Skip to content

Codex L2 food trucks killed by 600s stream-idle watchdog while blocked on long-running MCP calls — suppression heuristics inapplicable, healthy children orphaned #4202

Description

@Trecek

Problem

Codex L2 food-truck orchestrators are killed by the stream-idle watchdog (run_skill.stream_idle_timeout_ms = 600000 → 600s; defaults.yaml:53, _config_dataclasses.py:106) while legitimately blocked on a long-running MCP tool call — specifically run_skill children (make-plan, implement) that routinely run 30–60+ minutes. The kill orphans the healthy child session, fails the dispatch with fleet_l3_no_result_block, and applies the fail label to the pipeline's issue.

Lineage: #1984 covered the same watchdog killing food trucks waiting on merge queue / CI (staged); this is the codex + in-flight-MCP-call variant, which that fix does not cover.

Observed (2026-07-07, autoskillit 0.10.851, codex-impl-loop attempt 4)

  • Dispatch ca51f8d0 / codex session 019f3c74-3b43-7312-acdd-d5df31a6711c (rollout: ~/.codex/sessions/2026/07/07/rollout-2026-07-07T05-01-18-*.jsonl).
  • Rollout shows a fully healthy L2: 34 events, 5 mcp_tool_call_end (open_kitchen → bootstrap_clone → claim_and_resolve → create_and_publish → run_skill make-plan), last event 12:02:20Z, then silence while awaiting the make-plan child.
  • Dispatcher log: stdout idle for 600.0s — firing IDLE_STALL at 05:39:34, Headless session killed. Envelope: fleet_l3_no_result_block, elapsed 2302s.
  • The make-plan child kept working after the parent was killed (clone file activity continued 30+ minutes past the kill: 2439 files modified in the following hour) — orphaned healthy work.
  • Why claude-code L2s survive identical spells: the stale detector suppresses on ESTABLISHED port-443 evidence ("JSONL silent for 1202s but ESTABLISHED port-443 — suppressing stale kill", observed repeatedly on the same night's claude dispatches). A codex L2 blocked on a local MCP socket has no port-443 connection and channel_b_capable=False (no JSONL side-channel), so no suppression path applies — the stream-idle kill fired with no suppression attempt logged.

Secondary observation

At kill time the codex NDJSON parser dropped item_type=error events (codex_ndjson_unknown_item_type, sealed enum from #3765; also noted on #4200) — kill-adjacent error payloads are invisible to diagnostics, which materially slowed root-causing this failure.

Expected behavior / fix shapes

  1. In-flight MCP call = alive. The MCP server knows when a run_skill (or any long tool call) is executing for a session — that registry is the truthful liveness signal. Suppress stream-idle/idle-stall kills while a tool call is in flight, backend-independently.
  2. Per-backend or per-session-type stream-idle threshold: an L2 food truck is expected to be stdout-silent for the full duration of each child session; its stream-idle floor should be >= run_skill.timeout (7200s), not 600s.
  3. Add error to the sealed codex NDJSON item enum so kill-adjacent error payloads are captured in diagnostics.

Mitigation in use (loop driver)

AUTOSKILLIT_RUN_SKILL__STREAM_IDLE_TIMEOUT_MS=7200000 on the dispatching environment.

References

Additional occurrence: claude-code variant via suppression bound (2026-07-07)

The same defect class also kills claude-code L2s: dispatch 045d509c (remediation of #4204) was killed at 1h30m by "Suppression bounded: stale kill after 2402s consecutive suppression (max_suppression_seconds=1800)" while legitimately blocked on its implement child. The port-443 suppression works but is CAPPED below realistic child-session durations (implement/resolve-failures children routinely run 30-90 min). Fix shape 1 ("in-flight MCP call = alive") covers this variant too — while a run_skill call is executing, neither the stream-idle kill, the stale kill, nor the suppression bound should fire. Interim mitigations in use by the loop driver: AUTOSKILLIT_RUN_SKILL__STREAM_IDLE_TIMEOUT_MS=7200000 and AUTOSKILLIT_RUN_SKILL__MAX_SUPPRESSION_SECONDS=7200.

Prior Codex Self-Test Attempt (2026-07-08/09) — blocked by #4215 before implementation

The required Codex self-test was retried after #4199 landed, using the bundled remediation recipe (not remediation-fable) and --backend codex:

env -u AUTOSKILLIT_SESSION_TYPE AUTOSKILLIT_CORE__DEFAULT_MODEL='opus[1m]' \
  AUTOSKILLIT_RUN_SKILL__STREAM_IDLE_TIMEOUT_MS=7200000 \
  AUTOSKILLIT_RUN_SKILL__MAX_SUPPRESSION_SECONDS=7200 \
  autoskillit fleet run remediation --backend codex \
  -t "Codex L2 food trucks killed by stream-idle watchdog while blocked on long MCP calls (fix GitHub issue #4202)" \
  -i issue_url=https://github.com/TalonT-Org/AutoSkillit/issues/4202 \
  -i source_dir=/home/talon/projects/generic_automation_mcp \
  -i post_run_diagnostics=true --timeout-sec 14400

Outcome: dispatch d6d87a72-f14a-4dc8-aca6-4c329ddfd1ec, parent Codex session 019f4498-1f77-70c2-ad4a-d80d40c234b2, failed at the first recipe step (investigate) before implementation began. The clone was preserved at /home/talon/projects/autoskillit-runs/remediation-20260708-185810-891274.

Failure signature: child investigate session 019f4499-47bf-7ba3-b2e6-624dc4d486a2 exited naturally with exit_code=0, but run_skill returned subtype=adjudicated_failure, success=false, fs_writes_detected=false, git_writes_detected=false, and write_call_count=0. Child artifacts:

  • Summary: ~/.local/share/autoskillit/logs/sessions/019f4499-47bf-7ba3-b2e6-624dc4d486a2/summary.json
  • Raw stdout: ~/.local/share/autoskillit/logs/sessions/019f4499-47bf-7ba3-b2e6-624dc4d486a2/raw_stdout.jsonl
  • Codex rollout: /home/talon/.local/share/autoskillit/logs/codex-sessions/2026/07/08/rollout-2026-07-08T18-58-43-019f4499-47bf-7ba3-b2e6-624dc4d486a2.jsonl

The child final message said it could not write the normal $investigate report under .autoskillit/temp/investigate/ because the session was read-only. It then produced useful root-cause analysis for this issue and emitted %%ORDER_UP::e284d23b%%, but the recipe could not consume it because the mandatory report artifact was missing.

New blocker filed: #4215, Codex investigate child runs read-only, cannot write required report artifact, and returns adjudicated_failure with zero writes.

Next-round guidance: do not rerun this same Codex remediation --backend codex dispatch until #4215 is fixed or the investigate step is manually routed through a writable provider. Once #4215 is staged/installed, rerun the exact self-test command above and continue this issue's remediation.

Blocker #4215 Resolved Before Retry (2026-07-09 UTC)

The prior Codex self-test failure described above was fixed by #4215 / PR #4216. PR #4216 merged into develop at 2026-07-09T03:39:36Z (7555994c4018bb5f5025bfec6ab0fe5db02b89c3), and the follow-up version-sync commit installed as AutoSkillit 0.10.858 at 1e76bde9af858757374348b357985d468d73c98b.

The fix makes /autoskillit:investigate writable for required report artifacts and gives the bundled remediation recipe an explicit output_dir: '{{AUTOSKILLIT_TEMP}}/investigate' for its first step. Local task test-check, pre-commit, GitHub Actions, and merge queue all passed.

Before retrying this issue, the driver verified no live fleet dispatch process was running and .autoskillit/temp/.hook_config_overlay.json had no quota_guard key, no empty locked-step scope, and no false locked steps. Proceed with the exact bundled remediation --backend codex self-test command above.

Codex Self-Test Attempt (2026-07-09 UTC) — resumed manually after Codex quota wall

The required bundled remediation --backend codex self-test was retried after #4215 / PR #4216 was installed as AutoSkillit 0.10.858:

  • Dispatch: f59e3e5b-8609-4d8b-ae3b-ea01d525285b
  • Parent Codex session: 019f44ff-0005-7bf0-897b-62ea829e078c
  • Dispatch log: .autoskillit/temp/codex-loop/4202-dispatch-20260708-204945.log
  • Clone: /home/talon/projects/autoskillit-runs/remediation-20260708-205019-355728
  • Worktree: /home/talon/projects/autoskillit-runs/worktrees/impl-4202-20260708-220503

Progress made: investigate, rectify, and dry-walkthrough completed successfully. The Codex L2 survived a long stdout-silent child session with stdout_idle_stall_suppressed warnings instead of being killed, which is direct live evidence for the #4202 fix path. The implementation step produced a substantial liveness-policy worktree, then hit context exhaustion. The L2 continued into testing/recovery and reduced local failures from 30 to 23, but then exited with envelope dispatch_status=resumable, reason=fleet_quota_exhausted, and summary: Codex weekly quota exhausted during remediation retries; reset window Jul 12 at 10am America/Los_Angeles.

