Skip to content

Commit faea93e

Browse files
benbrastmckiebenbrastmckie
committed
task 172: complete implementation
Session: sess_1781312776_63c955
1 parent 3830db1 commit faea93e

4 files changed

Lines changed: 24 additions & 46 deletions

File tree

‎specs/172_connectives_hasand_hasor_full_primitives/.return-meta.json‎

Lines changed: 0 additions & 28 deletions
This file was deleted.

‎specs/172_connectives_hasand_hasor_full_primitives/plans/01_hasand-hasor-plan.md‎

Lines changed: 1 addition & 1 deletion
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -1,7 +1,7 @@
11
# Implementation Plan: HasAnd/HasOr Atomic Typeclasses
22

33
- **Task**: 172 - connectives_hasand_hasor_full_primitives
4-
- **Status**: [IMPLEMENTING]
4+
- **Status**: [COMPLETED]
55
- **Effort**: 1.5 hours
66
- **Dependencies**: None (task 171 research complete; no code prerequisites)
77
- **Research Inputs**: reports/01_team-research.md

‎specs/TODO.md‎

Lines changed: 13 additions & 13 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -11,10 +11,10 @@ next_project_number: 179
1111
**Dependency Waves**:
1212
| Wave | Tasks | Blocked by | Topics |
1313
|------|-------|------------|--------|
14-
| 1 | 36,37,62,127,139,146,147,160,169,170,171,172 | -- | Bimodal Porting, Modal PRs, Propositional Logic, ... |
15-
| 2 | 39,40,63,140,148,161,173 | 36,37,62,139,147,160,172 | Modal PRs, Propositional PRs, Temporal Logic, ... |
16-
| 3 | 41,64,141,149,162,174,175,176,178 | 39,40,63,140,148,161,173 | Foundations, Modal PRs, Propositional PRs, ... |
17-
| 4 | 128,129,142,150,177 | 141,146,149,175,176 | Modal PRs, Propositional PRs, Foundations Refactor |
14+
| 1 | 36,37,62,127,139,146,147,160,169,170,171,173 | -- | Bimodal Porting, Modal PRs, Propositional Logic, ... |
15+
| 2 | 39,40,63,140,148,161,174,175,176,178 | 36,37,62,139,147,160,173 | Modal PRs, Propositional PRs, Temporal Logic, ... |
16+
| 3 | 41,64,141,149,162,177 | 39,40,63,140,148,161,175,176 | Foundations, Modal PRs, Propositional PRs, ... |
17+
| 4 | 128,129,142,150 | 141,146,149 | Modal PRs, Propositional PRs |
1818
| 5 | 126,143,151,152,154,163 | 142,150,160 | Modal PRs, Propositional PRs, Temporal PRs |
1919
| 6 | 130,133,144,153,155,156 | 126,127,143,151,152,154 | Modal PRs, Propositional PRs |
2020
| 7 | 131,132,134,135,157 | 127,128,130,133,152,156 | Modal PRs, Propositional PRs |
@@ -99,14 +99,13 @@ next_project_number: 179
9999

100100
### Foundations Refactor
101101

102-
172 [PLANNED] — Extend Cslib/Foundations/Logic/Connectives.lean for the hybrid fi
103-
└─ 173 [NOT STARTED] — Refactor Cslib/Logics/Propositional to the hybrid five-primitive
104-
└─ 174 [NOT STARTED] — Extend Cslib/Logics/Propositional/Semantics and Metalogic from th
105-
└─ 175 [NOT STARTED] — Propagate the hybrid five-primitive design to the Modal layer: Mo
106-
└─ 177 [NOT STARTED] — Propagate the hybrid five-primitive design to the Bimodal layer (
107-
└─ 176 [NOT STARTED] — Propagate the hybrid five-primitive design to the Temporal layer:
108-
└─ 177 [NOT STARTED] — Propagate the hybrid five-primitive design to the Bimodal layer ( (see above)
109-
└─ 178 [NOT STARTED] — Documentation and citation corrections from task 171 research: (1
102+
173 [NOT STARTED] — Refactor Cslib/Logics/Propositional to the hybrid five-primitive
103+
└─ 174 [NOT STARTED] — Extend Cslib/Logics/Propositional/Semantics and Metalogic from th
104+
└─ 175 [NOT STARTED] — Propagate the hybrid five-primitive design to the Modal layer: Mo
105+
└─ 177 [NOT STARTED] — Propagate the hybrid five-primitive design to the Bimodal layer (
106+
└─ 176 [NOT STARTED] — Propagate the hybrid five-primitive design to the Temporal layer:
107+
└─ 177 [NOT STARTED] — Propagate the hybrid five-primitive design to the Bimodal layer ( (see above)
108+
└─ 178 [NOT STARTED] — Documentation and citation corrections from task 171 research: (1
110109

111110
## Tasks
112111

@@ -171,11 +170,12 @@ next_project_number: 179
171170
---
172171

173172
### 172. Connectives hasand hasor full primitives
174-
- **Status**: [PLANNED]
173+
- **Status**: [COMPLETED]
175174
- **Task Type**: cslib
176175
- **Topic**: Foundations Refactor
177176
- **Dependencies**: None
178177
- **Plan**: [172_connectives_hasand_hasor_full_primitives/plans/01_hasand-hasor-plan.md]
178+
- **Summary**: [172_connectives_hasand_hasor_full_primitives/summaries/01_hasand-hasor-summary.md]
179179

180180
**Description**: Extend Cslib/Foundations/Logic/Connectives.lean for the hybrid five-primitive signature {atom, bot, imp, and, or}: add HasAnd and HasOr atomic typeclasses alongside HasBot/HasImp/HasBox/HasUntil/HasSince; update the bundled classes (PropositionalConnectives, ModalConnectives, TemporalConnectives, BimodalConnectives) to include them; revise or remove ImpBotDerived (the bot/imp-derived and/or defaults are classical-only per task 171 research and must not be presented as logic-neutral). Keep derived-connective defaults only for neg (A -> bot), top (bot -> bot), and iff, which are valid in minimal/intuitionistic/classical logic. Align design with fmontesi's PR #607 operator-typeclass direction (one class per operator, notation-level) to ease upstream reconciliation. Reference: specs/171_research_connective_basis_min_int_classical/reports/01_team-research.md.
181181

‎specs/state.json‎

Lines changed: 10 additions & 4 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -4,19 +4,24 @@
44
{
55
"project_number": 172,
66
"project_name": "connectives_hasand_hasor_full_primitives",
7-
"status": "planned",
7+
"status": "completed",
88
"task_type": "cslib",
99
"topic": "Foundations Refactor",
1010
"dependencies": [],
1111
"description": "Extend Cslib/Foundations/Logic/Connectives.lean for the hybrid five-primitive signature {atom, bot, imp, and, or}: add HasAnd and HasOr atomic typeclasses alongside HasBot/HasImp/HasBox/HasUntil/HasSince; update the bundled classes (PropositionalConnectives, ModalConnectives, TemporalConnectives, BimodalConnectives) to include them; revise or remove ImpBotDerived (the bot/imp-derived and/or defaults are classical-only per task 171 research and must not be presented as logic-neutral). Keep derived-connective defaults only for neg (A -> bot), top (bot -> bot), and iff, which are valid in minimal/intuitionistic/classical logic. Align design with fmontesi's PR #607 operator-typeclass direction (one class per operator, notation-level) to ease upstream reconciliation. Reference: specs/171_research_connective_basis_min_int_classical/reports/01_team-research.md.",
1212
"created": "2026-06-13T00:28:47Z",
13-
"last_updated": "2026-06-13T01:04:32Z",
14-
"session_id": "sess_1781312396_0c26a5",
13+
"last_updated": "2026-06-13T01:16:36Z",
14+
"session_id": "sess_1781312776_63c955",
1515
"artifacts": [
1616
{
1717
"path": "specs/172_connectives_hasand_hasor_full_primitives/plans/01_hasand-hasor-plan.md",
1818
"type": "plan",
1919
"summary": "3-phase implementation plan for HasAnd/HasOr typeclasses, ImpBotDerived trim, and docstring updates in Connectives.lean"
20+
},
21+
{
22+
"path": "specs/172_connectives_hasand_hasor_full_primitives/summaries/01_hasand-hasor-summary.md",
23+
"type": "summary",
24+
"summary": "Three phases implemented: HasAnd/HasOr standalone typeclasses added, ImpBotDerived trimmed to neg/top, module docstring updated to five-primitive design rationale. PropositionalConnectives bundled extension deferred to task 173 (abbrev-pathway does not auto-resolve in Lean 4 typeclass synthesizer)."
2025
}
2126
],
2227
"plan_metadata": {
@@ -43,7 +48,8 @@
4348
"integrated_date": "2026-06-12"
4449
}
4550
]
46-
}
51+
},
52+
"completion_summary": "Added HasAnd/HasOr atomic typeclasses to Connectives.lean, trimmed ImpBotDerived to neg/top (removed classical-only Lukasiewicz and/or defaults), updated module docstring to five-primitive design rationale. PropositionalConnectives bundled extension deferred to task 173 (abbrev-pathway resolution failed). Full build, checkInitImports, and lint-style all passed; 0 sorries."
4753
},
4854
{
4955
"project_number": 173,

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)