
                    if m == "":
                        continue
                    if "-" not in m:
                        a = self.atoms[int(m) - 1]
                        tmp += [a]
                        continue
                    m = m.split("-")
                    for i in range(int(m[0]) - 1, int(m[1])):
                        try:
                            a = self.atoms[i]
                        except IndexError:
                            continue
                        tmp += [a]
                rv["ligand"] += [tmp]
        #link atoms
        match = re.search("LA:([0-9;-]+)", self.comment)
        if match is not None:
            rv["link_atoms"] = []
            match = match.group(1).split(";")
            for m in match:
                if m == "":
                    continue
                m = m.split("-")
                m = [int(i) - 1 for i in m]
                rv["link_atoms"] += [m]
                for i, j in zip(m[:-1], m[1:]):
                    a = self.atoms[i]
                    b = self.atoms[j]
                    a.add_tag("LAH bonded to " + b.name)
                    b.add_tag("bonded to LA on " + a.name)
        # scale factors for link atoms
        match = re.search("SF:([0-9,.;-]+)", self.comment)
        if match is not None:
            rv["scale factors"] = []
            match = match.group(1).split(";")
            for m in match:
                m = m.split("-")
                atom_index = int(m[0])-1
                scale_factors = m[1].split(",")
                self.atoms[atom_index].add_tag("scale factors " + scale_factors)
        # key atoms
        match = re.search("K:([0-9,;]+)", self.comment)
        if match is not None:
            rv["key_atoms"] = []
            match = match.group(1).split(";")
            for m in match:
                if m == "":
                    continue
                m = m.split(",")
                for i in m:
                    if i == "":
                        continue
                    rv["key_atoms"] += [int(i) - 1]
        self.other = rv
        return rv

    def fix_comment(self):
        """
        sets self.comment to define key atoms for ligands, etc.
        """
        if not hasattr(self, "components"):
            return
        elif self.components is None:
            self.detect_components()
        new_comment = ""
        # center
        if self.center:
            new_comment += "C:"
            for c in self.center:
                new_comment += "{},".format(self.atoms.index(c) + 1)
            else:
                new_comment = new_comment[:-1]

        # key atoms
        new_comment += " K:"
        for frag in sorted(self.components):
            tmp = ""
            for key in sorted(frag.key_atoms, key=self.atoms.index):
                tmp += "{},".format(self.atoms.index(key) + 1)
            if tmp:
                new_comment += tmp[:-1] + ";"
        if new_comment[-3:] == " K:":
            new_comment = new_comment[:-3]
        else:
            new_comment = new_comment[:-1]

        # constrained bonds
        constrained = self.get_constraints()
        if constrained:
            new_comment += " F:"
            for cons in constrained:
                ids = [cons[0] + 1]
                ids += [cons[1] + 1]
                new_comment += "{}-{};".format(*sorted(ids))
            else:
                new_comment = new_comment[:-1]

        # components
        if self.components:
            new_comment += " L:"
            for lig in sorted(self.components):
                ids = sorted([1 + self.atoms.index(a) for a in lig])
                tmp = []
                for i in ids:
                    if i == ids[0]:
                        tmp = [i]
                        continue
                    if i == tmp[-1] + 1:
                        tmp += [i]
                    elif len(tmp) == 1:
                        new_comment += "{},".format(tmp[0])
                        tmp = [i]
                    else:
                        new_comment += "{}-{},".format(tmp[0], tmp[-1])
                        tmp = [i]
                if len(tmp) == 1:
                    new_comment += "{},".format(tmp[0])
                else:
                    new_comment += "{}-{},".format(tmp[0], tmp[-1])
                new_comment = new_comment[:-1] + ";"
            new_comment = new_comment[:-1]


        # save new comment (original comment still in self.other)
        self.comment = new_comment

    def _flag(self, flag, targets=None):
        """
        freezes targets if <flag> is True,
        relaxes targets if <flag> is False
        """
        if isinstance(targets, Config):
            if targets._changed_list is not None:
                targets = targets._changed_list
            else:
                raise RuntimeError(
                    "Substitutions/Mappings requested, but not performed"
                )
        if targets is not None:
            targets = self.find(targets)
            if not targets:
                targets = self.atoms
        else:
            targets = self.atoms
        for a in targets:
            a.flag = flag
        return

    def freeze(self, targets=None):
        """
        freezes atoms in the geometry
        
        :param list(Atom|str|Finder) targets: atoms to freeze
        """
        self._flag(True, targets)

    def relax(self, targets=None):
        """
        relaxes atoms in the geometry
        
        :param list(Atom|str|Finder) targets: atoms to unfreeze
        """
        self._flag(False, targets)

    def get_constraints(self, as_index=True):
        """
        get frozen atoms
        
        :param bool as_index: return indices instead of atoms
        
        :return: frozen atoms
        :rtype: list(int|Atom)
        """
        rv = {}
        for i, a in enumerate(self.atoms[:-1]):
            if not a.constraint:
                continue
            for j, b in enumerate(self.atoms[i:]):
                for atom, dist in a.constraint:
                    if b == atom:
                        if as_index:
                            rv[(i, i + j)] = dist
                        else:
                            rv[(a, b)] = dist
                        break
        return rv

    def get_connectivity(self):
        """
        Iterates through each atom and finds its connected atoms

        :return: list of all atoms' connectivities
        :rtype: list(list(Atom))
        """
        rv = []
        for atom in self.atoms:
            rv += [atom.connected]
        return rv

    def get_frag_list(self, targets=None, max_order=None):
        """
        find fragments connected by only one bond
        (both fragments contain no overlapping atoms)
        
        :param targets: atoms to look for fragments on,
            defaults to all atoms
        :param int max_order: max bond order to cut when
            defining fragments
        :return: list of all fragments found
        :rtype: list(list(Atom))
        """
        if targets:
            atoms = self.find(targets)
        else:
            atoms = self.atoms
        frag_list = []
        for i, a in enumerate(atoms[:-1]):
            for b in atoms[i + 1 :]:
                if b not in a.connected:
                    continue

                frag_a = self.get_fragment(a, b)
                if any(x in b.connected for x in frag_a[1:]):
                    continue
                frag_b = self.get_fragment(b, a)
                if any(x in a.connected for x in frag_b[1:]):
                    continue

                if sorted(frag_a) == sorted(frag_b):
                    continue

                if len(frag_a) == 1 and frag_a[0].element == "H":
                    continue
                if len(frag_b) == 1 and frag_b[0].element == "H":
                    continue

                if max_order is not None and a.bond_order(b) > max_order:
                    continue

                if (frag_a, a, b) not in frag_list:
                    frag_list += [(frag_a, a, b)]
                if (frag_b, b, a) not in frag_list:
                    frag_list += [(frag_b, b, a)]
        return frag_list

    def get_graph(self):
        """
        returns a graph based on connectivity
        graph consists of a list for each atom consisting of a list of connected atoms
        For example, for H2O with O as atom 1, graph = [[1,2], [0], [0]]

        :return: graph created by the method
        """
        ndx = {a: i for i, a in enumerate(self.atoms)}
        graph = [[ndx[b] for b in a.connected if b in ndx] for a in self.atoms]
        return graph

    def detect_substituents(self):
        """sets self.substituents to a list of substituents"""
        from AaronTools.substituent import Substituent

        # TODO: allow detection of specific substituents only
        #       -check fragment length and elements against
        #        that of the specified substituent
        # copy-pasted from Component.detect_backbone, but
        # removed stuff that refers to the center/backbone

        if not hasattr(self, "substituents") or self.substituents is None:
            self.substituents = []

        frag_list = self.get_frag_list()

        new_tags = {}  # hold atom tag options until assignment determined
        subs_found = {}  # for testing which sub assignment is best
        sub_atoms = set([])  # holds atoms assigned to substituents
        for frag_tup in sorted(frag_list, key=lambda x: len(x[0])):
            frag, start, end = frag_tup
            if frag[0] != start:
                frag = self.reorder(start=start, targets=frag)[0]

            # try to find fragment in substituent library
            try:
                sub = Substituent(frag, end=end)
            except LookupError:
                continue

            # substituents with more than half of self's atoms are ignored
            if len(frag) > len(self.atoms) - len(frag):
                continue
            # save atoms and tags if found
            sub_atoms = sub_atoms.union(set(frag))
            subs_found[sub.name] = len(sub.atoms)
            for a in sub.atoms:
                if a in new_tags:
                    new_tags[a] += [sub.name]
                else:
                    new_tags[a] = [sub.name]

            # save substituent
            self.substituents += [sub]

        # tag substituents
        for a in new_tags:
            tags = new_tags[a]
            if len(tags) > 1:
                # if multiple substituent assignments possible,
                # want to keep the largest one (eg: tBu instead of Me)
                sub_length = []
                for t in tags:
                    sub_length += [subs_found[t]]
                max_length = max(sub_length)
                if max_length < 0:
                    max_length = min(sub_length)
                keep = sub_length.index(max_length)
                a.add_tag(tags[keep])
            else:
                a.add_tag(tags[0])

    def find(self, *args, debug=False): # Parameter debug is unused in method. Remove?
        """
        finds atom in geometry

        :param list|tuple|str|Finder args: tags, names, elements, or a Finder subclass
            args=(['this', 'that'], 'other') will find atoms for which
            ('this' || 'that') && 'other' == True

        :return: list of matching atoms 
        :rtype: list(Atom)|list()
        
        :raises LookupError: when the tags/names provided do not exist.
            However, it will return empty list if valid tag/names were provided
            but were screened out using the && argument form
        """

        name_str = re.compile("^(\*|\d)+(\.?\*|\.\d+)*$")
        elements_set = set(ELEMENTS)
        def _find(arg):
            """find a single atom"""
            # print(arg)
            if isinstance(arg, Atom):
                # print("atom")
                return [arg]

            rv = []
            if isinstance(arg, Finder):
                # print("finder")
                rv += arg.get_matching_atoms(self.atoms, self)

            elif isinstance(arg, str) and name_str.match(arg) is not None:
                # print("name")
                test_name = arg.replace(".", "\.")
                test_name = test_name.replace("*", "(\.?\d+\.?)*")
                test_name = re.compile("^" + test_name + "$")
                # this is a name
                for a in self.atoms:
                    if test_name.search(a.name) is not None:
                        rv += [a]

            elif arg == "all":
                rv += [a for a in self.atoms]

            elif isinstance(arg, str) and len(arg.split(",")) > 1:
                # print("comma list")
                list_style = arg.split(",")
                if len(list_style) > 1:
                    for i in list_style:
                        if len(i.split("-")) > 1:
                            rv += _find_between(i)
                        else:
                            rv += _find(i)

            elif (
                isinstance(arg, str)
                and len(arg.split("-")) > 1
                and not re.search("[A-Za-z]", arg)
            ):
                # print("range list")
                rv += _find_between(arg)

            elif isinstance(arg, str) and arg in elements_set:
                # print("element")
                # this is an element
                for a in self.atoms:
                    if a.element == arg:
                        rv += [a]
            else:
                # print("tag")
                # this is a tag
                for a in self.atoms:
                    if arg in a.tags:
                        rv += [a]
            return rv

        def _find_between(arg):
            """find sequence of atoms"""

            def _name2ints(name):
                name = name.split(".")
                return [int(i) for i in name]

            a1, a2 = tuple(arg.split("-"))
            a1 = _find(a1)[0]
            a2 = _find(a2)[0]

            rv = []
            for a in self.atoms:
                # keep if a.name is between a1.name and a2.name
                test_name = _name2ints(a.name)
                a1_name = _name2ints(a1.name)
                a2_name = _name2ints(a2.name)

                for tn, a1n, a2n in zip(test_name, a1_name, a2_name):
                    if tn < a1n:
                        # don't want if test atom sorts before a1
                        break
                    if tn > a2n:
                        # don't want if test atom sorts after a2
                        break
                else:
                    rv += _find(a)
            return rv

        if len(args) == 1:
            if isinstance(args[0], tuple):
                args = args[0]
        rv = []
        for a in args:
            if hasattr(a, "__iter__") and not isinstance(a, str):
                # argument is a list of sub-arguments
                # OR condition
                tmp = []
                for i in a:
                    tmp += _find(i)
                rv += [tmp]
            else:
                rv += [_find(a)]

        # error if no atoms found (no error if AND filters out all found atoms)
        # if len(rv) == 1:
        #     if len(rv[0]) == 0:
        #         raise LookupError(
        #             "Could not find atom: %s on\n%s\n%s"
        #             % ("; ".join([str(x) for x in args]), self.name, str(self))
        #         )
        #     return rv[0]

        # exclude atoms not fulfilling AND requirement
        tmp = []
        for i in rv[0]:
            good = True
            for j in rv[1:]:
                if i not in j:
                    good = False
            if good:
                tmp += [i]
        return tmp

    def find_exact(self, *args):
        """
        finds exactly the same number of atoms as arguments used.
        
        :param list|tuple|str|Finder args: tags, names, elements, or Finder subclass
            consisting of those you want to check self for

        :return: list of atoms found
        :rtype: tuple(Atom)

        :raises LookupError: if wrong number of atoms found
        """
        rv = []
        err = "Wrong number of atoms found: "
        is_err = False
        for arg in args:
            a = self.find(arg)

            if len(a) != 1:
                is_err = True
                err += "{} (found {}), ".format(arg, len(a))
            else:
                rv += a

        if is_err:
            err = err[:-2]
            raise LookupError(err)
        return tuple(rv)

    def _fix_connectivity(self, atoms=None, copy=True):
        """
        for fixing the connectivity for a set of atoms when grabbing
        a fragment or copying atoms, ensures atom references are sane

        :param atoms: the atoms to fix connectivity for; connections to atoms
            outside of this list are severed in the resulting list
        :param bool copy: perform a deepcopy of the atom list, defaults to True
        """
        if atoms is None:
            atoms = self.atoms
        else:
            atoms = self.find(atoms)

        ndx = {atom: i for i, atom in enumerate(atoms)}

        connectivity = []
        for a in atoms:
            connectivity += [
                [ndx[i] for i in a.connected if i in ndx]
            ]
        if copy:
            atoms = [a.copy() for a in atoms]
        for a, con in zip(atoms, connectivity):
            a.connected = set([])
            for c in con:
                a.connected.add(atoms[c])

        return atoms

    def refresh_connected(self, targets=None, threshold=0.3):
        """
        reset connected atoms
        
        atoms are connected if their distance from each other is less than
        the sum of their covalent radii plus a threshold
        
        :param targets: atoms to update connectivity
        :param float threshold: upper limit on difference to ideal
            covalent bond length
        """
        # clear current connectivity
        if targets is None:
            targets = self.atoms
        else:
            targets = self.find(targets)
        
        # reset the connectivity and make sure each atom has a covalent radius
        radii_list = []
        for a in targets:
            if targets is not self.atoms:
                for b in a.connected:
                    b.connected.discard(a)
            a.connected = set([])
            radii_list.append(a._radii)

        coords = self.coordinates(targets)

        # get a distance matrix and a matrix with the max distance
        # each atom can be from another atom and still be connected to it
        D = distance.squareform(distance.pdist(coords, "sqeuclidean"))
        max_connected_dist = np.add.outer(radii_list, radii_list) + threshold
        max_connected_dist = max_connected_dist ** 2
        
        # wherever distance < max connected distance, that pair
        # of atoms is connected
        # we only filled the lower triangle for max_connected_dist, so
        # the upper triangle is all zeros
        # np.tril basically discards the upper triangle, and
        # nonzero gives the indices of all True values
        connected = np.tril(D < max_connected_dist, k=-1).nonzero()
        for (ndx1, ndx2) in zip(*connected):
            targets[ndx1].add_bond_to(targets[ndx2])

    def refresh_ranks(self, invariant=True):
        """
        updates ranks of all atoms
        
        :param bool invariant: passed to Geometry.canonical_rank
        """
        rank = self.canonical_rank(invariant=invariant)
        for a, r in zip(self.atoms, rank):
            a._rank = r
        return

    def make_oniom(self):
        """convert existing geometry composed of Atom objects
        to geometry of OniomAtom objects including changing
        all atoms in attribute lists to OniomAtom objects"""
        
        old_connectivity = []
        ndx = {atom: i for i, atom in enumerate(self.atoms)}
        constraint_ndx = {}
        oniomatoms = []

        for i, atom in enumerate(self.atoms):
            old_connectivity.append([])
            for connected in atom.connected:
                old_connectivity[-1].append(ndx[connected])
            if atom.constraint:
                for j, b in enumerate(self.atoms[i:]):
                    for a, dist in a.constraint:
                        if b == a:
                            constraint_ndx[i] = [j, dist]
            oniomatom = OniomAtom(atom=atom)
            oniomatoms.append(oniomatom)

        for oniomatom, connectivity in zip(oniomatoms, old_connectivity):
            oniomatom.connected = set([])
            for i in connectivity:
                oniomatom.connected.add(oniomatoms[i])
        for key, val in constraint_ndx:
            oniomatoms[key].constraint = set([])
            oniomatoms[key].constraint.add((oniomatoms[val[0]], val[1]))
            oniomatoms[val[0]].constraint.add((oniomatoms[key], val[1]))

        geom = Geometry(structure = oniomatoms, name = self.name, comment = self.comment, components = self.components)
        return geom

    def get_invariants(self, heavy_only=False):
        """
        returns a list of invariants for the specified targets
        see Atom.get_invariant for some more details

        :param list(Atom) heavy_only: atoms to get invariants for
        :param bool heavy_only: ignores hydrogens if true
        """
        targets = self.atoms

        if heavy_only:
            targets = [a for a in targets if a.element != "H"]

        indices = {a: i for i, a in enumerate(targets)}
        useful_atoms = set(targets)
        for a in targets:
            useful_atoms.update(a.connected)
        useful_atoms = list(useful_atoms)
        n_useful = len(useful_atoms)
        useful_indices = {a: i for i, a in enumerate(useful_atoms)}
        target_set = set(targets)

        coords = self.coordinates(targets)

        def get_bo(atom1, atom2, dist):
            """
            atom1, atom2 - Atom()
            dist - float, distance between atom1 and atom2
            returns a bond order (float) or 1 if we don't have
            bond info for these atoms' elements
            """
            return atom1._bo.get(atom1, atom2, dist=dist)

        atom_numbers = [ELEMENTS.index(a.element) for a in targets]
        hydrogen_bonds = np.zeros(len(targets))
        bo_sums = np.zeros(len(targets))
        heavy_bonds = np.zeros(len(targets))
        dists = distance.pdist(self.coordinates(useful_atoms))
        for i, atom1 in enumerate(targets):
            if not atom1.connected:
                continue
            if atom1.element != "H":
                n = useful_indices[atom1]
            for k, atom2 in enumerate(atom1.connected):
                if atom2 in target_set:
                    j = indices[atom2]
                else:
                    j = None

                if atom2.element == "H":
                    hydrogen_bonds[i] += 1
                else:
                    heavy_bonds[i] += 1

                if atom1.element == "H":
                    hydrogen_bonds[j] += 1
                elif j is not None:
                    heavy_bonds[j] += 1

                bond_order = 1
                if atom1.element != "H" and atom2.element != "H":
                    m = useful_indices[atom2]
                    min_ndx, max_ndx = n, m
                    if n > m:
                        min_ndx, max_ndx = m, n
                    ndx = n_useful * min_ndx + max_ndx - ((min_ndx + 2) * (min_ndx + 1)) // 2
                    bond_order = get_bo(atom1, atom2, dists[ndx])
                
                if atom2.element != "H":
                    bo_sums[i] += bond_order

                if j is not None and atom1.element != "H":
                        bo_sums[j] += bond_order

                elif j is None and atom2.element == "H":
                    hydrogen_bonds[i] += 1
                
                elif j is None:
                    heavy_bonds[i] += 1
                    bo_sums[i] += bond_order

        invariants = []
        for nconn, nB, z, nH in zip(
            heavy_bonds, bo_sums, atom_numbers, hydrogen_bonds
        ):
            invariants.append(
                "{:01d}{:03d}{:03d}{:01d}".format(
                    int(nconn), int(nB * 10), int(z), int(nH)
                )
            )

        return invariants
    
    def canonical_rank(
        self, heavy_only=False, break_ties=True, update=False, invariant=True,
        initial_ranks=None,
    ): 
        """
        determine canonical ranking for atoms
        
        :param bool heavy_only: ignores hydrogens if true
        :param bool break_ties: breaks ties based on angle around COM 
        :param bool invariant: if True, use invariant described in
            J. Chem. Inf. Comput. Sci. 1989, 29, 2, 97–101
            (DOI: 10.1021/ci00062a008)
            if False, use neighbor IDs
        :param list initial_ranks: list of initial ranks, one for each atom

        :return: list of rankings

        algorithm described in J. Chem. Inf. Model. 2015, 55, 10, 2111–2120
        (DOI: 10.1021/acs.jcim.5b00543)
        """
        CITATION = "doi:10.1021/ci00062a008"
        self.LOG.citation(CITATION)
        CITATION = "doi:10.1021/acs.jcim.5b00543"
        self.LOG.citation(CITATION)

        primes = Primes.list(len(self.atoms))
        # list of atoms we are ranking
        atoms = []
        # list of ranks corresponding to each atom
        ranks = []
        # index of each atom (faster than using atoms.index,
        # particularly for larger structures
        indices = dict()
        # set of atoms for performance reasons
        atoms_set = set()

        # using the catalyst's center can make it difficult
        # to compare C2 symmetric ligands
        # center = list(filter(lambda x: "center" in x.tags, self))
        # if center:
        #     center = self.COM(targets=center)
        # else:
        center = self.COM()

        def neighbors_rank(ranks):
            # partitions key is product of rank and neighbors' rank
            # use prime numbers for product so products are distinct
            # eg: primes[2]*primes[2] != primes[1]*primes[4]
            
            # some high-symmetry molecules can get a rank greater than
            # the number of atoms
            # I've had this issue with adamantane (Td)
            # this is a lazy fix that reduces the rank of some atoms by 1
            while max(ranks) >= len(ranks):
                for i in range(1, max(ranks) + 1):
                    if ranks.count(i - 1) == 0:
                        for j in range(1, len(ranks)):
                            if ranks[j] >= i:
                                ranks[j] -= 1

            partitions = {r: {} for r in ranks}
            for i, a in enumerate(atoms):
                key = primes[ranks[i]]
                for b in a.connected.intersection(atoms_set):
                    # print(indices[b], ranks[indices[b]])
                    key *= primes[ranks[indices[b]]]
                try:
                    partitions[ranks[i]][key] += [i]
                except KeyError:
                    partitions[ranks[i]][key] = [i]
            return update_ranks(ranks, partitions)

        def update_ranks(ranks, partitions):
            new_ranks = ranks.copy()
            for rank, key_dict in partitions.items():
                if len(key_dict) == 1:
                    continue
                for key in sorted(key_dict.keys()):
                    for idx in key_dict[key]:
                        new_ranks[idx] = rank
                    rank += len(key_dict[key])
            return new_ranks

        def tie_break(ranks):
            """
            Uses atom angles around COM -> shared_atom axis to break ties[
            Does not break symmetry (eg: pentane carbons still [0, 2, 4, 2, 0]
            because C2 and C4 are ~180 deg apart relative to COM-C5 axis)
            """

            def get_angle(vi, vj, norm):
                dot = np.dot(vi, vj)
                # numpy cross products are slower apparently 
                cross = np.array([
                    [vi[1] * vj[2] - vi[2] * vj[1]],
                    [vi[2] * vj[0] - vi[0] * vj[2]],
                    [vi[0] * vj[1] - vi[1] * vj[0]],
                ])
                det = np.dot(norm, cross)
                rv = np.arctan2(det, dot)
                return round(rv[0], 1)

            
            # this code isn't used?
            def get_start(connected, center, norm):
                # if we can, use the COM of tied atoms as reference 0-deg
                start = self.COM(targets=[atoms[c] for c in connected])
                start -= center
                if np.linalg.norm(np.cross(start, norm)) > 1e-2:
                    return start
                # if there's one atom that is closest/farthest to center,
                # use that as start
                start_min = None, None
                start_max = None, None
                for i, c in enumerate(connected):
                    dist = np.linalg.norm(atoms[c].coords - center)
                    if start_min[0] is None or dist < start_min[1]:
                        start_min = [c], dist
                    elif dist == start_min[1]:
                        start_min = start_min[0] + [c], dist
                    if start_max[0] is None or d < start_max[1]: #TODO d is undefined
                        start_max = [c], dist
                    elif dist == start_max[1]:
                        start_max = start_max[0] + [c], dist
                if len(start_min[0]) == 1:
                    start = atoms[start_min[0][0]].coords - center
                    return start
                if len(start_max[0]) == 1:
                    start = atoms[start_max[0][0]].coords - center
                    return start
                # otherwise, try to use COM of equally close/far atoms
                if len(start_min[0]) < len(connected):
                    start = self.COM(targets=[atoms[c] for c in start_min[0]])
                    start -= center
                    if np.linalg.norm(np.cross(start, norm)) > 1e-2:
                        return start
                if len(start_max[0]) < len(connected):
                    start = self.COM(targets=[atoms[c] for c in start_max[0]])
                    start -= center
                    if np.linalg.norm(np.cross(start, norm)) > 1e-2:
                        return start
                # if all else fails, just use the first atom I guess...
                return atoms[connected[0]].coords - center

            partitions = {r: {} for r in ranks}
            for i, rank in enumerate(ranks):
                try:
                    partitions[rank][rank] += [i]
                except KeyError:
                    partitions[rank][rank] = [i]

            new_partitions = partitions.copy()

            for rank, rank_dict in partitions.items():
                idx_list = rank_dict[rank]
                if len(idx_list) == 1:
                    continue
                # split ties into groups connected to same atom
                groups = {}
                for i in idx_list[:-1]:
                    a = atoms[i]
                    for j in idx_list[1:]:
                        b = atoms[j]
                        connected = a.connected & b.connected
                        if len(connected) == 1:
                            k = connected.pop()
                            try:
                                k = indices[k]
                                groups.setdefault(k, set([i]))
                                groups[k] |= set([j])
                            except KeyError:
                                pass
                # atoms in each group sorted in counter clockwise order
                # around axis centered at shared atom and orthogonal to COM
                for shared_idx, connected in groups.items():
                    connected = sorted(connected)
                    start = atoms[shared_idx].coords - center
                    # numpy cross products are slower apparently 
                    norm = np.array([
                        start[1] * center[2] - start[2] * center[1],
                        start[2] * center[0] - start[0] * center[2],
                        start[0] * center[1] - start[1] * center[0]
                    ])
                    angles = {}
                    for c in connected:
                        this = atoms[c].coords - center
                        angle = get_angle(start, this, norm)
                        try:
                            angles[angle] += [c]
                        except KeyError:
                            angles[angle] = [c]
                    if len(angles) == 1 and atoms[shared_idx].connected - set(
                        [atoms[c] for c in connected]
                    ):
                        tmp_center = self.COM(
                            atoms[shared_idx].connected
                            - set([atoms[c] for c in connected])
                        )
                        start = atoms[shared_idx].coords - tmp_center
                        norm = np.array([
                            start[1] * tmp_center[2] - start[2] * tmp_center[1],
                            start[2] * tmp_center[0] - start[0] * tmp_center[2],
                            start[0] * tmp_center[1] - start[1] * tmp_center[0]
                        ])
                        # norm = np.cross(start, tmp_center)
                        angles = {}
                        for c in connected:
                            this = atoms[c].coords - tmp_center
                            angle = get_angle(start, this, norm)
                            try:
                                angles[angle] += [c]
                            except KeyError:
                                angles[angle] = [c]
                    for i, angle in enumerate(sorted(angles.keys())):
                        try:
                            new_partitions[rank][rank + i] += angles[angle]
                        except KeyError:
                            new_partitions[rank][rank + i] = angles[angle]
                        for idx in angles[angle]:
                            # if idx in new_partitions[rank][rank]:
                                # new_partitions[rank][rank].remove(idx)
                            try:
                                new_partitions[rank][rank].remove(idx)
                            except ValueError:
                                continue
            return update_ranks(ranks, new_partitions)

        # rank all atoms the same initially
        c = 0
        if initial_ranks is None:
            starting_ranks = [0 for a in self.atoms]
        else:
            starting_ranks = initial_ranks
        for a, r in zip(self.atoms, starting_ranks):
            if heavy_only and a.element == "H":
                continue
            atoms += [a]
            ranks += [r]
            indices[a] = c
            c += 1
        atoms_set = set(atoms)

        # partition and re-rank using invariants
        partitions = {}
        if invariant:
            invariants = self.get_invariants(heavy_only=heavy_only)
        else:
            invariants = [a.get_neighbor_id() for a in atoms]
        partitions = {atom_id: [] for atom_id in invariants}
        for i, atom_id in enumerate(invariants):
            partitions[atom_id].append(i)
        if initial_ranks is None:
            new_rank = 0
            for key in sorted(partitions.keys()):
                idx_list = partitions[key]
                for idx in idx_list:
                    ranks[idx] = new_rank
                new_rank += len(idx_list)

        # re-rank using neighbors until no change
        for i in range(0, min(500, len(ranks))):
            new_ranks = neighbors_rank(ranks)
            if ranks == new_ranks:
                break
            ranks = new_ranks
        else:
            self.LOG.warning(
                "Max cycles reached in canonical sorting (neighbor-ranks)"
            )

        # break ties using spatial positions
        # AND update neighbors until no change
        if break_ties:
            for i in range(0, min(500, len(ranks))):
                new_ranks = tie_break(ranks)
                new_ranks = neighbors_rank(new_ranks)
                if ranks == new_ranks:
                    break
                ranks = new_ranks
            else:
                self.LOG.warning(
                    "Max cycles reached in canonical sorting (tie-breaking)"
                )

        if update:
            for a, r in zip(atoms, ranks):
                a._rank = r

        return ranks

    def element_counts(self):
        """
        number of each element in this Geometry
        
        :rtype: dict(str:int)
        """
        eles = dict()
        for ele in self.elements:
            eles.setdefault(ele, 0)
            eles[ele] += 1

        return eles

    def reorder(
        self,
        start=None,
        targets=None,
        heavy_only=False,
    ):
        """
        Depth-first reorder of atoms based on canonical ranking
        
        :param Atom start: atom to start the reorder from, defaults to first atom
        :param list(Atom) targets: atoms to be reordered, defaults to all atoms
        :param bool heavy_only: ignores hydrogens if true

        :rtype: tuple(list(ordered_targets), list(non_targets))
        """

        if not targets:
            targets = self.atoms
        else:
            targets = self.find(targets)
        if heavy_only:
            targets = [t for t in targets if t.element != "H"]
        non_targets = [a for a in self.atoms if a not in set(targets)]

        if targets is self.atoms:
            ranks = [a._rank for a in targets]
            if not all(r is not None for r in ranks):
                ranks = self.canonical_rank()
            sorted_atoms = [a for _, a in sorted(zip(ranks, self.atoms), key = lambda x: x[0])]
        elif not start:
            sorted_atoms = sorted(targets)

        # get starting atom
        if not start:
            order = [sorted_atoms[0]]
        else:
            order = sorted(self.find(start))
        start = sorted(order)
        visited = set(start)
        stack = []
        for s in start:
            stack += sorted(s.connected)
        atoms_left = set(targets)
        atoms_left -= set(order)
        while len(atoms_left) > 0:
            if not stack and atoms_left:
                stack += [sorted(atoms_left)[0]]

            this = stack.pop()
            if heavy_only and this.element == "H":
                continue
            if this in visited:
                continue
            order += [this]
            visited.add(this)
            connected = set(this.connected & atoms_left)
            try:
                atoms_left.remove(this)
            except KeyError:
                pass
            stack += sorted(connected)

        return order, non_targets

    def rebuild(self):
        atoms = []
        if self.components:
            if self.center:
                atoms += self.center
            for comp in sorted(self.components):
                comp.rebuild()
                atoms += comp.atoms
            self.atoms = atoms
        self.fix_comment()
        self.refresh_ranks()

    def detect_components(self, center=None):
        from AaronTools.component import Component

        self.components = []
        if center is None:
            self.center = []
        else:
            self.center = self.find(center)

        # get center
        if not self.center:
            for a in self.atoms:
                if a.element in TMETAL.keys():
                    # detect transition metal center
                    if a not in self.center:
                        self.center += [a]
                    a.add_tag("center")
                if "center" in a.tags:
                    # center provided by comment line in xyz file
                    if a not in self.center:
                        self.center += [a]

        # label key atoms:
        for i, a in enumerate(self.atoms):
            if "key_atoms" not in self.other:
                break
            if i in self.other["key_atoms"]:
                a.add_tag("key")
        else:
            del self.other["key_atoms"]

        # get components
        self.components = self.detect_fragments(self.atoms)
        # rename
        for i, frag in enumerate(self.components):
            name = self.name + ".{:g}".format(
                min(
                    [
                        float(a.name)
                        if utils.is_num(a.name)
                        else frag.index(a)
                        for a in frag
                    ]
                )
            )
            self.components[i] = Component(frag, name)

        self.rebuild()
        return

    def detect_fragments(self, targets, avoid=None):
        """
        Returns a list of Geometries in which the connection to other
        atoms in the larger geometry must go through the center atoms
        
        for example, ::
        
            L1--C--L2 
            (  /
            L1/
        
        will give two fragments, L1 and L2

        :param Geometry self: Structure to be searched for fragments
        :param list(Atom) targets: Returned fragments will include targets
        :param list(Atom) avoid: Atoms to be ignored during search; center atom is avoided by default

        :returns: List of fragments
        :rtype: list(Geometry)
        """

        def add_tags(frag):
            for f in frag:
                found.add(f)
                for c in self.center:
                    if f in c.connected:
                        f.add_tag("key")

        if avoid is None and self.center:
            avoid = self.center
        found = set([])
        rv = []

        if "ligand" in self.other:
            for ligand in self.other["ligand"]:
                frag = set(self.find(ligand))
                frag -= found
                add_tags(frag)
                rv += [sorted(frag)]
                found.union(frag)

        for a in targets:
            if a in found:
                continue
            if avoid:
                if a in avoid:
                    continue
                frag = set(self.get_fragment(a, avoid))
                frag -= found
                add_tags(frag)
                rv += [sorted(frag)]
                found.union(frag)
            else:
                frag = set([a])
                queue = a.connected.copy()
                while queue:
                    this = queue.pop()
                    if this in frag:
                        continue
                    frag.add(this)
                    queue = queue.union(this.connected)
                frag -= found
                add_tags(frag)
                rv += [sorted(frag)]
                found = found.union(frag)
        return rv

    def shortest_path(self, atom1, atom2, avoid=None):
        """
        Uses Dijkstra's algorithm to find shortest path between atom1 and atom2
        
        :param atom1: starting atom
        :param atom2: ending atom
        :param avoid: atoms to avoid on the path
        
        :return: atoms on the path from atom1 to atom2, including atom1 and atom2
        :rtype: list(Atom)
        """
        a1 = self.find(atom1)[0]
        a2 = self.find(atom2)[0]
        if not avoid:
            path = utils.shortest_path(self, a1, a2)
        else:
            avoid = self.find(avoid)
            ndx = {atom: i for i, atom in enumerate(self.atoms)}
            graph = [
                [
                    ndx[j] for j in i.connected
                    if j in self.atoms and j not in avoid
                ]
                if i not in avoid
                else []
                for i in self.atoms
            ]
            path = utils.shortest_path(
                graph, ndx[a1], ndx[a2]
            )
        if not path:
            raise LookupError(
                "could not determine best path between {} and {}".format(
                    atom1, atom2
                )
            )
        return [self.atoms[i] for i in path]

#Modified to return monomers with original atom ordering (SEW)
# -ordering within each monomer returned matches original
# -monomer ordering matches the order within the dimer
    def get_monomers(self):
        """
        Searches a geometry for monomers
        
        :returns: A list of atoms for each monomer of self in order
        :rtype: list(Atom)
        """

        all_atoms = [a for a in self.atoms]
        ndx = {a: i for i, a in enumerate(self.atoms)}
        monomers = []
        while all_atoms:
            atom = all_atoms.pop(0)
            monomer = self.get_all_connected(atom)
            for a in monomer:
                try:
                    all_atoms.remove(a)
                except ValueError:
                    # `atom` will not be in all_atoms because we popped it
                    pass
            monomer.sort(key=lambda a: ndx[a])
            monomers.append(monomer)

        return monomers

#OLD
#    def get_monomers(self):
#        """returns a list of lists of atoms for each monomer of self"""
#        
#        all_atoms = set(self.atoms)
#        monomers = []
#        while all_atoms:
#            atom = all_atoms.pop()
#            monomer = set(self.get_all_connected(atom))
#            all_atoms -= monomer
#            monomers.append(monomer)
#        
#        return [list(monomer) for monomer in monomers]

    # geometry measurement
    def bond(self, a1, a2):
        """
        takes two atoms and returns the bond vector (need to fix formatting)
        
        :param Atom a1: First atom in bond
        :param Atom a2: Second atom in bond
        :returns: the vector of the two atoms' bond
        """
        
        a1, a2 = self.find_exact(a1, a2)
        return a1.bond(a2)

    def angle(self, a1, a2, a3=None):
        """
        returns a1-a2-a3 angle
        
        :param Atom a1: First atom
        :param Atom a2: Central atom
        :param Atom a3: Last atom
        :returns: the internal angle of the three atoms
        """
        a1, a2, a3 = self.find_exact(a1, a2, a3)
        return a2.angle(a1, a3)

    def dihedral(self, a1, a2, a3, a4):
        """
        measures dihedral angle of a1 and a4 with respect to a2-a3 bond
        
        :param Atom a1: First atom 
        :param Atom a2: Second atom
        :param Atom a3: Third atom
        :param Atom a4: Last atom
        :returns: the angle between a1 and a4
        """
        a1, a2, a3, a4 = self.find_exact(a1, a2, a3, a4)

        b12 = a1.bond(a2)
        b23 = a2.bond(a3)
        b34 = a3.bond(a4)

        dihedral = np.cross(np.cross(b12, b23), np.cross(b23, b34))
        dihedral = np.dot(dihedral, b23) / np.linalg.norm(b23)
        dihedral = np.arctan2(
            dihedral, np.dot(np.cross(b12, b23), np.cross(b23, b34))
        )

        return dihedral

    def COM(self, targets=None, heavy_only=False, mass_weight=True, charge_weight=False):
        """
        calculates center of mass of the target atoms
        mass_weight and charge_weight cannot both be true
        
        :param targets: the atoms to use in calculation, defaults to all
        :param bool heavy_only: exclude hydrogens, defaults to False
        :param bool mass_weight: bases calculations on mass, defaults to True
        :param bool charge_weight: based calculations on charge, defaults to False
        :returns: a vector from the origin to the center of mass
        """
        if mass_weight and charge_weight:
            raise RuntimeError("cannot use both charge_weight and mass_weight")
        
        # get targets
        if targets:
            targets = self.find(targets)
        else:
            targets = list(self.atoms)
        # screen hydrogens if necessary
        if heavy_only:
            targets = [a for a in targets if a.element != "H"]

        coords = self.coordinates(targets)
        if mass_weight:
            total_mass = 0
            for i in range(0, len(coords)):
                coords[i] *= targets[i].mass
                total_mass += targets[i].mass
        if charge_weight:
            total_charge = 0
            for i in range(0, len(coords)):
                charge = ELEMENTS.index(targets[i].element)
                coords[i] *= charge
                total_charge += charge
                
        # COM = (1/M) * sum(m * r) = sum(m*r) / sum(m)
        center = np.mean(coords, axis=0)

        if mass_weight and total_mass:
            return center * len(targets) / total_mass
        if charge_weight and total_charge:
            return center * len(targets) / total_charge
        return center

    def RMSD(
        self,
        ref,
        align=False,
        heavy_only=False,
        sort=True,
        refresh_ranks=True,
        targets=None,
        ref_targets=None,
        debug=False,
        weights=None,
        ref_weights=None,
    ):
        """
        calculates the RMSD between two geometries

        :param Geometry ref: the geometry to compare to
        :param bool align: if True (default), align self to other;
            if False, just calculate the RMSD
        :param bool heavy_only: only use heavy atoms (default False)
        :param targets: the atoms in `self` to use in calculation
        :param ref_targets:  the atoms in the reference geometry to use
        :param bool sort: canonical sorting of atoms before comparing
        :param bool sort: refresh atom ranks before doing canonical sorting
        :param bool debug: returns RMSD and Geometry([ref_targets]), Geometry([targets])
        :param list(float) weights: weights to apply to targets
        :param list(float) ref_weights: weights to apply to ref_targets
        :returns: RMSD in Angstroms
        :rtype: float
        """

        def _RMSD(ref, other):
            """
            ref and other are lists of atoms
            returns rmsd, angle, vector
                rmsd (float)
                angle (float) angle to rotate by
                vector (np.array(float)) the rotation axis
            """
            matrix = np.zeros((4, 4), dtype=np.float64)
            # not sure why we don't throw an error if the ref
            # and targets aren't the same amount
            if len(other) < len(ref):
                ref = ref[:len(other)]
            matrix = utils.quat_matrix(other, ref)

            eigenval, eigenvec = np.linalg.eigh(matrix)
            val = eigenval[0]
            vec = eigenvec.T[0]

            if val > 0:
                # val is the SD
                rmsd = np.sqrt(val / len(ref))
            else:
                # negative numbers that are basically zero, like -1e-16
                rmsd = 0

            # sometimes it freaks out if the coordinates are right on
            # top of each other and gives overly large rmsd/rotation
            # I think this is a numpy precision problem, may want to
            # try scipy.linalg to see if that helps?
            tmp = np.sqrt(np.sum((ref - other) ** 2) / len(ref))
            if tmp < rmsd:
                rmsd = tmp
                vec = np.array([0, 0, 0])
            return rmsd, vec

        # get target atoms
        tmp = targets
        if targets is not None:
            targets = self.find(targets)
        else:
            targets = self.atoms
        if ref_targets is not None:
            ref_targets = ref.find(ref_targets)
        elif tmp is not None:
            ref_targets = ref.find(tmp)
        else:
            ref_targets = ref.atoms

        # screen out hydrogens if heavy_only requested
        if heavy_only:
            targets = [a for a in targets if a.element != "H"]
            ref_targets = [a for a in ref_targets if a.element != "H"]

        # using _fix_connectivity is generally slightly faster b/c we don't need
        # to redetermine connectivity
        # however, some methods like map_ligand don't alter the bonds at all
        # therefore, we will redetermine the connectivity for these copied atoms
        # this = Geometry(self._fix_connectivity(targets), refresh_ranks=sort and refresh_ranks, refresh_connected=False)
        # ref = Geometry(ref._fix_connectivity(ref_targets), refresh_ranks=sort and refresh_ranks, refresh_connected=False)
        this = Geometry([t.copy() for t in targets], refresh_ranks=sort and refresh_ranks, refresh_connected=sort)
        ref = Geometry([r.copy() for r in ref_targets], refresh_ranks=sort and refresh_ranks, refresh_connected=sort)
        if weights is not None:
            for w, a in zip(weights, this.atoms):
                a.coords *= w

        if ref_weights is not None:
            for w, a in zip(ref_weights, ref.atoms):
                a.coords *= w

        # align center of mass to origin
        com = this.COM()
        ref_com = ref.COM()

        this.coord_shift(-com)
        ref.coord_shift(-ref_com)

        # try current ordering
        min_rmsd = _RMSD(ref.coords, this.coords)
        # try canonical ordering
        if sort:
            this.atoms = this.reorder()[0]
            ref.atoms = ref.reorder()[0]
            this_ranks = [a._rank for a in this.atoms]
            ref_ranks = [a._rank for a in ref.atoms]
            if (
                len(this_ranks) != len(set(this_ranks)) or
                len(ref_ranks) != len(set(ref_ranks))
            ):
                # if there are atoms with the same rank, align both ref and this
                # to their principle axes and use the distance between the atoms
                # in the structures to determine the order
                this_atoms = []
                ref_atoms = [a for a in ref.atoms]
                _, this_axes = this.get_principle_axes()
                _, ref_axes = ref.get_principle_axes()
                this_coords = this.coords - this.COM()
                ref_coords = ref.coords - ref.COM()
                # align this to ref using the matrix that aligns this's principle axes
                # to ref's principle axes
                H = np.dot(ref_coords.T, this_coords)
                u, s, vh = np.linalg.svd(H, compute_uv=True)
                d = 1.0
                if np.linalg.det(np.matmul(vh.T, u.T)) < 0:
                    d = -1.0
                m = np.diag([1.0, 1.0, d])
                R = np.matmul(vh.T, m)
                R = np.matmul(R, u.T)

                this_coords = np.dot(this_coords, R)

                # find the closest atom in this to the closest atom in ref
                dist = distance_matrix(ref_coords, this_coords)
                for i, r_a in enumerate(ref.atoms):
                    min_dist = None
                    match = None
                    for j, t_a in enumerate(this.atoms):
                        if t_a.element != r_a.element:
                            continue
                        if t_a in this_atoms:
                            continue

                        if min_dist is None or dist[i, j] < min_dist:
                            min_dist = dist[i, j]
                            match = t_a
                    if match is not None:
                        this_atoms.append(match)
                    else:
                        ref_atoms.remove(r_a)

                # if we didn't find any matches or not all atoms are matched,
                # use the original order
                # otherwise, use the order determined by distances
                if len(ref_atoms) == len(this_atoms) and ref_atoms:
                    res = _RMSD(
                        np.array([a.coords for a in ref_atoms]),
                        np.array([a.coords for a in this_atoms])
                    )
                else:
                    res = _RMSD(ref.coords, this.coords)

            else:
                res = _RMSD(ref.coords, this.coords)

            if res[0] < min_rmsd[0]:
                min_rmsd = res

        rmsd, vec = min_rmsd

        # return rmsd
        if not align:
            if debug:
                return this, ref, rmsd, vec
            else:
                return rmsd
        # or update geometry and return rmsd
        self.coord_shift(-com)
        if np.linalg.norm(vec) > 0:
            self.rotate(vec)
        self.coord_shift(ref_com)
        if debug:
            this.rotate(vec)
            return this, ref, rmsd, vec
        else:
            return rmsd

    def RMSD_permute(
        self,
        ref,
        align=False,
        heavy_only=False,
        targets=None,
        ref_targets=None,
        debug=False,
        weights=None,
        ref_weights=None,
        max_order="smallest",
        stop_threshold=1e-3,
    ):
        """
        calculate the RMSD between two structures by considering permutations
        of equivalent atoms
        
        :param Geometry ref: structure to compare to
        :param bool align: align self to ref
        :param bool heavy_only: only use non-H atoms
        :param list targets: atoms on self to use in RMSD calculation
        :param list ref_targets: atoms on ref to use in RMSD calculation
        :param list weights: list of weights for each atom for weighted RMSD calculation
        :param list ref_weights: list of weights for each ref atom for weighted RMSD calculation
        :param int max_order: max size of groups of atoms to permute (default is the size of the smallest group)
        :param float stop_threshold: stop checking permutations if we find an RMSD < stop_threshold
        :returns: RMSD in Angstroms
        :rtype: float
        """
    
        # _RMSD is copy-pasted from RMSD(), consider moving to utils?
        def _RMSD(ref, other):
            """
            ref and other are lists of atoms
            returns rmsd, angle, vector
                rmsd (float)
                angle (float) angle to rotate by
                vector (np.array(float)) the rotation axis
            """
            matrix = np.zeros((4, 4), dtype=np.float64)
            # not sure why we don't throw an error if the ref
            # and targets aren't the same amount
            if len(other) < len(ref):
                ref = ref[:len(other)]
            matrix = utils.quat_matrix(other, ref)

            eigenval, eigenvec = np.linalg.eigh(matrix)
            val = eigenval[0]
            vec = eigenvec.T[0]

            if val > 0:
                # val is the SD
                rmsd = np.sqrt(val / len(ref))
            else:
                # negative numbers that are basically zero, like -1e-16
                rmsd = 0

            # sometimes it freaks out if the coordinates are right on
            # top of each other and gives overly large rmsd/rotation
            # I think this is a numpy precision problem, may want to
            # try scipy.linalg to see if that helps?
            tmp = np.sqrt(np.sum((ref - other) ** 2) / len(ref))
            if tmp < rmsd:
                rmsd = tmp
                vec = np.array([0, 0, 0])
            return rmsd, vec

        # get target atoms
        tmp = targets
        if targets is not None:
            targets = self.find(targets)
        else:
            targets = self.atoms
        if ref_targets is not None:
            ref_targets = ref.find(ref_targets)
        elif tmp is not None:
            ref_targets = ref.find(tmp)
        else:
            ref_targets = ref.atoms

        # screen out hydrogens if heavy_only requested
        if heavy_only:
            targets = [a for a in targets if a.element != "H"]
            ref_targets = [a for a in ref_targets if a.element != "H"]

        # using _fix_connectivity is generally slightly faster b/c we don't need
        # to redetermine connectivity
        # however, some methods like map_ligand don't alter the bonds at all
        # therefore, we will redetermine the connectivity for these copied atoms
        # this = Geometry(self._fix_connectivity(targets), refresh_ranks=sort and refresh_ranks, refresh_connected=False)
        # ref = Geometry(ref._fix_connectivity(ref_targets), refresh_ranks=sort and refresh_ranks, refresh_connected=False)
        this = Geometry([t.copy() for t in targets], refresh_ranks=False, refresh_connected=True)
        ref = Geometry([r.copy() for r in ref_targets], refresh_ranks=False, refresh_connected=True)
        if weights is not None:
            for w, a in zip(weights, this.atoms):
                a.coords *= w

        if ref_weights is not None:
            for w, a in zip(ref_weights, ref.atoms):
                a.coords *= w

        # align center of mass to origin
        com = this.COM()
        ref_com = ref.COM()

        this.coord_shift(-com)
        ref.coord_shift(-ref_com)

        ndx = {a: i for i, a in enumerate(this.atoms)}
        ref_ndx = {a: i for i, a in enumerate(ref.atoms)}
        # determine which atoms are equivalent based on rank
        this_ranks = this.canonical_rank(break_ties=False, update=False, heavy_only=heavy_only)
        this_groups = {}
        for a, r in zip(this.atoms, this_ranks):
            this_groups.setdefault(r, [])
            this_groups[r].append(a)
        
        ref_ranks = ref.canonical_rank(break_ties=False, update=False)
        ref_groups = {}
        for a, r in zip(ref.atoms, ref_ranks):
            ref_groups.setdefault(r, [])
            ref_groups[r].append(a)
        
        dupe_groups = sorted([k for k in this_groups.keys() if len(this_groups[k]) > 1], key=lambda x: len(this_groups[x]))
        dupe_ref_groups = sorted([k for k in ref_groups.keys() if len(ref_groups[k]) > 1], key=lambda x: len(ref_groups[x]))
        
        min_rmsd = _RMSD(ref.coords, this.coords)
        # print(min_rmsd)
        n = 0
        ref.canonical_rank(update=True, initial_ranks=ref_ranks, break_ties=True)
        # for atoms with the same rank, try different ranks
        # if we find and rmsd < stop_threshold, stop trying
        # XXX: we do need to check if ref has some equivalent atoms
        # if ref does and this doesn't, we should be changing
        # the ranks of ref and not this
        # though this would only happen in cases where the connectivity is different
        # so the ranks based on a molecular graph might not even work
        # TODO: this only looks at one rank at a time
        # make it look at multiple
        # the code for that would be similar to makeConf
        if max_order == "smallest":
            max_order = min([len(group) for group in this_groups.values()])
        for rank in sorted(dupe_groups, key=lambda x: len(this_groups[x])):
            if len(this_groups[rank]) > max_order:
                break
            # print("checking rank", rank, "which has", len(this_groups[rank]), "members")
            for atoms in itertools.permutations(this_groups[rank], len(this_groups[rank])):
                test_this_ranks = [r for r in this_ranks]
                for i, a in enumerate(atoms):
                    test_this_ranks[ndx[a]] = test_this_ranks[ndx[a]] + i
                this.canonical_rank(update=True, initial_ranks=test_this_ranks, break_ties=True)

                this.atoms = this.reorder()[0]
                ref.atoms = ref.reorder()[0]
                res = _RMSD(ref.coords, this.coords)
                n += 1
        
                if res[0] < min_rmsd[0]:
                    min_rmsd = res

                if min_rmsd[0] < stop_threshold:
                    break
            if min_rmsd[0] < stop_threshold:
                break

        rmsd, vec = min_rmsd

        # return rmsd
        if not align:
            if debug:
                return this, ref, rmsd, vec
            else:
                return rmsd
        # or update geometry and return rmsd
        self.coord_shift(-com)
        if np.linalg.norm(vec) > 0:
            self.rotate(vec)
        self.coord_shift(ref_com)
        if debug:
            this.rotate(vec)
            return this, ref, rmsd, vec
        else:
            return rmsd

    def get_near(self, ref, dist, by_bond=False, include_ref=False):
        """
        :returns: list of atoms within a distance or number of bonds of a
            reference point, line, plane, atom, or list of atoms
        :rtype: list(Atom)

        :param list ref: the point (eg: [0, 0, 0]), line (eg: ['*', 0, 0]), plane
            (eg: ['*', '*', 0]), atom, or list of atoms
        :param float dist: the distance threshold or number of bonds away threshold, is an
            inclusive upper bound (uses `this <= dist`)
        :param bool by_bond: if true, `dist` is interpreted as the number of bonds away
            instead of distance in angstroms
            NOTE: by_bond=True means that ref must be an atom or list of atoms
        :param bool include_ref: if Atom or list(Atom) given as ref, include these in the
            returned list, (default=False, do not include ref in returned list)
        """
        if dist < 0:
            raise ValueError(
                "Distance or number of bonds threshold must be positive"
            )
        if not hasattr(ref, "iter") and isinstance(ref, Atom):
            ref = [ref]
        rv = []

        # find atoms within number of bonds away
        if by_bond:
            dist_err = "by_bond=True only applicable for integer bonds away"
            ref_err = (
                "by_bond=True only applicable for ref of type Atom() or "
                "list(Atom())"
            )
            if int(dist) != dist:
                raise ValueError(dist_err)
            for r in ref:
                if not isinstance(r, Atom):
                    raise TypeError(ref_err)
            stack = set(ref)
            rv = set([])
            while dist > 0:
                dist -= 1
                new_stack = set([])
                for s in stack:
                    rv = rv.union(s.connected)
                    new_stack = new_stack.union(s.connected)
                stack = new_stack
            if not include_ref:
                rv = rv - set(ref)
            return sorted(rv)

        # find atoms within distance
        if isinstance(ref, Atom):
            ref = [ref.coords]
        elif isinstance(ref, list):
            new_ref = []
            just_nums = []
            for r in ref:
                if isinstance(r, Atom):
                    new_ref += [r.coords]
                elif isinstance(r, list):
                    new_ref += [r]
                else:
                    just_nums += [r]
            if len(just_nums) % 3 != 0:
                raise ValueError(
                    "coordinates (or wildcards) must be passed in sets of "
                    "three: [x, y, z]"
                )
            else:
                while len(just_nums) > 0:
                    new_ref += [just_nums[-3:]]
                    just_nums = just_nums[:-3]
        mask = [False, False, False]
        for r in new_ref:
            for i, x in enumerate(r):
                if x == "*":
                    mask[i] = True
                    r[i] = 0
            for a in self.atoms:
                coords = a.coords.copy()
                for i, x in enumerate(mask):
                    if x:
                        coords[i] = 0
                if np.linalg.norm(np.array(r, dtype=float) - coords) <= dist:
                    rv += [a]
        if not include_ref:
            for r in ref:
                if isinstance(r, Atom) and r in rv:
                    rv.remove(r)
        return rv

    def get_principle_axes(self, targets=None, mass_weight=True, center=None):
        """
        :param bool mass_weight: mass-weight axes (i.e. moments of inertia)
        :param targets: atoms to include in the calculation (default: all atoms)
        :param np.ndarray center: center of rotation, defaults to Geometry.COM
        
        :returns: [principal moments], [principle axes]
        """
        if targets is None:
            targets = self.atoms
        targets = self.find(targets)
        
        if center is None:
            COM = self.COM(mass_weight=mass_weight, targets=targets)
        else:
            COM = center
        I_CM = np.zeros((3, 3))
        for a in targets:
            if mass_weight:
                mass = a.mass
            else:
                mass = 1
            coords = a.coords - COM
            I_CM[0, 0] += mass * (coords[1] ** 2 + coords[2] ** 2)
            I_CM[1, 1] += mass * (coords[0] ** 2 + coords[2] ** 2)
            I_CM[2, 2] += mass * (coords[0] ** 2 + coords[1] ** 2)
            I_CM[0, 1] -= mass * (coords[0] * coords[1])
            I_CM[0, 2] -= mass * (coords[0] * coords[2])
            I_CM[1, 2] -= mass * (coords[1] * coords[2])
        I_CM[1, 0] = I_CM[0, 1]
        I_CM[2, 0] = I_CM[0, 2]
        I_CM[2, 1] = I_CM[1, 2]

        return np.linalg.eigh(I_CM)

    def LJ_energy(self, other=None, use_prev_params=False):
        """
        computes LJ energy using autodock parameters
        
        :param Geometry other: calculate LJ energy between self and other
            instead of just self
        :param bool use_prev_params: use same sigma/epsilon as the last time
            LJ_energy was called; useful for methods that make repetitive
            LJ_energy calls, like minimize_torsion
        """

        if (
            use_prev_params
            and self._sigmat is not None
            and self._sigmat.shape != (len(self), len(other))
        ):
            sigmat = self._sigmat
            epsmat = self._epsmat
        else:
            sigmat = np.array(
                [[a.rij(b) for a in self.atoms] for b in self.atoms]
            ) ** 2
            epsmat = np.array(
                [[a.eij(b) for a in self.atoms] for b in self.atoms]
            ) ** 2

        if other is None or other is self:
            D = distance.pdist(self.coords, "sqeuclidean")
            D = distance.squareform(D)
            np.fill_diagonal(D, 1)

        else:
            if hasattr(other, "coords"):
                D = distance.cdist(self.coords, other.coords, "sqeuclidean")
                other = other.atoms

                sigmat = np.array(
                    [[a.rij(b) for a in other] for b in self.atoms]
                ) ** 2
                epsmat = np.array(
                    [[a.eij(b) for a in other] for b in self.atoms]
                ) ** 2
            else:
                D = distance.cdist(
                    self.coords, np.array([a.coords for a in other])
                )

        self._sigmat = sigmat
        self._epsmat = epsmat

        repmat = sigmat / D
        # repmat = repmat ** 2
        repmat = repmat ** 3
        attmat = repmat ** 2

        if other is None or other is self:
            nrgmat = np.tril(epsmat * (attmat - repmat), -1)
        else:
            nrgmat = epsmat * (attmat - repmat)

        return np.sum(nrgmat)

    def examine_constraints(self, thresh=None):
        """
        Determines if constrained atoms are too close/ too far apart
       
        :param float thresh: threshold to define 'too close' or 'too far'

        :returns: (atom1, atom2, flag) where flag is 1 if atoms too close,
            -1 if atoms to far apart (so one can multiply a distance to change
            by the flag and it will adjust in the correct direction)
        """
        rv = []
        if thresh is None:
            thresh = D_CUTOFF
        constraints = self.get_constraints()
        # con of form (atom_name_1, atom_name_2, original_distance)
        for con in constraints:
            if len(con) != 2:
                continue
            dist = self.atoms[con[0]].dist(self.atoms[con[1]])
            if dist - constraints[con] > thresh:
                # current > constraint: atoms too far apart
                # want to move closer together
                rv += [(con[0], con[1], -1)]
            elif constraints[con] - dist > thresh:
                # constraint > current: atoms too close together
                # want to move farther apart
                rv += [(con[0], con[1], 1)]
        return rv

    def compare_connectivity(self, ref, thresh=None, return_idx=False):
        """
        Compares connectivity of self relative to ref
        
        :param ref: the structure to compare to (str(path), FileReader, or Geometry)
            ref.atoms should be in the same order as self.atoms
        :param float thresh: allow for connectivity changes as long as the difference
            between bond distances is below a threshold, default None
        :param bool return_idx: output will be indices of atoms instead of names

        
        :returns: broken, formed
        
            * broken - set of atom name pairs for which a bond broke
            * formed - set of atom name pairs for which a bond formed

        :rtype: set(), set()
        """
        broken = set([])
        formed = set([])
        if not isinstance(ref, Geometry):
            ref = Geometry(ref)

        not_found = set(self.atoms)
        for i, r in enumerate(ref.atoms):
            s = self.find(r.name)[0]
            not_found.remove(s)

            conn = set(self.find(i.name)[0] for i in r.connected)
            if not conn ^ s.connected:
                continue
            for c in conn - s.connected:
                if thresh is not None:
                    dist = r.dist(ref.find(c.name)[0]) - s.dist(c)
                    if abs(dist) <= thresh:
                        continue
                if return_idx:
                    broken.add(tuple(sorted([i, self.atoms.index(c)])))
                else:
                    broken.add(tuple(sorted([s.name, c.name])))
            for c in s.connected - conn:
                if thresh is not None:
                    dist = r.dist(ref.find(c.name)[0]) - s.dist(c)
                    if abs(dist) <= thresh:
                        continue
                if return_idx:
                    broken.add(tuple(sorted([i, self.atoms.index(c)])))
                else:
                    formed.add(tuple(sorted([s.name, c.name])))
        return broken, formed

    def percent_buried_volume(
        self,
        center=None,
        targets=None,
        radius=3.5,
        radii="umn",
        scale=1.17,
        exclude=None,
        method="lebedev",
        rpoints=20,
        apoints=1454,
        min_iter=25,
        basis=None,
        n_threads=1,
    ):
        """
        calculates % buried volume (%V_bur) using Monte-Carlo or Gauss-Legendre/Lebedev integration
        
        see Organometallics 2008, 27, 12, 2679–2681 (DOI: 10.1021/om8001119) for details

        :param center: center atom(s) or np.array of coordinates
            if more than one atom is specified, the sphere will be centered on
            the centroid between the atoms
        :param targets: atoms to use in calculation, defaults to all non-center if there
            is only one center, otherwise all atoms
        :param float radius: sphere radius around center atom
        :param str|dict radii: "umn", "bondi", or sambvca - VDW radii to use
            can also be a dict() with atom symbols as the keys and
            their respective radii as the values
        :param float scale: scale VDW radii by this
        :param list(Atom) exclude: atoms to exclude from calculation
        :param str method: integration method (MC or lebedev)
        :param int rpoints: number of radial shells for Lebedev integration
        :param int apoints: number of angular points for Lebedev integration
        :param int min_iter: minimum number of iterations for MC integration
            each iteration is a batch of 3000 points
            iterations will continue beyond min_iter if the volume has not converged
        :param np.ndarray basis: change of basis matrix
            will cause %Vbur to be returned as a tuple for different quadrants (I, II, III, IV)
        :param int n_threads: number of threads to use for MC integration
            using multiple threads doesn't benefit performance very much
        :returns: the percent buried volume
        :rtype: float
        """
        # NOTE - it would be nice to multiprocess the MC integration (or
        #        split up the shells for the Lebedev integration, but...
        #        python's multiprocessing doesn't let you spawn processes
        #        outside of the __name__ == '__main__' context

        # determine center if none was specified
        if center is None:
            if self.center is None:
                self.detect_components()
            center = self.center
            center_coords = self.COM(center)

        else:
            center_atoms = self.find(center)
            if center_atoms:
                center_coords = self.COM(center_atoms)
            else:
                # assume an array was given
                center_coords = center

        # determine atoms if none were specified
        if targets is None:
            if center is None:
                targets = self.atoms
            else:
                if len(center) == 1:
                    targets = [
                        atom for atom in self.atoms if atom not in center
                    ]
                else:
                    targets = [atom for atom in self.atoms]
        else:
            targets = self.find(targets)

        # VDW radii to use
        if isinstance(radii, dict):
            radii_dict = radii
        elif radii.lower() == "umn":
            radii_dict = VDW_RADII
        elif radii.lower() == "bondi":
            radii_dict = BONDI_RADII
        elif radii.lower() == "sambvca":
            radii_dict = SAMBVCA_RADII
        else:
            raise RuntimeError(
                "received %s for radii, must be a dictionary, umn, bondi, or sambvca" % radii
            )

        # list of scaled VDW radii for each atom that's close enough to
        # the center of the sphere
        radius_list = []
        atoms_within_radius = []

        # determine which atom's radii extend within the sphere
        # reduces the number of distances we need to calculate
        # also determine innermost and outermost atom edges (minr and maxr)
        # so we can skip integration shells that don't contain atoms
        minr = radius
        maxr = 0.0
        for atom in targets:
            if exclude is not None and atom in exclude:
                continue
            d = np.linalg.norm(center_coords - atom.coords)
            inner_edge = d - scale * radii_dict[atom.element]
            outer_edge = inner_edge + 2 * scale * radii_dict[atom.element]
            if inner_edge < radius:
                atoms_within_radius.append(atom)
                if inner_edge < minr:
                    minr = inner_edge
                if outer_edge > maxr:
                    maxr = outer_edge
        maxr = min(maxr, radius)
        if minr < 0:
            minr = 0

        # sort atoms based on their distance to the center
        # this makes is so we usually break out of looping over the atoms faster
        atoms_within_radius.sort(
            key=lambda a, c=center_coords: np.linalg.norm(a.coords - c)
        )

        for atom in atoms_within_radius:
            radius_list.append(scale * radii_dict[atom.element])

        radius_list = np.array(radius_list) ** 2
        coords = self.coordinates(atoms_within_radius)

        # Monte-Carlo integration
        if method.lower() == "mc":
            n_samples = 3000
            def get_iter_vol(n_samples=n_samples):
                """get the buried points and total points for one MC batch"""
                if basis is None:
                    buried_points = 0
                    tot_points = 0
    
                else:
                    buried_points = np.zeros(8)
                    tot_points = np.zeros(8)

                # get a random point uniformly distributed inside the sphere
                # only sample points between minr and maxr because maybe that makes
                # things converge faster
                r = (maxr - minr) * np.random.uniform(0, 1, n_samples) ** (
                    1 / 3
                )
                r += minr
                z = np.random.uniform(-1, 1, n_samples)

                theta = np.arcsin(z) + np.pi / 2
                phi = np.random.uniform(0, 2 * np.pi, n_samples)

                x = r * np.sin(theta) * np.cos(phi)
                y = r * np.sin(theta) * np.sin(phi)
                z *= r

                xyz = np.array([x, y, z]).T
                if basis is not None:
                    # determine what quadrant this point is in, add it to the appropriate bin
                    map_xyz = np.dot(xyz, basis)
                    signs = np.sign(map_xyz)
                    oct_0 = np.where(np.dot(signs, [1, 1, 1]) > 2, 1, 0)
                    tot_points[0] += sum(oct_0)
                    oct_1 = np.where(np.dot(signs, [-1, 1, 1]) >= 2, 1, 0)
                    tot_points[1] += sum(oct_1)
                    oct_2 = np.where(np.dot(signs, [-1, -1, 1]) > 2, 1, 0)
                    tot_points[2] += sum(oct_2)
                    oct_3 = np.where(np.dot(signs, [1, -1, 1]) >= 2, 1, 0)
                    tot_points[3] += sum(oct_3)
                    oct_4 = np.where(np.dot(signs, [1, -1, -1]) > 2, 1, 0)
                    tot_points[4] += sum(oct_4)
                    oct_5 = np.where(np.dot(signs, [-1, -1, -1]) >= 2, 1, 0)
                    tot_points[5] += sum(oct_5)
                    oct_6 = np.where(np.dot(signs, [-1, 1, -1]) > 2, 1, 0)
                    tot_points[6] += sum(oct_6)
                    oct_7 = np.where(np.dot(signs, [1, 1, -1]) >= 2, 1, 0)
                    tot_points[7] += sum(oct_7)

                xyz += center_coords
                # see if the point is inside of any atom's
                # scaled VDW radius
                D = distance.cdist(xyz, coords, "sqeuclidean")
                diff_mat = D - radius_list
                if basis is None:
                    buried_points += np.sum(np.any(diff_mat <= 0, axis=1))
                else:
                    mask = np.any(diff_mat <= 0, axis=1)
                    buried_coords = map_xyz[mask]
                    signs = np.sign(buried_coords)
                    oct_0 = np.where(np.dot(signs, [1, 1, 1]) > 2, 1, 0)
                    buried_points[0] += sum(oct_0)
                    oct_1 = np.where(np.dot(signs, [-1, 1, 1]) > 2, 1, 0)
                    buried_points[1] += sum(oct_1)
                    oct_2 = np.where(np.dot(signs, [-1, -1, 1]) > 2, 1, 0)
                    buried_points[2] += sum(oct_2)
                    oct_3 = np.where(np.dot(signs, [1, -1, 1]) > 2, 1, 0)
                    buried_points[3] += sum(oct_3)
                    oct_4 = np.where(np.dot(signs, [1, -1, -1]) > 2, 1, 0)
                    buried_points[4] += sum(oct_4)
                    oct_5 = np.where(np.dot(signs, [-1, -1, -1]) > 2, 1, 0)
                    buried_points[5] += sum(oct_5)
                    oct_6 = np.where(np.dot(signs, [-1, 1, -1]) > 2, 1, 0)
                    buried_points[6] += sum(oct_6)
                    oct_7 = np.where(np.dot(signs, [1, 1, -1]) > 2, 1, 0)
                    buried_points[7] += sum(oct_7)

                return buried_points, tot_points


            dV = []
            i = 0
            if basis is None:
                prev_vol = cur_vol = 0
                buried_points = 0
                tot_points = 0

            else:
                prev_vol = np.zeros(8)
                cur_vol = np.zeros(8)
                buried_points = np.zeros(8)
                tot_points = np.zeros(8)
            # determine %V_bur
            # do at least 75000 total points, but keep going until
            # the last 5 changes are all less than 1e-4
            while i < min_iter or not (
                all(dv < 2e-4 for dv in dV[-5:]) and np.mean(dV[-5:]) < 1e-4
            ):
                if n_threads == 1:
                    iter_buried, iter_tot = get_iter_vol()
                    buried_points += iter_buried
                    tot_points += iter_tot
                    if basis is None:
                        cur_vol = float(buried_points) / (float((i + 1) * n_samples))
                        dV.append(abs(cur_vol - prev_vol))
                        prev_vol = cur_vol
                    else:
                        cur_vol = np.divide(buried_points, tot_points) / 8
                        dV.append(abs(sum(cur_vol) - sum(prev_vol)))
                        prev_vol = cur_vol

                else:
                    with concurrent.futures.ThreadPoolExecutor(
                        max_workers=n_threads
                    ) as executor:
                        out = [executor.submit(get_iter_vol) for k in range(0, n_threads)]
                    results = [data.result() for data in out]
                    for k in range(0, n_threads):
                        buried_points += results[k][0]
                        if basis is None:
                            cur_vol = float(buried_points) / (float((i + k + 1) * n_samples))
                            dV.append(abs(cur_vol - prev_vol))
                            prev_vol = cur_vol
                        else:
                            tot_points += results[k][1]
                            cur_vol = np.divide(buried_points, tot_points) / 8
                            dV.append(abs(sum(cur_vol) - sum(prev_vol)))
                            prev_vol = cur_vol
                i += n_threads

            between_v = cur_vol * (maxr ** 3 - minr ** 3)
            tot_v = radius ** 3
            return 100 * between_v / tot_v

        # default to Gauss-Legendre integration over Lebedev spheres
        else:
            # grab radial grid points and weights for range (minr, maxr)
            rgrid, rweights = utils.gauss_legendre_grid(
                start=minr, stop=maxr, num=rpoints
            )
            # grab Lebedev grid for unit sphere at origin
            agrid, aweights = utils.lebedev_sphere(
                radius=1, center=np.zeros(3), num=apoints
            )

            # value of integral (without 4 pi r^2) for each shell
            if basis is not None:
                shell_values = np.zeros((8, rpoints))
            else:
                shell_values = np.zeros(rpoints)
            # loop over radial shells

            for i, rvalue in enumerate(rgrid):
                # collect non-zero weights in inside_weights, then sum after looping over shell
                # scale grid point to radius and shift to center
                agrid_r = agrid * rvalue
                if basis is not None:
                    map_agrid_r = np.dot(agrid_r, basis)
                agrid_r += center_coords
                D = distance.cdist(agrid_r, coords, "sqeuclidean")
                diff_mat = D - radius_list
                mask = np.any(diff_mat <= 0, axis=1)
                if basis is None:
                    shell_values[i] = sum(aweights[mask])
                else:
                    mask = np.any(diff_mat <= 0, axis=1)
                    buried_coords = map_agrid_r[mask]
                    buried_weights = aweights[mask]
                    signs = np.sign(buried_coords)
                    # dot product should be 3, but > 2 allows for
                    # numerical error
                    oct_0 = np.where(np.dot(signs, [1, 1, 1]) > 2, 1, 0)
                    shell_values[0][i] += np.dot(oct_0, buried_weights)
                    oct_1 = np.where(np.dot(signs, [-1, 1, 1]) >= 2, 1, 0)
                    shell_values[1][i] += np.dot(oct_1, buried_weights)
                    oct_2 = np.where(np.dot(signs, [-1, -1, 1]) > 2, 1, 0)
                    shell_values[2][i] += np.dot(oct_2, buried_weights)
                    oct_3 = np.where(np.dot(signs, [1, -1, 1]) >= 2, 1, 0)
                    shell_values[3][i] += np.dot(oct_3, buried_weights)
                    oct_4 = np.where(np.dot(signs, [1, -1, -1]) > 2, 1, 0)
                    shell_values[4][i] += np.dot(oct_4, buried_weights)
                    oct_5 = np.where(np.dot(signs, [-1, -1, -1]) >= 2, 1, 0)
                    shell_values[5][i] += np.dot(oct_5, buried_weights)
                    oct_6 = np.where(np.dot(signs, [-1, 1, -1]) > 2, 1, 0)
                    shell_values[6][i] += np.dot(oct_6, buried_weights)
                    oct_7 = np.where(np.dot(signs, [1, 1, -1]) >= 2, 1, 0)
                    shell_values[7][i] += np.dot(oct_7, buried_weights)

            if basis is not None:
                # return a list of buried volume in each quadrant
                return [
                    300
                    * np.dot(shell_values[k] * rgrid ** 2, rweights)
                    / (radius ** 3)
                    for k in range(0, 8)
                ]
            else:
                # return buried volume
                return (
                    300
                    * np.dot(shell_values * rgrid ** 2, rweights)
                    / (radius ** 3)
                )

    def steric_map(
        self,
        center=None,
        key_atoms=None,
        targets=None,
        radii="umn",
        radius=3.5,
        oop_vector=None,
        ip_vector=None,
        return_basis=False,
        num_pts=100,
        shape="circle",
    ):
        """
        Creates a steric map based on a Geometry

        :param center: atom, list of atoms, or array specifiying the origin
        :param key_atoms: list of ligand key atoms. Atoms on these ligands will be in the steric map.
        :param list(Atom) targets: atoms to be included in the map, defaults to all
        :param str|dict radii: "umn", "bondi", "sambvca", or dict() specifying the VDW radii to use
        :param float radius: atomic radius to be considered in Angstroms, default 3.5
        :param np.ndarray oop_vector: None or array specifying the direction out of the plane of the steric map
            if None, oop_vector is determined using the average vector from the key
            atoms to the center atom
        :param np.ndarray ip_vector: None or array specifying a vector in the plane of the steric map
            if None, ip_vector is determined as the plane of best fit through the
            key_atoms and the center
        :param bool return_basis: whether or not to return a change of basis matrix
        :param int num_pts: number of points along x and y axis to use
        :param str shape: "circle" or "square"

        :returns: x, y, z, min_alt, max_alt
        
            or x, y, z, min_alt, max_alt, basis, atoms if return_basis is True

            a contour plot can be created with this data - see stericMap.py command line script
        
            x - x coordinates for grid
        
            y - y coordinates for grid
        
            z - altitude levels; points where no atoms are will be -1000
        
            min_alt - minimum altitude (above -1000)
        
            max_alt - maximum altitute
        
            basis - basis to e.g. reorient structure with np.dot(self.coords, basis)
        
            atoms - list of atoms that are in the steric map
        """

        # determine center if none was specified
        if center is None:
            if self.center is None:
                self.detect_components()
            center = self.center
            center_coords = self.COM(center)

        else:
            center_atoms = self.find(center)
            if center_atoms:
                center_coords = self.COM(center_atoms)
            else:
                # assume an array was given
                center_coords = center

        # VDW radii to use
        if isinstance(radii, dict):
            radii_dict = radii
        elif radii.lower() == "umn":
            radii_dict = VDW_RADII
        elif radii.lower() == "bondi":
            radii_dict = BONDI_RADII
        elif radii.lower() == "sambvca":
            radii_dict = SAMBVCA_RADII
        else:
            raise RuntimeError(
                "received %s for radii, must be a dictionary, umn, sambvca, or bondi" % radii
            )

        if key_atoms is None:
            key_atoms = []
            if self.components is None:
                self.detect_components()

            for comp in self.components:
                key_atoms.extend(comp.key_atoms)

        else:
            key_atoms = self.find(key_atoms)

        if targets is None:
            targets = []
            for key in key_atoms:
                if key not in targets:
                    if isinstance(center, Atom) or (
                        hasattr(center, "__iter__")
                        and all(isinstance(a, Atom) for a in center)
                    ):
                        targets.extend(self.get_fragment(key, center))
    
                    else:
                        targets.extend(self.get_all_connected(key))
        else:
            targets = self.find(targets)

        if oop_vector is None:
            oop_vector = np.zeros(3)
            for atom in key_atoms:
                oop_vector += center_coords - atom.coords

        oop_vector /= np.linalg.norm(oop_vector)

        if ip_vector is None:
            if len(key_atoms) == 1:
                ip_vector = utils.perp_vector(oop_vector)
                x_vec = np.cross(ip_vector, oop_vector)
            else:
                coords = [atom.coords for atom in key_atoms]
                coords.append(center_coords)
                coords = np.array(coords)
                ip_vector = utils.perp_vector(coords)
                x_vec = np.cross(ip_vector, oop_vector)
                x_vec /= np.linalg.norm(x_vec)
                ip_vector = -np.cross(x_vec, oop_vector)

        else:
            x_vec = np.cross(ip_vector, oop_vector)

        basis = np.array([x_vec, ip_vector, oop_vector]).T
        coords = self.coordinates(targets) - center_coords
        new_coords = np.dot(coords, basis)
        dist_ip = distance_matrix(new_coords[:, 0:2], [np.zeros(2)])[:, 0]
        atoms_within_radius = []
        radius_list = []
        for i, atom in enumerate(targets):
            try:
                if (
                    shape == "circle"
                    and dist_ip[i] - radii_dict[atom.element] < radius
                ):
                    atoms_within_radius.append(atom)
                    radius_list.append(radii_dict[atom.element] ** 2)
                elif (
                    shape == "square"
                    and dist_ip[i] - radii_dict[atom.element] < np.sqrt(2) * radius
                ):
                    atoms_within_radius.append(atom)
                    radius_list.append(radii_dict[atom.element] ** 2)
            except KeyError:
                raise KeyError("%s radii has no radius for %s" % (
                    str(radii), atom.element
                ))

        atom_coords = np.dot(
            self.coordinates(atoms_within_radius) - center_coords, basis
        )

        x = np.linspace(-radius, radius, num=num_pts)
        y = np.linspace(-radius, radius, num=num_pts)
        xs, ys = np.meshgrid(x, y)
        if shape == "circle":
            pt_in_shape = (xs ** 2 + ys ** 2) < radius ** 2
            xs = xs[pt_in_shape]
            ys = ys[pt_in_shape]
        else:
            pt_in_shape = np.ones((num_pts, num_pts), dtype=bool)
            xs = xs[pt_in_shape]
            ys = ys[pt_in_shape]
        z = -1000 * np.ones((num_pts, num_pts))
        w = np.empty((num_pts, num_pts))
        w[:] = np.nan
        for k in range(0, len(atoms_within_radius)):
            w[pt_in_shape] = (xs - atom_coords[k][0]) ** 2 + (ys - atom_coords[k][1]) ** 2
            ndx = w < radius_list[k]
            alt = np.sqrt(radius_list[k] - w[ndx]) + atom_coords[k, 2]
            z[ndx] = np.maximum(z[ndx], alt)

        min_alt = np.min(z[z > -1000])
        max_alt = np.max(z)

        if return_basis:
            return x, y, z, min_alt, max_alt, basis, atoms_within_radius
        return x, y, z, min_alt, max_alt

    def sterimol(
        self,
        L_axis,
        start_atom,
        targets,
        L_func=None,
        return_vector=False,
        radii="bondi",
        at_L=None,
        buried=False,
        max_error=None,
    ):
        """
        Determines sterimol parameters of a Geometry.

        B1 is determined numerically; B2-B4 depend on B1
        
        B5 and L are analytical (unless L_func is not analytical)
        
        see Verloop, A. and Tipker, J. (1976), Use of linear free energy
        related and other parameters in the study of fungicidal
        selectivity. Pestic. Sci., 7: 379-390.
        (DOI: 10.1002/ps.2780070410)

        :param str|dict|list radii:
            
            * "bondi" - Bondi vdW radii
            * "umn"   - vdW radii from Mantina, Chamberlin, Valero, Cramer, and Truhlar
            * "sambvca"   - radii used by sambvca
            * dict()  - radii are values and elements are keys
            * list()  - list of radii corresponding to targets

        :param np.ndarray L_axis: vector defining L-axis
        :param targets: atoms to include in the parameter calculation
        :param function L_func: function to evaluate for getting the L value and vector
            for each atom
            takes positional arguments:
            
            * :atom: Atom - atom being checked
            * :start: Atom - start_atom
            * :radius: vdw radius of atom
            * :L_axis: unit vector for L-axis

            if L_func is not given, the default is the distance from
            start_atom to the furthest vdw radius projected onto the
            L-axis
        :param bool return_vector: returned dictionary will have tuples of start, end
            for vectors to represent the parameters in 3D space
        :param float at_L: - L value to calculate sterimol parameters at
               
               Useful for Sterimol2Vec
        :param float|bool buried: calculate buried sterimol using the given
            buried radius (or 5.5 if buried is simply True)
            
            buried and at_L are incompatible
        :param float max_error: max. error in angstroms for B1
            higher error can sometimes make the calculation
            go slightly faster
            
            max_error=None will have an error for B1 of at most
            (sum of radii tangent to B1 face) * (1 - cos(0.5 degrees))

        :returns: sterimol parameter values in a dictionary
        
        keys are B1, B2, B3, B4, B5, and L
        """
        from scipy.spatial import ConvexHull

        CITATION = "doi:10.1002/ps.2780070410"
        if at_L:
            CITATION += "; doi:10.5281/zenodo.4702098"
        self.LOG.citation(CITATION)

        if at_L not in (None, False) and buried not in (None, False):
            raise RuntimeError("cannot calculate sterimol2vec and buried sterimol at the same time")

        targets = self.find(targets)
        start = self.find(start_atom)
        if len(start) != 1:
            raise TypeError(
                "start must be exactly 1 atom, %i found for %s"
                % (
                    len(start),
                    repr(start_atom),
                )
            )
        start = start[0]

        L_axis /= np.linalg.norm(L_axis)

        if not L_func:

            def L_func(atom, start, radius, L_axis):
                test_v = start.bond(atom)
                test_L = np.dot(test_v, L_axis) + radius
                vec = (start.coords, start.coords + test_L * L_axis)
                return test_L, vec

        radius_list = []
        radii_dict = None
        if isinstance(radii, dict):
            radii_dict = radii
        elif isinstance(radii, list):
            radius_list = radii
        elif radii.lower() == "bondi":
            radii_dict = BONDI_RADII
        elif radii.lower() == "sambvcaa":
            radii_dict = SAMBVCA_RADII
        elif radii.lower() == "umn":
            radii_dict = VDW_RADII

        B1 = None
        B2 = None
        B3 = None
        B4 = None
        B5 = None
        L = None
        vector = {
            "B1": None,
            "B2": None,
            "B3": None,
            "B4": None,
            "B5": None,
            "L": None,
            "Bperp_big": None,
            "Bperp_small": None,
            "Bpar": None,
        }
        # for B1, we're going to use ConvexHull to find the minimum distance
        # from one face of a bounding box
        # to do this, we're going to project the substituent in a plane
        # perpendicular to the L-axis and get a set of points along the
        # vdw radii of the atoms
        # ConvexHull will take these points and figure out which ones
        # are on the outside (vertices)
        # we then just need to find the bounding box with the minimum distance
        # from L-axis to one side of the box
        points = np.empty((0,2))
        ndx = np.empty(0, dtype=int)
        # just grab a random vector perpendicular to the L-axis
        # it doesn't matter really
        ip_vector = utils.perp_vector(L_axis)
        x_vec = np.cross(ip_vector, L_axis)
        x_vec /= np.linalg.norm(x_vec)
        basis = np.array([x_vec, ip_vector, L_axis]).T

        if not radius_list:
            radius_list = []
        coords = self.coordinates(targets)
        L_vals = []
        
        if radii_dict is not None:
            radius_list = [radii_dict[atom.element] for atom in targets]
        
        if buried is not False:
            if buried is True:
                buried = 5.5
            
            for i, atom in enumerate(targets):
                if radius_list[i] < 0:
                    continue
                if (start.dist(atom) + radius_list[i] / 2) > buried:
                    radius_list[i] = -1

        for i, atom in enumerate(targets):
            if radius_list[i] < 0:
                continue
            test_v = start.bond(atom)

            # L
            test_L, L_vec = L_func(atom, start, radius_list[i], L_axis)
            L_vals.append(test_L)
            if L is None or test_L > L:
                L = test_L
                vector["L"] = L_vec
        
        num_pts = 240
        if max_error is not None:
            # max error estimate is:
            # (sum of atom radii that are tangent to B1 face) *
            # (1 - cos(360 degrees / (2 * number of points)))
            # we don't know B1 until after we pick num_pts, so
            # we don't know which atoms determine the B1 face here
            # but it is either one or two atoms and we guess
            # it's the two largest atoms
            num_pts = int(
                2 / np.arccos(
                    1 - max_error / sum(
                        np.argsort(radius_list)[:-2][::-1]
                    )
                )
            )
        v = np.linspace(0, 2 * np.pi, num=num_pts)
        b1_points = np.stack(
            (np.cos(v), np.sin(v)), axis=1
        )
        std_ndx = np.ones(num_pts, dtype=int)

        # if a specific L value was requested, only check atoms
        # with a radius that intersects the plane at that L
        # value
        # do this by setting the radii of atoms that don't intersect
        # that plane to -1 so they are skipped later
        # adjust the radii of atoms that do intersect to be the
        # radius of the circle formed by the interection of the
        # plane with the VDW sphere and adjust the coordinates
        # so it looks like the atom is in that plane
        if at_L is not None:
            if not any(L >= at_L for L in L_vals):
                at_L = max(L_vals)
            if all(L < at_L for L in L_vals):
                at_L = 0
            L_vec = vector["L"][1] - vector["L"][0]
            L_vec *= at_L / np.linalg.norm(L_vec)
            vector["L"] = (vector["L"][0], vector["L"][0] + L_vec)
            L = at_L
            for i in range(0, len(coords)):
                if radius_list[i] < 0:
                    continue
                if L_vals[i] - 2 * radius_list[i] > at_L:
                    radius_list[i] = -1
                    continue
                if L_vals[i] < at_L:
                    radius_list[i] = -1
                    continue
                diff = L_vals[i] - radius_list[i] - at_L
                radius_list[i] = np.sqrt(radius_list[i] ** 2 - diff ** 2)
                coords[i] -= diff * L_axis

        radius_list = np.array(radius_list)
        # radii are negative if we don't want to consider them
        # e.g. calculating parameters at a specific L value
        # we only need to work with atoms with positive radii
        # going forward
        positive_radii = np.where(radius_list >= 0)
        positive_radius_list = radius_list[positive_radii]
        considered_coords = coords[positive_radii]
        # vector from each atom to starting atom
        if len(considered_coords) == 0:
            if at_L is not None:
                self.LOG.warning(
                    "there are no atoms at %.2f along the L axis" % at_L
                )
                if return_vector:
                    vector["B1"] = (vector["L"][1], vector["L"][1])
                    vector["B2"] = (vector["L"][1], vector["L"][1])
                    vector["B3"] = (vector["L"][1], vector["L"][1])
                    vector["B4"] = (vector["L"][1], vector["L"][1])
                    vector["B5"] = (vector["L"][1], vector["L"][1])
                    vector["Bperp_small"] = (vector["L"][1], vector["L"][1])
                    vector["Bperp_big"] = (vector["L"][1], vector["L"][1])
                    vector["Bperp_small"] = (vector["L"][1], vector["L"][1])
                    return vector
                params = {
                    "L": L,
                    "B1": 0,
                    "B2": 0,
                    "B3": 0,
                    "B4": 0,
                    "B5": 0,
                    "Bperp_small": 0,
                    "Bperp_big": 0,
                    "Bpar": 0,
                }
                return params
            raise RuntimeError("there are no atoms with a non-zero radius")
        test_v = considered_coords - start.coords
        # project onto basis such that z is along L axis
        # and x and y can be used to find B_n
        new_coords = np.dot(test_v, basis)
        ip_coords = new_coords[:, 0:2]
        # construct an array of points around the circumference of 
        # each atom's radius projected onto the xy plane
        ndx = np.outer(positive_radii, std_ndx).reshape(-1)
        points = np.outer(positive_radius_list, b1_points).reshape(
            len(positive_radius_list) * num_pts, 2
        )
        block_ndx = np.outer(np.arange(0, len(positive_radius_list)), std_ndx).reshape(-1)
        points += ip_coords[block_ndx]
        # determine component of each atom-start vector that is 
        # parallel to L axis
        # subtract this out and add the radii - the max. of these
        # is the B5
        para = np.sum(test_v * L_axis, axis=1)
        test_B5_v = test_v - np.outer(para, L_axis)
        test_B5 = np.linalg.norm(test_B5_v, axis=1) + positive_radius_list
        b5_ndx = np.argmax(test_B5)
        B5 = test_B5[b5_ndx]
        start_x = considered_coords[b5_ndx] - test_B5_v[b5_ndx]
        if np.linalg.norm(test_B5_v[b5_ndx]) > 3 * np.finfo(float).eps:
            perp_vec = test_B5_v[b5_ndx]
        else:
            # if the atom is along the L-axis, we can use any vector
            # orthogonal to L-axis
            # this is more stable
            v_n = test_v[b5_ndx] / np.linalg.norm(test_v[b5_ndx])
            perp_vec = utils.perp_vector(L_axis)
            perp_vec -= np.dot(v_n, perp_vec) * v_n
        
        end = start_x + B5 * (perp_vec / np.linalg.norm(perp_vec))
        vector["B5"] = (start_x, end)


        points = np.array(points)
        if np.sum((points - points[0, np.newaxis]) ** 2) < 1e-8:
            if at_L is not None:
                self.LOG.warning(
                    "%.2f along the L axis is close to the actual L; setting all parameters to 0" % at_L
                )
                if return_vector:
                    vector["B1"] = (vector["L"][1], vector["L"][1])
                    vector["B2"] = (vector["L"][1], vector["L"][1])
                    vector["B3"] = (vector["L"][1], vector["L"][1])
                    vector["B4"] = (vector["L"][1], vector["L"][1])
                    vector["B5"] = (vector["L"][1], vector["L"][1])
                    vector["Bperp_small"] = (vector["L"][1], vector["L"][1])
                    vector["Bperp_big"] = (vector["L"][1], vector["L"][1])
                    vector["Bperp_small"] = (vector["L"][1], vector["L"][1])
                    return vector
                params = {
                    "L": L,
                    "B1": 0,
                    "B2": 0,
                    "B3": 0,
                    "B4": 0,
                    "B5": 0,
                    "Bperp_small": 0,
                    "Bperp_big": 0,
                    "Bpar": 0,
                }
                return params
            raise RuntimeError("atom radii too small to safely determine sterimol parameters")

        # some things I thought would make this run faster
        # by reducing the number of points we give to
        # ConvexHull, but it turns out doing these is slower
        # leaving it here in case there's some really large
        # thing that this somehow helps with
        # 
        # # we can remove points that are facing the L axis
        # # these points will be on the interior of the convex hull
        # # this will speed up the convex hull
        # 
        # # also keep points on atoms that are basically on the
        # # L axis for numerical precision reasons
        # if not at_L:
        #     v = ip_coords[block_ndx]
        #     g = points - ip_coords[block_ndx]
        #     mask = np.sum(v * g, axis=1) >= 0
        #     inv_mask = np.invert(mask)
        #     d = np.linalg.norm(ip_coords, axis=1) < positive_radius_list
        #     mask[inv_mask] = d[block_ndx[inv_mask]]
        #     points = points[mask]
        #     block_ndx = block_ndx[mask]
        #     ndx = ndx[mask]
        # 
        # # Laguerre-Voronoi tesselation sort of
        # # this will basically just leave the points that are
        # # not covered up by another atom's VDW radius
        # # if d^2 - r^2 for an atom's point is smallest for
        # # that atom, keep the point
        # # otherwise, discard
        # d = np.sum((points[:, np.newaxis, :] - ip_coords[np.newaxis, :, :]) ** 2, axis=-1)
        # d = np.transpose(d - positive_radius_list ** 2)
        # mask = np.equal(np.argmin(d, axis=0), block_ndx)
        # points = points[mask]
        # block_ndx = block_ndx[mask]
        # ndx = ndx[mask]

        hull = ConvexHull(points)

        # import matplotlib.pyplot as plt
        # for i, pt in enumerate(points):
        #     color = "blue"
        #     if self.atoms[ndx[i]].element == "H":
        #         color = "white"
        #     if self.atoms[ndx[i]].element == "C":
        #         color = "#5c5c5c"
        #     if self.atoms[ndx[i]].element == "F":
        #         color = "#90e050"
        #     if self.atoms[ndx[i]].element == "O":
        #         color = "#ff0000"
        #     plt.plot(*pt, 'o', markersize=1, color=color)
        # # plt.plot(points[:, 0], points[:, 1], 'o', markersize=0.1)
        # plt.plot(0, 0, 'kx')
        # plt.plot(
        #     [*points[hull.vertices, 0], points[hull.vertices[0], 0]],
        #     [*points[hull.vertices, 1], points[hull.vertices[0], 1]],
        #     'ro-',
        #     markersize=3,    
        # )
        # 
        # ax = plt.gca()
        # ax.set_aspect('equal')
        # ax.set_facecolor("#dddddd")

        # go through each edge, find a vector perpendicular to the one
        # defined by the edge that passes through the origin
        # the length of the shortest of these vectors is B1
        tangents = points[np.roll(hull.vertices, 1)] - points[hull.vertices]
        tangents = tangents / np.linalg.norm(tangents, axis=1)[:, None]
        paras = np.sum(
            tangents * points[hull.vertices], axis=1
        )
        norms = points[hull.vertices] - paras[:, None] * tangents
        norm_mags = np.linalg.norm(norms, axis=1)
        B1_ndx = np.argmin(norm_mags)
        B1 = norm_mags[B1_ndx]
        b1_atom_coords = considered_coords[block_ndx[hull.vertices[B1_ndx]]]
        test_v = b1_atom_coords - start.coords
        test_B1_v = test_v - (np.dot(test_v, L_axis) * L_axis)
        start_x = b1_atom_coords - test_B1_v
        end = x_vec * norms[B1_ndx][0] + ip_vector * norms[B1_ndx][1]
        end += start_x
        vector["B1"] = (start_x, end)

        # figure out B2-4
        # these need to be sorted in increasing order
        # for now, they will just be Bpar for the one opposite B1
        # and Bperp1 and Bperp2 for the ones perpendicular to B1
        b1_norm = end - start_x
        b1_norm /= np.linalg.norm(b1_norm)
        b1_perp = np.cross(L_axis, b1_norm)
        b1_perp /= np.linalg.norm(b1_perp)
        Bpar = None
        Bperp1 = None
        Bperp2 = None
        perp_vec1 = None
        perp_vec2 = None
        for rad, coord in zip(positive_radius_list, considered_coords):
            test_v = coord - start.coords
            b = np.dot(test_v, L_axis)
            test_B_v = test_v - (b * L_axis)
            test_par_vec = np.dot(test_B_v, b1_norm) * b1_norm
            test_par_vec -= rad * b1_norm
            start_x = coord - test_B_v
            end = start_x + test_par_vec

            test_Bpar = np.linalg.norm(end - start_x)
            if Bpar is None or test_Bpar > Bpar:
                Bpar = test_Bpar
                par_vec = (start_x, end)

            perp_vec = np.dot(test_B_v, b1_perp) * b1_perp
            if (
                np.dot(test_B_v, b1_perp) > 0
                or abs(np.dot(b1_perp, test_B_v)) < 1e-3
            ):
                test_perp_vec1 = perp_vec + rad * b1_perp
                end = start_x + test_perp_vec1
                test_Bperp1 = np.linalg.norm(end - start_x)
                if Bperp1 is None or test_Bperp1 > Bperp1:
                    Bperp1 = test_Bperp1
                    perp_vec1 = (start_x, end)

            if (
                np.dot(test_B_v, b1_perp) < 0
                or abs(np.dot(b1_perp, test_B_v)) < 1e-3
            ):
                test_perp_vec2 = perp_vec - rad * b1_perp
                end = start_x + test_perp_vec2
                test_Bperp2 = np.linalg.norm(end - start_x)
                if Bperp2 is None or test_Bperp2 > Bperp2:
                    Bperp2 = test_Bperp2
                    perp_vec2 = (start_x, end)

        if perp_vec1 is None:
            perp_vec1 = perp_vec2[0], -perp_vec2[1]
            Bperp1 = Bperp2

        if perp_vec2 is None:
            perp_vec2 = perp_vec1[0], -perp_vec1[1]
            Bperp2 = Bperp1

        # put B2-4 in order
        i = 0
        Bs = [Bpar, Bperp1, Bperp2]
        Bvecs = [par_vec, perp_vec1, perp_vec2]
        while Bs:
            max_b = max(Bs)
            n = Bs.index(max_b)
            max_v = Bvecs.pop(n)
            Bs.pop(n)

            if i == 0:
                B4 = max_b
                vector["B4"] = max_v
            elif i == 1:
                B3 = max_b
                vector["B3"] = max_v
            elif i == 2:
                B2 = max_b
                vector["B2"] = max_v
            i += 1

        vector["Bpar"] = par_vec
        if Bperp1 > Bperp2:
            vector["Bperp_small"] = perp_vec2
            vector["Bperp_big"] = perp_vec1
        else:
            vector["Bperp_small"] = perp_vec1
            vector["Bperp_big"] = perp_vec2

        params = {
            "B1": B1,
            "B2": B2,
            "B3": B3,
            "B4": B4,
            "B5": B5,
            "Bperp_small": min([Bperp1, Bperp2]),
            "Bperp_big": max([Bperp1, Bperp2]),
            "Bpar": Bpar,
            "L": L,
        }

        # plt.plot(
        #     [0, norms[B1_ndx,0]],
        #     [0, norms[B1_ndx,1]],
        #     'g-', markersize=10,
        # )
        # plt.show()

        if return_vector:
            return vector
        return params

    # geometry manipulation
    def append_structure(self, structure):
        from AaronTools.component import Component

        if not isinstance(structure, Geometry):
            structure = Component(structure)
        if not self.components:
            self.detect_components()
        self.components += [structure]
        self.rebuild()

    def update_geometry(self, structure):
        """
        Replace current coords with those from :structure:

        :param structure: a file name, atom list, Geometry or np.array() of shape Nx3
        """
        if isinstance(structure, np.ndarray):
            coords = structure
            elements = None
        else:
            atoms = Geometry(structure).atoms
            elements = [a.element for a in atoms]
            coords = [a.coords for a in atoms]
        if len(coords) != len(self.atoms):
            raise RuntimeError(
                "Updated geometry has different number of atoms"
            )
        for i, row in enumerate(coords):
            if elements is not None and elements[i] != self.atoms[i].element:
                raise RuntimeError(
                    "Updated coords atom order doesn't seem to match original "
                    "atom order. Stopping..."
                )
            self.atoms[i].coords = row
        self.refresh_connected()
        return

    def get_all_connected(self, target):
        """
        Finds all elements of a monomer

        :param Atom target: atom to be searched
        
        :returns: list of all elements on the target atom's monomer
        :rtype: list(Atom)
        """

        def _get_all_connected(geom, target, avoid):
            atoms = [target]
            for atom in target.connected:
                if atom not in avoid:
                    new_avoid = avoid + [target]
                    atoms.extend(
                        [
                            x
                            for x in _get_all_connected(geom, atom, new_avoid)
                            if x not in atoms
                        ]
                    )

            return atoms

        target = self.find(target)[0]
        atoms = _get_all_connected(self, target, [])

        return atoms

    def get_fragment(self, start, stop=None, as_object=False, copy=False, biggest=False):
        """
        Finds and returns a fragment of a Geometry object

        :param start: the atoms to start on
        :param stop: the atom(s) to avoid
            stop=None will try all possibilities and return smallest fragment
        :param bool as_object: return as list (default) or Geometry object
        :param bool copy: whether or not to copy the atoms before returning the list;
            copy will automatically fix connectivity information
        :param bool biggest: if stop=None, will return biggest possible fragment
            instead of smallest

        :returns:
        
            * [Atoms()] if as_object == False
            
            * Geometry() if as_object == True
        """
        start = self.find(start)
        if stop is None:
            best = None
            for stop in itertools.chain(*[s.connected for s in start]):
                frag = self.get_fragment(start, stop, as_object, copy)
                if (
                    best is None
                    or (len(frag) < len(best) and not biggest)
                    or (len(frag) > len(best) and biggest)
                ):
                    best = frag
            return best
        stop = self.find(stop)

        stack = deque(start)
        frag = start
        while len(stack) > 0:
            connected = stack.popleft()
            connected = connected.connected - set(stop) - set(frag)
            stack.extend(connected)
            frag += connected

        if as_object:
            return self.copy(atoms=frag, comment="")
        if copy:
            return self._fix_connectivity(frag, copy=True)
        return frag

    def remove_fragment(self, start, avoid=None, add_H=True):
        """
        Removes a fragment of the geometry

        :param start: the atom of the fragment to be removed that attaches to the
            rest of the geometry
        :param avoid: the atoms :start: is attached to that should be avoided
        :param bool add_H: default is to change :start: to H and update bond lengths, but
            add_H=False overrides this behaviour

        :returns: :start: + the removed fragment
        :rtype: list(Atom)
        """
        start = self.find(start)
        if avoid is not None:
            avoid = self.find(avoid)
        frag = self.get_fragment(start, avoid)[len(start) :]
        self -= frag
        rv = start + frag

        # replace start with H
        if add_H:
            for a in start:
                a.element = "H"
                self.change_distance(a, a.connected - set(frag), fix=2)
        return rv

    def coord_shift(self, vector, targets=None):
        """
        shifts the coordinates of the target atoms by a vector

        :param np.ndarray vector: the shift vector
        :param list(Atom) targets: the target atoms to shift (default to all)
        """
        if targets is None:
            targets = self.atoms
        else:
            targets = self.find(targets)

        if not isinstance(vector, np.ndarray):
            vector = np.array(vector, dtype=np.float64)
        for t in targets:
            t.coords += vector
        return

    def change_distance(
        self, a1, a2, dist=None, adjust=False, fix=0, as_group=True
    ):
        """
        For setting/adjusting bond length between atoms

        :param a1: the first atom
        :param a2: the second atom
        :param float dist: the distance to change by/to.
            Default is to set the bond length to that determined by RADII
        :param bool adjust: default is to set the bond length to `dist`,
            adjust=True indicates the current bond length should be adjusted by `dist`
        :param int fix: default is to move both a1 and a2 by half of `dist`, fix=1
            will move only a2 and fix=2 will move only a1
        :param bool as_group: default is to move the fragments connected to a1 and a2
            as well, as_group=False will only move the requested atom(s)
        """
        a1, a2 = self.find_exact(a1, a2)

        # determine new bond length
        if isinstance(dist, str):
            dist = float(dist)
        if dist is None:
            if hasattr(a1, "_radii") and hasattr(a2, "_radii"):
                new_dist = a1._radii + a2._radii
            elif not hasattr(a1, "_radii"):
                self.LOG.warning("no radii for %s", a1)
                return
            elif not hasattr(a2, "_radii"):
                self.LOG.warning("no radii for %s", a2)
                return
        elif adjust:
            new_dist = a1.dist(a2) + dist
        else:
            new_dist = dist
        dist = a1.dist(a2)

        # adjustment vector for each atom
        v = a2.bond(a1)
        d = np.linalg.norm(v)
        adj_a1 = (new_dist - dist) * v / d
        adj_a2 = -adj_a1
        if fix == 0:
            adj_a1 /= 2
            adj_a2 /= 2
        elif fix == 1:
            adj_a1 = None
        elif fix == 2:
            adj_a2 = None
        else:
            raise ValueError(
                "Bad parameter `fix` (should be 0, 1, or 2):", fix
            )

        # get atoms to adjust
        if as_group:
            a1 = self.get_fragment(a1, a2)
            a2 = self.get_fragment(a2, a1)
        else:
            a1 = [a1]
            a2 = [a2]

        # translate atom(s)
        for i in a1:
            if adj_a1 is None:
                break
            i.coords += adj_a1
        for i in a2:
            if adj_a2 is None:
                break
            i.coords += adj_a2

        return

    def rotate_fragment(self, start, avoid, angle):
        """
        rotates the all atoms on the 'start' side of the
        start-avoid bond about the bond vector by angle

        :param Atom start: atom to start the rotation at
        :param Atom avoid: atom to end the rotation at
        :param float angle: angle to rotate the group by
        """
        start = self.find(start)[0]
        avoid = self.find(avoid)[0]
        shift = start.coords
        self.coord_shift(-shift)
        self.rotate(
            start.bond(avoid),
            angle=angle * 180 / np.pi,
            targets=self.get_fragment(start, avoid),
        )
        self.coord_shift(shift)

    def rotate(self, w, angle=None, targets=None, center=None):
        """
        rotates target atoms by an angle about an axis

        :param np.ndarray w: the axis of rotation (doesnt need to be unit vector)
            or a quaternion (angle not required then)
        :param float angle: the angle by which to rotate (in radians)
        :param targets: atoms to rotate (defaults to all)
        :param center: if provided, the atom (or COM of a list)
            will be centered at the origin before rotation, then shifted
            back after rotation
        """
        if targets is None:
            targets = self.atoms
        else:
            targets = self.find(targets)

        # shift geometry to place center atom at origin
        if center is not None:
            if not (
                hasattr(center, "__len__")
                and all(isinstance(x, float) for x in center)
            ):
                tmp = self.find(center)
                if len(tmp) > 1:
                    center = deepcopy(self.COM(tmp))
                else:
                    center = deepcopy(tmp[0].coords)
            else:
                center = deepcopy(center)
            self.coord_shift(-1 * center)

        if not isinstance(w, np.ndarray):
            w = np.array(w, dtype=np.double)

        if angle is not None and len(w) == 3:
            w = w / np.linalg.norm(w)
            q = np.hstack(([np.cos(angle / 2)], w * np.sin(angle / 2)))
        elif len(w) != 4:
            raise TypeError(
                """Vector `w` must be either a rotation vector (len 3)
                or a quaternion (len 4). Angle parameter required if `w` is a
                rotation vector"""
            )
        else:
            q = w

        q /= np.linalg.norm(q)
        qs = q[0]
        qv = q[1:]

        xyz = self.coordinates(targets)
        xprod = np.cross(qv, xyz)
        qs_xprod = 2 * qs * xprod
        qv_xprod = 2 * np.cross(qv, xprod)

        xyz += qs_xprod + qv_xprod
        for t, coord in zip(targets, xyz):
            t.coords = coord

        if center is not None:
            self.coord_shift(center)

    def mirror(self, plane="xy"):
        """
        mirror self across a plane

        :param str plane: plane to mirror the Geometry object across
            can be xy, xz, yz, or an array for a vector orthogonal to a plane
        """
        eye = np.identity(3)
        if isinstance(plane, str):
            if plane.lower() == "xy":
                eye[2, 2] *= -1
            if plane.lower() == "xz":
                eye[1, 1] *= -1
            if plane.lower() == "yz":
                eye[0, 0] *= -1

        else:
            eye = utils.mirror_matrix(plane)

        self.update_geometry(np.dot(self.coords, eye))

    def invert(self):
        """
        invert self's coordinates 
        """
        op = -np.identity(3)
        self.update_geometry(np.dot(self.coords, op))

    def change_angle(
        self,
        a1,
        a2,
        a3,
        angle,
        radians=True,
        adjust=False,
        fix=0,
        as_group=True,
    ):
        """For setting/adjusting angle between atoms

        :param a1: first atom
        :param a2: second atom (vertex)
        :param a3: third atom
        :param float angle: the angle to change by/to
        :param bool radians: default units are radians, radians=False uses degrees
        :param bool adjust: default is to set the angle to `angle`, adjust=True
            indicates the current angle should be adjusted by `angle`
        :param int fix: default is to move both a1 and a3 by half of `angle`, fix=1
            will move only a3 and fix=3 will move only a1
        :param bool as_group: default is to move the fragments connected to a1 and a3
            as well, as_group=False will only move the requested atom(s)
        """
        try:
            a1, a2, a3 = self.find([a1, a2, a3])
        except ValueError:
            raise LookupError(
                "Bad atom request: {}, {}, {}".format(a1, a2, a3)
            )

        # get rotation vector
        v1 = a2.bond(a1)
        v2 = a2.bond(a3)
        # bond vectors are nearly colinear
        if abs(abs(np.dot(v1, v2)) / (a2.dist(a1) * a2.dist(a3)) - 1) < 1e-4:
            w = utils.perp_vector(v1)
        else:
            w = np.cross(v1, v2)
            w = w / np.linalg.norm(w)

        # determine rotation angle
        if not radians:
            angle = np.deg2rad(angle)
        if not adjust:
            angle -= a2.angle(a1, a3)

        # get target fragments
        if as_group:
            a1_frag = self.get_fragment(a1, a2)
            a3_frag = self.get_fragment(a3, a2)
        else:
            a1_frag = [a1]
            a3_frag = [a3]
            
        # shift a2 to origin
        # using center=a2 to be cleaner and consistent with change_dihedral
        #self.coord_shift(-a2.coords, a1_frag)
        #self.coord_shift(-a2.coords, a3_frag)

        # perform rotation
        if fix == 0:
            angle /= 2
            self.rotate(w, -angle, a1_frag, center=a2)
            self.rotate(w, angle, a3_frag, center=a2)
        elif fix == 1:
            self.rotate(w, angle, a3_frag, center=a2)
        elif fix == 3:
            self.rotate(w, -angle, a1_frag, center=a2)
        else:
            raise ValueError("fix must be 0, 1, 3 (supplied: {})".format(fix))

        # shift a2 back to original location
        #self.coord_shift(a2.coords, a1_frag)
        #self.coord_shift(a2.coords, a3_frag)

    def change_dihedral(self, *args, **kwargs):
        """
        For setting/adjusting dihedrals

        :param args:
        
            * :a1: the first atom
            * :a2: the second atom
            * :a3: the third atom (optional for adjust=True if as_group=True)
            * :a4: the fourth atom (optional for adjust=True if as_group=True)
            * :dihedral: the dihedral to change by/to


        :param kwargs:
        
            * :fix: default is to move both a1 and a4 by half of `dihedral`,
                fix=1 will move only a4 and fix=4 will move only a1
            * :adjust: default is to set the dihedral to `dihedral`, adjust=True
                indicates the current dihedral should be adjusted by `dihedral`
            * :as_group: default is to move the fragments connected to a1 and a3 as well,
                as_group=False will only move the requested atom(s)
            * :radians: default units are degrees, radians=True to use radians

        """
        fix = kwargs.get("fix", 0)
        adjust = kwargs.get("adjust", False)
        as_group = kwargs.get("as_group", True)
        radians = kwargs.get("radians", False)
        left_over = set(kwargs.keys()) - set(
            ["fix", "adjust", "as_group", "radians"]
        )
        if left_over:
            raise SyntaxError(
                "Unused **kwarg(s) provided: {}".format(left_over)
            )
        # get atoms
        count = len(args)
        if count == 3 and adjust:
            # we can just define the bond to rotate about, as long as we are
            # adjusting, not setting, the whole fragments on either side
            as_group = True
            a2, a3 = self.find_exact(*args[:2])
            dihedral = args[2]
            try:
                a1 = next(iter(a2.connected - set([a2, a3])))
            except StopIteration:
                a1 = next(iter(set(self.atoms) - set([a2, a3])))
            try:
                a4 = next(iter(a3.connected - set([a1, a2, a3])))
            except StopIteration:
                a4 = next(iter(set(self.atoms) - set([a1, a2, a3])))
        elif count != 5:
            raise TypeError(
                "Number of atom arguments provided insufficient to define "
                + "dihedral"
            )
        else:
            a1, a2, a3, a4 = self.find_exact(*args[:4])
            dihedral = args[4]
        # get fragments
        if as_group:
            a2_frag = self.get_fragment(a2, a3)[1:]
            a3_frag = self.get_fragment(a3, a2)[1:]
            if any(atom in a2_frag for atom in a3_frag):
                self.LOG.warning(
                    "changing dihedral that is part of a ring: %s %s", a2, a3
                )
        else:
            a2_frag = [a1]
            a3_frag = [a4]

        # fix units
        if not radians:
            dihedral = np.deg2rad(dihedral)
        # get adjustment
        if not adjust:
            dihedral -= self.dihedral(a1, a2, a3, a4)

        # rotate fragments
        if not a2_frag and not a3_frag:
            raise RuntimeError(
                "Cannot change dihedral, no fragments to target for rotation"
            )
        if not a2_frag and fix == 0:
            fix = 1
        if not a3_frag and fix == 0:
            fix = 4
        if fix == 0:
            dihedral /= 2
            self.rotate(a2.bond(a3), -dihedral, a2_frag, center=a2)
            self.rotate(a2.bond(a3), dihedral, a3_frag, center=a3)
        elif fix == 1:
            self.rotate(a2.bond(a3), dihedral, a3_frag, center=a3)
        elif fix == 4:
            self.rotate(a2.bond(a3), -dihedral, a2_frag, center=a2)
        else:
            raise ValueError(
                "`fix` must be 0, 1, or 4 (supplied: {})".format(fix)
            )

    def minimize_sub_torsion(
        self, geom=None, all_frags=False, increment=30, allow_planar=False
    ):
        """rotate substituents to try to minimize LJ potential
        
        :param geom: calculate LJ potential between self and another geometry-like
              object, instead of just within self
        :param  bool all_frags: minimize rotatable bonds on substituents
        :param  float increment: angle stride in degrees
        :param bool allow_planar: allow substituents that start and end with atoms
            with planar VSEPR geometries that are nearly
            planar to be rotated
        """
        # minimize torsion for each substituent

        if not hasattr(self, "substituents") or self.substituents is None:
            self.detect_substituents()

        # we don't want to rotate any substituents that
        # shouldn't be rotate-able
        # filter out any substituents that start on a planar atom
        # and end on a planar atom
        if not allow_planar:
            vsepr = [atom.get_vsepr()[0] for atom in self.atoms]

        for i, sub in enumerate(sorted(self.substituents, reverse=True)):
            if len(sub.atoms) < 2:
                continue
            
            if not allow_planar:
                # don't rotate substituents that might be E/Z
                vsepr_1 = vsepr[self.atoms.index(sub.end)]
                vsepr_2 = vsepr[self.atoms.index(sub.atoms[0])]
                if (
                    vsepr_1 and vsepr_2 and
                    "planar" in vsepr_1 and "planar" in vsepr_2
                ):
                    a1 = [a for a in sub.end.connected if a is not sub.atoms[0]][0]
                    a2 = [a for a in sub.atoms[0].connected if a is not sub.end][0]
                    angle = self.dihedral(a1, sub.end, sub.atoms[0], a2)
                    # ~5 degree tolerance for being planar
                    if any(np.isclose(angle, ref, atol=0.09) for ref in [np.pi, 0, -np.pi]):
                        continue
            
            axis = sub.atoms[0].bond(sub.end)
            center = sub.end
            self.minimize_torsion(
                sub.atoms, axis, center, geom, increment=increment
            )
            if all_frags:
                for frag, a, b in self.get_frag_list(
                    targets=sub.atoms, max_order=1
                ):
                    axis = a.bond(b)
                    center = b.coords
                    self.minimize_torsion(frag, axis, center, geom)

    def minimize_torsion(self, targets, axis, center, geom=None, increment=5):
        """
        Rotate targets to minimize the LJ potential

        :param list(Atom) targets: the target atoms to rotate
        :param np.ndarray axis: the axis by which to rotate
        :param np.ndarray|Atom center: where to center before rotation
        :param Geometry geom: calculate LJ potential between self and another geometry-like
            object, instead of just within self
        :param float increment: angle stride in degrees
        """
        targets = Geometry(
            self.find(targets),
            refresh_connected=False,
            refresh_ranks=False,
        )

        if geom is None or geom is self:
            from AaronTools.finders import NotAny

            atoms = self.find(NotAny(targets))
            if not atoms:
                return
            geom = Geometry(
                atoms,
                refresh_connected=False,
                refresh_ranks=False,
            )

        E_min = None
        angle_min = None
        # copied an reorganized some stuff from Geometry.rotate for
        # performance reasons
        if hasattr(center, "__iter__") and all(
            isinstance(x, float) for x in center
        ):
            center_coords = center
        else:
            center_coords = self.COM(center)

        axis = axis / np.linalg.norm(axis)
        q = np.hstack(
            (
                [np.cos(np.deg2rad(increment) / 2)],
                axis * np.sin(np.deg2rad(increment) / 2),
            )
        )
        q /= np.linalg.norm(q)
        qs = q[0]
        qv = q[1:]

        # rotate targets by increment and save lowest energy
        angle = 0
        xyz = targets.coords
        for inc in range(0, 360, increment):
            angle += increment

            xyz -= center_coords
            xprod = np.cross(qv, xyz)
            qs_xprod = 2 * qs * xprod
            qv_xprod = 2 * np.cross(qv, xprod)

            xyz += qs_xprod + qv_xprod
            xyz += center_coords
            for t, coord in zip(targets.atoms, xyz):
                t.coords = coord

            energy = targets.LJ_energy(other=geom, use_prev_params=True)

            if E_min is None or energy < E_min:
                E_min = energy
                angle_min = angle

        # rotate to min angle
        self.rotate(
            axis,
            np.deg2rad(angle_min - angle),
            targets=targets,
            center=center_coords,
        )

        return

    def substitute(self, sub, target, attached_to=None, minimize=False):
        """
        substitutes fragment containing `target` with substituent `sub`
        
        :param str|Substituent sub: substituent (or name from the library) to use
        :param target: atom to place the substituent on
        :param attached_to: if attached_to is provided, this is the atom where the substituent is attached;         
        
            if attached_to=None, replace the smallest fragment containing `target`
        
        :param bool minimize: rotate sub to lower LJ potential
        """
        from AaronTools.component import Component

        # set up substituent
        if not isinstance(sub, AaronTools.substituent.Substituent):
            sub = AaronTools.substituent.Substituent(sub)
        # sub.refresh_connected()
        # determine target and atoms defining connection bond
        target = self.find(target)
        # if we have components, do the substitution to the component
        # otherwise, just do it on self
        geom = self
        if hasattr(self, "components") and self.components is not None:
            for comp in self.components:
                if target in comp:
                    geom = comp
                    break

        # attached_to is provided or is the atom giving the
        # smallest target fragment
        if attached_to is not None:
            attached_to = geom.find_exact(attached_to)
        else:
            smallest_frag = None
            smallest_attached_to = None
            # get all possible connection points
            attached_to = set()
            for t in target:
                attached_to = attached_to | (t.connected - set(target))
            # find smallest fragment
            frags = [set(geom.get_fragment(target, e)) for e in attached_to]
            for e, frag in zip(attached_to, frags):
                if any(e in a.connected for a in frag - set(target)):
                    continue
                if smallest_frag is None or len(frag) < len(smallest_frag):
                    smallest_frag = frag
                    smallest_attached_to = e
            if smallest_frag is None:
                n_bonds = sum([len(t.connected) for t in target])
                raise RuntimeError(
                    "could not determine a suitable group to replace with "
                    "the new substituent\n"
                    "the target atom (%s) should have only one bond "
                    "to the rest of the molecule\n" 
                    "the target atom(s) have %i bonds%s" % (
                        str(target),
                        n_bonds,
                        ", but they are all part of a ring system" if n_bonds else "",
                    )
                )
            attached_to = [smallest_attached_to]
        if len(attached_to) != 1:
            raise NotImplementedError(
                "Can only replace substituents with one point of attachment"
            )
        attached_to = attached_to[0]
        sub.end = attached_to

        # determine which atom of target fragment is connected to attached_to
        sub_attach = attached_to.connected & set(target)
        if len(sub_attach) > 1:
            raise NotImplementedError(
                "Can only replace substituents with one point of attachment"
            )
        if len(sub_attach) < 1:
            raise LookupError("attached_to atom not connected to targets")
        sub_attach = sub_attach.pop()

        # manipulate substituent geometry; want sub.atoms[0] -> sub_attach
        #   attached_to == sub.end
        #   sub_attach will eventually be sub.atoms[0]
        # move attached_to to the origin
        shift = np.array([x for x in attached_to.coords])
        geom.coord_shift(-1 * shift)
        # align substituent to current bond
        bond = geom.bond(attached_to, sub_attach)
        sub.align_to_bond(bond)
        # shift geometry back and shift substituent to appropriate place
        geom.coord_shift(shift)
        sub.coord_shift(shift)

        # tag and update name for sub atoms
        for i, s in enumerate(sub.atoms):
            s.add_tag(sub.name)
            if i > 0:
                s.name = sub_attach.name + "." + s.name
            else:
                s.name = sub_attach.name

        # add first atoms of new substituent where the target atoms were
        # add the rest of the new substituent at the end
        old = geom.get_fragment(target, attached_to)
        for i, a in enumerate(old):
            if i == len(sub.atoms):
                break
            geom.atoms.insert(geom.atoms.index(old[i]), sub.atoms[i])
            sub.atoms[i].name = old[i].name
        else:
            if len(sub.atoms) > len(old):
                geom += sub.atoms[i + 1 :]
        # remove old substituent
        geom -= old
        attached_to.connected.discard(sub_attach)

        # fix connections (in lieu of geom.refresh_connected(), since clashing may occur)
        attached_to.connected.add(sub.atoms[0])
        sub.atoms[0].connected.add(attached_to)

        # fix bond distance
        geom.change_distance(attached_to, sub.atoms[0], as_group=True, fix=1)

        # clean up changes
        if isinstance(geom, Component):
            self.substituents += [sub]
            self.detect_backbone(to_center=self.backbone)
            self.rebuild()
        self.refresh_ranks()
        if minimize:
            self.minimize_torsion(sub.atoms, bond, shift)
        return sub

    def find_substituent(self, start, for_confs=False):
        """
        Finds a substituent based on a given atom (matches start==sub.atoms[0])

        :param start: the first atom of the subsituent, where it connects to sub.end
        :param for_confs: if true, only consider substituents that need to
            be rotated to generate conformers
        :returns: substituent that matches the given criteria
        :rtype: Substituent
        """
        start = self.find(start)[0]
        for sub in self.get_substituents(for_confs):
            if sub.atoms[0] == start:
                return sub
        else:
            if for_confs:
                for sub in self.get_substituents(for_confs=not for_confs):
                    if sub.atoms[0] == start:
                        return None
            msg = "Could not find substituent starting at atom {}."
            raise LookupError(msg.format(start.name))

        if not hasattr(self, "substituents") or self.substituents is None:
            self.substituents = []

        self.substituents.append(sub)

    def get_substituents(self, for_confs=True):
        """
        Returns list of all substituents found on all components

        :param for_confs: if true (default), returns only substituents that need to
            be rotated to generate conformers
        :returns: subsituents that match criteria
        :rtype: list(Substituent)
        """
        rv = []
        if self.components is None:
            self.detect_components()
        for comp in self.components:
            if comp.substituents is None:
                comp.detect_backbone()
            for sub in comp.substituents:
                if for_confs and (sub.conf_num is None or sub.conf_num <= 1):
                    continue
                rv += [sub]
        return rv

    def ring_substitute(
        self, targets, ring_fragment, minimize=False, flip_walk=False
    ):
        """
        take ring, reorient it, put it on self and replace targets with atoms
        on the ring fragment
        
        :param targets: pair of atoms to be in the ring
        :param str|Ring ring_fragment: Ring or name of ring in the library
        :param bool minimize: try other rings with the same name (appended with a number)
            in the library to see if they fit better
        :param bool flip_walk: also flip the rings when minimizing to see if that fits better
        """

        def attach_short(geom, walk, ring_fragment):
            """for when walk < end, rmsd and remove end[1:-1]"""
            # align ring's end to geom's walk
            ring_fragment.RMSD(
                geom,
                align=True,
                targets=ring_fragment.end,
                ref_targets=walk,
                sort=False,
            )

            ring_waddle(geom, targets, [walk[1], walk[-2]], ring_fragment)

            for atom in ring_fragment.end[1:-1]:
                for t in atom.connected:
                    if t not in ring_fragment.end:
                        ring_fragment.remove_fragment(t, atom, add_H=False)
                        ring_fragment -= t

                ring_fragment -= atom

            geom.remove_fragment([walk[0], walk[-1]], walk[1:-1], add_H=False)
            geom -= [walk[0], walk[-1]]

            walk[1].connected.add(ring_fragment.end[0])
            walk[-2].connected.add(ring_fragment.end[-1])
            ring_fragment.end[-1].connected.add(walk[-2])
            ring_fragment.end[0].connected.add(walk[1])
            ring_fragment.end = walk[1:-1]
            geom.atoms.extend(ring_fragment.atoms)
            geom.refresh_ranks()

        def ring_waddle(geom, targets, walk_end, ring):
            """adjusted the new bond lengths by moving the ring in a 'waddling' motion
            pivot on one end atom to adjust the bond lenth of the other, then do
            the same with the other end atom"""
            if hasattr(ring.end[0], "_radii") and hasattr(
                walk_end[0], "_radii"
            ):
                d1 = ring.end[0]._radii + walk_end[0]._radii
            else:
                d1 = ring.end[0].dist(walk_end[0])

            v1 = ring.end[-1].bond(walk_end[0])
            v2 = ring.end[-1].bond(ring.end[0])

            v1_n = np.linalg.norm(v1)
            v2_n = np.linalg.norm(v2)

            target_angle = np.arccos(
                (d1 ** 2 - v1_n ** 2 - v2_n ** 2) / (-2.0 * v1_n * v2_n)
            )
            current_angle = ring.end[-1].angle(ring.end[0], walk_end[0])
            ra = target_angle - current_angle

            rv = np.cross(v1, v2)

            ring.rotate(rv, ra, center=ring.end[-1])

            if hasattr(ring.end[-1], "_radii") and hasattr(
                walk_end[-1], "_radii"
            ):
                d1 = ring.end[-1]._radii + walk_end[-1]._radii
            else:
                d1 = ring.end[-1].dist(walk_end[-1])

            v1 = ring.end[0].bond(walk_end[-1])
            v2 = ring.end[0].bond(ring.end[-1])

            v1_n = np.linalg.norm(v1)
            v2_n = np.linalg.norm(v2)

            target_angle = np.arccos(
                (d1 ** 2 - v1_n ** 2 - v2_n ** 2) / (-2.0 * v1_n * v2_n)
            )
            current_angle = ring.end[0].angle(ring.end[-1], walk_end[-1])
            ra = target_angle - current_angle

            rv = np.cross(v1, v2)

            ring.rotate(rv, ra, center=ring.end[0])

        def clashing(geom, ring):
            from AaronTools.finders import NotAny

            geom_coords = geom.coordinates(NotAny(ring.atoms))
            dist_mat = distance_matrix(geom_coords, ring.coords)
            if np.any(dist_mat < 0.75):
                return True

            return False

        from AaronTools.ring import Ring

        if not isinstance(ring_fragment, Ring):
            ring_fragment = Ring(ring_fragment)

        targets = self.find(targets)
        # we want to keep atom naming conventions consistent with regular substitutions
        for atom in ring_fragment.atoms:
            atom.name = "{}.{}".format(targets[0].name, atom.name)

        # find a path between the targets
        walk = self.shortest_path(*targets)
        if len(ring_fragment.end) != len(walk):
            ring_fragment.find_end(len(walk), start=ring_fragment.end)

        if len(walk) == len(ring_fragment.end) and len(walk) != 2:
            if not minimize:
                attach_short(self, walk, ring_fragment)
            else:
                # to minimize, check VSEPR on self's atoms attached to targets
                # lower deviation is better
                # do this for the original ring and also try flipping the ring
                # ring is flipped by reversing walk
                # check for other rings in the library with ring.\d+
                # e.g. cyclohexane.2
                vsepr1, _ = walk[1].get_vsepr()
                vsepr2, _ = walk[-2].get_vsepr()
                geom = self.copy()
                test_walk = [
                    geom.atoms[i]
                    for i in [self.atoms.index(atom) for atom in walk]
                ]
                frag = ring_fragment.copy()
                attach_short(geom, test_walk, frag)
                new_vsepr1, score1 = test_walk[1].get_vsepr()
                new_vsepr2, score2 = test_walk[-2].get_vsepr()
                new_vsepr3, score3 = frag.end[0].get_vsepr()
                new_vsepr4, score4 = frag.end[-1].get_vsepr()

                score = score1 + score2 + score3 + score4

                min_diff = score
                min_ring = 0

                # print("%s score: %.3f" % (ring_fragment.name, score))

                if flip_walk:
                    geom = self.copy()
                    test_walk = [
                        geom.atoms[i]
                        for i in [self.atoms.index(atom) for atom in walk]
                    ][::-1]
                    frag = ring_fragment.copy()
                    attach_short(geom, test_walk, frag)
                    new_vsepr1, score1 = test_walk[1].get_vsepr()
                    new_vsepr2, score2 = test_walk[-2].get_vsepr()
                    new_vsepr3, score3 = frag.end[0].get_vsepr()
                    new_vsepr4, score4 = frag.end[-1].get_vsepr()

                    score = score1 + score2 + score3 + score4

                    if score < min_diff and not clashing(geom, frag):
                        min_ring = 1
                        min_diff = score

                    # print("flipped %s score: %.3f" % (ring_fragment.name, score))

                # check other rings in library
                # for these, flip the ring end instead of walk
                for ring_name in Ring.list():
                    if re.search("%s\.\d+" % ring_fragment.name, ring_name):
                        test_ring_0 = Ring(ring_name)

                        geom = self.copy()
                        test_walk = [
                            geom.atoms[i]
                            for i in [self.atoms.index(atom) for atom in walk]
                        ]
                        if len(test_ring_0.end) != len(walk):
                            test_ring_0.find_end(
                                len(walk), start=test_ring_0.end
                            )

                        frag = test_ring_0.copy()
                        attach_short(geom, test_walk, frag)
                        new_vsepr1, score1 = test_walk[1].get_vsepr()
                        new_vsepr2, score2 = test_walk[-2].get_vsepr()
                        new_vsepr3, score3 = frag.end[0].get_vsepr()
                        new_vsepr4, score4 = frag.end[-1].get_vsepr()

                        score = score1 + score2 + score3 + score4

                        if score < min_diff and not clashing(geom, frag):
                            min_ring = test_ring_0
                            min_diff = score

                        # print("%s score: %.3f" % (ring_name, score))

                        if flip_walk:
                            test_ring_1 = Ring(ring_name)
                            test_ring_1.end.reverse()

                            geom = self.copy()
                            test_walk = [
                                geom.atoms[i]
                                for i in [
                                    self.atoms.index(atom) for atom in walk
                                ]
                            ]
                            if len(test_ring_0.end) != len(walk):
                                test_ring_0.find_end(
                                    len(walk), start=test_ring_0.end
                                )

                            frag = test_ring_1.copy()
                            attach_short(geom, test_walk, frag)
                            new_vsepr1, score1 = test_walk[1].get_vsepr()
                            new_vsepr2, score2 = test_walk[-2].get_vsepr()
                            new_vsepr3, score3 = frag.end[0].get_vsepr()
                            new_vsepr4, score4 = frag.end[-1].get_vsepr()

                            score = score1 + score2 + score3 + score4

                            # print("flipped %s score: %.3f" % (ring_name, score))

                            if score < min_diff and not clashing(geom, frag):
                                min_ring = test_ring_1
                                min_diff = score

                if not isinstance(min_ring, Ring) and min_ring == 0:
                    walk = self.shortest_path(*targets)
                    attach_short(self, walk, ring_fragment)
                elif not isinstance(min_ring, Ring) and min_ring == 1:
                    walk = self.shortest_path(*targets)[::-1]
                    attach_short(self, walk, ring_fragment)
                else:
                    walk = self.shortest_path(*targets)
                    attach_short(self, walk, min_ring)

        elif not walk[1:-1]:
            raise ValueError(
                "insufficient information to close ring - selected atoms are bonded to each other: %s"
                % (" ".join(str(a) for a in targets))
            )

        else:
            raise ValueError(
                "this ring is not appropriate to connect\n%s\nand\n%s:\n%s\nspacing is %i; expected %i"
                % (
                    targets[0],
                    targets[1],
                    ring_fragment.name,
                    len(ring_fragment.end),
                    len(walk),
                )
            )
        # AaronJr needs to know this when relaxing changes
        return ring_fragment.atoms

    def change_element(
        self,
        target,
        new_element,
        adjust_bonds=False,
        adjust_hydrogens=False,
        hold_steady=None,
    ):
        """
        change the element of an atom on self
        
        :param target: target atom
        :param str new_element:  element of new atom
        :param bool adjust_bonds: bool adjust distance to bonded atoms
        :param bool|tuple(int, str) adjust_hydrogens:
        
            * :bool: try to add or remove hydrogens and guess how many hydrogens to add or remove
            * :tuple(int, str): remove specified number of hydrogens and set the geometry to
                the specified shape (see Atom.get_shape for a list of shapes)
        
        :param hold_steady: atom bonded to target that will be held steady when
            adjusting bonds; Default - longest fragment
        """

        def get_corresponding_shape(target, shape_object, frags):
            """
            returns shape object, but where shape_object.atoms are lined up with
            target.connected as much as possible
            """
            shape_object.coord_shift(
                target.coords - shape_object.atoms[0].coords
            )
            if len(frags) == 0:
                return shape_object

            # to minimize changes to the structure, things are aligned to the largest fragment
            max_frag = sorted(frags, key=len, reverse=True)[0]
            angle = target.angle(shape_object.atoms[1], max_frag[0])
            v1 = target.bond(max_frag[0])
            v2 = shape_object.atoms[0].bond(shape_object.atoms[1])
            v1 /= np.linalg.norm(v1)
            v2 /= np.linalg.norm(v2)
            rv = np.cross(v1, v2)

            # could have numerical issues
            # avoid those, but check to see if the angle is 180 degrees
            if abs(np.linalg.norm(rv)) < 10 ** -3 or abs(angle) < 10 ** -3:
                if np.dot(v1, v2) == -1:
                    rv = np.array([v1[2], v1[0], v1[1]])
                    shape_object.rotate(rv, np.pi, center=target)
                    angle = 0

            if abs(np.linalg.norm(rv)) > 10 ** -3 and abs(angle) > 10 ** -3:
                shape_object.rotate(rv, -angle, center=target)

            # rotate about the vector from the center (target atom) to the first
            # atom in shape (which will be the largest fragment) to get the shape object
            # as lined up with the rest of the connected atoms as possible
            rv = target.bond(shape_object.atoms[1])
            min_dev = None
            min_angle = 0
            inc = 5
            angle = 0
            while angle < 360:
                angle += inc
                shape_object.rotate(rv, np.deg2rad(inc), center=target)

                previous_positions = [0]
                dev = 0
                for j, frag in enumerate(sorted(frags, key=len, reverse=True)):
                    if j == 0:
                        continue
                    v1 = target.bond(frag[0])
                    max_overlap = None
                    corresponding_position = None
                    for i, position in enumerate(shape_object.atoms[1:]):
                        if i in previous_positions:
                            continue
                        v2 = shape_object.atoms[0].bond(position)
                        d = np.dot(v1, v2)
                        if max_overlap is None or d > max_overlap:
                            max_overlap = d
                            corresponding_position = i

                    if corresponding_position is None:
                        continue

                    previous_positions.append(corresponding_position)
                    dev += (
                        max_overlap
                        - (
                            np.linalg.norm(frag[0].coords)
                            * np.linalg.norm(
                                shape_object.atoms[
                                    corresponding_position + 1
                                ].coords
                            )
                        )
                    ) ** 2

                if min_dev is None or dev < min_dev:
                    min_dev = dev
                    min_angle = angle

            shape_object.rotate(rv, np.deg2rad(min_angle), center=target)

            return shape_object

        target = self.find(target)
        if len(target) > 1:
            raise RuntimeError(
                "only one atom's element can be changed at a time (%i attempted)"
                % len(target)
            )
        else:
            target = target[0]

        # new_atom is only used to determine how many H's to add
        new_atom = Atom(
            element=new_element, name=target.name, coords=target.coords
        )

        if adjust_hydrogens is True:
            # try to determine how many hydrogens to add based on how many hydrogens are currently
            # bonded and what the saturation of the atoms is
            # e.g. C(H3) -> N(H?)
            # C's saturation is 4, it's missing one
            # N's saturation is 3, it should be missing one: N(H2)
            if hasattr(target, "_saturation") and hasattr(
                new_atom, "_saturation"
            ):
                change_hydrogens = new_atom._saturation - target._saturation
                new_shape = None
            else:
                raise RuntimeError(
                    "H adjust requested, but saturation is not known for %s"
                    % ", ".join(
                        [
                            atom.element
                            for atom in [target, new_atom]
                            if not hasattr(atom, "_saturation")
                        ]
                    )
                )

        elif isinstance(adjust_hydrogens, tuple):
            # tuple of (change in hydrogens, vsepr shape) was given
            change_hydrogens, new_shape = adjust_hydrogens
            if callable(change_hydrogens):
                change_hydrogens = change_hydrogens(target)

        else:
            # no change was requested, only the element will change
            # and maybe bond lengths
            change_hydrogens = 0
            new_shape = None

        if change_hydrogens != 0 or new_shape is not None:
            # if we're removing hydrogens, check if we have enough to remove
            if change_hydrogens < 0:
                n_hygrogens = sum(
                    [1 for atom in target.connected if atom.element == "H"]
                )
                if n_hygrogens + change_hydrogens < 0:
                    raise RuntimeError(
                        "cannot remove %i hydrogens from an atom with %i hydrogens"
                        % (abs(change_hydrogens), n_hygrogens)
                    )

            # get vsepr geometry
            old_shape, score = target.get_vsepr()

            if new_shape is None:
                shape = old_shape
                if hasattr(new_atom, "_connectivity"):
                    new_connectivity = new_atom._connectivity
                else:
                    new_connectivity = None

                # if we're changing the number of hydrogens, but no shape was specified,
                # we will remove hydrogens one by one and see what shape we end up with
                # shape changes are based on rules like adding a bond to a trigonal planar
                # atom will cause it to be tetrahedral (e.g. carbocation gaining a hydride)
                for i in range(0, abs(change_hydrogens)):
                    shape = Atom.new_shape(
                        shape, new_connectivity, np.sign(change_hydrogens)
                    )
                    if shape is None:
                        raise RuntimeError(
                            "shape changed from %s to None" % old_shape
                        )

                new_shape = shape

            shape_coords = Atom.get_shape(new_shape)
            shape_atoms = [
                Atom(name="%i" % i, coords=coords, element="X") for i, coords in
                enumerate(shape_coords)
            ]
            shape_object = Geometry(shape_atoms)

            if (
                len(shape_object.atoms[1:]) - len(target.connected)
                != change_hydrogens
            ):
                # insufficient to change the shape
                # we cannot delete random fragments
                raise RuntimeError(
                    "number of positions changed by %i, but a change of %i hydrogens was attempted"
                    % (
                        len(shape_object.atoms[1:]) - len(target.connected),
                        change_hydrogens,
                    )
                )

            # get each branch off of the target atom
            frags = [
                self.get_fragment(atom, target) for atom in target.connected
            ]

            if new_shape != old_shape or change_hydrogens == 0:
                if change_hydrogens < 0:
                    # remove extra hydrogens
                    shape_object = get_corresponding_shape(
                        target, shape_object, frags
                    )
                    removed_Hs = 1
                    while removed_Hs <= abs(change_hydrogens):
                        H_atom = [
                            atom
                            for atom in target.connected
                            if atom.element == "H"
                        ][0]
                        self -= H_atom
                        removed_Hs += 1

                # get fragments after hydrogens have been removed
                frags = [
                    self.get_fragment(atom, target)
                    for atom in target.connected
                ]

                # align the shape object
                # the shape object's first atom will be on top of target
                # the second will be lined up with the largest fragment on target
                # the rest are rotated to minimize deviation from the remaining groups
                shape_object = get_corresponding_shape(
                    target, shape_object, frags
                )

                # ring detection - remove ring fragments because those are more difficult to adjust
                remove_frags = []
                for i, frag1 in enumerate(frags):
                    for frag2 in frags[i + 1 :]:
                        dups = [atom for atom in frag2 if atom in frag1]
                        if len(dups) != 0:
                            remove_frags.append(frag1)
                            remove_frags.append(frag2)

                # add Hs if needed
                if change_hydrogens > 0:
                    # determine which connected atom is occupying which position on the shape
                    shape_object = get_corresponding_shape(
                        target, shape_object, frags
                    )

                    positions = []
                    for j, frag in enumerate(
                        sorted(frags, key=len, reverse=True)
                    ):
                        v2 = target.bond(frag[0])
                        max_overlap = None
                        position = None
                        for i, pos in enumerate(shape_object.atoms[1:]):
                            v1 = shape_object.atoms[0].bond(pos)
                            if i in positions:
                                continue

                            d = np.dot(v1, v2)

                            if max_overlap is None or d > max_overlap:
                                max_overlap = d
                                position = i

                        positions.append(position)

                    # add hydrogens to positions that are not occupied
                    for open_position in [
                        i + 1
                        for i in range(0, len(shape_object.atoms[1:]))
                        if i not in positions
                    ]:
                        # add one because the 0th "position" of the shape is the central atom
                        H_atom = Atom(
                            element="H",
                            coords=shape_object.atoms[open_position].coords,
                            name=str(len(self.atoms) + 1),
                        )

                        self.change_distance(target, H_atom, fix=1)
                        self += H_atom
                        target.connected.add(H_atom)
                        H_atom.connected.add(target)
                        frags.append([H_atom])

                # for each position on the new idealized geometry, find the fragment
                # that corresponds to it the best
                # reorient that fragment to match the idealized geometry

                previous_positions = []
                frag_atoms = []
                first_frag = None
                if hold_steady:
                    hold_steady = self.find(hold_steady)
                for j, frag in enumerate(sorted(frags, key=len, reverse=True)):
                    # print(j, frag)
                    if j == 0 or (hold_steady and frag[0] in hold_steady):
                        # skip the first fragment
                        # that's already aligned with one of the atoms on shape_object
                        first_frag = frag
                        continue
                    frag_atoms.extend(frag)
                    v1 = target.bond(frag[0])
                    max_overlap = None
                    corresponding_position = None
                    for i, position in enumerate(shape_object.atoms[2:]):
                        if i in previous_positions:
                            continue
                        v2 = shape_object.atoms[0].bond(position)
                        d = np.dot(v1, v2)
                        # determine by max. bond overlap
                        if max_overlap is None or d > max_overlap:
                            max_overlap = d
                            corresponding_position = i

                    previous_positions.append(corresponding_position)
                    corresponding_position += 2

                    v1 = target.bond(frag[0])
                    v1 /= np.linalg.norm(v1)
                    v2 = shape_object.atoms[0].bond(
                        shape_object.atoms[corresponding_position]
                    )
                    v2 /= np.linalg.norm(v2)

                    rv = np.cross(v1, v2)

                    if np.linalg.norm(rv) < 10 ** -3:
                        continue

                    c = np.linalg.norm(v1 - v2)

                    if abs((c ** 2 - 2.0) / -2.0) >= 1:
                        continue

                    angle = np.arccos((c ** 2 - 2.0) / -2.0)

                    self.rotate(rv, angle, targets=frag, center=target)

                # rotate the normal of this atom to be parallel to the largest group
                # this makes changing to trigonal planar look cleaner
                # don't do this if it isn't planar
                if "planar" in new_shape:
                    for frag in frags:
                        if first_frag and frag is first_frag:
                            stop = frag[0]
                            other_vsepr = stop.get_vsepr()[0]
                            if (
                                isinstance(other_vsepr, str)
                                and "planar" in other_vsepr
                            ):
                                min_torsion = None
                                for atom in target.connected:
                                    if atom is stop:
                                        continue

                                    for a4 in stop.connected:
                                        if a4 is target:
                                            continue
                                        torsion = self.dihedral(
                                            atom, target, stop, a4
                                        )
                                        # print("checking", atom, a4, torsion, min_torsion)
                                        if min_torsion is None or abs(
                                            torsion
                                        ) < abs(min_torsion):
                                            min_torsion = torsion

                                if (
                                    min_torsion is not None
                                    and abs(min_torsion) > 1e-2
                                ):
                                    angle = min_torsion
                                    targs = []
                                    self.write(outfile="test_ele.xyz")
                                    for f in frags:
                                        if f is frag:
                                            continue
                                        targs.extend(f)

                                    self.rotate(
                                        target.bond(stop),
                                        angle,
                                        targets=targs,
                                        center=target,
                                    )

                    for frag in frags:
                        if first_frag and frag is not first_frag:
                            stop = frag[0]
                            if len(stop.connected) > 1:
                                other_vsepr = stop.get_vsepr()[0]
                                if (
                                    isinstance(other_vsepr, str)
                                    and "planar" in other_vsepr
                                ):
                                    min_torsion = None
                                    for atom in target.connected:
                                        if atom is stop:
                                            continue
                                        for atom2 in stop.connected:
                                            if atom2 is target:
                                                continue
                                            torsion = self.dihedral(
                                                atom, target, stop, atom2
                                            )
                                            if min_torsion is None or abs(
                                                torsion
                                            ) < abs(min_torsion):
                                                min_torsion = torsion

                                    if (
                                        min_torsion is not None
                                        and abs(min_torsion) > 1e-2
                                    ):
                                        angle = -1 * min_torsion
                                        targs = frag

                                        self.rotate(
                                            target.bond(stop),
                                            angle,
                                            targets=targs,
                                            center=target,
                                        )

        self.refresh_ranks()

        target.element = new_element

        # these methods are normally called when an atom is instantiated
        target.reset()

        # fix bond lengths if requested
        # try to guess the bond order based on saturation
        if adjust_bonds:
            from AaronTools.atoms import BondOrder

            bo = BondOrder()

            if hold_steady:
                hold_steady = self.find(hold_steady)
            frags = [
                self.get_fragment(atom, target) for atom in target.connected
            ]
            target_bo = 1
            if hasattr(target, "_saturation"):
                target_bo = max(
                    1 + target._saturation - len(target.connected), 1
                )

            for i, frag in enumerate(sorted(frags, key=len, reverse=True)):
                frag_bo = 1
                if hasattr(frag[0], "_saturation"):
                    frag_bo = max(
                        1 + frag[0]._saturation - len(frag[0].connected), 1
                    )

                expected_bo = "%.1f" % float(min(frag_bo, target_bo))
                # print(expected_bo)
                key = bo.key(frag[0], target)
                try:
                    expected_dist = bo.bonds[key][expected_bo]
                except KeyError:
                    expected_dist = None

                if hold_steady:
                    self.change_distance(
                        target,
                        frag[0],
                        as_group=True,
                        dist=expected_dist,
                        fix=2 if frag[0] in hold_steady else 1,
                    )
                else:
                    self.change_distance(
                        target,
                        frag[0],
                        as_group=True,
                        dist=expected_dist,
                        fix=2 if i == 0 else 1,
                    )

    def map_ligand(self, ligands, old_keys, minimize=True, center=None):
        """
        Maps new ligand according to key_map

        :param ligands:    the name of a ligand in the ligand library
        :param old_keys:  the key atoms of the old ligand to map to
        :param bool minimize: rotate groups slightly to reduce steric clashing
        :param Atom center: center of the ligand, defaults to computed center
        :returns: new mapped ligand
        :rtype: Geometry
        """

        def get_rotation(old_axis, new_axis):
            w = np.cross(old_axis, new_axis)
            # if old and new axes are colinear, use perp_vector
            if np.linalg.norm(w) <= 1e-4:
                w = utils.perp_vector(old_axis)
            angle = np.dot(old_axis, new_axis)
            angle /= np.linalg.norm(old_axis)
            angle /= np.linalg.norm(new_axis)
            # occasionally there will be some round-off errors,
            # so let's fix those before we take arccos
            if angle > 1 + 10 ** -12 or angle < -1 - 10 ** -12:
                # and check to make sure we aren't covering something
                # more senister up...
                raise ValueError("Bad angle value for arccos():", angle)
            elif angle > 1:
                angle = 1.0
            elif angle < -1:
                angle = -1.0
            angle = np.arccos(angle)
            return w, -1 * angle

        def map_1_key(self, ligand, old_key, new_key):
            # align new key to old key
            shift = new_key.bond(old_key)
            ligand.coord_shift(shift)
            # rotate ligand
            targets = [
                atom for atom in self.center if atom.is_connected(old_key)
            ]
            if len(targets) > 0:
                new_axis = shift - new_key.coords
            else:
                targets = old_key.connected - set(self.center)
                new_axis = (
                    ligand.COM(targets=new_key.connected) - new_key.coords
                )

            if not targets:
                old_axis = old_key.coords - self.COM(self.center)
            else:
                old_axis = self.COM(targets=targets) - old_key.coords
            angle = 1
            while angle > 1e-4:
                w, angle = get_rotation(old_axis, new_axis)
                if np.linalg.norm(w) > 1e-4:
                    ligand.rotate(w, angle, center=new_key)
                else:
                    break
            return ligand

        def map_2_key(old_ligand, ligand, old_keys, new_keys, rev_ang=False):

            # align COM of key atoms
            center = old_ligand.COM(targets=old_keys)
            ligand_com = ligand.COM(targets=new_keys)
            shift = center - ligand_com
            ligand.coord_shift(shift)
            remove_centers = []

            old_walk = False
            # bend around key axis
            try:
                old_walk = old_ligand.shortest_path(*old_keys)

            except (LookupError, ValueError):
                # for some ferrocene ligands, AaronTools misidentifies the Fe
                # as another metal center
                # we'll remove any centers that are on the path between the key atoms
                # also, sometimes the ligand atoms don't have the center in their connected
                # attribute, even though the center has the ligand atoms in its
                # connected attribute
                for c in self.center:
                    for key in old_keys:
                        if c.is_connected(key):
                            c.add_bond_to(key)
                # print("old keys:", old_keys)
                # print("old ligand:\n", old_ligand)
                stop = [
                    atom
                    for atom in old_keys[0].connected
                    if atom not in old_ligand.atoms
                ]
                if stop:
                    frag = old_ligand.get_fragment(
                        old_keys[0],
                        stop=stop,
                    )
                    if all(atom in frag for atom in old_keys):
                        old_walk = self.shortest_path(
                            *old_keys,
                            avoid=[
                                a
                                for a in self.center
                                if any(k.is_connected(a) for k in old_keys)
                            ]
                        )
                        remove_centers = [
                            c for c in self.center if c in old_walk
                        ]

                else:
                    old_walk = [a for a in old_keys]

            if old_walk and len(old_walk) == 2:
                old_con = set([])
                for k in old_keys:
                    for c in k.connected:
                        old_con.add(c)
                if old_con:
                    old_vec = old_ligand.COM(targets=old_con) - center
                else:
                    old_vec = center

            elif old_walk:
                old_vec = old_ligand.COM(targets=old_walk[1:-1]) - center
            else:
                old_vec = np.zeros(3)
                for atom in old_keys:
                    if any(
                        bonded_atom not in old_ligand.atoms
                        for bonded_atom in atom.connected
                    ):
                        v = atom.coords - self.COM(
                            targets=[
                                bonded_atom
                                for bonded_atom in atom.connected
                                if bonded_atom not in old_ligand.atoms
                            ]
                        )
                        v /= np.linalg.norm(v)
                        old_vec += v

                old_vec /= np.linalg.norm(old_vec)

            try:
                new_walk = ligand.shortest_path(*new_keys)
                if len(new_walk) == 2:
                    new_con = set([])
                    for k in new_keys:
                        for c in k.connected:
                            new_con.add(c)
                    new_vec = ligand.COM(targets=new_con) - center
                else:
                    new_vec = ligand.COM(targets=new_walk[1:-1]) - center
            except LookupError:
                if len(ligand.atoms) == 2:
                    new_vec = utils.perp_vector(new_keys[0].bond(new_keys[1]))
                else:
                    new_vec = ligand.COM(targets=[a for a in ligand.atoms if a not in new_keys])

            w, angle = get_rotation(old_vec, new_vec)
            if rev_ang:
                angle = -angle
            ligand.rotate(w, angle, center=center)

            # rotate for best overlap
            old_axis = old_keys[0].bond(old_keys[1])
            new_axis = new_keys[0].bond(new_keys[1])
            old_axis -= utils.proj(old_vec, old_axis)
            new_axis -= utils.proj(old_vec, new_axis)
            w = old_vec
            v1 = old_axis / np.linalg.norm(old_axis)
            v2 = new_axis / np.linalg.norm(new_axis)
            angle = np.arccos(np.dot(v1, v2))
            if np.dot(np.cross(v1, v2), w) > 0:
                angle *= -1
            ligand.rotate(w, angle, center=center)

            return remove_centers

        def map_rot_frag(frag, a, b, ligand, old_key, new_key):
            old_vec = old_key.coords - b.coords
            new_vec = new_key.coords - b.coords
            axis, angle = get_rotation(old_vec, new_vec)
            ligand.rotate(b.bond(a), -1 * angle, targets=frag, center=b.coords)

            for c in new_key.connected:
                con_frag = ligand.get_fragment(new_key, c)
                if len(con_frag) > len(frag):
                    continue
                old_vec = self.COM(targets=old_key.connected)
                old_vec -= old_key.coords
                new_vec = ligand.COM(targets=new_key.connected)
                new_vec -= new_key.coords
                axis, angle = get_rotation(old_vec, new_vec)
                ligand.rotate(
                    c.bond(new_key),
                    -1 * angle,
                    targets=con_frag,
                    center=new_key.coords,
                )

        def map_more_key(self, old_ligand, ligand, old_keys, new_keys):
            # backbone fragments separated by rotatable bonds
            frag_list = ligand.get_frag_list(max_order=1)
            # ligand.write("ligand")
            remove_centers = [c for c in old_keys if c in self.center]

            target_neighbors = []
            target_dists = []
            weights = []
            for ok, nk in zip(old_keys, new_keys):
                target_neighbors.append([])
                target_dists.append([])
                weights.append([])
                # print(ok.connected)
                # for ok_neighbor in ok.connected:
                #     if ok_neighbor in old_ligand.atoms:
                #         continue
                #     target_neighbors[-1].append(ok_neighbor)
                #     target_dists[-1].append(nk._radii + ok_neighbor._radii)
                #     weights[-1].append(0)
                target_neighbors[-1].append(ok)
                target_dists[-1].append(0)
                weights[-1].append(1)

            # print("targets")
            # for n, d, w in zip(target_neighbors, target_dists, weights):
            #     print(n, d, w)
            # 
            # print("old key")
            # print([k.name for k in old_keys])
            # 
            # print("new key")
            # print([k.name for k in new_keys])

            def difference(new_key_coords):
                diff = 0
                for i in range(0, len(new_keys)):
                    coords = new_key_coords[i]
                    for n, d, w in zip(target_neighbors[i], target_dists[i], weights[i]):
                        cd = np.linalg.norm(n.coords - coords)
                        dr = d - cd
                        diff += w * dr
                return diff

            ndx = {a: i for i, a in enumerate(ligand.atoms)}
            new_key_ndx = [ndx[nk] for nk in new_keys]

            # self.write(outfile="test-maplig-1.xyz")
            # ligand.write(outfile="test-maplig-2.xyz")

            prev_dx = 0
            prev_dy = 0
            prev_dz = 0
            for i in range(0, 500):
                coords = ligand.coords
                cur_diff = difference(coords[new_key_ndx])
                # print(cur_diff)
                centroid = ligand.COM()
                
                rot_step = 0.0001
                trans_step = 0.0001
                
                ligand.rotate([1, 0, 0], angle=rot_step, center=centroid)
                d_rx = difference(ligand.coords[new_key_ndx]) - cur_diff
                d_rx /= rot_step
                ligand.coords = coords
    
                ligand.rotate([0, 1, 0], angle=rot_step, center=centroid)
                d_ry = difference(ligand.coords[new_key_ndx]) - cur_diff
                d_ry /= rot_step
                ligand.coords = coords
    
                ligand.rotate([0, 0, 1], angle=rot_step, center=centroid)
                d_rz = difference(ligand.coords[new_key_ndx]) - cur_diff
                d_rz /= rot_step
                ligand.coords = coords

                dx = difference(
                    ligand.coords[new_key_ndx] + np.array([trans_step, 0, 0])
                ) - cur_diff
                dx /= trans_step
                dy = difference(
                    ligand.coords[new_key_ndx] + np.array([0, trans_step, 0])
                ) - cur_diff
                dy /= trans_step
                dz = difference(
                    ligand.coords[new_key_ndx] + np.array([0, 0, trans_step])
                ) - cur_diff
                dz /= trans_step

                # print(d_rx, d_ry, d_rz, dx, dy, dz)

                t_lr = 0.05
                r_lr = 0.025
                if i < 100:
                    t_lr = 0.25
                    r_lr = 0.1
                if i > 250:
                    r_lr = 0.01
                if i > 450:
                    t_lr = 0.001
                    r_lr = 0.001

                ligand.rotate([1, 0, 0], angle=r_lr * d_rx, center=centroid)
                ligand.rotate([0, 1, 0], angle=r_lr * d_ry, center=centroid)
                ligand.rotate([0, 0, 1], angle=r_lr * d_rz, center=centroid)
                ligand.coords += np.array([0.9 * dx + 0.1 * prev_dx, 0, 0]) * t_lr
                ligand.coords += np.array([0, 0.9 * dy + 0.1 * prev_dy, 0]) * t_lr
                ligand.coords += np.array([0, 0, 0.9 * dz + 0.1 * prev_dz]) * t_lr

                prev_d_rx = d_rx
                prev_d_ry = d_ry
                prev_d_rz = d_rz
                prev_dx = dx
                prev_dy = dy
                prev_dz = dz
                
                # ligand.write(outfile="test-maplig-2.xyz", append=True)

            neighbors = []
            for nk, ok in zip(new_keys, old_keys):
                neighbors.append([])
                for con in ok.connected:
                    if con in old_ligand.atoms:
                        continue
                    neighbors[-1].append(con)

            for i in range(0, 50):
                dx = np.zeros(3)
                for nk, neighbor_group in zip(new_keys, neighbors):
                    for n in neighbor_group:
                        v = nk.coords - n.coords
                        v /= np.linalg.norm(v)
    
                        dr = nk._radii + n._radii - nk.dist(n)
                        dx += 0.1 * dr * v
                ligand.coords += dx
 
            return remove_centers

        if not self.components:
            self.detect_components(center=center)

        # find old and new keys
        old_keys = self.find(old_keys)
        if isinstance(ligands, (str, Geometry)):
            ligands = [ligands]
        new_keys = []
        for i, ligand in enumerate(ligands):
            if not isinstance(ligand, AaronTools.component.Component):
                ligand = AaronTools.component.Component(ligand)
                ligands[i] = ligand
            ligand.refresh_connected()
            new_keys += ligand.key_atoms
        if len(old_keys) != len(new_keys):
            raise ValueError(
                "Cannot map ligand. "
                + "Differing number of key atoms. "
                + "Old keys: "
                + ",".join([i.name for i in old_keys])
                + "; "
                + "New keys: "
                + ",".join([i.name for i in new_keys])
            )

        old_ligand = []
        remove_components = []
        for k in old_keys:
            for i, c in enumerate(self.components):
                if k in c.atoms and k not in old_ligand:
                    old_ligand.extend(c.atoms)
                    remove_components.append(i)

        for i in remove_components:
            self.components.pop(i)
            for j in range(0, len(remove_components)):
                if remove_components[j] > i:
                    remove_components[j] -= 1

        old_ligand = Geometry(old_ligand)
        for c in self.center:
            for n in c.connected:
                if n in old_ligand.atoms:
                    n.connected.add(c)

        start = 0
        end = None
        remove_centers = []
        for i, ligand in enumerate(ligands):
            end = start + len(ligand.key_atoms)
            if len(ligand.key_atoms) == 1:
                map_1_key(self, ligand, old_keys[start], new_keys[start])
            elif len(ligand.key_atoms) == 2:
                remove_centers.extend(
                    map_2_key(
                        old_ligand,
                        ligand,
                        old_keys[start:end],
                        new_keys[start:end],
                    )
                )
            else:
                remove_centers.extend(
                    map_more_key(
                        self,
                        old_ligand,
                        ligand,
                        old_keys[start:end],
                        new_keys[start:end],
                    )
                )

            for a in ligand.atoms:
                a.name = old_keys[start].name + "." + a.name
                a.add_tag("ligand")
            start = end

        for atom in self.atoms:
            if atom.connected & set(old_ligand.atoms):
                atom.connected = atom.connected - set(old_ligand.atoms)

        # remove extraneous centers, i.e. from ferrocene ligands
        for rc in remove_centers:
            self.center.remove(rc)

        # add new
        for ligand in ligands:
            self.components += [ligand]
        rv = ligands

        self.rebuild()
        # rotate monodentate to relieve clashing
        if minimize:
            for ligand in ligands:
                if len(ligand.key_atoms) == 1:
                    targets = ligand.atoms
                    key = ligand.key_atoms[0]
                    if self.center:
                        start = self.COM(self.center)
                        end = key.coords
                    else:
                        start = key.coords
                        end = self.COM(key.connected)
                    axis = end - start
                    self.minimize_torsion(targets, axis, center=key, increment=10)

        self.remove_clash()
        if minimize:
            targets = []
            for lig in ligands:
                targets.extend(lig.atoms)
            self.minimize(targets=targets)

        self.refresh_ranks()

        return rv

    def remove_clash(self, sub_list=None):
        """
        rotates substituents slightly to reduce steric clashing

        :param list(Atom) sub_list: list of atoms to rotate, defaults to all
        :returns: substituents that could not be relieved
        :rtype: list(Atom)
        """
        def get_clash(sub, scale):
            """
            Returns: np.array(bend_axis) if clash found, False otherwise
            """

            clashing = []
            D = distance_matrix(self.coords, sub.coords)
            for i, atom in enumerate(self.atoms):
                if atom in sub.atoms or atom == sub.end:
                    continue
                threshold = atom._radii
                for j, sub_atom in enumerate(sub.atoms):
                    threshold += sub_atom._radii
                    threshold *= scale
                    dist = D[i, j]
                    if dist < threshold or dist < 0.8:
                        clashing += [(atom, threshold - dist)]
            if not clashing:
                return False
            rot_axis = sub.atoms[0].bond(sub.end)
            vector = np.array([0, 0, 0], dtype=float)
            for a, w in clashing:
                vector += a.bond(sub.end) * w
            bend_axis = np.cross(rot_axis, vector)
            return bend_axis

        bad_subs = []  # substituents for which releif not found
        # bend_angles = [8, -16, 32, -48, 68, -88]
        # bend_back = np.deg2rad(20)
        bend_angles = [8, 8, 8, 5, 5, 5]
        bend_back = []
        rot_angles = [8, -16, 32, -48]
        rot_back = np.deg2rad(16)
        scale = 0.75  # for scaling distance threshold

        if sub_list is None:
            sub_list = sorted(self.get_substituents())
            try_twice = True
        else:
            scale = 0.65
            sub_list = sorted(sub_list, reverse=True)
            try_twice = False

        for i, b in enumerate(bend_angles):
            bend_angles[i] = -np.deg2rad(b)
        for i, r in enumerate(rot_angles):
            rot_angles[i] = np.deg2rad(r)

        for sub in sub_list:
            b, r = 0, 0  # bend_angle, rot_angle index counters
            bend_axis = get_clash(sub, scale)
            if bend_axis is False:
                continue
            else:
                # try just rotating first
                while r < len(rot_angles):
                    # try rotating
                    if r < len(rot_angles):
                        sub.sub_rotate(rot_angles[r])
                        r += 1
                    if get_clash(sub, scale) is False:
                        break
                else:
                    sub.sub_rotate(rot_back)
                    r = 0
            bend_axis = get_clash(sub, scale)
            while b < len(bend_angles) and bend_axis is not False:
                bend_back += [bend_axis]
                # try bending
                if b < len(bend_angles):
                    sub.rotate(bend_axis, bend_angles[b], center=sub.end)
                    b += 1
                bend_axis = get_clash(sub, scale)
                if bend_axis is False:
                    break
                while r < len(rot_angles):
                    # try rotating
                    if r < len(rot_angles):
                        sub.sub_rotate(rot_angles[r])
                        r += 1
                    if get_clash(sub, scale) is False:
                        break
                else:
                    sub.sub_rotate(rot_back)
                    r = 0
            else:
                # bend back to original if cannot automatically remove
                # the clash, add to bad_sub list
                bend_axis = get_clash(sub, scale)
                if bend_axis is False:
                    break
                for bend_axis in bend_back:
                    sub.rotate(bend_axis, -bend_angles[0], center=sub.end)
                bad_subs += [sub]

        # try a second time just in case other subs moved out of the way enough
        # for the first subs encountered to work now
        if try_twice and len(bad_subs) > 0:
            bad_subs = self.remove_clash(bad_subs)
        return bad_subs

    def minimize(self, targets=None, increment=5):
        """
        Rotates substituents in each component to minimize LJ_energy.
        Different from Component.minimize_sub_torsion() in that it minimizes
        with respect to the entire catalyst instead of just the component
        """
        substituents = {}
        if targets is not None:
            targets = self.find(targets)
        
        for sub in self.get_substituents(for_confs=True):
            if len(sub.atoms) < 2:
                continue
            if targets and not any(a in targets for a in sub.atoms):
                continue
            try:
                substituents[len(sub.atoms)] += [sub]
            except KeyError:
                substituents[len(sub.atoms)] = [sub]

        # minimize torsion for each substituent
        # smallest to largest
        for k in sorted(substituents.keys()):
            for sub in substituents[k]:
                axis = sub.atoms[0].bond(sub.end)
                center = sub.end
                self.minimize_torsion(sub.atoms, axis, center, increment=increment)

    def next_conformer(self, conf_spec, skip_spec={}):
        """
        Generates the next possible conformer

        :param dict conf_spec: {sub_start_number: conf_number}
        :param dict skip_spec: {sub_start_number: [skip_numbers]}


        :returns:
            conf_spec if there are still more conformers
            {} if there are no more conformers to generate
        """
        for start, conf_num in sorted(conf_spec.items()):
            sub = self.find_substituent(start)
            # skip conformer if signalled it's a repeat
            skip = skip_spec.get(start, [])
            if skip == "all" or conf_num == 0 or conf_num in skip:
                if conf_num == sub.conf_num:
                    conf_spec[start] = 1
                else:
                    conf_spec[start] += 1
                continue
            # reset conf if we hit max conf #
            if conf_num == sub.conf_num:
                sub.sub_rotate()
                conf_spec[start] = 1
                continue
            # perform rotation
            sub.sub_rotate()
            conf_spec[start] += 1
            self.remove_clash()
            # continue if the same as cf1
            angle = int(np.rad2deg((conf_spec[start] - 1) * sub.conf_angle))
            if angle != 360 and angle != 0:
                return conf_spec
            else:
                continue
        else:
            # we are done now
            return {}

    def oniom_layer(self, layer = "", low_layer="", as_object=False):
        """
        returns atoms for the specified layer and adds link atoms to satisfy valence
        
        :param str layer: ONIOM layer (H, M, L)
        :param str low_layer: label for low layer, defaults to L
        :param bool as_object:
        
            * True - return Geometry
            * False - return list(Atom)

        :rtype: list(Atom)
        """
        frag=[]
        #self.sub_links() TODO figure out if this function cna be useful here
        if layer not in ['H', 'L', 'M']:
            raise ValueError("Error in layer request")
        if any((layer == "H", layer == "M")) and low_layer=="":
            low_layer = "L"
        comment_info = self.parse_comment()
        if as_object and layer != "L":
            self.add_links(high_layer = layer, low_layer=low_layer)
        for a in self.atoms:
            if isinstance(a, OniomAtom) and a.layer==layer:
                frag.append(a)
            elif not isinstance (a, OniomAtom):
                raise TypeError("Atom does not have property 'layer'")
 
        if as_object:
            #need to write function to write a comment based on tags
            frag = Geometry(structure=frag)
        return frag

    def add_links(self, high_layer="", low_layer=""):
        """
        adds link atom hydrogens to molecular structure (useful when separating out a layer as a fragment)

        :param str high_layer: higher ONIOM layer
        :param str low_layer: lower ONIOM layer
        :returns: edited Geometry with link atoms as part of molecular structure
        :rtype: Geometry
        """
        # TODO determine what else should be added to self such as updated connectivity info
        adjust=[]
        tmp=[]
        for a in self.atoms:
            found_LAH = False
            connection = None
            found_LAC = False
            if a.link_info != {} and any((a.layer == low_layer, a.layer == "")):
                #print(a)
                c = OniomAtom(element="H", layer=high_layer, coords=a.coords, charge=a.charge, atomtype=a.atomtype)
                c.link_info["host"] = a
                c.connected = set([])
                found_LAH = True
                #print(a.link_info["connected"])
                if "connected" in a.link_info.keys() and self.atoms[a.link_info["connected"]-1].layer == high_layer:
                    connection = self.atoms[a.link_info["connected"]-1]
                    found_LAC = True
                    connection.add_bond_to(c)
                    print("bond added between ", connection, c)
                    #print(connection)
                elif "connected" not in a.link_info.keys():
                    for atom in a.connected:
                        if atom.layer == high_layer:
                            connection = atom
                            connection.add_bond_to(c)
                            found_LAC = True
                            break
                if found_LAH and found_LAC:
                    if "atomtype" in a.link_info.keys():
                        c.atomtype = a.link_info["atomtype"]
                    else:
                        if connection.atomtype != "":
                            if connection.element == "C":
                                c.atomtype = "HC"
                            if connection.element == "N":
                                c.atomtype = "HN"
                            else:
                                c.atomtype = "H"
                        else:
                            c.atomtype = "" 
                    if "charge" in a.link_info.keys():
                        c.charge = float(a.link_info["charge"])
                    else:
                        if a.charge != None:
                            c.charge = float(a.charge)
                    c._set_radii()
                    adjust.append([connection, c])
                    tmp.append(c)
                elif found_LAH and not found_LAC:
                    self.LOG.warning("atom %s identified as Link atom Host but no link atom connection found" % a.name)
        self = self + tmp
    #        print(adjust)
#        for pair in adjust:
#            print(pair[0],pair[1])
#            print(pair[0].dist(pair[1]))
#            self.change_distance(pair[0], pair[1], dist="1.00", fix=1, as_group=False)
#            print(pair[0].dist(pair[1]))
        return self

    def sub_link_hosts(self):
        """remove link atom hosts from a molecular structure

        :return: the Geometry with link atom hosts removed from the list of atoms in the structure
        :rtype: Geometry
        """
        # TODO determine what else the function should remove from self such as connectivity info
        tmp = []
        for a in self.atoms:
            if a.link_info and "host" in a.link_info.keys():
                tmp.append(a)
            else:
                pass
        self = self - tmp
        return self

    def sub_links(self):
        """remove link atoms from a molecular structure

        :return: the Geometry with link atoms removed from the list of atoms in the structure
        :rtype: _type_
        """
        # TODO determine what else the function should remove from self such as connectivity info
        tmp = []
        for a in self.atoms:
            if a.link_info and "link" in a.link_info.keys():
                tmp.append(a.link_info["link"])
            else:
                pass
        print(tmp)
        self = self - tmp
        return self

    def fix_links(self):
        #connectivity = self.get_connectivity()
        #atoms = enumerate(self.atoms)
        if not hasattr(self.atoms[0], "index"):
            for i, atom in enumerate(self.atoms):
                atom.index = i
        for a in self.atoms:
            if a.link_info != None and "connected" in a.link_info.keys():
                if a.is_connected(self.atoms[a.link_info["connected"]-1]) == False:
                    self.atoms[a.link_info["connected"]-1].link_info = {}
                    self.atoms[a.index].link_info = {}
                elif a.is_connected(self.atoms[a.link_info["connected"]-1]) and a.layer == self.atoms[a.link_info["connected"]-1].layer:
                    self.atoms[a.link_info["connected"]-1].link_info = {}
                    self.atoms[a.index].link_info = {}
 
            for c in a.connected:
                if a.layer != c.layer:
                    if a > c:
                        self.atoms[c.index].link_info["connected"] = a.index+1
                        self.atoms[c.index].link_info["element"] = "H"
                    elif c > a:
                        self.atoms[a.index].link_info["connected"] = c.index+1
                        self.atoms[a.index].link_info["element"] = "H"

        return

    #def write_comment(self):
    #    for atom in self.atoms:
    #        if "constraint" in str(atom.tags):
    #            do something coming soon



    def make_conformer(self, conf_spec):
        """
        rotates substituents according to the specified conformer specification
        
        :param dict conf_spec: 
            {sub_start_number: (conf_number, [skip_numbers])}

        :returns:
            conf_spec, True if conformer generated (allowed by conf_spec),
            conf_spec, False if not allowed or invalid

        """
        original = self.copy()
        for start, conf_num in conf_spec.items():
            current, skip = conf_spec[start]
            # skip if flagged a repeat
            if conf_num in skip or skip == "all":
                self = original
                return conf_spec, False
            sub = self.find_substituent(start)
            # validate conf_spec
            if conf_num > sub.conf_num:
                self = original
                self.LOG.warning(
                    "Bad conformer number given: {} {} > {}".format(
                        sub.name, conf_num, sub.conf_num
                    )
                )
                return conf_spec, False
            if conf_num > current:
                n_rot = conf_num - current - 1
                for _ in range(n_rot):
                    conf_spec[start][0] += 1
                    sub.rotate()
            elif conf_num < current:
                n_rot = current - conf_num - 1
                for _ in range(n_rot):
                    conf_spec[start][0] -= 1
                    sub.rotate(reverse=True)
        return conf_spec, True

    def get_aromatic_atoms(self, return_rings=False, return_h=False):
        """
        Finds atoms within aromatic rings in a molecule

        :param bool return_rings: returns full aromatic rings if true, default False
        :param bool return_h: includes hydrogens in return if true, default False
        :returns:
        
            * List(Atom) of atoms in aromatic rings, including hydrogens if return_h is True
            * Charge (int) (also could be number of atoms in aromatic rings not participating in aromaticity) of rings
                number of rings (int) that are fused (napthalene would be 2)
            * List of aromatic rings if return_rings is True

        """

        def is_aromatic(num):
            """returns true if the number follows the huckel rule of 4n + 2"""
            return (int(num) - 2) % 4 == 0

        contribution = {
            "bent 2 planar": {'C': 1, 'S': 1, 'O': 1, 'N': 1, 'P': 1},
            "bent 2 tetrahedral": {'S': 2, 'O': 2, 'C': 0},
            "trigonal planar": {'C': 1, 'N': 2, 'P': 2, 'B': 0},
            "bent 3 tetrahedral": {'N': 2},
        }

        aromatic_elements = ["B", "C", "N", "O", "P", "S"]

        matching_atoms = []
        unchecked_atoms = list(self.atoms)
        fused = 0
        charge=0
        rings = []
        for atom in unchecked_atoms:
            if not any(atom.element == aromatic_element for aromatic_element in aromatic_elements):
                continue
            vsepr = atom.get_vsepr()[0]
            fusedRing = False
            if any(vsepr == ring_vsepr for ring_vsepr in ['trigonal planar', 'bent 2 planar', 'bent 2 tetrahedral']):
                for i, a1 in enumerate(atom.connected):
                    if not any(a1.element == aromatic_element for aromatic_element in aromatic_elements):
                        continue
                    for a2 in list(atom.connected)[:i]:
                        if not any(a2.element == aromatic_element for aromatic_element in aromatic_elements):
                            continue
                        try:
                            path = self.shortest_path(a1, a2, avoid=atom)
                        except LookupError:
                            continue

                        ring = path
                        huckel_num = 0
                        try:
                            huckel_num += contribution[vsepr][atom.element]
                        except IndexError:
                            continue
                        ring.append(atom)
                        #rings.append(ring)
                        for checked_atom in path:
                            try:
                                unchecked_atoms.remove(checked_atom)
                            except ValueError:
                                fusedRing=True
                        for ring_atom in ring:
                            if ring_atom is atom:
                                continue
                            try:
                                huckel_num += contribution[ring_atom.get_vsepr()[0]][ring_atom.element]
                            except LookupError:
                                huckel_num = 0
                                break
                        if (huckel_num % 2) != 0:
                            n_counter = 0
                            for ring_atom in ring:
                                if ring_atom.element == 'N': n_counter += 1
                            if n_counter == 2: huckel_num -= 2
                            else: huckel_num -= 1
                            charge += 1
                        if is_aromatic(huckel_num) == True:
                            for match in ring:
                                if match not in matching_atoms:
                                    matching_atoms.append(match)
                                if return_h == True:
                                    for connected in match.connected:
                                        if connected.element == 'H' and connected not in ring: ring.append(connected)
                            rings.append(ring)
            if fusedRing == True:
                fused+=1
        if return_rings == True:
            return matching_atoms, charge, fused, rings
        else: 
            return matching_atoms, charge, fused

    def get_gaff_geom(self):
        """:returns: geometry comprised of OniomAtoms with GAFF atomtypes from OfType finder"""
        if not isinstance(self.atoms[0], OniomAtom):
            geom = self.make_oniom()
        else:
            geom = self
        typelist = []
        elementlist = []
        atoms = geom.atoms
        for i, atom in enumerate(atoms):
            atom.index = i
            if atom.element not in elementlist: elementlist.append(atom.element)
        for element in elementlist:
            if element == 'C': typelist = typelist + ['c','c1','c2','c3','ca']
            if element == 'O': typelist = typelist + ['o','oh','os','ow']
            if element == 'N': typelist = typelist + ['n','n1','n2','n3','n4','na','nh','no']
            if element == 'S': typelist = typelist + ['s2','sh','ss','s4','s6']
            if element == 'H': typelist = typelist + ['hc','ha','hn','ho','hs','hp','hw']
            if element == 'P': typelist = typelist + ['p2','p3','p4','p5']
            if element in {'Br', 'Cl', 'F', 'I'}: typelist.append(element)
        oniomatoms = [0]*len(atoms)
        untyped_atoms = list(atoms)
        for atomtype in typelist:
            matches = OfType(atomtype).get_matching_atoms(atoms,geom)
            for match in matches:
                untyped_atoms.remove(match)
#                if not isinstance(match, OniomAtom):
#                    oniomatom = OniomAtom(atom=match, atomtype=atomtype)
#                    oniomatom.index = match.index
#                    oniomatoms[match.index] = oniomatom
#                else:
                match.atomtype = atomtype
                oniomatoms[match.index] = match
        for atom in untyped_atoms:
#            if not isinstance(atom, OniomAtom):
#                oniomatom = OniomAtom(atom=atom, atomtype=atom.element)
#                oniomatom.index = atom.index
#                oniomatoms[atom.index] = oniomatom
#            else:
            atom.atomtype = atom.element
            oniomatoms[atom.index] = atom

        typed_geom = Geometry(structure=oniomatoms, name = self.name, comment = self.comment, components = self.components)
        return typed_geom
#        return

    def define_layer(self, layer, reference, distance, bond_based=False, expand=True, force=False, res_based=False):
        """
        define an ONIOM layer based on reference information
        reference can be list(Atom), list(list(float)), list(float), or str representing a layer (H, M, L, !H, etc)
        if defining a 3 layer job, start at High layer (reaction center)

        :param str layer: new ONIOM layer to be defined
        :param reference: atom, atoms, or layer to be used as reference point(s) for beginning of layer definition
        :type reference: Atom|list(Atom)|list(list(float(coords)))|list(float(coords))|str(layer)
        :param float distance: distance from reference point to boundary of new layer
        :param bool bond_based: will treat distance as number of bonds from reference if True, default False
        :param bool expand: determines whether to expand layer or contract if new layer boundary cuts across pi or polar bond(s), default True
        :param bool force: determines whether to force new layer boundary to cut across pi or polar bond(s), default False
        :param bool res_based: new layer will include entire amino acid residue if new layer boundary cuts across intra-residue bonds if True, default False
        """

        if not isinstance(self.atoms[0], OniomAtom):
            self = self.make_oniom()

        if not hasattr(self.atoms[0], "index"):
            for i, atom in enumerate(self.atoms):
                atom.index = i

        avoid = set([])
        layer_atoms = set([])
        new_atoms = []
        constraints = self.get_constraints()
        for key, val in constraints:
            a = WithinBondsOf(self.atoms[key[0]],3).get_matching_atoms(self.atoms)
            b =  WithinBondsOf(self.atoms[key[1]],3).get_matching_atoms(self.atoms)
            for atom in a+b:
                avoid.add(atom)

        def in_ring(a1, a2):
            #determine if the bond between two atoms is in a ring
            for connected in a1.connected:
                if connected == a2 or connected.element=="H":
                    continue
                else:
                    try:
                        path = self.shortest_path(a2, connected, avoid=a1)
                        return True
                    except LookupError:
                        continue
            return False

        dummy = OniomAtom(element="H", coords = np.array((0,0,0)), layer = layer)

        if isinstance(reference, list):
            if isinstance(reference[0], float) or isinstance(reference[0], int):
                new_atoms = WithinRadiusFromPoint(reference, distance).get_matching_atoms(self.atoms)
            elif isinstance(reference[0], list):
                if isinstance(reference[0][0], float):
                    for point in reference:
                        new_atoms += WithinRadiusFromPoint(point, distance).get_matching_atoms(self.atoms)
            elif isinstance(reference[0], Atom):
                for atom in reference:
                    new_atoms.append(atom)
                    if bond_based == False:
                        new_atoms += WithinRadiusFromAtom(atom,distance).get_matching_atoms(self.atoms)
                    elif bond_based == True:
                        new_atoms += WithinBondsOf(atom, distance).get_matching_atoms(self.atoms)
        elif isinstance(reference, Atom):
            new_atoms.append(reference)
            if bond_based == False:
                new_atoms += WithinRadiusFromAtom(reference, distance).get_matching_atoms(self.atoms)
            elif bond_based == True:
                new_atoms += WithinBondsOf(reference,distance).get_matching_atoms(self.atoms)

        elif isinstance(reference, str):
            if reference.startswith("!") and reference[1].upper() in ("H", "M", "L"):
                not_layer = reference[1].upper()
                for atom in self.atoms:
                    if atom.layer != not_layer and not atom > dummy:
                        layer_atoms.add(atom)
                        atom.layer = layer.upper()
                #fix link atom stuff
                return
            elif reference.upper() in ("H", "M", "L"):
                ref_atoms = []
                for atom in self.atoms:
                    if atom.layer == reference.upper():
                        ref_atoms.append(atom)
                for atom in ref_atoms:
                    if bond_based == False:
                        new_atoms += WithinRadiusFromAtom(atom,distance).get_matching_atoms(self.atoms)
                    elif bond_based == True:
                        new_atoms += WithinBondsOf(atom, distance).get_matching_atoms(self.atoms)

            elif reference.upper() == "OTHER":
                for atom in self.atoms:
                    if atom.layer == "":
                        atom.layer = layer.upper()
                #fix link atom stuff
                return

        for new_atom in new_atoms:
            if dummy > new_atom:
                layer_atoms.add(new_atom)
        boundary_atoms = set([])
        unchecked_atoms = layer_atoms
        for atom in unchecked_atoms:
            for connected in atom.connected:
                if connected in layer_atoms:
                    pass
                else:
                    boundary_atoms.add(atom)
                    break
        boundary_atoms = [*boundary_atoms, ]
        if res_based == True:
            new_layer_atoms = set([])
            new_boundary_atoms = []
            for boundary_atom in boundary_atoms:
                if boundary_atom in avoid:
                    self.LOG.warning("Layer boundary at atom %s is too close to bond order change" % boundary_atom.name)
                for connected in boundary_atom.connected:
                    if connected.res == "" or boundary_atom.res == "":
                        raise AttributeError("residues not defined for atoms in molecule, set res_based to False")
                    elif connected.res == boundary_atom.res and connected not in layer_atoms:
                        new_layer_atoms.add(connected)
                        new_boundary_atoms.append(connected)
                    elif connected.res != boundary_atom.res and connected not in layer_atoms:
                        if connected > dummy:
                            boundary_atom.link_info["element"] = "H"
                            boundary_atom.link_info["connected"] = connected.index + 1
                        elif dummy > connected: 
                            connected.link_info["element"] = "H"
                            connected.link_info["connected"]= boundary_atom.index + 1
                boundary_atoms += new_boundary_atoms
                new_boundary_atoms = []
                layer_atoms.update(new_layer_atoms)
                new_layer_atoms = set([])

        elif res_based == False:
            for boundary_atom in boundary_atoms:
                if boundary_atom in avoid:
                    self.LOG.warning("Layer boundary at atom %s may be too close to bond order change" % boundary_atom.name)
                new_layer_atoms = []
                new_boundary_atoms = []
                if boundary_atom.element == "H":
                    if force==True:
                        for connected in boundary_atom.connected:
                            if hasattr(connected, "layer"):
                                if connected > dummy:
                                    boundary_atom.link_info["element"] = "H"
                                    boundary_atom.link_info["connected"] = connected.index + 1
                                elif dummy > connected:
                                    connected.link_info["element"] = "H"
                                    connected.link_info["connected"]= boundary_atom.index + 1
                            else:
                                connected.link_info["element"] = "H"
                                connected.link_info["connected"]= boundary_atom.index + 1
                        self.LOG.warning("Layer boundary across bond between atom %s and hydrogen atom %s" % connected.name % boundary_atom.name)
                    else:
                        boundary_atoms.remove(boundary_atom)
                        layer_atoms.remove(boundary_atom)
                else:
                    for connected in boundary_atom.connected:
                        if connected not in layer_atoms:
                            if connected.element == "H" and all((expand == True, force == False)):
                                new_layer_atoms += [connected]
                            elif connected.element == "H" and any((expand == False, force == True)):
                                if hasattr(connected, "layer"):
                                    if connected > dummy:
                                        boundary_atom.link_info["element"] = "H"
                                        boundary_atom.link_info["connected"] = connected.index + 1
                                    else:
                                        connected.link_info["element"] = "H"
                                        connected.link_info["connected"]= boundary_atom.index + 1
                                else:
                                    connected.link_info["element"] = "H"
                                    connected.link_info["connected"]= boundary_atom.index + 1
                                self.LOG.warning("Atom %s set as link atom host is hydrogen atom" % connected.name)
                            elif connected.element == "C" and boundary_atom.element == "C":
                                bond_order = BondOrder.get(connected, boundary_atom)
                                if bond_order > 1:
                                    if any((expand==True, expand==False)) and force==True:
                                        if hasattr(connected, "layer"):
                                            if connected > dummy:
                                                boundary_atom.link_info["element"] = "H"
                                                boundary_atom.link_info["connected"] = connected.index + 1
                                            else:
                                                connected.link_info["element"] = "H"
                                                connected.link_info["connected"]= boundary_atom.index + 1
                                        else:
                                            connected.link_info["element"] = "H"
                                            connected.link_info["connected"]= boundary_atom.index + 1
                                        self.LOG.warning("Layer boundary cuts across bond of order > 1 between atoms %s and %s" % boundary_atom.name % connected.name)
                                    elif expand==True and force==False:
                                        new_boundary_atoms += [connected]
                                        new_layer_atoms += [connected]
                                    elif expand == False and force==False:
                                        layer_atoms.remove(boundary_atom)
                                        for connected in boundary_atom.connected:
                                            if connected.element == "H" and connected in layer_atoms:
                                                layer_atoms.remove(connected)
                                            if connected in layer_atoms and connected not in boundary_atoms and connected.element != "H":
                                                boundary_atoms += [connected]
                                        new_layer_atoms = []
                                        new_boundary_atoms = []
                                        break
                                elif bond_order == 1:
                                    if in_ring(connected, boundary_atom) and force==True:
                                        if hasattr(connected, "layer"):
                                            if connected > dummy:
                                                boundary_atom.link_info["element"] = "H"
                                                boundary_atom.link_info["connected"] = connected.index + 1
                                            else:
                                                connected.link_info["element"] = "H"
                                                connected.link_info["connected"]= boundary_atom.index + 1
                                        else:
                                            connected.link_info["element"] = "H"
                                            connected.link_info["connected"]= boundary_atom.index + 1
                                        self.LOG.warning("Layer boundary cuts across bond in a ring between atoms %s and %s" % boundary_atom.name % connected.name)
                                    elif in_ring(connected, boundary_atom) and force==False:
                                        boundary_atoms.remove(boundary_atom)
                                        if expand == False:
                                            layer_atoms.remove(boundary_atom)
                                            for connected in boundary_atom.connected:
                                                if connected in layer_atoms and connected not in boundary_atoms and connected.element != "H":
                                                    boundary_atoms.append(connected)
                                                if connected in layer_atoms and connected.element == "H":
                                                    layer_atoms.remove(connected)
                                            new_layer_atoms = []
                                            new_boundary_atoms = []
                                            break
                                        elif expand == True:
                                            new_layer_atoms += [connected]
                                            new_boundary_atoms += [connected]
                                    elif not in_ring(connected, boundary_atom):
                                        if hasattr(connected, "layer"):
                                            if connected > dummy:
                                                boundary_atom.link_info["element"] = "H"
                                                boundary_atom.link_info["connected"] = connected.index + 1
                                            else:
                                                connected.link_info["element"] = "H"
                                                connected.link_info["connected"]= boundary_atom.index + 1
                                        else:
                                            connected.link_info["element"] = "H"
                                            connected.link_info["connected"]= boundary_atom.index + 1
                            elif connected.element != "H" and connected.element != boundary_atom.element:
                                if force == True:
                                    if hasattr(connected, "layer"):
                                        if connected > dummy:
                                            boundary_atom.link_info["element"] = "H"
                                            boundary_atom.link_info["connected"] = connected.index + 1
                                        else:
                                            connected.link_info["element"] = "H"
                                            connected.link_info["connected"]= boundary_atom.index + 1
                                    else:
                                        connected.link_info["element"] = "H"
                                        connected.link_info["connected"]= boundary_atom.index + 1
                                    if boundary_atom.element == "C":
                                        self.LOG.warning("Layer boundary cuts between bond between carbon atom %s and heteroatom %s" % boundary_atom.name % connected.name)
                                    elif connected.element == "C":
                                        self.LOG.warning("Layer boundary cuts between bond between carbon atom %s and heteroatom %s" % connected.name % boundary_atom.name)
                                    elif connected.element != "C" and boundary_atom.element != "C":
                                        self.LOG.warning("Layer boundary cuts between bond between heteroatom %s and heteroatom %s" % connected.name % boundary_atom.name)
                                elif force == False and expand == True:
                                    num_h = 0
                                    hydrogens = []
                                    for surrounding in connected.connected:
                                        if surrounding.element == "H":
                                            num_h += 1
                                            hydrogens += [surrounding]
                                    new_layer_atoms += [connected]
                                    new_layer_atoms += hydrogens
                                    if num_h +1 != len(connected.connected):
                                        new_boundary_atoms += [connected]
                                elif force == False and expand == False:
                                    layer_atoms.remove(boundary_atom)
                                    for connected in boundary_atom.connected:
                                        if connected.element == "H" and connected in layer_atoms:
                                            layer_atoms.remove(connected)
                                        if connected.element != "H" and connected in layer_atoms and connected not in boundary_atoms:
                                            boundary_atoms.append(connected)
                                    new_layer_atoms = []
                                    new_boundary_atoms = []
                                    break
                boundary_atoms+=new_boundary_atoms
                #print(new_boundary_atoms)
                layer_atoms.update(new_layer_atoms)

        #if res_based==True:
            #new_geom=Geometry(layer_atoms, refresh_connected=True)
        #    terminal_atoms = ["H", "F", "Cl", "Br", "I"]
            #unchecked_atoms = new_geom.atoms
        #    unchecked_atoms = layer_atoms
        #    molecules = []
        #    for atom in unchecked_atoms:
        #        connected_list = [atm for atm in atom.connected]
        #        molecule = []
        #        molecule.append(atom)
        #        complete = False
 #               while complete == False:
 #                   new_connected_list = []
 #                   for a in connected_list:
 #                       if a not in molecule and a in unchecked_atoms:
 #                           molecule.append(a)
 #                           unchecked_atoms.remove(a)
 #                           if a.element not in terminal_atoms:
 #                               for connected in a.connected:
 #                                   if connected not in molecule and connected in unchecked_atoms:
 #                                       new_connected_list += [connected]
 #                                       molecule.append(connected)
 #                                       unchecked_atoms.remove(connected)
 #                   if new_connected_list == []:
 #                       complete = True
 #                       molecules.append(molecule)
 #           for m in molecules:
 #               if len(m)<10:
 #                   if m[0].res != "":
 #                       self.LOG.warning("Incomplete residue at atoms " + str(m[0].name))

        #layer_atoms = set(layer_atoms)
        #for layer_atom in layer_atoms:
        for atom in self.atoms:
            if atom in layer_atoms:
                atom.layer = layer.upper()
            elif atom not in layer_atoms and atom.layer == layer.upper():
                atom.layer = ""
                atom.link_info = {}

    def change_chirality(self, target):
        """
        change chirality of the target atom

        :param Atom target: atom to be changed, should be a chiral
            center that is not a bridgehead of a fused ring,
            though spiro centers are allowed

        :returns: changed chiral center
        :rtype: list(Atom)
        """
        # find two fragments
        # rotate those about the vector that bisects the angle between them
        # this effectively changes the chirality
        target = self.find_exact(target)[0]
        fragments = []
        for a in target.connected:
            frag = self.get_fragment(
                a, target,
            )
            if sum(int(target in frag_atom.connected) for frag_atom in frag) == 1:
                fragments.append([atom.copy() for atom in frag])
            if len(fragments) == 2:
                break
        
        # if there are not two fragments not in a ring,
        # this is a spiro center
        # find a spiro ring and rotate that
        a2 = None
        if len(fragments) < 2:
            for a1 in target.connected:
                targets = self.get_fragment(
                    a1, stop=target,
                )
                a2 = [a for a in targets if a in target.connected and a is not a1]
                if a2:
                    a2 = a2[0]
                    break
            if not a2:
                raise RuntimeError(
                    "could not find suitable groups to swap on %s" % target
                )
            v1 = target.bond(a1)
            v1 /= np.linalg.norm(v1)
            v2 = target.bond(a2)
            v2 /= np.linalg.norm(v2)
            rv = v1 + v2
        
            self.rotate(
                rv, angle=np.pi, center=target,
                targets=targets,
            )
        else:
            v1 = target.bond(fragments[0][0])
            v1 /= np.linalg.norm(v1)
            v2 = target.bond(fragments[1][0])
            v2 /= np.linalg.norm(v2)
            rv = v1 + v2
        
            targets = [atom.name for atom in fragments[0]]
            targets.extend([atom.name for atom in fragments[1]])
        
            self.rotate(
                rv, angle=np.pi, center=target,
                targets=targets,
            )
        return targets

    def detect_solvent(self, solvent):
        """
        detects solvent based on either an input solvent xyz, solvent in solvent library, or input SMILES

        :param str solvent: solvent to be detected
        :returns: solvent if able to be found
        :rtype: list(Geometry)
        """

        AARON_LIBS = os.path.join(AARONLIB, "Solvents")
        BUILTIN = os.path.join(AARONTOOLS, "Solvents")

        try:
            solv = self.get_solvent(solvent)
        except LookupError:
            try:
                solv = Geometry(solvent)
            except NotImplementedError:
                solv = Geometry.from_string(solvent)

        mol_list = []
        checked_atoms = set()
        mol_list = [
            Geometry(m, refresh_connected=False) for m in self.get_monomers()
            if len(m) == len(solv.atoms)
        ]

        solv_ndx = {atom: i for i, atom in enumerate(solv.atoms)}
        solv_connectivity = []
        for atom in solv.atoms:
            solv_connectivity.append([])
            for a in atom.connected:
                solv_connectivity[-1].append(solv_ndx[a])
                solv_connectivity[-1] = sorted(solv_connectivity[-1])

        vetted_mols = []

        solvent_elements = sorted([a.element for a in solv.atoms])
        solvent_ranks = solv.canonical_rank(
            update=False, break_ties=False, invariant=False
        )
        sorted_solvent_atoms = sorted(
            [x for _, x in sorted(
                zip(solvent_ranks, solv.atoms), key=lambda pair: pair[0])
            ]
        )
        for candidate in mol_list:
            candidate_elements = sorted([a.element for a in candidate.atoms])
            if not all([solvent_elements[i] == candidate_elements[i] for i in range(0, len(solv.atoms))]):
                continue
            candidate_ranks = candidate.canonical_rank(
                update=False, break_ties=False, invariant=False
            )
            sorted_candidate_atoms = sorted(
                [x for _, x in sorted(
                    zip(candidate_ranks, candidate.atoms), key=lambda pair: pair[0])
                ]
            )
            for a, b in zip(sorted_solvent_atoms, sorted_candidate_atoms):
                if a.element != b.element:
                    break
                
                if len(a.connected) != len(b.connected):
                    break
                
                failed = False
                for j, k in zip(
                    sorted([aa.element for aa in a.connected]),
                    sorted([bb.element for bb in b.connected]),
                ):
                    if j != k:
                        failed = True
                        break
                if failed:
                    break
            else:
                vetted_mols.append(candidate)

        return vetted_mols

    @classmethod
    def from_pdb(cls, structure, name=""):
        """Returns a list of Geometry objects from pdb files with multiple structural poses

        :param structure: molecular structure information from a pdb file
        :type structure: FileReader|str
        :param name: name to be assigned to molecular structure, defaults to ""
        :type name: str, optional
        :return: Geometry objects for all poses of structure in pdb file
        :rtype: list(Geometry)
        """
        if isinstance(structure, FileReader):
            from_file = structure
        elif isinstance(structure, str):
            from_file = FileReader(structure)
        if name == "":
            base_name = from_file.name
            if base_name =="":
                base_name = cls.name
        else:
            base_name = name
        geom_list=[]
        struct_list = {base_name + "_" + "model_1":from_file.atoms}
        for key in from_file.other.keys():
            if "model" in key:
                struct_list[base_name + "_" + key] = from_file.other[key]
        for struct_name, atoms in struct_list:
            geom = cls(name=struct_name, structure=atoms,comment=cls.comment)
            geom_list.append(geom)
        return geom_list

    def update_charges(self, charges=""):
        """
        update the atomic partial charges.
        accepts Tuple or List(charges), Dict{atom name: charge}

        :param tuple(charges)|list(charges)|dict(charges) charges: new charges to update to
        """
        if not any((isinstance(charges, tuple), isinstance(charges, list), isinstance(charges, dict))):
            raise ValueError("charges must be in tuple, list, or dict")
        elif isinstance(charges, dict):
            for name, charge in charges:
                if not isinstance(name, str):
                    name = str(name)
                for atom in self.atoms:
                    if atom.name == name:
                        atom.charge = charge
        elif isinstance(charges, list) or isinstance(charges, tuple):
            for atom, charge in zip(self.atoms, charges):
                atom.charge = charge
        return

    def update_atom_types(self, atom_types):
        """
        update the molecular mechanics atom types.
        accepts Tuple or List(atom types), Dict{atom name: atom type}

        :param tuple(Atom)|list(Atom)|dict(Atom) atom_types: new atom types to update to
        """
        if not any((isinstance(atom_types, tuple), isinstance(atom_types, list), isinstance(atom_types, dict))):
            raise ValueError("atom types must be in tuple, list, or dict")
        elif isinstance(atom_types, dict):
            for name, at in atom_types:
                if not isinstance(name, str):
                    name = str(name)
                for atom in self.atoms:
                    if atom.name == name:
                        atom.atom_type = str(at)
        elif isinstance(atom_types, list) or isinstance(atom_types, tuple):
            for atom, at in zip(self.atoms, atom_types):
                atom.atom_type = at
        return

    #def oniom_fragment(self, reference, distance, bond_based=False, expand=True, force=False)