Because the remaining route is blocked by Codex quota rather than engineering intent, the driver is entering operator-authorized UNCLOGGER mode and continuing manually from the existing worktree in recipe order. Next manual step: run /autoskillit:resolve-failures against the preserved worktree and plan artifact, using the existing MiniMax/claude-code provider route rather than re-dispatching Codex.

Correction to 2026-07-09 Quota Interpretation

Follow-up investigation found the prior phrase "Codex weekly quota exhausted" was imprecise.

The dispatch envelope for f59e3e5b-8609-4d8b-ae3b-ea01d525285b was correctly dispatch_status=resumable, reason=fleet_quota_exhausted, but the exhausted quota was not the parent Codex L2. The parent Codex rollout continued to report roughly 28% five-hour and 10% seven-day usage with no rate_limit_reached_type through the final turn.

The actual 429s came from downstream Claude Code child sessions launched after implementation context exhaustion:

  • retry_worktree session 9cfe2d84-1b2b-467c-987f-f7dbfe439d1c
  • resolve-failures session f6aa47c2-f434-48bb-b0fc-946cad7a1b83
  • resolve-failures session 49e3e00c-a583-469e-af3f-4c71e6c3d4ca

The last child Claude log contains provider-layer metadata: error="rate_limit", isApiErrorMessage=true, apiErrorStatus=429, and text You've hit your weekly limit · resets Jul 12, 10am (America/Los_Angeles). Those recovery steps had provider_used="", while the earlier implement child used provider_used="minimax". Current config maps remediation implement to MiniMax, but not retry_worktree, assess, or merge_gate_assess.

Operational guidance remains: continue manually from the preserved worktree with explicit step_provider=minimax for /autoskillit:resolve-failures; do not re-dispatch into recovery steps that can fall back to Anthropic without provider override coverage.

Manual UNCLOGGER Resolve-Failures Continuation (2026-07-09)

Because the MCP kitchen was still stale after the installed package changed, the driver continued the recipe's resolve-failures intent manually in the preserved worktree rather than re-dispatching into the Anthropic-backed recovery wall.

Worktree: /home/talon/projects/autoskillit-runs/worktrees/impl-4202-20260708-220503

Plan artifact: /home/talon/projects/autoskillit-runs/remediation-20260708-205019-355728/.autoskillit/temp/rectify/rectify_codex_l2_liveness_policy_2026-07-08_211800.md

Commits created:

  • ceed47554fix: centralize codex liveness supervision
  • badb43e17test: update liveness type contracts

What changed:

  • Added OperationLiveness and SessionLivenessSpec to the core backend type contract.
  • Added Codex parser liveness events for in-flight operations while keeping started/updated records out of final result evidence.
  • Added a per-attempt ProcessLivenessSupervisor and a headless liveness resolver.
  • Routed stdout-idle, session-log stale, and deadline-extension decisions through the supervisor without expanding the public SubprocessRunner API.
  • Removed the old unsafe coupling where Codex stream_idle_timeout_ms / CmdSpec.process_idle_timeout_ms could lower the parent outer watchdog.
  • Updated tests, architecture inventories, and AGENTS docs for the new contract.

Validation:

  • Focused prior-failure set: PYTEST_TEST_PATHS="tests/core/types/test_session_event.py tests/core/types/test_type_liveness.py tests/execution/backends/test_codex_backend.py tests/server/test_factory_recording.py tests/execution/test_backend_dispatch.py tests/execution/test_headless_backend_override.py tests/execution/test_headless_execute.py tests/execution/test_headless_provider_forwarding.py tests/execution/test_idle_output_env.py tests/arch/test_import_linter_contracts.py tests/arch/test_subpackage_isolation.py tests/arch/test_subpackage_structure.py tests/contracts/test_instruction_surface.py tests/contracts/test_protocol_satisfaction.py tests/execution/process/test_liveness_supervisor.py" task test-check -> PASS (1414 passed, 57 skipped), output temp/test-2026-07-09_060427.txt.
  • Pre-commit: pre-commit run --all-files -> PASS.
  • Full gate after follow-up contract fix: task test-check -> PASS (29810 passed, 603 skipped, 44 xfailed), output /home/talon/projects/autoskillit-runs/worktrees/impl-4202-20260708-220503/temp/test-2026-07-09_061035.txt.

Next recipe-tail step: push the worktree branch and run the normal audit/PR/review tail (audit-impl if available, then prepare/compose PR, review, resolve-review, CI, merge queue). If MCP run_skill remains blocked by stale server state, continue the tail manually only as far as the runbook allows and document each action here.

Manual UNCLOGGER Audit-Tail Continuation (2026-07-09)

After MCP reload, the driver continued the #4202 recipe tail manually from the preserved worktree rather than re-dispatching into the known downstream Anthropic quota wall.

Worktree: /home/talon/projects/autoskillit-runs/worktrees/impl-4202-20260708-220503

Branch pushed: codex-l2-liveness-supervision-4202

Additional commit created and pushed:

  • 4e682c2befix: align codex liveness child hints

What changed in this audit-remediation commit:

  • Mirrored resolved SessionLivenessSpec back into child AUTOSKILLIT_IDLE_OUTPUT_TIMEOUT before runner invocation, including explicit idle_output_timeout=0 removing stale Codex stream-idle hints.
  • Preserved raw Codex backend payloads on operation-liveness events and on item.started / item.updated metadata.
  • Added focused Codex lifecycle, child-env, server, and stdout-idle watchdog regression tests.
  • Kept _execute_claude_headless.py under the source-size guard by moving resolved child-idle env normalization into _headless_liveness.py.

Validation before audit rerun:

  • Focused liveness/arch set: PYTEST_TEST_PATHS="tests/arch/test_execution_source_split.py tests/core/types/test_type_liveness.py tests/execution/backends/test_codex_stream_parser.py tests/execution/test_idle_output_env.py tests/execution/test_process_idle_watchdog.py tests/server/test_tools_execution_command.py" task test-check -> PASS (115 passed), output temp/test-2026-07-09_064325.txt.
  • Full gate: task test-check -> PASS (29818 passed, 603 skipped, 44 xfailed), output /home/talon/projects/autoskillit-runs/worktrees/impl-4202-20260708-220503/temp/test-2026-07-09_064344.txt.
  • Pre-commit: pre-commit run --all-files -> PASS.

Manual run_skill audit step:

  • Command: /autoskillit:audit-impl /home/talon/projects/autoskillit-runs/remediation-20260708-205019-355728/.autoskillit/temp/rectify/rectify_codex_l2_liveness_policy_2026-07-08_211800.md 1e76bde9af858757374348b357985d468d73c98b develop
  • step_provider=minimax, order_id=4202-manual, idle_output_timeout=0
  • Session: 84459105-5bd5-40ad-a3a3-05a92a38728c
  • Result: verdict = NO GO
  • Remediation file: /home/talon/projects/autoskillit-runs/worktrees/impl-4202-20260708-220503/.autoskillit/temp/audit-impl/remediation_codex_l2_liveness_policy_2026-07-09_065658.md

Current route: continue manual remediation from the audit file. Three disjoint worker subagents were launched for watcher/process tests, fleet/provider-fallback tests, and config/arch/contract guards. Do not open the PR until audit-impl returns GO.

Manual Audit Remediation Round 2 (2026-07-09)

The driver completed the audit-impl NO GO remediation from the preserved worktree and pushed the follow-up coverage commit.

Worktree: /home/talon/projects/autoskillit-runs/worktrees/impl-4202-20260708-220503

Branch: codex-l2-liveness-supervision-4202

New commit:

  • 3a2e096a4test: complete liveness audit coverage

What changed:

  • Added the missing liveness contract, core API, protocol, architecture, watcher, Channel-B stale, provider-fallback, and fleet Codex coverage requested by audit.
  • Added tests/contracts/test_headless_liveness_contracts.py and source-map/docs entries for _headless_liveness.py.
  • Added architecture guards that keep Codex parent idle behavior sourced from resolved SessionLivenessSpec, not backend child hints or ambient env reads.
  • Added watcher/process tests proving in-flight operation liveness suppresses stdout idle and Channel-B stale, and clamps child-activity deadline extension to the operation deadline.
  • Added provider fallback and fleet Codex regressions for stdout-silent MCP activity and fresh per-attempt supervisor state.
  • Made dispatch wrapper tests deterministic by patching quota wait/refresher dependencies in non-quota server tests; this fixed a full-suite-only timeout where real quota state could sleep long enough for pytest-timeout and surface as fleet_l3_startup_or_crash / CancelledError: transport teardown.

Validation:

  • Broad focused remediation set: PYTEST_TEST_PATHS="tests/arch/test_backend_builder_no_independent_copies.py tests/arch/test_watcher_signal_consistency.py tests/arch/test_layer_enforcement.py tests/config/test_defaults.py tests/contracts/test_backend_protocol.py tests/contracts/test_core_public_api_surface.py tests/contracts/test_protocol_satisfaction.py tests/contracts/test_headless_liveness_contracts.py tests/core/test_backend_protocols.py tests/execution/test_headless_provider_fallback.py tests/execution/test_process_deadline_extension.py tests/execution/test_process_heartbeat.py tests/execution/test_process_session_log_monitor.py tests/execution/test_process_session_log_monitor_dispatch_marker.py tests/execution/test_process_session_log_monitor_stale_suppression.py tests/execution/test_process_submodules.py tests/fleet/test_fleet_e2e_codex.py tests/infra/test_ci_dev_config.py" task test-check -> PASS (1087 passed), output temp/test-2026-07-09_073217.txt.
  • Server/deadline focused set after deterministic quota patch: PYTEST_TEST_PATHS="tests/server/test_tools_dispatch_halt.py tests/server/test_tools_dispatch_params.py tests/execution/test_process_deadline_extension.py tests/server/_helpers.py" task test-check -> PASS (33 passed), output temp/test-2026-07-09_074243.txt.
  • Full gate before commit: task test-check -> PASS (29844 passed, 603 skipped, 44 xfailed), output temp/test-2026-07-09_074632.txt.
  • Pre-commit: pre-commit run --all-files -> PASS.
  • Post-format focused contract/docs set: PYTEST_TEST_PATHS="tests/contracts/test_headless_liveness_contracts.py tests/docs/test_check_sub_claude_md_script.py tests/docs/test_tests_sub_claude_md_completeness.py" task test-check -> PASS (19 passed), output temp/test-2026-07-09_075025.txt.

Next route: rerun audit-impl with step_provider=minimax. If it returns GO, continue the PR tail with prepare-pr, compose-pr, review-pr, and resolve-review as directed by the recipe/runbook.

Manual Audit Rerun GO (2026-07-09)

Manual audit-impl was rerun after remediation round 2 with MiniMax provider routing.

Command:

/autoskillit:audit-impl /home/talon/projects/autoskillit-runs/remediation-20260708-205019-355728/.autoskillit/temp/rectify/rectify_codex_l2_liveness_policy_2026-07-08_211800.md 1e76bde9af858757374348b357985d468d73c98b develop

Run parameters: step_provider=minimax, order_id=4202-manual-audit2, idle_output_timeout=0, stale_threshold=7200.

Session: 7dd2e5ff-b18a-4850-9967-fd7daa2202bc

Result: verdict = GO / merge approved.

Next route: continue the normal recipe PR tail from branch codex-l2-liveness-supervision-4202: prepare PR metadata, compose/open PR, run review-pr, and route any review findings through resolve-review before CI/merge queue.

Manual PR / Review Tail Continuation (2026-07-09)

After audit-impl returned GO, the driver continued the recipe PR tail manually with MiniMax-backed run_skill steps from the preserved worktree.

Worktree: /home/talon/projects/autoskillit-runs/worktrees/impl-4202-20260708-220503

Branch / PR: codex-l2-liveness-supervision-4202 -> PR #4217 (https://github.com/TalonT-Org/AutoSkillit/pull/4217)

Manual recipe-tail steps:

  • prepare-pr (step_provider=minimax, order 4202-manual-prepare-pr) succeeded; session 21006243-3370-43ac-a91c-d1ba2528e1a0; prep path .autoskillit/temp/prepare-pr/pr_prep_2026-07-09_080201.md; selected lenses none.
  • compose-pr (step_provider=minimax, order 4202-manual-compose-pr) succeeded; session 596f7f59-8c42-4104-b4ce-2b070a08fc74; opened PR Rectify: Codex L2 Liveness Policy #4217.
  • First review-pr (step_provider=minimax, order 4202-manual-review-pr-0) posted review comments and returned changes_requested; session 35c6f84d-5602-4bd5-a5c4-7f36d31046f8.
  • resolve-review initially ran into a read-only source-edit constraint, then the driver manually applied the documented review plan and committed the fixes.
  • Second review-pr (step_provider=minimax, order 4202-manual-review-pr-1) returned approved_with_comments; session cb0f833b-9c4b-43cb-b70b-3c1a54491ed5.
  • Final resolve-review (step_provider=minimax, order 4202-manual-resolve-review-2) applied 5 warning fixes, rejected 5 comments, left 5 DISCUSS, resolved/replied to 16 threads, and reported verdict = real_fix; session e8b80f0b-d613-4ad6-9ce6-713951bf76e9.

Additional review-fix commits pushed after audit GO:

  • 03cd54a11fix: address liveness review findings
  • 3700465eetest: address liveness review coverage
  • 517c59c55fix(review): robust fallback test asserts >= 2 attempts
  • 718be5b64test(review): dedupe liveness supervisor helpers and add negative suppression test
  • 4bf8bbb80test(review): parametrize legal silence window over enable_deadline_extension
  • 8bceb191bfix(review): drop redundant authorized_sources kwarg from resolver
  • bb2b03dbdfix(review): drop dead process_idle_timeout_ms kwarg from codex builders
  • c0facfe1bRevert "fix(review): drop dead process_idle_timeout_ms kwarg from codex builders" (resolver reclassified that suggestion as an arch-guard violation)

Validation after review fixes:

  • Focused review-fix set: task test-check with liveness/review paths -> PASS (114 passed, 1 warning), output temp/test-2026-07-09_083634.txt.
  • Pre-commit: pre-commit run --all-files -> PASS.
  • Full gate before resolver follow-up commits: task test-check -> PASS (29843 passed, 603 skipped, 44 xfailed), output temp/test-2026-07-09_083722.txt.
  • Final full gate after resolver commits: task test-check -> PASS (29847 passed, 603 skipped, 44 xfailed), output temp/test-2026-07-09_091458.txt.

Current state: PR #4217 is pushed at head c0facfe1b55585a20792bbdd5070383a22e65d10; GitHub Actions are queued/running. Next route is CI monitoring, diagnose-ci if needed, then merge queue.

Staged via PR #4217 (2026-07-09)

PR #4217 (https://github.com/TalonT-Org/AutoSkillit/pull/4217) merged into develop through the merge queue at 2026-07-09T16:35:05Z.

Merge commit: f5148ae3afa03d4d36a40c427f5a3f2354878654

Post-merge state:

  • Follow-up version-sync advanced develop to a0ef226826a6a33b52af8af5ad310d8f40cfe7ab.
  • Installed AutoSkillit updated from 0.10.858 to 0.10.859 via autoskillit update.
  • CI rerun outcome: the first Test (general) job failed before tests due arduino/setup-task HTTP 504 while downloading go-task; diagnose-ci classified it as env/env, not code-fixable. Rerunning failed jobs passed.
  • Final GitHub Actions on PR Rectify: Codex L2 Liveness Policy #4217: Preflight checks PASS, Test (execution) PASS, Test (general) PASS.
  • Local final validation before merge: pre-commit run --all-files PASS and task test-check PASS (29847 passed, 603 skipped, 44 xfailed), output temp/test-2026-07-09_091458.txt.
  • Issue labels swapped from in-progress to staged.

This completes the required Codex self-test remediation target for #4202.


Rollback / Rerun Correction — 2026-07-09

The previous staged status was incorrect. The Codex-backed #4202 remediation dispatch did not complete the bundled remediation recipe end-to-end and did not persist/review a final analyze-pipeline-health report. It proved the early Codex liveness path through investigate, rectify, and dry_walkthrough, but then hit implementation context exhaustion, failed worktree tests, and stopped when downstream Claude Code recovery sessions hit Anthropic weekly 429s.

Manual UNCLOGGER continuation produced PR #4217, but that manual PR/review/CI/merge tail cannot count as the #4202 Codex self-test. The success condition requires the Codex backend to complete the bundled remediation recipe independently, including post-run diagnostics/health analysis.

Actions taken:

  • Reverted PR Rectify: Codex L2 Liveness Policy #4217 on develop: fa9854f26145c2830631671347de7126cd394804 (revert: undo codex liveness self-test merge).
  • Kept only a separate test-only stabilization so dispatch tests do not use the live Anthropic quota path: d89fb2aa0fa42d8f53830ccf53afa7da2cdf2853 (test: isolate dispatch tests from quota state). This does not restore the Rectify: Codex L2 Liveness Policy #4217 liveness implementation.
  • Reset labels by removing staged; current labels should be bug + recipe:remediation.
  • Validation after rollback: pre-commit run --all-files PASS; focused dispatch tests PASS (23 passed, temp/test-2026-07-09_100810.txt); full task test-check PASS (29800 passed, 604 skipped, 44 xfailed, temp/test-2026-07-09_100830.txt).

Next required route: rerun #4202 the right way. If the Codex backend cannot complete the recipe, manual work is limited to remediating the blocker that prevents a later autonomous Codex completion; manual recipe/PR/review/merge steps cannot substitute for the required Codex self-test.

Rerun Attempt Interrupted — 2026-07-09 Codex Alias Blocker

Fresh Codex self-test dispatch 4e6fbbea-f4fc-4176-bfce-34cb09157a68 was started after the #4217 rollback, but it was intentionally interrupted before it could count as a valid #4202 self-test. Evidence from the process tree showed the Codex L2 food-truck process launched with --model gpt-5.4, which violates the active operator constraint to use gpt-5.5 and avoid 5.4/mini routes.

This is a separate pipeline/backend blocker, now tracked as #4218. Local dispatch state was marked interrupted with reason operator_stopped_for_forbidden_gpt_5_4, and the stale in-progress label was removed from #4202. #4202 remains bug + recipe:remediation and must be rerun only after #4218 is merged/installed.

Manual work on #4218 is limited to remediating this blocker so a later #4202 Codex backend run can complete autonomously. It does not count as completing #4202.

Autonomous Rerun Preflight — 2026-07-09 13:26 PDT

After #4218/PR #4220 installed AutoSkillit 0.10.861, the Claude marketplace plugin cache needed a local administrative refresh before MiniMax + claude-code worker steps could safely launch. The cache was refreshed with AUTOSKILLIT_AGENT_BACKEND__BACKEND=claude-code autoskillit install --scope user; this performed only local marketplace/plugin administration and did not launch an Anthropic model session.

Verified state before the fresh #4202 dispatch:

  • installed_plugins.json points autoskillit@autoskillit-local at /home/talon/.claude/plugins/cache/autoskillit-local/autoskillit/0.10.861 with version 0.10.861.
  • AutoSkillit's runtime marketplace resolver returns that versioned path, and version_info reports package 0.10.861, plugin manifest 0.10.861, match=true.
  • A restarted MCP server opens the kitchen successfully and reports AutoSkillit 0.10.861.
  • Direct kitchen_status invocation from this Codex client returns Unknown tool: 'kitchen_status'; this is a client/tool-visibility discrepancy, not a package/cache mismatch. The independent runtime resolver check above verifies the same version contract used by a newly launched fleet server.
  • The bundled remediation recipe validates under the exact dispatch-style ingredient shape with valid=true, dispatch_feasible=true, and zero error-severity findings. A schema-only call that forced post_run_diagnostics=true while deferring every other guarded ingredient exposed a separate pruning-filter edge case, but the real fleet validation path resolves defaults and is unaffected.
  • No autoskillit fleet process is running.
  • .autoskillit/temp/.hook_config_overlay.json is absent, so no stale ingredient locks or quota guard remain.
  • Codex L2 food trucks killed by 600s stream-idle watchdog while blocked on long-running MCP calls — suppression heuristics inapplicable, healthy children orphaned #4202 is OPEN with only bug and recipe:remediation; no stale in-progress or fail label remains.

Next action: launch a completely fresh bundled remediation --backend codex run with post_run_diagnostics=true, then verify the live L2 process uses gpt-5.6-sol with model_reasoning_effort=xhigh. This dispatch must complete the recipe and health-analysis tail autonomously; manual completion of its engineering/PR tail is not an allowed success route.

Rerun Interrupted — 2026-07-09 Sol Effort Override Key

Fresh dispatch 0b23e627-a221-4948-8f07-5792235a8f2f was launched after the 0.10.861 reload and stopped before engineering. Live process evidence showed the L2 using --model gpt-5.6-sol -c model_reasoning_effort=high. The model family was correct, but #4202 is an Opus-class serious remediation and requires xhigh.

This was a runbook configuration-key error, not a failure of the Sol alias mapping. The command used AUTOSKILLIT_CORE__DEFAULT_MODEL='opus[1m]', which is ignored by the config loader and leaves model.default=sonnet. Direct installed-package probes established:

  • AUTOSKILLIT_CORE__DEFAULT_MODEL='opus[1m]' -> effective default sonnet
  • AUTOSKILLIT_MODEL__DEFAULT_MODEL='opus[1m]' -> effective default sonnet
  • AUTOSKILLIT_MODEL__DEFAULT='opus[1m]' -> effective default opus[1m]

The dispatch record is marked interrupted with reason operator_stopped_for_sol_effort_downgrade, its process tree is gone, and the transient fail label was removed. The handoff command now uses AUTOSKILLIT_MODEL__DEFAULT='opus[1m]'.

Next action: start another completely fresh dispatch with the corrected key and require live gpt-5.6-sol + model_reasoning_effort=xhigh evidence before allowing the autonomous recipe to continue. Do not resume this interrupted session.

Autonomous Codex Rerun Active — 2026-07-09 13:32 PDT

Fresh bundled-remediation dispatch f6b3f866-1f83-487d-80e0-1ff00a4f74c5 is the current valid #4202 self-test.

  • Fleet command uses AUTOSKILLIT_MODEL__DEFAULT='opus[1m]', the 7200-second stream-idle/suppression overrides, --backend codex, and post_run_diagnostics=true.
  • Live L2 process PID 3276930 was process-verified with --model gpt-5.6-sol -c model_reasoning_effort=xhigh.
  • The L2 environment carries AUTOSKILLIT_DISPATCH_ID=f6b3f866-1f83-487d-80e0-1ff00a4f74c5, AUTOSKILLIT_HEADLESS=1, and AUTOSKILLIT_AGENT_BACKEND__BACKEND=codex.
  • Dispatch record: .autoskillit/temp/dispatches/f6b3f866-1f83-487d-80e0-1ff00a4f74c5.json (status=running).
  • Driver exec session: 10867.
  • Driver log: .autoskillit/temp/codex-loop/4202-dispatch-20260709-1331-sol-xhigh.log.
  • Isolated clone: /home/talon/projects/autoskillit-runs/remediation-20260709-133256-648970.
  • Codex L2 food trucks killed by 600s stream-idle watchdog while blocked on long-running MCP calls — suppression heuristics inapplicable, healthy children orphaned #4202 is claimed with in-progress.

This run must complete the entire recipe, including PR/review/merge gates and the final analyze-pipeline-health step, without the driver taking over its engineering tail. If it exposes another pipeline blocker, harvest that failure, remediate only the blocker, and rerun #4202 fresh.

Prior Autonomous Remediation Attempt: Sol/xhigh round (2026-07-09)

Dispatch f6b3f866-1f83-487d-80e0-1ff00a4f74c5 ran the bundled remediation recipe on the Codex backend for 2h47m. The L2 and all serious Codex stages were process-verified on gpt-5.6-sol with model_reasoning_effort=xhigh; worker-write and recovery stages used the configured MiniMax + claude-code route. No Anthropic-backed step was used.

Completed autonomously:

  • investigate -> report /home/talon/projects/autoskillit-runs/remediation-20260709-133256-648970/.autoskillit/temp/investigate/investigation_codex_l2_stream_idle_watchdog_4202_2026-07-09_134002.md
  • rectify -> plan /home/talon/projects/autoskillit-runs/remediation-20260709-133256-648970/.autoskillit/temp/rectify/rectify_codex_l2_attempt_liveness_2026-07-09_134934.md
  • first dry-walkthrough
  • implementation, retry-worktree, test recovery, and a green gate (24326 passed, 540 skipped, 44 xfailed)
  • audit-impl -> genuine NO GO with remediation artifact /home/talon/projects/autoskillit-runs/remediation-20260709-133256-648970/.autoskillit/temp/audit-impl/remediation_codex_l2_attempt_liveness_2026-07-09_154037.md
  • audit-remediation make-plan -> /home/talon/projects/autoskillit-runs/remediation-20260709-133256-648970/.autoskillit/temp/make-plan/codex_l2_attempt_liveness_remediation_plan_2026-07-09_155341.md
  • final analyze-pipeline-health session 019f4926-9abc-74f0-bd84-effbf70e1f99

Preserved work:

  • Remote branch: codex-l2-food-trucks-killed-by-600s-stream-idle-watchdog-whi/4202-4
  • Head: a561449a9
  • Five commits ahead of develop
  • Clone: /home/talon/projects/autoskillit-runs/remediation-20260709-133256-648970
  • No PR was opened.

The branch is partial, not an accepted implementation. Health analysis found that the reproducer's 1.2-second simulated stall ends before the watcher's first 5-second poll and that production observations use hard_deadline_monotonic=0.0, so the green test was a false positive. audit-impl independently found that the seven-slice liveness architecture remained incomplete.

Terminal failure:

The audit-remediation dry walkthrough received only the remediation plan, not the current remediation_path. It treated REQ-001 through REQ-042 as unmapped, made zero writes, and asked to be rerun with the audit artifact. The L3 envelope reported:

Pipeline failed after the remediation dry-walkthrough did not receive the required remediation_path; diagnostics completed and the clone was preserved.

Blockers activated from this run:

Health analysis confirmed four bugs: the false-positive liveness test/inert production deadline, incomplete implementation hidden by green tests, missing remediation-path propagation, and search-command guard false positives. It also recorded implementation/retry context exhaustion, skipped audit parallel/chunk discipline, Codex NDJSON error item drift, one recoverable 1-second wait error, and read-only/offline rectify verification limits.

No JSON health report exists because #3209 supplied an empty dispatch ID. The reviewed health text is preserved in the final agent_message of rollout /home/talon/.local/share/autoskillit/logs/codex-sessions/2026/07/09/rollout-2026-07-09T16-11-34-019f4926-9abc-74f0-bd84-effbf70e1f99.jsonl.

Next-round guidance: do not reimplement from scratch and do not treat the five commits as complete. Fix and install #4185 and #3209 first. Then launch a fresh bundled-remediation Codex round that adopts remote branch .../4202-4, completes the missing liveness architecture, opens/finishes its own PR, and persists/reviews the dispatch-scoped health report autonomously.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    bugExisting behavior is brokenfailrecipe:remediationRoute: investigate/decompose before implementation

    Type

    No type

    Fields

    No fields configured for issues without a type.

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions