Update Safe Routes to School.json

[shockwave656]

The quests have been updated to reflect feedback from Anat - the biggest change for the quests is that they are now based on what we have for the KCM Walk Audit quest form, though there have been some edits made here that aren't present in the KCM Walk Audit quest form.

[uw-amy-bordenave]

Remove or clarify the purpose of the duplicated "home"/"additional" quests:

[uw-amy-bordenave]

Thank you for improving the pictures links, @shockwave656!

Have you run the /Review-Quest-Definition quests\prod\Safe Routes to School\Safe Routes to School.json prompt? This will return a review of the quest definition that highlights possible issues. Like any AI output, you can't trust it implicitly; however, it's very helpful for finding potential issues.

Example output, which I checked and verified that the majority of the feedback does identify needed changes:

Review summary

The quest definition is valid against the schema:

• File: quests/prod/Safe Routes to School/Safe Routes to School.json
• Schema: v3.0.0
• Questions: 184 across 5 element types
• Validator result: Passed
• Duplicate quest IDs/tags: None
• Missing dependency targets: None
• Dependency cycles: None
• Image URL syntax: Valid

Findings

1. Critical: many “additional instance” questions are not gated

There are 65 questions tagged with _additional; 51 do not have quest_answer_dependency. Their titles say they should only be answered for an additional feature instance, but the schema will expose them unconditionally.

Examples:

• 1018, 1020, 1026, 1028, 1030, 1032, 1034, 1036
• 2016, 2019, 2023, 2025, 2027, 2029, 2035, 2037, 2039, 2041
• 3013, 3019, 3023, 3025, 3027, 3029, 3031, 3033, 3037, 3039, 3045, 3047, 3049, 3051, 3055, 3057, 3059, 3061, 3063
• 4009, 4011, 4014, 4018, 4020, 4022
• 5010, 5012, 5014, 5016, 5018, 5020, 5022, 5024

This is inconsistent with existing paired questions such as 1021/1022, 3040/3041, and 5011/5012 patterns. Add dependencies to the appropriate primary-instance or feature-presence question, or remove the “additional instance” wording if these are intentionally always shown.

2. Important: curb-ramp additional measurements lack the primary ramp dependency

The primary curb-ramp measurements are gated by question 5001, but the additional versions are not:

• 5012 — ramp width
• 5014 — running slope
• 5016 — cross slope
• 5018 — landing width
• 5020 — landing depth
• 5022 — side-flare slope
• 5024 — surface material

They should likely retain the same 5001 dependency as their corresponding “home” questions, in addition to whatever mechanism identifies the additional instance.

3. Important: driveway questions are not conditionally gated

The following questions ask about driveways but are always visible:

• 1029 — driveway count
• 1030 — additional driveway count
• 1031/1032 — driveway-level path
• 1033/1034 — widest driveway

1031 provides an N/A (No driveways) answer, but the count and width questions do not. Consider either:

• adding a consistent “no driveways” option/dependency strategy, or
• gating follow-up questions based on 1029 > 0 if the dependency system supports numeric comparisons.

4. Important: 1013 has conflicting MultipleChoice sentinel values

Question 1013 includes both:

• none_observed_or_known
• unable_to_determine

alongside many selectable conditions. A MultipleChoice control may allow combinations such as:

• none_observed_or_known + leaf_fall
• unable_to_determine + flooding_or_drainage

These sentinel choices should normally be mutually exclusive with substantive answers. The current v3 schema does not express that constraint.

5. Suggestion: numeric units should be standardized

Most sidewalk and buffer measurements use feet, while curb-ramp measurements use inches:

• 1007, 1023, 1024, 1033, 1034: feet
• 5011–5020: inches

This may be intentional, but it increases field-user error risk. Consider standardizing units or making the unit especially prominent in both the title and description.

6. Suggestion: wording and data type mismatch

Question 3022/3023 are ExclusiveChoice questions titled “How many landing pads,” but the answers are categories such as “All three doors” and “Front door only.” A title such as “Which boarding positions have landing pads?” would better match the data.

Recommended priority

1. Fix missing dependencies for the 51 _additional questions.
2. Gate the curb-ramp additional measurements consistently with the primary ramp questions.
3. Resolve sentinel behavior in MultipleChoice questions, especially 1013.
4. Decide how zero/unknown driveway measurements should be represented.
5. Re-run the validator after changes; the current validator will not detect these semantic issues.