Skip to content

fix: stale content cleanup — 13 findings + remove stale external reviews#18

Merged
dacervera merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
fix/stale-content-cleanup
Mar 13, 2026
Merged

fix: stale content cleanup — 13 findings + remove stale external reviews#18
dacervera merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
fix/stale-content-cleanup

Conversation

@dacervera

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Summary

Drains the stale content backlog (13 findings, threshold exceeded at 10).

External Reviews Removed

3 frontier model review files deleted — evaluated v0.5.3, product is now at v0.7.2 with materially different capabilities (Tester, golden test set, coverage counts, documentation rubric). EXTERNAL_REVIEWS.md replaced with community invitation template.

Also resolves P-014 (CRITICAL): internal identifiers (DEC references, sprint backlog items) in public review response annotations.

Stale Content Fixed (13 findings)

  • Tester: marked as shipped across SPEC, TUTORIAL, SKILL, RUBRIC_BUILDING_GUIDE (was 'not yet built')
  • Critic counts: updated to 6 shipped across all docs
  • Learning memory: marked shipped (v0.5.3) across IMPLEMENTATION, CONFIG_REFERENCE, TUTORIAL
  • Confidence → coverage: replaced confidence score references with coverage language (v0.6.1)
  • Version headers: updated to v0.7.2 in IMPLEMENTATION, CONFIG_REFERENCE
  • Depth profiles: aligned with critic-status.yaml (quick=2, standard=3+tester, thorough=4+tester)
  • Framework docs: SECURITY_CRITIC_FRAMEWORK and CODE_HYGIENE_FRAMEWORK status checklists updated from v0.5.1
  • Broken links: TESTER_CRITIC_BRIEF cross-refs, INSTALLATION rubrics link

Also Included

  • .clawhubignore added (excludes venv and test data from ClawHub publish)

Validation

  • validate-docs.py: PASS
  • pytest: 879 passed, 6 skipped
  • Boundary scan: clean
  • Quorum documentation rubric (standard depth): PASS

Backlog drain: P-002 through P-015 (13 findings).

Major changes:
- Remove 3 stale frontier model review files (evaluated v0.5.3, now at v0.7.2)
  and replace EXTERNAL_REVIEWS.md with practitioner invitation template.
  Also resolves P-014 boundary leak (internal identifiers in review responses).
- Tester shipped but docs said 'not yet built' (P-002, P-005, P-008, P-010)
- Version/count staleness across SPEC, IMPLEMENTATION, CONFIG_REFERENCE (P-003, P-004, P-007, P-009)
- Framework docs stuck at v0.5.1 status (P-012, P-013)
- Broken cross-references (P-011, P-015)
- Learning memory marked shipped across all docs (was v0.5.3)
- Confidence scores replaced with coverage language (was v0.6.1)
- Added .clawhubignore (excludes venv, test data from ClawHub publish)
@dacervera

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

A remarkable note: First CI scan that quorum returned zero findings, zero false positives.

@dacervera
dacervera merged commit 088626e into main Mar 13, 2026
7 checks passed
@dacervera
dacervera deleted the fix/stale-content-cleanup branch March 13, 2026 01:55
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant