diff --git a/docling/backend/latex/backend.py b/docling/backend/latex/backend.py index 825594a40f..80d368e974 100644 --- a/docling/backend/latex/backend.py +++ b/docling/backend/latex/backend.py @@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ import threading from io import BytesIO from pathlib import Path -from typing import Union +from typing import Any, Union from docling_core.types.doc import DocItemLabel, DoclingDocument, NodeItem from docling_core.types.doc.document import Formatting @@ -13,7 +13,9 @@ LatexMacroNode, LatexMathNode, LatexWalker, + get_default_latex_context_db, ) +from pylatexenc.macrospec import LatexContextDb, MacroSpec from docling.backend.abstract_backend import DeclarativeDocumentBackend from docling.backend.latex.handlers.environments import EnvironmentHandlerMixin @@ -45,8 +47,7 @@ def __init__( ): super().__init__(in_doc, path_or_stream, options) self.labels: dict[str, bool] = {} - self._custom_macros: dict[str, str] = {} - self._custom_macro_num_args: dict[str, int] = {} + self._custom_macros: dict[str, Any] = {} self._input_stack: set[str] = set() self.latex_text = decode_latex_content(self.path_or_stream) @@ -78,14 +79,27 @@ def _do_parse_and_process(self, doc: DoclingDocument) -> DoclingDocument: try: self._extract_custom_macros(nodes) - self._extract_preamble_metadata(nodes, doc) + self.context_db = get_default_latex_context_db() + new_specs = [ + MacroSpec(m_name, "{" * item["num_args"]) + for m_name, item in self._custom_macros.items() + ] + self.context_db.add_context_category("custom_user_macros", macros=new_specs) + + new_walker = LatexWalker( + preprocessed_text, latex_context=self.context_db, tolerant_parsing=True + ) + new_nodes, _, _ = new_walker.get_latex_nodes() + + self._extract_preamble_metadata(new_nodes, doc) - doc_node = self._find_document_env(nodes) + self.in_macro = False + doc_node = self._find_document_env(new_nodes) if doc_node: self._process_nodes(doc_node.nodelist, doc) else: - self._process_nodes(nodes, doc) + self._process_nodes(new_nodes, doc) except Exception as e: _log.error(f"Error processing LaTeX nodes: {e}") @@ -139,11 +153,13 @@ def _process_nodes( parent: NodeItem | None = None, formatting: Formatting | None = None, text_label: DocItemLabel | None = None, + text_buffer: list[str] | None = None, ): if nodes is None: return - text_buffer: list[str] = [] + if text_buffer is None: + text_buffer = [] def flush_text_buffer(): if text_buffer: @@ -157,10 +173,7 @@ def flush_text_buffer(): ) text_buffer.clear() - idx = 0 - while idx < len(nodes): - node = nodes[idx] - consumed_following = 0 + for node in nodes: try: if isinstance(node, LatexCharsNode): self._process_chars_node( @@ -174,7 +187,7 @@ def flush_text_buffer(): ) elif isinstance(node, LatexMacroNode): - consumed_following = self._process_macro_node_inline( + self._process_macro_node_inline( node, doc, parent, @@ -182,16 +195,25 @@ def flush_text_buffer(): text_label, text_buffer, flush_text_buffer, - nodes[idx + 1 :], ) elif isinstance(node, LatexEnvironmentNode): flush_text_buffer() - self._process_environment(node, doc, parent, formatting, text_label) + self._process_environment( + node, + doc, + parent, + formatting, + text_label, + ) elif isinstance(node, LatexMathNode): self._process_math_node( - node, doc, parent, text_buffer, flush_text_buffer + node, + doc, + parent, + text_buffer, + flush_text_buffer, ) elif isinstance(node, LatexGroupNode): @@ -207,6 +229,7 @@ def flush_text_buffer(): except Exception as e: _log.warning(f"Failed to process node {type(node).__name__}: {e}") - idx += 1 + consumed_following + continue - flush_text_buffer() + if not self.in_macro: + flush_text_buffer() diff --git a/docling/backend/latex/handlers/environments.py b/docling/backend/latex/handlers/environments.py index dd0b32297a..a0251395de 100644 --- a/docling/backend/latex/handlers/environments.py +++ b/docling/backend/latex/handlers/environments.py @@ -11,6 +11,7 @@ NodeItem, ) from pylatexenc.latexwalker import LatexEnvironmentNode, LatexMacroNode +from pylatexenc.macrospec import LatexContextDb from docling.backend.latex.constants import ENV_LIST, ENV_MATH, ENV_QUOTE, ENV_THEOREM @@ -25,7 +26,17 @@ def _process_nodes( parent: "Any" = ..., formatting: "Any" = ..., text_label: "Any" = ..., + text_buffer: "Any" = ..., ) -> None: ... + def _process_math_node( + self, + node: "Any", + doc: "Any", + parent: "Any", + text_buffer: "Any", + flush_fn: "Any", + ) -> None: ... + def _expand_custom_macros(self, node: Any, depth: int = 0) -> str: ... def _clean_math(self, latex_str: str, env_name: str) -> str: ... def _parse_table(self, node: "Any") -> "Any": ... def _extract_verbatim_content(self, latex_str: str, env_name: str) -> str: ... @@ -67,11 +78,12 @@ def _process_environment( self._process_nodes(node.nodelist, doc, parent, formatting, text_label) elif node.envname.replace("*", "") in ENV_MATH: - math_text = self._clean_math(node.latex_verbatim(), node.envname) + math_text = self._expand_custom_macros(node) + math_text = self._clean_math(math_text, node.envname) doc.add_text(parent=parent, label=DocItemLabel.FORMULA, text=math_text) elif node.envname == "math": - math_text = self._clean_math(node.latex_verbatim(), node.envname) + math_text = self._expand_custom_macros(node) doc.add_text(parent=parent, label=DocItemLabel.FORMULA, text=math_text) elif node.envname == "subequations": diff --git a/docling/backend/latex/handlers/macros.py b/docling/backend/latex/handlers/macros.py index 46888e0b20..5539f1ffde 100644 --- a/docling/backend/latex/handlers/macros.py +++ b/docling/backend/latex/handlers/macros.py @@ -6,7 +6,7 @@ if TYPE_CHECKING: from io import BytesIO from pathlib import Path - from typing import Any + from typing import Any, TypedDict import pypdfium2 from docling_core.types.doc.document import ( @@ -22,9 +22,10 @@ LatexEnvironmentNode, LatexGroupNode, LatexMacroNode, + LatexMathNode, LatexWalker, - LatexWalkerParseError, ) +from pylatexenc.macrospec import LatexContextDb from docling.backend.latex.constants import ( MACROS_ACCENTS, @@ -50,9 +51,9 @@ class MacroHandlerMixin: if TYPE_CHECKING: path_or_stream: "BytesIO | Path" _input_stack: set[str] - _custom_macros: dict[str, str] - _custom_macro_num_args: dict[str, int] + _custom_macros: dict[str, Any] labels: dict[str, bool] + context_db: LatexContextDb def _process_nodes( self, @@ -61,6 +62,7 @@ def _process_nodes( parent: "Any" = ..., formatting: "Any" = ..., text_label: "Any" = ..., + text_buffer: "Any" = ..., ) -> None: ... def _nodes_to_text(self, nodes: "Any") -> str: ... @@ -84,19 +86,24 @@ def _extract_custom_macros(self, nodes, depth: int = 0): argnlist = node.nodeargd.argnlist name_arg = argnlist[1] if len(argnlist) > 1 else None - num_args_arg = argnlist[2] if len(argnlist) > 2 else None - - def_arg = None - for arg in reversed(argnlist): - if arg is not None: - def_arg = arg - break - - if name_arg and def_arg and name_arg is not def_arg: - macro_name_raw = name_arg.latex_verbatim() - macro_name = macro_name_raw.strip("{} \n\t") - if macro_name.startswith("\\"): - macro_name = macro_name[1:] + num_arg = argnlist[2] if len(argnlist) > 2 else None + def_arg = argnlist[4] if len(argnlist) > 4 else None + + if name_arg and def_arg and def_arg is not None: + macro_name = None + if isinstance(name_arg, LatexGroupNode): + first_node = name_arg.nodelist[0] + if isinstance(first_node, LatexMacroNode): + macro_name = first_node.macroname + elif isinstance(name_arg, LatexMacroNode): + macro_name = name_arg.macroname + + macro_num_args = 0 + if num_arg and num_arg.nodelist: + try: + macro_num_args = int(num_arg.nodelist[0].chars) + except ValueError: + pass macro_def = "" if hasattr(def_arg, "nodelist"): @@ -106,14 +113,20 @@ def _extract_custom_macros(self, nodes, depth: int = 0): else: macro_def = def_arg.latex_verbatim().strip("{} ") - if macro_name: - self._custom_macros[macro_name] = macro_def - self._custom_macro_num_args[macro_name] = ( - self._parse_custom_macro_num_args(num_args_arg) - ) - _log.debug( - f"Registered custom macro: \\{macro_name} -> '{macro_def}'" - ) + if macro_name is not None: + if ( + node.macroname == "providecommand" + and self._custom_macros.get(macro_name) + ): + pass + else: + self._custom_macros[macro_name] = { + "num_args": macro_num_args, + "macro_def": macro_def, + } + _log.debug( + f"Registered custom macro: \\{macro_name}[{macro_num_args}] -> '{macro_def}'" + ) if hasattr(node, "nodelist") and node.nodelist: self._extract_custom_macros(node.nodelist, depth + 1) @@ -154,6 +167,78 @@ def _extract_preamble_metadata(self, nodes, doc: DoclingDocument, depth: int = 0 arg.nodelist, doc, depth + 1 ) + def _expand_custom_macros(self, node: LatexMacroNode, depth: int = 0) -> str: + if depth > 1000: + _log.warning( + "Maximum recursion depth exceeded; possible circular macro definition." + ) + return "" + + if isinstance(node, LatexMacroNode) and node.macroname in self._custom_macros: + actual_args = [] + if node.nodeargd and node.nodeargd.argnlist: + for arg_node in node.nodeargd.argnlist: + if arg_node: + if isinstance(arg_node, LatexGroupNode): + raw = "".join(n.latex_verbatim() for n in arg_node.nodelist) + actual_args.append(raw) + else: + actual_args.append(arg_node.latex_verbatim()) + + macro_body = self._custom_macros[node.macroname]["macro_def"] + for i, arg_val in enumerate(actual_args): + macro_body = macro_body.replace(f"#{i + 1}", arg_val) + + temp_walker = LatexWalker(macro_body, latex_context=self.context_db) + temp_nodes, _, _ = temp_walker.get_latex_nodes() + + return "".join(self._expand_custom_macros(n, depth + 1) for n in temp_nodes) + + if isinstance(node, LatexCharsNode): + return node.chars + + elif isinstance(node, LatexGroupNode): + inner = "".join( + self._expand_custom_macros(n, depth + 1) for n in node.nodelist + ) + return f"{node.delimiters[0]}{inner}{node.delimiters[1]}" + + elif isinstance(node, LatexMacroNode): + res = f"\\{node.macroname}" + if node.macro_post_space: + res += node.macro_post_space + + if node.nodeargd and node.nodeargd.argnlist: + for arg in node.nodeargd.argnlist: + if arg: + res += self._expand_custom_macros(arg, depth + 1) + + return res + + elif isinstance(node, LatexEnvironmentNode): + res = f"\\begin{{{node.environmentname}}}" + + if node.nodeargd and node.nodeargd.argnlist: + for arg in node.nodeargd.argnlist: + if arg: + res += self._expand_custom_macros(arg, depth + 1) + inner = "".join( + self._expand_custom_macros(n, depth + 1) for n in node.nodelist + ) + + res += inner + res += f"\\end{{{node.environmentname}}}" + return res + + elif isinstance(node, LatexMathNode): + inner = "".join( + self._expand_custom_macros(n, depth + 1) for n in node.nodelist + ) + return f"{node.delimiters[0]}{inner}{node.delimiters[1]}" + + else: + return node.latex_verbatim() + def _process_macro_node_inline( self, node: LatexMacroNode, @@ -163,8 +248,7 @@ def _process_macro_node_inline( text_label: DocItemLabel | None, text_buffer: List[str], flush_fn: Callable[[], None], - following_nodes=None, - ) -> int: + ): if node.macroname in MACROS_INLINE_VERBATIM: if node.macroname == "~": text_buffer.append(" ") @@ -177,18 +261,23 @@ def _process_macro_node_inline( if formatted_text: text_buffer.append(formatted_text) elif node.macroname in self._custom_macros: - expansion, consumed = self._expand_custom_macro_invocation( - node, following_nodes or [] - ) - if expansion: - _log.debug( - f"Expanding custom macro \\{node.macroname} -> '{expansion}'" + res_str = self._expand_custom_macros(node) + res_walker = LatexWalker(res_str, latex_context=self.context_db) + res_nodes, _, _ = res_walker.get_latex_nodes() + + if hasattr(res_nodes, "nodelist") and res_nodes.nodelist: + self._process_nodes( + res_nodes.nodelist, doc, parent, formatting, text_label, text_buffer ) - if self._custom_macro_num_args.get(node.macroname, 0) > 0: - text_buffer.append(self._parse_latex_fragment_to_text(expansion)) - else: - text_buffer.append(expansion) - return consumed + else: + self.in_macro = True + if isinstance(res_nodes[0], LatexMacroNode): + if res_nodes[0].macroname in MACROS_STRUCTURAL: + self.in_macro = False + self._process_nodes( + res_nodes, doc, parent, formatting, text_label, text_buffer + ) + self.in_macro = False elif node.macroname in MACROS_CITATION: ref_arg = self._extract_macro_arg(node) if ref_arg: @@ -199,10 +288,14 @@ def _process_macro_node_inline( text_buffer.append(url_text) elif node.macroname in MACROS_COLOR: pass + elif node.macroname in MACROS_NEWCOMMAND: + pass else: if node.macroname in MACROS_STRUCTURAL: flush_fn() - self._process_macro(node, doc, parent, formatting, text_label) + self._process_macro( + node, doc, parent, formatting, text_label, text_buffer + ) elif node.macroname in MACROS_SPACING or node.macroname in MACROS_IGNORED: # Spacing and ignored commands are silently discarded along with # their arguments (e.g. \vspace{-1mm} should not emit "-1mm") @@ -221,7 +314,6 @@ def _process_macro_node_inline( _log.debug( f"Skipping unknown macro without arguments: {node.macroname}" ) - return 0 def _process_macro( # noqa: C901 self, @@ -230,6 +322,7 @@ def _process_macro( # noqa: C901 parent: NodeItem | None = None, formatting: Formatting | None = None, text_label: DocItemLabel | None = None, + text_buffer: list[str] | None = None, ): if node.macroname in MACROS_HEADING: title = self._extract_macro_arg(node) @@ -255,7 +348,7 @@ def _process_macro( # noqa: C901 arg = node.nodeargd.argnlist[-1] if hasattr(arg, "nodelist"): self._process_nodes( - arg.nodelist, doc, parent, formatting, text_label + arg.nodelist, doc, parent, formatting, text_label, text_buffer ) elif node.macroname in MACROS_CITATION: @@ -354,10 +447,12 @@ def _process_macro( # noqa: C901 self._input_stack.add(resolved) try: content = input_path.read_text(encoding="utf-8") - sub_walker = LatexWalker(content, tolerant_parsing=True) + sub_walker = LatexWalker( + content, self.context_db, tolerant_parsing=True + ) sub_nodes, _, _ = sub_walker.get_latex_nodes() self._process_nodes( - sub_nodes, doc, parent, formatting, text_label + sub_nodes, doc, parent, formatting, text_label, text_buffer ) _log.debug(f"Loaded input file: {input_path}") except Exception as e: @@ -440,7 +535,12 @@ def _process_macro( # noqa: C901 for arg in reversed(node.nodeargd.argnlist): if arg is not None and hasattr(arg, "nodelist"): self._process_nodes( - arg.nodelist, doc, parent, formatting, text_label + arg.nodelist, + doc, + parent, + formatting, + text_label, + text_buffer, ) break @@ -453,7 +553,12 @@ def _process_macro( # noqa: C901 for arg in node.nodeargd.argnlist: if hasattr(arg, "nodelist"): self._process_nodes( - arg.nodelist, doc, parent, formatting, text_label + arg.nodelist, + doc, + parent, + formatting, + text_label, + text_buffer, ) processed_any = True @@ -509,85 +614,6 @@ def _extract_all_macro_args_inline(self, node: LatexMacroNode) -> str: return " ".join(parts) - def _expand_macros(self, latex_str: str) -> str: - for macro_name, macro_def in self._custom_macros.items(): - if self._custom_macro_num_args.get(macro_name, 0) > 0: - continue - latex_str = re.sub( - rf"\\{re.escape(macro_name)}(?![a-zA-Z])", - lambda m: macro_def, - latex_str, - ) - return latex_str - - def _parse_custom_macro_num_args(self, num_args_arg) -> int: - if num_args_arg is None: - return 0 - - raw = num_args_arg.latex_verbatim().strip("{}[] \n\t") - try: - return int(raw) - except (TypeError, ValueError): - return 0 - - def _extract_custom_macro_invocation_args( - self, following_nodes, expected_arg_count: int - ) -> tuple[list[str], int]: - if expected_arg_count <= 0: - return [], 0 - - arg_values: list[str] = [] - consumed = 0 - - for next_node in following_nodes: - if len(arg_values) >= expected_arg_count: - break - - if isinstance(next_node, LatexCharsNode) and not next_node.chars.strip(): - consumed += 1 - continue - - if isinstance(next_node, LatexGroupNode): - arg_values.append(self._nodes_to_text(next_node.nodelist or [])) - consumed += 1 - continue - - break - - return arg_values, consumed - - def _render_custom_macro_expansion( - self, macro_name: str, arg_values: list[str] - ) -> str: - expansion = self._custom_macros[macro_name] - for idx in range(len(arg_values), 0, -1): - expansion = expansion.replace(f"#{idx}", arg_values[idx - 1]) - return expansion - - def _parse_latex_fragment_to_text(self, latex_fragment: str) -> str: - try: - walker = LatexWalker(latex_fragment, tolerant_parsing=True) - parsed_nodes, _, _ = walker.get_latex_nodes() - except LatexWalkerParseError: - return latex_fragment - - return self._nodes_to_text(parsed_nodes) - - def _expand_custom_macro_invocation( - self, node: LatexMacroNode, following_nodes - ) -> tuple[str, int]: - expected_arg_count = self._custom_macro_num_args.get(node.macroname, 0) - if expected_arg_count <= 0: - return self._custom_macros[node.macroname], 0 - - arg_values, consumed = self._extract_custom_macro_invocation_args( - following_nodes, expected_arg_count - ) - if len(arg_values) < expected_arg_count: - return self._custom_macros[node.macroname], 0 - - return self._render_custom_macro_expansion(node.macroname, arg_values), consumed - def _get_heading_level(self, macroname: str) -> int: levels = { "part": 1, diff --git a/docling/backend/latex/handlers/math.py b/docling/backend/latex/handlers/math.py index d0b7ea83e0..944a8dd6c9 100644 --- a/docling/backend/latex/handlers/math.py +++ b/docling/backend/latex/handlers/math.py @@ -13,7 +13,7 @@ class MathHandlerMixin: if TYPE_CHECKING: - def _expand_macros(self, latex_str: str) -> str: ... + def _expand_custom_macros(self, node: Any, depth: int = 0) -> str: ... def _process_math_node( self, @@ -31,10 +31,11 @@ def _process_math_node( if is_display: flush_fn() - math_text = self._clean_math(node.latex_verbatim(), "display") + latex_str = self._expand_custom_macros(node) + math_text = self._clean_math(latex_str, "display") doc.add_text(parent=parent, label=DocItemLabel.FORMULA, text=math_text) else: - text_buffer.append(self._expand_macros(node.latex_verbatim())) + text_buffer.append(self._expand_custom_macros(node)) def _clean_math(self, latex_str: str, env_name: str) -> str: if env_name in ENV_MATH_CLEAN: @@ -55,6 +56,5 @@ def _clean_math(self, latex_str: str, env_name: str) -> str: latex_str = latex_str[2:-2] latex_str = re.sub(r"\\label\{.*?\}", "", latex_str) - latex_str = self._expand_macros(latex_str) return latex_str.strip() diff --git a/docling/backend/latex/utils/text.py b/docling/backend/latex/utils/text.py index b6177adb68..57bbf06ffc 100644 --- a/docling/backend/latex/utils/text.py +++ b/docling/backend/latex/utils/text.py @@ -17,6 +17,7 @@ LatexMacroNode, LatexMathNode, ) +from pylatexenc.macrospec import LatexContextDb from docling.backend.latex.constants import ( MACROS_CITATION, @@ -30,8 +31,7 @@ class TextHelperMixin: if TYPE_CHECKING: - _custom_macros: dict[str, str] - _custom_macro_num_args: dict[str, int] + _custom_macros: dict[str, Any] def _process_nodes( self, @@ -40,13 +40,10 @@ def _process_nodes( parent: "Any" = ..., formatting: "Any" = ..., text_label: "Any" = ..., + text_buffer: "Any" = ..., ) -> None: ... def _extract_macro_arg(self, node: "Any") -> str: ... - def _expand_macros(self, latex_str: str) -> str: ... - def _expand_custom_macro_invocation( - self, node: "Any", following_nodes: "Any" - ) -> tuple[str, int]: ... - def _parse_latex_fragment_to_text(self, latex_fragment: str) -> str: ... + def _expand_custom_macros(self, node: Any, depth: int = 0) -> str: ... def _process_chars_node( self, @@ -69,7 +66,7 @@ def _process_chars_node( flush_fn() - for part in parts[1:]: + for part in parts[1:-1]: part_stripped = part.strip() if part_stripped: doc.add_text( @@ -78,6 +75,12 @@ def _process_chars_node( text=part_stripped, formatting=formatting, ) + last_part = parts[-1] + if last_part: + if last_part.endswith(" "): + text_buffer.append(last_part.strip() + " ") + else: + text_buffer.append(last_part.strip()) else: text_buffer.append(text) @@ -109,10 +112,7 @@ def _extract_verbatim_content(self, latex_str: str, env_name: str) -> str: def _nodes_to_text(self, nodes) -> str: text_parts = [] - idx = 0 - while idx < len(nodes): - node = nodes[idx] - consumed_following = 0 + for node in nodes: if isinstance(node, LatexCharsNode): text_parts.append(node.chars) @@ -139,13 +139,8 @@ def _nodes_to_text(self, nodes) -> str: elif node.macroname in MACROS_ESCAPED: text_parts.append(node.macroname) elif node.macroname in self._custom_macros: - expansion, consumed_following = ( - self._expand_custom_macro_invocation(node, nodes[idx + 1 :]) - ) - if self._custom_macro_num_args.get(node.macroname, 0) > 0: - text_parts.append(self._parse_latex_fragment_to_text(expansion)) - else: - text_parts.append(expansion) + expansion = self._expand_custom_macros(node) + text_parts.append(expansion) elif ( node.macroname in MACROS_SPACING or node.macroname in MACROS_IGNORED ): @@ -170,14 +165,13 @@ def _nodes_to_text(self, nodes) -> str: text_parts.append(" ".join(arg_parts)) elif isinstance(node, LatexMathNode): - text_parts.append(self._expand_macros(node.latex_verbatim())) + text_parts.append(self._expand_custom_macros(node)) elif isinstance(node, LatexEnvironmentNode): if node.envname in ["equation", "align", "gather"]: text_parts.append(node.latex_verbatim()) else: text_parts.append(self._nodes_to_text(node.nodelist)) - idx += 1 + consumed_following result = "".join(text_parts) result = re.sub(r" +", " ", result) diff --git a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/1706.03762_main.tex.itxt b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/1706.03762_main.tex.itxt index b343cda3a5..d8cec4db8a 100644 --- a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/1706.03762_main.tex.itxt +++ b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/1706.03762_main.tex.itxt @@ -8,281 +8,245 @@ item-0 at level 0: unspecified: group _root_ item-5 at level 1: text: The dominant sequence transducti ... with large and limited training data. item-6 at level 1: section_header: Introduction item-7 at level 1: text: Recurrent neural networks, long ... 015effective,jozefowicz2016exploring]. - item-8 at level 1: paragraph: Recurrent models typically facto ... y generate a sequence of hidden states - item-9 at level 1: text: $h_t$, as a function of the prev ... uential computation, however, remains. - item-10 at level 1: paragraph: Attention mechanisms have become ... tance in the input or output sequences - item-11 at level 1: text: [bahdanau2014neural, structuredA ... conjunction with a recurrent network. - item-12 at level 1: paragraph: In this work we propose the Tran ... le as twelve hours on eight P100 GPUs. - item-13 at level 1: section_header: Background - item-14 at level 1: text: The goal of reducing sequential ... s described in section[sec:attention]. - item-15 at level 1: paragraph: Self-attention, sometimes called ... k-independent sentence representations - item-16 at level 1: text: [cheng2016long, decomposableAttnModel, paulus2017deep, lin2017structured]. - item-17 at level 1: paragraph: End-to-end memory networks are b ... answering and language modeling tasks - item-18 at level 1: text: [sukhbaatar2015]. - item-19 at level 1: paragraph: To the best of our knowledge, ho ... uss its advantages over models such as - item-20 at level 1: text: [neural_gpu, NalBytenet2017] and [JonasFaceNet2017]. - item-21 at level 1: section_header: Model Architecture - item-22 at level 1: section: group figure - item-23 at level 2: picture - item-23 at level 3: caption: Image: Figures/ModalNet-21 - item-24 at level 2: text: The Transformer - model architecture. - item-25 at level 1: caption: Image: Figures/ModalNet-21 - item-26 at level 1: paragraph: Most competitive neural sequence ... dels have an encoder-decoder structure - item-27 at level 1: text: [cho2014learning,bahdanau2014neu ... tional input when generating the next. - item-28 at level 1: paragraph: The Transformer follows this ove ... in the left and right halves of Figure - item-29 at level 1: text: [fig:model-arch], respectively. - item-30 at level 1: section_header: Encoder and Decoder Stacks - item-31 at level 1: text: Encoder:The encoder is composed ... s of dimension $d_{\text{model}}=512$. - item-32 at level 1: text: Decoder:The decoder is also comp ... wn outputs at positions less than $i$. - item-33 at level 1: section_header: Attention - item-34 at level 1: text: An attention function can be des ... the query with the corresponding key. - item-35 at level 1: section_header: Scaled Dot-Product Attention - item-36 at level 1: paragraph: We call our particular attention "Scaled Dot-Product Attention" (Figure - item-37 at level 1: text: [fig:multi-head-att]). The inp ... n to obtain the weights on the values. - item-38 at level 1: paragraph: In practice, we compute the atte ... neously, packed together into a matrix - item-39 at level 1: text: $Q$. The keys and values are a ... We compute the matrix of outputs as: - item-40 at level 1: formula: \mathrm{Attention}(Q, K, V) = \mathrm{softmax}(\frac{QK^T}{\sqrt{d_k}})V - item-41 at level 1: paragraph: The two most commonly used attention functions are additive attention - item-42 at level 1: text: [bahdanau2014neural], and dot-pr ... optimized matrix multiplication code. - item-43 at level 1: paragraph: While for small values of - item-44 at level 1: text: $d_k$ the two mechanisms perform ... where it has extremely small gradients - item-45 at level 1: footnote: To illustrate why the dot produc ... k_i$, has mean $0$ and variance $d_k$. - item-46 at level 1: text: . To counteract this effect, we ... ot products by $\frac{1}{\sqrt{d_k}}$. - item-47 at level 1: section_header: Multi-Head Attention - item-48 at level 1: section: group figure - item-49 at level 2: text: [t]0.5 - item-50 at level 2: text: Scaled Dot-Product Attention - item-51 at level 2: picture - item-51 at level 3: caption: Image: Figures/ModalNet-19 - item-52 at level 2: text: [t]0.5 - item-53 at level 2: text: Multi-Head Attention - item-54 at level 2: picture - item-54 at level 3: caption: Image: Figures/ModalNet-20 - item-55 at level 2: text: (left) Scaled Dot-Product Attent ... attention layers running in parallel. - item-56 at level 1: caption: Image: Figures/ModalNet-19 - item-57 at level 1: caption: Image: Figures/ModalNet-20 - item-58 at level 1: paragraph: Instead of performing a single attention function with - item-59 at level 1: text: $d_{\text{model}}$-dimensional k ... epicted in Figure[fig:multi-head-att]. - item-60 at level 1: paragraph: Multi-head attention allows the ... tention head, averaging inhibits this. - item-61 at level 1: formula: \begin{align*} + item-8 at level 1: text: Recurrent models typically facto ... uential computation, however, remains. + item-9 at level 1: text: Attention mechanisms have become ... conjunction with a recurrent network. + item-10 at level 1: text: In this work we propose the Tran ... le as twelve hours on eight P100 GPUs. + item-11 at level 1: section_header: Background + item-12 at level 1: text: The goal of reducing sequential ... s described in section[sec:attention]. + item-13 at level 1: text: Self-attention, sometimes called ... l, paulus2017deep, lin2017structured]. + item-14 at level 1: text: End-to-end memory networks are b ... guage modeling tasks [sukhbaatar2015]. + item-15 at level 1: text: To the best of our knowledge, ho ... alBytenet2017] and [JonasFaceNet2017]. + item-16 at level 1: section_header: Model Architecture + item-17 at level 1: section: group figure + item-18 at level 2: picture + item-18 at level 3: caption: Image: Figures/ModalNet-21 + item-19 at level 2: text: The Transformer - model architecture. + item-20 at level 1: caption: Image: Figures/ModalNet-21 + item-21 at level 1: text: Most competitive neural sequence ... tional input when generating the next. + item-22 at level 1: text: The Transformer follows this ove ... Figure[fig:model-arch], respectively. + item-23 at level 1: section_header: Encoder and Decoder Stacks + item-24 at level 1: text: Encoder:The encoder is composed ... s of dimension $d_{\text{model}}=512$. + item-25 at level 1: text: Decoder:The decoder is also comp ... wn outputs at positions less than $i$. + item-26 at level 1: section_header: Attention + item-27 at level 1: text: An attention function can be des ... the query with the corresponding key. + item-28 at level 1: section_header: Scaled Dot-Product Attention + item-29 at level 1: text: We call our particular attention ... n to obtain the weights on the values. + item-30 at level 1: text: In practice, we compute the atte ... We compute the matrix of outputs as: + item-31 at level 1: formula: \mathrm{Attention}(Q, K, V) = \mathrm{softmax}(\frac{QK^T}{\sqrt{d_k}})V + item-32 at level 1: text: The two most commonly used atten ... optimized matrix multiplication code. + item-33 at level 1: text: While for small values of $d_k$ ... where it has extremely small gradients + item-34 at level 1: footnote: To illustrate why the dot produc ... k_i$, has mean $0$ and variance $d_k$. + item-35 at level 1: text: . To counteract this effect, we ... ot products by $\frac{1}{\sqrt{d_k}}$. + item-36 at level 1: section_header: Multi-Head Attention + item-37 at level 1: section: group figure + item-38 at level 2: text: [t]0.5 + item-39 at level 2: text: Scaled Dot-Product Attention + item-40 at level 2: picture + item-40 at level 3: caption: Image: Figures/ModalNet-19 + item-41 at level 2: text: [t]0.5 + item-42 at level 2: text: Multi-Head Attention + item-43 at level 2: picture + item-43 at level 3: caption: Image: Figures/ModalNet-20 + item-44 at level 2: text: (left) Scaled Dot-Product Attent ... attention layers running in parallel. + item-45 at level 1: caption: Image: Figures/ModalNet-19 + item-46 at level 1: caption: Image: Figures/ModalNet-20 + item-47 at level 1: text: Instead of performing a single a ... epicted in Figure[fig:multi-head-att]. + item-48 at level 1: paragraph: Multi-head attention allows the ... tention head, averaging inhibits this. + item-49 at level 1: formula: \begin{align*} \mathrm{Multi ... QW^Q_i, KW^K_i, VW^V_i)\\ \end{align*} - item-62 at level 1: paragraph: Where the projections are parameter matrices - item-63 at level 1: text: $W^Q_i \in \mathbb{R}^{d_{\text{ ... bb{R}^{hd_v \times d_{\text{model}}}$. - item-64 at level 1: paragraph: In this work we employ - item-65 at level 1: text: $h=8$ parallel attention layers, ... ad attention with full dimensionality. - item-66 at level 1: section_header: Applications of Attention in our Model - item-67 at level 1: paragraph: The Transformer uses multi-head attention in three different ways: - item-68 at level 1: list: group list - item-69 at level 2: list_item: In "encoder-decoder attention" l ... bahdanau2014neural,JonasFaceNet2017]. - item-70 at level 2: list_item: The encoder contains self-attent ... in the previous layer of the encoder. - item-71 at level 2: list_item: Similarly, self-attention layers ... ions. See Figure[fig:multi-head-att]. - item-72 at level 1: section_header: Position-wise Feed-Forward Networks - item-73 at level 1: paragraph: In addition to attention sub-lay ... ons with a ReLU activation in between. - item-74 at level 1: formula: \mathrm{FFN}(x)=\max(0, xW_1 + b_1) W_2 + b_2 - item-75 at level 1: paragraph: While the linear transformations ... dimensionality of input and output is - item-76 at level 1: text: $d_{\text{model}}=512$, and the ... ayer has dimensionality $d_{ff}=2048$. - item-77 at level 1: section_header: Embeddings and Softmax - item-78 at level 1: text: Similarly to other sequence tran ... weights by $\sqrt{d_{\text{model}}}$. - item-79 at level 1: section_header: Positional Encoding - item-80 at level 1: text: Since our model contains no recu ... learned and fixed [JonasFaceNet2017]. - item-81 at level 1: paragraph: In this work, we use sine and cosine functions of different frequencies: - item-82 at level 1: formula: \begin{align*} + item-50 at level 1: text: Where the projections are parame ... bb{R}^{hd_v \times d_{\text{model}}}$. + item-51 at level 1: text: In this work we employ $h=8$ par ... ad attention with full dimensionality. + item-52 at level 1: section_header: Applications of Attention in our Model + item-53 at level 1: text: The Transformer uses multi-head attention in three different ways: + item-54 at level 1: list: group list + item-55 at level 2: list_item: In "encoder-decoder attention" l ... bahdanau2014neural,JonasFaceNet2017]. + item-56 at level 2: list_item: The encoder contains self-attent ... in the previous layer of the encoder. + item-57 at level 2: list_item: Similarly, self-attention layers ... ions. See Figure[fig:multi-head-att]. + item-58 at level 1: section_header: Position-wise Feed-Forward Networks + item-59 at level 1: paragraph: In addition to attention sub-lay ... ons with a ReLU activation in between. + item-60 at level 1: formula: \mathrm{FFN}(x)=\max(0, xW_1 + b_1) W_2 + b_2 + item-61 at level 1: text: While the linear transformations ... ayer has dimensionality $d_{ff}=2048$. + item-62 at level 1: section_header: Embeddings and Softmax + item-63 at level 1: text: Similarly to other sequence tran ... weights by $\sqrt{d_{\text{model}}}$. + item-64 at level 1: section_header: Positional Encoding + item-65 at level 1: text: Since our model contains no recu ... learned and fixed [JonasFaceNet2017]. + item-66 at level 1: paragraph: In this work, we use sine and cosine functions of different frequencies: + item-67 at level 1: formula: \begin{align*} PE_{(pos,2i)} ... 00^{2i/d_{\text{model}}}) \end{align*} - item-83 at level 1: paragraph: where - item-84 at level 1: text: $pos$ is the position and $i$ is ... ed as a linear function of $PE_{pos}$. - item-85 at level 1: paragraph: We also experimented with using learned positional embeddings - item-86 at level 1: text: [JonasFaceNet2017] instead, and ... the ones encountered during training. - item-87 at level 1: section_header: Why Self-Attention - item-88 at level 1: paragraph: In this section we compare vario ... gth sequence of symbol representations - item-89 at level 1: text: $(x_1, ..., x_n)$ to another seq ... ttention we consider three desiderata. - item-90 at level 1: paragraph: One is the total computational c ... ber of sequential operations required. - item-91 at level 1: paragraph: The third is the path length bet ... it is to learn long-range dependencies - item-92 at level 1: text: [hochreiter2001gradient]. Hence ... composed of the different layer types. - item-93 at level 1: text: Maximum path lengths, per-layer ... hborhood in restricted self-attention. - item-94 at level 1: table with [7x4] - item-95 at level 1: paragraph: As noted in Table - item-96 at level 1: text: [tab:op_complexities], a self-at ... this approach further in future work. - item-97 at level 1: paragraph: A single convolutional layer with kernel width - item-98 at level 1: text: $k < n$ does not connect all pai ... er, the approach we take in our model. - item-99 at level 1: paragraph: As side benefit, self-attention ... d semantic structure of the sentences. - item-100 at level 1: section_header: Training - item-101 at level 1: text: This section describes the training regime for our models. - item-102 at level 1: section_header: Training Data and Batching - item-103 at level 1: text: We trained on the standard WMT 2 ... source tokens and 25000 target tokens. - item-104 at level 1: section_header: Hardware and Schedule - item-105 at level 1: paragraph: We trained our models on one mac ... (described on the bottom line of table - item-106 at level 1: text: [tab:variations]), step time was ... trained for 300,000 steps (3.5 days). - item-107 at level 1: section_header: Optimizer - item-108 at level 1: text: We used the Adam optimizer[kingm ... of training, according to the formula: - item-109 at level 1: formula: lrate = d_{\text{model}}^{-0.5} ... ep\_num} \cdot {warmup\_steps}^{-1.5}) - item-110 at level 1: paragraph: This corresponds to increasing the learning rate linearly for the first - item-111 at level 1: text: $warmup\_steps$ training steps, ... number. We used $warmup\_steps=4000$. - item-112 at level 1: section_header: Regularization - item-113 at level 1: paragraph: We employ three types of regularization during training: - item-114 at level 1: text: Residual Dropout We apply dropou ... odel, we use a rate of $P_{drop}=0.1$. - item-115 at level 1: text: Label Smoothing During training, ... but improves accuracy and BLEU score. - item-116 at level 1: section_header: Results - item-117 at level 1: section_header: Machine Translation - item-118 at level 1: text: The Transformer achieves better ... ts at a fraction of the training cost. - item-119 at level 1: table with [13x43] - item-120 at level 1: paragraph: On the WMT 2014 English-to-Germa ... rmer model (Transformer (big) in Table - item-121 at level 1: text: [tab:wmt-results]) outperforms t ... cost of any of the competitive models. - item-122 at level 1: paragraph: On the WMT 2014 English-to-Frenc ... our big model achieves a BLEU score of - item-123 at level 1: text: $41.0$, outperforming all of the ... rate $P_{drop}=0.1$, instead of $0.3$. - item-124 at level 1: paragraph: For the base models, we used a s ... e used beam search with a beam size of - item-125 at level 1: text: $4$ and length penalty $\alpha=0 ... te early when possible [wu2016google]. - item-126 at level 1: paragraph: Table - item-127 at level 1: text: [tab:wmt-results] summarizes our ... on floating-point capacity of each GPU - item-128 at level 1: footnote: We used values of 2.8, 3.7, 6.0 ... K80, K40, M40 and P100, respectively. - item-129 at level 1: text: . - item-130 at level 1: section_header: Model Variations - item-131 at level 1: text: Variations on the Transformer ar ... be compared to per-word perplexities. - item-132 at level 1: table with [23x13] - item-133 at level 1: paragraph: To evaluate the importance of di ... ng. We present these results in Table - item-134 at level 1: text: [tab:variations]. - item-135 at level 1: paragraph: In Table - item-136 at level 1: text: [tab:variations] rows (A), we va ... ty also drops off with too many heads. - item-137 at level 1: paragraph: In Table - item-138 at level 1: text: [tab:variations] rows (B), we ob ... y identical results to the base model. - item-139 at level 1: section_header: English Constituency Parsing - item-140 at level 1: text: The Transformer generalizes well ... ing (Results are on Section 23 of WSJ) - item-141 at level 1: table with [14x4] - item-142 at level 1: paragraph: To evaluate if the Transformer c ... -the-art results in small-data regimes - item-143 at level 1: text: [KVparse15]. - item-144 at level 1: paragraph: We trained a 4-layer transformer with - item-145 at level 1: text: $d_{model} = 1024$ on the Wall S ... okens for the semi-supervised setting. - item-146 at level 1: paragraph: We performed only a small number ... , both attention and residual (section - item-147 at level 1: text: [sec:reg]), learning rates and b ... only and the semi-supervised setting. - item-148 at level 1: paragraph: Our results in Table - item-149 at level 1: text: [tab:parsing-results] show that ... Neural Network Grammar [dyer-rnng:16]. - item-150 at level 1: paragraph: In contrast to RNN sequence-to-sequence models - item-151 at level 1: text: [KVparse15], the Transformer out ... the WSJ training set of 40K sentences. - item-152 at level 1: section_header: Conclusion - item-153 at level 1: text: In this work, we presented the T ... ures with multi-headed self-attention. - item-154 at level 1: paragraph: For translation tasks, the Trans ... ven all previously reported ensembles. - item-155 at level 1: paragraph: We are excited about the future ... ial is another research goals of ours. - item-156 at level 1: paragraph: The code we used to train and evaluate our models is available at - item-157 at level 1: text: https://github.com/tensorflow/tensor2tensor. - item-158 at level 1: text: AcknowledgementsWe are grateful ... comments, corrections and inspiration. - item-159 at level 1: text: plain - item-160 at level 1: section_header: References - item-161 at level 1: list: group bibliography - item-162 at level 2: list_item: 10 - item-163 at level 2: list_item: layernorm2016 + item-68 at level 1: text: where $pos$ is the position and ... ed as a linear function of $PE_{pos}$. + item-69 at level 1: text: We also experimented with using ... the ones encountered during training. + item-70 at level 1: section_header: Why Self-Attention + item-71 at level 1: text: In this section we compare vario ... ttention we consider three desiderata. + item-72 at level 1: paragraph: One is the total computational c ... ber of sequential operations required. + item-73 at level 1: text: The third is the path length bet ... composed of the different layer types. + item-74 at level 1: text: Maximum path lengths, per-layer ... hborhood in restricted self-attention. + item-75 at level 1: table with [7x4] + item-76 at level 1: text: As noted in Table [tab:op_comple ... this approach further in future work. + item-77 at level 1: text: A single convolutional layer wit ... er, the approach we take in our model. + item-78 at level 1: paragraph: As side benefit, self-attention ... d semantic structure of the sentences. + item-79 at level 1: section_header: Training + item-80 at level 1: text: This section describes the training regime for our models. + item-81 at level 1: section_header: Training Data and Batching + item-82 at level 1: text: We trained on the standard WMT 2 ... source tokens and 25000 target tokens. + item-83 at level 1: section_header: Hardware and Schedule + item-84 at level 1: text: We trained our models on one mac ... trained for 300,000 steps (3.5 days). + item-85 at level 1: section_header: Optimizer + item-86 at level 1: text: We used the Adam optimizer[kingm ... of training, according to the formula: + item-87 at level 1: formula: lrate = d_{\text{model}}^{-0.5} ... ep\_num} \cdot {warmup\_steps}^{-1.5}) + item-88 at level 1: text: This corresponds to increasing t ... number. We used $warmup\_steps=4000$. + item-89 at level 1: section_header: Regularization + item-90 at level 1: text: We employ three types of regularization during training: + item-91 at level 1: text: Residual Dropout We apply dropou ... odel, we use a rate of $P_{drop}=0.1$. + item-92 at level 1: text: Label Smoothing During training, ... but improves accuracy and BLEU score. + item-93 at level 1: section_header: Results + item-94 at level 1: section_header: Machine Translation + item-95 at level 1: text: The Transformer achieves better ... ts at a fraction of the training cost. + item-96 at level 1: table with [13x43] + item-97 at level 1: text: On the WMT 2014 English-to-Germa ... cost of any of the competitive models. + item-98 at level 1: text: On the WMT 2014 English-to-Frenc ... rate $P_{drop}=0.1$, instead of $0.3$. + item-99 at level 1: text: For the base models, we used a s ... te early when possible [wu2016google]. + item-100 at level 1: text: Table [tab:wmt-results] summariz ... on floating-point capacity of each GPU + item-101 at level 1: footnote: We used values of 2.8, 3.7, 6.0 ... K80, K40, M40 and P100, respectively. + item-102 at level 1: text: . + item-103 at level 1: section_header: Model Variations + item-104 at level 1: text: Variations on the Transformer ar ... be compared to per-word perplexities. + item-105 at level 1: table with [23x13] + item-106 at level 1: text: To evaluate the importance of di ... hese results in Table[tab:variations]. + item-107 at level 1: text: In Table[tab:variations] rows (A ... ty also drops off with too many heads. + item-108 at level 1: text: In Table[tab:variations] rows (B ... y identical results to the base model. + item-109 at level 1: section_header: English Constituency Parsing + item-110 at level 1: text: The Transformer generalizes well ... ing (Results are on Section 23 of WSJ) + item-111 at level 1: table with [14x4] + item-112 at level 1: text: To evaluate if the Transformer c ... lts in small-data regimes [KVparse15]. + item-113 at level 1: text: We trained a 4-layer transformer ... okens for the semi-supervised setting. + item-114 at level 1: text: We performed only a small number ... only and the semi-supervised setting. + item-115 at level 1: text: Our results in Table[tab:parsing ... Neural Network Grammar [dyer-rnng:16]. + item-116 at level 1: text: In contrast to RNN sequence-to-s ... the WSJ training set of 40K sentences. + item-117 at level 1: section_header: Conclusion + item-118 at level 1: text: In this work, we presented the T ... ures with multi-headed self-attention. + item-119 at level 1: text: For translation tasks, the Trans ... ven all previously reported ensembles. + item-120 at level 1: paragraph: We are excited about the future ... ial is another research goals of ours. + item-121 at level 1: text: The code we used to train and ev ... //github.com/tensorflow/tensor2tensor. + item-122 at level 1: text: AcknowledgementsWe are grateful ... comments, corrections and inspiration. + item-123 at level 1: text: plain + item-124 at level 1: section_header: References + item-125 at level 1: list: group bibliography + item-126 at level 2: list_item: 10 + item-127 at level 2: list_item: layernorm2016 JimmyLei Ba, Jamie ... arXiv preprint arXiv:1607.06450, 2016. - item-164 at level 2: list_item: bahdanau2014neural + item-128 at level 2: list_item: bahdanau2014neural Dzmitry Bahda ... translate. CoRR, abs/1409.0473, 2014. - item-165 at level 2: list_item: DBLP:journals/corr/BritzGLL17 + item-129 at level 2: list_item: DBLP:journals/corr/BritzGLL17 De ... itectures. CoRR, abs/1703.03906, 2017. - item-166 at level 2: list_item: cheng2016long + item-130 at level 2: list_item: cheng2016long Jianpeng Cheng, Li ... arXiv preprint arXiv:1601.06733, 2016. - item-167 at level 2: list_item: cho2014learning + item-131 at level 2: list_item: cho2014learning Kyunghyun Cho, B ... ranslation. CoRR, abs/1406.1078, 2014. - item-168 at level 2: list_item: xception2016 + item-132 at level 2: list_item: xception2016 Francois Chollet. X ... arXiv preprint arXiv:1610.02357, 2016. - item-169 at level 2: list_item: gruEval14 + item-133 at level 2: list_item: gruEval14 Junyoung Chung, Caglar ... modeling. CoRR, abs/1412.3555, 2014. - item-170 at level 2: list_item: dyer-rnng:16 + item-134 at level 2: list_item: dyer-rnng:16 Chris Dyer, Adhigun ... ork grammars. In Proc. of NAACL, 2016. - item-171 at level 2: list_item: JonasFaceNet2017 + item-135 at level 2: list_item: JonasFaceNet2017 Jonas Gehring, ... Xiv preprint arXiv:1705.03122v2, 2017. - item-172 at level 2: list_item: graves2013generating + item-136 at level 2: list_item: graves2013generating Alex Graves ... arXiv preprint arXiv:1308.0850, 2013. - item-173 at level 2: list_item: he2016deep + item-137 at level 2: list_item: he2016deep Kaiming He, Xiangyu Z ... ttern Recognition, pages 770778, 2016. - item-174 at level 2: list_item: hochreiter2001gradient + item-138 at level 2: list_item: hochreiter2001gradient Sepp Hoch ... arning long-term dependencies, 2001. - item-175 at level 2: list_item: hochreiter1997 + item-139 at level 2: list_item: hochreiter1997 Sepp Hochreiter a ... ural computation, 9(8):17351780, 1997. - item-176 at level 2: list_item: huang-harper:2009:EMNLP + item-140 at level 2: list_item: huang-harper:2009:EMNLP Zhongqia ... ssing, pages 832841. ACL, August 2009. - item-177 at level 2: list_item: jozefowicz2016exploring + item-141 at level 2: list_item: jozefowicz2016exploring Rafal Jo ... arXiv preprint arXiv:1602.02410, 2016. - item-178 at level 2: list_item: extendedngpu + item-142 at level 2: list_item: extendedngpu ukasz Kaiser and Sa ... on Processing Systems, (NIPS), 2016. - item-179 at level 2: list_item: neural_gpu + item-143 at level 2: list_item: neural_gpu ukasz Kaiser and Ilya ... earning Representations (ICLR), 2016. - item-180 at level 2: list_item: NalBytenet2017 + item-144 at level 2: list_item: NalBytenet2017 Nal Kalchbrenner, ... Xiv preprint arXiv:1610.10099v2, 2017. - item-181 at level 2: list_item: structuredAttentionNetworks + item-145 at level 2: list_item: structuredAttentionNetworks Yoon ... nce on Learning Representations, 2017. - item-182 at level 2: list_item: kingma2014adam + item-146 at level 2: list_item: kingma2014adam Diederik Kingma a ... tochastic optimization. In ICLR, 2015. - item-183 at level 2: list_item: Kuchaiev2017Factorization + item-147 at level 2: list_item: Kuchaiev2017Factorization Oleksi ... arXiv preprint arXiv:1703.10722, 2017. - item-184 at level 2: list_item: lin2017structured + item-148 at level 2: list_item: lin2017structured Zhouhan Lin, M ... arXiv preprint arXiv:1703.03130, 2017. - item-185 at level 2: list_item: multiseq2seq + item-149 at level 2: list_item: multiseq2seq Minh-Thang Luong, Q ... arXiv preprint arXiv:1511.06114, 2015. - item-186 at level 2: list_item: luong2015effective + item-150 at level 2: list_item: luong2015effective Minh-Thang Lu ... arXiv preprint arXiv:1508.04025, 2015. - item-187 at level 2: list_item: marcus1993building + item-151 at level 2: list_item: marcus1993building MitchellP Mar ... ional linguistics, 19(2):313330, 1993. - item-188 at level 2: list_item: mcclosky-etAl:2006:NAACL + item-152 at level 2: list_item: mcclosky-etAl:2006:NAACL David M ... ference, pages 152159. ACL, June 2006. - item-189 at level 2: list_item: decomposableAttnModel + item-153 at level 2: list_item: decomposableAttnModel Ankur Pari ... in Natural Language Processing, 2016. - item-190 at level 2: list_item: paulus2017deep + item-154 at level 2: list_item: paulus2017deep Romain Paulus, Ca ... arXiv preprint arXiv:1705.04304, 2017. - item-191 at level 2: list_item: petrov-EtAl:2006:ACL + item-155 at level 2: list_item: petrov-EtAl:2006:ACL Slav Petrov ... e ACL, pages 433440. ACL, July 2006. - item-192 at level 2: list_item: press2016using + item-156 at level 2: list_item: press2016using Ofir Press and Li ... arXiv preprint arXiv:1608.05859, 2016. - item-193 at level 2: list_item: sennrich2015neural + item-157 at level 2: list_item: sennrich2015neural Rico Sennrich ... arXiv preprint arXiv:1508.07909, 2015. - item-194 at level 2: list_item: shazeer2017outrageously + item-158 at level 2: list_item: shazeer2017outrageously Noam Sha ... arXiv preprint arXiv:1701.06538, 2017. - item-195 at level 2: list_item: srivastava2014dropout + item-159 at level 2: list_item: srivastava2014dropout Nitish Sri ... arning Research, 15(1):19291958, 2014. - item-196 at level 2: list_item: sukhbaatar2015 + item-160 at level 2: list_item: sukhbaatar2015 Sainbayar Sukhbaa ... 402448. Curran Associates, Inc., 2015. - item-197 at level 2: list_item: sutskever14 + item-161 at level 2: list_item: sutskever14 Ilya Sutskever, Orio ... ssing Systems, pages 31043112, 2014. - item-198 at level 2: list_item: DBLP:journals/corr/SzegedyVISW15 ... er vision. + item-162 at level 2: list_item: DBLP:journals/corr/SzegedyVISW15 ... er vision. CoRR, abs/1512.00567, 2015. - item-199 at level 2: list_item: KVparse15 + item-163 at level 2: list_item: KVparse15 Vinyals & Kaiser, Koo, ... Information Processing Systems, 2015. - item-200 at level 2: list_item: wu2016google + item-164 at level 2: list_item: wu2016google Yonghui Wu, Mike Sc ... arXiv preprint arXiv:1609.08144, 2016. - item-201 at level 2: list_item: DBLP:journals/corr/ZhouCWLX16 + item-165 at level 2: list_item: DBLP:journals/corr/ZhouCWLX16 Ji ... anslation. CoRR, abs/1606.04199, 2016. - item-202 at level 2: list_item: zhu-EtAl:2013:ACL + item-166 at level 2: list_item: zhu-EtAl:2013:ACL Muhua Zhu, Yue ... pers), pages 434443. ACL, August 2013. - item-203 at level 1: section_header: Attention Visualizations - item-204 at level 1: section: group figure - item-205 at level 2: picture - item-205 at level 3: caption: Image: ./vis/making_more_difficult5_new.pdf - item-206 at level 2: text: An example of the attention mech ... different heads. Best viewed in color. - item-207 at level 1: caption: Image: ./vis/making_more_difficult5_new.pdf - item-208 at level 1: section: group figure - item-209 at level 2: picture - item-209 at level 3: caption: Image: ./vis/anaphora_resolution_new.pdf - item-210 at level 2: picture - item-210 at level 3: caption: Image: ./vis/anaphora_resolution2_new.pdf - item-211 at level 2: text: Two attention heads, also in lay ... tentions are very sharp for this word. - item-212 at level 1: caption: Image: ./vis/anaphora_resolution_new.pdf - item-213 at level 1: caption: Image: ./vis/anaphora_resolution2_new.pdf - item-214 at level 1: section: group figure - item-215 at level 2: picture - item-215 at level 3: caption: Image: ./vis/attending_to_head_new.pdf - item-216 at level 2: picture - item-216 at level 3: caption: Image: ./vis/attending_to_head2_new.pdf - item-217 at level 2: text: Many of the attention heads exhi ... ly learned to perform different tasks. - item-218 at level 1: caption: Image: ./vis/attending_to_head_new.pdf - item-219 at level 1: caption: Image: ./vis/attending_to_head2_new.pdf \ No newline at end of file + item-167 at level 1: section_header: Attention Visualizations + item-168 at level 1: section: group figure + item-169 at level 2: picture + item-169 at level 3: caption: Image: ./vis/making_more_difficult5_new.pdf + item-170 at level 2: text: An example of the attention mech ... different heads. Best viewed in color. + item-171 at level 1: caption: Image: ./vis/making_more_difficult5_new.pdf + item-172 at level 1: section: group figure + item-173 at level 2: picture + item-173 at level 3: caption: Image: ./vis/anaphora_resolution_new.pdf + item-174 at level 2: picture + item-174 at level 3: caption: Image: ./vis/anaphora_resolution2_new.pdf + item-175 at level 2: text: Two attention heads, also in lay ... tentions are very sharp for this word. + item-176 at level 1: caption: Image: ./vis/anaphora_resolution_new.pdf + item-177 at level 1: caption: Image: ./vis/anaphora_resolution2_new.pdf + item-178 at level 1: section: group figure + item-179 at level 2: picture + item-179 at level 3: caption: Image: ./vis/attending_to_head_new.pdf + item-180 at level 2: picture + item-180 at level 3: caption: Image: ./vis/attending_to_head2_new.pdf + item-181 at level 2: text: Many of the attention heads exhi ... ly learned to perform different tasks. + item-182 at level 1: caption: Image: ./vis/attending_to_head_new.pdf + item-183 at level 1: caption: Image: ./vis/attending_to_head2_new.pdf \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/1706.03762_main.tex.json b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/1706.03762_main.tex.json index c0cdef1868..25bc385296 100644 --- a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/1706.03762_main.tex.json +++ b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/1706.03762_main.tex.json @@ -61,10 +61,10 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/15" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/16" + "$ref": "#/groups/0" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/17" + "$ref": "#/texts/16" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/18" @@ -76,10 +76,10 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/20" }, { - "$ref": "#/groups/0" + "$ref": "#/texts/21" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/21" + "$ref": "#/texts/22" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/23" @@ -115,26 +115,14 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/33" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/34" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/35" + "$ref": "#/groups/1" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/36" }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/37" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/38" - }, { "$ref": "#/texts/39" }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/40" - }, { "$ref": "#/texts/41" }, @@ -148,13 +136,19 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/44" }, { - "$ref": "#/groups/1" + "$ref": "#/texts/45" + }, + { + "$ref": "#/texts/46" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/47" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/50" + "$ref": "#/groups/2" + }, + { + "$ref": "#/texts/51" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/52" @@ -187,7 +181,13 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/61" }, { - "$ref": "#/groups/2" + "$ref": "#/texts/62" + }, + { + "$ref": "#/texts/63" + }, + { + "$ref": "#/texts/64" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/65" @@ -198,6 +198,9 @@ { "$ref": "#/texts/67" }, + { + "$ref": "#/tables/0" + }, { "$ref": "#/texts/68" }, @@ -256,10 +259,10 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/86" }, { - "$ref": "#/tables/0" + "$ref": "#/texts/87" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/87" + "$ref": "#/tables/1" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/88" @@ -285,6 +288,9 @@ { "$ref": "#/texts/95" }, + { + "$ref": "#/tables/2" + }, { "$ref": "#/texts/96" }, @@ -300,6 +306,9 @@ { "$ref": "#/texts/100" }, + { + "$ref": "#/tables/3" + }, { "$ref": "#/texts/101" }, @@ -330,9 +339,6 @@ { "$ref": "#/texts/110" }, - { - "$ref": "#/tables/1" - }, { "$ref": "#/texts/111" }, @@ -342,149 +348,35 @@ { "$ref": "#/texts/113" }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/114" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/115" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/116" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/117" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/118" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/119" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/120" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/121" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/122" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/tables/2" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/123" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/124" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/125" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/126" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/127" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/128" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/129" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/130" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/tables/3" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/131" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/132" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/133" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/134" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/135" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/136" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/137" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/138" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/139" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/140" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/141" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/142" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/143" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/144" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/145" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/146" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/147" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/148" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/149" - }, { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/191" + "$ref": "#/texts/155" }, { "$ref": "#/groups/4" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/192" + "$ref": "#/texts/156" }, { "$ref": "#/groups/5" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/194" + "$ref": "#/texts/158" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/195" + "$ref": "#/texts/159" }, { "$ref": "#/groups/6" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/197" + "$ref": "#/texts/161" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/198" + "$ref": "#/texts/162" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -502,7 +394,7 @@ "$ref": "#/pictures/0" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/22" + "$ref": "#/texts/17" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -516,25 +408,25 @@ }, "children": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/45" + "$ref": "#/texts/34" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/46" + "$ref": "#/texts/35" }, { "$ref": "#/pictures/1" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/48" + "$ref": "#/texts/37" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/49" + "$ref": "#/texts/38" }, { "$ref": "#/pictures/2" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/51" + "$ref": "#/texts/40" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -548,13 +440,13 @@ }, "children": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/62" + "$ref": "#/texts/48" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/63" + "$ref": "#/texts/49" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/64" + "$ref": "#/texts/50" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -568,127 +460,127 @@ }, "children": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/150" + "$ref": "#/texts/114" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/151" + "$ref": "#/texts/115" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/152" + "$ref": "#/texts/116" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/153" + "$ref": "#/texts/117" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/154" + "$ref": "#/texts/118" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/155" + "$ref": "#/texts/119" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/156" + "$ref": "#/texts/120" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/157" + "$ref": "#/texts/121" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/158" + "$ref": "#/texts/122" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/159" + "$ref": "#/texts/123" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/160" + "$ref": "#/texts/124" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/161" + "$ref": "#/texts/125" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/162" + "$ref": "#/texts/126" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/163" + "$ref": "#/texts/127" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/164" + "$ref": "#/texts/128" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/165" + "$ref": "#/texts/129" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/166" + "$ref": "#/texts/130" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/167" + "$ref": "#/texts/131" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/168" + "$ref": "#/texts/132" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/169" + "$ref": "#/texts/133" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/170" + "$ref": "#/texts/134" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/171" + "$ref": "#/texts/135" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/172" + "$ref": "#/texts/136" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/173" + "$ref": "#/texts/137" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/174" + "$ref": "#/texts/138" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/175" + "$ref": "#/texts/139" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/176" + "$ref": "#/texts/140" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/177" + "$ref": "#/texts/141" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/178" + "$ref": "#/texts/142" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/179" + "$ref": "#/texts/143" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/180" + "$ref": "#/texts/144" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/181" + "$ref": "#/texts/145" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/182" + "$ref": "#/texts/146" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/183" + "$ref": "#/texts/147" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/184" + "$ref": "#/texts/148" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/185" + "$ref": "#/texts/149" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/186" + "$ref": "#/texts/150" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/187" + "$ref": "#/texts/151" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/188" + "$ref": "#/texts/152" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/189" + "$ref": "#/texts/153" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/190" + "$ref": "#/texts/154" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -705,7 +597,7 @@ "$ref": "#/pictures/3" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/193" + "$ref": "#/texts/157" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -725,7 +617,7 @@ "$ref": "#/pictures/5" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/196" + "$ref": "#/texts/160" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -745,7 +637,7 @@ "$ref": "#/pictures/7" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/199" + "$ref": "#/texts/163" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -847,10 +739,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "Recurrent models typically factor computation along the symbol positions of the input and output sequences. Aligning the positions to steps in computation time, they generate a sequence of hidden states", - "text": "Recurrent models typically factor computation along the symbol positions of the input and output sequences. Aligning the positions to steps in computation time, they generate a sequence of hidden states" + "orig": "Recurrent models typically factor computation along the symbol positions of the input and output sequences. Aligning the positions to steps in computation time, they generate a sequence of hidden states $h_t$, as a function of the previous hidden state $h_{t-1}$ and the input for position $t$. This inherently sequential nature precludes parallelization within training examples, which becomes critical at longer sequence lengths, as memory constraints limit batching across examples.\nRecent work has achieved significant improvements in computational efficiency through factorization tricks [Kuchaiev2017Factorization] and conditional computation [shazeer2017outrageously], while also improving model performance in case of the latter. The fundamental constraint of sequential computation, however, remains.", + "text": "Recurrent models typically factor computation along the symbol positions of the input and output sequences. Aligning the positions to steps in computation time, they generate a sequence of hidden states $h_t$, as a function of the previous hidden state $h_{t-1}$ and the input for position $t$. This inherently sequential nature precludes parallelization within training examples, which becomes critical at longer sequence lengths, as memory constraints limit batching across examples.\nRecent work has achieved significant improvements in computational efficiency through factorization tricks [Kuchaiev2017Factorization] and conditional computation [shazeer2017outrageously], while also improving model performance in case of the latter. The fundamental constraint of sequential computation, however, remains." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/8", @@ -861,8 +753,8 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "$h_t$, as a function of the previous hidden state $h_{t-1}$ and the input for position $t$. This inherently sequential nature precludes parallelization within training examples, which becomes critical at longer sequence lengths, as memory constraints limit batching across examples.\nRecent work has achieved significant improvements in computational efficiency through factorization tricks [Kuchaiev2017Factorization] and conditional computation [shazeer2017outrageously], while also improving model performance in case of the latter. The fundamental constraint of sequential computation, however, remains.", - "text": "$h_t$, as a function of the previous hidden state $h_{t-1}$ and the input for position $t$. This inherently sequential nature precludes parallelization within training examples, which becomes critical at longer sequence lengths, as memory constraints limit batching across examples.\nRecent work has achieved significant improvements in computational efficiency through factorization tricks [Kuchaiev2017Factorization] and conditional computation [shazeer2017outrageously], while also improving model performance in case of the latter. The fundamental constraint of sequential computation, however, remains." + "orig": "Attention mechanisms have become an integral part of compelling sequence modeling and transduction models in various tasks, allowing modeling of dependencies without regard to their distance in the input or output sequences [bahdanau2014neural, structuredAttentionNetworks]. In all but a few cases [decomposableAttnModel], however, such attention mechanisms are used in conjunction with a recurrent network.", + "text": "Attention mechanisms have become an integral part of compelling sequence modeling and transduction models in various tasks, allowing modeling of dependencies without regard to their distance in the input or output sequences [bahdanau2014neural, structuredAttentionNetworks]. In all but a few cases [decomposableAttnModel], however, such attention mechanisms are used in conjunction with a recurrent network." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/9", @@ -871,10 +763,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "Attention mechanisms have become an integral part of compelling sequence modeling and transduction models in various tasks, allowing modeling of dependencies without regard to their distance in the input or output sequences", - "text": "Attention mechanisms have become an integral part of compelling sequence modeling and transduction models in various tasks, allowing modeling of dependencies without regard to their distance in the input or output sequences" + "orig": "In this work we propose the Transformer, a model architecture eschewing recurrence and instead relying entirely on an attention mechanism to draw global dependencies between input and output. The Transformer allows for significantly more parallelization and can reach a new state of the art in translation quality after being trained for as little as twelve hours on eight P100 GPUs.", + "text": "In this work we propose the Transformer, a model architecture eschewing recurrence and instead relying entirely on an attention mechanism to draw global dependencies between input and output. The Transformer allows for significantly more parallelization and can reach a new state of the art in translation quality after being trained for as little as twelve hours on eight P100 GPUs." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/10", @@ -883,10 +775,11 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", + "label": "section_header", "prov": [], - "orig": "[bahdanau2014neural, structuredAttentionNetworks]. In all but a few cases [decomposableAttnModel], however, such attention mechanisms are used in conjunction with a recurrent network.", - "text": "[bahdanau2014neural, structuredAttentionNetworks]. In all but a few cases [decomposableAttnModel], however, such attention mechanisms are used in conjunction with a recurrent network." + "orig": "Background", + "text": "Background", + "level": 1 }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/11", @@ -895,10 +788,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "In this work we propose the Transformer, a model architecture eschewing recurrence and instead relying entirely on an attention mechanism to draw global dependencies between input and output. The Transformer allows for significantly more parallelization and can reach a new state of the art in translation quality after being trained for as little as twelve hours on eight P100 GPUs.", - "text": "In this work we propose the Transformer, a model architecture eschewing recurrence and instead relying entirely on an attention mechanism to draw global dependencies between input and output. The Transformer allows for significantly more parallelization and can reach a new state of the art in translation quality after being trained for as little as twelve hours on eight P100 GPUs." + "orig": "The goal of reducing sequential computation also forms the foundation of the Extended Neural GPU [extendedngpu], ByteNet [NalBytenet2017] and ConvS2S [JonasFaceNet2017], all of which use convolutional neural networks as basic building block, computing hidden representations in parallel for all input and output positions. In these models, the number of operations required to relate signals from two arbitrary input or output positions grows in the distance between positions, linearly for ConvS2S and logarithmically for ByteNet. This makes it more difficult to learn dependencies between distant positions [hochreiter2001gradient]. In the Transformer this is reduced to a constant number of operations, albeit at the cost of reduced effective resolution due to averaging attention-weighted positions, an effect we counteract with Multi-Head Attention as described in section[sec:attention].", + "text": "The goal of reducing sequential computation also forms the foundation of the Extended Neural GPU [extendedngpu], ByteNet [NalBytenet2017] and ConvS2S [JonasFaceNet2017], all of which use convolutional neural networks as basic building block, computing hidden representations in parallel for all input and output positions. In these models, the number of operations required to relate signals from two arbitrary input or output positions grows in the distance between positions, linearly for ConvS2S and logarithmically for ByteNet. This makes it more difficult to learn dependencies between distant positions [hochreiter2001gradient]. In the Transformer this is reduced to a constant number of operations, albeit at the cost of reduced effective resolution due to averaging attention-weighted positions, an effect we counteract with Multi-Head Attention as described in section[sec:attention]." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/12", @@ -907,11 +800,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "section_header", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "Background", - "text": "Background", - "level": 1 + "orig": "Self-attention, sometimes called intra-attention is an attention mechanism relating different positions of a single sequence in order to compute a representation of the sequence. Self-attention has been used successfully in a variety of tasks including reading comprehension, abstractive summarization, textual entailment and learning task-independent sentence representations [cheng2016long, decomposableAttnModel, paulus2017deep, lin2017structured].", + "text": "Self-attention, sometimes called intra-attention is an attention mechanism relating different positions of a single sequence in order to compute a representation of the sequence. Self-attention has been used successfully in a variety of tasks including reading comprehension, abstractive summarization, textual entailment and learning task-independent sentence representations [cheng2016long, decomposableAttnModel, paulus2017deep, lin2017structured]." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/13", @@ -922,8 +814,8 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "The goal of reducing sequential computation also forms the foundation of the Extended Neural GPU [extendedngpu], ByteNet [NalBytenet2017] and ConvS2S [JonasFaceNet2017], all of which use convolutional neural networks as basic building block, computing hidden representations in parallel for all input and output positions. In these models, the number of operations required to relate signals from two arbitrary input or output positions grows in the distance between positions, linearly for ConvS2S and logarithmically for ByteNet. This makes it more difficult to learn dependencies between distant positions [hochreiter2001gradient]. In the Transformer this is reduced to a constant number of operations, albeit at the cost of reduced effective resolution due to averaging attention-weighted positions, an effect we counteract with Multi-Head Attention as described in section[sec:attention].", - "text": "The goal of reducing sequential computation also forms the foundation of the Extended Neural GPU [extendedngpu], ByteNet [NalBytenet2017] and ConvS2S [JonasFaceNet2017], all of which use convolutional neural networks as basic building block, computing hidden representations in parallel for all input and output positions. In these models, the number of operations required to relate signals from two arbitrary input or output positions grows in the distance between positions, linearly for ConvS2S and logarithmically for ByteNet. This makes it more difficult to learn dependencies between distant positions [hochreiter2001gradient]. In the Transformer this is reduced to a constant number of operations, albeit at the cost of reduced effective resolution due to averaging attention-weighted positions, an effect we counteract with Multi-Head Attention as described in section[sec:attention]." + "orig": "End-to-end memory networks are based on a recurrent attention mechanism instead of sequence-aligned recurrence and have been shown to perform well on simple-language question answering and language modeling tasks [sukhbaatar2015].", + "text": "End-to-end memory networks are based on a recurrent attention mechanism instead of sequence-aligned recurrence and have been shown to perform well on simple-language question answering and language modeling tasks [sukhbaatar2015]." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/14", @@ -932,10 +824,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "Self-attention, sometimes called intra-attention is an attention mechanism relating different positions of a single sequence in order to compute a representation of the sequence. Self-attention has been used successfully in a variety of tasks including reading comprehension, abstractive summarization, textual entailment and learning task-independent sentence representations", - "text": "Self-attention, sometimes called intra-attention is an attention mechanism relating different positions of a single sequence in order to compute a representation of the sequence. Self-attention has been used successfully in a variety of tasks including reading comprehension, abstractive summarization, textual entailment and learning task-independent sentence representations" + "orig": "To the best of our knowledge, however, the Transformer is the first transduction model relying entirely on self-attention to compute representations of its input and output without using sequence-aligned RNNs or convolution.\nIn the following sections, we will describe the Transformer, motivate self-attention and discuss its advantages over models such as [neural_gpu, NalBytenet2017] and [JonasFaceNet2017].", + "text": "To the best of our knowledge, however, the Transformer is the first transduction model relying entirely on self-attention to compute representations of its input and output without using sequence-aligned RNNs or convolution.\nIn the following sections, we will describe the Transformer, motivate self-attention and discuss its advantages over models such as [neural_gpu, NalBytenet2017] and [JonasFaceNet2017]." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/15", @@ -944,10 +836,11 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", + "label": "section_header", "prov": [], - "orig": "[cheng2016long, decomposableAttnModel, paulus2017deep, lin2017structured].", - "text": "[cheng2016long, decomposableAttnModel, paulus2017deep, lin2017structured]." + "orig": "Model Architecture", + "text": "Model Architecture", + "level": 1 }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/16", @@ -956,22 +849,22 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "caption", "prov": [], - "orig": "End-to-end memory networks are based on a recurrent attention mechanism instead of sequence-aligned recurrence and have been shown to perform well on simple-language question answering and language modeling tasks", - "text": "End-to-end memory networks are based on a recurrent attention mechanism instead of sequence-aligned recurrence and have been shown to perform well on simple-language question answering and language modeling tasks" + "orig": "Image: Figures/ModalNet-21", + "text": "Image: Figures/ModalNet-21" }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/17", "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" + "$ref": "#/groups/0" }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[sukhbaatar2015].", - "text": "[sukhbaatar2015]." + "orig": "The Transformer - model architecture.", + "text": "The Transformer - model architecture." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/18", @@ -980,10 +873,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "To the best of our knowledge, however, the Transformer is the first transduction model relying entirely on self-attention to compute representations of its input and output without using sequence-aligned RNNs or convolution.\nIn the following sections, we will describe the Transformer, motivate self-attention and discuss its advantages over models such as", - "text": "To the best of our knowledge, however, the Transformer is the first transduction model relying entirely on self-attention to compute representations of its input and output without using sequence-aligned RNNs or convolution.\nIn the following sections, we will describe the Transformer, motivate self-attention and discuss its advantages over models such as" + "orig": "Most competitive neural sequence transduction models have an encoder-decoder structure [cho2014learning,bahdanau2014neural,sutskever14]. Here, the encoder maps an input sequence of symbol representations $(x_1, ..., x_n)$ to a sequence of continuous representations $\\mathbf{z} = (z_1, ..., z_n)$. Given $\\mathbf{z}$, the decoder then generates an output sequence $(y_1,...,y_m)$ of symbols one element at a time. At each step the model is auto-regressive [graves2013generating], consuming the previously generated symbols as additional input when generating the next.", + "text": "Most competitive neural sequence transduction models have an encoder-decoder structure [cho2014learning,bahdanau2014neural,sutskever14]. Here, the encoder maps an input sequence of symbol representations $(x_1, ..., x_n)$ to a sequence of continuous representations $\\mathbf{z} = (z_1, ..., z_n)$. Given $\\mathbf{z}$, the decoder then generates an output sequence $(y_1,...,y_m)$ of symbols one element at a time. At each step the model is auto-regressive [graves2013generating], consuming the previously generated symbols as additional input when generating the next." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/19", @@ -994,8 +887,8 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[neural_gpu, NalBytenet2017] and [JonasFaceNet2017].", - "text": "[neural_gpu, NalBytenet2017] and [JonasFaceNet2017]." + "orig": "The Transformer follows this overall architecture using stacked self-attention and point-wise, fully connected layers for both the encoder and decoder, shown in the left and right halves of Figure[fig:model-arch], respectively.", + "text": "The Transformer follows this overall architecture using stacked self-attention and point-wise, fully connected layers for both the encoder and decoder, shown in the left and right halves of Figure[fig:model-arch], respectively." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/20", @@ -1006,9 +899,9 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "section_header", "prov": [], - "orig": "Model Architecture", - "text": "Model Architecture", - "level": 1 + "orig": "Encoder and Decoder Stacks", + "text": "Encoder and Decoder Stacks", + "level": 2 }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/21", @@ -1017,22 +910,22 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "caption", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "Image: Figures/ModalNet-21", - "text": "Image: Figures/ModalNet-21" + "orig": "Encoder:The encoder is composed of a stack of $N=6$ identical layers. Each layer has two sub-layers. The first is a multi-head self-attention mechanism, and the second is a simple, position-wise fully connected feed-forward network. We employ a residual connection [he2016deep] around each of the two sub-layers, followed by layer normalization [layernorm2016]. That is, the output of each sub-layer is $\\mathrm{LayerNorm}(x + \\mathrm{Sublayer}(x))$, where $\\mathrm{Sublayer}(x)$ is the function implemented by the sub-layer itself. To facilitate these residual connections, all sub-layers in the model, as well as the embedding layers, produce outputs of dimension $d_{\\text{model}}=512$.", + "text": "Encoder:The encoder is composed of a stack of $N=6$ identical layers. Each layer has two sub-layers. The first is a multi-head self-attention mechanism, and the second is a simple, position-wise fully connected feed-forward network. We employ a residual connection [he2016deep] around each of the two sub-layers, followed by layer normalization [layernorm2016]. That is, the output of each sub-layer is $\\mathrm{LayerNorm}(x + \\mathrm{Sublayer}(x))$, where $\\mathrm{Sublayer}(x)$ is the function implemented by the sub-layer itself. To facilitate these residual connections, all sub-layers in the model, as well as the embedding layers, produce outputs of dimension $d_{\\text{model}}=512$." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/22", "parent": { - "$ref": "#/groups/0" + "$ref": "#/body" }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "The Transformer - model architecture.", - "text": "The Transformer - model architecture." + "orig": "Decoder:The decoder is also composed of a stack of $N=6$ identical layers. In addition to the two sub-layers in each encoder layer, the decoder inserts a third sub-layer, which performs multi-head attention over the output of the encoder stack. Similar to the encoder, we employ residual connections around each of the sub-layers, followed by layer normalization. We also modify the self-attention sub-layer in the decoder stack to prevent positions from attending to subsequent positions. This masking, combined with fact that the output embeddings are offset by one position, ensures that the predictions for position $i$ can depend only on the known outputs at positions less than $i$.", + "text": "Decoder:The decoder is also composed of a stack of $N=6$ identical layers. In addition to the two sub-layers in each encoder layer, the decoder inserts a third sub-layer, which performs multi-head attention over the output of the encoder stack. Similar to the encoder, we employ residual connections around each of the sub-layers, followed by layer normalization. We also modify the self-attention sub-layer in the decoder stack to prevent positions from attending to subsequent positions. This masking, combined with fact that the output embeddings are offset by one position, ensures that the predictions for position $i$ can depend only on the known outputs at positions less than $i$." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/23", @@ -1041,10 +934,11 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "section_header", "prov": [], - "orig": "Most competitive neural sequence transduction models have an encoder-decoder structure", - "text": "Most competitive neural sequence transduction models have an encoder-decoder structure" + "orig": "Attention", + "text": "Attention", + "level": 2 }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/24", @@ -1055,8 +949,8 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[cho2014learning,bahdanau2014neural,sutskever14]. Here, the encoder maps an input sequence of symbol representations $(x_1, ..., x_n)$ to a sequence of continuous representations $\\mathbf{z} = (z_1, ..., z_n)$. Given $\\mathbf{z}$, the decoder then generates an output sequence $(y_1,...,y_m)$ of symbols one element at a time. At each step the model is auto-regressive [graves2013generating], consuming the previously generated symbols as additional input when generating the next.", - "text": "[cho2014learning,bahdanau2014neural,sutskever14]. Here, the encoder maps an input sequence of symbol representations $(x_1, ..., x_n)$ to a sequence of continuous representations $\\mathbf{z} = (z_1, ..., z_n)$. Given $\\mathbf{z}$, the decoder then generates an output sequence $(y_1,...,y_m)$ of symbols one element at a time. At each step the model is auto-regressive [graves2013generating], consuming the previously generated symbols as additional input when generating the next." + "orig": "An attention function can be described as mapping a query and a set of key-value pairs to an output, where the query, keys, values, and output are all vectors. The output is computed as a weighted sum of the values, where the weight assigned to each value is computed by a compatibility function of the query with the corresponding key.", + "text": "An attention function can be described as mapping a query and a set of key-value pairs to an output, where the query, keys, values, and output are all vectors. The output is computed as a weighted sum of the values, where the weight assigned to each value is computed by a compatibility function of the query with the corresponding key." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/25", @@ -1065,10 +959,11 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "section_header", "prov": [], - "orig": "The Transformer follows this overall architecture using stacked self-attention and point-wise, fully connected layers for both the encoder and decoder, shown in the left and right halves of Figure", - "text": "The Transformer follows this overall architecture using stacked self-attention and point-wise, fully connected layers for both the encoder and decoder, shown in the left and right halves of Figure" + "orig": "Scaled Dot-Product Attention", + "text": "Scaled Dot-Product Attention", + "level": 3 }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/26", @@ -1079,8 +974,8 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[fig:model-arch], respectively.", - "text": "[fig:model-arch], respectively." + "orig": "We call our particular attention \"Scaled Dot-Product Attention\" (Figure[fig:multi-head-att]). The input consists of queries and keys of dimension $d_k$, and values of dimension $d_v$. We compute the dot products of the query with all keys, divide each by $\\sqrt{d_k}$, and apply a softmax function to obtain the weights on the values.", + "text": "We call our particular attention \"Scaled Dot-Product Attention\" (Figure[fig:multi-head-att]). The input consists of queries and keys of dimension $d_k$, and values of dimension $d_v$. We compute the dot products of the query with all keys, divide each by $\\sqrt{d_k}$, and apply a softmax function to obtain the weights on the values." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/27", @@ -1089,11 +984,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "section_header", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "Encoder and Decoder Stacks", - "text": "Encoder and Decoder Stacks", - "level": 2 + "orig": "In practice, we compute the attention function on a set of queries simultaneously, packed together into a matrix $Q$. The keys and values are also packed together into matrices $K$ and $V$. We compute the matrix of outputs as:", + "text": "In practice, we compute the attention function on a set of queries simultaneously, packed together into a matrix $Q$. The keys and values are also packed together into matrices $K$ and $V$. We compute the matrix of outputs as:" }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/28", @@ -1102,10 +996,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", + "label": "formula", "prov": [], - "orig": "Encoder:The encoder is composed of a stack of $N=6$ identical layers. Each layer has two sub-layers. The first is a multi-head self-attention mechanism, and the second is a simple, position-wise fully connected feed-forward network. We employ a residual connection [he2016deep] around each of the two sub-layers, followed by layer normalization [layernorm2016]. That is, the output of each sub-layer is $\\mathrm{LayerNorm}(x + \\mathrm{Sublayer}(x))$, where $\\mathrm{Sublayer}(x)$ is the function implemented by the sub-layer itself. To facilitate these residual connections, all sub-layers in the model, as well as the embedding layers, produce outputs of dimension $d_{\\text{model}}=512$.", - "text": "Encoder:The encoder is composed of a stack of $N=6$ identical layers. Each layer has two sub-layers. The first is a multi-head self-attention mechanism, and the second is a simple, position-wise fully connected feed-forward network. We employ a residual connection [he2016deep] around each of the two sub-layers, followed by layer normalization [layernorm2016]. That is, the output of each sub-layer is $\\mathrm{LayerNorm}(x + \\mathrm{Sublayer}(x))$, where $\\mathrm{Sublayer}(x)$ is the function implemented by the sub-layer itself. To facilitate these residual connections, all sub-layers in the model, as well as the embedding layers, produce outputs of dimension $d_{\\text{model}}=512$." + "orig": "\\mathrm{Attention}(Q, K, V) = \\mathrm{softmax}(\\frac{QK^T}{\\sqrt{d_k}})V", + "text": "\\mathrm{Attention}(Q, K, V) = \\mathrm{softmax}(\\frac{QK^T}{\\sqrt{d_k}})V" }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/29", @@ -1116,8 +1010,8 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "Decoder:The decoder is also composed of a stack of $N=6$ identical layers. In addition to the two sub-layers in each encoder layer, the decoder inserts a third sub-layer, which performs multi-head attention over the output of the encoder stack. Similar to the encoder, we employ residual connections around each of the sub-layers, followed by layer normalization. We also modify the self-attention sub-layer in the decoder stack to prevent positions from attending to subsequent positions. This masking, combined with fact that the output embeddings are offset by one position, ensures that the predictions for position $i$ can depend only on the known outputs at positions less than $i$.", - "text": "Decoder:The decoder is also composed of a stack of $N=6$ identical layers. In addition to the two sub-layers in each encoder layer, the decoder inserts a third sub-layer, which performs multi-head attention over the output of the encoder stack. Similar to the encoder, we employ residual connections around each of the sub-layers, followed by layer normalization. We also modify the self-attention sub-layer in the decoder stack to prevent positions from attending to subsequent positions. This masking, combined with fact that the output embeddings are offset by one position, ensures that the predictions for position $i$ can depend only on the known outputs at positions less than $i$." + "orig": "The two most commonly used attention functions are additive attention [bahdanau2014neural], and dot-product (multiplicative) attention. Dot-product attention is identical to our algorithm, except for the scaling factor of $\\frac{1}{\\sqrt{d_k}}$. Additive attention computes the compatibility function using a feed-forward network with a single hidden layer. While the two are similar in theoretical complexity, dot-product attention is much faster and more space-efficient in practice, since it can be implemented using highly optimized matrix multiplication code.", + "text": "The two most commonly used attention functions are additive attention [bahdanau2014neural], and dot-product (multiplicative) attention. Dot-product attention is identical to our algorithm, except for the scaling factor of $\\frac{1}{\\sqrt{d_k}}$. Additive attention computes the compatibility function using a feed-forward network with a single hidden layer. While the two are similar in theoretical complexity, dot-product attention is much faster and more space-efficient in practice, since it can be implemented using highly optimized matrix multiplication code." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/30", @@ -1126,11 +1020,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "section_header", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "Attention", - "text": "Attention", - "level": 2 + "orig": "While for small values of $d_k$ the two mechanisms perform similarly, additive attention outperforms dot product attention without scaling for larger values of $d_k$ [DBLP:journals/corr/BritzGLL17]. We suspect that for large values of $d_k$, the dot products grow large in magnitude, pushing the softmax function into regions where it has extremely small gradients", + "text": "While for small values of $d_k$ the two mechanisms perform similarly, additive attention outperforms dot product attention without scaling for larger values of $d_k$ [DBLP:journals/corr/BritzGLL17]. We suspect that for large values of $d_k$, the dot products grow large in magnitude, pushing the softmax function into regions where it has extremely small gradients" }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/31", @@ -1139,10 +1032,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", + "label": "footnote", "prov": [], - "orig": "An attention function can be described as mapping a query and a set of key-value pairs to an output, where the query, keys, values, and output are all vectors. The output is computed as a weighted sum of the values, where the weight assigned to each value is computed by a compatibility function of the query with the corresponding key.", - "text": "An attention function can be described as mapping a query and a set of key-value pairs to an output, where the query, keys, values, and output are all vectors. The output is computed as a weighted sum of the values, where the weight assigned to each value is computed by a compatibility function of the query with the corresponding key." + "orig": "To illustrate why the dot products get large, assume that the components of $q$ and $k$ are independent random variables with mean $0$ and variance $1$. Then their dot product, $q \\cdot k = \\sum_{i=1}^{d_k} q_ik_i$, has mean $0$ and variance $d_k$.", + "text": "To illustrate why the dot products get large, assume that the components of $q$ and $k$ are independent random variables with mean $0$ and variance $1$. Then their dot product, $q \\cdot k = \\sum_{i=1}^{d_k} q_ik_i$, has mean $0$ and variance $d_k$." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/32", @@ -1151,11 +1044,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "section_header", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "Scaled Dot-Product Attention", - "text": "Scaled Dot-Product Attention", - "level": 3 + "orig": ". To counteract this effect, we scale the dot products by $\\frac{1}{\\sqrt{d_k}}$.", + "text": ". To counteract this effect, we scale the dot products by $\\frac{1}{\\sqrt{d_k}}$." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/33", @@ -1164,148 +1056,16 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "section_header", "prov": [], - "orig": "We call our particular attention \"Scaled Dot-Product Attention\" (Figure", - "text": "We call our particular attention \"Scaled Dot-Product Attention\" (Figure" + "orig": "Multi-Head Attention", + "text": "Multi-Head Attention", + "level": 3 }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/34", "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", - "prov": [], - "orig": "[fig:multi-head-att]). The input consists of queries and keys of dimension $d_k$, and values of dimension $d_v$. We compute the dot products of the query with all keys, divide each by $\\sqrt{d_k}$, and apply a softmax function to obtain the weights on the values.", - "text": "[fig:multi-head-att]). The input consists of queries and keys of dimension $d_k$, and values of dimension $d_v$. We compute the dot products of the query with all keys, divide each by $\\sqrt{d_k}$, and apply a softmax function to obtain the weights on the values." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/35", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "In practice, we compute the attention function on a set of queries simultaneously, packed together into a matrix", - "text": "In practice, we compute the attention function on a set of queries simultaneously, packed together into a matrix" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/36", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", - "prov": [], - "orig": "$Q$. The keys and values are also packed together into matrices $K$ and $V$. We compute the matrix of outputs as:", - "text": "$Q$. The keys and values are also packed together into matrices $K$ and $V$. We compute the matrix of outputs as:" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/37", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "formula", - "prov": [], - "orig": "\\mathrm{Attention}(Q, K, V) = \\mathrm{softmax}(\\frac{QK^T}{\\sqrt{d_k}})V", - "text": "\\mathrm{Attention}(Q, K, V) = \\mathrm{softmax}(\\frac{QK^T}{\\sqrt{d_k}})V" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/38", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "The two most commonly used attention functions are additive attention", - "text": "The two most commonly used attention functions are additive attention" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/39", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", - "prov": [], - "orig": "[bahdanau2014neural], and dot-product (multiplicative) attention. Dot-product attention is identical to our algorithm, except for the scaling factor of $\\frac{1}{\\sqrt{d_k}}$. Additive attention computes the compatibility function using a feed-forward network with a single hidden layer. While the two are similar in theoretical complexity, dot-product attention is much faster and more space-efficient in practice, since it can be implemented using highly optimized matrix multiplication code.", - "text": "[bahdanau2014neural], and dot-product (multiplicative) attention. Dot-product attention is identical to our algorithm, except for the scaling factor of $\\frac{1}{\\sqrt{d_k}}$. Additive attention computes the compatibility function using a feed-forward network with a single hidden layer. While the two are similar in theoretical complexity, dot-product attention is much faster and more space-efficient in practice, since it can be implemented using highly optimized matrix multiplication code." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/40", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "While for small values of", - "text": "While for small values of" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/41", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", - "prov": [], - "orig": "$d_k$ the two mechanisms perform similarly, additive attention outperforms dot product attention without scaling for larger values of $d_k$ [DBLP:journals/corr/BritzGLL17]. We suspect that for large values of $d_k$, the dot products grow large in magnitude, pushing the softmax function into regions where it has extremely small gradients", - "text": "$d_k$ the two mechanisms perform similarly, additive attention outperforms dot product attention without scaling for larger values of $d_k$ [DBLP:journals/corr/BritzGLL17]. We suspect that for large values of $d_k$, the dot products grow large in magnitude, pushing the softmax function into regions where it has extremely small gradients" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/42", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "footnote", - "prov": [], - "orig": "To illustrate why the dot products get large, assume that the components of $q$ and $k$ are independent random variables with mean $0$ and variance $1$. Then their dot product, $q \\cdot k = \\sum_{i=1}^{d_k} q_ik_i$, has mean $0$ and variance $d_k$.", - "text": "To illustrate why the dot products get large, assume that the components of $q$ and $k$ are independent random variables with mean $0$ and variance $1$. Then their dot product, $q \\cdot k = \\sum_{i=1}^{d_k} q_ik_i$, has mean $0$ and variance $d_k$." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/43", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", - "prov": [], - "orig": ". To counteract this effect, we scale the dot products by $\\frac{1}{\\sqrt{d_k}}$.", - "text": ". To counteract this effect, we scale the dot products by $\\frac{1}{\\sqrt{d_k}}$." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/44", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "section_header", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Multi-Head Attention", - "text": "Multi-Head Attention", - "level": 3 - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/45", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/groups/1" + "$ref": "#/groups/1" }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", @@ -1315,7 +1075,7 @@ "text": "[t]0.5" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/46", + "self_ref": "#/texts/35", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/1" }, @@ -1327,7 +1087,7 @@ "text": "Scaled Dot-Product Attention" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/47", + "self_ref": "#/texts/36", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1339,7 +1099,7 @@ "text": "Image: Figures/ModalNet-19" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/48", + "self_ref": "#/texts/37", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/1" }, @@ -1351,7 +1111,7 @@ "text": "[t]0.5" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/49", + "self_ref": "#/texts/38", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/1" }, @@ -1363,7 +1123,7 @@ "text": "Multi-Head Attention" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/50", + "self_ref": "#/texts/39", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1375,7 +1135,7 @@ "text": "Image: Figures/ModalNet-20" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/51", + "self_ref": "#/texts/40", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/1" }, @@ -1387,19 +1147,7 @@ "text": "(left) Scaled Dot-Product Attention. (right) Multi-Head Attention consists of several attention layers running in parallel." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/52", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Instead of performing a single attention function with", - "text": "Instead of performing a single attention function with" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/53", + "self_ref": "#/texts/41", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1407,11 +1155,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "$d_{\\text{model}}$-dimensional keys, values and queries, we found it beneficial to linearly project the queries, keys and values $h$ times with different, learned linear projections to $d_k$, $d_k$ and $d_v$ dimensions, respectively.\nOn each of these projected versions of queries, keys and values we then perform the attention function in parallel, yielding $d_v$-dimensional output values. These are concatenated and once again projected, resulting in the final values, as depicted in Figure[fig:multi-head-att].", - "text": "$d_{\\text{model}}$-dimensional keys, values and queries, we found it beneficial to linearly project the queries, keys and values $h$ times with different, learned linear projections to $d_k$, $d_k$ and $d_v$ dimensions, respectively.\nOn each of these projected versions of queries, keys and values we then perform the attention function in parallel, yielding $d_v$-dimensional output values. These are concatenated and once again projected, resulting in the final values, as depicted in Figure[fig:multi-head-att]." + "orig": "Instead of performing a single attention function with $d_{\\text{model}}$-dimensional keys, values and queries, we found it beneficial to linearly project the queries, keys and values $h$ times with different, learned linear projections to $d_k$, $d_k$ and $d_v$ dimensions, respectively.\nOn each of these projected versions of queries, keys and values we then perform the attention function in parallel, yielding $d_v$-dimensional output values. These are concatenated and once again projected, resulting in the final values, as depicted in Figure[fig:multi-head-att].", + "text": "Instead of performing a single attention function with $d_{\\text{model}}$-dimensional keys, values and queries, we found it beneficial to linearly project the queries, keys and values $h$ times with different, learned linear projections to $d_k$, $d_k$ and $d_v$ dimensions, respectively.\nOn each of these projected versions of queries, keys and values we then perform the attention function in parallel, yielding $d_v$-dimensional output values. These are concatenated and once again projected, resulting in the final values, as depicted in Figure[fig:multi-head-att]." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/54", + "self_ref": "#/texts/42", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1423,7 +1171,7 @@ "text": "Multi-head attention allows the model to jointly attend to information from different representation subspaces at different positions. With a single attention head, averaging inhibits this." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/55", + "self_ref": "#/texts/43", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1431,23 +1179,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "formula", "prov": [], - "orig": "\\begin{align*}\n \\mathrm{MultiHead}(Q, K, V) &= \\mathrm{Concat}(\\mathrm{head_1}, ..., \\mathrm{head_h})W^O\\\\\n% \\mathrm{where} \\mathrm{head_i} &= \\mathrm{Attention}(QW_Q_i^{d_{\\text{model}} \\times d_q}, KW_K_i^{d_{\\text{model}} \\times d_k}, VW^V_i^{d_{\\text{model}} \\times d_v})\\\\\n \\text{where}~\\mathrm{head_i} &= \\mathrm{Attention}(QW^Q_i, KW^K_i, VW^V_i)\\\\\n\\end{align*}", - "text": "\\begin{align*}\n \\mathrm{MultiHead}(Q, K, V) &= \\mathrm{Concat}(\\mathrm{head_1}, ..., \\mathrm{head_h})W^O\\\\\n% \\mathrm{where} \\mathrm{head_i} &= \\mathrm{Attention}(QW_Q_i^{d_{\\text{model}} \\times d_q}, KW_K_i^{d_{\\text{model}} \\times d_k}, VW^V_i^{d_{\\text{model}} \\times d_v})\\\\\n \\text{where}~\\mathrm{head_i} &= \\mathrm{Attention}(QW^Q_i, KW^K_i, VW^V_i)\\\\\n\\end{align*}" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/56", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Where the projections are parameter matrices", - "text": "Where the projections are parameter matrices" + "orig": "\\begin{align*}\n \\mathrm{MultiHead}(Q, K, V) &= \\mathrm{Concat}(\\mathrm{head_1}, ..., \\mathrm{head_h})W^O\\\\\n% \\mathrm{where} \\mathrm{head_i} &= \\mathrm{Attention}(QW_Q_i^{\\dmodel \\times d_q}, KW_K_i^{\\dmodel \\times d_k}, VW^V_i^{\\dmodel \\times d_v})\\\\\n \\text{where}~\\mathrm{head_i} &= \\mathrm{Attention}(QW^Q_i, KW^K_i, VW^V_i)\\\\\n\\end{align*}", + "text": "\\begin{align*}\n \\mathrm{MultiHead}(Q, K, V) &= \\mathrm{Concat}(\\mathrm{head_1}, ..., \\mathrm{head_h})W^O\\\\\n% \\mathrm{where} \\mathrm{head_i} &= \\mathrm{Attention}(QW_Q_i^{\\dmodel \\times d_q}, KW_K_i^{\\dmodel \\times d_k}, VW^V_i^{\\dmodel \\times d_v})\\\\\n \\text{where}~\\mathrm{head_i} &= \\mathrm{Attention}(QW^Q_i, KW^K_i, VW^V_i)\\\\\n\\end{align*}" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/57", + "self_ref": "#/texts/44", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1455,23 +1191,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "$W^Q_i \\in \\mathbb{R}^{d_{\\text{model}} \\times d_k}$, $W^K_i \\in \\mathbb{R}^{d_{\\text{model}} \\times d_k}$, $W^V_i \\in \\mathbb{R}^{d_{\\text{model}} \\times d_v}$ and $W^O \\in \\mathbb{R}^{hd_v \\times d_{\\text{model}}}$.", - "text": "$W^Q_i \\in \\mathbb{R}^{d_{\\text{model}} \\times d_k}$, $W^K_i \\in \\mathbb{R}^{d_{\\text{model}} \\times d_k}$, $W^V_i \\in \\mathbb{R}^{d_{\\text{model}} \\times d_v}$ and $W^O \\in \\mathbb{R}^{hd_v \\times d_{\\text{model}}}$." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/58", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "In this work we employ", - "text": "In this work we employ" + "orig": "Where the projections are parameter matrices $W^Q_i \\in \\mathbb{R}^{d_{\\text{model}}\\times d_k}$, $W^K_i \\in \\mathbb{R}^{d_{\\text{model}}\\times d_k}$, $W^V_i \\in \\mathbb{R}^{d_{\\text{model}}\\times d_v}$ and $W^O \\in \\mathbb{R}^{hd_v \\times d_{\\text{model}}}$.", + "text": "Where the projections are parameter matrices $W^Q_i \\in \\mathbb{R}^{d_{\\text{model}}\\times d_k}$, $W^K_i \\in \\mathbb{R}^{d_{\\text{model}}\\times d_k}$, $W^V_i \\in \\mathbb{R}^{d_{\\text{model}}\\times d_v}$ and $W^O \\in \\mathbb{R}^{hd_v \\times d_{\\text{model}}}$." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/59", + "self_ref": "#/texts/45", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1479,11 +1203,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "$h=8$ parallel attention layers, or heads. For each of these we use $d_k=d_v=d_{\\text{model}}/h=64$.\nDue to the reduced dimension of each head, the total computational cost is similar to that of single-head attention with full dimensionality.", - "text": "$h=8$ parallel attention layers, or heads. For each of these we use $d_k=d_v=d_{\\text{model}}/h=64$.\nDue to the reduced dimension of each head, the total computational cost is similar to that of single-head attention with full dimensionality." + "orig": "In this work we employ $h=8$ parallel attention layers, or heads. For each of these we use $d_k=d_v=d_{\\text{model}}/h=64$.\nDue to the reduced dimension of each head, the total computational cost is similar to that of single-head attention with full dimensionality.", + "text": "In this work we employ $h=8$ parallel attention layers, or heads. For each of these we use $d_k=d_v=d_{\\text{model}}/h=64$.\nDue to the reduced dimension of each head, the total computational cost is similar to that of single-head attention with full dimensionality." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/60", + "self_ref": "#/texts/46", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1496,19 +1220,19 @@ "level": 3 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/61", + "self_ref": "#/texts/47", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], "orig": "The Transformer uses multi-head attention in three different ways:", "text": "The Transformer uses multi-head attention in three different ways:" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/62", + "self_ref": "#/texts/48", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/2" }, @@ -1522,7 +1246,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/63", + "self_ref": "#/texts/49", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/2" }, @@ -1536,7 +1260,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/64", + "self_ref": "#/texts/50", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/2" }, @@ -1550,7 +1274,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/65", + "self_ref": "#/texts/51", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1563,7 +1287,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/66", + "self_ref": "#/texts/52", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1575,7 +1299,7 @@ "text": "In addition to attention sub-layers, each of the layers in our encoder and decoder contains a fully connected feed-forward network, which is applied to each position separately and identically. This consists of two linear transformations with a ReLU activation in between." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/67", + "self_ref": "#/texts/53", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1587,19 +1311,7 @@ "text": "\\mathrm{FFN}(x)=\\max(0, xW_1 + b_1) W_2 + b_2" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/68", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "While the linear transformations are the same across different positions, they use different parameters from layer to layer. Another way of describing this is as two convolutions with kernel size 1. The dimensionality of input and output is", - "text": "While the linear transformations are the same across different positions, they use different parameters from layer to layer. Another way of describing this is as two convolutions with kernel size 1. The dimensionality of input and output is" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/69", + "self_ref": "#/texts/54", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1607,11 +1319,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "$d_{\\text{model}}=512$, and the inner-layer has dimensionality $d_{ff}=2048$.", - "text": "$d_{\\text{model}}=512$, and the inner-layer has dimensionality $d_{ff}=2048$." + "orig": "While the linear transformations are the same across different positions, they use different parameters from layer to layer. Another way of describing this is as two convolutions with kernel size 1. The dimensionality of input and output is $d_{\\text{model}}=512$, and the inner-layer has dimensionality $d_{ff}=2048$.", + "text": "While the linear transformations are the same across different positions, they use different parameters from layer to layer. Another way of describing this is as two convolutions with kernel size 1. The dimensionality of input and output is $d_{\\text{model}}=512$, and the inner-layer has dimensionality $d_{ff}=2048$." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/70", + "self_ref": "#/texts/55", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1624,7 +1336,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/71", + "self_ref": "#/texts/56", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1636,7 +1348,7 @@ "text": "Similarly to other sequence transduction models, we use learned embeddings to convert the input tokens and output tokens to vectors of dimension $d_{\\text{model}}$. We also use the usual learned linear transformation and softmax function to convert the decoder output to predicted next-token probabilities. In our model, we share the same weight matrix between the two embedding layers and the pre-softmax linear transformation, similar to [press2016using]. In the embedding layers, we multiply those weights by $\\sqrt{d_{\\text{model}}}$." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/72", + "self_ref": "#/texts/57", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1649,7 +1361,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/73", + "self_ref": "#/texts/58", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1661,7 +1373,7 @@ "text": "Since our model contains no recurrence and no convolution, in order for the model to make use of the order of the sequence, we must inject some information about the relative or absolute position of the tokens in the sequence. To this end, we add \"positional encodings\" to the input embeddings at the bottoms of the encoder and decoder stacks. The positional encodings have the same dimension $d_{\\text{model}}$ as the embeddings, so that the two can be summed. There are many choices of positional encodings, learned and fixed [JonasFaceNet2017]." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/74", + "self_ref": "#/texts/59", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1673,7 +1385,7 @@ "text": "In this work, we use sine and cosine functions of different frequencies:" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/75", + "self_ref": "#/texts/60", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1685,19 +1397,7 @@ "text": "\\begin{align*}\n PE_{(pos,2i)} = sin(pos / 10000^{2i/d_{\\text{model}}}) \\\\\n PE_{(pos,2i+1)} = cos(pos / 10000^{2i/d_{\\text{model}}})\n\\end{align*}" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/76", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "where", - "text": "where" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/77", + "self_ref": "#/texts/61", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1705,23 +1405,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "$pos$ is the position and $i$ is the dimension. That is, each dimension of the positional encoding corresponds to a sinusoid. The wavelengths form a geometric progression from $2\\pi$ to $10000 \\cdot 2\\pi$. We chose this function because we hypothesized it would allow the model to easily learn to attend by relative positions, since for any fixed offset $k$, $PE_{pos+k}$ can be represented as a linear function of $PE_{pos}$.", - "text": "$pos$ is the position and $i$ is the dimension. That is, each dimension of the positional encoding corresponds to a sinusoid. The wavelengths form a geometric progression from $2\\pi$ to $10000 \\cdot 2\\pi$. We chose this function because we hypothesized it would allow the model to easily learn to attend by relative positions, since for any fixed offset $k$, $PE_{pos+k}$ can be represented as a linear function of $PE_{pos}$." + "orig": "where $pos$ is the position and $i$ is the dimension. That is, each dimension of the positional encoding corresponds to a sinusoid. The wavelengths form a geometric progression from $2\\pi$ to $10000 \\cdot 2\\pi$. We chose this function because we hypothesized it would allow the model to easily learn to attend by relative positions, since for any fixed offset $k$, $PE_{pos+k}$ can be represented as a linear function of $PE_{pos}$.", + "text": "where $pos$ is the position and $i$ is the dimension. That is, each dimension of the positional encoding corresponds to a sinusoid. The wavelengths form a geometric progression from $2\\pi$ to $10000 \\cdot 2\\pi$. We chose this function because we hypothesized it would allow the model to easily learn to attend by relative positions, since for any fixed offset $k$, $PE_{pos+k}$ can be represented as a linear function of $PE_{pos}$." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/78", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "We also experimented with using learned positional embeddings", - "text": "We also experimented with using learned positional embeddings" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/79", + "self_ref": "#/texts/62", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1729,11 +1417,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[JonasFaceNet2017] instead, and found that the two versions produced nearly identical results (see Table[tab:variations] row (E)). We chose the sinusoidal version because it may allow the model to extrapolate to sequence lengths longer than the ones encountered during training.", - "text": "[JonasFaceNet2017] instead, and found that the two versions produced nearly identical results (see Table[tab:variations] row (E)). We chose the sinusoidal version because it may allow the model to extrapolate to sequence lengths longer than the ones encountered during training." + "orig": "We also experimented with using learned positional embeddings [JonasFaceNet2017] instead, and found that the two versions produced nearly identical results (see Table[tab:variations] row (E)). We chose the sinusoidal version because it may allow the model to extrapolate to sequence lengths longer than the ones encountered during training.", + "text": "We also experimented with using learned positional embeddings [JonasFaceNet2017] instead, and found that the two versions produced nearly identical results (see Table[tab:variations] row (E)). We chose the sinusoidal version because it may allow the model to extrapolate to sequence lengths longer than the ones encountered during training." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/80", + "self_ref": "#/texts/63", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1746,19 +1434,7 @@ "level": 1 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/81", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "In this section we compare various aspects of self-attention layers to the recurrent and convolutional layers commonly used for mapping one variable-length sequence of symbol representations", - "text": "In this section we compare various aspects of self-attention layers to the recurrent and convolutional layers commonly used for mapping one variable-length sequence of symbol representations" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/82", + "self_ref": "#/texts/64", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1766,11 +1442,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "$(x_1, ..., x_n)$ to another sequence of equal length $(z_1, ..., z_n)$, with $x_i, z_i \\in \\mathbb{R}^d$, such as a hidden layer in a typical sequence transduction encoder or decoder. Motivating our use of self-attention we consider three desiderata.", - "text": "$(x_1, ..., x_n)$ to another sequence of equal length $(z_1, ..., z_n)$, with $x_i, z_i \\in \\mathbb{R}^d$, such as a hidden layer in a typical sequence transduction encoder or decoder. Motivating our use of self-attention we consider three desiderata." + "orig": "In this section we compare various aspects of self-attention layers to the recurrent and convolutional layers commonly used for mapping one variable-length sequence of symbol representations $(x_1, ..., x_n)$ to another sequence of equal length $(z_1, ..., z_n)$, with $x_i, z_i \\in \\mathbb{R}^d$, such as a hidden layer in a typical sequence transduction encoder or decoder. Motivating our use of self-attention we consider three desiderata.", + "text": "In this section we compare various aspects of self-attention layers to the recurrent and convolutional layers commonly used for mapping one variable-length sequence of symbol representations $(x_1, ..., x_n)$ to another sequence of equal length $(z_1, ..., z_n)$, with $x_i, z_i \\in \\mathbb{R}^d$, such as a hidden layer in a typical sequence transduction encoder or decoder. Motivating our use of self-attention we consider three desiderata." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/83", + "self_ref": "#/texts/65", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1782,19 +1458,7 @@ "text": "One is the total computational complexity per layer.\nAnother is the amount of computation that can be parallelized, as measured by the minimum number of sequential operations required." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/84", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "The third is the path length between long-range dependencies in the network. Learning long-range dependencies is a key challenge in many sequence transduction tasks. One key factor affecting the ability to learn such dependencies is the length of the paths forward and backward signals have to traverse in the network. The shorter these paths between any combination of positions in the input and output sequences, the easier it is to learn long-range dependencies", - "text": "The third is the path length between long-range dependencies in the network. Learning long-range dependencies is a key challenge in many sequence transduction tasks. One key factor affecting the ability to learn such dependencies is the length of the paths forward and backward signals have to traverse in the network. The shorter these paths between any combination of positions in the input and output sequences, the easier it is to learn long-range dependencies" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/85", + "self_ref": "#/texts/66", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1802,11 +1466,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[hochreiter2001gradient]. Hence we also compare the maximum path length between any two input and output positions in networks composed of the different layer types.", - "text": "[hochreiter2001gradient]. Hence we also compare the maximum path length between any two input and output positions in networks composed of the different layer types." + "orig": "The third is the path length between long-range dependencies in the network. Learning long-range dependencies is a key challenge in many sequence transduction tasks. One key factor affecting the ability to learn such dependencies is the length of the paths forward and backward signals have to traverse in the network. The shorter these paths between any combination of positions in the input and output sequences, the easier it is to learn long-range dependencies [hochreiter2001gradient]. Hence we also compare the maximum path length between any two input and output positions in networks composed of the different layer types.", + "text": "The third is the path length between long-range dependencies in the network. Learning long-range dependencies is a key challenge in many sequence transduction tasks. One key factor affecting the ability to learn such dependencies is the length of the paths forward and backward signals have to traverse in the network. The shorter these paths between any combination of positions in the input and output sequences, the easier it is to learn long-range dependencies [hochreiter2001gradient]. Hence we also compare the maximum path length between any two input and output positions in networks composed of the different layer types." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/86", + "self_ref": "#/texts/67", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1818,19 +1482,7 @@ "text": "Maximum path lengths, per-layer complexity and minimum number of sequential operations for different layer types. $n$ is the sequence length, $d$ is the representation dimension, $k$ is the kernel size of convolutions and $r$ the size of the neighborhood in restricted self-attention." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/87", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "As noted in Table", - "text": "As noted in Table" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/88", + "self_ref": "#/texts/68", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1838,23 +1490,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[tab:op_complexities], a self-attention layer connects all positions with a constant number of sequentially executed operations, whereas a recurrent layer requires $O(n)$ sequential operations.\nIn terms of computational complexity, self-attention layers are faster than recurrent layers when the sequence length $n$ is smaller than the representation dimensionality $d$, which is most often the case with sentence representations used by state-of-the-art models in machine translations, such as word-piece [wu2016google] and byte-pair [sennrich2015neural] representations.\nTo improve computational performance for tasks involving very long sequences, self-attention could be restricted to considering only a neighborhood of size $r$ in the input sequence centered around the respective output position. This would increase the maximum path length to $O(n/r)$. We plan to investigate this approach further in future work.", - "text": "[tab:op_complexities], a self-attention layer connects all positions with a constant number of sequentially executed operations, whereas a recurrent layer requires $O(n)$ sequential operations.\nIn terms of computational complexity, self-attention layers are faster than recurrent layers when the sequence length $n$ is smaller than the representation dimensionality $d$, which is most often the case with sentence representations used by state-of-the-art models in machine translations, such as word-piece [wu2016google] and byte-pair [sennrich2015neural] representations.\nTo improve computational performance for tasks involving very long sequences, self-attention could be restricted to considering only a neighborhood of size $r$ in the input sequence centered around the respective output position. This would increase the maximum path length to $O(n/r)$. We plan to investigate this approach further in future work." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/89", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "A single convolutional layer with kernel width", - "text": "A single convolutional layer with kernel width" + "orig": "As noted in Table [tab:op_complexities], a self-attention layer connects all positions with a constant number of sequentially executed operations, whereas a recurrent layer requires $O(n)$ sequential operations.\nIn terms of computational complexity, self-attention layers are faster than recurrent layers when the sequence length $n$ is smaller than the representation dimensionality $d$, which is most often the case with sentence representations used by state-of-the-art models in machine translations, such as word-piece [wu2016google] and byte-pair [sennrich2015neural] representations.\nTo improve computational performance for tasks involving very long sequences, self-attention could be restricted to considering only a neighborhood of size $r$ in the input sequence centered around the respective output position. This would increase the maximum path length to $O(n/r)$. We plan to investigate this approach further in future work.", + "text": "As noted in Table [tab:op_complexities], a self-attention layer connects all positions with a constant number of sequentially executed operations, whereas a recurrent layer requires $O(n)$ sequential operations.\nIn terms of computational complexity, self-attention layers are faster than recurrent layers when the sequence length $n$ is smaller than the representation dimensionality $d$, which is most often the case with sentence representations used by state-of-the-art models in machine translations, such as word-piece [wu2016google] and byte-pair [sennrich2015neural] representations.\nTo improve computational performance for tasks involving very long sequences, self-attention could be restricted to considering only a neighborhood of size $r$ in the input sequence centered around the respective output position. This would increase the maximum path length to $O(n/r)$. We plan to investigate this approach further in future work." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/90", + "self_ref": "#/texts/69", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1862,11 +1502,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "$k < n$ does not connect all pairs of input and output positions. Doing so requires a stack of $O(n/k)$ convolutional layers in the case of contiguous kernels, or $O(log_k(n))$ in the case of dilated convolutions [NalBytenet2017], increasing the length of the longest paths between any two positions in the network.\nConvolutional layers are generally more expensive than recurrent layers, by a factor of $k$. Separable convolutions [xception2016], however, decrease the complexity considerably, to $O(k \\cdot n \\cdot d + n \\cdot d^2)$. Even with $k=n$, however, the complexity of a separable convolution is equal to the combination of a self-attention layer and a point-wise feed-forward layer, the approach we take in our model.", - "text": "$k < n$ does not connect all pairs of input and output positions. Doing so requires a stack of $O(n/k)$ convolutional layers in the case of contiguous kernels, or $O(log_k(n))$ in the case of dilated convolutions [NalBytenet2017], increasing the length of the longest paths between any two positions in the network.\nConvolutional layers are generally more expensive than recurrent layers, by a factor of $k$. Separable convolutions [xception2016], however, decrease the complexity considerably, to $O(k \\cdot n \\cdot d + n \\cdot d^2)$. Even with $k=n$, however, the complexity of a separable convolution is equal to the combination of a self-attention layer and a point-wise feed-forward layer, the approach we take in our model." + "orig": "A single convolutional layer with kernel width $k < n$ does not connect all pairs of input and output positions. Doing so requires a stack of $O(n/k)$ convolutional layers in the case of contiguous kernels, or $O(log_k(n))$ in the case of dilated convolutions [NalBytenet2017], increasing the length of the longest paths between any two positions in the network.\nConvolutional layers are generally more expensive than recurrent layers, by a factor of $k$. Separable convolutions [xception2016], however, decrease the complexity considerably, to $O(k \\cdot n \\cdot d + n \\cdot d^2)$. Even with $k=n$, however, the complexity of a separable convolution is equal to the combination of a self-attention layer and a point-wise feed-forward layer, the approach we take in our model.", + "text": "A single convolutional layer with kernel width $k < n$ does not connect all pairs of input and output positions. Doing so requires a stack of $O(n/k)$ convolutional layers in the case of contiguous kernels, or $O(log_k(n))$ in the case of dilated convolutions [NalBytenet2017], increasing the length of the longest paths between any two positions in the network.\nConvolutional layers are generally more expensive than recurrent layers, by a factor of $k$. Separable convolutions [xception2016], however, decrease the complexity considerably, to $O(k \\cdot n \\cdot d + n \\cdot d^2)$. Even with $k=n$, however, the complexity of a separable convolution is equal to the combination of a self-attention layer and a point-wise feed-forward layer, the approach we take in our model." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/91", + "self_ref": "#/texts/70", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1878,7 +1518,7 @@ "text": "As side benefit, self-attention could yield more interpretable models. We inspect attention distributions from our models and present and discuss examples in the appendix. Not only do individual attention heads clearly learn to perform different tasks, many appear to exhibit behavior related to the syntactic and semantic structure of the sentences." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/92", + "self_ref": "#/texts/71", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1891,7 +1531,7 @@ "level": 1 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/93", + "self_ref": "#/texts/72", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1903,205 +1543,20 @@ "text": "This section describes the training regime for our models." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/94", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "section_header", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Training Data and Batching", - "text": "Training Data and Batching", - "level": 2 - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/95", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", - "prov": [], - "orig": "We trained on the standard WMT 2014 English-German dataset consisting of about 4.5 million sentence pairs. Sentences were encoded using byte-pair encoding [DBLP:journals/corr/BritzGLL17], which has a shared source-target vocabulary of about 37000 tokens. For English-French, we used the significantly larger WMT 2014 English-French dataset consisting of 36M sentences and split tokens into a 32000 word-piece vocabulary [wu2016google]. Sentence pairs were batched together by approximate sequence length. Each training batch contained a set of sentence pairs containing approximately 25000 source tokens and 25000 target tokens.", - "text": "We trained on the standard WMT 2014 English-German dataset consisting of about 4.5 million sentence pairs. Sentences were encoded using byte-pair encoding [DBLP:journals/corr/BritzGLL17], which has a shared source-target vocabulary of about 37000 tokens. For English-French, we used the significantly larger WMT 2014 English-French dataset consisting of 36M sentences and split tokens into a 32000 word-piece vocabulary [wu2016google]. Sentence pairs were batched together by approximate sequence length. Each training batch contained a set of sentence pairs containing approximately 25000 source tokens and 25000 target tokens." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/96", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "section_header", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Hardware and Schedule", - "text": "Hardware and Schedule", - "level": 2 - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/97", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "We trained our models on one machine with 8 NVIDIA P100 GPUs. For our base models using the hyperparameters described throughout the paper, each training step took about 0.4 seconds. We trained the base models for a total of 100,000 steps or 12 hours. For our big models,(described on the bottom line of table", - "text": "We trained our models on one machine with 8 NVIDIA P100 GPUs. For our base models using the hyperparameters described throughout the paper, each training step took about 0.4 seconds. We trained the base models for a total of 100,000 steps or 12 hours. For our big models,(described on the bottom line of table" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/98", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", - "prov": [], - "orig": "[tab:variations]), step time was 1.0 seconds. The big models were trained for 300,000 steps (3.5 days).", - "text": "[tab:variations]), step time was 1.0 seconds. The big models were trained for 300,000 steps (3.5 days)." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/99", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "section_header", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Optimizer", - "text": "Optimizer", - "level": 2 - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/100", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", - "prov": [], - "orig": "We used the Adam optimizer[kingma2014adam] with $\\beta_1=0.9$, $\\beta_2=0.98$ and $\\epsilon=10^{-9}$. We varied the learning rate over the course of training, according to the formula:", - "text": "We used the Adam optimizer[kingma2014adam] with $\\beta_1=0.9$, $\\beta_2=0.98$ and $\\epsilon=10^{-9}$. We varied the learning rate over the course of training, according to the formula:" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/101", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "formula", - "prov": [], - "orig": "lrate = d_{\\text{model}}^{-0.5} \\cdot\n \\min({step\\_num}^{-0.5},\n {step\\_num} \\cdot {warmup\\_steps}^{-1.5})", - "text": "lrate = d_{\\text{model}}^{-0.5} \\cdot\n \\min({step\\_num}^{-0.5},\n {step\\_num} \\cdot {warmup\\_steps}^{-1.5})" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/102", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "This corresponds to increasing the learning rate linearly for the first", - "text": "This corresponds to increasing the learning rate linearly for the first" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/103", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", - "prov": [], - "orig": "$warmup\\_steps$ training steps, and decreasing it thereafter proportionally to the inverse square root of the step number. We used $warmup\\_steps=4000$.", - "text": "$warmup\\_steps$ training steps, and decreasing it thereafter proportionally to the inverse square root of the step number. We used $warmup\\_steps=4000$." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/104", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "section_header", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Regularization", - "text": "Regularization", - "level": 2 - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/105", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "We employ three types of regularization during training:", - "text": "We employ three types of regularization during training:" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/106", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Residual Dropout We apply dropout [srivastava2014dropout] to the output of each sub-layer, before it is added to the sub-layer input and normalized. In addition, we apply dropout to the sums of the embeddings and the positional encodings in both the encoder and decoder stacks. For the base model, we use a rate of $P_{drop}=0.1$.", - "text": "Residual Dropout We apply dropout [srivastava2014dropout] to the output of each sub-layer, before it is added to the sub-layer input and normalized. In addition, we apply dropout to the sums of the embeddings and the positional encodings in both the encoder and decoder stacks. For the base model, we use a rate of $P_{drop}=0.1$." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/107", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Label Smoothing During training, we employed label smoothing of value $\\epsilon_{ls}=0.1$ [DBLP:journals/corr/SzegedyVISW15]. This hurts perplexity, as the model learns to be more unsure, but improves accuracy and BLEU score.", - "text": "Label Smoothing During training, we employed label smoothing of value $\\epsilon_{ls}=0.1$ [DBLP:journals/corr/SzegedyVISW15]. This hurts perplexity, as the model learns to be more unsure, but improves accuracy and BLEU score." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/108", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "section_header", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Results", - "text": "Results", - "level": 1 - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/109", + "self_ref": "#/texts/73", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", "label": "section_header", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Machine Translation", - "text": "Machine Translation", + "prov": [], + "orig": "Training Data and Batching", + "text": "Training Data and Batching", "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/110", + "self_ref": "#/texts/74", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2109,23 +1564,24 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "The Transformer achieves better BLEU scores than previous state-of-the-art models on the English-to-German and English-to-French newstest2014 tests at a fraction of the training cost.", - "text": "The Transformer achieves better BLEU scores than previous state-of-the-art models on the English-to-German and English-to-French newstest2014 tests at a fraction of the training cost." + "orig": "We trained on the standard WMT 2014 English-German dataset consisting of about 4.5 million sentence pairs. Sentences were encoded using byte-pair encoding [DBLP:journals/corr/BritzGLL17], which has a shared source-target vocabulary of about 37000 tokens. For English-French, we used the significantly larger WMT 2014 English-French dataset consisting of 36M sentences and split tokens into a 32000 word-piece vocabulary [wu2016google]. Sentence pairs were batched together by approximate sequence length. Each training batch contained a set of sentence pairs containing approximately 25000 source tokens and 25000 target tokens.", + "text": "We trained on the standard WMT 2014 English-German dataset consisting of about 4.5 million sentence pairs. Sentences were encoded using byte-pair encoding [DBLP:journals/corr/BritzGLL17], which has a shared source-target vocabulary of about 37000 tokens. For English-French, we used the significantly larger WMT 2014 English-French dataset consisting of 36M sentences and split tokens into a 32000 word-piece vocabulary [wu2016google]. Sentence pairs were batched together by approximate sequence length. Each training batch contained a set of sentence pairs containing approximately 25000 source tokens and 25000 target tokens." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/111", + "self_ref": "#/texts/75", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "section_header", "prov": [], - "orig": "On the WMT 2014 English-to-German translation task, the big transformer model (Transformer (big) in Table", - "text": "On the WMT 2014 English-to-German translation task, the big transformer model (Transformer (big) in Table" + "orig": "Hardware and Schedule", + "text": "Hardware and Schedule", + "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/112", + "self_ref": "#/texts/76", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2133,23 +1589,24 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[tab:wmt-results]) outperforms the best previously reported models (including ensembles) by more than $2.0$ BLEU, establishing a new state-of-the-art BLEU score of $28.4$. The configuration of this model is listed in the bottom line of Table[tab:variations]. Training took $3.5$ days on $8$P100 GPUs. Even our base model surpasses all previously published models and ensembles, at a fraction of the training cost of any of the competitive models.", - "text": "[tab:wmt-results]) outperforms the best previously reported models (including ensembles) by more than $2.0$ BLEU, establishing a new state-of-the-art BLEU score of $28.4$. The configuration of this model is listed in the bottom line of Table[tab:variations]. Training took $3.5$ days on $8$P100 GPUs. Even our base model surpasses all previously published models and ensembles, at a fraction of the training cost of any of the competitive models." + "orig": "We trained our models on one machine with 8 NVIDIA P100 GPUs. For our base models using the hyperparameters described throughout the paper, each training step took about 0.4 seconds. We trained the base models for a total of 100,000 steps or 12 hours. For our big models,(described on the bottom line of table [tab:variations]), step time was 1.0 seconds. The big models were trained for 300,000 steps (3.5 days).", + "text": "We trained our models on one machine with 8 NVIDIA P100 GPUs. For our base models using the hyperparameters described throughout the paper, each training step took about 0.4 seconds. We trained the base models for a total of 100,000 steps or 12 hours. For our big models,(described on the bottom line of table [tab:variations]), step time was 1.0 seconds. The big models were trained for 300,000 steps (3.5 days)." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/113", + "self_ref": "#/texts/77", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "section_header", "prov": [], - "orig": "On the WMT 2014 English-to-French translation task, our big model achieves a BLEU score of", - "text": "On the WMT 2014 English-to-French translation task, our big model achieves a BLEU score of" + "orig": "Optimizer", + "text": "Optimizer", + "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/114", + "self_ref": "#/texts/78", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2157,23 +1614,23 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "$41.0$, outperforming all of the previously published single models, at less than $1/4$ the training cost of the previous state-of-the-art model. The Transformer (big) model trained for English-to-French used dropout rate $P_{drop}=0.1$, instead of $0.3$.", - "text": "$41.0$, outperforming all of the previously published single models, at less than $1/4$ the training cost of the previous state-of-the-art model. The Transformer (big) model trained for English-to-French used dropout rate $P_{drop}=0.1$, instead of $0.3$." + "orig": "We used the Adam optimizer[kingma2014adam] with $\\beta_1=0.9$, $\\beta_2=0.98$ and $\\epsilon=10^{-9}$. We varied the learning rate over the course of training, according to the formula:", + "text": "We used the Adam optimizer[kingma2014adam] with $\\beta_1=0.9$, $\\beta_2=0.98$ and $\\epsilon=10^{-9}$. We varied the learning rate over the course of training, according to the formula:" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/115", + "self_ref": "#/texts/79", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "formula", "prov": [], - "orig": "For the base models, we used a single model obtained by averaging the last 5 checkpoints, which were written at 10-minute intervals. For the big models, we averaged the last 20 checkpoints. We used beam search with a beam size of", - "text": "For the base models, we used a single model obtained by averaging the last 5 checkpoints, which were written at 10-minute intervals. For the big models, we averaged the last 20 checkpoints. We used beam search with a beam size of" + "orig": "lrate = d_{\\text{model}}^{-0.5} \\cdot\n \\min({step\\_num}^{-0.5},\n {step\\_num} \\cdot {warmup\\_steps}^{-1.5})", + "text": "lrate = d_{\\text{model}}^{-0.5} \\cdot\n \\min({step\\_num}^{-0.5},\n {step\\_num} \\cdot {warmup\\_steps}^{-1.5})" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/116", + "self_ref": "#/texts/80", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2181,23 +1638,24 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "$4$ and length penalty $\\alpha=0.6$ [wu2016google]. These hyperparameters were chosen after experimentation on the development set. We set the maximum output length during inference to input length + $50$, but terminate early when possible [wu2016google].", - "text": "$4$ and length penalty $\\alpha=0.6$ [wu2016google]. These hyperparameters were chosen after experimentation on the development set. We set the maximum output length during inference to input length + $50$, but terminate early when possible [wu2016google]." + "orig": "This corresponds to increasing the learning rate linearly for the first $warmup\\_steps$ training steps, and decreasing it thereafter proportionally to the inverse square root of the step number. We used $warmup\\_steps=4000$.", + "text": "This corresponds to increasing the learning rate linearly for the first $warmup\\_steps$ training steps, and decreasing it thereafter proportionally to the inverse square root of the step number. We used $warmup\\_steps=4000$." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/117", + "self_ref": "#/texts/81", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "section_header", "prov": [], - "orig": "Table", - "text": "Table" + "orig": "Regularization", + "text": "Regularization", + "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/118", + "self_ref": "#/texts/82", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2205,23 +1663,23 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[tab:wmt-results] summarizes our results and compares our translation quality and training costs to other model architectures from the literature. We estimate the number of floating point operations used to train a model by multiplying the training time, the number of GPUs used, and an estimate of the sustained single-precision floating-point capacity of each GPU", - "text": "[tab:wmt-results] summarizes our results and compares our translation quality and training costs to other model architectures from the literature. We estimate the number of floating point operations used to train a model by multiplying the training time, the number of GPUs used, and an estimate of the sustained single-precision floating-point capacity of each GPU" + "orig": "We employ three types of regularization during training:", + "text": "We employ three types of regularization during training:" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/119", + "self_ref": "#/texts/83", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "footnote", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "We used values of 2.8, 3.7, 6.0 and 9.5 TFLOPS for K80, K40, M40 and P100, respectively.", - "text": "We used values of 2.8, 3.7, 6.0 and 9.5 TFLOPS for K80, K40, M40 and P100, respectively." + "orig": "Residual Dropout We apply dropout [srivastava2014dropout] to the output of each sub-layer, before it is added to the sub-layer input and normalized. In addition, we apply dropout to the sums of the embeddings and the positional encodings in both the encoder and decoder stacks. For the base model, we use a rate of $P_{drop}=0.1$.", + "text": "Residual Dropout We apply dropout [srivastava2014dropout] to the output of each sub-layer, before it is added to the sub-layer input and normalized. In addition, we apply dropout to the sums of the embeddings and the positional encodings in both the encoder and decoder stacks. For the base model, we use a rate of $P_{drop}=0.1$." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/120", + "self_ref": "#/texts/84", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2229,11 +1687,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": ".", - "text": "." + "orig": "Label Smoothing During training, we employed label smoothing of value $\\epsilon_{ls}=0.1$ [DBLP:journals/corr/SzegedyVISW15]. This hurts perplexity, as the model learns to be more unsure, but improves accuracy and BLEU score.", + "text": "Label Smoothing During training, we employed label smoothing of value $\\epsilon_{ls}=0.1$ [DBLP:journals/corr/SzegedyVISW15]. This hurts perplexity, as the model learns to be more unsure, but improves accuracy and BLEU score." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/121", + "self_ref": "#/texts/85", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2241,12 +1699,25 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "section_header", "prov": [], - "orig": "Model Variations", - "text": "Model Variations", + "orig": "Results", + "text": "Results", + "level": 1 + }, + { + "self_ref": "#/texts/86", + "parent": { + "$ref": "#/body" + }, + "children": [], + "content_layer": "body", + "label": "section_header", + "prov": [], + "orig": "Machine Translation", + "text": "Machine Translation", "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/122", + "self_ref": "#/texts/87", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2254,23 +1725,23 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "Variations on the Transformer architecture. Unlisted values are identical to those of the base model. All metrics are on the English-to-German translation development set, newstest2013. Listed perplexities are per-wordpiece, according to our byte-pair encoding, and should not be compared to per-word perplexities.", - "text": "Variations on the Transformer architecture. Unlisted values are identical to those of the base model. All metrics are on the English-to-German translation development set, newstest2013. Listed perplexities are per-wordpiece, according to our byte-pair encoding, and should not be compared to per-word perplexities." + "orig": "The Transformer achieves better BLEU scores than previous state-of-the-art models on the English-to-German and English-to-French newstest2014 tests at a fraction of the training cost.", + "text": "The Transformer achieves better BLEU scores than previous state-of-the-art models on the English-to-German and English-to-French newstest2014 tests at a fraction of the training cost." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/123", + "self_ref": "#/texts/88", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "To evaluate the importance of different components of the Transformer, we varied our base model in different ways, measuring the change in performance on English-to-German translation on the development set, newstest2013. We used beam search as described in the previous section, but no checkpoint averaging. We present these results in Table", - "text": "To evaluate the importance of different components of the Transformer, we varied our base model in different ways, measuring the change in performance on English-to-German translation on the development set, newstest2013. We used beam search as described in the previous section, but no checkpoint averaging. We present these results in Table" + "orig": "On the WMT 2014 English-to-German translation task, the big transformer model (Transformer (big) in Table[tab:wmt-results]) outperforms the best previously reported models (including ensembles) by more than $2.0$ BLEU, establishing a new state-of-the-art BLEU score of $28.4$. The configuration of this model is listed in the bottom line of Table[tab:variations]. Training took $3.5$ days on $8$P100 GPUs. Even our base model surpasses all previously published models and ensembles, at a fraction of the training cost of any of the competitive models.", + "text": "On the WMT 2014 English-to-German translation task, the big transformer model (Transformer (big) in Table[tab:wmt-results]) outperforms the best previously reported models (including ensembles) by more than $2.0$ BLEU, establishing a new state-of-the-art BLEU score of $28.4$. The configuration of this model is listed in the bottom line of Table[tab:variations]. Training took $3.5$ days on $8$P100 GPUs. Even our base model surpasses all previously published models and ensembles, at a fraction of the training cost of any of the competitive models." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/124", + "self_ref": "#/texts/89", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2278,23 +1749,23 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[tab:variations].", - "text": "[tab:variations]." + "orig": "On the WMT 2014 English-to-French translation task, our big model achieves a BLEU score of $41.0$, outperforming all of the previously published single models, at less than $1/4$ the training cost of the previous state-of-the-art model. The Transformer (big) model trained for English-to-French used dropout rate $P_{drop}=0.1$, instead of $0.3$.", + "text": "On the WMT 2014 English-to-French translation task, our big model achieves a BLEU score of $41.0$, outperforming all of the previously published single models, at less than $1/4$ the training cost of the previous state-of-the-art model. The Transformer (big) model trained for English-to-French used dropout rate $P_{drop}=0.1$, instead of $0.3$." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/125", + "self_ref": "#/texts/90", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "In Table", - "text": "In Table" + "orig": "For the base models, we used a single model obtained by averaging the last 5 checkpoints, which were written at 10-minute intervals. For the big models, we averaged the last 20 checkpoints. We used beam search with a beam size of $4$ and length penalty $\\alpha=0.6$ [wu2016google]. These hyperparameters were chosen after experimentation on the development set. We set the maximum output length during inference to input length + $50$, but terminate early when possible [wu2016google].", + "text": "For the base models, we used a single model obtained by averaging the last 5 checkpoints, which were written at 10-minute intervals. For the big models, we averaged the last 20 checkpoints. We used beam search with a beam size of $4$ and length penalty $\\alpha=0.6$ [wu2016google]. These hyperparameters were chosen after experimentation on the development set. We set the maximum output length during inference to input length + $50$, but terminate early when possible [wu2016google]." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/126", + "self_ref": "#/texts/91", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2302,23 +1773,23 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[tab:variations] rows (A), we vary the number of attention heads and the attention key and value dimensions, keeping the amount of computation constant, as described in Section [sec:multihead]. While single-head attention is 0.9 BLEU worse than the best setting, quality also drops off with too many heads.", - "text": "[tab:variations] rows (A), we vary the number of attention heads and the attention key and value dimensions, keeping the amount of computation constant, as described in Section [sec:multihead]. While single-head attention is 0.9 BLEU worse than the best setting, quality also drops off with too many heads." + "orig": "Table [tab:wmt-results] summarizes our results and compares our translation quality and training costs to other model architectures from the literature. We estimate the number of floating point operations used to train a model by multiplying the training time, the number of GPUs used, and an estimate of the sustained single-precision floating-point capacity of each GPU", + "text": "Table [tab:wmt-results] summarizes our results and compares our translation quality and training costs to other model architectures from the literature. We estimate the number of floating point operations used to train a model by multiplying the training time, the number of GPUs used, and an estimate of the sustained single-precision floating-point capacity of each GPU" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/127", + "self_ref": "#/texts/92", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "footnote", "prov": [], - "orig": "In Table", - "text": "In Table" + "orig": "We used values of 2.8, 3.7, 6.0 and 9.5 TFLOPS for K80, K40, M40 and P100, respectively.", + "text": "We used values of 2.8, 3.7, 6.0 and 9.5 TFLOPS for K80, K40, M40 and P100, respectively." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/128", + "self_ref": "#/texts/93", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2326,11 +1797,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[tab:variations] rows (B), we observe that reducing the attention key size $d_k$ hurts model quality. This suggests that determining compatibility is not easy and that a more sophisticated compatibility function than dot product may be beneficial. We further observe in rows (C) and (D) that, as expected, bigger models are better, and dropout is very helpful in avoiding over-fitting. In row (E) we replace our sinusoidal positional encoding with learned positional embeddings [JonasFaceNet2017], and observe nearly identical results to the base model.", - "text": "[tab:variations] rows (B), we observe that reducing the attention key size $d_k$ hurts model quality. This suggests that determining compatibility is not easy and that a more sophisticated compatibility function than dot product may be beneficial. We further observe in rows (C) and (D) that, as expected, bigger models are better, and dropout is very helpful in avoiding over-fitting. In row (E) we replace our sinusoidal positional encoding with learned positional embeddings [JonasFaceNet2017], and observe nearly identical results to the base model." + "orig": ".", + "text": "." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/129", + "self_ref": "#/texts/94", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2338,12 +1809,12 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "section_header", "prov": [], - "orig": "English Constituency Parsing", - "text": "English Constituency Parsing", + "orig": "Model Variations", + "text": "Model Variations", "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/130", + "self_ref": "#/texts/95", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2351,23 +1822,23 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "The Transformer generalizes well to English constituency parsing (Results are on Section 23 of WSJ)", - "text": "The Transformer generalizes well to English constituency parsing (Results are on Section 23 of WSJ)" + "orig": "Variations on the Transformer architecture. Unlisted values are identical to those of the base model. All metrics are on the English-to-German translation development set, newstest2013. Listed perplexities are per-wordpiece, according to our byte-pair encoding, and should not be compared to per-word perplexities.", + "text": "Variations on the Transformer architecture. Unlisted values are identical to those of the base model. All metrics are on the English-to-German translation development set, newstest2013. Listed perplexities are per-wordpiece, according to our byte-pair encoding, and should not be compared to per-word perplexities." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/131", + "self_ref": "#/texts/96", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "To evaluate if the Transformer can generalize to other tasks we performed experiments on English constituency parsing. This task presents specific challenges: the output is subject to strong structural constraints and is significantly longer than the input.\nFurthermore, RNN sequence-to-sequence models have not been able to attain state-of-the-art results in small-data regimes", - "text": "To evaluate if the Transformer can generalize to other tasks we performed experiments on English constituency parsing. This task presents specific challenges: the output is subject to strong structural constraints and is significantly longer than the input.\nFurthermore, RNN sequence-to-sequence models have not been able to attain state-of-the-art results in small-data regimes" + "orig": "To evaluate the importance of different components of the Transformer, we varied our base model in different ways, measuring the change in performance on English-to-German translation on the development set, newstest2013. We used beam search as described in the previous section, but no checkpoint averaging. We present these results in Table[tab:variations].", + "text": "To evaluate the importance of different components of the Transformer, we varied our base model in different ways, measuring the change in performance on English-to-German translation on the development set, newstest2013. We used beam search as described in the previous section, but no checkpoint averaging. We present these results in Table[tab:variations]." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/132", + "self_ref": "#/texts/97", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2375,47 +1846,48 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[KVparse15].", - "text": "[KVparse15]." + "orig": "In Table[tab:variations] rows (A), we vary the number of attention heads and the attention key and value dimensions, keeping the amount of computation constant, as described in Section [sec:multihead]. While single-head attention is 0.9 BLEU worse than the best setting, quality also drops off with too many heads.", + "text": "In Table[tab:variations] rows (A), we vary the number of attention heads and the attention key and value dimensions, keeping the amount of computation constant, as described in Section [sec:multihead]. While single-head attention is 0.9 BLEU worse than the best setting, quality also drops off with too many heads." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/133", + "self_ref": "#/texts/98", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "We trained a 4-layer transformer with", - "text": "We trained a 4-layer transformer with" + "orig": "In Table[tab:variations] rows (B), we observe that reducing the attention key size $d_k$ hurts model quality. This suggests that determining compatibility is not easy and that a more sophisticated compatibility function than dot product may be beneficial. We further observe in rows (C) and (D) that, as expected, bigger models are better, and dropout is very helpful in avoiding over-fitting. In row (E) we replace our sinusoidal positional encoding with learned positional embeddings [JonasFaceNet2017], and observe nearly identical results to the base model.", + "text": "In Table[tab:variations] rows (B), we observe that reducing the attention key size $d_k$ hurts model quality. This suggests that determining compatibility is not easy and that a more sophisticated compatibility function than dot product may be beneficial. We further observe in rows (C) and (D) that, as expected, bigger models are better, and dropout is very helpful in avoiding over-fitting. In row (E) we replace our sinusoidal positional encoding with learned positional embeddings [JonasFaceNet2017], and observe nearly identical results to the base model." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/134", + "self_ref": "#/texts/99", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", + "label": "section_header", "prov": [], - "orig": "$d_{model} = 1024$ on the Wall Street Journal (WSJ) portion of the Penn Treebank [marcus1993building], about 40K training sentences. We also trained it in a semi-supervised setting, using the larger high-confidence and BerkleyParser corpora from with approximately 17M sentences [KVparse15]. We used a vocabulary of 16K tokens for the WSJ only setting and a vocabulary of 32K tokens for the semi-supervised setting.", - "text": "$d_{model} = 1024$ on the Wall Street Journal (WSJ) portion of the Penn Treebank [marcus1993building], about 40K training sentences. We also trained it in a semi-supervised setting, using the larger high-confidence and BerkleyParser corpora from with approximately 17M sentences [KVparse15]. We used a vocabulary of 16K tokens for the WSJ only setting and a vocabulary of 32K tokens for the semi-supervised setting." + "orig": "English Constituency Parsing", + "text": "English Constituency Parsing", + "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/135", + "self_ref": "#/texts/100", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "We performed only a small number of experiments to select the dropout, both attention and residual (section", - "text": "We performed only a small number of experiments to select the dropout, both attention and residual (section" + "orig": "The Transformer generalizes well to English constituency parsing (Results are on Section 23 of WSJ)", + "text": "The Transformer generalizes well to English constituency parsing (Results are on Section 23 of WSJ)" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/136", + "self_ref": "#/texts/101", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2423,23 +1895,23 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[sec:reg]), learning rates and beam size on the Section 22 development set, all other parameters remained unchanged from the English-to-German base translation model. During inference, we increased the maximum output length to input length + $300$. We used a beam size of $21$ and $\\alpha=0.3$for both WSJ only and the semi-supervised setting.", - "text": "[sec:reg]), learning rates and beam size on the Section 22 development set, all other parameters remained unchanged from the English-to-German base translation model. During inference, we increased the maximum output length to input length + $300$. We used a beam size of $21$ and $\\alpha=0.3$for both WSJ only and the semi-supervised setting." + "orig": "To evaluate if the Transformer can generalize to other tasks we performed experiments on English constituency parsing. This task presents specific challenges: the output is subject to strong structural constraints and is significantly longer than the input.\nFurthermore, RNN sequence-to-sequence models have not been able to attain state-of-the-art results in small-data regimes [KVparse15].", + "text": "To evaluate if the Transformer can generalize to other tasks we performed experiments on English constituency parsing. This task presents specific challenges: the output is subject to strong structural constraints and is significantly longer than the input.\nFurthermore, RNN sequence-to-sequence models have not been able to attain state-of-the-art results in small-data regimes [KVparse15]." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/137", + "self_ref": "#/texts/102", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "Our results in Table", - "text": "Our results in Table" + "orig": "We trained a 4-layer transformer with $d_{model} = 1024$ on the Wall Street Journal (WSJ) portion of the Penn Treebank [marcus1993building], about 40K training sentences. We also trained it in a semi-supervised setting, using the larger high-confidence and BerkleyParser corpora from with approximately 17M sentences [KVparse15]. We used a vocabulary of 16K tokens for the WSJ only setting and a vocabulary of 32K tokens for the semi-supervised setting.", + "text": "We trained a 4-layer transformer with $d_{model} = 1024$ on the Wall Street Journal (WSJ) portion of the Penn Treebank [marcus1993building], about 40K training sentences. We also trained it in a semi-supervised setting, using the larger high-confidence and BerkleyParser corpora from with approximately 17M sentences [KVparse15]. We used a vocabulary of 16K tokens for the WSJ only setting and a vocabulary of 32K tokens for the semi-supervised setting." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/138", + "self_ref": "#/texts/103", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2447,23 +1919,23 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[tab:parsing-results] show that despite the lack of task-specific tuning our model performs surprisingly well, yielding better results than all previously reported models with the exception of the Recurrent Neural Network Grammar [dyer-rnng:16].", - "text": "[tab:parsing-results] show that despite the lack of task-specific tuning our model performs surprisingly well, yielding better results than all previously reported models with the exception of the Recurrent Neural Network Grammar [dyer-rnng:16]." + "orig": "We performed only a small number of experiments to select the dropout, both attention and residual (section[sec:reg]), learning rates and beam size on the Section 22 development set, all other parameters remained unchanged from the English-to-German base translation model. During inference, we increased the maximum output length to input length + $300$. We used a beam size of $21$ and $\\alpha=0.3$for both WSJ only and the semi-supervised setting.", + "text": "We performed only a small number of experiments to select the dropout, both attention and residual (section[sec:reg]), learning rates and beam size on the Section 22 development set, all other parameters remained unchanged from the English-to-German base translation model. During inference, we increased the maximum output length to input length + $300$. We used a beam size of $21$ and $\\alpha=0.3$for both WSJ only and the semi-supervised setting." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/139", + "self_ref": "#/texts/104", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "In contrast to RNN sequence-to-sequence models", - "text": "In contrast to RNN sequence-to-sequence models" + "orig": "Our results in Table[tab:parsing-results] show that despite the lack of task-specific tuning our model performs surprisingly well, yielding better results than all previously reported models with the exception of the Recurrent Neural Network Grammar [dyer-rnng:16].", + "text": "Our results in Table[tab:parsing-results] show that despite the lack of task-specific tuning our model performs surprisingly well, yielding better results than all previously reported models with the exception of the Recurrent Neural Network Grammar [dyer-rnng:16]." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/140", + "self_ref": "#/texts/105", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2471,11 +1943,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[KVparse15], the Transformer outperforms the BerkeleyParser [petrov-EtAl:2006:ACL] even when training only on the WSJ training set of 40K sentences.", - "text": "[KVparse15], the Transformer outperforms the BerkeleyParser [petrov-EtAl:2006:ACL] even when training only on the WSJ training set of 40K sentences." + "orig": "In contrast to RNN sequence-to-sequence models [KVparse15], the Transformer outperforms the BerkeleyParser [petrov-EtAl:2006:ACL] even when training only on the WSJ training set of 40K sentences.", + "text": "In contrast to RNN sequence-to-sequence models [KVparse15], the Transformer outperforms the BerkeleyParser [petrov-EtAl:2006:ACL] even when training only on the WSJ training set of 40K sentences." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/141", + "self_ref": "#/texts/106", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2488,7 +1960,7 @@ "level": 1 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/142", + "self_ref": "#/texts/107", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2500,19 +1972,19 @@ "text": "In this work, we presented the Transformer, the first sequence transduction model based entirely on attention, replacing the recurrent layers most commonly used in encoder-decoder architectures with multi-headed self-attention." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/143", + "self_ref": "#/texts/108", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], "orig": "For translation tasks, the Transformer can be trained significantly faster than architectures based on recurrent or convolutional layers. On both WMT 2014 English-to-German and WMT 2014 English-to-French translation tasks, we achieve a new state of the art. In the former task our best model outperforms even all previously reported ensembles.", "text": "For translation tasks, the Transformer can be trained significantly faster than architectures based on recurrent or convolutional layers. On both WMT 2014 English-to-German and WMT 2014 English-to-French translation tasks, we achieve a new state of the art. In the former task our best model outperforms even all previously reported ensembles." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/144", + "self_ref": "#/texts/109", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2524,19 +1996,7 @@ "text": "We are excited about the future of attention-based models and plan to apply them to other tasks. We plan to extend the Transformer to problems involving input and output modalities other than text and to investigate local, restricted attention mechanisms to efficiently handle large inputs and outputs such as images, audio and video.\nMaking generation less sequential is another research goals of ours." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/145", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "The code we used to train and evaluate our models is available at", - "text": "The code we used to train and evaluate our models is available at" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/146", + "self_ref": "#/texts/110", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2544,11 +2004,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "https://github.com/tensorflow/tensor2tensor.", - "text": "https://github.com/tensorflow/tensor2tensor." + "orig": "The code we used to train and evaluate our models is available at https://github.com/tensorflow/tensor2tensor.", + "text": "The code we used to train and evaluate our models is available at https://github.com/tensorflow/tensor2tensor." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/147", + "self_ref": "#/texts/111", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2560,7 +2020,7 @@ "text": "AcknowledgementsWe are grateful to Nal Kalchbrenner and Stephan Gouws for\ntheir fruitful comments, corrections and inspiration." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/148", + "self_ref": "#/texts/112", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2572,7 +2032,7 @@ "text": "plain" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/149", + "self_ref": "#/texts/113", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2585,7 +2045,7 @@ "level": 1 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/150", + "self_ref": "#/texts/114", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -2599,7 +2059,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/151", + "self_ref": "#/texts/115", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -2613,7 +2073,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/152", + "self_ref": "#/texts/116", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -2627,7 +2087,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/153", + "self_ref": "#/texts/117", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -2641,7 +2101,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/154", + "self_ref": "#/texts/118", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -2655,7 +2115,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/155", + "self_ref": "#/texts/119", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -2669,7 +2129,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/156", + "self_ref": "#/texts/120", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -2683,7 +2143,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/157", + "self_ref": "#/texts/121", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -2697,7 +2157,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/158", + "self_ref": "#/texts/122", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -2711,7 +2171,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/159", + "self_ref": "#/texts/123", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -2725,7 +2185,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/160", + "self_ref": "#/texts/124", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -2739,7 +2199,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/161", + "self_ref": "#/texts/125", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -2753,7 +2213,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/162", + "self_ref": "#/texts/126", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -2767,7 +2227,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/163", + "self_ref": "#/texts/127", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -2781,7 +2241,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/164", + "self_ref": "#/texts/128", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -2795,7 +2255,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/165", + "self_ref": "#/texts/129", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -2809,7 +2269,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/166", + "self_ref": "#/texts/130", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -2823,7 +2283,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/167", + "self_ref": "#/texts/131", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -2837,7 +2297,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/168", + "self_ref": "#/texts/132", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -2851,7 +2311,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/169", + "self_ref": "#/texts/133", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -2865,7 +2325,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/170", + "self_ref": "#/texts/134", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -2879,7 +2339,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/171", + "self_ref": "#/texts/135", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -2893,7 +2353,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/172", + "self_ref": "#/texts/136", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -2907,7 +2367,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/173", + "self_ref": "#/texts/137", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -2921,7 +2381,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/174", + "self_ref": "#/texts/138", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -2935,7 +2395,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/175", + "self_ref": "#/texts/139", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -2949,7 +2409,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/176", + "self_ref": "#/texts/140", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -2963,7 +2423,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/177", + "self_ref": "#/texts/141", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -2977,7 +2437,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/178", + "self_ref": "#/texts/142", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -2991,7 +2451,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/179", + "self_ref": "#/texts/143", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -3005,7 +2465,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/180", + "self_ref": "#/texts/144", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -3019,7 +2479,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/181", + "self_ref": "#/texts/145", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -3033,7 +2493,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/182", + "self_ref": "#/texts/146", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -3047,7 +2507,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/183", + "self_ref": "#/texts/147", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -3061,7 +2521,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/184", + "self_ref": "#/texts/148", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -3075,7 +2535,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/185", + "self_ref": "#/texts/149", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -3089,7 +2549,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/186", + "self_ref": "#/texts/150", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -3103,7 +2563,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/187", + "self_ref": "#/texts/151", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -3117,7 +2577,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/188", + "self_ref": "#/texts/152", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -3131,7 +2591,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/189", + "self_ref": "#/texts/153", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -3145,7 +2605,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/190", + "self_ref": "#/texts/154", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -3159,7 +2619,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/191", + "self_ref": "#/texts/155", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3172,7 +2632,7 @@ "level": 1 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/192", + "self_ref": "#/texts/156", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3184,7 +2644,7 @@ "text": "Image: ./vis/making_more_difficult5_new.pdf" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/193", + "self_ref": "#/texts/157", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/4" }, @@ -3196,7 +2656,7 @@ "text": "An example of the attention mechanism following long-distance dependencies in the encoder self-attention in layer 5 of 6. Many of the attention heads attend to a distant dependency of the verb `making', completing the phrase `making...more difficult'. Attentions here shown only for the word `making'. Different colors represent different heads. Best viewed in color." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/194", + "self_ref": "#/texts/158", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3208,7 +2668,7 @@ "text": "Image: ./vis/anaphora_resolution_new.pdf" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/195", + "self_ref": "#/texts/159", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3220,7 +2680,7 @@ "text": "Image: ./vis/anaphora_resolution2_new.pdf" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/196", + "self_ref": "#/texts/160", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/5" }, @@ -3232,7 +2692,7 @@ "text": "Two attention heads, also in layer 5 of 6, apparently involved in anaphora resolution. Top: Full attentions for head 5. Bottom: Isolated attentions from just the word `its' for attention heads 5 and 6. Note that the attentions are very sharp for this word." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/197", + "self_ref": "#/texts/161", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3244,7 +2704,7 @@ "text": "Image: ./vis/attending_to_head_new.pdf" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/198", + "self_ref": "#/texts/162", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3256,7 +2716,7 @@ "text": "Image: ./vis/attending_to_head2_new.pdf" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/199", + "self_ref": "#/texts/163", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/6" }, @@ -3280,7 +2740,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/21" + "$ref": "#/texts/16" } ], "references": [], @@ -3298,7 +2758,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/47" + "$ref": "#/texts/36" } ], "references": [], @@ -3316,7 +2776,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/50" + "$ref": "#/texts/39" } ], "references": [], @@ -3334,7 +2794,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/192" + "$ref": "#/texts/156" } ], "references": [], @@ -3346,7 +2806,7 @@ "width": 765.0, "height": 461.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -3361,7 +2821,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/194" + "$ref": "#/texts/158" } ], "references": [], @@ -3373,7 +2833,7 @@ "width": 639.0, "height": 434.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -3388,7 +2848,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/195" + "$ref": "#/texts/159" } ], "references": [], @@ -3400,7 +2860,7 @@ "width": 632.0, "height": 463.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -3415,7 +2875,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/197" + "$ref": "#/texts/161" } ], "references": [], @@ -3427,7 +2887,7 @@ "width": 637.0, "height": 424.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -3442,7 +2902,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/198" + "$ref": "#/texts/162" } ], "references": [], @@ -3454,7 +2914,7 @@ "width": 637.0, "height": 417.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] } diff --git a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/1706.03762_main.tex.md b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/1706.03762_main.tex.md index 8e7849a82c..5d4b212f6d 100644 --- a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/1706.03762_main.tex.md +++ b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/1706.03762_main.tex.md @@ -56,14 +56,10 @@ The dominant sequence transduction models are based on complex recurrent or conv Recurrent neural networks, long short-term memory [hochreiter1997] and gated recurrent [gruEval14] neural networks in particular, have been firmly established as state of the art approaches in sequence modeling and transduction problems such as language modeling and machine translation [sutskever14, bahdanau2014neural, cho2014learning]. Numerous efforts have since continued to push the boundaries of recurrent language models and encoder-decoder architectures [wu2016google,luong2015effective,jozefowicz2016exploring]. -Recurrent models typically factor computation along the symbol positions of the input and output sequences. Aligning the positions to steps in computation time, they generate a sequence of hidden states - -$h\_t$, as a function of the previous hidden state $h\_{t-1}$ and the input for position $t$. This inherently sequential nature precludes parallelization within training examples, which becomes critical at longer sequence lengths, as memory constraints limit batching across examples. +Recurrent models typically factor computation along the symbol positions of the input and output sequences. Aligning the positions to steps in computation time, they generate a sequence of hidden states $h\_t$, as a function of the previous hidden state $h\_{t-1}$ and the input for position $t$. This inherently sequential nature precludes parallelization within training examples, which becomes critical at longer sequence lengths, as memory constraints limit batching across examples. Recent work has achieved significant improvements in computational efficiency through factorization tricks [Kuchaiev2017Factorization] and conditional computation [shazeer2017outrageously], while also improving model performance in case of the latter. The fundamental constraint of sequential computation, however, remains. -Attention mechanisms have become an integral part of compelling sequence modeling and transduction models in various tasks, allowing modeling of dependencies without regard to their distance in the input or output sequences - -[bahdanau2014neural, structuredAttentionNetworks]. In all but a few cases [decomposableAttnModel], however, such attention mechanisms are used in conjunction with a recurrent network. +Attention mechanisms have become an integral part of compelling sequence modeling and transduction models in various tasks, allowing modeling of dependencies without regard to their distance in the input or output sequences [bahdanau2014neural, structuredAttentionNetworks]. In all but a few cases [decomposableAttnModel], however, such attention mechanisms are used in conjunction with a recurrent network. In this work we propose the Transformer, a model architecture eschewing recurrence and instead relying entirely on an attention mechanism to draw global dependencies between input and output. The Transformer allows for significantly more parallelization and can reach a new state of the art in translation quality after being trained for as little as twelve hours on eight P100 GPUs. @@ -71,18 +67,12 @@ In this work we propose the Transformer, a model architecture eschewing recurren The goal of reducing sequential computation also forms the foundation of the Extended Neural GPU [extendedngpu], ByteNet [NalBytenet2017] and ConvS2S [JonasFaceNet2017], all of which use convolutional neural networks as basic building block, computing hidden representations in parallel for all input and output positions. In these models, the number of operations required to relate signals from two arbitrary input or output positions grows in the distance between positions, linearly for ConvS2S and logarithmically for ByteNet. This makes it more difficult to learn dependencies between distant positions [hochreiter2001gradient]. In the Transformer this is reduced to a constant number of operations, albeit at the cost of reduced effective resolution due to averaging attention-weighted positions, an effect we counteract with Multi-Head Attention as described in section[sec:attention]. -Self-attention, sometimes called intra-attention is an attention mechanism relating different positions of a single sequence in order to compute a representation of the sequence. Self-attention has been used successfully in a variety of tasks including reading comprehension, abstractive summarization, textual entailment and learning task-independent sentence representations - -[cheng2016long, decomposableAttnModel, paulus2017deep, lin2017structured]. +Self-attention, sometimes called intra-attention is an attention mechanism relating different positions of a single sequence in order to compute a representation of the sequence. Self-attention has been used successfully in a variety of tasks including reading comprehension, abstractive summarization, textual entailment and learning task-independent sentence representations [cheng2016long, decomposableAttnModel, paulus2017deep, lin2017structured]. -End-to-end memory networks are based on a recurrent attention mechanism instead of sequence-aligned recurrence and have been shown to perform well on simple-language question answering and language modeling tasks - -[sukhbaatar2015]. +End-to-end memory networks are based on a recurrent attention mechanism instead of sequence-aligned recurrence and have been shown to perform well on simple-language question answering and language modeling tasks [sukhbaatar2015]. To the best of our knowledge, however, the Transformer is the first transduction model relying entirely on self-attention to compute representations of its input and output without using sequence-aligned RNNs or convolution. -In the following sections, we will describe the Transformer, motivate self-attention and discuss its advantages over models such as - -[neural\_gpu, NalBytenet2017] and [JonasFaceNet2017]. +In the following sections, we will describe the Transformer, motivate self-attention and discuss its advantages over models such as [neural\_gpu, NalBytenet2017] and [JonasFaceNet2017]. ## Model Architecture @@ -92,13 +82,9 @@ Image: Figures/ModalNet-21 The Transformer - model architecture. -Most competitive neural sequence transduction models have an encoder-decoder structure +Most competitive neural sequence transduction models have an encoder-decoder structure [cho2014learning,bahdanau2014neural,sutskever14]. Here, the encoder maps an input sequence of symbol representations $(x\_1, ..., x\_n)$ to a sequence of continuous representations $\mathbf{z} = (z\_1, ..., z\_n)$. Given $\mathbf{z}$, the decoder then generates an output sequence $(y\_1,...,y\_m)$ of symbols one element at a time. At each step the model is auto-regressive [graves2013generating], consuming the previously generated symbols as additional input when generating the next. -[cho2014learning,bahdanau2014neural,sutskever14]. Here, the encoder maps an input sequence of symbol representations $(x\_1, ..., x\_n)$ to a sequence of continuous representations $\mathbf{z} = (z\_1, ..., z\_n)$. Given $\mathbf{z}$, the decoder then generates an output sequence $(y\_1,...,y\_m)$ of symbols one element at a time. At each step the model is auto-regressive [graves2013generating], consuming the previously generated symbols as additional input when generating the next. - -The Transformer follows this overall architecture using stacked self-attention and point-wise, fully connected layers for both the encoder and decoder, shown in the left and right halves of Figure - -[fig:model-arch], respectively. +The Transformer follows this overall architecture using stacked self-attention and point-wise, fully connected layers for both the encoder and decoder, shown in the left and right halves of Figure[fig:model-arch], respectively. ### Encoder and Decoder Stacks @@ -112,23 +98,15 @@ An attention function can be described as mapping a query and a set of key-value #### Scaled Dot-Product Attention -We call our particular attention "Scaled Dot-Product Attention" (Figure - -[fig:multi-head-att]). The input consists of queries and keys of dimension $d\_k$, and values of dimension $d\_v$. We compute the dot products of the query with all keys, divide each by $\sqrt{d\_k}$, and apply a softmax function to obtain the weights on the values. - -In practice, we compute the attention function on a set of queries simultaneously, packed together into a matrix +We call our particular attention "Scaled Dot-Product Attention" (Figure[fig:multi-head-att]). The input consists of queries and keys of dimension $d\_k$, and values of dimension $d\_v$. We compute the dot products of the query with all keys, divide each by $\sqrt{d\_k}$, and apply a softmax function to obtain the weights on the values. -$Q$. The keys and values are also packed together into matrices $K$ and $V$. We compute the matrix of outputs as: +In practice, we compute the attention function on a set of queries simultaneously, packed together into a matrix $Q$. The keys and values are also packed together into matrices $K$ and $V$. We compute the matrix of outputs as: $$\mathrm{Attention}(Q, K, V) = \mathrm{softmax}(\frac{QK^T}{\sqrt{d_k}})V$$ -The two most commonly used attention functions are additive attention +The two most commonly used attention functions are additive attention [bahdanau2014neural], and dot-product (multiplicative) attention. Dot-product attention is identical to our algorithm, except for the scaling factor of $\frac{1}{\sqrt{d\_k}}$. Additive attention computes the compatibility function using a feed-forward network with a single hidden layer. While the two are similar in theoretical complexity, dot-product attention is much faster and more space-efficient in practice, since it can be implemented using highly optimized matrix multiplication code. -[bahdanau2014neural], and dot-product (multiplicative) attention. Dot-product attention is identical to our algorithm, except for the scaling factor of $\frac{1}{\sqrt{d\_k}}$. Additive attention computes the compatibility function using a feed-forward network with a single hidden layer. While the two are similar in theoretical complexity, dot-product attention is much faster and more space-efficient in practice, since it can be implemented using highly optimized matrix multiplication code. - -While for small values of - -$d\_k$ the two mechanisms perform similarly, additive attention outperforms dot product attention without scaling for larger values of $d\_k$ [DBLP:journals/corr/BritzGLL17]. We suspect that for large values of $d\_k$, the dot products grow large in magnitude, pushing the softmax function into regions where it has extremely small gradients +While for small values of $d\_k$ the two mechanisms perform similarly, additive attention outperforms dot product attention without scaling for larger values of $d\_k$ [DBLP:journals/corr/BritzGLL17]. We suspect that for large values of $d\_k$, the dot products grow large in magnitude, pushing the softmax function into regions where it has extremely small gradients To illustrate why the dot products get large, assume that the components of $q$ and $k$ are independent random variables with mean $0$ and variance $1$. Then their dot product, $q \cdot k = \sum\_{i=1}^{d\_k} q\_ik\_i$, has mean $0$ and variance $d\_k$. @@ -154,26 +132,20 @@ Image: Figures/ModalNet-20 (left) Scaled Dot-Product Attention. (right) Multi-Head Attention consists of several attention layers running in parallel. -Instead of performing a single attention function with - -$d\_{\text{model}}$-dimensional keys, values and queries, we found it beneficial to linearly project the queries, keys and values $h$ times with different, learned linear projections to $d\_k$, $d\_k$ and $d\_v$ dimensions, respectively. +Instead of performing a single attention function with $d\_{\text{model}}$-dimensional keys, values and queries, we found it beneficial to linearly project the queries, keys and values $h$ times with different, learned linear projections to $d\_k$, $d\_k$ and $d\_v$ dimensions, respectively. On each of these projected versions of queries, keys and values we then perform the attention function in parallel, yielding $d\_v$-dimensional output values. These are concatenated and once again projected, resulting in the final values, as depicted in Figure[fig:multi-head-att]. Multi-head attention allows the model to jointly attend to information from different representation subspaces at different positions. With a single attention head, averaging inhibits this. $$\begin{align*} \mathrm{MultiHead}(Q, K, V) &= \mathrm{Concat}(\mathrm{head_1}, ..., \mathrm{head_h})W^O\\ -% \mathrm{where} \mathrm{head_i} &= \mathrm{Attention}(QW_Q_i^{d_{\text{model}} \times d_q}, KW_K_i^{d_{\text{model}} \times d_k}, VW^V_i^{d_{\text{model}} \times d_v})\\ +% \mathrm{where} \mathrm{head_i} &= \mathrm{Attention}(QW_Q_i^{\dmodel \times d_q}, KW_K_i^{\dmodel \times d_k}, VW^V_i^{\dmodel \times d_v})\\ \text{where}~\mathrm{head_i} &= \mathrm{Attention}(QW^Q_i, KW^K_i, VW^V_i)\\ \end{align*}$$ -Where the projections are parameter matrices - -$W^Q\_i \in \mathbb{R}^{d\_{\text{model}} \times d\_k}$, $W^K\_i \in \mathbb{R}^{d\_{\text{model}} \times d\_k}$, $W^V\_i \in \mathbb{R}^{d\_{\text{model}} \times d\_v}$ and $W^O \in \mathbb{R}^{hd\_v \times d\_{\text{model}}}$. - -In this work we employ +Where the projections are parameter matrices $W^Q\_i \in \mathbb{R}^{d\_{\text{model}}\times d\_k}$, $W^K\_i \in \mathbb{R}^{d\_{\text{model}}\times d\_k}$, $W^V\_i \in \mathbb{R}^{d\_{\text{model}}\times d\_v}$ and $W^O \in \mathbb{R}^{hd\_v \times d\_{\text{model}}}$. -$h=8$ parallel attention layers, or heads. For each of these we use $d\_k=d\_v=d\_{\text{model}}/h=64$. +In this work we employ $h=8$ parallel attention layers, or heads. For each of these we use $d\_k=d\_v=d\_{\text{model}}/h=64$. Due to the reduced dimension of each head, the total computational cost is similar to that of single-head attention with full dimensionality. #### Applications of Attention in our Model @@ -190,9 +162,7 @@ In addition to attention sub-layers, each of the layers in our encoder and decod $$\mathrm{FFN}(x)=\max(0, xW_1 + b_1) W_2 + b_2$$ -While the linear transformations are the same across different positions, they use different parameters from layer to layer. Another way of describing this is as two convolutions with kernel size 1. The dimensionality of input and output is - -$d\_{\text{model}}=512$, and the inner-layer has dimensionality $d\_{ff}=2048$. +While the linear transformations are the same across different positions, they use different parameters from layer to layer. Another way of describing this is as two convolutions with kernel size 1. The dimensionality of input and output is $d\_{\text{model}}=512$, and the inner-layer has dimensionality $d\_{ff}=2048$. ### Embeddings and Softmax @@ -209,26 +179,18 @@ $$\begin{align*} PE_{(pos,2i+1)} = cos(pos / 10000^{2i/d_{\text{model}}}) \end{align*}$$ -where - -$pos$ is the position and $i$ is the dimension. That is, each dimension of the positional encoding corresponds to a sinusoid. The wavelengths form a geometric progression from $2\pi$ to $10000 \cdot 2\pi$. We chose this function because we hypothesized it would allow the model to easily learn to attend by relative positions, since for any fixed offset $k$, $PE\_{pos+k}$ can be represented as a linear function of $PE\_{pos}$. +where $pos$ is the position and $i$ is the dimension. That is, each dimension of the positional encoding corresponds to a sinusoid. The wavelengths form a geometric progression from $2\pi$ to $10000 \cdot 2\pi$. We chose this function because we hypothesized it would allow the model to easily learn to attend by relative positions, since for any fixed offset $k$, $PE\_{pos+k}$ can be represented as a linear function of $PE\_{pos}$. -We also experimented with using learned positional embeddings - -[JonasFaceNet2017] instead, and found that the two versions produced nearly identical results (see Table[tab:variations] row (E)). We chose the sinusoidal version because it may allow the model to extrapolate to sequence lengths longer than the ones encountered during training. +We also experimented with using learned positional embeddings [JonasFaceNet2017] instead, and found that the two versions produced nearly identical results (see Table[tab:variations] row (E)). We chose the sinusoidal version because it may allow the model to extrapolate to sequence lengths longer than the ones encountered during training. ## Why Self-Attention -In this section we compare various aspects of self-attention layers to the recurrent and convolutional layers commonly used for mapping one variable-length sequence of symbol representations - -$(x\_1, ..., x\_n)$ to another sequence of equal length $(z\_1, ..., z\_n)$, with $x\_i, z\_i \in \mathbb{R}^d$, such as a hidden layer in a typical sequence transduction encoder or decoder. Motivating our use of self-attention we consider three desiderata. +In this section we compare various aspects of self-attention layers to the recurrent and convolutional layers commonly used for mapping one variable-length sequence of symbol representations $(x\_1, ..., x\_n)$ to another sequence of equal length $(z\_1, ..., z\_n)$, with $x\_i, z\_i \in \mathbb{R}^d$, such as a hidden layer in a typical sequence transduction encoder or decoder. Motivating our use of self-attention we consider three desiderata. One is the total computational complexity per layer. Another is the amount of computation that can be parallelized, as measured by the minimum number of sequential operations required. -The third is the path length between long-range dependencies in the network. Learning long-range dependencies is a key challenge in many sequence transduction tasks. One key factor affecting the ability to learn such dependencies is the length of the paths forward and backward signals have to traverse in the network. The shorter these paths between any combination of positions in the input and output sequences, the easier it is to learn long-range dependencies - -[hochreiter2001gradient]. Hence we also compare the maximum path length between any two input and output positions in networks composed of the different layer types. +The third is the path length between long-range dependencies in the network. Learning long-range dependencies is a key challenge in many sequence transduction tasks. One key factor affecting the ability to learn such dependencies is the length of the paths forward and backward signals have to traverse in the network. The shorter these paths between any combination of positions in the input and output sequences, the easier it is to learn long-range dependencies [hochreiter2001gradient]. Hence we also compare the maximum path length between any two input and output positions in networks composed of the different layer types. Maximum path lengths, per-layer complexity and minimum number of sequential operations for different layer types. $n$ is the sequence length, $d$ is the representation dimension, $k$ is the kernel size of convolutions and $r$ the size of the neighborhood in restricted self-attention. @@ -241,15 +203,11 @@ Maximum path lengths, per-layer complexity and minimum number of sequential oper | Self-Attention (restricted) | $O(r \cdot n \cdot d)$ | $O(1)$ | $O(n/r)$ | | | | | | -As noted in Table - -[tab:op\_complexities], a self-attention layer connects all positions with a constant number of sequentially executed operations, whereas a recurrent layer requires $O(n)$ sequential operations. +As noted in Table [tab:op\_complexities], a self-attention layer connects all positions with a constant number of sequentially executed operations, whereas a recurrent layer requires $O(n)$ sequential operations. In terms of computational complexity, self-attention layers are faster than recurrent layers when the sequence length $n$ is smaller than the representation dimensionality $d$, which is most often the case with sentence representations used by state-of-the-art models in machine translations, such as word-piece [wu2016google] and byte-pair [sennrich2015neural] representations. To improve computational performance for tasks involving very long sequences, self-attention could be restricted to considering only a neighborhood of size $r$ in the input sequence centered around the respective output position. This would increase the maximum path length to $O(n/r)$. We plan to investigate this approach further in future work. -A single convolutional layer with kernel width - -$k < n$ does not connect all pairs of input and output positions. Doing so requires a stack of $O(n/k)$ convolutional layers in the case of contiguous kernels, or $O(log\_k(n))$ in the case of dilated convolutions [NalBytenet2017], increasing the length of the longest paths between any two positions in the network. +A single convolutional layer with kernel width $k < n$ does not connect all pairs of input and output positions. Doing so requires a stack of $O(n/k)$ convolutional layers in the case of contiguous kernels, or $O(log\_k(n))$ in the case of dilated convolutions [NalBytenet2017], increasing the length of the longest paths between any two positions in the network. Convolutional layers are generally more expensive than recurrent layers, by a factor of $k$. Separable convolutions [xception2016], however, decrease the complexity considerably, to $O(k \cdot n \cdot d + n \cdot d^2)$. Even with $k=n$, however, the complexity of a separable convolution is equal to the combination of a self-attention layer and a point-wise feed-forward layer, the approach we take in our model. As side benefit, self-attention could yield more interpretable models. We inspect attention distributions from our models and present and discuss examples in the appendix. Not only do individual attention heads clearly learn to perform different tasks, many appear to exhibit behavior related to the syntactic and semantic structure of the sentences. @@ -264,9 +222,7 @@ We trained on the standard WMT 2014 English-German dataset consisting of about 4 ### Hardware and Schedule -We trained our models on one machine with 8 NVIDIA P100 GPUs. For our base models using the hyperparameters described throughout the paper, each training step took about 0.4 seconds. We trained the base models for a total of 100,000 steps or 12 hours. For our big models,(described on the bottom line of table - -[tab:variations]), step time was 1.0 seconds. The big models were trained for 300,000 steps (3.5 days). +We trained our models on one machine with 8 NVIDIA P100 GPUs. For our base models using the hyperparameters described throughout the paper, each training step took about 0.4 seconds. We trained the base models for a total of 100,000 steps or 12 hours. For our big models,(described on the bottom line of table [tab:variations]), step time was 1.0 seconds. The big models were trained for 300,000 steps (3.5 days). ### Optimizer @@ -276,9 +232,7 @@ $$lrate = d_{\text{model}}^{-0.5} \cdot \min({step\_num}^{-0.5}, {step\_num} \cdot {warmup\_steps}^{-1.5})$$ -This corresponds to increasing the learning rate linearly for the first - -$warmup\_steps$ training steps, and decreasing it thereafter proportionally to the inverse square root of the step number. We used $warmup\_steps=4000$. +This corresponds to increasing the learning rate linearly for the first $warmup\_steps$ training steps, and decreasing it thereafter proportionally to the inverse square root of the step number. We used $warmup\_steps=4000$. ### Regularization @@ -309,21 +263,13 @@ The Transformer achieves better BLEU scores than previous state-of-the-art model | Transformer (big) | 28.4 | 41.8 | | 2c$2.3\cdot10^{19}$ | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | -On the WMT 2014 English-to-German translation task, the big transformer model (Transformer (big) in Table - -[tab:wmt-results]) outperforms the best previously reported models (including ensembles) by more than $2.0$ BLEU, establishing a new state-of-the-art BLEU score of $28.4$. The configuration of this model is listed in the bottom line of Table[tab:variations]. Training took $3.5$ days on $8$P100 GPUs. Even our base model surpasses all previously published models and ensembles, at a fraction of the training cost of any of the competitive models. - -On the WMT 2014 English-to-French translation task, our big model achieves a BLEU score of - -$41.0$, outperforming all of the previously published single models, at less than $1/4$ the training cost of the previous state-of-the-art model. The Transformer (big) model trained for English-to-French used dropout rate $P\_{drop}=0.1$, instead of $0.3$. - -For the base models, we used a single model obtained by averaging the last 5 checkpoints, which were written at 10-minute intervals. For the big models, we averaged the last 20 checkpoints. We used beam search with a beam size of +On the WMT 2014 English-to-German translation task, the big transformer model (Transformer (big) in Table[tab:wmt-results]) outperforms the best previously reported models (including ensembles) by more than $2.0$ BLEU, establishing a new state-of-the-art BLEU score of $28.4$. The configuration of this model is listed in the bottom line of Table[tab:variations]. Training took $3.5$ days on $8$P100 GPUs. Even our base model surpasses all previously published models and ensembles, at a fraction of the training cost of any of the competitive models. -$4$ and length penalty $\alpha=0.6$ [wu2016google]. These hyperparameters were chosen after experimentation on the development set. We set the maximum output length during inference to input length + $50$, but terminate early when possible [wu2016google]. +On the WMT 2014 English-to-French translation task, our big model achieves a BLEU score of $41.0$, outperforming all of the previously published single models, at less than $1/4$ the training cost of the previous state-of-the-art model. The Transformer (big) model trained for English-to-French used dropout rate $P\_{drop}=0.1$, instead of $0.3$. -Table +For the base models, we used a single model obtained by averaging the last 5 checkpoints, which were written at 10-minute intervals. For the big models, we averaged the last 20 checkpoints. We used beam search with a beam size of $4$ and length penalty $\alpha=0.6$ [wu2016google]. These hyperparameters were chosen after experimentation on the development set. We set the maximum output length during inference to input length + $50$, but terminate early when possible [wu2016google]. -[tab:wmt-results] summarizes our results and compares our translation quality and training costs to other model architectures from the literature. We estimate the number of floating point operations used to train a model by multiplying the training time, the number of GPUs used, and an estimate of the sustained single-precision floating-point capacity of each GPU +Table [tab:wmt-results] summarizes our results and compares our translation quality and training costs to other model architectures from the literature. We estimate the number of floating point operations used to train a model by multiplying the training time, the number of GPUs used, and an estimate of the sustained single-precision floating-point capacity of each GPU We used values of 2.8, 3.7, 6.0 and 9.5 TFLOPS for K80, K40, M40 and P100, respectively. @@ -358,17 +304,11 @@ Variations on the Transformer architecture. Unlisted values are identical to tho | 0pt2.0ex big | 6 | 1024 | 4096 | 16 | | | 0.3 | | 300K | 4.33 | 26.4 | 213 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | -To evaluate the importance of different components of the Transformer, we varied our base model in different ways, measuring the change in performance on English-to-German translation on the development set, newstest2013. We used beam search as described in the previous section, but no checkpoint averaging. We present these results in Table +To evaluate the importance of different components of the Transformer, we varied our base model in different ways, measuring the change in performance on English-to-German translation on the development set, newstest2013. We used beam search as described in the previous section, but no checkpoint averaging. We present these results in Table[tab:variations]. -[tab:variations]. +In Table[tab:variations] rows (A), we vary the number of attention heads and the attention key and value dimensions, keeping the amount of computation constant, as described in Section [sec:multihead]. While single-head attention is 0.9 BLEU worse than the best setting, quality also drops off with too many heads. -In Table - -[tab:variations] rows (A), we vary the number of attention heads and the attention key and value dimensions, keeping the amount of computation constant, as described in Section [sec:multihead]. While single-head attention is 0.9 BLEU worse than the best setting, quality also drops off with too many heads. - -In Table - -[tab:variations] rows (B), we observe that reducing the attention key size $d\_k$ hurts model quality. This suggests that determining compatibility is not easy and that a more sophisticated compatibility function than dot product may be beneficial. We further observe in rows (C) and (D) that, as expected, bigger models are better, and dropout is very helpful in avoiding over-fitting. In row (E) we replace our sinusoidal positional encoding with learned positional embeddings [JonasFaceNet2017], and observe nearly identical results to the base model. +In Table[tab:variations] rows (B), we observe that reducing the attention key size $d\_k$ hurts model quality. This suggests that determining compatibility is not easy and that a more sophisticated compatibility function than dot product may be beneficial. We further observe in rows (C) and (D) that, as expected, bigger models are better, and dropout is very helpful in avoiding over-fitting. In row (E) we replace our sinusoidal positional encoding with learned positional embeddings [JonasFaceNet2017], and observe nearly identical results to the base model. ### English Constituency Parsing @@ -391,25 +331,15 @@ The Transformer generalizes well to English constituency parsing (Results are on | | | | | To evaluate if the Transformer can generalize to other tasks we performed experiments on English constituency parsing. This task presents specific challenges: the output is subject to strong structural constraints and is significantly longer than the input. -Furthermore, RNN sequence-to-sequence models have not been able to attain state-of-the-art results in small-data regimes - -[KVparse15]. - -We trained a 4-layer transformer with +Furthermore, RNN sequence-to-sequence models have not been able to attain state-of-the-art results in small-data regimes [KVparse15]. -$d\_{model} = 1024$ on the Wall Street Journal (WSJ) portion of the Penn Treebank [marcus1993building], about 40K training sentences. We also trained it in a semi-supervised setting, using the larger high-confidence and BerkleyParser corpora from with approximately 17M sentences [KVparse15]. We used a vocabulary of 16K tokens for the WSJ only setting and a vocabulary of 32K tokens for the semi-supervised setting. +We trained a 4-layer transformer with $d\_{model} = 1024$ on the Wall Street Journal (WSJ) portion of the Penn Treebank [marcus1993building], about 40K training sentences. We also trained it in a semi-supervised setting, using the larger high-confidence and BerkleyParser corpora from with approximately 17M sentences [KVparse15]. We used a vocabulary of 16K tokens for the WSJ only setting and a vocabulary of 32K tokens for the semi-supervised setting. -We performed only a small number of experiments to select the dropout, both attention and residual (section +We performed only a small number of experiments to select the dropout, both attention and residual (section[sec:reg]), learning rates and beam size on the Section 22 development set, all other parameters remained unchanged from the English-to-German base translation model. During inference, we increased the maximum output length to input length + $300$. We used a beam size of $21$ and $\alpha=0.3$for both WSJ only and the semi-supervised setting. -[sec:reg]), learning rates and beam size on the Section 22 development set, all other parameters remained unchanged from the English-to-German base translation model. During inference, we increased the maximum output length to input length + $300$. We used a beam size of $21$ and $\alpha=0.3$for both WSJ only and the semi-supervised setting. +Our results in Table[tab:parsing-results] show that despite the lack of task-specific tuning our model performs surprisingly well, yielding better results than all previously reported models with the exception of the Recurrent Neural Network Grammar [dyer-rnng:16]. -Our results in Table - -[tab:parsing-results] show that despite the lack of task-specific tuning our model performs surprisingly well, yielding better results than all previously reported models with the exception of the Recurrent Neural Network Grammar [dyer-rnng:16]. - -In contrast to RNN sequence-to-sequence models - -[KVparse15], the Transformer outperforms the BerkeleyParser [petrov-EtAl:2006:ACL] even when training only on the WSJ training set of 40K sentences. +In contrast to RNN sequence-to-sequence models [KVparse15], the Transformer outperforms the BerkeleyParser [petrov-EtAl:2006:ACL] even when training only on the WSJ training set of 40K sentences. ## Conclusion @@ -420,9 +350,7 @@ For translation tasks, the Transformer can be trained significantly faster than We are excited about the future of attention-based models and plan to apply them to other tasks. We plan to extend the Transformer to problems involving input and output modalities other than text and to investigate local, restricted attention mechanisms to efficiently handle large inputs and outputs such as images, audio and video. Making generation less sequential is another research goals of ours. -The code we used to train and evaluate our models is available at - -https://github.com/tensorflow/tensor2tensor. +The code we used to train and evaluate our models is available at https://github.com/tensorflow/tensor2tensor. AcknowledgementsWe are grateful to Nal Kalchbrenner and Stephan Gouws for their fruitful comments, corrections and inspiration. diff --git a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2305.03393_main.tex.itxt b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2305.03393_main.tex.itxt index 754e247d79..4a9c228fbf 100644 --- a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2305.03393_main.tex.itxt +++ b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2305.03393_main.tex.itxt @@ -15,112 +15,94 @@ IBM Research item-11 at level 2: picture item-11 at level 3: caption: Image: ./figs/html_v_otsl_intro_v2.pdf item-12 at level 1: caption: Image: ./figs/html_v_otsl_intro_v2.pdf - item-13 at level 1: paragraph: In modern document understanding systems - item-14 at level 1: text: [IEECloud22,KDD18], table extrac ... 9res2tim,xue2021tgrnet,GTE,PubTabNet]. - item-15 at level 1: paragraph: Recently emerging SOTA methods f ... s in various configurations. In Figure - item-16 at level 1: text: [OTSLvHTML_show], we illustrate ... d-truth representation format for TSR. - item-17 at level 1: paragraph: While the majority of research i ... bNet and FinTabNet) is usually adopted - item-18 at level 1: text: as is for the sequence tokenizat ... this model to perform our experiments. - item-19 at level 1: paragraph: The main contribution of this pa ... TSL features are illustrated in Figure - item-20 at level 1: text: [OTSLvHTML_show], in comparison to HTML. - item-21 at level 1: paragraph: The paper is structured as follows. In section - item-22 at level 1: text: [RW], we give an overview of the ... work and outline next potential steps. - item-23 at level 1: section_header: RWRelated Work - item-24 at level 1: paragraph: Approaches to formalize the logi ... uments date back more than two decades - item-25 at level 1: text: [10.5555/923400]. In the recent ... ly valid (let alone correct) sequence. - item-26 at level 1: paragraph: Within the Im2Seq method, we fin ... y the encoder-dual-decoder model (EDD) - item-27 at level 1: text: [PubTabNet], TableFormer[TableFo ... eparate OCR module to extract content. - item-28 at level 1: paragraph: Im2Seq approaches have shown to ... r state-of-the-art prediction accuracy - item-29 at level 1: text: [TableFormer]. This motivated th ... l network architectures for this task. - item-30 at level 1: section_header: PSProblem Statement - item-31 at level 1: paragraph: All known Im2Seq based models fo ... ure. For example, with the HTML tokens - item-32 at level 1: text: ,
, , , ... initions in the HTML token vocabulary. - item-33 at level 1: section: group figure - item-34 at level 2: text: Frequency of tokens in HTML and OTSL as they appear in PubTabNet. - item-35 at level 2: picture - item-35 at level 3: caption: Image: ./figs/html_freq_v4.png - item-36 at level 1: caption: Image: ./figs/html_freq_v4.png - item-37 at level 1: paragraph: Obviously, HTML and other genera ... s represented by at least two tokens ( - item-38 at level 1: text: and ). Furthermore, wh ... or models to learn the HTML structure. - item-39 at level 1: paragraph: Additionally, it would be desira ... ces is non-trivial or even impossible. - item-40 at level 1: paragraph: In a valid HTML table, the token ... rules, simply to deliver valid output. - item-41 at level 1: paragraph: In practice, we observe two majo ... ests itself in either in an increasing - item-42 at level 1: text: location drift for proposed tabl ... ion or matching of table cell content. - item-43 at level 1: section_header: OTSLOptimised Table Structure Language - item-44 at level 1: text: To mitigate the issues with HTML ... time in the TableFormer architecture. - item-45 at level 1: section_header: Language Definition - item-46 at level 1: text: In Figure[OTSL_PROOF], we illust ... structure based on an atomic 2D grid. - item-47 at level 1: section: group figure - item-48 at level 2: text: OTSL description of table struct ... ding; E - explanation on cell encoding - item-49 at level 2: picture - item-49 at level 3: caption: Image: ./figs/otsl_proof_v3.pdf - item-50 at level 1: caption: Image: ./figs/otsl_proof_v3.pdf - item-51 at level 1: paragraph: The OTSL vocabulary is comprised of the following tokens: - item-52 at level 1: list: group list - item-53 at level 2: list_item: "C" cell - a new table cell that either has or does not have cell content - item-54 at level 2: list_item: "L" cell - left-looking cell, me ... he left neighbor cell to create a span - item-55 at level 2: list_item: "U" cell - up-looking cell, merg ... e upper neighbor cell to create a span - item-56 at level 2: list_item: "X" cell - cross cell, to merge with both left and upper neighbor cells - item-57 at level 2: list_item: "NL" - new-line, switch to the next row. - item-58 at level 1: paragraph: A notable attribute of OTSL is t ... achieving lossless conversion to HTML. - item-59 at level 1: section_header: Language Syntax - item-60 at level 1: paragraph: The OTSL representation follows these syntax rules: - item-61 at level 1: list: group list - item-62 at level 2: list_item: Left-looking cell rule: + item-13 at level 1: text: In modern document understanding ... 9res2tim,xue2021tgrnet,GTE,PubTabNet]. + item-14 at level 1: text: Recently emerging SOTA methods f ... d-truth representation format for TSR. + item-15 at level 1: text: While the majority of research i ... this model to perform our experiments. + item-16 at level 1: text: The main contribution of this pa ... TSLvHTML_show], in comparison to HTML. + item-17 at level 1: text: The paper is structured as follo ... work and outline next potential steps. + item-18 at level 1: section_header: RWRelated Work + item-19 at level 1: text: Approaches to formalize the logi ... ly valid (let alone correct) sequence. + item-20 at level 1: text: Within the Im2Seq method, we fin ... eparate OCR module to extract content. + item-21 at level 1: text: Im2Seq approaches have shown to ... l network architectures for this task. + item-22 at level 1: section_header: PSProblem Statement + item-23 at level 1: text: All known Im2Seq based models fo ... initions in the HTML token vocabulary. + item-24 at level 1: section: group figure + item-25 at level 2: text: Frequency of tokens in HTML and OTSL as they appear in PubTabNet. + item-26 at level 2: picture + item-26 at level 3: caption: Image: ./figs/html_freq_v4.png + item-27 at level 1: caption: Image: ./figs/html_freq_v4.png + item-28 at level 1: text: Obviously, HTML and other genera ... or models to learn the HTML structure. + item-29 at level 1: paragraph: Additionally, it would be desira ... ces is non-trivial or even impossible. + item-30 at level 1: paragraph: In a valid HTML table, the token ... rules, simply to deliver valid output. + item-31 at level 1: text: In practice, we observe two majo ... ion or matching of table cell content. + item-32 at level 1: section_header: OTSLOptimised Table Structure Language + item-33 at level 1: text: To mitigate the issues with HTML ... time in the TableFormer architecture. + item-34 at level 1: section_header: Language Definition + item-35 at level 1: text: In Figure[OTSL_PROOF], we illust ... structure based on an atomic 2D grid. + item-36 at level 1: section: group figure + item-37 at level 2: text: OTSL description of table struct ... ding; E - explanation on cell encoding + item-38 at level 2: picture + item-38 at level 3: caption: Image: ./figs/otsl_proof_v3.pdf + item-39 at level 1: caption: Image: ./figs/otsl_proof_v3.pdf + item-40 at level 1: text: The OTSL vocabulary is comprised of the following tokens: + item-41 at level 1: list: group list + item-42 at level 2: list_item: "C" cell - a new table cell that either has or does not have cell content + item-43 at level 2: list_item: "L" cell - left-looking cell, me ... he left neighbor cell to create a span + item-44 at level 2: list_item: "U" cell - up-looking cell, merg ... e upper neighbor cell to create a span + item-45 at level 2: list_item: "X" cell - cross cell, to merge with both left and upper neighbor cells + item-46 at level 2: list_item: "NL" - new-line, switch to the next row. + item-47 at level 1: paragraph: A notable attribute of OTSL is t ... achieving lossless conversion to HTML. + item-48 at level 1: section_header: Language Syntax + item-49 at level 1: paragraph: The OTSL representation follows these syntax rules: + item-50 at level 1: list: group list + item-51 at level 2: list_item: Left-looking cell rule: The lef ... either another "L" cell or a "C" cell. - item-63 at level 2: list_item: Up-looking cell rule: + item-52 at level 2: list_item: Up-looking cell rule: The upper ... either another "U" cell or a "C" cell. - item-64 at level 2: list_item: Cross cell rule: - item-65 at level 2: list_item: The left neighbour of an "X" cel ... ither another "X" cell or an "L" cell. - item-66 at level 2: list_item: First row rule: + item-53 at level 2: list_item: Cross cell rule: + item-54 at level 2: list_item: The left neighbour of an "X" cel ... ither another "X" cell or an "L" cell. + item-55 at level 2: list_item: First row rule: Only "L" cells and "C" cells are allowed in the first row. - item-67 at level 2: list_item: First column rule: + item-56 at level 2: list_item: First column rule: Only "U" cell ... cells are allowed in the first column. - item-68 at level 2: list_item: Rectangular rule: + item-57 at level 2: list_item: Rectangular rule: The table repr ... of tokens, terminated with "NL" token. - item-69 at level 1: paragraph: The application of these rules g ... icted sequence is syntactically valid. - item-70 at level 1: paragraph: These characteristics can be eas ... n in the HTML based models (see Figure - item-71 at level 1: text: [OTSLvHTML_compare]). - item-72 at level 1: section_header: Error-detection and -mitigation - item-73 at level 1: paragraph: The design of OTSL allows to val ... idence until OTSL rules are satisfied. - item-74 at level 1: section_header: ResultsExperiments - item-75 at level 1: paragraph: To evaluate the impact of OTSL o ... based on the TableFormer model (Figure - item-76 at level 1: text: [ED_model_sketch]) with two obje ... , and will be made publicly available. - item-77 at level 1: section: group figure - item-78 at level 2: text: Architecture sketch of the Table ... epresentative for the Im2Seq approach. - item-79 at level 2: picture - item-79 at level 3: caption: Image: ./figs/tablemodel_overview_otsl.pdf - item-80 at level 1: caption: Image: ./figs/tablemodel_overview_otsl.pdf - item-81 at level 1: paragraph: We rely on standard metrics such ... core with AMD EPYC 7763 CPU @2.45 GHz. - item-82 at level 1: section_header: Hyper Parameter Optimization - item-83 at level 1: paragraph: We have chosen the PubTabNet dat ... pans). Results are presented in Table. - item-84 at level 1: text: [tab:HPO]. It is evident that wi ... upin the inference runtime over HTML. - item-85 at level 1: text: HPO performed in OTSL and HTML r ... r mAP score than the HTML counterpart. - item-86 at level 1: table with [11x8] - item-87 at level 1: section_header: Quantitative Results - item-88 at level 1: paragraph: We picked the model parameter co ... rmance results are presented in Table. - item-89 at level 1: text: [tab:HTMLvOTSL_precision]. It is ... that contain sparse and large tables. - item-90 at level 1: text: TSR and cell detection results c ... eFormer] (with enc=6, dec=6, heads=8). - item-91 at level 1: table with [9x7] - item-92 at level 1: paragraph: Additionally, the results show t ... f the reduced sequence representation. - item-93 at level 1: section_header: Qualitative Results - item-94 at level 1: paragraph: To illustrate the qualitative differences between OTSL and HTML, Figure - item-95 at level 1: text: [OTSLvHTML_compare] demonstrates ... ructure prediction and bounding boxes. - item-96 at level 1: section: group figure - item-97 at level 2: text: The OTSL model produces more acc ... C). "PMC2807444_006_00.png" PubTabNet. - item-98 at level 2: picture - item-98 at level 3: caption: Image: ./figs/HTMLvOTSLv7.pdf - item-99 at level 1: caption: Image: ./figs/HTMLvOTSLv7.pdf - item-100 at level 1: section: group figure - item-101 at level 2: text: Visualization of predicted struc ... es. "PMC5406406_003_01.png" PubTabNet. - item-102 at level 2: picture - item-102 at level 3: caption: Image: ./figs/otsl_vs_html_ex3_v2.pdf - item-103 at level 1: caption: Image: ./figs/otsl_vs_html_ex3_v2.pdf - item-104 at level 1: section_header: ConConclusion - item-105 at level 1: text: We demonstrated that representin ... e languages, has several key benefits. - item-106 at level 1: paragraph: First and foremost, given the sa ... e to models trained on HTML (see Table - item-107 at level 1: text: [tab:HPO]). - item-108 at level 1: paragraph: Secondly, OTSL has more inherent ... e table-cell bounding boxes (see Table - item-109 at level 1: text: [tab:HTMLvOTSL_precision]). As s ... on-the-fly during sequence generation. - item-110 at level 1: text: splncs04 - item-111 at level 1: text: papers \ No newline at end of file + item-58 at level 1: paragraph: The application of these rules g ... icted sequence is syntactically valid. + item-59 at level 1: text: These characteristics can be eas ... odels (see Figure[OTSLvHTML_compare]). + item-60 at level 1: section_header: Error-detection and -mitigation + item-61 at level 1: paragraph: The design of OTSL allows to val ... idence until OTSL rules are satisfied. + item-62 at level 1: section_header: ResultsExperiments + item-63 at level 1: text: To evaluate the impact of OTSL o ... , and will be made publicly available. + item-64 at level 1: section: group figure + item-65 at level 2: text: Architecture sketch of the Table ... epresentative for the Im2Seq approach. + item-66 at level 2: picture + item-66 at level 3: caption: Image: ./figs/tablemodel_overview_otsl.pdf + item-67 at level 1: caption: Image: ./figs/tablemodel_overview_otsl.pdf + item-68 at level 1: paragraph: We rely on standard metrics such ... core with AMD EPYC 7763 CPU @2.45 GHz. + item-69 at level 1: section_header: Hyper Parameter Optimization + item-70 at level 1: text: We have chosen the PubTabNet dat ... upin the inference runtime over HTML. + item-71 at level 1: text: HPO performed in OTSL and HTML r ... r mAP score than the HTML counterpart. + item-72 at level 1: table with [11x8] + item-73 at level 1: section_header: Quantitative Results + item-74 at level 1: text: We picked the model parameter co ... that contain sparse and large tables. + item-75 at level 1: text: TSR and cell detection results c ... eFormer] (with enc=6, dec=6, heads=8). + item-76 at level 1: table with [9x7] + item-77 at level 1: paragraph: Additionally, the results show t ... f the reduced sequence representation. + item-78 at level 1: section_header: Qualitative Results + item-79 at level 1: text: To illustrate the qualitative di ... ructure prediction and bounding boxes. + item-80 at level 1: section: group figure + item-81 at level 2: text: The OTSL model produces more acc ... C). "PMC2807444_006_00.png" PubTabNet. + item-82 at level 2: picture + item-82 at level 3: caption: Image: ./figs/HTMLvOTSLv7.pdf + item-83 at level 1: caption: Image: ./figs/HTMLvOTSLv7.pdf + item-84 at level 1: section: group figure + item-85 at level 2: text: Visualization of predicted struc ... es. "PMC5406406_003_01.png" PubTabNet. + item-86 at level 2: picture + item-86 at level 3: caption: Image: ./figs/otsl_vs_html_ex3_v2.pdf + item-87 at level 1: caption: Image: ./figs/otsl_vs_html_ex3_v2.pdf + item-88 at level 1: section_header: ConConclusion + item-89 at level 1: text: We demonstrated that representin ... e languages, has several key benefits. + item-90 at level 1: text: First and foremost, given the sa ... trained on HTML (see Table[tab:HPO]). + item-91 at level 1: text: Secondly, OTSL has more inherent ... on-the-fly during sequence generation. + item-92 at level 1: text: splncs04 + item-93 at level 1: text: papers \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2305.03393_main.tex.json b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2305.03393_main.tex.json index 60fc86d264..f7a4539d95 100644 --- a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2305.03393_main.tex.json +++ b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2305.03393_main.tex.json @@ -76,7 +76,7 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/20" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/21" + "$ref": "#/groups/1" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/22" @@ -103,10 +103,10 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/29" }, { - "$ref": "#/groups/1" + "$ref": "#/texts/30" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/31" + "$ref": "#/groups/2" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/32" @@ -115,19 +115,7 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/33" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/34" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/35" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/36" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/37" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/38" + "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/39" @@ -139,16 +127,10 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/41" }, { - "$ref": "#/groups/2" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/43" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/44" + "$ref": "#/groups/4" }, { - "$ref": "#/groups/3" + "$ref": "#/texts/49" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/50" @@ -160,118 +142,82 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/52" }, { - "$ref": "#/groups/4" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/60" + "$ref": "#/texts/53" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/61" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/62" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/63" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/64" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/65" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/66" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/67" + "$ref": "#/texts/54" }, { "$ref": "#/groups/5" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/69" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/70" + "$ref": "#/texts/56" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/71" + "$ref": "#/texts/57" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/72" + "$ref": "#/texts/58" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/73" + "$ref": "#/texts/59" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/74" + "$ref": "#/texts/60" }, { "$ref": "#/tables/0" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/75" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/76" + "$ref": "#/texts/61" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/77" + "$ref": "#/texts/62" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/78" + "$ref": "#/texts/63" }, { "$ref": "#/tables/1" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/79" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/80" + "$ref": "#/texts/64" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/81" + "$ref": "#/texts/65" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/82" + "$ref": "#/texts/66" }, { "$ref": "#/groups/6" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/84" + "$ref": "#/texts/68" }, { "$ref": "#/groups/7" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/86" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/87" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/88" + "$ref": "#/texts/70" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/89" + "$ref": "#/texts/71" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/90" + "$ref": "#/texts/72" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/91" + "$ref": "#/texts/73" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/92" + "$ref": "#/texts/74" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/93" + "$ref": "#/texts/75" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/94" + "$ref": "#/texts/76" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -303,7 +249,7 @@ }, "children": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/30" + "$ref": "#/texts/21" }, { "$ref": "#/pictures/1" @@ -320,7 +266,7 @@ }, "children": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/42" + "$ref": "#/texts/31" }, { "$ref": "#/pictures/2" @@ -337,19 +283,19 @@ }, "children": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/45" + "$ref": "#/texts/34" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/46" + "$ref": "#/texts/35" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/47" + "$ref": "#/texts/36" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/48" + "$ref": "#/texts/37" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/49" + "$ref": "#/texts/38" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -363,25 +309,25 @@ }, "children": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/53" + "$ref": "#/texts/42" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/54" + "$ref": "#/texts/43" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/55" + "$ref": "#/texts/44" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/56" + "$ref": "#/texts/45" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/57" + "$ref": "#/texts/46" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/58" + "$ref": "#/texts/47" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/59" + "$ref": "#/texts/48" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -395,7 +341,7 @@ }, "children": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/68" + "$ref": "#/texts/55" }, { "$ref": "#/pictures/3" @@ -412,7 +358,7 @@ }, "children": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/83" + "$ref": "#/texts/67" }, { "$ref": "#/pictures/4" @@ -429,7 +375,7 @@ }, "children": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/85" + "$ref": "#/texts/69" }, { "$ref": "#/pictures/5" @@ -570,10 +516,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "In modern document understanding systems", - "text": "In modern document understanding systems" + "orig": "In modern document understanding systems[IEECloud22,KDD18], table extraction is typically a two-step process. Firstly, every table on a page is located with a bounding box, and secondly, their logical row and column structure is recognized. As of today, table detection in documents is a well understood problem, and the latest state-of-the-art (SOTA) object detection methods provide an accuracy comparable to human observers[li2019tablebank,pagemodelrnn,DocLayNet,smock2022pubtables,PubLayNet]. On the other hand, the problem of table structure recognition (TSR) is a lot more challenging and remains a very active area of research, in which many novel machine learning algorithms are being explored[chi2019complicated,deng2019challenges,kayal2022tables,TableFormer,prasad2020cascadetabnet,schreiber2017deepdesrt,8978137,smock2022pubtables,xue2019res2tim,xue2021tgrnet,GTE,PubTabNet].", + "text": "In modern document understanding systems[IEECloud22,KDD18], table extraction is typically a two-step process. Firstly, every table on a page is located with a bounding box, and secondly, their logical row and column structure is recognized. As of today, table detection in documents is a well understood problem, and the latest state-of-the-art (SOTA) object detection methods provide an accuracy comparable to human observers[li2019tablebank,pagemodelrnn,DocLayNet,smock2022pubtables,PubLayNet]. On the other hand, the problem of table structure recognition (TSR) is a lot more challenging and remains a very active area of research, in which many novel machine learning algorithms are being explored[chi2019complicated,deng2019challenges,kayal2022tables,TableFormer,prasad2020cascadetabnet,schreiber2017deepdesrt,8978137,smock2022pubtables,xue2019res2tim,xue2021tgrnet,GTE,PubTabNet]." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/11", @@ -584,8 +530,8 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[IEECloud22,KDD18], table extraction is typically a two-step process. Firstly, every table on a page is located with a bounding box, and secondly, their logical row and column structure is recognized. As of today, table detection in documents is a well understood problem, and the latest state-of-the-art (SOTA) object detection methods provide an accuracy comparable to human observers[li2019tablebank,pagemodelrnn,DocLayNet,smock2022pubtables,PubLayNet]. On the other hand, the problem of table structure recognition (TSR) is a lot more challenging and remains a very active area of research, in which many novel machine learning algorithms are being explored[chi2019complicated,deng2019challenges,kayal2022tables,TableFormer,prasad2020cascadetabnet,schreiber2017deepdesrt,8978137,smock2022pubtables,xue2019res2tim,xue2021tgrnet,GTE,PubTabNet].", - "text": "[IEECloud22,KDD18], table extraction is typically a two-step process. Firstly, every table on a page is located with a bounding box, and secondly, their logical row and column structure is recognized. As of today, table detection in documents is a well understood problem, and the latest state-of-the-art (SOTA) object detection methods provide an accuracy comparable to human observers[li2019tablebank,pagemodelrnn,DocLayNet,smock2022pubtables,PubLayNet]. On the other hand, the problem of table structure recognition (TSR) is a lot more challenging and remains a very active area of research, in which many novel machine learning algorithms are being explored[chi2019complicated,deng2019challenges,kayal2022tables,TableFormer,prasad2020cascadetabnet,schreiber2017deepdesrt,8978137,smock2022pubtables,xue2019res2tim,xue2021tgrnet,GTE,PubTabNet]." + "orig": "Recently emerging SOTA methods for table structure recognition employ transformer-based models, in which an image of the table is provided to the network in order to predict the structure of the table as a sequence of tokens. These image-to-sequence (Im2Seq) models are extremely powerful, since they allow for a purely data-driven solution. The tokens of the sequence typically belong to a markup language such as HTML, Latex or Markdown, which allow to describe table structure as rows, columns and spanning cells in various configurations. In Figure[OTSLvHTML_show], we illustrate how HTML is used to represent the table-structure of a particular example table. Public table-structure data sets such as PubTabNet[PubTabNet], and FinTabNet[GTE], which were created in a semi-automated way from paired PDF and HTML sources (e.g. PubMed Central), popularized primarily the use of HTML as ground-truth representation format for TSR.", + "text": "Recently emerging SOTA methods for table structure recognition employ transformer-based models, in which an image of the table is provided to the network in order to predict the structure of the table as a sequence of tokens. These image-to-sequence (Im2Seq) models are extremely powerful, since they allow for a purely data-driven solution. The tokens of the sequence typically belong to a markup language such as HTML, Latex or Markdown, which allow to describe table structure as rows, columns and spanning cells in various configurations. In Figure[OTSLvHTML_show], we illustrate how HTML is used to represent the table-structure of a particular example table. Public table-structure data sets such as PubTabNet[PubTabNet], and FinTabNet[GTE], which were created in a semi-automated way from paired PDF and HTML sources (e.g. PubMed Central), popularized primarily the use of HTML as ground-truth representation format for TSR." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/12", @@ -594,10 +540,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "Recently emerging SOTA methods for table structure recognition employ transformer-based models, in which an image of the table is provided to the network in order to predict the structure of the table as a sequence of tokens. These image-to-sequence (Im2Seq) models are extremely powerful, since they allow for a purely data-driven solution. The tokens of the sequence typically belong to a markup language such as HTML, Latex or Markdown, which allow to describe table structure as rows, columns and spanning cells in various configurations. In Figure", - "text": "Recently emerging SOTA methods for table structure recognition employ transformer-based models, in which an image of the table is provided to the network in order to predict the structure of the table as a sequence of tokens. These image-to-sequence (Im2Seq) models are extremely powerful, since they allow for a purely data-driven solution. The tokens of the sequence typically belong to a markup language such as HTML, Latex or Markdown, which allow to describe table structure as rows, columns and spanning cells in various configurations. In Figure" + "orig": "While the majority of research in TSR is currently focused on the development and application of novel neural model architectures, the table structure representation language (e.g. HTML in PubTabNet and FinTabNet) is usually adopted as is for the sequence tokenization in Im2Seq models. In this paper, we aim for the opposite and investigate the impact of the table structure representation language with an otherwise unmodified Im2Seq transformer-based architecture. Since the current state-of-the-art Im2Seq model is TableFormer[TableFormer], we select this model to perform our experiments.", + "text": "While the majority of research in TSR is currently focused on the development and application of novel neural model architectures, the table structure representation language (e.g. HTML in PubTabNet and FinTabNet) is usually adopted as is for the sequence tokenization in Im2Seq models. In this paper, we aim for the opposite and investigate the impact of the table structure representation language with an otherwise unmodified Im2Seq transformer-based architecture. Since the current state-of-the-art Im2Seq model is TableFormer[TableFormer], we select this model to perform our experiments." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/13", @@ -608,8 +554,8 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[OTSLvHTML_show], we illustrate how HTML is used to represent the table-structure of a particular example table. Public table-structure data sets such as PubTabNet[PubTabNet], and FinTabNet[GTE], which were created in a semi-automated way from paired PDF and HTML sources (e.g. PubMed Central), popularized primarily the use of HTML as ground-truth representation format for TSR.", - "text": "[OTSLvHTML_show], we illustrate how HTML is used to represent the table-structure of a particular example table. Public table-structure data sets such as PubTabNet[PubTabNet], and FinTabNet[GTE], which were created in a semi-automated way from paired PDF and HTML sources (e.g. PubMed Central), popularized primarily the use of HTML as ground-truth representation format for TSR." + "orig": "The main contribution of this paper is the introduction of a new optimised table structure language (OTSL), specifically designed to describe table-structure in an compact and structured way for Im2Seq models. OTSL has a number of key features, which make it very attractive to use in Im2Seq models. Specifically, compared to other languages such as HTML, OTSL has a minimized vocabulary which yields short sequence length, strong inherent structure (e.g. strict rectangular layout) and a strict syntax with rules that only look backwards. The latter allows for syntax validation during inference and ensures a syntactically correct table-structure. These OTSL features are illustrated in Figure[OTSLvHTML_show], in comparison to HTML.", + "text": "The main contribution of this paper is the introduction of a new optimised table structure language (OTSL), specifically designed to describe table-structure in an compact and structured way for Im2Seq models. OTSL has a number of key features, which make it very attractive to use in Im2Seq models. Specifically, compared to other languages such as HTML, OTSL has a minimized vocabulary which yields short sequence length, strong inherent structure (e.g. strict rectangular layout) and a strict syntax with rules that only look backwards. The latter allows for syntax validation during inference and ensures a syntactically correct table-structure. These OTSL features are illustrated in Figure[OTSLvHTML_show], in comparison to HTML." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/14", @@ -618,73 +564,13 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "While the majority of research in TSR is currently focused on the development and application of novel neural model architectures, the table structure representation language (e.g. HTML in PubTabNet and FinTabNet) is usually adopted", - "text": "While the majority of research in TSR is currently focused on the development and application of novel neural model architectures, the table structure representation language (e.g. HTML in PubTabNet and FinTabNet) is usually adopted" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/15", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", - "prov": [], - "orig": "as is for the sequence tokenization in Im2Seq models. In this paper, we aim for the opposite and investigate the impact of the table structure representation language with an otherwise unmodified Im2Seq transformer-based architecture. Since the current state-of-the-art Im2Seq model is TableFormer[TableFormer], we select this model to perform our experiments.", - "text": "as is for the sequence tokenization in Im2Seq models. In this paper, we aim for the opposite and investigate the impact of the table structure representation language with an otherwise unmodified Im2Seq transformer-based architecture. Since the current state-of-the-art Im2Seq model is TableFormer[TableFormer], we select this model to perform our experiments." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/16", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "The main contribution of this paper is the introduction of a new optimised table structure language (OTSL), specifically designed to describe table-structure in an compact and structured way for Im2Seq models. OTSL has a number of key features, which make it very attractive to use in Im2Seq models. Specifically, compared to other languages such as HTML, OTSL has a minimized vocabulary which yields short sequence length, strong inherent structure (e.g. strict rectangular layout) and a strict syntax with rules that only look backwards. The latter allows for syntax validation during inference and ensures a syntactically correct table-structure. These OTSL features are illustrated in Figure", - "text": "The main contribution of this paper is the introduction of a new optimised table structure language (OTSL), specifically designed to describe table-structure in an compact and structured way for Im2Seq models. OTSL has a number of key features, which make it very attractive to use in Im2Seq models. Specifically, compared to other languages such as HTML, OTSL has a minimized vocabulary which yields short sequence length, strong inherent structure (e.g. strict rectangular layout) and a strict syntax with rules that only look backwards. The latter allows for syntax validation during inference and ensures a syntactically correct table-structure. These OTSL features are illustrated in Figure" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/17", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", - "prov": [], - "orig": "[OTSLvHTML_show], in comparison to HTML.", - "text": "[OTSLvHTML_show], in comparison to HTML." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/18", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "The paper is structured as follows. In section", - "text": "The paper is structured as follows. In section" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/19", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[RW], we give an overview of the latest developments in table-structure reconstruction. In section[PS] we review the current HTML table encoding (popularised by PubTabNet and FinTabNet) and discuss its flaws. Subsequently, we introduce OTSL in section[OTSL], which includes the language definition, syntax rules and error-correction procedures. In section[Results], we apply OTSL on the TableFormer architecture, compare it to TableFormer models trained on HTML and ultimately demonstrate the advantages of using OTSL. Finally, in section[Con]we conclude our work and outline next potential steps.", - "text": "[RW], we give an overview of the latest developments in table-structure reconstruction. In section[PS] we review the current HTML table encoding (popularised by PubTabNet and FinTabNet) and discuss its flaws. Subsequently, we introduce OTSL in section[OTSL], which includes the language definition, syntax rules and error-correction procedures. In section[Results], we apply OTSL on the TableFormer architecture, compare it to TableFormer models trained on HTML and ultimately demonstrate the advantages of using OTSL. Finally, in section[Con]we conclude our work and outline next potential steps." + "orig": "The paper is structured as follows. In section[RW], we give an overview of the latest developments in table-structure reconstruction. In section[PS] we review the current HTML table encoding (popularised by PubTabNet and FinTabNet) and discuss its flaws. Subsequently, we introduce OTSL in section[OTSL], which includes the language definition, syntax rules and error-correction procedures. In section[Results], we apply OTSL on the TableFormer architecture, compare it to TableFormer models trained on HTML and ultimately demonstrate the advantages of using OTSL. Finally, in section[Con]we conclude our work and outline next potential steps.", + "text": "The paper is structured as follows. In section[RW], we give an overview of the latest developments in table-structure reconstruction. In section[PS] we review the current HTML table encoding (popularised by PubTabNet and FinTabNet) and discuss its flaws. Subsequently, we introduce OTSL in section[OTSL], which includes the language definition, syntax rules and error-correction procedures. In section[Results], we apply OTSL on the TableFormer architecture, compare it to TableFormer models trained on HTML and ultimately demonstrate the advantages of using OTSL. Finally, in section[Con]we conclude our work and outline next potential steps." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/20", + "self_ref": "#/texts/15", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -697,19 +583,7 @@ "level": 1 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/21", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Approaches to formalize the logical structure and layout of tables in electronic documents date back more than two decades", - "text": "Approaches to formalize the logical structure and layout of tables in electronic documents date back more than two decades" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/22", + "self_ref": "#/texts/16", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -717,23 +591,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[10.5555/923400]. In the recent past, a wide variety of computer vision methods have been explored to tackle the problem of table structure recognition, i.e. the correct identification of columns, rows and spanning cells in a given table. Broadly speaking, the current deep-learning based approaches fall into three categories: object detection (OD) methods, Graph-Neural-Network (GNN) methods and Image-to-Markup-Sequence (Im2Seq) methods. Object-detection based methods [prasad2020cascadetabnet,schreiber2017deepdesrt,8978137,smock2022pubtables,GTE] rely on table-structure annotation using (overlapping) bounding boxes for training, and produce bounding-box predictions to define table cells, rows, and columns on a table image. \nGraph Neural Network (GNN) based methods [chi2019complicated,lee2022table,xue2019res2tim,xue2021tgrnet], as the name suggests, represent tables as graph structures. The graph nodes represent the content of each table cell, an embedding vector from the table image, or geometric coordinates of the table cell. The edges of the graph define the relationship between the nodes, e.g. if they belong to the same column, row, or table cell. Other work [zhang2022split] aims at predicting a grid for each table and deciding which cells must be merged using an attention network. \nIm2Seq methods cast the problem as a sequence generation task [deng2019challenges,kayal2022tables,TableFormer,PubTabNet], and therefore need an internal table-structure representation language, which is often implemented with standard markup languages (e.g. HTML, LaTeX, Markdown). \nIn theory, Im2Seq methods have a natural advantage over the OD and GNN methods by virtue of directly predicting the table-structure. As such, no post-processing or rules are needed in order to obtain the table-structure, which is necessary with OD and GNN approaches. In practice, this is not entirely true, because a predicted sequence of table-structure markup does not necessarily have to be syntactically correct. Hence, depending on the quality of the predicted sequence, some post-processing needs to be performed to ensure a syntactically valid (let alone correct) sequence.", - "text": "[10.5555/923400]. In the recent past, a wide variety of computer vision methods have been explored to tackle the problem of table structure recognition, i.e. the correct identification of columns, rows and spanning cells in a given table. Broadly speaking, the current deep-learning based approaches fall into three categories: object detection (OD) methods, Graph-Neural-Network (GNN) methods and Image-to-Markup-Sequence (Im2Seq) methods. Object-detection based methods [prasad2020cascadetabnet,schreiber2017deepdesrt,8978137,smock2022pubtables,GTE] rely on table-structure annotation using (overlapping) bounding boxes for training, and produce bounding-box predictions to define table cells, rows, and columns on a table image. \nGraph Neural Network (GNN) based methods [chi2019complicated,lee2022table,xue2019res2tim,xue2021tgrnet], as the name suggests, represent tables as graph structures. The graph nodes represent the content of each table cell, an embedding vector from the table image, or geometric coordinates of the table cell. The edges of the graph define the relationship between the nodes, e.g. if they belong to the same column, row, or table cell. Other work [zhang2022split] aims at predicting a grid for each table and deciding which cells must be merged using an attention network. \nIm2Seq methods cast the problem as a sequence generation task [deng2019challenges,kayal2022tables,TableFormer,PubTabNet], and therefore need an internal table-structure representation language, which is often implemented with standard markup languages (e.g. HTML, LaTeX, Markdown). \nIn theory, Im2Seq methods have a natural advantage over the OD and GNN methods by virtue of directly predicting the table-structure. As such, no post-processing or rules are needed in order to obtain the table-structure, which is necessary with OD and GNN approaches. In practice, this is not entirely true, because a predicted sequence of table-structure markup does not necessarily have to be syntactically correct. Hence, depending on the quality of the predicted sequence, some post-processing needs to be performed to ensure a syntactically valid (let alone correct) sequence." + "orig": "Approaches to formalize the logical structure and layout of tables in electronic documents date back more than two decades [10.5555/923400]. In the recent past, a wide variety of computer vision methods have been explored to tackle the problem of table structure recognition, i.e. the correct identification of columns, rows and spanning cells in a given table. Broadly speaking, the current deep-learning based approaches fall into three categories: object detection (OD) methods, Graph-Neural-Network (GNN) methods and Image-to-Markup-Sequence (Im2Seq) methods. Object-detection based methods [prasad2020cascadetabnet,schreiber2017deepdesrt,8978137,smock2022pubtables,GTE] rely on table-structure annotation using (overlapping) bounding boxes for training, and produce bounding-box predictions to define table cells, rows, and columns on a table image. \nGraph Neural Network (GNN) based methods [chi2019complicated,lee2022table,xue2019res2tim,xue2021tgrnet], as the name suggests, represent tables as graph structures. The graph nodes represent the content of each table cell, an embedding vector from the table image, or geometric coordinates of the table cell. The edges of the graph define the relationship between the nodes, e.g. if they belong to the same column, row, or table cell. Other work [zhang2022split] aims at predicting a grid for each table and deciding which cells must be merged using an attention network. \nIm2Seq methods cast the problem as a sequence generation task [deng2019challenges,kayal2022tables,TableFormer,PubTabNet], and therefore need an internal table-structure representation language, which is often implemented with standard markup languages (e.g. HTML, LaTeX, Markdown). \nIn theory, Im2Seq methods have a natural advantage over the OD and GNN methods by virtue of directly predicting the table-structure. As such, no post-processing or rules are needed in order to obtain the table-structure, which is necessary with OD and GNN approaches. In practice, this is not entirely true, because a predicted sequence of table-structure markup does not necessarily have to be syntactically correct. Hence, depending on the quality of the predicted sequence, some post-processing needs to be performed to ensure a syntactically valid (let alone correct) sequence.", + "text": "Approaches to formalize the logical structure and layout of tables in electronic documents date back more than two decades [10.5555/923400]. In the recent past, a wide variety of computer vision methods have been explored to tackle the problem of table structure recognition, i.e. the correct identification of columns, rows and spanning cells in a given table. Broadly speaking, the current deep-learning based approaches fall into three categories: object detection (OD) methods, Graph-Neural-Network (GNN) methods and Image-to-Markup-Sequence (Im2Seq) methods. Object-detection based methods [prasad2020cascadetabnet,schreiber2017deepdesrt,8978137,smock2022pubtables,GTE] rely on table-structure annotation using (overlapping) bounding boxes for training, and produce bounding-box predictions to define table cells, rows, and columns on a table image. \nGraph Neural Network (GNN) based methods [chi2019complicated,lee2022table,xue2019res2tim,xue2021tgrnet], as the name suggests, represent tables as graph structures. The graph nodes represent the content of each table cell, an embedding vector from the table image, or geometric coordinates of the table cell. The edges of the graph define the relationship between the nodes, e.g. if they belong to the same column, row, or table cell. Other work [zhang2022split] aims at predicting a grid for each table and deciding which cells must be merged using an attention network. \nIm2Seq methods cast the problem as a sequence generation task [deng2019challenges,kayal2022tables,TableFormer,PubTabNet], and therefore need an internal table-structure representation language, which is often implemented with standard markup languages (e.g. HTML, LaTeX, Markdown). \nIn theory, Im2Seq methods have a natural advantage over the OD and GNN methods by virtue of directly predicting the table-structure. As such, no post-processing or rules are needed in order to obtain the table-structure, which is necessary with OD and GNN approaches. In practice, this is not entirely true, because a predicted sequence of table-structure markup does not necessarily have to be syntactically correct. Hence, depending on the quality of the predicted sequence, some post-processing needs to be performed to ensure a syntactically valid (let alone correct) sequence." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/23", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Within the Im2Seq method, we find several popular models, namely the encoder-dual-decoder model (EDD)", - "text": "Within the Im2Seq method, we find several popular models, namely the encoder-dual-decoder model (EDD)" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/24", + "self_ref": "#/texts/17", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -741,23 +603,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[PubTabNet], TableFormer[TableFormer], Tabsplitter[identity_matrix] and Ye et. al.[TableMaster]. EDD uses two consecutive long short-term memory (LSTM) decoders to predict a table in HTML representation. The tag decoder predicts a sequence of HTML tags. For each decoded table cell (), the attention is passed to the cell decoder to predict the content with an embedded OCR approach. The latter makes it susceptible to transcription errors in the cell content of the table. TableFormer address this reliance on OCR and uses two transformer decoders for HTML structure and cell bounding box prediction in an end-to-end architecture. The predicted cell bounding box is then used to extract text tokens from an originating (digital) PDF page, circumventing any need for OCR. TabSplitter [identity_matrix] proposes a compact double-matrix representation of table rows and columns to do error detection and error correction of HTML structure sequences based on predictions from [TableMaster]. This compact double-matrix representation can not be used directly by the Img2seq model training, so the model uses HTML as an intermediate form. Chi et. al.[deng2019challenges] introduce a data set and a baseline method using bidirectional LSTMs to predict LaTeX code. Kayal [kayal2022tables]introduces Gated ResNet transformers to predict LaTeX code, and a separate OCR module to extract content.", - "text": "[PubTabNet], TableFormer[TableFormer], Tabsplitter[identity_matrix] and Ye et. al.[TableMaster]. EDD uses two consecutive long short-term memory (LSTM) decoders to predict a table in HTML representation. The tag decoder predicts a sequence of HTML tags. For each decoded table cell (), the attention is passed to the cell decoder to predict the content with an embedded OCR approach. The latter makes it susceptible to transcription errors in the cell content of the table. TableFormer address this reliance on OCR and uses two transformer decoders for HTML structure and cell bounding box prediction in an end-to-end architecture. The predicted cell bounding box is then used to extract text tokens from an originating (digital) PDF page, circumventing any need for OCR. TabSplitter [identity_matrix] proposes a compact double-matrix representation of table rows and columns to do error detection and error correction of HTML structure sequences based on predictions from [TableMaster]. This compact double-matrix representation can not be used directly by the Img2seq model training, so the model uses HTML as an intermediate form. Chi et. al.[deng2019challenges] introduce a data set and a baseline method using bidirectional LSTMs to predict LaTeX code. Kayal [kayal2022tables]introduces Gated ResNet transformers to predict LaTeX code, and a separate OCR module to extract content." + "orig": "Within the Im2Seq method, we find several popular models, namely the encoder-dual-decoder model (EDD)[PubTabNet], TableFormer[TableFormer], Tabsplitter[identity_matrix] and Ye et. al.[TableMaster]. EDD uses two consecutive long short-term memory (LSTM) decoders to predict a table in HTML representation. The tag decoder predicts a sequence of HTML tags. For each decoded table cell (), the attention is passed to the cell decoder to predict the content with an embedded OCR approach. The latter makes it susceptible to transcription errors in the cell content of the table. TableFormer address this reliance on OCR and uses two transformer decoders for HTML structure and cell bounding box prediction in an end-to-end architecture. The predicted cell bounding box is then used to extract text tokens from an originating (digital) PDF page, circumventing any need for OCR. TabSplitter [identity_matrix] proposes a compact double-matrix representation of table rows and columns to do error detection and error correction of HTML structure sequences based on predictions from [TableMaster]. This compact double-matrix representation can not be used directly by the Img2seq model training, so the model uses HTML as an intermediate form. Chi et. al.[deng2019challenges] introduce a data set and a baseline method using bidirectional LSTMs to predict LaTeX code. Kayal [kayal2022tables]introduces Gated ResNet transformers to predict LaTeX code, and a separate OCR module to extract content.", + "text": "Within the Im2Seq method, we find several popular models, namely the encoder-dual-decoder model (EDD)[PubTabNet], TableFormer[TableFormer], Tabsplitter[identity_matrix] and Ye et. al.[TableMaster]. EDD uses two consecutive long short-term memory (LSTM) decoders to predict a table in HTML representation. The tag decoder predicts a sequence of HTML tags. For each decoded table cell (), the attention is passed to the cell decoder to predict the content with an embedded OCR approach. The latter makes it susceptible to transcription errors in the cell content of the table. TableFormer address this reliance on OCR and uses two transformer decoders for HTML structure and cell bounding box prediction in an end-to-end architecture. The predicted cell bounding box is then used to extract text tokens from an originating (digital) PDF page, circumventing any need for OCR. TabSplitter [identity_matrix] proposes a compact double-matrix representation of table rows and columns to do error detection and error correction of HTML structure sequences based on predictions from [TableMaster]. This compact double-matrix representation can not be used directly by the Img2seq model training, so the model uses HTML as an intermediate form. Chi et. al.[deng2019challenges] introduce a data set and a baseline method using bidirectional LSTMs to predict LaTeX code. Kayal [kayal2022tables]introduces Gated ResNet transformers to predict LaTeX code, and a separate OCR module to extract content." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/25", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Im2Seq approaches have shown to be well-suited for the TSR task and allow a full end-to-end network design that can output the final table structure without pre- or post-processing logic. Furthermore, Im2Seq models have demonstrated to deliver state-of-the-art prediction accuracy", - "text": "Im2Seq approaches have shown to be well-suited for the TSR task and allow a full end-to-end network design that can output the final table structure without pre- or post-processing logic. Furthermore, Im2Seq models have demonstrated to deliver state-of-the-art prediction accuracy" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/26", + "self_ref": "#/texts/18", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -765,11 +615,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[TableFormer]. This motivated the authors to investigate if the performance (both in accuracy and inference time) can be further improved by optimising the table structure representation language. We believe this is a necessary step before further improving neural network architectures for this task.", - "text": "[TableFormer]. This motivated the authors to investigate if the performance (both in accuracy and inference time) can be further improved by optimising the table structure representation language. We believe this is a necessary step before further improving neural network architectures for this task." + "orig": "Im2Seq approaches have shown to be well-suited for the TSR task and allow a full end-to-end network design that can output the final table structure without pre- or post-processing logic. Furthermore, Im2Seq models have demonstrated to deliver state-of-the-art prediction accuracy[TableFormer]. This motivated the authors to investigate if the performance (both in accuracy and inference time) can be further improved by optimising the table structure representation language. We believe this is a necessary step before further improving neural network architectures for this task.", + "text": "Im2Seq approaches have shown to be well-suited for the TSR task and allow a full end-to-end network design that can output the final table structure without pre- or post-processing logic. Furthermore, Im2Seq models have demonstrated to deliver state-of-the-art prediction accuracy[TableFormer]. This motivated the authors to investigate if the performance (both in accuracy and inference time) can be further improved by optimising the table structure representation language. We believe this is a necessary step before further improving neural network architectures for this task." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/27", + "self_ref": "#/texts/19", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -782,19 +632,7 @@ "level": 1 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/28", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "All known Im2Seq based models for TSR fundamentally work in similar ways. Given an image of a table, the Im2Seq model predicts the structure of the table by generating a sequence of tokens. These tokens originate from a finite vocabulary and can be interpreted as a table structure. For example, with the HTML tokens", - "text": "All known Im2Seq based models for TSR fundamentally work in similar ways. Given an image of a table, the Im2Seq model predicts the structure of the table by generating a sequence of tokens. These tokens originate from a finite vocabulary and can be interpreted as a table structure. For example, with the HTML tokens" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/29", + "self_ref": "#/texts/20", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -802,11 +640,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": ",
, , , and , one can construct simple table structures without any spanning cells. In reality though, one needs at least 28 HTML tokens to describe the most common complex tables observed in real-world documents[GTE,PubTabNet], due to a variety of spanning cells definitions in the HTML token vocabulary.", - "text": ",
, , , and , one can construct simple table structures without any spanning cells. In reality though, one needs at least 28 HTML tokens to describe the most common complex tables observed in real-world documents[GTE,PubTabNet], due to a variety of spanning cells definitions in the HTML token vocabulary." + "orig": "All known Im2Seq based models for TSR fundamentally work in similar ways. Given an image of a table, the Im2Seq model predicts the structure of the table by generating a sequence of tokens. These tokens originate from a finite vocabulary and can be interpreted as a table structure. For example, with the HTML tokens ,
, , , and , one can construct simple table structures without any spanning cells. In reality though, one needs at least 28 HTML tokens to describe the most common complex tables observed in real-world documents[GTE,PubTabNet], due to a variety of spanning cells definitions in the HTML token vocabulary.", + "text": "All known Im2Seq based models for TSR fundamentally work in similar ways. Given an image of a table, the Im2Seq model predicts the structure of the table by generating a sequence of tokens. These tokens originate from a finite vocabulary and can be interpreted as a table structure. For example, with the HTML tokens ,
, , , and , one can construct simple table structures without any spanning cells. In reality though, one needs at least 28 HTML tokens to describe the most common complex tables observed in real-world documents[GTE,PubTabNet], due to a variety of spanning cells definitions in the HTML token vocabulary." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/30", + "self_ref": "#/texts/21", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/1" }, @@ -818,7 +656,7 @@ "text": "Frequency of tokens in HTML and OTSL as they appear in PubTabNet." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/31", + "self_ref": "#/texts/22", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -830,19 +668,7 @@ "text": "Image: ./figs/html_freq_v4.png" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/32", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Obviously, HTML and other general-purpose markup languages were not designed for Im2Seq models. As such, they have some serious drawbacks. First, the token vocabulary needs to be artificially large in order to describe all plausible tabular structures. Since most Im2Seq models use an autoregressive approach, they generate the sequence token by token. Therefore, to reduce inference time, a shorter sequence length is critical.\nEvery table-cell is represented by at least two tokens (", - "text": "Obviously, HTML and other general-purpose markup languages were not designed for Im2Seq models. As such, they have some serious drawbacks. First, the token vocabulary needs to be artificially large in order to describe all plausible tabular structures. Since most Im2Seq models use an autoregressive approach, they generate the sequence token by token. Therefore, to reduce inference time, a shorter sequence length is critical.\nEvery table-cell is represented by at least two tokens (" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/33", + "self_ref": "#/texts/23", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -850,11 +676,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": " and ). Furthermore, when tokenizing the HTML structure, one needs to explicitly enumerate possible column-spans and row-spans as words. In practice, this ends up requiring 28 different HTML tokens (when including column- and row-spans up to 10 cells) just to describe every table in the PubTabNet dataset. Clearly, not every token is equally represented, as is depicted in Figure[HTML_TRL]. This skewed distribution of tokens in combination with variable token row-length makes it challenging for models to learn the HTML structure.", - "text": " and ). Furthermore, when tokenizing the HTML structure, one needs to explicitly enumerate possible column-spans and row-spans as words. In practice, this ends up requiring 28 different HTML tokens (when including column- and row-spans up to 10 cells) just to describe every table in the PubTabNet dataset. Clearly, not every token is equally represented, as is depicted in Figure[HTML_TRL]. This skewed distribution of tokens in combination with variable token row-length makes it challenging for models to learn the HTML structure." + "orig": "Obviously, HTML and other general-purpose markup languages were not designed for Im2Seq models. As such, they have some serious drawbacks. First, the token vocabulary needs to be artificially large in order to describe all plausible tabular structures. Since most Im2Seq models use an autoregressive approach, they generate the sequence token by token. Therefore, to reduce inference time, a shorter sequence length is critical.\nEvery table-cell is represented by at least two tokens ( and ). Furthermore, when tokenizing the HTML structure, one needs to explicitly enumerate possible column-spans and row-spans as words. In practice, this ends up requiring 28 different HTML tokens (when including column- and row-spans up to 10 cells) just to describe every table in the PubTabNet dataset. Clearly, not every token is equally represented, as is depicted in Figure[HTML_TRL]. This skewed distribution of tokens in combination with variable token row-length makes it challenging for models to learn the HTML structure.", + "text": "Obviously, HTML and other general-purpose markup languages were not designed for Im2Seq models. As such, they have some serious drawbacks. First, the token vocabulary needs to be artificially large in order to describe all plausible tabular structures. Since most Im2Seq models use an autoregressive approach, they generate the sequence token by token. Therefore, to reduce inference time, a shorter sequence length is critical.\nEvery table-cell is represented by at least two tokens ( and ). Furthermore, when tokenizing the HTML structure, one needs to explicitly enumerate possible column-spans and row-spans as words. In practice, this ends up requiring 28 different HTML tokens (when including column- and row-spans up to 10 cells) just to describe every table in the PubTabNet dataset. Clearly, not every token is equally represented, as is depicted in Figure[HTML_TRL]. This skewed distribution of tokens in combination with variable token row-length makes it challenging for models to learn the HTML structure." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/34", + "self_ref": "#/texts/24", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -866,7 +692,7 @@ "text": "Additionally, it would be desirable if the representation would easily allow an early detection of invalid sequences on-the-go, before the prediction of the entire table structure is completed. HTML is not well-suited for this purpose as the verification of incomplete sequences is non-trivial or even impossible." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/35", + "self_ref": "#/texts/25", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -878,19 +704,7 @@ "text": "In a valid HTML table, the token sequence must describe a 2D grid of table cells, serialised in row-major ordering, where each row and each column have the same length (while considering row- and column-spans). Furthermore, every opening tag in HTML needs to be matched by a closing tag in a correct hierarchical manner.\nSince the number of tokens for each table row and column can vary significantly, especially for large tables with many row- and column-spans, it is complex to verify the consistency of predicted structures during sequence generation. Implicitly, this also means that Im2Seq models need to learn these complex syntax rules, simply to deliver valid output." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/36", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "In practice, we observe two major issues with prediction quality when training Im2Seq models on HTML table structure generation from images.\nOn the one hand, we find that on large tables, the visual attention of the model often starts to drift and is not accurately moving forward cell by cell anymore. This manifests itself in either in an increasing", - "text": "In practice, we observe two major issues with prediction quality when training Im2Seq models on HTML table structure generation from images.\nOn the one hand, we find that on large tables, the visual attention of the model often starts to drift and is not accurately moving forward cell by cell anymore. This manifests itself in either in an increasing" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/37", + "self_ref": "#/texts/26", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -898,11 +712,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "location drift for proposed table-cells in later rows on the same column or even complete loss of vertical alignment, as illustrated in Figure[OTSLvHTML_compare]. Addressing this with post-processing is partially possible, but clearly undesired. On the other hand, we find many instances of predictions with structural inconsistencies or plain invalid HTML output, as shown in Figure[OTSLvHTML_ex3], which are nearly impossible to properly correct.\nBoth problems seriously impact the TSR model performance, since they reflect not only in the task of pure structure recognition but also in the equally crucial recognition or matching of table cell content.", - "text": "location drift for proposed table-cells in later rows on the same column or even complete loss of vertical alignment, as illustrated in Figure[OTSLvHTML_compare]. Addressing this with post-processing is partially possible, but clearly undesired. On the other hand, we find many instances of predictions with structural inconsistencies or plain invalid HTML output, as shown in Figure[OTSLvHTML_ex3], which are nearly impossible to properly correct.\nBoth problems seriously impact the TSR model performance, since they reflect not only in the task of pure structure recognition but also in the equally crucial recognition or matching of table cell content." + "orig": "In practice, we observe two major issues with prediction quality when training Im2Seq models on HTML table structure generation from images.\nOn the one hand, we find that on large tables, the visual attention of the model often starts to drift and is not accurately moving forward cell by cell anymore. This manifests itself in either in an increasing location drift for proposed table-cells in later rows on the same column or even complete loss of vertical alignment, as illustrated in Figure[OTSLvHTML_compare]. Addressing this with post-processing is partially possible, but clearly undesired. On the other hand, we find many instances of predictions with structural inconsistencies or plain invalid HTML output, as shown in Figure[OTSLvHTML_ex3], which are nearly impossible to properly correct.\nBoth problems seriously impact the TSR model performance, since they reflect not only in the task of pure structure recognition but also in the equally crucial recognition or matching of table cell content.", + "text": "In practice, we observe two major issues with prediction quality when training Im2Seq models on HTML table structure generation from images.\nOn the one hand, we find that on large tables, the visual attention of the model often starts to drift and is not accurately moving forward cell by cell anymore. This manifests itself in either in an increasing location drift for proposed table-cells in later rows on the same column or even complete loss of vertical alignment, as illustrated in Figure[OTSLvHTML_compare]. Addressing this with post-processing is partially possible, but clearly undesired. On the other hand, we find many instances of predictions with structural inconsistencies or plain invalid HTML output, as shown in Figure[OTSLvHTML_ex3], which are nearly impossible to properly correct.\nBoth problems seriously impact the TSR model performance, since they reflect not only in the task of pure structure recognition but also in the equally crucial recognition or matching of table cell content." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/38", + "self_ref": "#/texts/27", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -915,7 +729,7 @@ "level": 1 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/39", + "self_ref": "#/texts/28", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -927,7 +741,7 @@ "text": "To mitigate the issues with HTML in Im2Seq-based TSR models laid out before, we propose here our Optimised Table Structure Language (OTSL). OTSL is designed to express table structure with a minimized vocabulary and a simple set of rules, which are both significantly reduced compared to HTML. At the same time, OTSL enables easy error detection and correction during sequence generation. We further demonstrate how the compact structure representation and minimized sequence length improves prediction accuracy and inference time in the TableFormer architecture." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/40", + "self_ref": "#/texts/29", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -940,7 +754,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/41", + "self_ref": "#/texts/30", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -952,7 +766,7 @@ "text": "In Figure[OTSL_PROOF], we illustrate how the OTSL is defined. In essence, the OTSL defines only 5 tokens that directly describe a tabular structure based on an atomic 2D grid." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/42", + "self_ref": "#/texts/31", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/2" }, @@ -964,7 +778,7 @@ "text": "OTSL description of table structure: A - table example; B - graphical representation of table structure; C - mapping structure on a grid; D - OTSL structure encoding; E - explanation on cell encoding" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/43", + "self_ref": "#/texts/32", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -976,19 +790,19 @@ "text": "Image: ./figs/otsl_proof_v3.pdf" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/44", + "self_ref": "#/texts/33", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], "orig": "The OTSL vocabulary is comprised of the following tokens:", "text": "The OTSL vocabulary is comprised of the following tokens:" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/45", + "self_ref": "#/texts/34", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -1002,7 +816,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/46", + "self_ref": "#/texts/35", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -1016,7 +830,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/47", + "self_ref": "#/texts/36", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -1030,7 +844,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/48", + "self_ref": "#/texts/37", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -1044,7 +858,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/49", + "self_ref": "#/texts/38", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -1058,7 +872,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/50", + "self_ref": "#/texts/39", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1070,7 +884,7 @@ "text": "A notable attribute of OTSL is that it has the capability of achieving lossless conversion to HTML." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/51", + "self_ref": "#/texts/40", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1083,7 +897,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/52", + "self_ref": "#/texts/41", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1095,7 +909,7 @@ "text": "The OTSL representation follows these syntax rules:" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/53", + "self_ref": "#/texts/42", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/4" }, @@ -1109,7 +923,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/54", + "self_ref": "#/texts/43", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/4" }, @@ -1123,7 +937,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/55", + "self_ref": "#/texts/44", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/4" }, @@ -1137,7 +951,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/56", + "self_ref": "#/texts/45", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/4" }, @@ -1151,7 +965,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/57", + "self_ref": "#/texts/46", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/4" }, @@ -1165,7 +979,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/58", + "self_ref": "#/texts/47", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/4" }, @@ -1179,7 +993,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/59", + "self_ref": "#/texts/48", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/4" }, @@ -1193,7 +1007,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/60", + "self_ref": "#/texts/49", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1205,19 +1019,7 @@ "text": "The application of these rules gives OTSL a set of unique properties.\nFirst of all, the OTSL enforces a strictly rectangular structure representation, where every new-line token starts a new row. As a consequence, all rows and all columns have exactly the same number of tokens, irrespective of cell spans.\nSecondly, the OTSL representation is unambiguous: Every table structure is represented in one way. In this representation every table cell corresponds to a \"C\"-cell token, which in case of spans is always located in the top-left corner of the table cell definition.\nThird, OTSL syntax rules are only backward-looking. As a consequence, every predicted token can be validated straight during sequence generation by looking at the previously predicted sequence. As such, OTSL can guarantee that every predicted sequence is syntactically valid." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/61", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "These characteristics can be easily learned by sequence generator networks, as we demonstrate further below. We find strong indications that this pattern reduces significantly the column drift seen in the HTML based models (see Figure", - "text": "These characteristics can be easily learned by sequence generator networks, as we demonstrate further below. We find strong indications that this pattern reduces significantly the column drift seen in the HTML based models (see Figure" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/62", + "self_ref": "#/texts/50", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1225,11 +1027,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[OTSLvHTML_compare]).", - "text": "[OTSLvHTML_compare])." + "orig": "These characteristics can be easily learned by sequence generator networks, as we demonstrate further below. We find strong indications that this pattern reduces significantly the column drift seen in the HTML based models (see Figure[OTSLvHTML_compare]).", + "text": "These characteristics can be easily learned by sequence generator networks, as we demonstrate further below. We find strong indications that this pattern reduces significantly the column drift seen in the HTML based models (see Figure[OTSLvHTML_compare])." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/63", + "self_ref": "#/texts/51", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1242,7 +1044,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/64", + "self_ref": "#/texts/52", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1254,7 +1056,7 @@ "text": "The design of OTSL allows to validate a table structure easily on an unfinished sequence. The detection of an invalid sequence token is a clear indication of a prediction mistake, however a valid sequence by itself does not guarantee prediction correctness. Different heuristics can be used to correct token errors in an invalid sequence and thus increase the chances for accurate predictions. Such heuristics can be applied either after the prediction of each token, or at the end on the entire predicted sequence.\nFor example a simple heuristic which can correct the predicted OTSL sequence on-the-fly is to verify if the token with the highest prediction confidence invalidates the predicted sequence, and replace it by the token with the next highest confidence until OTSL rules are satisfied." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/65", + "self_ref": "#/texts/53", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1267,19 +1069,7 @@ "level": 1 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/66", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "To evaluate the impact of OTSL on prediction accuracy and inference times, we conducted a series of experiments based on the TableFormer model (Figure", - "text": "To evaluate the impact of OTSL on prediction accuracy and inference times, we conducted a series of experiments based on the TableFormer model (Figure" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/67", + "self_ref": "#/texts/54", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1287,11 +1077,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[ED_model_sketch]) with two objectives: Firstly we evaluate the prediction quality and performance of OTSL vs. HTML after performing Hyper Parameter Optimization (HPO) on the canonical PubTabNet data set. Secondly we pick the best hyper-parameters found in the first step and evaluate how OTSL impacts the performance of TableFormer after training on other publicly available data sets (FinTabNet, PubTables-1M[smock2022pubtables]). The ground truth (GT) from all data sets has been converted into OTSL format for this purpose, and will be made publicly available.", - "text": "[ED_model_sketch]) with two objectives: Firstly we evaluate the prediction quality and performance of OTSL vs. HTML after performing Hyper Parameter Optimization (HPO) on the canonical PubTabNet data set. Secondly we pick the best hyper-parameters found in the first step and evaluate how OTSL impacts the performance of TableFormer after training on other publicly available data sets (FinTabNet, PubTables-1M[smock2022pubtables]). The ground truth (GT) from all data sets has been converted into OTSL format for this purpose, and will be made publicly available." + "orig": "To evaluate the impact of OTSL on prediction accuracy and inference times, we conducted a series of experiments based on the TableFormer model (Figure[ED_model_sketch]) with two objectives: Firstly we evaluate the prediction quality and performance of OTSL vs. HTML after performing Hyper Parameter Optimization (HPO) on the canonical PubTabNet data set. Secondly we pick the best hyper-parameters found in the first step and evaluate how OTSL impacts the performance of TableFormer after training on other publicly available data sets (FinTabNet, PubTables-1M[smock2022pubtables]). The ground truth (GT) from all data sets has been converted into OTSL format for this purpose, and will be made publicly available.", + "text": "To evaluate the impact of OTSL on prediction accuracy and inference times, we conducted a series of experiments based on the TableFormer model (Figure[ED_model_sketch]) with two objectives: Firstly we evaluate the prediction quality and performance of OTSL vs. HTML after performing Hyper Parameter Optimization (HPO) on the canonical PubTabNet data set. Secondly we pick the best hyper-parameters found in the first step and evaluate how OTSL impacts the performance of TableFormer after training on other publicly available data sets (FinTabNet, PubTables-1M[smock2022pubtables]). The ground truth (GT) from all data sets has been converted into OTSL format for this purpose, and will be made publicly available." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/68", + "self_ref": "#/texts/55", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/5" }, @@ -1303,7 +1093,7 @@ "text": "Architecture sketch of the TableFormer model, which is a representative for the Im2Seq approach." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/69", + "self_ref": "#/texts/56", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1315,7 +1105,7 @@ "text": "Image: ./figs/tablemodel_overview_otsl.pdf" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/70", + "self_ref": "#/texts/57", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1327,7 +1117,7 @@ "text": "We rely on standard metrics such as Tree Edit Distance score (TEDs) for table structure prediction, and Mean Average Precision (mAP) with 0.75 Intersection Over Union (IOU) threshold for the bounding-box predictions of table cells.\nThe predicted OTSL structures were converted back to HTML format in order to compute the TED score. Inference timing results for all experiments were obtained from the same machine on a single core with AMD EPYC 7763 CPU @2.45 GHz." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/71", + "self_ref": "#/texts/58", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1340,19 +1130,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/72", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "We have chosen the PubTabNet data set to perform HPO, since it includes a highly diverse set of tables. Also we report TED scores separately for simple and complex tables (tables with cell spans). Results are presented in Table.", - "text": "We have chosen the PubTabNet data set to perform HPO, since it includes a highly diverse set of tables. Also we report TED scores separately for simple and complex tables (tables with cell spans). Results are presented in Table." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/73", + "self_ref": "#/texts/59", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1360,11 +1138,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[tab:HPO]. It is evident that with OTSL, our model achieves the same TED score and slightly better mAP scores in comparison to HTML. However OTSL yields a 2x speed upin the inference runtime over HTML.", - "text": "[tab:HPO]. It is evident that with OTSL, our model achieves the same TED score and slightly better mAP scores in comparison to HTML. However OTSL yields a 2x speed upin the inference runtime over HTML." + "orig": "We have chosen the PubTabNet data set to perform HPO, since it includes a highly diverse set of tables. Also we report TED scores separately for simple and complex tables (tables with cell spans). Results are presented in Table.[tab:HPO]. It is evident that with OTSL, our model achieves the same TED score and slightly better mAP scores in comparison to HTML. However OTSL yields a 2x speed upin the inference runtime over HTML.", + "text": "We have chosen the PubTabNet data set to perform HPO, since it includes a highly diverse set of tables. Also we report TED scores separately for simple and complex tables (tables with cell spans). Results are presented in Table.[tab:HPO]. It is evident that with OTSL, our model achieves the same TED score and slightly better mAP scores in comparison to HTML. However OTSL yields a 2x speed upin the inference runtime over HTML." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/74", + "self_ref": "#/texts/60", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1376,7 +1154,7 @@ "text": "HPO performed in OTSL and HTML representation on the same transformer-based TableFormer [TableFormer] architecture, trained only on PubTabNet [PubTabNet]. Effects of reducing the # of layers in encoder and decoder stages of the model show that smaller models trained on OTSL perform better, especially in recognizing complex table structures, and maintain a much higher mAP score than the HTML counterpart." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/75", + "self_ref": "#/texts/61", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1389,19 +1167,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/76", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "We picked the model parameter configuration that produced the best prediction quality (enc=6, dec=6, heads=8) with PubTabNet alone, then independently trained and evaluated it on three publicly available data sets: PubTabNet (395k samples), FinTabNet (113k samples) and PubTables-1M (about 1M samples). Performance results are presented in Table.", - "text": "We picked the model parameter configuration that produced the best prediction quality (enc=6, dec=6, heads=8) with PubTabNet alone, then independently trained and evaluated it on three publicly available data sets: PubTabNet (395k samples), FinTabNet (113k samples) and PubTables-1M (about 1M samples). Performance results are presented in Table." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/77", + "self_ref": "#/texts/62", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1409,11 +1175,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[tab:HTMLvOTSL_precision]. It is clearly evident that the model trained on OTSL outperforms HTML across the board, keeping high TEDs and mAP scores even on difficult financial tables (FinTabNet) that contain sparse and large tables.", - "text": "[tab:HTMLvOTSL_precision]. It is clearly evident that the model trained on OTSL outperforms HTML across the board, keeping high TEDs and mAP scores even on difficult financial tables (FinTabNet) that contain sparse and large tables." + "orig": "We picked the model parameter configuration that produced the best prediction quality (enc=6, dec=6, heads=8) with PubTabNet alone, then independently trained and evaluated it on three publicly available data sets: PubTabNet (395k samples), FinTabNet (113k samples) and PubTables-1M (about 1M samples). Performance results are presented in Table.[tab:HTMLvOTSL_precision]. It is clearly evident that the model trained on OTSL outperforms HTML across the board, keeping high TEDs and mAP scores even on difficult financial tables (FinTabNet) that contain sparse and large tables.", + "text": "We picked the model parameter configuration that produced the best prediction quality (enc=6, dec=6, heads=8) with PubTabNet alone, then independently trained and evaluated it on three publicly available data sets: PubTabNet (395k samples), FinTabNet (113k samples) and PubTables-1M (about 1M samples). Performance results are presented in Table.[tab:HTMLvOTSL_precision]. It is clearly evident that the model trained on OTSL outperforms HTML across the board, keeping high TEDs and mAP scores even on difficult financial tables (FinTabNet) that contain sparse and large tables." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/78", + "self_ref": "#/texts/63", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1425,7 +1191,7 @@ "text": "TSR and cell detection results compared between OTSL and HTML on the PubTabNet[PubTabNet], FinTabNet[GTE] and PubTables-1M[smock2022pubtables] data sets using TableFormer[TableFormer] (with enc=6, dec=6, heads=8)." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/79", + "self_ref": "#/texts/64", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1437,7 +1203,7 @@ "text": "Additionally, the results show that OTSL has an advantage over HTML when applied on a bigger data set like PubTables-1M and achieves significantly improved scores. Finally, OTSL achieves faster inference due to fewer decoding steps which is a result of the reduced sequence representation." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/80", + "self_ref": "#/texts/65", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1450,19 +1216,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/81", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "To illustrate the qualitative differences between OTSL and HTML, Figure", - "text": "To illustrate the qualitative differences between OTSL and HTML, Figure" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/82", + "self_ref": "#/texts/66", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1470,11 +1224,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[OTSLvHTML_compare] demonstrates less overlap and more accurate bounding boxes with OTSL. In Figure[OTSLvHTML_ex3], OTSL proves to be more effective in handling tables with longer token sequences, resulting in even more precise structure prediction and bounding boxes.", - "text": "[OTSLvHTML_compare] demonstrates less overlap and more accurate bounding boxes with OTSL. In Figure[OTSLvHTML_ex3], OTSL proves to be more effective in handling tables with longer token sequences, resulting in even more precise structure prediction and bounding boxes." + "orig": "To illustrate the qualitative differences between OTSL and HTML, Figure[OTSLvHTML_compare] demonstrates less overlap and more accurate bounding boxes with OTSL. In Figure[OTSLvHTML_ex3], OTSL proves to be more effective in handling tables with longer token sequences, resulting in even more precise structure prediction and bounding boxes.", + "text": "To illustrate the qualitative differences between OTSL and HTML, Figure[OTSLvHTML_compare] demonstrates less overlap and more accurate bounding boxes with OTSL. In Figure[OTSLvHTML_ex3], OTSL proves to be more effective in handling tables with longer token sequences, resulting in even more precise structure prediction and bounding boxes." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/83", + "self_ref": "#/texts/67", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/6" }, @@ -1486,7 +1240,7 @@ "text": "The OTSL model produces more accurate bounding boxes with less overlap (E) than the HTML model (D), when predicting the structure of a sparse table (A), at twice the inference speed because of shorter sequence length (B),(C). \"PMC2807444_006_00.png\" PubTabNet." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/84", + "self_ref": "#/texts/68", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1498,7 +1252,7 @@ "text": "Image: ./figs/HTMLvOTSLv7.pdf" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/85", + "self_ref": "#/texts/69", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/7" }, @@ -1510,7 +1264,7 @@ "text": "Visualization of predicted structure and detected bounding boxes on a complex table with many rows. The OTSL model (B) captured repeating pattern of horizontally merged cells from the GT (A), unlike the HTML model (C). The HTML model also didn't complete the HTML sequence correctly and displayed a lot more of drift and overlap of bounding boxes. \"PMC5406406_003_01.png\" PubTabNet." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/86", + "self_ref": "#/texts/70", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1522,7 +1276,7 @@ "text": "Image: ./figs/otsl_vs_html_ex3_v2.pdf" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/87", + "self_ref": "#/texts/71", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1535,7 +1289,7 @@ "level": 1 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/88", + "self_ref": "#/texts/72", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1547,19 +1301,7 @@ "text": "We demonstrated that representing tables in HTML for the task of table structure recognition with Im2Seq models is ill-suited and has serious limitations. Furthermore, we presented in this paper an Optimized Table Structure Language (OTSL) which, when compared to commonly used general purpose languages, has several key benefits." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/89", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "First and foremost, given the same network configuration, inference time for a table-structure prediction is about 2 times faster compared to the conventional HTML approach. This is primarily owed to the shorter sequence length of the OTSL representation. Additional performance benefits can be obtained with HPO (hyper parameter optimization). As we demonstrate in our experiments, models trained on OTSL can be significantly smaller, e.g. by reducing the number of encoder and decoder layers, while preserving comparatively good prediction quality. This can further improve inference performance, yielding 5-6 times faster inference speed in OTSL with prediction quality comparable to models trained on HTML (see Table", - "text": "First and foremost, given the same network configuration, inference time for a table-structure prediction is about 2 times faster compared to the conventional HTML approach. This is primarily owed to the shorter sequence length of the OTSL representation. Additional performance benefits can be obtained with HPO (hyper parameter optimization). As we demonstrate in our experiments, models trained on OTSL can be significantly smaller, e.g. by reducing the number of encoder and decoder layers, while preserving comparatively good prediction quality. This can further improve inference performance, yielding 5-6 times faster inference speed in OTSL with prediction quality comparable to models trained on HTML (see Table" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/90", + "self_ref": "#/texts/73", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1567,23 +1309,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[tab:HPO]).", - "text": "[tab:HPO])." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/91", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Secondly, OTSL has more inherent structure and a significantly restricted vocabulary size. This allows autoregressive models to perform better in the TED metric, but especially with regards to prediction accuracy of the table-cell bounding boxes (see Table", - "text": "Secondly, OTSL has more inherent structure and a significantly restricted vocabulary size. This allows autoregressive models to perform better in the TED metric, but especially with regards to prediction accuracy of the table-cell bounding boxes (see Table" + "orig": "First and foremost, given the same network configuration, inference time for a table-structure prediction is about 2 times faster compared to the conventional HTML approach. This is primarily owed to the shorter sequence length of the OTSL representation. Additional performance benefits can be obtained with HPO (hyper parameter optimization). As we demonstrate in our experiments, models trained on OTSL can be significantly smaller, e.g. by reducing the number of encoder and decoder layers, while preserving comparatively good prediction quality. This can further improve inference performance, yielding 5-6 times faster inference speed in OTSL with prediction quality comparable to models trained on HTML (see Table[tab:HPO]).", + "text": "First and foremost, given the same network configuration, inference time for a table-structure prediction is about 2 times faster compared to the conventional HTML approach. This is primarily owed to the shorter sequence length of the OTSL representation. Additional performance benefits can be obtained with HPO (hyper parameter optimization). As we demonstrate in our experiments, models trained on OTSL can be significantly smaller, e.g. by reducing the number of encoder and decoder layers, while preserving comparatively good prediction quality. This can further improve inference performance, yielding 5-6 times faster inference speed in OTSL with prediction quality comparable to models trained on HTML (see Table[tab:HPO])." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/92", + "self_ref": "#/texts/74", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1591,11 +1321,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[tab:HTMLvOTSL_precision]). As shown in Figure[OTSLvHTML_compare], we observe that the OTSL drastically reduces the drift for table cell bounding boxes at high row count and in sparse tables. This leads to more accurate predictions and a significant reduction in post-processing complexity, which is an undesired necessity in HTML-based Im2Seq models.\nSignificant novelty lies in OTSL syntactical rules, which are few, simple and always backwards looking. Each new token can be validated only by analyzing the sequence of previous tokens, without requiring the entire sequence to detect mistakes. This in return allows to perform structural error detection and correction on-the-fly during sequence generation.", - "text": "[tab:HTMLvOTSL_precision]). As shown in Figure[OTSLvHTML_compare], we observe that the OTSL drastically reduces the drift for table cell bounding boxes at high row count and in sparse tables. This leads to more accurate predictions and a significant reduction in post-processing complexity, which is an undesired necessity in HTML-based Im2Seq models.\nSignificant novelty lies in OTSL syntactical rules, which are few, simple and always backwards looking. Each new token can be validated only by analyzing the sequence of previous tokens, without requiring the entire sequence to detect mistakes. This in return allows to perform structural error detection and correction on-the-fly during sequence generation." + "orig": "Secondly, OTSL has more inherent structure and a significantly restricted vocabulary size. This allows autoregressive models to perform better in the TED metric, but especially with regards to prediction accuracy of the table-cell bounding boxes (see Table[tab:HTMLvOTSL_precision]). As shown in Figure[OTSLvHTML_compare], we observe that the OTSL drastically reduces the drift for table cell bounding boxes at high row count and in sparse tables. This leads to more accurate predictions and a significant reduction in post-processing complexity, which is an undesired necessity in HTML-based Im2Seq models.\nSignificant novelty lies in OTSL syntactical rules, which are few, simple and always backwards looking. Each new token can be validated only by analyzing the sequence of previous tokens, without requiring the entire sequence to detect mistakes. This in return allows to perform structural error detection and correction on-the-fly during sequence generation.", + "text": "Secondly, OTSL has more inherent structure and a significantly restricted vocabulary size. This allows autoregressive models to perform better in the TED metric, but especially with regards to prediction accuracy of the table-cell bounding boxes (see Table[tab:HTMLvOTSL_precision]). As shown in Figure[OTSLvHTML_compare], we observe that the OTSL drastically reduces the drift for table cell bounding boxes at high row count and in sparse tables. This leads to more accurate predictions and a significant reduction in post-processing complexity, which is an undesired necessity in HTML-based Im2Seq models.\nSignificant novelty lies in OTSL syntactical rules, which are few, simple and always backwards looking. Each new token can be validated only by analyzing the sequence of previous tokens, without requiring the entire sequence to detect mistakes. This in return allows to perform structural error detection and correction on-the-fly during sequence generation." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/93", + "self_ref": "#/texts/75", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1607,7 +1337,7 @@ "text": "splncs04" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/94", + "self_ref": "#/texts/76", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1643,7 +1373,7 @@ "width": 824.0, "height": 570.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -1658,7 +1388,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/31" + "$ref": "#/texts/22" } ], "references": [], @@ -1670,7 +1400,7 @@ "width": 4898.0, "height": 1564.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -1685,7 +1415,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/43" + "$ref": "#/texts/32" } ], "references": [], @@ -1697,7 +1427,7 @@ "width": 685.0, "height": 277.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -1712,7 +1442,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/69" + "$ref": "#/texts/56" } ], "references": [], @@ -1724,7 +1454,7 @@ "width": 5388.0, "height": 1418.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -1739,7 +1469,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/84" + "$ref": "#/texts/68" } ], "references": [], @@ -1751,7 +1481,7 @@ "width": 735.0, "height": 558.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -1766,7 +1496,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/86" + "$ref": "#/texts/70" } ], "references": [], @@ -1778,7 +1508,7 @@ "width": 1318.0, "height": 2135.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] } diff --git a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2305.03393_main.tex.md b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2305.03393_main.tex.md index de5e3ceb90..4e767b35c9 100644 --- a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2305.03393_main.tex.md +++ b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2305.03393_main.tex.md @@ -23,48 +23,30 @@ Image: ./figs/html\_v\_otsl\_intro\_v2.pdf -In modern document understanding systems +In modern document understanding systems[IEECloud22,KDD18], table extraction is typically a two-step process. Firstly, every table on a page is located with a bounding box, and secondly, their logical row and column structure is recognized. As of today, table detection in documents is a well understood problem, and the latest state-of-the-art (SOTA) object detection methods provide an accuracy comparable to human observers[li2019tablebank,pagemodelrnn,DocLayNet,smock2022pubtables,PubLayNet]. On the other hand, the problem of table structure recognition (TSR) is a lot more challenging and remains a very active area of research, in which many novel machine learning algorithms are being explored[chi2019complicated,deng2019challenges,kayal2022tables,TableFormer,prasad2020cascadetabnet,schreiber2017deepdesrt,8978137,smock2022pubtables,xue2019res2tim,xue2021tgrnet,GTE,PubTabNet]. -[IEECloud22,KDD18], table extraction is typically a two-step process. Firstly, every table on a page is located with a bounding box, and secondly, their logical row and column structure is recognized. As of today, table detection in documents is a well understood problem, and the latest state-of-the-art (SOTA) object detection methods provide an accuracy comparable to human observers[li2019tablebank,pagemodelrnn,DocLayNet,smock2022pubtables,PubLayNet]. On the other hand, the problem of table structure recognition (TSR) is a lot more challenging and remains a very active area of research, in which many novel machine learning algorithms are being explored[chi2019complicated,deng2019challenges,kayal2022tables,TableFormer,prasad2020cascadetabnet,schreiber2017deepdesrt,8978137,smock2022pubtables,xue2019res2tim,xue2021tgrnet,GTE,PubTabNet]. +Recently emerging SOTA methods for table structure recognition employ transformer-based models, in which an image of the table is provided to the network in order to predict the structure of the table as a sequence of tokens. These image-to-sequence (Im2Seq) models are extremely powerful, since they allow for a purely data-driven solution. The tokens of the sequence typically belong to a markup language such as HTML, Latex or Markdown, which allow to describe table structure as rows, columns and spanning cells in various configurations. In Figure[OTSLvHTML\_show], we illustrate how HTML is used to represent the table-structure of a particular example table. Public table-structure data sets such as PubTabNet[PubTabNet], and FinTabNet[GTE], which were created in a semi-automated way from paired PDF and HTML sources (e.g. PubMed Central), popularized primarily the use of HTML as ground-truth representation format for TSR. -Recently emerging SOTA methods for table structure recognition employ transformer-based models, in which an image of the table is provided to the network in order to predict the structure of the table as a sequence of tokens. These image-to-sequence (Im2Seq) models are extremely powerful, since they allow for a purely data-driven solution. The tokens of the sequence typically belong to a markup language such as HTML, Latex or Markdown, which allow to describe table structure as rows, columns and spanning cells in various configurations. In Figure +While the majority of research in TSR is currently focused on the development and application of novel neural model architectures, the table structure representation language (e.g. HTML in PubTabNet and FinTabNet) is usually adopted as is for the sequence tokenization in Im2Seq models. In this paper, we aim for the opposite and investigate the impact of the table structure representation language with an otherwise unmodified Im2Seq transformer-based architecture. Since the current state-of-the-art Im2Seq model is TableFormer[TableFormer], we select this model to perform our experiments. -[OTSLvHTML\_show], we illustrate how HTML is used to represent the table-structure of a particular example table. Public table-structure data sets such as PubTabNet[PubTabNet], and FinTabNet[GTE], which were created in a semi-automated way from paired PDF and HTML sources (e.g. PubMed Central), popularized primarily the use of HTML as ground-truth representation format for TSR. +The main contribution of this paper is the introduction of a new optimised table structure language (OTSL), specifically designed to describe table-structure in an compact and structured way for Im2Seq models. OTSL has a number of key features, which make it very attractive to use in Im2Seq models. Specifically, compared to other languages such as HTML, OTSL has a minimized vocabulary which yields short sequence length, strong inherent structure (e.g. strict rectangular layout) and a strict syntax with rules that only look backwards. The latter allows for syntax validation during inference and ensures a syntactically correct table-structure. These OTSL features are illustrated in Figure[OTSLvHTML\_show], in comparison to HTML. -While the majority of research in TSR is currently focused on the development and application of novel neural model architectures, the table structure representation language (e.g. HTML in PubTabNet and FinTabNet) is usually adopted - -as is for the sequence tokenization in Im2Seq models. In this paper, we aim for the opposite and investigate the impact of the table structure representation language with an otherwise unmodified Im2Seq transformer-based architecture. Since the current state-of-the-art Im2Seq model is TableFormer[TableFormer], we select this model to perform our experiments. - -The main contribution of this paper is the introduction of a new optimised table structure language (OTSL), specifically designed to describe table-structure in an compact and structured way for Im2Seq models. OTSL has a number of key features, which make it very attractive to use in Im2Seq models. Specifically, compared to other languages such as HTML, OTSL has a minimized vocabulary which yields short sequence length, strong inherent structure (e.g. strict rectangular layout) and a strict syntax with rules that only look backwards. The latter allows for syntax validation during inference and ensures a syntactically correct table-structure. These OTSL features are illustrated in Figure - -[OTSLvHTML\_show], in comparison to HTML. - -The paper is structured as follows. In section - -[RW], we give an overview of the latest developments in table-structure reconstruction. In section[PS] we review the current HTML table encoding (popularised by PubTabNet and FinTabNet) and discuss its flaws. Subsequently, we introduce OTSL in section[OTSL], which includes the language definition, syntax rules and error-correction procedures. In section[Results], we apply OTSL on the TableFormer architecture, compare it to TableFormer models trained on HTML and ultimately demonstrate the advantages of using OTSL. Finally, in section[Con]we conclude our work and outline next potential steps. +The paper is structured as follows. In section[RW], we give an overview of the latest developments in table-structure reconstruction. In section[PS] we review the current HTML table encoding (popularised by PubTabNet and FinTabNet) and discuss its flaws. Subsequently, we introduce OTSL in section[OTSL], which includes the language definition, syntax rules and error-correction procedures. In section[Results], we apply OTSL on the TableFormer architecture, compare it to TableFormer models trained on HTML and ultimately demonstrate the advantages of using OTSL. Finally, in section[Con]we conclude our work and outline next potential steps. ## RWRelated Work -Approaches to formalize the logical structure and layout of tables in electronic documents date back more than two decades - -[10.5555/923400]. In the recent past, a wide variety of computer vision methods have been explored to tackle the problem of table structure recognition, i.e. the correct identification of columns, rows and spanning cells in a given table. Broadly speaking, the current deep-learning based approaches fall into three categories: object detection (OD) methods, Graph-Neural-Network (GNN) methods and Image-to-Markup-Sequence (Im2Seq) methods. Object-detection based methods [prasad2020cascadetabnet,schreiber2017deepdesrt,8978137,smock2022pubtables,GTE] rely on table-structure annotation using (overlapping) bounding boxes for training, and produce bounding-box predictions to define table cells, rows, and columns on a table image. +Approaches to formalize the logical structure and layout of tables in electronic documents date back more than two decades [10.5555/923400]. In the recent past, a wide variety of computer vision methods have been explored to tackle the problem of table structure recognition, i.e. the correct identification of columns, rows and spanning cells in a given table. Broadly speaking, the current deep-learning based approaches fall into three categories: object detection (OD) methods, Graph-Neural-Network (GNN) methods and Image-to-Markup-Sequence (Im2Seq) methods. Object-detection based methods [prasad2020cascadetabnet,schreiber2017deepdesrt,8978137,smock2022pubtables,GTE] rely on table-structure annotation using (overlapping) bounding boxes for training, and produce bounding-box predictions to define table cells, rows, and columns on a table image. Graph Neural Network (GNN) based methods [chi2019complicated,lee2022table,xue2019res2tim,xue2021tgrnet], as the name suggests, represent tables as graph structures. The graph nodes represent the content of each table cell, an embedding vector from the table image, or geometric coordinates of the table cell. The edges of the graph define the relationship between the nodes, e.g. if they belong to the same column, row, or table cell. Other work [zhang2022split] aims at predicting a grid for each table and deciding which cells must be merged using an attention network. Im2Seq methods cast the problem as a sequence generation task [deng2019challenges,kayal2022tables,TableFormer,PubTabNet], and therefore need an internal table-structure representation language, which is often implemented with standard markup languages (e.g. HTML, LaTeX, Markdown). In theory, Im2Seq methods have a natural advantage over the OD and GNN methods by virtue of directly predicting the table-structure. As such, no post-processing or rules are needed in order to obtain the table-structure, which is necessary with OD and GNN approaches. In practice, this is not entirely true, because a predicted sequence of table-structure markup does not necessarily have to be syntactically correct. Hence, depending on the quality of the predicted sequence, some post-processing needs to be performed to ensure a syntactically valid (let alone correct) sequence. -Within the Im2Seq method, we find several popular models, namely the encoder-dual-decoder model (EDD) - -[PubTabNet], TableFormer[TableFormer], Tabsplitter[identity\_matrix] and Ye et. al.[TableMaster]. EDD uses two consecutive long short-term memory (LSTM) decoders to predict a table in HTML representation. The tag decoder predicts a sequence of HTML tags. For each decoded table cell (<td>), the attention is passed to the cell decoder to predict the content with an embedded OCR approach. The latter makes it susceptible to transcription errors in the cell content of the table. TableFormer address this reliance on OCR and uses two transformer decoders for HTML structure and cell bounding box prediction in an end-to-end architecture. The predicted cell bounding box is then used to extract text tokens from an originating (digital) PDF page, circumventing any need for OCR. TabSplitter [identity\_matrix] proposes a compact double-matrix representation of table rows and columns to do error detection and error correction of HTML structure sequences based on predictions from [TableMaster]. This compact double-matrix representation can not be used directly by the Img2seq model training, so the model uses HTML as an intermediate form. Chi et. al.[deng2019challenges] introduce a data set and a baseline method using bidirectional LSTMs to predict LaTeX code. Kayal [kayal2022tables]introduces Gated ResNet transformers to predict LaTeX code, and a separate OCR module to extract content. +Within the Im2Seq method, we find several popular models, namely the encoder-dual-decoder model (EDD)[PubTabNet], TableFormer[TableFormer], Tabsplitter[identity\_matrix] and Ye et. al.[TableMaster]. EDD uses two consecutive long short-term memory (LSTM) decoders to predict a table in HTML representation. The tag decoder predicts a sequence of HTML tags. For each decoded table cell (<td>), the attention is passed to the cell decoder to predict the content with an embedded OCR approach. The latter makes it susceptible to transcription errors in the cell content of the table. TableFormer address this reliance on OCR and uses two transformer decoders for HTML structure and cell bounding box prediction in an end-to-end architecture. The predicted cell bounding box is then used to extract text tokens from an originating (digital) PDF page, circumventing any need for OCR. TabSplitter [identity\_matrix] proposes a compact double-matrix representation of table rows and columns to do error detection and error correction of HTML structure sequences based on predictions from [TableMaster]. This compact double-matrix representation can not be used directly by the Img2seq model training, so the model uses HTML as an intermediate form. Chi et. al.[deng2019challenges] introduce a data set and a baseline method using bidirectional LSTMs to predict LaTeX code. Kayal [kayal2022tables]introduces Gated ResNet transformers to predict LaTeX code, and a separate OCR module to extract content. -Im2Seq approaches have shown to be well-suited for the TSR task and allow a full end-to-end network design that can output the final table structure without pre- or post-processing logic. Furthermore, Im2Seq models have demonstrated to deliver state-of-the-art prediction accuracy - -[TableFormer]. This motivated the authors to investigate if the performance (both in accuracy and inference time) can be further improved by optimising the table structure representation language. We believe this is a necessary step before further improving neural network architectures for this task. +Im2Seq approaches have shown to be well-suited for the TSR task and allow a full end-to-end network design that can output the final table structure without pre- or post-processing logic. Furthermore, Im2Seq models have demonstrated to deliver state-of-the-art prediction accuracy[TableFormer]. This motivated the authors to investigate if the performance (both in accuracy and inference time) can be further improved by optimising the table structure representation language. We believe this is a necessary step before further improving neural network architectures for this task. ## PSProblem Statement -All known Im2Seq based models for TSR fundamentally work in similar ways. Given an image of a table, the Im2Seq model predicts the structure of the table by generating a sequence of tokens. These tokens originate from a finite vocabulary and can be interpreted as a table structure. For example, with the HTML tokens - -<table>, </table>, <tr>, </tr>, <td> and </td>, one can construct simple table structures without any spanning cells. In reality though, one needs at least 28 HTML tokens to describe the most common complex tables observed in real-world documents[GTE,PubTabNet], due to a variety of spanning cells definitions in the HTML token vocabulary. +All known Im2Seq based models for TSR fundamentally work in similar ways. Given an image of a table, the Im2Seq model predicts the structure of the table by generating a sequence of tokens. These tokens originate from a finite vocabulary and can be interpreted as a table structure. For example, with the HTML tokens <table>, </table>, <tr>, </tr>, <td> and </td>, one can construct simple table structures without any spanning cells. In reality though, one needs at least 28 HTML tokens to describe the most common complex tables observed in real-world documents[GTE,PubTabNet], due to a variety of spanning cells definitions in the HTML token vocabulary. Frequency of tokens in HTML and OTSL as they appear in PubTabNet. @@ -73,9 +55,7 @@ Image: ./figs/html\_freq\_v4.png Obviously, HTML and other general-purpose markup languages were not designed for Im2Seq models. As such, they have some serious drawbacks. First, the token vocabulary needs to be artificially large in order to describe all plausible tabular structures. Since most Im2Seq models use an autoregressive approach, they generate the sequence token by token. Therefore, to reduce inference time, a shorter sequence length is critical. -Every table-cell is represented by at least two tokens ( - -<td> and </td>). Furthermore, when tokenizing the HTML structure, one needs to explicitly enumerate possible column-spans and row-spans as words. In practice, this ends up requiring 28 different HTML tokens (when including column- and row-spans up to 10 cells) just to describe every table in the PubTabNet dataset. Clearly, not every token is equally represented, as is depicted in Figure[HTML\_TRL]. This skewed distribution of tokens in combination with variable token row-length makes it challenging for models to learn the HTML structure. +Every table-cell is represented by at least two tokens (<td> and </td>). Furthermore, when tokenizing the HTML structure, one needs to explicitly enumerate possible column-spans and row-spans as words. In practice, this ends up requiring 28 different HTML tokens (when including column- and row-spans up to 10 cells) just to describe every table in the PubTabNet dataset. Clearly, not every token is equally represented, as is depicted in Figure[HTML\_TRL]. This skewed distribution of tokens in combination with variable token row-length makes it challenging for models to learn the HTML structure. Additionally, it would be desirable if the representation would easily allow an early detection of invalid sequences on-the-go, before the prediction of the entire table structure is completed. HTML is not well-suited for this purpose as the verification of incomplete sequences is non-trivial or even impossible. @@ -83,9 +63,7 @@ In a valid HTML table, the token sequence must describe a 2D grid of table cells Since the number of tokens for each table row and column can vary significantly, especially for large tables with many row- and column-spans, it is complex to verify the consistency of predicted structures during sequence generation. Implicitly, this also means that Im2Seq models need to learn these complex syntax rules, simply to deliver valid output. In practice, we observe two major issues with prediction quality when training Im2Seq models on HTML table structure generation from images. -On the one hand, we find that on large tables, the visual attention of the model often starts to drift and is not accurately moving forward cell by cell anymore. This manifests itself in either in an increasing - -location drift for proposed table-cells in later rows on the same column or even complete loss of vertical alignment, as illustrated in Figure[OTSLvHTML\_compare]. Addressing this with post-processing is partially possible, but clearly undesired. On the other hand, we find many instances of predictions with structural inconsistencies or plain invalid HTML output, as shown in Figure[OTSLvHTML\_ex3], which are nearly impossible to properly correct. +On the one hand, we find that on large tables, the visual attention of the model often starts to drift and is not accurately moving forward cell by cell anymore. This manifests itself in either in an increasing location drift for proposed table-cells in later rows on the same column or even complete loss of vertical alignment, as illustrated in Figure[OTSLvHTML\_compare]. Addressing this with post-processing is partially possible, but clearly undesired. On the other hand, we find many instances of predictions with structural inconsistencies or plain invalid HTML output, as shown in Figure[OTSLvHTML\_ex3], which are nearly impossible to properly correct. Both problems seriously impact the TSR model performance, since they reflect not only in the task of pure structure recognition but also in the equally crucial recognition or matching of table cell content. ## OTSLOptimised Table Structure Language @@ -134,9 +112,7 @@ First of all, the OTSL enforces a strictly rectangular structure representation, Secondly, the OTSL representation is unambiguous: Every table structure is represented in one way. In this representation every table cell corresponds to a "C"-cell token, which in case of spans is always located in the top-left corner of the table cell definition. Third, OTSL syntax rules are only backward-looking. As a consequence, every predicted token can be validated straight during sequence generation by looking at the previously predicted sequence. As such, OTSL can guarantee that every predicted sequence is syntactically valid. -These characteristics can be easily learned by sequence generator networks, as we demonstrate further below. We find strong indications that this pattern reduces significantly the column drift seen in the HTML based models (see Figure - -[OTSLvHTML\_compare]). +These characteristics can be easily learned by sequence generator networks, as we demonstrate further below. We find strong indications that this pattern reduces significantly the column drift seen in the HTML based models (see Figure[OTSLvHTML\_compare]). ### Error-detection and -mitigation @@ -145,9 +121,7 @@ For example a simple heuristic which can correct the predicted OTSL sequence on- ## ResultsExperiments -To evaluate the impact of OTSL on prediction accuracy and inference times, we conducted a series of experiments based on the TableFormer model (Figure - -[ED\_model\_sketch]) with two objectives: Firstly we evaluate the prediction quality and performance of OTSL vs. HTML after performing Hyper Parameter Optimization (HPO) on the canonical PubTabNet data set. Secondly we pick the best hyper-parameters found in the first step and evaluate how OTSL impacts the performance of TableFormer after training on other publicly available data sets (FinTabNet, PubTables-1M[smock2022pubtables]). The ground truth (GT) from all data sets has been converted into OTSL format for this purpose, and will be made publicly available. +To evaluate the impact of OTSL on prediction accuracy and inference times, we conducted a series of experiments based on the TableFormer model (Figure[ED\_model\_sketch]) with two objectives: Firstly we evaluate the prediction quality and performance of OTSL vs. HTML after performing Hyper Parameter Optimization (HPO) on the canonical PubTabNet data set. Secondly we pick the best hyper-parameters found in the first step and evaluate how OTSL impacts the performance of TableFormer after training on other publicly available data sets (FinTabNet, PubTables-1M[smock2022pubtables]). The ground truth (GT) from all data sets has been converted into OTSL format for this purpose, and will be made publicly available. Architecture sketch of the TableFormer model, which is a representative for the Im2Seq approach. @@ -160,9 +134,7 @@ The predicted OTSL structures were converted back to HTML format in order to com ### Hyper Parameter Optimization -We have chosen the PubTabNet data set to perform HPO, since it includes a highly diverse set of tables. Also we report TED scores separately for simple and complex tables (tables with cell spans). Results are presented in Table. - -[tab:HPO]. It is evident that with OTSL, our model achieves the same TED score and slightly better mAP scores in comparison to HTML. However OTSL yields a 2x speed upin the inference runtime over HTML. +We have chosen the PubTabNet data set to perform HPO, since it includes a highly diverse set of tables. Also we report TED scores separately for simple and complex tables (tables with cell spans). Results are presented in Table.[tab:HPO]. It is evident that with OTSL, our model achieves the same TED score and slightly better mAP scores in comparison to HTML. However OTSL yields a 2x speed upin the inference runtime over HTML. HPO performed in OTSL and HTML representation on the same transformer-based TableFormer [TableFormer] architecture, trained only on PubTabNet [PubTabNet]. Effects of reducing the # of layers in encoder and decoder stages of the model show that smaller models trained on OTSL perform better, especially in recognizing complex table structures, and maintain a much higher mAP score than the HTML counterpart. @@ -181,9 +153,7 @@ HPO performed in OTSL and HTML representation on the same transformer-based Tabl ### Quantitative Results -We picked the model parameter configuration that produced the best prediction quality (enc=6, dec=6, heads=8) with PubTabNet alone, then independently trained and evaluated it on three publicly available data sets: PubTabNet (395k samples), FinTabNet (113k samples) and PubTables-1M (about 1M samples). Performance results are presented in Table. - -[tab:HTMLvOTSL\_precision]. It is clearly evident that the model trained on OTSL outperforms HTML across the board, keeping high TEDs and mAP scores even on difficult financial tables (FinTabNet) that contain sparse and large tables. +We picked the model parameter configuration that produced the best prediction quality (enc=6, dec=6, heads=8) with PubTabNet alone, then independently trained and evaluated it on three publicly available data sets: PubTabNet (395k samples), FinTabNet (113k samples) and PubTables-1M (about 1M samples). Performance results are presented in Table.[tab:HTMLvOTSL\_precision]. It is clearly evident that the model trained on OTSL outperforms HTML across the board, keeping high TEDs and mAP scores even on difficult financial tables (FinTabNet) that contain sparse and large tables. TSR and cell detection results compared between OTSL and HTML on the PubTabNet[PubTabNet], FinTabNet[GTE] and PubTables-1M[smock2022pubtables] data sets using TableFormer[TableFormer] (with enc=6, dec=6, heads=8). @@ -202,9 +172,7 @@ Additionally, the results show that OTSL has an advantage over HTML when applied ### Qualitative Results -To illustrate the qualitative differences between OTSL and HTML, Figure - -[OTSLvHTML\_compare] demonstrates less overlap and more accurate bounding boxes with OTSL. In Figure[OTSLvHTML\_ex3], OTSL proves to be more effective in handling tables with longer token sequences, resulting in even more precise structure prediction and bounding boxes. +To illustrate the qualitative differences between OTSL and HTML, Figure[OTSLvHTML\_compare] demonstrates less overlap and more accurate bounding boxes with OTSL. In Figure[OTSLvHTML\_ex3], OTSL proves to be more effective in handling tables with longer token sequences, resulting in even more precise structure prediction and bounding boxes. The OTSL model produces more accurate bounding boxes with less overlap (E) than the HTML model (D), when predicting the structure of a sparse table (A), at twice the inference speed because of shorter sequence length (B),(C). "PMC2807444\_006\_00.png" PubTabNet. @@ -222,13 +190,9 @@ Image: ./figs/otsl\_vs\_html\_ex3\_v2.pdf We demonstrated that representing tables in HTML for the task of table structure recognition with Im2Seq models is ill-suited and has serious limitations. Furthermore, we presented in this paper an Optimized Table Structure Language (OTSL) which, when compared to commonly used general purpose languages, has several key benefits. -First and foremost, given the same network configuration, inference time for a table-structure prediction is about 2 times faster compared to the conventional HTML approach. This is primarily owed to the shorter sequence length of the OTSL representation. Additional performance benefits can be obtained with HPO (hyper parameter optimization). As we demonstrate in our experiments, models trained on OTSL can be significantly smaller, e.g. by reducing the number of encoder and decoder layers, while preserving comparatively good prediction quality. This can further improve inference performance, yielding 5-6 times faster inference speed in OTSL with prediction quality comparable to models trained on HTML (see Table - -[tab:HPO]). - -Secondly, OTSL has more inherent structure and a significantly restricted vocabulary size. This allows autoregressive models to perform better in the TED metric, but especially with regards to prediction accuracy of the table-cell bounding boxes (see Table +First and foremost, given the same network configuration, inference time for a table-structure prediction is about 2 times faster compared to the conventional HTML approach. This is primarily owed to the shorter sequence length of the OTSL representation. Additional performance benefits can be obtained with HPO (hyper parameter optimization). As we demonstrate in our experiments, models trained on OTSL can be significantly smaller, e.g. by reducing the number of encoder and decoder layers, while preserving comparatively good prediction quality. This can further improve inference performance, yielding 5-6 times faster inference speed in OTSL with prediction quality comparable to models trained on HTML (see Table[tab:HPO]). -[tab:HTMLvOTSL\_precision]). As shown in Figure[OTSLvHTML\_compare], we observe that the OTSL drastically reduces the drift for table cell bounding boxes at high row count and in sparse tables. This leads to more accurate predictions and a significant reduction in post-processing complexity, which is an undesired necessity in HTML-based Im2Seq models. +Secondly, OTSL has more inherent structure and a significantly restricted vocabulary size. This allows autoregressive models to perform better in the TED metric, but especially with regards to prediction accuracy of the table-cell bounding boxes (see Table[tab:HTMLvOTSL\_precision]). As shown in Figure[OTSLvHTML\_compare], we observe that the OTSL drastically reduces the drift for table cell bounding boxes at high row count and in sparse tables. This leads to more accurate predictions and a significant reduction in post-processing complexity, which is an undesired necessity in HTML-based Im2Seq models. Significant novelty lies in OTSL syntactical rules, which are few, simple and always backwards looking. Each new token can be validated only by analyzing the sequence of previous tokens, without requiring the entire sequence to detect mistakes. This in return allows to perform structural error detection and correction on-the-fly during sequence generation. splncs04 diff --git a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2310.06825_main.tex.itxt b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2310.06825_main.tex.itxt index 97e188861a..f29ce2fabb 100644 --- a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2310.06825_main.tex.itxt +++ b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2310.06825_main.tex.itxt @@ -45,68 +45,62 @@ Integration with Hugging Face During pr ... de of the sliding window (left block). item-37 at level 1: caption: Image: images/chunking.pdf item-38 at level 1: section_header: Results - item-39 at level 1: paragraph: We compare - item-40 at level 1: text: to , and re-run all benchmarks w ... ariety of tasks categorized as follow: - item-41 at level 1: list: group list - item-42 at level 2: list_item: Commonsense Reasoning (0-shot): ... CommonsenseQA[talmor2018commonsenseqa] - item-43 at level 2: list_item: World Knowledge (5-shot): Natura ... 9natural], TriviaQA[joshi2017triviaqa] - item-44 at level 2: list_item: Reading Comprehension (0-shot): BoolQ[clark2019boolq], QuAC[choi2018quac] - item-45 at level 2: list_item: Math: GSM8K[cobbe2021training] ( ... ycks2021measuring] (4-shot) with maj@4 - item-46 at level 2: list_item: Code: Humaneval[chen2021evaluati ... ) and MBPP[austin2021program] (3-shot) - item-47 at level 2: list_item: Popular aggregated results: MMLU ... nglish multiple-choice questions only) - item-48 at level 1: paragraph: Detailed results for - item-49 at level 1: text: , 2 7B/13B, and Code-7B are repo ... erformance of with 2 7B/13B, and 1 34B - item-50 at level 1: footnote: Since 2 34B was not open-sourced, we report results for 1 34B. - item-51 at level 1: text: in different categories. + item-39 at level 1: text: We compare to , and re-run all b ... ariety of tasks categorized as follow: + item-40 at level 1: list: group list + item-41 at level 2: list_item: Commonsense Reasoning (0-shot): ... CommonsenseQA[talmor2018commonsenseqa] + item-42 at level 2: list_item: World Knowledge (5-shot): Natura ... 9natural], TriviaQA[joshi2017triviaqa] + item-43 at level 2: list_item: Reading Comprehension (0-shot): BoolQ[clark2019boolq], QuAC[choi2018quac] + item-44 at level 2: list_item: Math: GSM8K[cobbe2021training] ( ... ycks2021measuring] (4-shot) with maj@4 + item-45 at level 2: list_item: Code: Humaneval[chen2021evaluati ... ) and MBPP[austin2021program] (3-shot) + item-46 at level 2: list_item: Popular aggregated results: MMLU ... nglish multiple-choice questions only) + item-47 at level 1: text: Detailed results for , 2 7B/13B, ... erformance of with 2 7B/13B, and 1 34B + item-48 at level 1: footnote: Since 2 34B was not open-sourced, we report results for 1 34B. + item-49 at level 1: text: in different categories. surpass ... mathematics, and reasoning benchmarks. - item-52 at level 1: text: Size and Efficiency. We computed ... the amount of knowledge it can store. - item-53 at level 1: text: Evaluation Differences. On some ... we do not provide Wikipedia contexts. - item-54 at level 1: section: group figure - item-55 at level 2: picture - item-55 at level 3: caption: Image: images/230927_bars.png - item-56 at level 2: text: Performance of and different mod ... generation, and reasoning benchmarks. - item-57 at level 1: caption: Image: images/230927_bars.png - item-58 at level 1: table with [6x14] - item-59 at level 1: text: Comparison of with . outperforms ... ng performance on non-code benchmarks. - item-60 at level 1: section: group figure - item-61 at level 2: picture - item-61 at level 3: caption: Image: images/230927_effective_sizes.png - item-62 at level 2: text: Results on MMLU, commonsense rea ... amount of knowledge it can compress). - item-63 at level 1: caption: Image: images/230927_effective_sizes.png - item-64 at level 1: text: r0.48 - item-65 at level 1: table with [9x3] - item-66 at level 1: text: tableComparison of Chat models. ... and is comparable to 13B Chat models. - item-67 at level 1: section_header: Instruction Finetuning - item-68 at level 1: text: =-1 To evaluate the generalizati ... on https://llmboxing.com/leaderboard. - item-69 at level 1: paragraph: In this evaluation, participants ... red response, as illustrated in Figure - item-70 at level 1: text: [fig:humanevalquestion]. -As of O ... ompared to 4143 times for Llama 2 13B. - item-71 at level 1: section_header: Adding guardrails for front-facing applications - item-72 at level 1: text: =-1 The ability to enforce guard ... force quality content in applications. - item-73 at level 1: section_header: System prompt to enforce guardrails - item-74 at level 1: paragraph: We introduce a system prompt (se ... rdrails, similar to the work done with - item-75 at level 1: text: 2. Using this prompt allows the ... as indicated in Table[tab:guardrails]. - item-76 at level 1: text: 0.98Always assist with care, res ... plies promote fairness and positivity. - item-77 at level 1: text: r0.38 - item-78 at level 1: table with [5x2] - item-79 at level 1: text: tableSystem prompts. Mean offici ... Chat reports official results of 6.65. - item-80 at level 1: text: =-1 We use a set of 175 unsafe p ... o answer 100%of the harmful questions. - item-81 at level 1: text: =-1 As an illustration, we provi ... y when system prompts are deactivated. - item-82 at level 1: table with [4x2] - item-83 at level 1: text: Comparison between Mistral and s ... question How to kill a linux process. - item-84 at level 1: section_header: Content moderation with self-reflection - item-85 at level 1: text: =-1 can be used as a content mod ... n legal, medical or financial domains. - item-86 at level 1: text: =-1 To do so, we designed a self ... ring acceptable prompts as positives). - item-87 at level 1: text: =-1 The use cases are vast, from ... er based on their particular use-case. - item-88 at level 1: section_header: Conclusion - item-89 at level 1: paragraph: Our work on Mistral 7B demonstra ... l capabilities to training cost, as in - item-90 at level 1: text: [hoffmann2022compute]); the prob ... ance with the smallest possible model. - item-91 at level 1: section_header: Acknowledgements - item-92 at level 1: text: =-1 We are grateful to CoreWeave ... aking our model compatible everywhere. - item-93 at level 1: section: group figure - item-94 at level 2: picture - item-94 at level 3: caption: Image: images/llama_vs_mistral_example.png - item-95 at level 2: text: Human evaluation of vs 213BChat ... cribes in the contents in more detail. - item-96 at level 1: caption: Image: images/llama_vs_mistral_example.png - item-97 at level 1: text: ref - item-98 at level 1: text: plain \ No newline at end of file + item-50 at level 1: text: Size and Efficiency. We computed ... the amount of knowledge it can store. + item-51 at level 1: text: Evaluation Differences. On some ... we do not provide Wikipedia contexts. + item-52 at level 1: section: group figure + item-53 at level 2: picture + item-53 at level 3: caption: Image: images/230927_bars.png + item-54 at level 2: text: Performance of and different mod ... generation, and reasoning benchmarks. + item-55 at level 1: caption: Image: images/230927_bars.png + item-56 at level 1: table with [6x14] + item-57 at level 1: text: Comparison of with . outperforms ... ng performance on non-code benchmarks. + item-58 at level 1: section: group figure + item-59 at level 2: picture + item-59 at level 3: caption: Image: images/230927_effective_sizes.png + item-60 at level 2: text: Results on MMLU, commonsense rea ... amount of knowledge it can compress). + item-61 at level 1: caption: Image: images/230927_effective_sizes.png + item-62 at level 1: text: r0.48 + item-63 at level 1: table with [9x3] + item-64 at level 1: text: tableComparison of Chat models. ... and is comparable to 13B Chat models. + item-65 at level 1: section_header: Instruction Finetuning + item-66 at level 1: text: =-1 To evaluate the generalizati ... on https://llmboxing.com/leaderboard. + item-67 at level 1: text: In this evaluation, participants ... ompared to 4143 times for Llama 2 13B. + item-68 at level 1: section_header: Adding guardrails for front-facing applications + item-69 at level 1: text: =-1 The ability to enforce guard ... force quality content in applications. + item-70 at level 1: section_header: System prompt to enforce guardrails + item-71 at level 1: text: We introduce a system prompt (se ... as indicated in Table[tab:guardrails]. + item-72 at level 1: text: 0.98Always assist with care, res ... plies promote fairness and positivity. + item-73 at level 1: text: r0.38 + item-74 at level 1: table with [5x2] + item-75 at level 1: text: tableSystem prompts. Mean offici ... Chat reports official results of 6.65. + item-76 at level 1: text: =-1 We use a set of 175 unsafe p ... o answer 100%of the harmful questions. + item-77 at level 1: text: =-1 As an illustration, we provi ... y when system prompts are deactivated. + item-78 at level 1: table with [4x2] + item-79 at level 1: text: Comparison between Mistral and s ... question How to kill a linux process. + item-80 at level 1: section_header: Content moderation with self-reflection + item-81 at level 1: text: =-1 can be used as a content mod ... n legal, medical or financial domains. + item-82 at level 1: text: =-1 To do so, we designed a self ... ring acceptable prompts as positives). + item-83 at level 1: text: =-1 The use cases are vast, from ... er based on their particular use-case. + item-84 at level 1: section_header: Conclusion + item-85 at level 1: text: Our work on Mistral 7B demonstra ... ance with the smallest possible model. + item-86 at level 1: section_header: Acknowledgements + item-87 at level 1: text: =-1 We are grateful to CoreWeave ... aking our model compatible everywhere. + item-88 at level 1: section: group figure + item-89 at level 2: picture + item-89 at level 3: caption: Image: images/llama_vs_mistral_example.png + item-90 at level 2: text: Human evaluation of vs 213BChat ... cribes in the contents in more detail. + item-91 at level 1: caption: Image: images/llama_vs_mistral_example.png + item-92 at level 1: text: ref + item-93 at level 1: text: plain \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2310.06825_main.tex.json b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2310.06825_main.tex.json index 2ca01bf606..f6634c3f51 100644 --- a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2310.06825_main.tex.json +++ b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2310.06825_main.tex.json @@ -109,10 +109,10 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/30" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/31" + "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, { - "$ref": "#/groups/3" + "$ref": "#/texts/37" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/38" @@ -127,34 +127,34 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/41" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/42" + "$ref": "#/groups/4" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/43" + "$ref": "#/texts/42" }, { - "$ref": "#/groups/4" + "$ref": "#/tables/1" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/44" }, { - "$ref": "#/tables/1" + "$ref": "#/groups/5" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/46" + "$ref": "#/texts/45" }, { - "$ref": "#/groups/5" + "$ref": "#/texts/47" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/47" + "$ref": "#/tables/2" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/49" + "$ref": "#/texts/48" }, { - "$ref": "#/tables/2" + "$ref": "#/texts/49" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/50" @@ -180,6 +180,9 @@ { "$ref": "#/texts/57" }, + { + "$ref": "#/tables/3" + }, { "$ref": "#/texts/58" }, @@ -190,10 +193,10 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/60" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/61" + "$ref": "#/tables/4" }, { - "$ref": "#/tables/3" + "$ref": "#/texts/61" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/62" @@ -204,9 +207,6 @@ { "$ref": "#/texts/64" }, - { - "$ref": "#/tables/4" - }, { "$ref": "#/texts/65" }, @@ -223,31 +223,16 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/69" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/70" + "$ref": "#/groups/6" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/71" + "$ref": "#/texts/70" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/72" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/73" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/74" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/groups/6" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/75" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/77" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/78" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -315,6 +300,9 @@ "$ref": "#/body" }, "children": [ + { + "$ref": "#/texts/31" + }, { "$ref": "#/texts/32" }, @@ -329,9 +317,6 @@ }, { "$ref": "#/texts/36" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/37" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -348,7 +333,7 @@ "$ref": "#/pictures/4" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/45" + "$ref": "#/texts/43" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -365,7 +350,7 @@ "$ref": "#/pictures/5" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/48" + "$ref": "#/texts/46" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -382,7 +367,7 @@ "$ref": "#/pictures/6" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/76" + "$ref": "#/texts/71" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -762,25 +747,13 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "We compare", - "text": "We compare" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/31", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "to , and re-run all benchmarks with our own evaluation pipeline for fair comparison.\nWe measure performance on a wide variety of tasks categorized as follow:", - "text": "to , and re-run all benchmarks with our own evaluation pipeline for fair comparison.\nWe measure performance on a wide variety of tasks categorized as follow:" + "orig": "We compare to , and re-run all benchmarks with our own evaluation pipeline for fair comparison.\nWe measure performance on a wide variety of tasks categorized as follow:", + "text": "We compare to , and re-run all benchmarks with our own evaluation pipeline for fair comparison.\nWe measure performance on a wide variety of tasks categorized as follow:" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/32", + "self_ref": "#/texts/31", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -794,7 +767,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/33", + "self_ref": "#/texts/32", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -808,7 +781,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/34", + "self_ref": "#/texts/33", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -822,7 +795,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/35", + "self_ref": "#/texts/34", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -836,7 +809,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/36", + "self_ref": "#/texts/35", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -850,7 +823,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/37", + "self_ref": "#/texts/36", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -864,19 +837,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/38", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Detailed results for", - "text": "Detailed results for" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/39", + "self_ref": "#/texts/37", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -884,11 +845,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": ", 2 7B/13B, and Code-7B are reported in Table[tab:results].\nFigure[fig:bars] compares the performance of with 2 7B/13B, and 1 34B", - "text": ", 2 7B/13B, and Code-7B are reported in Table[tab:results].\nFigure[fig:bars] compares the performance of with 2 7B/13B, and 1 34B" + "orig": "Detailed results for , 2 7B/13B, and Code-7B are reported in Table[tab:results].\nFigure[fig:bars] compares the performance of with 2 7B/13B, and 1 34B", + "text": "Detailed results for , 2 7B/13B, and Code-7B are reported in Table[tab:results].\nFigure[fig:bars] compares the performance of with 2 7B/13B, and 1 34B" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/40", + "self_ref": "#/texts/38", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -900,7 +861,7 @@ "text": "Since 2 34B was not open-sourced, we report results for 1 34B." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/41", + "self_ref": "#/texts/39", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -912,7 +873,7 @@ "text": "in different categories.\nsurpasses 2 13B across all metrics, and outperforms 134B on most benchmarks.\nIn particular, displays a superior performance in code, mathematics, and reasoning benchmarks." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/42", + "self_ref": "#/texts/40", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -924,7 +885,7 @@ "text": "Size and Efficiency. We computed equivalent model sizes of the 2 family, aiming to understand models' efficiency in the cost-performance spectrum (see Figure[fig:size]). When evaluated on reasoning, comprehension, and STEM reasoning (specifically MMLU), mirrored performance that one might expect from a 2 model with more than 3x its size. On the Knowledge benchmarks, 's performance achieves a lower compression rate of 1.9x, which is likely due to its limited parameter count that restricts the amount of knowledge it can store." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/43", + "self_ref": "#/texts/41", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -936,7 +897,7 @@ "text": "Evaluation Differences. On some benchmarks, there are some differences between our evaluation protocol and the one reported in the 2 paper: 1) on MBPP, we use the hand-verified subset 2) on TriviaQA, we do not provide Wikipedia contexts." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/44", + "self_ref": "#/texts/42", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -948,7 +909,7 @@ "text": "Image: images/230927_bars.png" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/45", + "self_ref": "#/texts/43", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/4" }, @@ -960,7 +921,7 @@ "text": "Performance of and different models on a wide range of benchmarks. All models were re-evaluated on all metrics with our evaluation pipeline for accurate comparison. significantly outperforms 2 7B and 2 13B on all benchmarks. It is also vastly superior to 1 34B in mathematics, code generation, and reasoning benchmarks." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/46", + "self_ref": "#/texts/44", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -972,7 +933,7 @@ "text": "Comparison of with . outperforms 2 13B on all metrics, and approaches the code performance of Code-7B without sacrificing performance on non-code benchmarks." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/47", + "self_ref": "#/texts/45", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -984,7 +945,7 @@ "text": "Image: images/230927_effective_sizes.png" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/48", + "self_ref": "#/texts/46", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/5" }, @@ -996,7 +957,7 @@ "text": "Results on MMLU, commonsense reasoning, world knowledge and reading comprehension for and 2 (7B/13B/70B). largely outperforms 2 13B on all evaluations, except on knowledge benchmarks, where it is on par (this is likely due to its limited parameter count, which limits the amount of knowledge it can compress)." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/49", + "self_ref": "#/texts/47", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1008,7 +969,7 @@ "text": "r0.48" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/50", + "self_ref": "#/texts/48", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1020,7 +981,7 @@ "text": "tableComparison of Chat models. outperforms all 7B models on MT-Bench, and is comparable to 13B Chat models." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/51", + "self_ref": "#/texts/49", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1033,7 +994,7 @@ "level": 1 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/52", + "self_ref": "#/texts/50", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1045,19 +1006,7 @@ "text": "=-1 To evaluate the generalization capabilities of , we fine-tuned it on instruction datasets publicly available on the Hugging Face repository.\nNo proprietary data or training tricks were utilized: model is a simple and preliminary demonstration that the base model can easily be fine-tuned to achieve good performance.\nIn Table[tab:results_finetuning], we observe that the resulting model, , exhibits superior performance compared to all 7B models on MT-Bench, and is comparable to 13B Chat models.\nAn independent human evaluation was conducted on https://llmboxing.com/leaderboard." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/53", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "In this evaluation, participants were provided with a set of questions along with anonymous responses from two models and were asked to select their preferred response, as illustrated in Figure", - "text": "In this evaluation, participants were provided with a set of questions along with anonymous responses from two models and were asked to select their preferred response, as illustrated in Figure" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/54", + "self_ref": "#/texts/51", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1065,11 +1014,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[fig:humanevalquestion].\nAs of October 6, 2023, the outputs generated by Mistral 7B were preferred 5020 times, compared to 4143 times for Llama 2 13B.", - "text": "[fig:humanevalquestion].\nAs of October 6, 2023, the outputs generated by Mistral 7B were preferred 5020 times, compared to 4143 times for Llama 2 13B." + "orig": "In this evaluation, participants were provided with a set of questions along with anonymous responses from two models and were asked to select their preferred response, as illustrated in Figure[fig:humanevalquestion].\nAs of October 6, 2023, the outputs generated by Mistral 7B were preferred 5020 times, compared to 4143 times for Llama 2 13B.", + "text": "In this evaluation, participants were provided with a set of questions along with anonymous responses from two models and were asked to select their preferred response, as illustrated in Figure[fig:humanevalquestion].\nAs of October 6, 2023, the outputs generated by Mistral 7B were preferred 5020 times, compared to 4143 times for Llama 2 13B." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/55", + "self_ref": "#/texts/52", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1082,7 +1031,7 @@ "level": 1 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/56", + "self_ref": "#/texts/53", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1094,7 +1043,7 @@ "text": "=-1 The ability to enforce guardrails when it comes to AI generation is important for front-facing applications.\nIn this section, we highlight how to leverage system prompting to optionally enforce output constraints on top of our models.\nAdditionally, we showcase the ability of to perform fine-grained content moderation, which can be useful to enforce quality content in applications." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/57", + "self_ref": "#/texts/54", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1107,19 +1056,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/58", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "We introduce a system prompt (see below) to guide the model to generate answers within specified guardrails, similar to the work done with", - "text": "We introduce a system prompt (see below) to guide the model to generate answers within specified guardrails, similar to the work done with" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/59", + "self_ref": "#/texts/55", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1127,11 +1064,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "2. Using this prompt allows the user to move on the Pareto front of model utility / guardrails enforcement, as indicated in Table[tab:guardrails].", - "text": "2. Using this prompt allows the user to move on the Pareto front of model utility / guardrails enforcement, as indicated in Table[tab:guardrails]." + "orig": "We introduce a system prompt (see below) to guide the model to generate answers within specified guardrails, similar to the work done with 2. Using this prompt allows the user to move on the Pareto front of model utility / guardrails enforcement, as indicated in Table[tab:guardrails].", + "text": "We introduce a system prompt (see below) to guide the model to generate answers within specified guardrails, similar to the work done with 2. Using this prompt allows the user to move on the Pareto front of model utility / guardrails enforcement, as indicated in Table[tab:guardrails]." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/60", + "self_ref": "#/texts/56", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1143,7 +1080,7 @@ "text": "0.98Always assist with care, respect, and truth. Respond with utmost utility yet securely. Avoid harmful, unethical, prejudiced, or negative content. Ensure replies promote fairness and positivity." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/61", + "self_ref": "#/texts/57", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1155,7 +1092,7 @@ "text": "r0.38" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/62", + "self_ref": "#/texts/58", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1167,7 +1104,7 @@ "text": "tableSystem prompts. Mean official MT Bench score over 10 iterations with standard deviation for . For reference, 2 13B Chat reports official results of 6.65." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/63", + "self_ref": "#/texts/59", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1179,7 +1116,7 @@ "text": "=-1 We use a set of 175 unsafe prompts for evaluating safety.\nWith the recommended system prompt, the model properly declines to answer 100%of the harmful questions." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/64", + "self_ref": "#/texts/60", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1191,7 +1128,7 @@ "text": "=-1 As an illustration, we provide in Table[tab:guardrails_example] the answers of both and 2 Chat 13B to the question How to kill a linux process with system prompts activated.\nWe observe that provides a correct response while 2 declines to answer.\nNote that on this specific question, both models answer correctly when system prompts are deactivated." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/65", + "self_ref": "#/texts/61", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1203,7 +1140,7 @@ "text": "Comparison between Mistral and system prompts.\nMistral provides the right answer whereas 2 declines to answer to the question How to kill a linux process." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/66", + "self_ref": "#/texts/62", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1216,7 +1153,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/67", + "self_ref": "#/texts/63", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1228,7 +1165,7 @@ "text": "=-1 can be used as a content moderator: the model itself is able to accurately classify a user prompt or its generated answer as being either acceptable or falling into one of the following categories:\nIllegal activities such as terrorism, child abuse or fraud;\nHateful, harassing or violent content such as discrimination, self-harm or bullying;\nUnqualified advice for instance in legal, medical or financial domains." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/68", + "self_ref": "#/texts/64", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1240,7 +1177,7 @@ "text": "=-1 To do so, we designed a self-reflection prompt that makes classify a prompt or a generated answer. We evaluated self-reflection on our manually curated and balanced dataset of adversarial and standard prompts and got a precision of 99.4% for a recall of 95.6%(considering acceptable prompts as positives)." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/69", + "self_ref": "#/texts/65", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1252,7 +1189,7 @@ "text": "=-1 The use cases are vast, from moderating comments on social media or forums to brand monitoring on the internet. In particular, the end user is able to select afterwards which categories to effectively filter based on their particular use-case." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/70", + "self_ref": "#/texts/66", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1265,19 +1202,7 @@ "level": 1 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/71", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Our work on Mistral 7B demonstrates that language models may compress knowledge more than what was previously thought. This opens up interesting perspectives: the field has so far put the emphasis on scaling laws in 2 dimensions (directly associating model capabilities to training cost, as in", - "text": "Our work on Mistral 7B demonstrates that language models may compress knowledge more than what was previously thought. This opens up interesting perspectives: the field has so far put the emphasis on scaling laws in 2 dimensions (directly associating model capabilities to training cost, as in" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/72", + "self_ref": "#/texts/67", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1285,11 +1210,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[hoffmann2022compute]); the problem is rather 3 dimensional (model capabilities, training cost, inference cost), and much remains to be explored to obtain the best performance with the smallest possible model.", - "text": "[hoffmann2022compute]); the problem is rather 3 dimensional (model capabilities, training cost, inference cost), and much remains to be explored to obtain the best performance with the smallest possible model." + "orig": "Our work on Mistral 7B demonstrates that language models may compress knowledge more than what was previously thought. This opens up interesting perspectives: the field has so far put the emphasis on scaling laws in 2 dimensions (directly associating model capabilities to training cost, as in [hoffmann2022compute]); the problem is rather 3 dimensional (model capabilities, training cost, inference cost), and much remains to be explored to obtain the best performance with the smallest possible model.", + "text": "Our work on Mistral 7B demonstrates that language models may compress knowledge more than what was previously thought. This opens up interesting perspectives: the field has so far put the emphasis on scaling laws in 2 dimensions (directly associating model capabilities to training cost, as in [hoffmann2022compute]); the problem is rather 3 dimensional (model capabilities, training cost, inference cost), and much remains to be explored to obtain the best performance with the smallest possible model." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/73", + "self_ref": "#/texts/68", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1302,7 +1227,7 @@ "level": 1 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/74", + "self_ref": "#/texts/69", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1314,7 +1239,7 @@ "text": "=-1 We are grateful to CoreWeave for their 24/7 help in marshalling our cluster. We thank the CINECA/EuroHPC team, and in particular the operators of Leonardo, for their resources and help. We thank the maintainers of FlashAttention, vLLM, xFormers, Skypilot for their precious assistance in implementing new features and integrating their solutions into ours. A huge thanks to Tri Dao and Daniel Haziza for helping include Mistral related changes to FlashAttention and xFormers on a tight schedule. We thank the teams of Hugging Face, AWS, GCP, Azure ML for their intense help in making our model compatible everywhere." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/75", + "self_ref": "#/texts/70", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1326,7 +1251,7 @@ "text": "Image: images/llama_vs_mistral_example.png" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/76", + "self_ref": "#/texts/71", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/6" }, @@ -1338,7 +1263,7 @@ "text": "Human evaluation of vs 213BChat Example. An example of human evaluation from llmboxing.com. The question asks for recommendations of books in quantum physics. 2 13B Chat recommends a general physics book, while recommends a more relevant book on quantum physics and describes in the contents in more detail." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/77", + "self_ref": "#/texts/72", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1350,7 +1275,7 @@ "text": "ref" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/78", + "self_ref": "#/texts/73", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1386,7 +1311,7 @@ "width": 1500.0, "height": 500.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -1413,7 +1338,7 @@ "width": 2148.0, "height": 800.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -1440,7 +1365,7 @@ "width": 2552.0, "height": 402.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -1467,7 +1392,7 @@ "width": 1559.0, "height": 635.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -1482,7 +1407,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/44" + "$ref": "#/texts/42" } ], "references": [], @@ -1494,7 +1419,7 @@ "width": 10973.0, "height": 3570.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -1509,7 +1434,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/47" + "$ref": "#/texts/45" } ], "references": [], @@ -1521,7 +1446,7 @@ "width": 6335.0, "height": 4386.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -1536,7 +1461,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/75" + "$ref": "#/texts/70" } ], "references": [], @@ -1548,7 +1473,7 @@ "width": 1656.0, "height": 2552.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] } diff --git a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2310.06825_main.tex.md b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2310.06825_main.tex.md index 9f8edd19f5..64fc414154 100644 --- a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2310.06825_main.tex.md +++ b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2310.06825_main.tex.md @@ -116,9 +116,7 @@ The figure shows what happens for the third chunk (the dog go to): it attends it ## Results -We compare - -to , and re-run all benchmarks with our own evaluation pipeline for fair comparison. +We compare to , and re-run all benchmarks with our own evaluation pipeline for fair comparison. We measure performance on a wide variety of tasks categorized as follow: - Commonsense Reasoning (0-shot): Hellaswag[zellers2019hellaswag], Winogrande[sakaguchi2021winogrande], PIQA[bisk2020piqa], SIQA[sap2019socialiqa], OpenbookQA[mihaylov2018can], ARC-Easy, ARC-Challenge[clark2018think], CommonsenseQA[talmor2018commonsenseqa] @@ -128,9 +126,7 @@ We measure performance on a wide variety of tasks categorized as follow: - Code: Humaneval[chen2021evaluating] (0-shot) and MBPP[austin2021program] (3-shot) - Popular aggregated results: MMLU[hendrycks2020measuring] (5-shot), BBH[suzgun2022challenging] (3-shot), and AGI Eval[zhong2023agieval] (3-5-shot, English multiple-choice questions only) -Detailed results for - -, 2 7B/13B, and Code-7B are reported in Table[tab:results]. +Detailed results for , 2 7B/13B, and Code-7B are reported in Table[tab:results]. Figure[fig:bars] compares the performance of with 2 7B/13B, and 1 34B Since 2 34B was not open-sourced, we report results for 1 34B. @@ -187,9 +183,7 @@ No proprietary data or training tricks were utilized: model is a simple and prel In Table[tab:results\_finetuning], we observe that the resulting model, , exhibits superior performance compared to all 7B models on MT-Bench, and is comparable to 13B Chat models. An independent human evaluation was conducted on https://llmboxing.com/leaderboard. -In this evaluation, participants were provided with a set of questions along with anonymous responses from two models and were asked to select their preferred response, as illustrated in Figure - -[fig:humanevalquestion]. +In this evaluation, participants were provided with a set of questions along with anonymous responses from two models and were asked to select their preferred response, as illustrated in Figure[fig:humanevalquestion]. As of October 6, 2023, the outputs generated by Mistral 7B were preferred 5020 times, compared to 4143 times for Llama 2 13B. ## Adding guardrails for front-facing applications @@ -200,9 +194,7 @@ Additionally, we showcase the ability of to perform fine-grained content moderat ### System prompt to enforce guardrails -We introduce a system prompt (see below) to guide the model to generate answers within specified guardrails, similar to the work done with - -2. Using this prompt allows the user to move on the Pareto front of model utility / guardrails enforcement, as indicated in Table[tab:guardrails]. +We introduce a system prompt (see below) to guide the model to generate answers within specified guardrails, similar to the work done with 2. Using this prompt allows the user to move on the Pareto front of model utility / guardrails enforcement, as indicated in Table[tab:guardrails]. 0.98Always assist with care, respect, and truth. Respond with utmost utility yet securely. Avoid harmful, unethical, prejudiced, or negative content. Ensure replies promote fairness and positivity. @@ -246,9 +238,7 @@ Unqualified advice for instance in legal, medical or financial domains. ## Conclusion -Our work on Mistral 7B demonstrates that language models may compress knowledge more than what was previously thought. This opens up interesting perspectives: the field has so far put the emphasis on scaling laws in 2 dimensions (directly associating model capabilities to training cost, as in - -[hoffmann2022compute]); the problem is rather 3 dimensional (model capabilities, training cost, inference cost), and much remains to be explored to obtain the best performance with the smallest possible model. +Our work on Mistral 7B demonstrates that language models may compress knowledge more than what was previously thought. This opens up interesting perspectives: the field has so far put the emphasis on scaling laws in 2 dimensions (directly associating model capabilities to training cost, as in [hoffmann2022compute]); the problem is rather 3 dimensional (model capabilities, training cost, inference cost), and much remains to be explored to obtain the best performance with the smallest possible model. ## Acknowledgements diff --git a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2412.19437_main.tex.itxt b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2412.19437_main.tex.itxt index 30b2e13694..6cb2735388 100644 --- a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2412.19437_main.tex.itxt +++ b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2412.19437_main.tex.itxt @@ -9,471 +9,396 @@ item-0 at level 0: unspecified: group _root_ item-7 at level 1: caption: Image: figures/dsv3_performance.pdf item-8 at level 1: text: 0.9 item-9 at level 1: section_header: Introduction - item-10 at level 1: paragraph: In recent years, Large Language Models - item-11 at level 1: text: (LLMs) have been undergoing rapi ... hich 37B are activated for each token. - item-12 at level 1: paragraph: With a forward-looking perspecti ... . -Therefore, in terms of architecture, - item-13 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V3 still adopts Multi-h ... performance on evaluation benchmarks. - item-14 at level 1: paragraph: In order to achieve efficient tr ... mising solution for efficient training - item-15 at level 1: text: [bf16train, fp16train, fp8lm, ll ... , we achieve high training efficiency. - item-16 at level 1: paragraph: During pre-training, we train - item-17 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V3 on 14.8T high-qualit ... model accuracy and generation length. - item-18 at level 1: paragraph: We evaluate - item-19 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V3 on a comprehensive a ... of standard and open-ended benchmarks. - item-20 at level 1: table with [4x5] - item-21 at level 1: text: Training costs of DeepSeek-V3, a ... ntal price of H800 is $2 per GPU hour. - item-22 at level 1: paragraph: Lastly, we emphasize again the economical training costs of - item-23 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V3, summarized in Table ... on architectures, algorithms, or data. - item-24 at level 1: paragraph: Our main contribution includes: - item-25 at level 1: text: Architecture: Innovative Load Balancing Strategy and Training Objective - item-26 at level 1: list: group list - item-27 at level 2: list_item: On top of the efficient architec ... rises from encouraging load balancing. - item-28 at level 2: list_item: We investigate a Multi-Token Pre ... e decoding for inference acceleration. - item-29 at level 1: text: Pre-Training: Towards Ultimate Training Efficiency - item-30 at level 1: list: group list - item-31 at level 2: list_item: We design an FP8 mixed precision ... ing on an extremely large-scale model. - item-32 at level 2: list_item: Through the co-design of algorit ... odel size without additional overhead. - item-33 at level 2: list_item: At an economical cost of only 2. ... -training require only 0.1M GPU hours. - item-34 at level 1: text: Post-Training: Knowledge Distillation from DeepSeek-R1 - item-35 at level 1: list: group list - item-36 at level 2: list_item: We introduce an innovative metho ... utput style and length of DeepSeek-V3. - item-37 at level 1: text: Summary of Core Evaluation Results - item-38 at level 1: list: group list - item-39 at level 2: list_item: Knowledge: + item-10 at level 1: text: In recent years, Large Language ... hich 37B are activated for each token. + item-11 at level 1: text: With a forward-looking perspecti ... performance on evaluation benchmarks. + item-12 at level 1: text: In order to achieve efficient tr ... , we achieve high training efficiency. + item-13 at level 1: text: During pre-training, we train De ... model accuracy and generation length. + item-14 at level 1: text: We evaluate DeepSeek-V3 on a com ... of standard and open-ended benchmarks. + item-15 at level 1: table with [4x5] + item-16 at level 1: text: Training costs of DeepSeek-V3, a ... ntal price of H800 is $2 per GPU hour. + item-17 at level 1: text: Lastly, we emphasize again the e ... on architectures, algorithms, or data. + item-18 at level 1: paragraph: Our main contribution includes: + item-19 at level 1: text: Architecture: Innovative Load Balancing Strategy and Training Objective + item-20 at level 1: list: group list + item-21 at level 2: list_item: On top of the efficient architec ... rises from encouraging load balancing. + item-22 at level 2: list_item: We investigate a Multi-Token Pre ... e decoding for inference acceleration. + item-23 at level 1: text: Pre-Training: Towards Ultimate Training Efficiency + item-24 at level 1: list: group list + item-25 at level 2: list_item: We design an FP8 mixed precision ... ing on an extremely large-scale model. + item-26 at level 2: list_item: Through the co-design of algorit ... odel size without additional overhead. + item-27 at level 2: list_item: At an economical cost of only 2. ... -training require only 0.1M GPU hours. + item-28 at level 1: text: Post-Training: Knowledge Distillation from DeepSeek-R1 + item-29 at level 1: list: group list + item-30 at level 2: list_item: We introduce an innovative metho ... utput style and length of DeepSeek-V3. + item-31 at level 1: text: Summary of Core Evaluation Results + item-32 at level 1: list: group list + item-33 at level 2: list_item: Knowledge: (1) On educa ... strength in Chinese factual knowledge. - item-40 at level 2: list_item: Code, Math, and Reasoning: + item-34 at level 2: list_item: Code, Math, and Reasoning: ... s across diverse technical benchmarks. - item-41 at level 1: text: In the remainder of this paper, ... re research (Section[sec:conclusion]). - item-42 at level 1: section_header: Architecture - item-43 at level 1: paragraph: We first introduce the basic architecture of - item-44 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V3, featured by Multi-h ... to the settings of DeepSeek-V2[dsvii]. - item-45 at level 1: section: group figure - item-46 at level 2: picture - item-46 at level 3: caption: Image: figures/basic_arch.pdf - item-47 at level 2: text: Illustration of the basic archit ... ent inference and economical training. - item-48 at level 1: caption: Image: figures/basic_arch.pdf - item-49 at level 1: section_header: Basic Architecture - item-50 at level 1: paragraph: The basic architecture of - item-51 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V3 is still within the ... f MLA and DeepSeekMoE in this section. - item-52 at level 1: section_header: Multi-Head Latent Attention - item-53 at level 1: paragraph: For attention, - item-54 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V3 adopts the MLA archi ... Key-Value (KV) cache during inference: - item-55 at level 1: formula: \begin{align} + item-35 at level 1: text: In the remainder of this paper, ... re research (Section[sec:conclusion]). + item-36 at level 1: section_header: Architecture + item-37 at level 1: text: We first introduce the basic arc ... to the settings of DeepSeek-V2[dsvii]. + item-38 at level 1: section: group figure + item-39 at level 2: picture + item-39 at level 3: caption: Image: figures/basic_arch.pdf + item-40 at level 2: text: Illustration of the basic archit ... ent inference and economical training. + item-41 at level 1: caption: Image: figures/basic_arch.pdf + item-42 at level 1: section_header: Basic Architecture + item-43 at level 1: text: The basic architecture of DeepSe ... f MLA and DeepSeekMoE in this section. + item-44 at level 1: section_header: Multi-Head Latent Attention + item-45 at level 1: text: For attention, DeepSeek-V3 adopt ... Key-Value (KV) cache during inference: + item-46 at level 1: formula: \begin{align} \boxed{\color{ ... {UV} \mathbf{c}_{t}^{KV}, \end{align} - item-56 at level 1: text: where $\mathbf{c}_{t}^{KV} \in \ ... lti-Head Attention (MHA)[transformer]. - item-57 at level 1: paragraph: For the attention queries, we al ... the activation memory during training: - item-58 at level 1: formula: \begin{align} + item-47 at level 1: text: where $\mathbf{c}_{t}^{KV} \in \ ... lti-Head Attention (MHA)[transformer]. + item-48 at level 1: text: For the attention queries, we al ... the activation memory during training: + item-49 at level 1: formula: \begin{align} \mathbf{c}_{t} ... }; \mathbf{q}_{t, i}^{R}], \end{align} - item-59 at level 1: text: where $\mathbf{c}_{t}^{Q} \in \m ... the decoupled queries that carry RoPE. - item-60 at level 1: paragraph: Ultimately, the attention queries ( - item-61 at level 1: text: $\mathbf{q}_{t, i}$), keys ($\ma ... nal attention output $\mathbf{u}_{t}$: - item-62 at level 1: formula: \begin{align} + item-50 at level 1: text: where $\mathbf{c}_{t}^{Q} \in \m ... the decoupled queries that carry RoPE. + item-51 at level 1: text: Ultimately, the attention querie ... nal attention output $\mathbf{u}_{t}$: + item-52 at level 1: formula: \begin{align} \mathbf{o}_{t, ... ..;\mathbf{o}_{t, n_{h}}], \end{align} - item-63 at level 1: text: where $W^{O} \in \mathbb{R}^{d \ ... $denotes the output projection matrix. - item-64 at level 1: section_header: DeepSeekMoE with Auxiliary-Loss-Free Load Balancing - item-65 at level 1: text: Basic Architecture of DeepSeekMo ... $\mathbf{h}_{t}^{\prime}$ as follows: - item-66 at level 1: formula: \begin{align} + item-53 at level 1: text: where $W^{O} \in \mathbb{R}^{d \ ... $denotes the output projection matrix. + item-54 at level 1: section_header: DeepSeekMoE with Auxiliary-Loss-Free Load Balancing + item-55 at level 1: text: Basic Architecture of DeepSeekMo ... $\mathbf{h}_{t}^{\prime}$ as follows: + item-56 at level 1: formula: \begin{align} \mathbf{h}_{t} ... T} \mathbf{e}_{i} \right), \end{align} - item-67 at level 1: text: where $N_{s}$ and $N_r$ denote t ... y scores to produce the gating values. - item-68 at level 1: text: Auxiliary-Loss-Free Load Balanci ... {i,t}$ to determine the top-K routing: - item-69 at level 1: formula: \begin{align} + item-57 at level 1: text: where $N_{s}$ and $N_r$ denote t ... y scores to produce the gating values. + item-58 at level 1: text: Auxiliary-Loss-Free Load Balanci ... {i,t}$ to determine the top-K routing: + item-59 at level 1: formula: \begin{align} g^{\prime}_{i, ... therwise}. \end{cases} \end{align} - item-70 at level 1: text: Note that the bias term is only ... balance through pure auxiliary losses. - item-71 at level 1: text: Complementary Sequence-Wise Auxi ... plementary sequence-wise balance loss: - item-72 at level 1: formula: \begin{align} + item-60 at level 1: text: Note that the bias term is only ... balance through pure auxiliary losses. + item-61 at level 1: text: Complementary Sequence-Wise Auxi ... plementary sequence-wise balance loss: + item-62 at level 1: formula: \begin{align} \mathcal{L}_{\ ... =1}^{T}{s^{\prime}_{i,t}}, \end{align} - item-73 at level 1: text: where the balance factor $\alpha ... load on each sequence to be balanced. - item-74 at level 1: text: Node-Limited Routing. + item-63 at level 1: text: where the balance factor $\alpha ... load on each sequence to be balanced. + item-64 at level 1: text: Node-Limited Routing. Like the d ... ull computation-communication overlap. - item-75 at level 1: text: No Token-Dropping. + item-65 at level 1: text: No Token-Dropping. Due to the ef ... does not drop tokens during inference. - item-76 at level 1: section: group figure - item-77 at level 2: picture - item-77 at level 3: caption: Image: figures/nextn.pdf - item-78 at level 2: text: Illustration of our Multi-Token ... rediction of each token at each depth. - item-79 at level 1: caption: Image: figures/nextn.pdf - item-80 at level 1: section_header: Multi-Token Prediction - item-81 at level 1: paragraph: Inspired by - item-82 at level 1: text: [meta_mtp], we investigate and s ... ur MTP implementation in this section. - item-83 at level 1: text: MTP Modules. + item-66 at level 1: section: group figure + item-67 at level 2: picture + item-67 at level 3: caption: Image: figures/nextn.pdf + item-68 at level 2: text: Illustration of our Multi-Token ... rediction of each token at each depth. + item-69 at level 1: caption: Image: figures/nextn.pdf + item-70 at level 1: section_header: Multi-Token Prediction + item-71 at level 1: text: Inspired by [meta_mtp], we inves ... ur MTP implementation in this section. + item-72 at level 1: text: MTP Modules. To be specific, our ... bb{R}^{d}$ with the linear projection: - item-84 at level 1: formula: \mathbf{h}_i^{\prime k} = M_k [\ ... MSNorm}(\operatorname{Emb}(t_{i+k}))], - item-85 at level 1: text: where $[\cdot ; \cdot]$ denotes ... he current depth $\mathbf{h}_{i}^{k}$: - item-86 at level 1: formula: \mathbf{h}_{1:T-k}^{k} = \operat ... TRM}_k(\mathbf{h}_{1:T-k}^{\prime k}), - item-87 at level 1: text: where $T$ represents the input s ... V}$, where $V$ is the vocabulary size: - item-88 at level 1: formula: P_{i+k+1}^{k} = \operatorname{OutHead}(\mathbf{h}_{i}^{k}). - item-89 at level 1: text: The output head $\operatorname{O ... as we utilize MTP to improve training. - item-90 at level 1: text: MTP Training Objective. + item-73 at level 1: formula: \mathbf{h}_i^{\prime k} = M_k [\ ... MSNorm}(\operatorname{Emb}(t_{i+k}))], + item-74 at level 1: text: where $[\cdot ; \cdot]$ denotes ... he current depth $\mathbf{h}_{i}^{k}$: + item-75 at level 1: formula: \mathbf{h}_{1:T-k}^{k} = \operat ... TRM}_k(\mathbf{h}_{1:T-k}^{\prime k}), + item-76 at level 1: text: where $T$ represents the input s ... V}$, where $V$ is the vocabulary size: + item-77 at level 1: formula: P_{i+k+1}^{k} = \operatorname{OutHead}(\mathbf{h}_{i}^{k}). + item-78 at level 1: text: The output head $\operatorname{O ... as we utilize MTP to improve training. + item-79 at level 1: text: MTP Training Objective. For each ... y loss $\mathcal{L}_{\text{MTP}}^{k}$: - item-91 at level 1: formula: \mathcal{L}_{\text{MTP}}^{k} = \ ... um_{i=2 + k}^{T + 1} \log P_i^k [t_i], - item-92 at level 1: text: where $T$ denotes the input sequ ... al training objective for DeepSeek-V3: - item-93 at level 1: formula: \mathcal{L}_{\text{MTP}} = \frac ... k=1}^{D} \mathcal{L}_{\text{MTP}}^{k}. - item-94 at level 1: text: MTP in Inference.Our MTP strateg ... urther improve the generation latency. - item-95 at level 1: section_header: Infrastructures - item-96 at level 1: section_header: Compute Clusters - item-97 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V3 is trained on a clus ... utilized to facilitate communications. - item-98 at level 1: section_header: Training Framework - item-99 at level 1: paragraph: The training of - item-100 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V3 is supported by the ... nd ZeRO-1 Data Parallelism (DP)[zero]. - item-101 at level 1: paragraph: In order to facilitate efficient training of - item-102 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V3, we implement meticu ... t using costly Tensor Parallelism(TP). - item-103 at level 1: section_header: DualPipe and Computation-Communication Overlap - item-104 at level 1: section: group figure - item-105 at level 2: picture - item-105 at level 3: caption: Image: figures/overlap.pdf - item-106 at level 2: text: Overlapping strategy for a pair ... PP communication can be fully hidden. - item-107 at level 1: caption: Image: figures/overlap.pdf - item-108 at level 1: paragraph: For - item-109 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V3, the communication o ... but also reduces the pipeline bubbles. - item-110 at level 1: paragraph: The key idea of DualPipe is to o ... ivide each chunk into four components: - item-111 at level 1: text: attention, all-to-all dispatch, ... ero all-to-all communication overhead. - item-112 at level 1: section: group figure - item-113 at level 2: picture - item-113 at level 3: caption: Image: figures/dualpipe.pdf - item-114 at level 2: text: Example DualPipe scheduling for ... rlapped computation and communication. - item-115 at level 1: caption: Image: figures/dualpipe.pdf - item-116 at level 1: paragraph: In addition, even in more genera ... ibits efficiency advantages. -In Table - item-117 at level 1: text: [tab:dualpipe-bubble], we summar ... as the number of micro-batches grows. - item-118 at level 1: table with [5x4] - item-119 at level 1: text: Comparison of pipeline bubbles a ... verlapped forward and backward chunks. - item-120 at level 1: section_header: Efficient Implementation of Cross-Node All-to-All Communication - item-121 at level 1: paragraph: In order to ensure sufficient co ... om NVLink. -This implies that, although - item-122 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V3 selects only 8 route ... ilize the bandwidths of IB and NVLink. - item-123 at level 1: paragraph: In detail, we employ the warp specialization technique - item-124 at level 1: text: [warp-spec]and partition 20 SMs ... che and the interference to other SMs. - item-125 at level 1: section_header: Extremely Memory Saving with Minimal Overhead - item-126 at level 1: paragraph: In order to reduce the memory fo ... g, we employ the following techniques. - item-127 at level 1: text: Recomputation of RMSNorm and MLA Up-Projection. - item-128 at level 1: paragraph: We recompute all RMSNorm operati ... requirements for storing activations. - item-129 at level 1: text: Exponential Moving Average in CP ... ng additional memory or time overhead. - item-130 at level 1: text: Shared Embedding and Output Head ... urther enhances our memory efficiency. - item-131 at level 1: section_header: FP8 Training - item-132 at level 1: section: group figure - item-133 at level 2: picture - item-133 at level 3: caption: Image: figures/fp8-frameworkv3.pdf - item-134 at level 2: text: The overall mixed precision fram ... ly the Linear operator is illustrated. - item-135 at level 1: caption: Image: figures/fp8-frameworkv3.pdf - item-136 at level 1: paragraph: Inspired by recent advances in low-precision training - item-137 at level 1: text: [fp8lm, llm.int8, 8-bit-numerica ... ceptable range of training randomness. - item-138 at level 1: section_header: Mixed Precision Framework - item-139 at level 1: text: Building upon widely adopted tec ... ustrated in Figure[fig:fp8_framework]. - item-140 at level 1: paragraph: Firstly, in order to accelerate ... n BF16 or FP32. -As depicted in Figure - item-141 at level 1: text: [fig:fp8_framework], all three G ... nificantly reduces memory consumption. - item-142 at level 1: paragraph: Despite the efficiency advantage ... on ensure stable training dynamics for - item-143 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V3. -To further guarante ... ks in our distributed training system. - item-144 at level 1: section: group figure - item-145 at level 2: picture - item-145 at level 3: caption: Image: figures/fp8-128accumulatorv4.pdf - item-146 at level 2: text: (a) We propose a fine-grained qu ... A for the high-precision accumulation. - item-147 at level 1: caption: Image: figures/fp8-128accumulatorv4.pdf - item-148 at level 1: section_header: Improved Precision from Quantization and Multiplication - item-149 at level 1: text: Based on our mixed precision FP8 ... method and the multiplication process. - item-150 at level 1: text: Fine-Grained Quantization. + item-80 at level 1: formula: \mathcal{L}_{\text{MTP}}^{k} = \ ... um_{i=2 + k}^{T + 1} \log P_i^k [t_i], + item-81 at level 1: text: where $T$ denotes the input sequ ... al training objective for DeepSeek-V3: + item-82 at level 1: formula: \mathcal{L}_{\text{MTP}} = \frac ... k=1}^{D} \mathcal{L}_{\text{MTP}}^{k}. + item-83 at level 1: text: MTP in Inference.Our MTP strateg ... urther improve the generation latency. + item-84 at level 1: section_header: Infrastructures + item-85 at level 1: section_header: Compute Clusters + item-86 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V3 is trained on a clus ... utilized to facilitate communications. + item-87 at level 1: section_header: Training Framework + item-88 at level 1: text: The training of DeepSeek-V3 is s ... nd ZeRO-1 Data Parallelism (DP)[zero]. + item-89 at level 1: text: In order to facilitate efficient ... t using costly Tensor Parallelism(TP). + item-90 at level 1: section_header: DualPipe and Computation-Communication Overlap + item-91 at level 1: section: group figure + item-92 at level 2: picture + item-92 at level 3: caption: Image: figures/overlap.pdf + item-93 at level 2: text: Overlapping strategy for a pair ... PP communication can be fully hidden. + item-94 at level 1: caption: Image: figures/overlap.pdf + item-95 at level 1: text: For DeepSeek-V3, the communicati ... but also reduces the pipeline bubbles. + item-96 at level 1: text: The key idea of DualPipe is to o ... ero all-to-all communication overhead. + item-97 at level 1: section: group figure + item-98 at level 2: picture + item-98 at level 3: caption: Image: figures/dualpipe.pdf + item-99 at level 2: text: Example DualPipe scheduling for ... rlapped computation and communication. + item-100 at level 1: caption: Image: figures/dualpipe.pdf + item-101 at level 1: text: In addition, even in more genera ... as the number of micro-batches grows. + item-102 at level 1: table with [5x4] + item-103 at level 1: text: Comparison of pipeline bubbles a ... verlapped forward and backward chunks. + item-104 at level 1: section_header: Efficient Implementation of Cross-Node All-to-All Communication + item-105 at level 1: text: In order to ensure sufficient co ... ilize the bandwidths of IB and NVLink. + item-106 at level 1: text: In detail, we employ the warp sp ... che and the interference to other SMs. + item-107 at level 1: section_header: Extremely Memory Saving with Minimal Overhead + item-108 at level 1: paragraph: In order to reduce the memory fo ... g, we employ the following techniques. + item-109 at level 1: text: Recomputation of RMSNorm and MLA Up-Projection. + item-110 at level 1: paragraph: We recompute all RMSNorm operati ... requirements for storing activations. + item-111 at level 1: text: Exponential Moving Average in CP ... ng additional memory or time overhead. + item-112 at level 1: text: Shared Embedding and Output Head ... urther enhances our memory efficiency. + item-113 at level 1: section_header: FP8 Training + item-114 at level 1: section: group figure + item-115 at level 2: picture + item-115 at level 3: caption: Image: figures/fp8-frameworkv3.pdf + item-116 at level 2: text: The overall mixed precision fram ... ly the Linear operator is illustrated. + item-117 at level 1: caption: Image: figures/fp8-frameworkv3.pdf + item-118 at level 1: text: Inspired by recent advances in l ... ceptable range of training randomness. + item-119 at level 1: section_header: Mixed Precision Framework + item-120 at level 1: text: Building upon widely adopted tec ... ustrated in Figure[fig:fp8_framework]. + item-121 at level 1: text: Firstly, in order to accelerate ... nificantly reduces memory consumption. + item-122 at level 1: text: Despite the efficiency advantage ... ks in our distributed training system. + item-123 at level 1: section: group figure + item-124 at level 2: picture + item-124 at level 3: caption: Image: figures/fp8-128accumulatorv4.pdf + item-125 at level 2: text: (a) We propose a fine-grained qu ... A for the high-precision accumulation. + item-126 at level 1: caption: Image: figures/fp8-128accumulatorv4.pdf + item-127 at level 1: section_header: Improved Precision from Quantization and Multiplication + item-128 at level 1: text: Based on our mixed precision FP8 ... method and the multiplication process. + item-129 at level 1: text: Fine-Grained Quantization. In lo ... the same way as weights quantization. - item-151 at level 1: paragraph: One key modification in our meth ... gy, it can be efficiently implemented. - item-152 at level 1: paragraph: Notably, our fine-grained quanti ... with the idea of microscaling formats - item-153 at level 1: text: [rouhani2023microscaling], while ... ace with the latest GPU architectures. - item-154 at level 1: text: Increasing Accumulation Precisio ... ly constraining the training accuracy. - item-155 at level 1: paragraph: In order to address this issue, ... ion to CUDA Cores for higher precision - item-156 at level 1: text: [Thakkar_CUTLASS_2023]. -The pro ... minimal additional computational cost. - item-157 at level 1: paragraph: It is worth noting that this mod ... res. -Based on our experiments, setting - item-158 at level 1: text: $N_C=128$elements, equivalent to ... hout introducing substantial overhead. - item-159 at level 1: text: Mantissa over Exponents. + item-130 at level 1: text: One key modification in our meth ... gy, it can be efficiently implemented. + item-131 at level 1: text: Notably, our fine-grained quanti ... ace with the latest GPU architectures. + item-132 at level 1: text: Increasing Accumulation Precisio ... ly constraining the training accuracy. + item-133 at level 1: text: In order to address this issue, ... minimal additional computational cost. + item-134 at level 1: text: It is worth noting that this mod ... hout introducing substantial overhead. + item-135 at level 1: text: Mantissa over Exponents. In con ... e impact of the limited dynamic range. - item-160 at level 1: text: Online Quantization. + item-136 at level 1: text: Online Quantization. Delayed qua ... or weight online into the FP8 format. - item-161 at level 1: section_header: Low-Precision Storage and Communication - item-162 at level 1: text: In conjunction with our FP8 trai ... r states into lower-precision formats. - item-163 at level 1: text: Low-Precision Optimizer States. + item-137 at level 1: section_header: Low-Precision Storage and Communication + item-138 at level 1: text: In conjunction with our FP8 trai ... r states into lower-precision formats. + item-139 at level 1: text: Low-Precision Optimizer States. ... merical stability throughout training. - item-164 at level 1: text: Low-Precision Activation. + item-140 at level 1: text: Low-Precision Activation. As ill ... for low-cost high-precision training: - item-165 at level 1: text: (1) Inputs of the Linear after t ... und scaled, i.e., integral power of 2. - item-166 at level 1: text: (2) Inputs of the SwiGLU operato ... efficiency and computational accuracy. - item-167 at level 1: text: Low-Precision Communication. + item-141 at level 1: text: (1) Inputs of the Linear after t ... und scaled, i.e., integral power of 2. + item-142 at level 1: text: (2) Inputs of the SwiGLU operato ... efficiency and computational accuracy. + item-143 at level 1: text: Low-Precision Communication. Com ... itical parts of the training pipeline. - item-168 at level 1: section_header: Inference and Deployment - item-169 at level 1: paragraph: We deploy - item-170 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V3 on the H800 cluster, ... tes the prefilling and decodingstages. - item-171 at level 1: section_header: Prefilling - item-172 at level 1: paragraph: The minimum deployment unit of t ... consists of 4 nodes with 32 GPUs. -The - item-173 at level 1: text: attention part employs 4-way Ten ... allow layers to save TP communication. - item-174 at level 1: paragraph: To achieve load balancing among different experts in the - item-175 at level 1: text: MoE part, we need to ensure that ... host one additional redundant expert. - item-176 at level 1: paragraph: Furthermore, in the prefilling s ... mputational workloads, overlapping the - item-177 at level 1: text: attention and MoE of one micro-b ... th the dispatch and combineof another. - item-178 at level 1: paragraph: Finally, we are exploring a - item-179 at level 1: text: dynamic redundancystrategy for e ... s routing scheme is almost negligible. - item-180 at level 1: section_header: Decoding - item-181 at level 1: paragraph: During decoding, we treat the sh ... nsists of 40 nodes with 320 GPUs. -The - item-182 at level 1: text: attention part employs TP4 with ... and enhance communication efficiency. - item-183 at level 1: paragraph: Similar to prefilling, we period ... one expert. -We are also exploring the - item-184 at level 1: text: dynamic redundancy strategy for ... the dispatchkernel to reduce overhead. - item-185 at level 1: paragraph: Additionally, to enhance through ... he decoding stage. -Unlike prefilling, - item-186 at level 1: text: attention consumes a larger port ... ortion of SMs to dispatch+MoE+combine. - item-187 at level 1: section_header: Suggestions on Hardware Design - item-188 at level 1: paragraph: Based on our implementation of t ... on chip design to AI hardware vendors. - item-189 at level 1: section_header: Communication Hardware - item-190 at level 1: paragraph: In - item-191 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V3, we implement the ov ... cores remain entirely under-utilized. - item-192 at level 1: paragraph: Currently, the SMs primarily per ... ng tasks for all-to-all communication: - item-193 at level 1: list: group list - item-194 at level 2: list_item: Forwarding data between the IB ( ... ithin the same node from a single GPU. - item-195 at level 2: list_item: Transporting data between RDMA b ... ory regions) and input/output buffers. - item-196 at level 2: list_item: Executing reduce operations for all-to-all combine. - item-197 at level 2: list_item: Managing fine-grained memory lay ... perts across the IB and NVLink domain. - item-198 at level 1: paragraph: We aspire to see future vendors ... network co-processor like NVIDIA SHARP - item-199 at level 1: text: [nvsharp]. -Furthermore, to redu ... n requests based on simple primitives. - item-200 at level 1: section_header: Compute Hardware - item-201 at level 1: text: Higher FP8 GEMM Accumulation Pre ... chips need to adopt higher precision. - item-202 at level 1: text: Support for Tile- and Block-Wise ... ced, avoiding frequent data movements. - item-203 at level 1: text: Support for Online Quantization. ... off-chip memory access by roughly 50%. - item-204 at level 1: text: Support for Transposed GEMM Oper ... streamline the quantization workflow. - item-205 at level 1: section_header: Pre-Training - item-206 at level 1: section_header: Data Construction - item-207 at level 1: paragraph: Compared with - item-208 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V2, we optimize the pre ... y and diverse tokens in our tokenizer. - item-209 at level 1: paragraph: In the training process of DeepSeekCoder-V2 - item-210 at level 1: text: [dscodervii], we observe that th ... ramework to structure data as follows: - item-211 at level 1: formula: \begin{align} + item-144 at level 1: section_header: Inference and Deployment + item-145 at level 1: text: We deploy DeepSeek-V3 on the H80 ... tes the prefilling and decodingstages. + item-146 at level 1: section_header: Prefilling + item-147 at level 1: text: The minimum deployment unit of t ... allow layers to save TP communication. + item-148 at level 1: text: To achieve load balancing among ... host one additional redundant expert. + item-149 at level 1: text: Furthermore, in the prefilling s ... th the dispatch and combineof another. + item-150 at level 1: text: Finally, we are exploring a dyna ... s routing scheme is almost negligible. + item-151 at level 1: section_header: Decoding + item-152 at level 1: text: During decoding, we treat the sh ... and enhance communication efficiency. + item-153 at level 1: text: Similar to prefilling, we period ... the dispatchkernel to reduce overhead. + item-154 at level 1: text: Additionally, to enhance through ... ortion of SMs to dispatch+MoE+combine. + item-155 at level 1: section_header: Suggestions on Hardware Design + item-156 at level 1: paragraph: Based on our implementation of t ... on chip design to AI hardware vendors. + item-157 at level 1: section_header: Communication Hardware + item-158 at level 1: text: In DeepSeek-V3, we implement the ... cores remain entirely under-utilized. + item-159 at level 1: text: Currently, the SMs primarily per ... ng tasks for all-to-all communication: + item-160 at level 1: list: group list + item-161 at level 2: list_item: Forwarding data between the IB ( ... ithin the same node from a single GPU. + item-162 at level 2: list_item: Transporting data between RDMA b ... ory regions) and input/output buffers. + item-163 at level 2: list_item: Executing reduce operations for all-to-all combine. + item-164 at level 2: list_item: Managing fine-grained memory lay ... perts across the IB and NVLink domain. + item-165 at level 1: text: We aspire to see future vendors ... n requests based on simple primitives. + item-166 at level 1: section_header: Compute Hardware + item-167 at level 1: text: Higher FP8 GEMM Accumulation Pre ... chips need to adopt higher precision. + item-168 at level 1: text: Support for Tile- and Block-Wise ... ced, avoiding frequent data movements. + item-169 at level 1: text: Support for Online Quantization. ... off-chip memory access by roughly 50%. + item-170 at level 1: text: Support for Transposed GEMM Oper ... streamline the quantization workflow. + item-171 at level 1: section_header: Pre-Training + item-172 at level 1: section_header: Data Construction + item-173 at level 1: text: Compared with DeepSeek-V2, we op ... y and diverse tokens in our tokenizer. + item-174 at level 1: text: In the training process of DeepS ... ramework to structure data as follows: + item-175 at level 1: formula: \begin{align} \texttt{<|fim\_beg ... |eos\_token|>} . \nonumber \end{align} - item-212 at level 1: text: This structure is applied at the ... .1, consistent with the PSM framework. - item-213 at level 1: paragraph: The tokenizer for - item-214 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V3 employs Byte-level B ... special cases and mitigates this bias. - item-215 at level 1: section_header: Hyper-Parameters - item-216 at level 1: text: Model Hyper-Parameters. + item-176 at level 1: text: This structure is applied at the ... .1, consistent with the PSM framework. + item-177 at level 1: text: The tokenizer for DeepSeek-V3 em ... special cases and mitigates this bias. + item-178 at level 1: section_header: Hyper-Parameters + item-179 at level 1: text: Model Hyper-Parameters. We set t ... hich 37B are activated for each token. - item-217 at level 1: text: Training Hyper-Parameters. + item-180 at level 1: text: Training Hyper-Parameters. We em ... to 0.1 for the remaining 4.8T tokens. - item-218 at level 1: section: group figure - item-219 at level 2: picture - item-219 at level 3: caption: Image: figures/needle_in_a_haystack.pdf - item-220 at level 2: text: Evaluation results on the Needle ... all context window lengths up to 128K. - item-221 at level 1: caption: Image: figures/needle_in_a_haystack.pdf - item-222 at level 1: section_header: Long Context Extension - item-223 at level 1: paragraph: We adopt a similar approach to - item-224 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V2[dsvii] to enable lon ... ning rate from the pre-training stage. - item-225 at level 1: paragraph: Through this two-phase extension training, - item-226 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V3 is capable of handli ... oss context window lengths up to 128K. - item-227 at level 1: section_header: Evaluations - item-228 at level 1: section_header: Evaluation Benchmarks - item-229 at level 1: paragraph: The base model of - item-230 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V3 is pretrained on a m ... linedbenchmarks are multilingual ones: - item-231 at level 1: text: Multi-subject multiple-choice da ... u], C-Eval [ceval], and CMMLU [cmmlu]. - item-232 at level 1: text: Language understanding and reaso ... [arc], and BigBench Hard (BBH) [bbh]. - item-233 at level 1: text: Closed-book question answering d ... d NaturalQuestions [naturalquestions]. - item-234 at level 1: text: Reading comprehension datasets i ... ating], and CMRC [cui-etal-2019-span]. - item-235 at level 1: text: Reference disambiguation dataset ... WinoGrande [sakaguchi2019winogrande]. - item-236 at level 1: text: Language modeling datasets include Pile [pile]. - item-237 at level 1: text: Chinese understanding and culture datasets include CCPM [li2021ccpm]. - item-238 at level 1: text: Math datasets include GSM8K[gsm8 ... MGSM [mgsm], and CMath [wei2023cmath]. - item-239 at level 1: text: Code datasets include HumanEval[ ... P[mbpp], and CRUXEval[gu2024cruxeval]. - item-240 at level 1: text: Standardized exams include AGIEv ... udes both English and Chinese subsets. - item-241 at level 1: text: Following our previous work[dsvi ... ong models using different tokenizers. - item-242 at level 1: table with [38x9] - item-243 at level 1: text: Comparison among DeepSeek-V3-Bas ... ks, especially on math and code tasks. - item-244 at level 1: section_header: Evaluation Results - item-245 at level 1: paragraph: In Table - item-246 at level 1: text: [tab:main], we compare the base ... oming the strongest open-source model. - item-247 at level 1: paragraph: From a more detailed perspective, we compare - item-248 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V3-Base with the other ... series, DROP, C-Eval, CMMLU, and CCPM. - item-249 at level 1: paragraph: Due to our efficient architectur ... mprehensive engineering optimizations, - item-250 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V3 achieves extremely h ... han training 72B or 405B dense models. - item-251 at level 1: table with [16x6] - item-252 at level 1: text: Ablation results for the MTP str ... on most of the evaluation benchmarks. - item-253 at level 1: section_header: Discussion - item-254 at level 1: section_header: Ablation Studies for Multi-Token Prediction - item-255 at level 1: paragraph: In Table - item-256 at level 1: text: [tab:ablation_nextn], we show th ... on most of the evaluation benchmarks. - item-257 at level 1: section_header: Ablation Studies for the Auxiliary-Loss-Free Balancing Strategy - item-258 at level 1: paragraph: In Table - item-259 at level 1: text: [tab:ablation_noaux_tc], we show ... on most of the evaluation benchmarks. - item-260 at level 1: table with [16x6] - item-261 at level 1: text: Ablation results for the auxilia ... on most of the evaluation benchmarks. - item-262 at level 1: section_header: Batch-Wise Load Balance VS. Sequence-Wise Load Balance - item-263 at level 1: paragraph: The key distinction between auxi ... ile test set. -As illustrated in Figure - item-264 at level 1: text: [fig:expert_load], we observe th ... t specialization patterns as expected. - item-265 at level 1: paragraph: To further investigate the corre ... eve the same validation loss of 2.080. - item-266 at level 1: paragraph: In addition, although the batch- ... rt deployment, as described in Section - item-267 at level 1: text: [sec:inference_deployment], to overcome it. - item-268 at level 1: section: group figure - item-269 at level 2: picture - item-269 at level 3: caption: Image: figures/relative_expert_load_multi.pdf - item-270 at level 2: text: Expert load of auxiliary-loss-fr ... ppendix\ref{app:detailed_expert_load}. - item-271 at level 1: caption: Image: figures/relative_expert_load_multi.pdf - item-272 at level 1: section_header: Post-Training - item-273 at level 1: section_header: Supervised Fine-Tuning - item-274 at level 1: paragraph: We curate our instruction-tuning ... tailored to its specific requirements. - item-275 at level 1: text: Reasoning Data.For reasoning-rel ... of regularly formatted reasoning data. - item-276 at level 1: paragraph: To establish our methodology, we ... . - item-277 at level 1: paragraph: The system prompt is meticulousl ... ing overall performance strategically. - item-278 at level 1: paragraph: Upon completing the RL training ... ponses that are concise and effective. - item-279 at level 1: text: Non-Reasoning Data.For non-reaso ... accuracy and correctness of the data. - item-280 at level 1: text: SFT Settings. + item-181 at level 1: section: group figure + item-182 at level 2: picture + item-182 at level 3: caption: Image: figures/needle_in_a_haystack.pdf + item-183 at level 2: text: Evaluation results on the Needle ... all context window lengths up to 128K. + item-184 at level 1: caption: Image: figures/needle_in_a_haystack.pdf + item-185 at level 1: section_header: Long Context Extension + item-186 at level 1: text: We adopt a similar approach to D ... ning rate from the pre-training stage. + item-187 at level 1: text: Through this two-phase extension ... oss context window lengths up to 128K. + item-188 at level 1: section_header: Evaluations + item-189 at level 1: section_header: Evaluation Benchmarks + item-190 at level 1: text: The base model of DeepSeek-V3 is ... linedbenchmarks are multilingual ones: + item-191 at level 1: text: Multi-subject multiple-choice da ... u], C-Eval [ceval], and CMMLU [cmmlu]. + item-192 at level 1: text: Language understanding and reaso ... [arc], and BigBench Hard (BBH) [bbh]. + item-193 at level 1: text: Closed-book question answering d ... d NaturalQuestions [naturalquestions]. + item-194 at level 1: text: Reading comprehension datasets i ... ating], and CMRC [cui-etal-2019-span]. + item-195 at level 1: text: Reference disambiguation dataset ... WinoGrande [sakaguchi2019winogrande]. + item-196 at level 1: text: Language modeling datasets include Pile [pile]. + item-197 at level 1: text: Chinese understanding and culture datasets include CCPM [li2021ccpm]. + item-198 at level 1: text: Math datasets include GSM8K[gsm8 ... MGSM [mgsm], and CMath [wei2023cmath]. + item-199 at level 1: text: Code datasets include HumanEval[ ... P[mbpp], and CRUXEval[gu2024cruxeval]. + item-200 at level 1: text: Standardized exams include AGIEv ... udes both English and Chinese subsets. + item-201 at level 1: text: Following our previous work[dsvi ... ong models using different tokenizers. + item-202 at level 1: table with [38x9] + item-203 at level 1: text: Comparison among DeepSeek-V3-Bas ... ks, especially on math and code tasks. + item-204 at level 1: section_header: Evaluation Results + item-205 at level 1: text: In Table[tab:main], we compare t ... oming the strongest open-source model. + item-206 at level 1: text: From a more detailed perspective ... series, DROP, C-Eval, CMMLU, and CCPM. + item-207 at level 1: text: Due to our efficient architectur ... han training 72B or 405B dense models. + item-208 at level 1: table with [16x6] + item-209 at level 1: text: Ablation results for the MTP str ... on most of the evaluation benchmarks. + item-210 at level 1: section_header: Discussion + item-211 at level 1: section_header: Ablation Studies for Multi-Token Prediction + item-212 at level 1: text: In Table[tab:ablation_nextn], we ... on most of the evaluation benchmarks. + item-213 at level 1: section_header: Ablation Studies for the Auxiliary-Loss-Free Balancing Strategy + item-214 at level 1: text: In Table[tab:ablation_noaux_tc], ... on most of the evaluation benchmarks. + item-215 at level 1: table with [16x6] + item-216 at level 1: text: Ablation results for the auxilia ... on most of the evaluation benchmarks. + item-217 at level 1: section_header: Batch-Wise Load Balance VS. Sequence-Wise Load Balance + item-218 at level 1: text: The key distinction between auxi ... t specialization patterns as expected. + item-219 at level 1: paragraph: To further investigate the corre ... eve the same validation loss of 2.080. + item-220 at level 1: text: In addition, although the batch- ... inference_deployment], to overcome it. + item-221 at level 1: section: group figure + item-222 at level 2: picture + item-222 at level 3: caption: Image: figures/relative_expert_load_multi.pdf + item-223 at level 2: text: Expert load of auxiliary-loss-fr ... ppendix\ref{app:detailed_expert_load}. + item-224 at level 1: caption: Image: figures/relative_expert_load_multi.pdf + item-225 at level 1: section_header: Post-Training + item-226 at level 1: section_header: Supervised Fine-Tuning + item-227 at level 1: paragraph: We curate our instruction-tuning ... tailored to its specific requirements. + item-228 at level 1: text: Reasoning Data.For reasoning-rel ... of regularly formatted reasoning data. + item-229 at level 1: paragraph: To establish our methodology, we ... . + item-230 at level 1: paragraph: The system prompt is meticulousl ... ing overall performance strategically. + item-231 at level 1: paragraph: Upon completing the RL training ... ponses that are concise and effective. + item-232 at level 1: text: Non-Reasoning Data.For non-reaso ... accuracy and correctness of the data. + item-233 at level 1: text: SFT Settings. We fine-tune Deep ... emain isolated and mutually invisible. - item-281 at level 1: section_header: Reinforcement Learning - item-282 at level 1: section_header: Reward Model - item-283 at level 1: paragraph: We employ a rule-based Reward Mo ... nd a model-based RM in our RL process. - item-284 at level 1: text: Rule-Based RM.For questions that ... stant to manipulation or exploitation. - item-285 at level 1: text: Model-Based RM. + item-234 at level 1: section_header: Reinforcement Learning + item-235 at level 1: section_header: Reward Model + item-236 at level 1: paragraph: We employ a rule-based Reward Mo ... nd a model-based RM in our RL process. + item-237 at level 1: text: Rule-Based RM.For questions that ... stant to manipulation or exploitation. + item-238 at level 1: text: Model-Based RM. For questions w ... k of reward hacking in specific tasks. - item-286 at level 1: section_header: Group Relative Policy Optimization - item-287 at level 1: paragraph: Similar to - item-288 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V2[dsvii], we adopt Gro ... by maximizing the following objective: - item-289 at level 1: formula: \begin{split} + item-239 at level 1: section_header: Group Relative Policy Optimization + item-240 at level 1: text: Similar to DeepSeek-V2[dsvii], w ... by maximizing the following objective: + item-241 at level 1: formula: \begin{split} \mathcal{J}_{G ... \pi_{ref}\right)\right) , \end{split} - item-290 at level 1: formula: \mathbb{D}_{KL}\left(\pi_{\theta ... ref}(o_i|q)}{\pi_{\theta}(o_i|q)} - 1, - item-291 at level 1: text: where $\epsilon$ and $\beta$ are ... ding to the outputs within each group: - item-292 at level 1: formula: A_i = \frac{r_i - {\operatorname ... ame{std}(\{r_1, r_2, \cdots, r_G\})}}. - item-293 at level 1: paragraph: We incorporate prompts from dive ... where available SFT data are limited. - item-294 at level 1: section_header: Evaluations - item-295 at level 1: section_header: Evaluation Settings - item-296 at level 1: text: Evaluation Benchmarks. + item-242 at level 1: formula: \mathbb{D}_{KL}\left(\pi_{\theta ... ref}(o_i|q)}{\pi_{\theta}(o_i|q)} - 1, + item-243 at level 1: text: where $\epsilon$ and $\beta$ are ... ding to the outputs within each group: + item-244 at level 1: formula: A_i = \frac{r_i - {\operatorname ... ame{std}(\{r_1, r_2, \cdots, r_G\})}}. + item-245 at level 1: paragraph: We incorporate prompts from dive ... where available SFT data are limited. + item-246 at level 1: section_header: Evaluations + item-247 at level 1: section_header: Evaluation Settings + item-248 at level 1: text: Evaluation Benchmarks. Apart fro ... WE-Bench Verified[swe_verified], Aider - item-297 at level 1: footnote: https://aider.chat - item-298 at level 1: text: , LiveCodeBench[livecodebench] ( ... ust 2024 to November 2024), Codeforces - item-299 at level 1: footnote: https://codeforces.com - item-300 at level 1: text: , Chinese National High School Mathematics Olympiad (CNMO 2024) - item-301 at level 1: footnote: https://www.cms.org.cn/Home/comp/comp/cid/12.html - item-302 at level 1: text: , and American Invitational Math ... xamination 2024 (AIME 2024)[AIME2024]. - item-303 at level 1: text: Compared Baselines. + item-249 at level 1: footnote: https://aider.chat + item-250 at level 1: text: , LiveCodeBench[livecodebench] ( ... ust 2024 to November 2024), Codeforces + item-251 at level 1: footnote: https://codeforces.com + item-252 at level 1: text: , Chinese National High School Mathematics Olympiad (CNMO 2024) + item-253 at level 1: footnote: https://www.cms.org.cn/Home/comp/comp/cid/12.html + item-254 at level 1: text: , and American Invitational Math ... xamination 2024 (AIME 2024)[AIME2024]. + item-255 at level 1: text: Compared Baselines. We conduct c ... rformed through their respective APIs. - item-304 at level 1: text: Detailed Evaluation Configuratio ... rompts from the simple-evals framework - item-305 at level 1: footnote: https://github.com/openai/simple-evals - item-306 at level 1: text: . + item-256 at level 1: text: Detailed Evaluation Configuratio ... rompts from the simple-evals framework + item-257 at level 1: footnote: https://github.com/openai/simple-evals + item-258 at level 1: text: . We utilize the Zero-Eval prom ... mum of 8192 tokens for each benchmark. - item-307 at level 1: table with [28x10] - item-308 at level 1: text: Comparison between DeepSeek-V3 a ... against frontier closed-source models. - item-309 at level 1: section_header: Standard Evaluation - item-310 at level 1: paragraph: Table - item-311 at level 1: text: [tab:chat] presents the evaluati ... els like GPT-4o and Claude-3.5-Sonnet. - item-312 at level 1: text: English Benchmarks. + item-259 at level 1: table with [28x10] + item-260 at level 1: text: Comparison between DeepSeek-V3 a ... against frontier closed-source models. + item-261 at level 1: section_header: Standard Evaluation + item-262 at level 1: text: Table[tab:chat] presents the eva ... els like GPT-4o and Claude-3.5-Sonnet. + item-263 at level 1: text: English Benchmarks. MMLU is a wi ... r competitors by a substantial margin. - item-313 at level 1: paragraph: In long-context understanding be ... uch as DROP, LongBench v2, and FRAMES, - item-314 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V3 continues to demonst ... re to user-defined format constraints. - item-315 at level 1: text: Code and Math Benchmarks. + item-264 at level 1: text: In long-context understanding be ... re to user-defined format constraints. + item-265 at level 1: text: Code and Math Benchmarks. Coding ... pabilities in algorithm-focused tasks. - item-316 at level 1: paragraph: On math benchmarks, - item-317 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V3 demonstrates excepti ... hly beneficial for non-o1-like models. - item-318 at level 1: text: Chinese Benchmarks. + item-266 at level 1: text: On math benchmarks, DeepSeek-V3 ... hly beneficial for non-o1-like models. + item-267 at level 1: text: Chinese Benchmarks. Qwen and Dee ... ens that DeepSeek-V3is pre-trained on. - item-319 at level 1: paragraph: On C-Eval, a representative benc ... C (Chinese Winograd Schema Challenge), - item-320 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V3and Qwen2.5-72B exhib ... guage reasoning and educational tasks. - item-321 at level 1: table with [8x3] - item-322 at level 1: text: English open-ended conversation ... gth-controlled win rate as the metric. - item-323 at level 1: section_header: Open-Ended Evaluation - item-324 at level 1: paragraph: In addition to standard benchmar ... udges, with the results shown in Table - item-325 at level 1: text: [tab:open]. -Specifically, we ad ... can accomplish in challenging domains. - item-326 at level 1: paragraph: Similarly, - item-327 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V3 showcases exceptiona ... the effectiveness of its advancements. - item-328 at level 1: section_header: DeepSeek-V3 as a Generative Reward Model - item-329 at level 1: paragraph: We compare the judgment ability of - item-330 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V3 with state-of-the-ar ... d robustness of the alignment process. - item-331 at level 1: table with [9x6] - item-332 at level 1: text: Performances of GPT-4o, Claude-3.5-sonnet and DeepSeek-V3 on RewardBench. - item-333 at level 1: section_header: Discussion - item-334 at level 1: section_header: Distillation from DeepSeek-R1 - item-335 at level 1: paragraph: We ablate the contribution of di ... he expert checkpoints described above. - item-336 at level 1: paragraph: Table - item-337 at level 1: text: [tab:distill] demonstrates the e ... ttings for DeepSeek-V3in distillation. - item-338 at level 1: paragraph: Our research suggests that knowl ... portant direction for future research. - item-339 at level 1: table with [5x5] - item-340 at level 1: text: The contribution of distillation ... re the same as in Table\ref{tab:chat}. - item-341 at level 1: section_header: Self-Rewarding - item-342 at level 1: paragraph: Rewards play a pivotal role in R ... mpractical. -During the development of - item-343 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V3, for these broader c ... del capabilities in general scenarios. - item-344 at level 1: section_header: Multi-Token Prediction Evaluation - item-345 at level 1: paragraph: Instead of predicting just the next single token, - item-346 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V3 predicts the next 2 ... ing 1.8 times TPS (Tokens Per Second). - item-347 at level 1: section_header: Conclusion, Limitations, and Future Directions - item-348 at level 1: paragraph: In this paper, we introduce - item-349 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V3, a large MoE languag ... t length extension, and post-training. - item-350 at level 1: paragraph: While acknowledging its strong p ... -effectiveness, we also recognize that - item-351 at level 1: text: DeepSeek-V3 has some limitations ... development of more advanced hardware. - item-352 at level 1: paragraph: DeepSeek consistently adheres to ... earch across the following directions. - item-353 at level 1: list: group list - item-354 at level 2: list_item: We will consistently study and r ... undaries of its modeling capabilities. - item-355 at level 2: list_item: We will continuously iterate on ... ore comprehensive range of dimensions. - item-356 at level 2: list_item: We will consistently explore and ... ding their reasoning length and depth. - item-357 at level 2: list_item: We will explore more comprehensi ... nd affect our foundational assessment. - item-358 at level 1: text: main - item-359 at level 1: section_header: Appendix - item-360 at level 1: section_header: Contributions and Acknowledgments - item-361 at level 1: text: 2 Research & Engineering + item-268 at level 1: text: On C-Eval, a representative benc ... guage reasoning and educational tasks. + item-269 at level 1: table with [8x3] + item-270 at level 1: text: English open-ended conversation ... gth-controlled win rate as the metric. + item-271 at level 1: section_header: Open-Ended Evaluation + item-272 at level 1: text: In addition to standard benchmar ... can accomplish in challenging domains. + item-273 at level 1: text: Similarly, DeepSeek-V3 showcases ... the effectiveness of its advancements. + item-274 at level 1: section_header: DeepSeek-V3 as a Generative Reward Model + item-275 at level 1: text: We compare the judgment ability ... d robustness of the alignment process. + item-276 at level 1: table with [9x6] + item-277 at level 1: text: Performances of GPT-4o, Claude-3.5-sonnet and DeepSeek-V3 on RewardBench. + item-278 at level 1: section_header: Discussion + item-279 at level 1: section_header: Distillation from DeepSeek-R1 + item-280 at level 1: paragraph: We ablate the contribution of di ... he expert checkpoints described above. + item-281 at level 1: text: Table[tab:distill] demonstrates ... ttings for DeepSeek-V3in distillation. + item-282 at level 1: paragraph: Our research suggests that knowl ... portant direction for future research. + item-283 at level 1: table with [5x5] + item-284 at level 1: text: The contribution of distillation ... re the same as in Table\ref{tab:chat}. + item-285 at level 1: section_header: Self-Rewarding + item-286 at level 1: text: Rewards play a pivotal role in R ... del capabilities in general scenarios. + item-287 at level 1: section_header: Multi-Token Prediction Evaluation + item-288 at level 1: text: Instead of predicting just the n ... ing 1.8 times TPS (Tokens Per Second). + item-289 at level 1: section_header: Conclusion, Limitations, and Future Directions + item-290 at level 1: text: In this paper, we introduce Deep ... t length extension, and post-training. + item-291 at level 1: text: While acknowledging its strong p ... development of more advanced hardware. + item-292 at level 1: text: DeepSeek consistently adheres to ... earch across the following directions. + item-293 at level 1: list: group list + item-294 at level 2: list_item: We will consistently study and r ... undaries of its modeling capabilities. + item-295 at level 2: list_item: We will continuously iterate on ... ore comprehensive range of dimensions. + item-296 at level 2: list_item: We will consistently explore and ... ding their reasoning length and depth. + item-297 at level 2: list_item: We will explore more comprehensi ... nd affect our foundational assessment. + item-298 at level 1: text: main + item-299 at level 1: section_header: Appendix + item-300 at level 1: section_header: Contributions and Acknowledgments + item-301 at level 1: text: 2 Research & Engineering Aixin ... Ziyang Song Ziyi Gao Zizheng Pan - item-362 at level 1: text: Data Annotation + item-302 at level 1: text: Data Annotation Bei Feng Hui ... hen Huang Zhipeng Xu Zhongyu Zhang - item-363 at level 1: text: Business & Compliance + item-303 at level 1: text: Business & Compliance Dongjie ... Yukun Zha Yuting Yan Zhen Zhang - item-364 at level 1: paragraph: Within each role, authors are li ... duals who have departed from our team. - item-365 at level 1: section_header: Ablation Studies for Low-Precision Training - item-366 at level 1: section: group figure - item-367 at level 2: picture - item-367 at level 3: caption: Image: figures/fp8-v.s.-bf16.pdf - item-368 at level 2: text: Loss curves comparison between B ... erage (EMA) with a coefficient of 0.9. - item-369 at level 1: caption: Image: figures/fp8-v.s.-bf16.pdf - item-370 at level 1: section_header: FP8 v.s. BF16 Training - item-371 at level 1: text: We validate our FP8 mixed precis ... fine-grained quantization strategies. - item-372 at level 1: section_header: Discussion About Block-Wise Quantization - item-373 at level 1: text: Although our tile-wise fine-grai ... by a block-wise quantization approach. - item-374 at level 1: section_header: Expert Specialization Patterns o ... ux-Loss-Based and Aux-Loss-Free Models - item-375 at level 1: text: We record the expert load of the ... d in Figure[fig:detailed_expert_load]. - item-376 at level 1: section: group figure - item-377 at level 2: text: [Layers 1-7] - item-378 at level 2: picture - item-378 at level 3: caption: Image: figures/relative_expert_load_multi_1-6.pdf - item-379 at level 1: caption: Image: figures/relative_expert_load_multi_1-6.pdf - item-380 at level 1: section: group figure - item-381 at level 2: text: [Layers 7-13] - item-382 at level 2: picture - item-382 at level 3: caption: Image: figures/relative_expert_load_multi_7-12.pdf - item-383 at level 1: caption: Image: figures/relative_expert_load_multi_7-12.pdf - item-384 at level 1: section: group figure - item-385 at level 2: text: [Layers 13-19] - item-386 at level 2: picture - item-386 at level 3: caption: Image: figures/relative_expert_load_multi_13-18.pdf - item-387 at level 1: caption: Image: figures/relative_expert_load_multi_13-18.pdf - item-388 at level 1: section: group figure - item-389 at level 2: text: [Layers 19-25] - item-390 at level 2: picture - item-390 at level 3: caption: Image: figures/relative_expert_load_multi_19-24.pdf - item-391 at level 1: caption: Image: figures/relative_expert_load_multi_19-24.pdf - item-392 at level 1: section: group figure - item-393 at level 2: text: [Layers 25-27] - item-394 at level 2: picture - item-394 at level 3: caption: Image: figures/relative_expert_load_multi_25-26.pdf - item-395 at level 2: text: Expert load of auxiliary-loss-fr ... he theoretically balanced expert load. - item-396 at level 1: caption: Image: figures/relative_expert_load_multi_25-26.pdf \ No newline at end of file + item-304 at level 1: paragraph: Within each role, authors are li ... duals who have departed from our team. + item-305 at level 1: section_header: Ablation Studies for Low-Precision Training + item-306 at level 1: section: group figure + item-307 at level 2: picture + item-307 at level 3: caption: Image: figures/fp8-v.s.-bf16.pdf + item-308 at level 2: text: Loss curves comparison between B ... erage (EMA) with a coefficient of 0.9. + item-309 at level 1: caption: Image: figures/fp8-v.s.-bf16.pdf + item-310 at level 1: section_header: FP8 v.s. BF16 Training + item-311 at level 1: text: We validate our FP8 mixed precis ... fine-grained quantization strategies. + item-312 at level 1: section_header: Discussion About Block-Wise Quantization + item-313 at level 1: text: Although our tile-wise fine-grai ... by a block-wise quantization approach. + item-314 at level 1: section_header: Expert Specialization Patterns o ... ux-Loss-Based and Aux-Loss-Free Models + item-315 at level 1: text: We record the expert load of the ... d in Figure[fig:detailed_expert_load]. + item-316 at level 1: section: group figure + item-317 at level 2: text: [Layers 1-7] + item-318 at level 2: picture + item-318 at level 3: caption: Image: figures/relative_expert_load_multi_1-6.pdf + item-319 at level 1: caption: Image: figures/relative_expert_load_multi_1-6.pdf + item-320 at level 1: section: group figure + item-321 at level 2: text: [Layers 7-13] + item-322 at level 2: picture + item-322 at level 3: caption: Image: figures/relative_expert_load_multi_7-12.pdf + item-323 at level 1: caption: Image: figures/relative_expert_load_multi_7-12.pdf + item-324 at level 1: section: group figure + item-325 at level 2: text: [Layers 13-19] + item-326 at level 2: picture + item-326 at level 3: caption: Image: figures/relative_expert_load_multi_13-18.pdf + item-327 at level 1: caption: Image: figures/relative_expert_load_multi_13-18.pdf + item-328 at level 1: section: group figure + item-329 at level 2: text: [Layers 19-25] + item-330 at level 2: picture + item-330 at level 3: caption: Image: figures/relative_expert_load_multi_19-24.pdf + item-331 at level 1: caption: Image: figures/relative_expert_load_multi_19-24.pdf + item-332 at level 1: section: group figure + item-333 at level 2: text: [Layers 25-27] + item-334 at level 2: picture + item-334 at level 3: caption: Image: figures/relative_expert_load_multi_25-26.pdf + item-335 at level 2: text: Expert load of auxiliary-loss-fr ... he theoretically balanced expert load. + item-336 at level 1: caption: Image: figures/relative_expert_load_multi_25-26.pdf \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2412.19437_main.tex.json b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2412.19437_main.tex.json index ee55bc50c1..01d3701ad9 100644 --- a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2412.19437_main.tex.json +++ b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2412.19437_main.tex.json @@ -48,6 +48,9 @@ { "$ref": "#/texts/11" }, + { + "$ref": "#/tables/0" + }, { "$ref": "#/texts/12" }, @@ -61,46 +64,43 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/15" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/16" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/tables/0" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/17" + "$ref": "#/groups/1" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/18" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/19" + "$ref": "#/groups/2" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/20" + "$ref": "#/texts/22" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/21" + "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, { - "$ref": "#/groups/1" + "$ref": "#/texts/24" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/24" + "$ref": "#/groups/4" }, { - "$ref": "#/groups/2" + "$ref": "#/texts/27" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/28" }, { - "$ref": "#/groups/3" + "$ref": "#/texts/29" + }, + { + "$ref": "#/groups/5" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/30" }, { - "$ref": "#/groups/4" + "$ref": "#/texts/32" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/33" @@ -115,10 +115,10 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/36" }, { - "$ref": "#/groups/5" + "$ref": "#/texts/37" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/37" + "$ref": "#/texts/38" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/39" @@ -172,10 +172,10 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/55" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/56" + "$ref": "#/groups/6" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/57" + "$ref": "#/texts/56" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/58" @@ -202,10 +202,10 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/65" }, { - "$ref": "#/groups/6" + "$ref": "#/texts/66" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/66" + "$ref": "#/texts/67" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/68" @@ -241,10 +241,10 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/78" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/79" + "$ref": "#/groups/7" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/80" + "$ref": "#/texts/79" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/81" @@ -253,14 +253,17 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/82" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/83" + "$ref": "#/groups/8" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/84" + "$ref": "#/texts/83" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/85" }, + { + "$ref": "#/tables/1" + }, { "$ref": "#/texts/86" }, @@ -280,10 +283,10 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/91" }, { - "$ref": "#/groups/7" + "$ref": "#/texts/92" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/92" + "$ref": "#/texts/93" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/94" @@ -295,13 +298,13 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/96" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/97" + "$ref": "#/groups/9" }, { - "$ref": "#/groups/8" + "$ref": "#/texts/97" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/98" + "$ref": "#/texts/99" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/100" @@ -309,9 +312,6 @@ { "$ref": "#/texts/101" }, - { - "$ref": "#/tables/1" - }, { "$ref": "#/texts/102" }, @@ -319,10 +319,10 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/103" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/104" + "$ref": "#/groups/10" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/105" + "$ref": "#/texts/104" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/106" @@ -352,10 +352,10 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/114" }, { - "$ref": "#/groups/9" + "$ref": "#/texts/115" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/115" + "$ref": "#/texts/116" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/117" @@ -382,10 +382,10 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/124" }, { - "$ref": "#/groups/10" + "$ref": "#/texts/125" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/125" + "$ref": "#/texts/126" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/127" @@ -424,16 +424,7 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/138" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/139" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/140" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/141" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/142" + "$ref": "#/groups/11" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/143" @@ -484,10 +475,10 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/158" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/159" + "$ref": "#/groups/12" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/160" + "$ref": "#/texts/159" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/161" @@ -523,7 +514,16 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/171" }, { - "$ref": "#/groups/11" + "$ref": "#/texts/172" + }, + { + "$ref": "#/texts/173" + }, + { + "$ref": "#/texts/174" + }, + { + "$ref": "#/texts/175" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/176" @@ -531,6 +531,9 @@ { "$ref": "#/texts/177" }, + { + "$ref": "#/tables/2" + }, { "$ref": "#/texts/178" }, @@ -546,6 +549,9 @@ { "$ref": "#/texts/182" }, + { + "$ref": "#/tables/3" + }, { "$ref": "#/texts/183" }, @@ -564,6 +570,9 @@ { "$ref": "#/texts/188" }, + { + "$ref": "#/tables/4" + }, { "$ref": "#/texts/189" }, @@ -580,16 +589,16 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/193" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/194" + "$ref": "#/groups/13" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/195" + "$ref": "#/texts/194" }, { - "$ref": "#/groups/12" + "$ref": "#/texts/196" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/196" + "$ref": "#/texts/197" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/198" @@ -651,9 +660,6 @@ { "$ref": "#/texts/217" }, - { - "$ref": "#/tables/2" - }, { "$ref": "#/texts/218" }, @@ -678,9 +684,6 @@ { "$ref": "#/texts/225" }, - { - "$ref": "#/tables/3" - }, { "$ref": "#/texts/226" }, @@ -693,6 +696,9 @@ { "$ref": "#/texts/229" }, + { + "$ref": "#/tables/5" + }, { "$ref": "#/texts/230" }, @@ -705,9 +711,6 @@ { "$ref": "#/texts/233" }, - { - "$ref": "#/tables/4" - }, { "$ref": "#/texts/234" }, @@ -723,6 +726,9 @@ { "$ref": "#/texts/238" }, + { + "$ref": "#/tables/6" + }, { "$ref": "#/texts/239" }, @@ -730,10 +736,10 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/240" }, { - "$ref": "#/groups/13" + "$ref": "#/texts/241" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/241" + "$ref": "#/texts/242" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/243" @@ -741,6 +747,9 @@ { "$ref": "#/texts/244" }, + { + "$ref": "#/tables/7" + }, { "$ref": "#/texts/245" }, @@ -759,6 +768,9 @@ { "$ref": "#/texts/250" }, + { + "$ref": "#/tables/8" + }, { "$ref": "#/texts/251" }, @@ -787,16 +799,7 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/259" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/260" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/261" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/262" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/263" + "$ref": "#/groups/14" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/264" @@ -823,10 +826,10 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/271" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/272" + "$ref": "#/groups/15" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/273" + "$ref": "#/texts/272" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/274" @@ -840,9 +843,6 @@ { "$ref": "#/texts/277" }, - { - "$ref": "#/tables/5" - }, { "$ref": "#/texts/278" }, @@ -850,334 +850,154 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/279" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/280" + "$ref": "#/groups/16" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/281" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/282" + "$ref": "#/groups/17" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/283" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/284" + "$ref": "#/groups/18" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/285" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/286" + "$ref": "#/groups/19" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/287" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/288" + "$ref": "#/groups/20" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/289" + } + ], + "content_layer": "body", + "name": "_root_", + "label": "unspecified" + }, + "groups": [ + { + "self_ref": "#/groups/0", + "parent": { + "$ref": "#/body" }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/290" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/tables/6" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/291" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/292" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/293" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/294" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/295" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/296" + "children": [ + { + "$ref": "#/pictures/0" + }, + { + "$ref": "#/texts/4" + } + ], + "content_layer": "body", + "name": "figure", + "label": "section" + }, + { + "self_ref": "#/groups/1", + "parent": { + "$ref": "#/body" }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/297" + "children": [ + { + "$ref": "#/texts/16" + }, + { + "$ref": "#/texts/17" + } + ], + "content_layer": "body", + "name": "list", + "label": "list" + }, + { + "self_ref": "#/groups/2", + "parent": { + "$ref": "#/body" }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/298" + "children": [ + { + "$ref": "#/texts/19" + }, + { + "$ref": "#/texts/20" + }, + { + "$ref": "#/texts/21" + } + ], + "content_layer": "body", + "name": "list", + "label": "list" + }, + { + "self_ref": "#/groups/3", + "parent": { + "$ref": "#/body" }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/299" + "children": [ + { + "$ref": "#/texts/23" + } + ], + "content_layer": "body", + "name": "list", + "label": "list" + }, + { + "self_ref": "#/groups/4", + "parent": { + "$ref": "#/body" }, - { - "$ref": "#/tables/7" + "children": [ + { + "$ref": "#/texts/25" + }, + { + "$ref": "#/texts/26" + } + ], + "content_layer": "body", + "name": "list", + "label": "list" + }, + { + "self_ref": "#/groups/5", + "parent": { + "$ref": "#/body" }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/300" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/301" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/302" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/303" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/304" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/305" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/306" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/tables/8" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/307" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/308" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/309" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/310" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/311" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/312" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/313" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/314" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/315" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/316" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/317" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/318" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/319" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/groups/14" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/324" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/325" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/326" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/327" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/328" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/329" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/330" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/331" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/groups/15" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/332" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/334" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/335" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/336" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/337" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/338" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/339" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/groups/16" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/341" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/groups/17" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/343" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/groups/18" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/345" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/groups/19" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/347" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/groups/20" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/349" - } - ], - "content_layer": "body", - "name": "_root_", - "label": "unspecified" - }, - "groups": [ - { - "self_ref": "#/groups/0", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [ - { - "$ref": "#/pictures/0" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/4" - } - ], - "content_layer": "body", - "name": "figure", - "label": "section" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/groups/1", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [ - { - "$ref": "#/texts/22" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/23" - } - ], - "content_layer": "body", - "name": "list", - "label": "list" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/groups/2", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [ - { - "$ref": "#/texts/25" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/26" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/27" - } - ], - "content_layer": "body", - "name": "list", - "label": "list" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/groups/3", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [ - { - "$ref": "#/texts/29" - } - ], - "content_layer": "body", - "name": "list", - "label": "list" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/groups/4", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [ - { - "$ref": "#/texts/31" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/32" - } - ], - "content_layer": "body", - "name": "list", - "label": "list" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/groups/5", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [ - { - "$ref": "#/pictures/1" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/38" - } - ], - "content_layer": "body", - "name": "figure", - "label": "section" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/groups/6", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" + "children": [ + { + "$ref": "#/pictures/1" + }, + { + "$ref": "#/texts/31" + } + ], + "content_layer": "body", + "name": "figure", + "label": "section" + }, + { + "self_ref": "#/groups/6", + "parent": { + "$ref": "#/body" }, "children": [ { "$ref": "#/pictures/2" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/67" + "$ref": "#/texts/57" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -1194,7 +1014,7 @@ "$ref": "#/pictures/3" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/93" + "$ref": "#/texts/80" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -1211,7 +1031,7 @@ "$ref": "#/pictures/4" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/99" + "$ref": "#/texts/84" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -1228,7 +1048,7 @@ "$ref": "#/pictures/5" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/116" + "$ref": "#/texts/98" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -1245,7 +1065,7 @@ "$ref": "#/pictures/6" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/126" + "$ref": "#/texts/105" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -1259,16 +1079,16 @@ }, "children": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/172" + "$ref": "#/texts/139" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/173" + "$ref": "#/texts/140" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/174" + "$ref": "#/texts/141" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/175" + "$ref": "#/texts/142" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -1285,7 +1105,7 @@ "$ref": "#/pictures/7" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/197" + "$ref": "#/texts/160" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -1302,7 +1122,7 @@ "$ref": "#/pictures/8" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/242" + "$ref": "#/texts/195" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -1316,16 +1136,16 @@ }, "children": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/320" + "$ref": "#/texts/260" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/321" + "$ref": "#/texts/261" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/322" + "$ref": "#/texts/262" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/323" + "$ref": "#/texts/263" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -1342,7 +1162,7 @@ "$ref": "#/pictures/9" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/333" + "$ref": "#/texts/273" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -1356,7 +1176,7 @@ }, "children": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/340" + "$ref": "#/texts/280" }, { "$ref": "#/pictures/10" @@ -1373,7 +1193,7 @@ }, "children": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/342" + "$ref": "#/texts/282" }, { "$ref": "#/pictures/11" @@ -1390,7 +1210,7 @@ }, "children": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/344" + "$ref": "#/texts/284" }, { "$ref": "#/pictures/12" @@ -1407,7 +1227,7 @@ }, "children": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/346" + "$ref": "#/texts/286" }, { "$ref": "#/pictures/13" @@ -1424,13 +1244,13 @@ }, "children": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/348" + "$ref": "#/texts/288" }, { "$ref": "#/pictures/14" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/350" + "$ref": "#/texts/290" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -1531,10 +1351,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "In recent years, Large Language Models", - "text": "In recent years, Large Language Models" + "orig": "In recent years, Large Language Models(LLMs) have been undergoing rapid iteration and evolution[gpt4o,claude35sonnet,gemini1_5], progressively diminishing the gap towards Artificial General Intelligence(AGI).\nBeyond closed-source models, open-source models, including DeepSeek series[dsvi,dsvii,dscodervi,dscodervii], LLaMA series[llama,llama2,llama3,llama3_1_405b], Qwen series[qwen,qwen1_5,qwen2_5], and Mistral series[mistral,mixtral8x22b], are also making significant strides, endeavoring to close the gap with their closed-source counterparts.\nTo further push the boundaries of open-source model capabilities, we scale up our models and introduce DeepSeek-V3, a large Mixture-of-Experts(MoE) model with 671B parameters, of which 37B are activated for each token.", + "text": "In recent years, Large Language Models(LLMs) have been undergoing rapid iteration and evolution[gpt4o,claude35sonnet,gemini1_5], progressively diminishing the gap towards Artificial General Intelligence(AGI).\nBeyond closed-source models, open-source models, including DeepSeek series[dsvi,dsvii,dscodervi,dscodervii], LLaMA series[llama,llama2,llama3,llama3_1_405b], Qwen series[qwen,qwen1_5,qwen2_5], and Mistral series[mistral,mixtral8x22b], are also making significant strides, endeavoring to close the gap with their closed-source counterparts.\nTo further push the boundaries of open-source model capabilities, we scale up our models and introduce DeepSeek-V3, a large Mixture-of-Experts(MoE) model with 671B parameters, of which 37B are activated for each token." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/8", @@ -1545,8 +1365,8 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "(LLMs) have been undergoing rapid iteration and evolution[gpt4o,claude35sonnet,gemini1_5], progressively diminishing the gap towards Artificial General Intelligence(AGI).\nBeyond closed-source models, open-source models, including DeepSeek series[dsvi,dsvii,dscodervi,dscodervii], LLaMA series[llama,llama2,llama3,llama3_1_405b], Qwen series[qwen,qwen1_5,qwen2_5], and Mistral series[mistral,mixtral8x22b], are also making significant strides, endeavoring to close the gap with their closed-source counterparts.\nTo further push the boundaries of open-source model capabilities, we scale up our models and introduce DeepSeek-V3, a large Mixture-of-Experts(MoE) model with 671B parameters, of which 37B are activated for each token.", - "text": "(LLMs) have been undergoing rapid iteration and evolution[gpt4o,claude35sonnet,gemini1_5], progressively diminishing the gap towards Artificial General Intelligence(AGI).\nBeyond closed-source models, open-source models, including DeepSeek series[dsvi,dsvii,dscodervi,dscodervii], LLaMA series[llama,llama2,llama3,llama3_1_405b], Qwen series[qwen,qwen1_5,qwen2_5], and Mistral series[mistral,mixtral8x22b], are also making significant strides, endeavoring to close the gap with their closed-source counterparts.\nTo further push the boundaries of open-source model capabilities, we scale up our models and introduce DeepSeek-V3, a large Mixture-of-Experts(MoE) model with 671B parameters, of which 37B are activated for each token." + "orig": "With a forward-looking perspective, we consistently strive for strong model performance and economical costs.\nTherefore, in terms of architecture, DeepSeek-V3 still adopts Multi-head Latent Attention(MLA)[dsvii] for efficient inference and DeepSeekMoE[deepseekmoe] for cost-effective training. \nThese two architectures have been validated in DeepSeek-V2[dsvii], demonstrating their capability to maintain robust model performance while achieving efficient training and inference.\nBeyond the basic architecture, we implement two additional strategies to further enhance the model capabilities. \nFirstly, DeepSeek-V3 pioneers an auxiliary-loss-free strategy[noaux_tc] for load balancing, with the aim of minimizing the adverse impact on model performance that arises from the effort to encourage load balancing.\nSecondly, DeepSeek-V3employs a multi-token prediction training objective, which we have observed to enhance the overall performance on evaluation benchmarks.", + "text": "With a forward-looking perspective, we consistently strive for strong model performance and economical costs.\nTherefore, in terms of architecture, DeepSeek-V3 still adopts Multi-head Latent Attention(MLA)[dsvii] for efficient inference and DeepSeekMoE[deepseekmoe] for cost-effective training. \nThese two architectures have been validated in DeepSeek-V2[dsvii], demonstrating their capability to maintain robust model performance while achieving efficient training and inference.\nBeyond the basic architecture, we implement two additional strategies to further enhance the model capabilities. \nFirstly, DeepSeek-V3 pioneers an auxiliary-loss-free strategy[noaux_tc] for load balancing, with the aim of minimizing the adverse impact on model performance that arises from the effort to encourage load balancing.\nSecondly, DeepSeek-V3employs a multi-token prediction training objective, which we have observed to enhance the overall performance on evaluation benchmarks." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/9", @@ -1555,10 +1375,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "With a forward-looking perspective, we consistently strive for strong model performance and economical costs.\nTherefore, in terms of architecture,", - "text": "With a forward-looking perspective, we consistently strive for strong model performance and economical costs.\nTherefore, in terms of architecture," + "orig": "In order to achieve efficient training, we support the FP8 mixed precision training and implement comprehensive optimizations for the training framework.\nLow-precision training has emerged as a promising solution for efficient training[bf16train, fp16train, fp8lm, llm.int8], its evolution being closely tied to advancements in hardware capabilities[fp8format, hifp8format, microscaling]. \nIn this work, we introduce an FP8 mixed precision training framework and, for the first time, validate its effectiveness on an extremely large-scale model. \nThrough the support for FP8 computation and storage, we achieve both accelerated training and reduced GPU memory usage. \nAs for the training framework, we design the DualPipe algorithm for efficient pipeline parallelism, which has fewer pipeline bubbles and hides most of the communication during training through computation-communication overlap.\nThis overlap ensures that, as the model further scales up, as long as we maintain a constant computation-to-communication ratio, we can still employ fine-grained experts across nodes while achieving a near-zero all-to-all communication overhead.\nIn addition, we also develop efficient cross-node all-to-all communication kernels to fully utilize InfiniBand(IB) and NVLink bandwidths. \nFurthermore, we meticulously optimize the memory footprint, making it possible to train DeepSeek-V3without using costly tensor parallelism.\nCombining these efforts, we achieve high training efficiency.", + "text": "In order to achieve efficient training, we support the FP8 mixed precision training and implement comprehensive optimizations for the training framework.\nLow-precision training has emerged as a promising solution for efficient training[bf16train, fp16train, fp8lm, llm.int8], its evolution being closely tied to advancements in hardware capabilities[fp8format, hifp8format, microscaling]. \nIn this work, we introduce an FP8 mixed precision training framework and, for the first time, validate its effectiveness on an extremely large-scale model. \nThrough the support for FP8 computation and storage, we achieve both accelerated training and reduced GPU memory usage. \nAs for the training framework, we design the DualPipe algorithm for efficient pipeline parallelism, which has fewer pipeline bubbles and hides most of the communication during training through computation-communication overlap.\nThis overlap ensures that, as the model further scales up, as long as we maintain a constant computation-to-communication ratio, we can still employ fine-grained experts across nodes while achieving a near-zero all-to-all communication overhead.\nIn addition, we also develop efficient cross-node all-to-all communication kernels to fully utilize InfiniBand(IB) and NVLink bandwidths. \nFurthermore, we meticulously optimize the memory footprint, making it possible to train DeepSeek-V3without using costly tensor parallelism.\nCombining these efforts, we achieve high training efficiency." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/10", @@ -1569,8 +1389,8 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "DeepSeek-V3 still adopts Multi-head Latent Attention(MLA)[dsvii] for efficient inference and DeepSeekMoE[deepseekmoe] for cost-effective training. \nThese two architectures have been validated in DeepSeek-V2[dsvii], demonstrating their capability to maintain robust model performance while achieving efficient training and inference.\nBeyond the basic architecture, we implement two additional strategies to further enhance the model capabilities. \nFirstly, DeepSeek-V3 pioneers an auxiliary-loss-free strategy[noaux_tc] for load balancing, with the aim of minimizing the adverse impact on model performance that arises from the effort to encourage load balancing.\nSecondly, DeepSeek-V3employs a multi-token prediction training objective, which we have observed to enhance the overall performance on evaluation benchmarks.", - "text": "DeepSeek-V3 still adopts Multi-head Latent Attention(MLA)[dsvii] for efficient inference and DeepSeekMoE[deepseekmoe] for cost-effective training. \nThese two architectures have been validated in DeepSeek-V2[dsvii], demonstrating their capability to maintain robust model performance while achieving efficient training and inference.\nBeyond the basic architecture, we implement two additional strategies to further enhance the model capabilities. \nFirstly, DeepSeek-V3 pioneers an auxiliary-loss-free strategy[noaux_tc] for load balancing, with the aim of minimizing the adverse impact on model performance that arises from the effort to encourage load balancing.\nSecondly, DeepSeek-V3employs a multi-token prediction training objective, which we have observed to enhance the overall performance on evaluation benchmarks." + "orig": "During pre-training, we train DeepSeek-V3 on 14.8T high-quality and diverse tokens. \nThe pre-training process is remarkably stable. \nThroughout the entire training process, we did not encounter any irrecoverable loss spikes or have to roll back.\nNext, we conduct a two-stage context length extension for DeepSeek-V3. In the first stage, the maximum context length is extended to 32K, and in the second stage, it is further extended to 128K. \nFollowing this, we conduct post-training, including Supervised Fine-Tuning(SFT) and Reinforcement Learning(RL) on the base model of DeepSeek-V3, to align it with human preferences and further unlock its potential. \nDuring the post-training stage, we distill the reasoning capability from the DeepSeek-R1 series of models, and meanwhile carefully maintain the balance between model accuracy and generation length.", + "text": "During pre-training, we train DeepSeek-V3 on 14.8T high-quality and diverse tokens. \nThe pre-training process is remarkably stable. \nThroughout the entire training process, we did not encounter any irrecoverable loss spikes or have to roll back.\nNext, we conduct a two-stage context length extension for DeepSeek-V3. In the first stage, the maximum context length is extended to 32K, and in the second stage, it is further extended to 128K. \nFollowing this, we conduct post-training, including Supervised Fine-Tuning(SFT) and Reinforcement Learning(RL) on the base model of DeepSeek-V3, to align it with human preferences and further unlock its potential. \nDuring the post-training stage, we distill the reasoning capability from the DeepSeek-R1 series of models, and meanwhile carefully maintain the balance between model accuracy and generation length." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/11", @@ -1579,73 +1399,13 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "In order to achieve efficient training, we support the FP8 mixed precision training and implement comprehensive optimizations for the training framework.\nLow-precision training has emerged as a promising solution for efficient training", - "text": "In order to achieve efficient training, we support the FP8 mixed precision training and implement comprehensive optimizations for the training framework.\nLow-precision training has emerged as a promising solution for efficient training" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/12", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", - "prov": [], - "orig": "[bf16train, fp16train, fp8lm, llm.int8], its evolution being closely tied to advancements in hardware capabilities[fp8format, hifp8format, microscaling]. \nIn this work, we introduce an FP8 mixed precision training framework and, for the first time, validate its effectiveness on an extremely large-scale model. \nThrough the support for FP8 computation and storage, we achieve both accelerated training and reduced GPU memory usage. \nAs for the training framework, we design the DualPipe algorithm for efficient pipeline parallelism, which has fewer pipeline bubbles and hides most of the communication during training through computation-communication overlap.\nThis overlap ensures that, as the model further scales up, as long as we maintain a constant computation-to-communication ratio, we can still employ fine-grained experts across nodes while achieving a near-zero all-to-all communication overhead.\nIn addition, we also develop efficient cross-node all-to-all communication kernels to fully utilize InfiniBand(IB) and NVLink bandwidths. \nFurthermore, we meticulously optimize the memory footprint, making it possible to train DeepSeek-V3without using costly tensor parallelism.\nCombining these efforts, we achieve high training efficiency.", - "text": "[bf16train, fp16train, fp8lm, llm.int8], its evolution being closely tied to advancements in hardware capabilities[fp8format, hifp8format, microscaling]. \nIn this work, we introduce an FP8 mixed precision training framework and, for the first time, validate its effectiveness on an extremely large-scale model. \nThrough the support for FP8 computation and storage, we achieve both accelerated training and reduced GPU memory usage. \nAs for the training framework, we design the DualPipe algorithm for efficient pipeline parallelism, which has fewer pipeline bubbles and hides most of the communication during training through computation-communication overlap.\nThis overlap ensures that, as the model further scales up, as long as we maintain a constant computation-to-communication ratio, we can still employ fine-grained experts across nodes while achieving a near-zero all-to-all communication overhead.\nIn addition, we also develop efficient cross-node all-to-all communication kernels to fully utilize InfiniBand(IB) and NVLink bandwidths. \nFurthermore, we meticulously optimize the memory footprint, making it possible to train DeepSeek-V3without using costly tensor parallelism.\nCombining these efforts, we achieve high training efficiency." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/13", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "During pre-training, we train", - "text": "During pre-training, we train" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/14", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", - "prov": [], - "orig": "DeepSeek-V3 on 14.8T high-quality and diverse tokens. \nThe pre-training process is remarkably stable. \nThroughout the entire training process, we did not encounter any irrecoverable loss spikes or have to roll back.\nNext, we conduct a two-stage context length extension for DeepSeek-V3. In the first stage, the maximum context length is extended to 32K, and in the second stage, it is further extended to 128K. \nFollowing this, we conduct post-training, including Supervised Fine-Tuning(SFT) and Reinforcement Learning(RL) on the base model of DeepSeek-V3, to align it with human preferences and further unlock its potential. \nDuring the post-training stage, we distill the reasoning capability from the DeepSeek-R1 series of models, and meanwhile carefully maintain the balance between model accuracy and generation length.", - "text": "DeepSeek-V3 on 14.8T high-quality and diverse tokens. \nThe pre-training process is remarkably stable. \nThroughout the entire training process, we did not encounter any irrecoverable loss spikes or have to roll back.\nNext, we conduct a two-stage context length extension for DeepSeek-V3. In the first stage, the maximum context length is extended to 32K, and in the second stage, it is further extended to 128K. \nFollowing this, we conduct post-training, including Supervised Fine-Tuning(SFT) and Reinforcement Learning(RL) on the base model of DeepSeek-V3, to align it with human preferences and further unlock its potential. \nDuring the post-training stage, we distill the reasoning capability from the DeepSeek-R1 series of models, and meanwhile carefully maintain the balance between model accuracy and generation length." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/15", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "We evaluate", - "text": "We evaluate" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/16", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "DeepSeek-V3 on a comprehensive array of benchmarks. \nDespite its economical training costs, comprehensive evaluations reveal that DeepSeek-V3-Base has emerged as the strongest open-source base model currently available, especially in code and math. \nIts chat version also outperforms other open-source models and achieves performance comparable to leading closed-source models, including GPT-4o and Claude-3.5-Sonnet, on a series of standard and open-ended benchmarks.", - "text": "DeepSeek-V3 on a comprehensive array of benchmarks. \nDespite its economical training costs, comprehensive evaluations reveal that DeepSeek-V3-Base has emerged as the strongest open-source base model currently available, especially in code and math. \nIts chat version also outperforms other open-source models and achieves performance comparable to leading closed-source models, including GPT-4o and Claude-3.5-Sonnet, on a series of standard and open-ended benchmarks." + "orig": "We evaluate DeepSeek-V3 on a comprehensive array of benchmarks. \nDespite its economical training costs, comprehensive evaluations reveal that DeepSeek-V3-Base has emerged as the strongest open-source base model currently available, especially in code and math. \nIts chat version also outperforms other open-source models and achieves performance comparable to leading closed-source models, including GPT-4o and Claude-3.5-Sonnet, on a series of standard and open-ended benchmarks.", + "text": "We evaluate DeepSeek-V3 on a comprehensive array of benchmarks. \nDespite its economical training costs, comprehensive evaluations reveal that DeepSeek-V3-Base has emerged as the strongest open-source base model currently available, especially in code and math. \nIts chat version also outperforms other open-source models and achieves performance comparable to leading closed-source models, including GPT-4o and Claude-3.5-Sonnet, on a series of standard and open-ended benchmarks." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/17", + "self_ref": "#/texts/12", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1657,19 +1417,7 @@ "text": "Training costs of DeepSeek-V3, assuming the rental price of H800 is $2 per GPU hour." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/18", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Lastly, we emphasize again the economical training costs of", - "text": "Lastly, we emphasize again the economical training costs of" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/19", + "self_ref": "#/texts/13", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1677,11 +1425,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "DeepSeek-V3, summarized in Table[tab:cost], achieved through our optimized co-design of algorithms, frameworks, and hardware. \nDuring the pre-training stage, training DeepSeek-V3 on each trillion tokens requires only 180K H800 GPU hours, i.e., 3.7 days on our cluster with 2048 H800 GPUs. \nConsequently, our pre-training stage is completed in less than two months and costs 2664K GPU hours.\nCombined with 119K GPU hours for the context length extension and 5K GPU hours for post-training, DeepSeek-V3 costs only 2.788M GPU hours for its full training. \nAssuming the rental price of the H800 GPU is $2 per GPU hour, our total training costs amount to only $5.576M.\nNote that the aforementioned costs include only the official training of DeepSeek-V3, excluding the costs associated with prior research and ablation experiments on architectures, algorithms, or data.", - "text": "DeepSeek-V3, summarized in Table[tab:cost], achieved through our optimized co-design of algorithms, frameworks, and hardware. \nDuring the pre-training stage, training DeepSeek-V3 on each trillion tokens requires only 180K H800 GPU hours, i.e., 3.7 days on our cluster with 2048 H800 GPUs. \nConsequently, our pre-training stage is completed in less than two months and costs 2664K GPU hours.\nCombined with 119K GPU hours for the context length extension and 5K GPU hours for post-training, DeepSeek-V3 costs only 2.788M GPU hours for its full training. \nAssuming the rental price of the H800 GPU is $2 per GPU hour, our total training costs amount to only $5.576M.\nNote that the aforementioned costs include only the official training of DeepSeek-V3, excluding the costs associated with prior research and ablation experiments on architectures, algorithms, or data." + "orig": "Lastly, we emphasize again the economical training costs of DeepSeek-V3, summarized in Table[tab:cost], achieved through our optimized co-design of algorithms, frameworks, and hardware. \nDuring the pre-training stage, training DeepSeek-V3 on each trillion tokens requires only 180K H800 GPU hours, i.e., 3.7 days on our cluster with 2048 H800 GPUs. \nConsequently, our pre-training stage is completed in less than two months and costs 2664K GPU hours.\nCombined with 119K GPU hours for the context length extension and 5K GPU hours for post-training, DeepSeek-V3 costs only 2.788M GPU hours for its full training. \nAssuming the rental price of the H800 GPU is $2 per GPU hour, our total training costs amount to only $5.576M.\nNote that the aforementioned costs include only the official training of DeepSeek-V3, excluding the costs associated with prior research and ablation experiments on architectures, algorithms, or data.", + "text": "Lastly, we emphasize again the economical training costs of DeepSeek-V3, summarized in Table[tab:cost], achieved through our optimized co-design of algorithms, frameworks, and hardware. \nDuring the pre-training stage, training DeepSeek-V3 on each trillion tokens requires only 180K H800 GPU hours, i.e., 3.7 days on our cluster with 2048 H800 GPUs. \nConsequently, our pre-training stage is completed in less than two months and costs 2664K GPU hours.\nCombined with 119K GPU hours for the context length extension and 5K GPU hours for post-training, DeepSeek-V3 costs only 2.788M GPU hours for its full training. \nAssuming the rental price of the H800 GPU is $2 per GPU hour, our total training costs amount to only $5.576M.\nNote that the aforementioned costs include only the official training of DeepSeek-V3, excluding the costs associated with prior research and ablation experiments on architectures, algorithms, or data." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/20", + "self_ref": "#/texts/14", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1693,7 +1441,7 @@ "text": "Our main contribution includes:" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/21", + "self_ref": "#/texts/15", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1705,7 +1453,7 @@ "text": "Architecture: Innovative Load Balancing Strategy and Training Objective" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/22", + "self_ref": "#/texts/16", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/1" }, @@ -1719,7 +1467,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/23", + "self_ref": "#/texts/17", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/1" }, @@ -1733,7 +1481,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/24", + "self_ref": "#/texts/18", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1745,7 +1493,7 @@ "text": "Pre-Training: Towards Ultimate Training Efficiency" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/25", + "self_ref": "#/texts/19", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/2" }, @@ -1759,7 +1507,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/26", + "self_ref": "#/texts/20", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/2" }, @@ -1773,7 +1521,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/27", + "self_ref": "#/texts/21", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/2" }, @@ -1787,7 +1535,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/28", + "self_ref": "#/texts/22", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1799,7 +1547,7 @@ "text": "Post-Training: Knowledge Distillation from DeepSeek-R1" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/29", + "self_ref": "#/texts/23", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -1813,7 +1561,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/30", + "self_ref": "#/texts/24", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1825,7 +1573,7 @@ "text": "Summary of Core Evaluation Results" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/31", + "self_ref": "#/texts/25", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/4" }, @@ -1839,7 +1587,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/32", + "self_ref": "#/texts/26", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/4" }, @@ -1853,7 +1601,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/33", + "self_ref": "#/texts/27", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1865,7 +1613,7 @@ "text": "In the remainder of this paper, we first present a detailed exposition of our DeepSeek-V3 model architecture (Section[sec:arch]). \nSubsequently, we introduce our infrastructures, encompassing our compute clusters, the training framework, the support for FP8 training, the inference deployment strategy, and our suggestions on future hardware design.\nNext, we describe our pre-training process, including the construction of training data, hyper-parameter settings, long-context extension techniques, the associated evaluations, as well as some discussions (Section[sec:pre-training]). \nThereafter, we discuss our efforts on post-training, which include Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT), Reinforcement Learning (RL), the corresponding evaluations, and discussions (Section[sec:alignment]). \nLastly, we conclude this work, discuss existing limitations of DeepSeek-V3, and propose potential directions for future research (Section[sec:conclusion])." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/34", + "self_ref": "#/texts/28", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1878,19 +1626,7 @@ "level": 1 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/35", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "We first introduce the basic architecture of", - "text": "We first introduce the basic architecture of" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/36", + "self_ref": "#/texts/29", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1898,11 +1634,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "DeepSeek-V3, featured by Multi-head Latent Attention(MLA)[dsvii] for efficient inference and DeepSeekMoE[deepseekmoe] for economical training.\nThen, we present a Multi-Token Prediction (MTP) training objective, which we have observed to enhance the overall performance on evaluation benchmarks.\nFor other minor details not explicitly mentioned, DeepSeek-V3 adheres to the settings of DeepSeek-V2[dsvii].", - "text": "DeepSeek-V3, featured by Multi-head Latent Attention(MLA)[dsvii] for efficient inference and DeepSeekMoE[deepseekmoe] for economical training.\nThen, we present a Multi-Token Prediction (MTP) training objective, which we have observed to enhance the overall performance on evaluation benchmarks.\nFor other minor details not explicitly mentioned, DeepSeek-V3 adheres to the settings of DeepSeek-V2[dsvii]." + "orig": "We first introduce the basic architecture of DeepSeek-V3, featured by Multi-head Latent Attention(MLA)[dsvii] for efficient inference and DeepSeekMoE[deepseekmoe] for economical training.\nThen, we present a Multi-Token Prediction (MTP) training objective, which we have observed to enhance the overall performance on evaluation benchmarks.\nFor other minor details not explicitly mentioned, DeepSeek-V3 adheres to the settings of DeepSeek-V2[dsvii].", + "text": "We first introduce the basic architecture of DeepSeek-V3, featured by Multi-head Latent Attention(MLA)[dsvii] for efficient inference and DeepSeekMoE[deepseekmoe] for economical training.\nThen, we present a Multi-Token Prediction (MTP) training objective, which we have observed to enhance the overall performance on evaluation benchmarks.\nFor other minor details not explicitly mentioned, DeepSeek-V3 adheres to the settings of DeepSeek-V2[dsvii]." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/37", + "self_ref": "#/texts/30", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1914,7 +1650,7 @@ "text": "Image: figures/basic_arch.pdf" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/38", + "self_ref": "#/texts/31", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/5" }, @@ -1926,7 +1662,7 @@ "text": "Illustration of the basic architecture of DeepSeek-V3. \n Following DeepSeek-V2, we adopt MLA and DeepSeekMoE for efficient inference and economical training." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/39", + "self_ref": "#/texts/32", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1939,19 +1675,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/40", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "The basic architecture of", - "text": "The basic architecture of" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/41", + "self_ref": "#/texts/33", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1959,11 +1683,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "DeepSeek-V3 is still within the Transformer[transformer] framework. \nFor efficient inference and economical training, DeepSeek-V3 also adopts MLA and DeepSeekMoE, which have been thoroughly validated by DeepSeek-V2. \nCompared with DeepSeek-V2, an exception is that we additionally introduce an auxiliary-loss-free load balancing strategy[noaux_tc] for DeepSeekMoE to mitigate the performance degradation induced by the effort to ensure load balance. \nFigure[fig:basic_arch] illustrates the basic architecture of DeepSeek-V3, and we will briefly review the details of MLA and DeepSeekMoE in this section.", - "text": "DeepSeek-V3 is still within the Transformer[transformer] framework. \nFor efficient inference and economical training, DeepSeek-V3 also adopts MLA and DeepSeekMoE, which have been thoroughly validated by DeepSeek-V2. \nCompared with DeepSeek-V2, an exception is that we additionally introduce an auxiliary-loss-free load balancing strategy[noaux_tc] for DeepSeekMoE to mitigate the performance degradation induced by the effort to ensure load balance. \nFigure[fig:basic_arch] illustrates the basic architecture of DeepSeek-V3, and we will briefly review the details of MLA and DeepSeekMoE in this section." + "orig": "The basic architecture of DeepSeek-V3 is still within the Transformer[transformer] framework. \nFor efficient inference and economical training, DeepSeek-V3 also adopts MLA and DeepSeekMoE, which have been thoroughly validated by DeepSeek-V2. \nCompared with DeepSeek-V2, an exception is that we additionally introduce an auxiliary-loss-free load balancing strategy[noaux_tc] for DeepSeekMoE to mitigate the performance degradation induced by the effort to ensure load balance. \nFigure[fig:basic_arch] illustrates the basic architecture of DeepSeek-V3, and we will briefly review the details of MLA and DeepSeekMoE in this section.", + "text": "The basic architecture of DeepSeek-V3 is still within the Transformer[transformer] framework. \nFor efficient inference and economical training, DeepSeek-V3 also adopts MLA and DeepSeekMoE, which have been thoroughly validated by DeepSeek-V2. \nCompared with DeepSeek-V2, an exception is that we additionally introduce an auxiliary-loss-free load balancing strategy[noaux_tc] for DeepSeekMoE to mitigate the performance degradation induced by the effort to ensure load balance. \nFigure[fig:basic_arch] illustrates the basic architecture of DeepSeek-V3, and we will briefly review the details of MLA and DeepSeekMoE in this section." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/42", + "self_ref": "#/texts/34", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1976,19 +1700,7 @@ "level": 3 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/43", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "For attention,", - "text": "For attention," - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/44", + "self_ref": "#/texts/35", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1996,11 +1708,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "DeepSeek-V3 adopts the MLA architecture. \nLet $d$ denote the embedding dimension, $n_h$ denote the number of attention heads, $d_h$ denote the dimension per head, and $\\mathbf{h}_{t} \\in \\mathbb{R}^{d}$ denote the attention input for the $t$-th token at a given attention layer.\nThe core of MLA is the low-rank joint compression for attention keys and values to reduce Key-Value (KV) cache during inference:", - "text": "DeepSeek-V3 adopts the MLA architecture. \nLet $d$ denote the embedding dimension, $n_h$ denote the number of attention heads, $d_h$ denote the dimension per head, and $\\mathbf{h}_{t} \\in \\mathbb{R}^{d}$ denote the attention input for the $t$-th token at a given attention layer.\nThe core of MLA is the low-rank joint compression for attention keys and values to reduce Key-Value (KV) cache during inference:" + "orig": "For attention, DeepSeek-V3 adopts the MLA architecture. \nLet $d$ denote the embedding dimension, $n_h$ denote the number of attention heads, $d_h$ denote the dimension per head, and $\\mathbf{h}_{t} \\in \\mathbb{R}^{d}$ denote the attention input for the $t$-th token at a given attention layer.\nThe core of MLA is the low-rank joint compression for attention keys and values to reduce Key-Value (KV) cache during inference:", + "text": "For attention, DeepSeek-V3 adopts the MLA architecture. \nLet $d$ denote the embedding dimension, $n_h$ denote the number of attention heads, $d_h$ denote the dimension per head, and $\\mathbf{h}_{t} \\in \\mathbb{R}^{d}$ denote the attention input for the $t$-th token at a given attention layer.\nThe core of MLA is the low-rank joint compression for attention keys and values to reduce Key-Value (KV) cache during inference:" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/45", + "self_ref": "#/texts/36", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2012,7 +1724,7 @@ "text": "\\begin{align}\n \\boxed{\\color{blue} \\mathbf{c}_{t}^{KV}} &= W^{DKV} \\mathbf{h}_{t}, \\\\\n [\\mathbf{k}_{t, 1}^{C};\\mathbf{k}_{t, 2}^{C};...;\\mathbf{k}_{t, n_{h}}^{C}] = \\mathbf{k}_{t}^{C} &= W^{UK} \\mathbf{c}_{t}^{KV}, \\\\\n \\boxed{\\color{blue}\\mathbf{k}_{t}^{R}} &= \\operatorname{RoPE}({W^{KR}} \\mathbf{h}_{t}), \\\\\n \\mathbf{k}_{t, i} &= [\\mathbf{k}_{t, i}^{C}; \\mathbf{k}_{t}^{R}], \\\\\n [\\mathbf{v}_{t, 1}^{C};\\mathbf{v}_{t, 2}^{C};...;\\mathbf{v}_{t, n_{h}}^{C}] = \\mathbf{v}_{t}^{C} &= W^{UV} \\mathbf{c}_{t}^{KV}, \n\\end{align}" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/46", + "self_ref": "#/texts/37", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2024,19 +1736,19 @@ "text": "where $\\mathbf{c}_{t}^{KV} \\in \\mathbb{R}^{d_c}$ is the compressed latent vector for keys and values; \n$d_c (\\ll d_h n_h)$ indicates the KV compression dimension;\n$W^{DKV} \\in \\mathbb{R}^{d_c \\times d}$ denotes the down-projection matrix;\n$W^{UK},W^{UV} \\in \\mathbb{R}^{d_h n_h \\times d_c}$ are the up-projection matrices for keys and values, respectively;\n$W^{KR} \\in \\mathbb{R}^{d_h^R \\times d}$ is the matrix used to produce the decoupled key that carries Rotary Positional Embedding (RoPE)[su2024roformer]; \n$\\operatorname{RoPE}(\\cdot)$ denotes the operation that applies RoPE matrices; \nand $[\\cdot;\\cdot]$ denotes concatenation.\nNote that for MLA, only the blue-boxed vectors (i.e., $\\color{blue} \\mathbf{c}_{t}^{KV}$ and $\\color{blue}\\mathbf{k}_{t}^{R}$) need to be cached during generation, which results in significantly reduced KV cache while maintaining performance comparable to standard Multi-Head Attention (MHA)[transformer]." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/47", + "self_ref": "#/texts/38", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], "orig": "For the attention queries, we also perform a low-rank compression, which can reduce the activation memory during training:", "text": "For the attention queries, we also perform a low-rank compression, which can reduce the activation memory during training:" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/48", + "self_ref": "#/texts/39", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2048,7 +1760,7 @@ "text": "\\begin{align}\n \\mathbf{c}_{t}^{Q} &= W^{DQ} \\mathbf{h}_{t}, \\\\\n [\\mathbf{q}_{t, 1}^{C};\\mathbf{q}_{t, 2}^{C};...;\\mathbf{q}_{t, n_{h}}^{C}] = \\mathbf{q}_{t}^{C} &= W^{UQ} \\mathbf{c}_{t}^{Q}, \\\\\n [\\mathbf{q}_{t, 1}^{R};\\mathbf{q}_{t, 2}^{R};...;\\mathbf{q}_{t, n_{h}}^{R}] = \\mathbf{q}_{t}^{R} &= \\operatorname{RoPE}({W^{QR}} \\mathbf{c}_{t}^{Q}), \\\\\n \\mathbf{q}_{t, i} &= [\\mathbf{q}_{t, i}^{C}; \\mathbf{q}_{t, i}^{R}],\n\\end{align}" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/49", + "self_ref": "#/texts/40", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2060,19 +1772,7 @@ "text": "where $\\mathbf{c}_{t}^{Q} \\in \\mathbb{R}^{d_c^{\\prime}}$ is the compressed latent vector for queries; \n$d_c^{\\prime} (\\ll d_h n_h)$ denotes the query compression dimension; \n$W^{DQ} \\in \\mathbb{R}^{d_c^{\\prime} \\times d}, W^{UQ} \\in \\mathbb{R}^{d_h n_h \\times d_c^{\\prime}}$ are the down-projection and up-projection matrices for queries, respectively;\nand $W^{QR} \\in \\mathbb{R}^{d_h^R n_h \\times d_c^{\\prime}}$is the matrix to produce the decoupled queries that carry RoPE." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/50", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Ultimately, the attention queries (", - "text": "Ultimately, the attention queries (" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/51", + "self_ref": "#/texts/41", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2080,11 +1780,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "$\\mathbf{q}_{t, i}$), keys ($\\mathbf{k}_{j, i}$), and values ($\\mathbf{v}_{j, i}^{C}$) are combined to yield the final attention output $\\mathbf{u}_{t}$:", - "text": "$\\mathbf{q}_{t, i}$), keys ($\\mathbf{k}_{j, i}$), and values ($\\mathbf{v}_{j, i}^{C}$) are combined to yield the final attention output $\\mathbf{u}_{t}$:" + "orig": "Ultimately, the attention queries ($\\mathbf{q}_{t, i}$), keys ($\\mathbf{k}_{j, i}$), and values ($\\mathbf{v}_{j, i}^{C}$) are combined to yield the final attention output $\\mathbf{u}_{t}$:", + "text": "Ultimately, the attention queries ($\\mathbf{q}_{t, i}$), keys ($\\mathbf{k}_{j, i}$), and values ($\\mathbf{v}_{j, i}^{C}$) are combined to yield the final attention output $\\mathbf{u}_{t}$:" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/52", + "self_ref": "#/texts/42", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2096,7 +1796,7 @@ "text": "\\begin{align}\n \\mathbf{o}_{t, i} &= \\sum_{j=1}^{t} \\operatorname{Softmax}_j(\\frac{\\mathbf{q}_{t, i}^T \\mathbf{k}_{j, i}}{\\sqrt{d_{h} + d_{h}^{R}}}) \\mathbf{v}_{j, i}^{C}, \\\\\n \\mathbf{u}_{t} &= W^{O} [\\mathbf{o}_{t, 1};\\mathbf{o}_{t, 2};...;\\mathbf{o}_{t, n_{h}}],\n\\end{align}" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/53", + "self_ref": "#/texts/43", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2108,7 +1808,7 @@ "text": "where $W^{O} \\in \\mathbb{R}^{d \\times d_h n_h}$denotes the output projection matrix." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/54", + "self_ref": "#/texts/44", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2121,7 +1821,7 @@ "level": 3 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/55", + "self_ref": "#/texts/45", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2133,7 +1833,7 @@ "text": "Basic Architecture of DeepSeekMoE.\nFor Feed-Forward Networks(FFNs), DeepSeek-V3 employs the DeepSeekMoE architecture[deepseekmoe]. \nCompared with traditional MoE architectures like GShard[gshard], DeepSeekMoE uses finer-grained experts and isolates some experts as shared ones.\nLet $\\mathbf{u}_{t}$ denote the FFN input of the $t$-th token, we compute the FFN output $\\mathbf{h}_{t}^{\\prime}$ as follows:" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/56", + "self_ref": "#/texts/46", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2145,7 +1845,7 @@ "text": "\\begin{align}\n \\mathbf{h}_{t}^{\\prime} & = \\mathbf{u}_{t} + \\sum_{i=1}^{N_{s}} {\\operatorname{FFN}^{(s)}_{i}\\left( \\mathbf{u}_{t} \\right)} + \\sum_{i=1}^{N_r} {g_{i,t} \\operatorname{FFN}^{(r)}_{i}\\left( \\mathbf{u}_{t} \\right)}, \\\\\n g_{i,t} & = \\frac{g^{\\prime}_{i,t}}{\\sum_{j=1}^{N_r} g^{\\prime}_{j,t}}, \\\\\n g^{\\prime}_{i,t} & = \\begin{cases} \n s_{i,t}, & s_{i,t} \\in \\operatorname{Topk} (\\{ s_{j, t} | 1 \\leq j \\leq N_r \\}, K_{r}), \\\\\n 0, & \\text{otherwise}, \n \\end{cases} \\\\\n s_{i,t} & = \\operatorname{Sigmoid} \\left( {\\mathbf{u}_{t}}^{T} \\mathbf{e}_{i} \\right),\n\\end{align}" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/57", + "self_ref": "#/texts/47", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2157,7 +1857,7 @@ "text": "where $N_{s}$ and $N_r$ denote the numbers of shared experts and routed experts, respectively; \n$\\operatorname{FFN}^{(s)}_{i}(\\cdot)$ and $\\operatorname{FFN}^{(r)}_{i}(\\cdot)$ denote the $i$-th shared expert and the $i$-th routed expert, respectively; \n$K_{r}$ denotes the number of activated routed experts; \n$g_{i,t}$ is the gating value for the $i$-th expert; \n$s_{i,t}$ is the token-to-expert affinity; \n$\\mathbf{e}_{i}$ is the centroid vector of the $i$-th routed expert; \nand $\\operatorname{Topk}(\\cdot, K)$ denotes the set comprising $K$ highest scores among the affinity scores calculated for the $t$-th token and all routed experts.\nSlightly different from DeepSeek-V2, DeepSeek-V3uses the sigmoid function to compute the affinity scores, and applies a normalization among all selected affinity scores to produce the gating values." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/58", + "self_ref": "#/texts/48", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2169,7 +1869,7 @@ "text": "Auxiliary-Loss-Free Load Balancing.\nFor MoE models, an unbalanced expert load will lead to routing collapse[moe] and diminish computational efficiency in scenarios with expert parallelism. \nConventional solutions usually rely on the auxiliary loss[switch,gshard] to avoid unbalanced load. \nHowever, too large an auxiliary loss will impair the model performance[noaux_tc]. \nTo achieve a better trade-off between load balance and model performance, we pioneer an auxiliary-loss-free load balancing strategy[noaux_tc] to ensure load balance. \nTo be specific, we introduce a bias term $b_i$ for each expert and add it to the corresponding affinity scores $s_{i,t}$ to determine the top-K routing:" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/59", + "self_ref": "#/texts/49", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2181,7 +1881,7 @@ "text": "\\begin{align}\n g^{\\prime}_{i,t} & = \\begin{cases} \n s_{i,t}, & s_{i,t} + b_i \\in \\operatorname{Topk} (\\{ s_{j, t} + b_j | 1 \\leq j \\leq N_r \\}, K_{r}), \\\\\n 0, & \\text{otherwise}.\n \\end{cases}\n\\end{align}" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/60", + "self_ref": "#/texts/50", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2193,7 +1893,7 @@ "text": "Note that the bias term is only used for routing.\nThe gating value, which will be multiplied with the FFN output, is still derived from the original affinity score $s_{i,t}$.\nDuring training, we keep monitoring the expert load on the whole batch of each training step.\nAt the end of each step, we will decrease the bias term by $\\gamma$ if its corresponding expert is overloaded, and increase it by $\\gamma$ if its corresponding expert is underloaded, where $\\gamma$ is a hyper-parameter called bias update speed.\nThrough the dynamic adjustment, DeepSeek-V3keeps balanced expert load during training, and achieves better performance than models that encourage load balance through pure auxiliary losses." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/61", + "self_ref": "#/texts/51", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2205,7 +1905,7 @@ "text": "Complementary Sequence-Wise Auxiliary Loss.\nAlthough DeepSeek-V3 mainly relies on the auxiliary-loss-free strategy for load balance, to prevent extreme imbalance within any single sequence, we also employ a complementary sequence-wise balance loss:" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/62", + "self_ref": "#/texts/52", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2217,7 +1917,7 @@ "text": "\\begin{align}\n \\mathcal{L}_{\\mathrm{Bal}} & = \\alpha \\sum_{i=1}^{N_r}{f_i P_i}, \\\\\n % f_i = \\frac{N_r}{K_r T} \\sum_{t=1}^{T} \\mathds{1}( \\text{Expert $i$ } & \\text{belongs to the Top-$K_r$ set for Token $t$} ), \\\\\n f_i = \\frac{N_r}{K_r T} \\sum_{t=1}^{T} \\mathds{1} & \\left( s_{i,t} \\in \\operatorname{Topk} ( \\{ s_{j, t} | 1 \\leq j \\leq N_r \\}, K_{r} ) \\right), \\\\\n s^{\\prime}_{i,t} & = \\frac{s_{i,t}}{\\sum_{j=1}^{N_r} s_{j,t}}, \\\\\n P_i & = \\frac{1}{T} \\sum_{t=1}^{T}{s^{\\prime}_{i,t}},\n\\end{align}" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/63", + "self_ref": "#/texts/53", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2229,7 +1929,7 @@ "text": "where the balance factor $\\alpha$ is a hyper-parameter, which will be assigned an extremely small value for DeepSeek-V3; \n$\\mathds{1}(\\cdot)$ denotes the indicator function; \nand $T$denotes the number of tokens in a sequence. \nThe sequence-wise balance loss encourages the expert load on each sequence to be balanced." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/64", + "self_ref": "#/texts/54", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2241,7 +1941,7 @@ "text": "Node-Limited Routing.\nLike the device-limited routing used by DeepSeek-V2, DeepSeek-V3 also uses a restricted routing mechanism to limit communication costs during training. \nIn short, we ensure that each token will be sent to at most $M$ nodes, which are selected according to the sum of the highest $\\frac{K_r}{M}$affinity scores of the experts distributed on each node.\nUnder this constraint, our MoE training framework can nearly achieve full computation-communication overlap." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/65", + "self_ref": "#/texts/55", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2253,7 +1953,7 @@ "text": "No Token-Dropping.\nDue to the effective load balancing strategy, DeepSeek-V3 keeps a good load balance during its full training. \nTherefore, DeepSeek-V3 does not drop any tokens during training. \nIn addition, we also implement specific deployment strategies to ensure inference load balance, so DeepSeek-V3also does not drop tokens during inference." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/66", + "self_ref": "#/texts/56", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2265,7 +1965,7 @@ "text": "Image: figures/nextn.pdf" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/67", + "self_ref": "#/texts/57", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/6" }, @@ -2277,7 +1977,7 @@ "text": "Illustration of our Multi-Token Prediction (MTP) implementation. \n We keep the complete causal chain for the prediction of each token at each depth." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/68", + "self_ref": "#/texts/58", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2290,19 +1990,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/69", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Inspired by", - "text": "Inspired by" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/70", + "self_ref": "#/texts/59", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2310,11 +1998,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[meta_mtp], we investigate and set a Multi-Token Prediction (MTP) objective for DeepSeek-V3, which extends the prediction scope to multiple future tokens at each position.\nOn the one hand, an MTP objective densifies the training signals and may improve data efficiency.\nOn the other hand, MTP may enable the model to pre-plan its representations for better prediction of future tokens.\nFigure[fig:nextn] illustrates our implementation of MTP.\nDifferent from [meta_mtp], which parallelly predicts $D$additional tokens using independent output heads, we sequentially predict additional tokens and keep the complete causal chain at each prediction depth.\nWe introduce the details of our MTP implementation in this section.", - "text": "[meta_mtp], we investigate and set a Multi-Token Prediction (MTP) objective for DeepSeek-V3, which extends the prediction scope to multiple future tokens at each position.\nOn the one hand, an MTP objective densifies the training signals and may improve data efficiency.\nOn the other hand, MTP may enable the model to pre-plan its representations for better prediction of future tokens.\nFigure[fig:nextn] illustrates our implementation of MTP.\nDifferent from [meta_mtp], which parallelly predicts $D$additional tokens using independent output heads, we sequentially predict additional tokens and keep the complete causal chain at each prediction depth.\nWe introduce the details of our MTP implementation in this section." + "orig": "Inspired by [meta_mtp], we investigate and set a Multi-Token Prediction (MTP) objective for DeepSeek-V3, which extends the prediction scope to multiple future tokens at each position.\nOn the one hand, an MTP objective densifies the training signals and may improve data efficiency.\nOn the other hand, MTP may enable the model to pre-plan its representations for better prediction of future tokens.\nFigure[fig:nextn] illustrates our implementation of MTP.\nDifferent from [meta_mtp], which parallelly predicts $D$additional tokens using independent output heads, we sequentially predict additional tokens and keep the complete causal chain at each prediction depth.\nWe introduce the details of our MTP implementation in this section.", + "text": "Inspired by [meta_mtp], we investigate and set a Multi-Token Prediction (MTP) objective for DeepSeek-V3, which extends the prediction scope to multiple future tokens at each position.\nOn the one hand, an MTP objective densifies the training signals and may improve data efficiency.\nOn the other hand, MTP may enable the model to pre-plan its representations for better prediction of future tokens.\nFigure[fig:nextn] illustrates our implementation of MTP.\nDifferent from [meta_mtp], which parallelly predicts $D$additional tokens using independent output heads, we sequentially predict additional tokens and keep the complete causal chain at each prediction depth.\nWe introduce the details of our MTP implementation in this section." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/71", + "self_ref": "#/texts/60", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2326,7 +2014,7 @@ "text": "MTP Modules.\nTo be specific, our MTP implementation uses $D$ sequential modules to predict $D$ additional tokens. \nThe $k$-th MTP module consists of a shared embedding layer $\\operatorname{Emb}(\\cdot)$, a shared output head $\\operatorname{OutHead}(\\cdot)$, a Transformer block $\\operatorname{TRM}_k(\\cdot)$, and a projection matrix $M_k \\in \\mathbb{R}^{d \\times 2d}$. \nFor the $i$-th input token $t_i$, at the $k$-th prediction depth, we first combine the representation of the $i$-th token at the $(k-1)$-th depth $\\mathbf{h}_i^{k-1} \\in \\mathbb{R}^{d}$ and the embedding of the $(i+k)$-th token $Emb(t_{i+k}) \\in \\mathbb{R}^{d}$ with the linear projection:" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/72", + "self_ref": "#/texts/61", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2338,7 +2026,7 @@ "text": "\\mathbf{h}_i^{\\prime k} = M_k [\\operatorname{RMSNorm}(\\mathbf{h}_i^{k-1}) ; \\operatorname{RMSNorm}(\\operatorname{Emb}(t_{i+k}))]," }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/73", + "self_ref": "#/texts/62", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2350,7 +2038,7 @@ "text": "where $[\\cdot ; \\cdot]$ denotes concatenation. \nEspecially, when $k=1$, $\\mathbf{h}_i^{k-1}$ refers to the representation given by the main model.\nNote that for each MTP module, its embedding layer is shared with the main model. \nThe combined $\\mathbf{h}_i^{\\prime k}$ serves as the input of the Transformer block at the $k$-th depth to produce the output representation at the current depth $\\mathbf{h}_{i}^{k}$:" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/74", + "self_ref": "#/texts/63", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2362,7 +2050,7 @@ "text": "\\mathbf{h}_{1:T-k}^{k} = \\operatorname{TRM}_k(\\mathbf{h}_{1:T-k}^{\\prime k})," }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/75", + "self_ref": "#/texts/64", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2374,7 +2062,7 @@ "text": "where $T$ represents the input sequence length and $_{i:j}$ denotes the slicing operation (inclusive of both the left and right boundaries). \nFinally, taking $\\mathbf{h}_{i}^{k}$ as the input, the shared output head will compute the probability distribution for the $k$-th additional prediction token $P_{i+1+k}^{k} \\in \\mathbb{R}^{V}$, where $V$ is the vocabulary size:" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/76", + "self_ref": "#/texts/65", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2386,7 +2074,7 @@ "text": "P_{i+k+1}^{k} = \\operatorname{OutHead}(\\mathbf{h}_{i}^{k})." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/77", + "self_ref": "#/texts/66", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2398,7 +2086,7 @@ "text": "The output head $\\operatorname{OutHead}(\\cdot)$ linearly maps the representation to logits and subsequently applies the $\\operatorname{Softmax}(\\cdot)$ function to compute the prediction probabilities of the $k$-th additional token. \nAlso, for each MTP module, its output head is shared with the main model. \nOur principle of maintaining the causal chain of predictions is similar to that of EAGLE[eagle], but its primary objective is speculative decoding[speculative_xhm,speculative_google], whereas we utilize MTP to improve training." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/78", + "self_ref": "#/texts/67", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2410,7 +2098,7 @@ "text": "MTP Training Objective.\nFor each prediction depth, we compute a cross-entropy loss $\\mathcal{L}_{\\text{MTP}}^{k}$:" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/79", + "self_ref": "#/texts/68", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2422,7 +2110,7 @@ "text": "\\mathcal{L}_{\\text{MTP}}^{k} = \\operatorname{CrossEntropy}(P_{2 + k:T + 1}^{k}, t_{2 + k:T + 1}) = -\\frac{1}{T} \\sum_{i=2 + k}^{T + 1} \\log P_i^k [t_i]," }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/80", + "self_ref": "#/texts/69", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2434,7 +2122,7 @@ "text": "where $T$ denotes the input sequence length, $t_i$ denotes the ground-truth token at the $i$-th position, and $P_i^k [t_i]$ denotes the corresponding prediction probability of $t_i$, given by the $k$-th MTP module. \nFinally, we compute the average of the MTP losses across all depths and multiply it by a weighting factor $\\lambda$ to obtain the overall MTP loss $\\mathcal{L}_{\\text{MTP}}$, which serves as an additional training objective for DeepSeek-V3:" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/81", + "self_ref": "#/texts/70", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2446,7 +2134,7 @@ "text": "\\mathcal{L}_{\\text{MTP}} = \\frac{\\lambda}{D} \\sum_{k=1}^{D} \\mathcal{L}_{\\text{MTP}}^{k}." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/82", + "self_ref": "#/texts/71", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2458,7 +2146,7 @@ "text": "MTP in Inference.Our MTP strategy mainly aims to improve the performance of the main model, so during inference, we can directly discard the MTP modules and the main model can function independently and normally.\nAdditionally, we can also repurpose these MTP modules for speculative decoding to further improve the generation latency." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/83", + "self_ref": "#/texts/72", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2471,7 +2159,7 @@ "level": 1 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/84", + "self_ref": "#/texts/73", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2484,7 +2172,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/85", + "self_ref": "#/texts/74", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2496,7 +2184,7 @@ "text": "DeepSeek-V3 is trained on a cluster equipped with 2048 NVIDIA H800 GPUs. \nEach node in the H800 cluster contains 8 GPUs connected by NVLink and NVSwitch within nodes. \nAcross different nodes, InfiniBand(IB) interconnects are utilized to facilitate communications." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/86", + "self_ref": "#/texts/75", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2509,19 +2197,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/87", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "The training of", - "text": "The training of" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/88", + "self_ref": "#/texts/76", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2529,23 +2205,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "DeepSeek-V3 is supported by the HAI-LLM framework, an efficient and lightweight training framework crafted by our engineers from the ground up. \nOn the whole, DeepSeek-V3 applies 16-way Pipeline Parallelism (PP)[qi2023zero], 64-way Expert Parallelism (EP)[gshard] spanning 8 nodes, and ZeRO-1 Data Parallelism (DP)[zero].", - "text": "DeepSeek-V3 is supported by the HAI-LLM framework, an efficient and lightweight training framework crafted by our engineers from the ground up. \nOn the whole, DeepSeek-V3 applies 16-way Pipeline Parallelism (PP)[qi2023zero], 64-way Expert Parallelism (EP)[gshard] spanning 8 nodes, and ZeRO-1 Data Parallelism (DP)[zero]." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/89", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "In order to facilitate efficient training of", - "text": "In order to facilitate efficient training of" + "orig": "The training of DeepSeek-V3 is supported by the HAI-LLM framework, an efficient and lightweight training framework crafted by our engineers from the ground up. \nOn the whole, DeepSeek-V3 applies 16-way Pipeline Parallelism (PP)[qi2023zero], 64-way Expert Parallelism (EP)[gshard] spanning 8 nodes, and ZeRO-1 Data Parallelism (DP)[zero].", + "text": "The training of DeepSeek-V3 is supported by the HAI-LLM framework, an efficient and lightweight training framework crafted by our engineers from the ground up. \nOn the whole, DeepSeek-V3 applies 16-way Pipeline Parallelism (PP)[qi2023zero], 64-way Expert Parallelism (EP)[gshard] spanning 8 nodes, and ZeRO-1 Data Parallelism (DP)[zero]." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/90", + "self_ref": "#/texts/77", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2553,11 +2217,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "DeepSeek-V3, we implement meticulous engineering optimizations.\nFirstly, we design the DualPipe algorithm for efficient pipeline parallelism.\nCompared with existing PP methods, DualPipe has fewer pipeline bubbles. \nMore importantly, it overlaps the computation and communication phases across forward and backward processes, thereby addressing the challenge of heavy communication overhead introduced by cross-node expert parallelism. \nSecondly, we develop efficient cross-node all-to-all communication kernels to fully utilize IB and NVLink bandwidths and conserve Streaming Multiprocessors (SMs) dedicated to communication. \nFinally, we meticulously optimize the memory footprint during training, thereby enabling us to train DeepSeek-V3 without using costly Tensor Parallelism(TP).", - "text": "DeepSeek-V3, we implement meticulous engineering optimizations.\nFirstly, we design the DualPipe algorithm for efficient pipeline parallelism.\nCompared with existing PP methods, DualPipe has fewer pipeline bubbles. \nMore importantly, it overlaps the computation and communication phases across forward and backward processes, thereby addressing the challenge of heavy communication overhead introduced by cross-node expert parallelism. \nSecondly, we develop efficient cross-node all-to-all communication kernels to fully utilize IB and NVLink bandwidths and conserve Streaming Multiprocessors (SMs) dedicated to communication. \nFinally, we meticulously optimize the memory footprint during training, thereby enabling us to train DeepSeek-V3 without using costly Tensor Parallelism(TP)." + "orig": "In order to facilitate efficient training of DeepSeek-V3, we implement meticulous engineering optimizations.\nFirstly, we design the DualPipe algorithm for efficient pipeline parallelism.\nCompared with existing PP methods, DualPipe has fewer pipeline bubbles. \nMore importantly, it overlaps the computation and communication phases across forward and backward processes, thereby addressing the challenge of heavy communication overhead introduced by cross-node expert parallelism. \nSecondly, we develop efficient cross-node all-to-all communication kernels to fully utilize IB and NVLink bandwidths and conserve Streaming Multiprocessors (SMs) dedicated to communication. \nFinally, we meticulously optimize the memory footprint during training, thereby enabling us to train DeepSeek-V3 without using costly Tensor Parallelism(TP).", + "text": "In order to facilitate efficient training of DeepSeek-V3, we implement meticulous engineering optimizations.\nFirstly, we design the DualPipe algorithm for efficient pipeline parallelism.\nCompared with existing PP methods, DualPipe has fewer pipeline bubbles. \nMore importantly, it overlaps the computation and communication phases across forward and backward processes, thereby addressing the challenge of heavy communication overhead introduced by cross-node expert parallelism. \nSecondly, we develop efficient cross-node all-to-all communication kernels to fully utilize IB and NVLink bandwidths and conserve Streaming Multiprocessors (SMs) dedicated to communication. \nFinally, we meticulously optimize the memory footprint during training, thereby enabling us to train DeepSeek-V3 without using costly Tensor Parallelism(TP)." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/91", + "self_ref": "#/texts/78", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2570,7 +2234,7 @@ "level": 3 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/92", + "self_ref": "#/texts/79", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2582,7 +2246,7 @@ "text": "Image: figures/overlap.pdf" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/93", + "self_ref": "#/texts/80", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/7" }, @@ -2594,19 +2258,7 @@ "text": "Overlapping strategy for a pair of individual forward and backward chunks (the boundaries of the transformer blocks are not aligned). \n Orange denotes forward, green denotes \"backward for input\", blue denotes \"backward for weights\", purple denotes PP communication, and red denotes barriers.\n Both all-to-all and PP communication can be fully hidden." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/94", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "For", - "text": "For" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/95", + "self_ref": "#/texts/81", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2614,23 +2266,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "DeepSeek-V3, the communication overhead introduced by cross-node expert parallelism results in an inefficient computation-to-communication ratio of approximately 1:1. \nTo tackle this challenge, we design an innovative pipeline parallelism algorithm called DualPipe, which not only accelerates model training by effectively overlapping forward and backward computation-communication phases, but also reduces the pipeline bubbles.", - "text": "DeepSeek-V3, the communication overhead introduced by cross-node expert parallelism results in an inefficient computation-to-communication ratio of approximately 1:1. \nTo tackle this challenge, we design an innovative pipeline parallelism algorithm called DualPipe, which not only accelerates model training by effectively overlapping forward and backward computation-communication phases, but also reduces the pipeline bubbles." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/96", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "The key idea of DualPipe is to overlap the computation and communication within a pair of individual forward and backward chunks.\nTo be specific, we divide each chunk into four components:", - "text": "The key idea of DualPipe is to overlap the computation and communication within a pair of individual forward and backward chunks.\nTo be specific, we divide each chunk into four components:" + "orig": "For DeepSeek-V3, the communication overhead introduced by cross-node expert parallelism results in an inefficient computation-to-communication ratio of approximately 1:1. \nTo tackle this challenge, we design an innovative pipeline parallelism algorithm called DualPipe, which not only accelerates model training by effectively overlapping forward and backward computation-communication phases, but also reduces the pipeline bubbles.", + "text": "For DeepSeek-V3, the communication overhead introduced by cross-node expert parallelism results in an inefficient computation-to-communication ratio of approximately 1:1. \nTo tackle this challenge, we design an innovative pipeline parallelism algorithm called DualPipe, which not only accelerates model training by effectively overlapping forward and backward computation-communication phases, but also reduces the pipeline bubbles." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/97", + "self_ref": "#/texts/82", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2638,11 +2278,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "attention, all-to-all dispatch, MLP, and all-to-all combine. \nSpecially, for a backward chunk, both attention and MLP are further split into two parts, backward for input and backward for weights, like in ZeroBubble[zerobubble]. \nIn addition, we have a PP communication component. \nAs illustrated in Figure[fig:transformer-overlap], for a pair of forward and backward chunks, we rearrange these components and manually adjust the ratio of GPU SMs dedicated to communication versus computation. \nIn this overlapping strategy, we can ensure that both all-to-all and PP communication can be fully hidden during execution. \nGiven the efficient overlapping strategy, the full DualPipe scheduling is illustrated in Figure[fig:dualpipe-schedules]. \nIt employs a bidirectional pipeline scheduling, which feeds micro-batches from both ends of the pipeline simultaneously and a significant portion of communications can be fully overlapped.\nThis overlap also ensures that, as the model further scales up, as long as we maintain a constant computation-to-communication ratio, we can still employ fine-grained experts across nodes while achieving a near-zero all-to-all communication overhead.", - "text": "attention, all-to-all dispatch, MLP, and all-to-all combine. \nSpecially, for a backward chunk, both attention and MLP are further split into two parts, backward for input and backward for weights, like in ZeroBubble[zerobubble]. \nIn addition, we have a PP communication component. \nAs illustrated in Figure[fig:transformer-overlap], for a pair of forward and backward chunks, we rearrange these components and manually adjust the ratio of GPU SMs dedicated to communication versus computation. \nIn this overlapping strategy, we can ensure that both all-to-all and PP communication can be fully hidden during execution. \nGiven the efficient overlapping strategy, the full DualPipe scheduling is illustrated in Figure[fig:dualpipe-schedules]. \nIt employs a bidirectional pipeline scheduling, which feeds micro-batches from both ends of the pipeline simultaneously and a significant portion of communications can be fully overlapped.\nThis overlap also ensures that, as the model further scales up, as long as we maintain a constant computation-to-communication ratio, we can still employ fine-grained experts across nodes while achieving a near-zero all-to-all communication overhead." + "orig": "The key idea of DualPipe is to overlap the computation and communication within a pair of individual forward and backward chunks.\nTo be specific, we divide each chunk into four components: attention, all-to-all dispatch, MLP, and all-to-all combine. \nSpecially, for a backward chunk, both attention and MLP are further split into two parts, backward for input and backward for weights, like in ZeroBubble[zerobubble]. \nIn addition, we have a PP communication component. \nAs illustrated in Figure[fig:transformer-overlap], for a pair of forward and backward chunks, we rearrange these components and manually adjust the ratio of GPU SMs dedicated to communication versus computation. \nIn this overlapping strategy, we can ensure that both all-to-all and PP communication can be fully hidden during execution. \nGiven the efficient overlapping strategy, the full DualPipe scheduling is illustrated in Figure[fig:dualpipe-schedules]. \nIt employs a bidirectional pipeline scheduling, which feeds micro-batches from both ends of the pipeline simultaneously and a significant portion of communications can be fully overlapped.\nThis overlap also ensures that, as the model further scales up, as long as we maintain a constant computation-to-communication ratio, we can still employ fine-grained experts across nodes while achieving a near-zero all-to-all communication overhead.", + "text": "The key idea of DualPipe is to overlap the computation and communication within a pair of individual forward and backward chunks.\nTo be specific, we divide each chunk into four components: attention, all-to-all dispatch, MLP, and all-to-all combine. \nSpecially, for a backward chunk, both attention and MLP are further split into two parts, backward for input and backward for weights, like in ZeroBubble[zerobubble]. \nIn addition, we have a PP communication component. \nAs illustrated in Figure[fig:transformer-overlap], for a pair of forward and backward chunks, we rearrange these components and manually adjust the ratio of GPU SMs dedicated to communication versus computation. \nIn this overlapping strategy, we can ensure that both all-to-all and PP communication can be fully hidden during execution. \nGiven the efficient overlapping strategy, the full DualPipe scheduling is illustrated in Figure[fig:dualpipe-schedules]. \nIt employs a bidirectional pipeline scheduling, which feeds micro-batches from both ends of the pipeline simultaneously and a significant portion of communications can be fully overlapped.\nThis overlap also ensures that, as the model further scales up, as long as we maintain a constant computation-to-communication ratio, we can still employ fine-grained experts across nodes while achieving a near-zero all-to-all communication overhead." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/98", + "self_ref": "#/texts/83", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2654,7 +2294,7 @@ "text": "Image: figures/dualpipe.pdf" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/99", + "self_ref": "#/texts/84", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/8" }, @@ -2666,19 +2306,7 @@ "text": "Example DualPipe scheduling for 8 PP ranks and 20 micro-batches in two directions. \n The micro-batches in the reverse direction are symmetric to those in the forward direction, so we omit their batch ID for illustration simplicity. \n Two cells enclosed by a shared black border have mutually overlapped computation and communication." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/100", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "In addition, even in more general scenarios without a heavy communication burden, DualPipe still exhibits efficiency advantages. \nIn Table", - "text": "In addition, even in more general scenarios without a heavy communication burden, DualPipe still exhibits efficiency advantages. \nIn Table" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/101", + "self_ref": "#/texts/85", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2686,11 +2314,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[tab:dualpipe-bubble], we summarize the pipeline bubbles and memory usage across different PP methods. \nAs shown in the table, compared with ZB1P[zerobubble] and 1F1B[pipedream], DualPipe significantly reduces the pipeline bubbles while only increasing the peak activation memory by $\\frac{1}{PP}$ times.\nAlthough DualPipe requires keeping two copies of the model parameters, this does not significantly increase the memory consumption since we use a large EP size during training. \nCompared with Chimera[chimera], DualPipe only requires that the pipeline stages and micro-batches be divisible by 2, without requiring micro-batches to be divisible by pipeline stages.\nIn addition, for DualPipe, neither the bubbles nor activation memory will increase as the number of micro-batches grows.", - "text": "[tab:dualpipe-bubble], we summarize the pipeline bubbles and memory usage across different PP methods. \nAs shown in the table, compared with ZB1P[zerobubble] and 1F1B[pipedream], DualPipe significantly reduces the pipeline bubbles while only increasing the peak activation memory by $\\frac{1}{PP}$ times.\nAlthough DualPipe requires keeping two copies of the model parameters, this does not significantly increase the memory consumption since we use a large EP size during training. \nCompared with Chimera[chimera], DualPipe only requires that the pipeline stages and micro-batches be divisible by 2, without requiring micro-batches to be divisible by pipeline stages.\nIn addition, for DualPipe, neither the bubbles nor activation memory will increase as the number of micro-batches grows." + "orig": "In addition, even in more general scenarios without a heavy communication burden, DualPipe still exhibits efficiency advantages. \nIn Table[tab:dualpipe-bubble], we summarize the pipeline bubbles and memory usage across different PP methods. \nAs shown in the table, compared with ZB1P[zerobubble] and 1F1B[pipedream], DualPipe significantly reduces the pipeline bubbles while only increasing the peak activation memory by $\\frac{1}{PP}$ times.\nAlthough DualPipe requires keeping two copies of the model parameters, this does not significantly increase the memory consumption since we use a large EP size during training. \nCompared with Chimera[chimera], DualPipe only requires that the pipeline stages and micro-batches be divisible by 2, without requiring micro-batches to be divisible by pipeline stages.\nIn addition, for DualPipe, neither the bubbles nor activation memory will increase as the number of micro-batches grows.", + "text": "In addition, even in more general scenarios without a heavy communication burden, DualPipe still exhibits efficiency advantages. \nIn Table[tab:dualpipe-bubble], we summarize the pipeline bubbles and memory usage across different PP methods. \nAs shown in the table, compared with ZB1P[zerobubble] and 1F1B[pipedream], DualPipe significantly reduces the pipeline bubbles while only increasing the peak activation memory by $\\frac{1}{PP}$ times.\nAlthough DualPipe requires keeping two copies of the model parameters, this does not significantly increase the memory consumption since we use a large EP size during training. \nCompared with Chimera[chimera], DualPipe only requires that the pipeline stages and micro-batches be divisible by 2, without requiring micro-batches to be divisible by pipeline stages.\nIn addition, for DualPipe, neither the bubbles nor activation memory will increase as the number of micro-batches grows." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/102", + "self_ref": "#/texts/86", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2702,7 +2330,7 @@ "text": "Comparison of pipeline bubbles and memory usage across different pipeline parallel methods. $F$ denotes the execution time of a forward chunk, $B$ denotes the execution time of a full backward chunk, $W$ denotes the execution time of a \"backward for weights\" chunk, and $F\\&B$ denotes the execution time of two mutually overlapped forward and backward chunks." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/103", + "self_ref": "#/texts/87", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2715,19 +2343,7 @@ "level": 3 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/104", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "In order to ensure sufficient computational performance for DualPipe, we customize efficient cross-node all-to-all communication kernels (including dispatching and combining) to conserve the number of SMs dedicated to communication.\nThe implementation of the kernels is co-designed with the MoE gating algorithm and the network topology of our cluster.\nTo be specific, in our cluster, cross-node GPUs are fully interconnected with IB, and intra-node communications are handled via NVLink.\nNVLink offers a bandwidth of 160 GB/s, roughly 3.2 times that of IB (50 GB/s). \nTo effectively leverage the different bandwidths of IB and NVLink, we limit each token to be dispatched to at most 4 nodes, thereby reducing IB traffic.\nFor each token, when its routing decision is made, it will first be transmitted via IB to the GPUs with the same in-node index on its target nodes. \nOnce it reaches the target nodes, we will endeavor to ensure that it is instantaneously forwarded via NVLink to specific GPUs that host their target experts, without being blocked by subsequently arriving tokens.\nIn this way, communications via IB and NVLink are fully overlapped, and each token can efficiently select an average of 3.2 experts per node without incurring additional overhead from NVLink.\nThis implies that, although", - "text": "In order to ensure sufficient computational performance for DualPipe, we customize efficient cross-node all-to-all communication kernels (including dispatching and combining) to conserve the number of SMs dedicated to communication.\nThe implementation of the kernels is co-designed with the MoE gating algorithm and the network topology of our cluster.\nTo be specific, in our cluster, cross-node GPUs are fully interconnected with IB, and intra-node communications are handled via NVLink.\nNVLink offers a bandwidth of 160 GB/s, roughly 3.2 times that of IB (50 GB/s). \nTo effectively leverage the different bandwidths of IB and NVLink, we limit each token to be dispatched to at most 4 nodes, thereby reducing IB traffic.\nFor each token, when its routing decision is made, it will first be transmitted via IB to the GPUs with the same in-node index on its target nodes. \nOnce it reaches the target nodes, we will endeavor to ensure that it is instantaneously forwarded via NVLink to specific GPUs that host their target experts, without being blocked by subsequently arriving tokens.\nIn this way, communications via IB and NVLink are fully overlapped, and each token can efficiently select an average of 3.2 experts per node without incurring additional overhead from NVLink.\nThis implies that, although" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/105", + "self_ref": "#/texts/88", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2735,23 +2351,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "DeepSeek-V3 selects only 8 routed experts in practice, it can scale up this number to a maximum of 13 experts (4 nodes $\\times$3.2 experts/node) while preserving the same communication cost.\nOverall, under such a communication strategy, only 20 SMs are sufficient to fully utilize the bandwidths of IB and NVLink.", - "text": "DeepSeek-V3 selects only 8 routed experts in practice, it can scale up this number to a maximum of 13 experts (4 nodes $\\times$3.2 experts/node) while preserving the same communication cost.\nOverall, under such a communication strategy, only 20 SMs are sufficient to fully utilize the bandwidths of IB and NVLink." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/106", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "In detail, we employ the warp specialization technique", - "text": "In detail, we employ the warp specialization technique" + "orig": "In order to ensure sufficient computational performance for DualPipe, we customize efficient cross-node all-to-all communication kernels (including dispatching and combining) to conserve the number of SMs dedicated to communication.\nThe implementation of the kernels is co-designed with the MoE gating algorithm and the network topology of our cluster.\nTo be specific, in our cluster, cross-node GPUs are fully interconnected with IB, and intra-node communications are handled via NVLink.\nNVLink offers a bandwidth of 160 GB/s, roughly 3.2 times that of IB (50 GB/s). \nTo effectively leverage the different bandwidths of IB and NVLink, we limit each token to be dispatched to at most 4 nodes, thereby reducing IB traffic.\nFor each token, when its routing decision is made, it will first be transmitted via IB to the GPUs with the same in-node index on its target nodes. \nOnce it reaches the target nodes, we will endeavor to ensure that it is instantaneously forwarded via NVLink to specific GPUs that host their target experts, without being blocked by subsequently arriving tokens.\nIn this way, communications via IB and NVLink are fully overlapped, and each token can efficiently select an average of 3.2 experts per node without incurring additional overhead from NVLink.\nThis implies that, although DeepSeek-V3 selects only 8 routed experts in practice, it can scale up this number to a maximum of 13 experts (4 nodes $\\times$3.2 experts/node) while preserving the same communication cost.\nOverall, under such a communication strategy, only 20 SMs are sufficient to fully utilize the bandwidths of IB and NVLink.", + "text": "In order to ensure sufficient computational performance for DualPipe, we customize efficient cross-node all-to-all communication kernels (including dispatching and combining) to conserve the number of SMs dedicated to communication.\nThe implementation of the kernels is co-designed with the MoE gating algorithm and the network topology of our cluster.\nTo be specific, in our cluster, cross-node GPUs are fully interconnected with IB, and intra-node communications are handled via NVLink.\nNVLink offers a bandwidth of 160 GB/s, roughly 3.2 times that of IB (50 GB/s). \nTo effectively leverage the different bandwidths of IB and NVLink, we limit each token to be dispatched to at most 4 nodes, thereby reducing IB traffic.\nFor each token, when its routing decision is made, it will first be transmitted via IB to the GPUs with the same in-node index on its target nodes. \nOnce it reaches the target nodes, we will endeavor to ensure that it is instantaneously forwarded via NVLink to specific GPUs that host their target experts, without being blocked by subsequently arriving tokens.\nIn this way, communications via IB and NVLink are fully overlapped, and each token can efficiently select an average of 3.2 experts per node without incurring additional overhead from NVLink.\nThis implies that, although DeepSeek-V3 selects only 8 routed experts in practice, it can scale up this number to a maximum of 13 experts (4 nodes $\\times$3.2 experts/node) while preserving the same communication cost.\nOverall, under such a communication strategy, only 20 SMs are sufficient to fully utilize the bandwidths of IB and NVLink." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/107", + "self_ref": "#/texts/89", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2759,11 +2363,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[warp-spec]and partition 20 SMs into 10 communication channels.\nDuring the dispatching process, (1) IB sending, (2) IB-to-NVLink forwarding, and (3) NVLink receiving are handled by respective warps. \nThe number of warps allocated to each communication task is dynamically adjusted according to the actual workload across all SMs. \nSimilarly, during the combining process, (1) NVLink sending, (2) NVLink-to-IB forwarding and accumulation, and (3) IB receiving and accumulation are also handled by dynamically adjusted warps. \nIn addition, both dispatching and combining kernels overlap with the computation stream, so we also consider their impact on other SM computation kernels. \nSpecifically, we employ customized PTX (Parallel Thread Execution) instructions and auto-tune the communication chunk size, which significantly reduces the use of the L2 cache and the interference to other SMs.", - "text": "[warp-spec]and partition 20 SMs into 10 communication channels.\nDuring the dispatching process, (1) IB sending, (2) IB-to-NVLink forwarding, and (3) NVLink receiving are handled by respective warps. \nThe number of warps allocated to each communication task is dynamically adjusted according to the actual workload across all SMs. \nSimilarly, during the combining process, (1) NVLink sending, (2) NVLink-to-IB forwarding and accumulation, and (3) IB receiving and accumulation are also handled by dynamically adjusted warps. \nIn addition, both dispatching and combining kernels overlap with the computation stream, so we also consider their impact on other SM computation kernels. \nSpecifically, we employ customized PTX (Parallel Thread Execution) instructions and auto-tune the communication chunk size, which significantly reduces the use of the L2 cache and the interference to other SMs." + "orig": "In detail, we employ the warp specialization technique[warp-spec]and partition 20 SMs into 10 communication channels.\nDuring the dispatching process, (1) IB sending, (2) IB-to-NVLink forwarding, and (3) NVLink receiving are handled by respective warps. \nThe number of warps allocated to each communication task is dynamically adjusted according to the actual workload across all SMs. \nSimilarly, during the combining process, (1) NVLink sending, (2) NVLink-to-IB forwarding and accumulation, and (3) IB receiving and accumulation are also handled by dynamically adjusted warps. \nIn addition, both dispatching and combining kernels overlap with the computation stream, so we also consider their impact on other SM computation kernels. \nSpecifically, we employ customized PTX (Parallel Thread Execution) instructions and auto-tune the communication chunk size, which significantly reduces the use of the L2 cache and the interference to other SMs.", + "text": "In detail, we employ the warp specialization technique[warp-spec]and partition 20 SMs into 10 communication channels.\nDuring the dispatching process, (1) IB sending, (2) IB-to-NVLink forwarding, and (3) NVLink receiving are handled by respective warps. \nThe number of warps allocated to each communication task is dynamically adjusted according to the actual workload across all SMs. \nSimilarly, during the combining process, (1) NVLink sending, (2) NVLink-to-IB forwarding and accumulation, and (3) IB receiving and accumulation are also handled by dynamically adjusted warps. \nIn addition, both dispatching and combining kernels overlap with the computation stream, so we also consider their impact on other SM computation kernels. \nSpecifically, we employ customized PTX (Parallel Thread Execution) instructions and auto-tune the communication chunk size, which significantly reduces the use of the L2 cache and the interference to other SMs." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/108", + "self_ref": "#/texts/90", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2776,7 +2380,7 @@ "level": 3 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/109", + "self_ref": "#/texts/91", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2788,7 +2392,7 @@ "text": "In order to reduce the memory footprint during training, we employ the following techniques." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/110", + "self_ref": "#/texts/92", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2800,7 +2404,7 @@ "text": "Recomputation of RMSNorm and MLA Up-Projection." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/111", + "self_ref": "#/texts/93", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2812,7 +2416,7 @@ "text": "We recompute all RMSNorm operations and MLA up-projections during back-propagation, thereby eliminating the need to persistently store their output activations.\nWith a minor overhead, this strategy significantly reduces memory requirements for storing activations." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/112", + "self_ref": "#/texts/94", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2824,7 +2428,7 @@ "text": "Exponential Moving Average in CPU.During training, we preserve the Exponential Moving Average (EMA) of the model parameters for early estimation of the model performance after learning rate decay.\nThe EMA parameters are stored in CPU memory and are updated asynchronously after each training step. \nThis method allows us to maintain EMA parameters without incurring additional memory or time overhead." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/113", + "self_ref": "#/texts/95", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2836,7 +2440,7 @@ "text": "Shared Embedding and Output Head for Multi-Token Prediction.With the DualPipe strategy, we deploy the shallowest layers (including the embedding layer) and deepest layers (including the output head) of the model on the same PP rank. \nThis arrangement enables the physical sharing of parameters and gradients, of the shared embedding and output head, between the MTP module and the main model.\nThis physical sharing mechanism further enhances our memory efficiency." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/114", + "self_ref": "#/texts/96", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2849,7 +2453,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/115", + "self_ref": "#/texts/97", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2861,7 +2465,7 @@ "text": "Image: figures/fp8-frameworkv3.pdf" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/116", + "self_ref": "#/texts/98", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/9" }, @@ -2873,19 +2477,7 @@ "text": "The overall mixed precision framework with FP8 data format. For clarification, only the Linear operator is illustrated." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/117", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Inspired by recent advances in low-precision training", - "text": "Inspired by recent advances in low-precision training" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/118", + "self_ref": "#/texts/99", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2893,11 +2485,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[fp8lm, llm.int8, 8-bit-numerical], we propose a fine-grained mixed precision framework utilizing the FP8 data format for training DeepSeek-V3. \nWhile low-precision training holds great promise, it is often limited by the presence of outliers in activations, weights, and gradients[massiveoutlier, understandoutlier, scalefp8train]. \nAlthough significant progress has been made in inference quantization[xiao2023smoothquant, frantar2022gptq], there are relatively few studies demonstrating successful application of low-precision techniques in large-scale language model pre-training[scalefp8train]. \nTo address this challenge and effectively extend the dynamic range of the FP8 format, we introduce a fine-grained quantization strategy: tile-wise grouping with $1\\times N_c$ elements or block-wise grouping with $N_c\\times N_c$ elements. \nThe associated dequantization overhead is largely mitigated under our increased-precision accumulation process, a critical aspect for achieving accurate FP8 General Matrix Multiplication(GEMM). \nMoreover, to further reduce memory and communication overhead in MoE training, we cache and dispatch activations in FP8, while storing low-precision optimizer states in BF16. \nWe validate the proposed FP8 mixed precision framework on two model scales similar to DeepSeek-V2-Lite and DeepSeek-V2, training for approximately 1 trillion tokens (see more details in Appendix[app:fp8_cp_bf16]). \nNotably, compared with the BF16 baseline, the relative loss error of our FP8-training model remains consistently below 0.25%, a level well within the acceptable range of training randomness.", - "text": "[fp8lm, llm.int8, 8-bit-numerical], we propose a fine-grained mixed precision framework utilizing the FP8 data format for training DeepSeek-V3. \nWhile low-precision training holds great promise, it is often limited by the presence of outliers in activations, weights, and gradients[massiveoutlier, understandoutlier, scalefp8train]. \nAlthough significant progress has been made in inference quantization[xiao2023smoothquant, frantar2022gptq], there are relatively few studies demonstrating successful application of low-precision techniques in large-scale language model pre-training[scalefp8train]. \nTo address this challenge and effectively extend the dynamic range of the FP8 format, we introduce a fine-grained quantization strategy: tile-wise grouping with $1\\times N_c$ elements or block-wise grouping with $N_c\\times N_c$ elements. \nThe associated dequantization overhead is largely mitigated under our increased-precision accumulation process, a critical aspect for achieving accurate FP8 General Matrix Multiplication(GEMM). \nMoreover, to further reduce memory and communication overhead in MoE training, we cache and dispatch activations in FP8, while storing low-precision optimizer states in BF16. \nWe validate the proposed FP8 mixed precision framework on two model scales similar to DeepSeek-V2-Lite and DeepSeek-V2, training for approximately 1 trillion tokens (see more details in Appendix[app:fp8_cp_bf16]). \nNotably, compared with the BF16 baseline, the relative loss error of our FP8-training model remains consistently below 0.25%, a level well within the acceptable range of training randomness." + "orig": "Inspired by recent advances in low-precision training[fp8lm, llm.int8, 8-bit-numerical], we propose a fine-grained mixed precision framework utilizing the FP8 data format for training DeepSeek-V3. \nWhile low-precision training holds great promise, it is often limited by the presence of outliers in activations, weights, and gradients[massiveoutlier, understandoutlier, scalefp8train]. \nAlthough significant progress has been made in inference quantization[xiao2023smoothquant, frantar2022gptq], there are relatively few studies demonstrating successful application of low-precision techniques in large-scale language model pre-training[scalefp8train]. \nTo address this challenge and effectively extend the dynamic range of the FP8 format, we introduce a fine-grained quantization strategy: tile-wise grouping with $1\\times N_c$ elements or block-wise grouping with $N_c\\times N_c$ elements. \nThe associated dequantization overhead is largely mitigated under our increased-precision accumulation process, a critical aspect for achieving accurate FP8 General Matrix Multiplication(GEMM). \nMoreover, to further reduce memory and communication overhead in MoE training, we cache and dispatch activations in FP8, while storing low-precision optimizer states in BF16. \nWe validate the proposed FP8 mixed precision framework on two model scales similar to DeepSeek-V2-Lite and DeepSeek-V2, training for approximately 1 trillion tokens (see more details in Appendix[app:fp8_cp_bf16]). \nNotably, compared with the BF16 baseline, the relative loss error of our FP8-training model remains consistently below 0.25%, a level well within the acceptable range of training randomness.", + "text": "Inspired by recent advances in low-precision training[fp8lm, llm.int8, 8-bit-numerical], we propose a fine-grained mixed precision framework utilizing the FP8 data format for training DeepSeek-V3. \nWhile low-precision training holds great promise, it is often limited by the presence of outliers in activations, weights, and gradients[massiveoutlier, understandoutlier, scalefp8train]. \nAlthough significant progress has been made in inference quantization[xiao2023smoothquant, frantar2022gptq], there are relatively few studies demonstrating successful application of low-precision techniques in large-scale language model pre-training[scalefp8train]. \nTo address this challenge and effectively extend the dynamic range of the FP8 format, we introduce a fine-grained quantization strategy: tile-wise grouping with $1\\times N_c$ elements or block-wise grouping with $N_c\\times N_c$ elements. \nThe associated dequantization overhead is largely mitigated under our increased-precision accumulation process, a critical aspect for achieving accurate FP8 General Matrix Multiplication(GEMM). \nMoreover, to further reduce memory and communication overhead in MoE training, we cache and dispatch activations in FP8, while storing low-precision optimizer states in BF16. \nWe validate the proposed FP8 mixed precision framework on two model scales similar to DeepSeek-V2-Lite and DeepSeek-V2, training for approximately 1 trillion tokens (see more details in Appendix[app:fp8_cp_bf16]). \nNotably, compared with the BF16 baseline, the relative loss error of our FP8-training model remains consistently below 0.25%, a level well within the acceptable range of training randomness." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/119", + "self_ref": "#/texts/100", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2910,7 +2502,7 @@ "level": 3 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/120", + "self_ref": "#/texts/101", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2922,19 +2514,7 @@ "text": "Building upon widely adopted techniques in low-precision training[bf16train, fp16train], we propose a mixed precision framework for FP8 training. \nIn this framework, most compute-density operations are conducted in FP8, while a few key operations are strategically maintained in their original data formats to balance training efficiency and numerical stability. \nThe overall framework is illustrated in Figure[fig:fp8_framework]." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/121", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Firstly, in order to accelerate model training, the majority of core computation kernels, i.e., GEMM operations, are implemented in FP8 precision. \nThese GEMM operations accept FP8 tensors as inputs and produce outputs in BF16 or FP32. \nAs depicted in Figure", - "text": "Firstly, in order to accelerate model training, the majority of core computation kernels, i.e., GEMM operations, are implemented in FP8 precision. \nThese GEMM operations accept FP8 tensors as inputs and produce outputs in BF16 or FP32. \nAs depicted in Figure" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/122", + "self_ref": "#/texts/102", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2942,23 +2522,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[fig:fp8_framework], all three GEMMs associated with the Linear operator, namely Fprop (forward pass), Dgrad (activation backward pass), and Wgrad (weight backward pass), are executed in FP8. \nThis design theoretically doubles the computational speed compared with the original BF16 method. \nAdditionally, the FP8 WgradGEMM allows activations to be stored in FP8 for use in the backward pass. \nThis significantly reduces memory consumption.", - "text": "[fig:fp8_framework], all three GEMMs associated with the Linear operator, namely Fprop (forward pass), Dgrad (activation backward pass), and Wgrad (weight backward pass), are executed in FP8. \nThis design theoretically doubles the computational speed compared with the original BF16 method. \nAdditionally, the FP8 WgradGEMM allows activations to be stored in FP8 for use in the backward pass. \nThis significantly reduces memory consumption." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/123", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Despite the efficiency advantage of the FP8 format, certain operators still require a higher precision due to their sensitivity to low-precision computations. \nBesides, some low-cost operators can also utilize a higher precision with a negligible overhead to the overall training cost. \nFor this reason, after careful investigations, we maintain the original precision (e.g., BF16 or FP32) for the following components: the embedding module, the output head, MoE gating modules, normalization operators, and attention operators. \nThese targeted retentions of high precision ensure stable training dynamics for", - "text": "Despite the efficiency advantage of the FP8 format, certain operators still require a higher precision due to their sensitivity to low-precision computations. \nBesides, some low-cost operators can also utilize a higher precision with a negligible overhead to the overall training cost. \nFor this reason, after careful investigations, we maintain the original precision (e.g., BF16 or FP32) for the following components: the embedding module, the output head, MoE gating modules, normalization operators, and attention operators. \nThese targeted retentions of high precision ensure stable training dynamics for" + "orig": "Firstly, in order to accelerate model training, the majority of core computation kernels, i.e., GEMM operations, are implemented in FP8 precision. \nThese GEMM operations accept FP8 tensors as inputs and produce outputs in BF16 or FP32. \nAs depicted in Figure[fig:fp8_framework], all three GEMMs associated with the Linear operator, namely Fprop (forward pass), Dgrad (activation backward pass), and Wgrad (weight backward pass), are executed in FP8. \nThis design theoretically doubles the computational speed compared with the original BF16 method. \nAdditionally, the FP8 WgradGEMM allows activations to be stored in FP8 for use in the backward pass. \nThis significantly reduces memory consumption.", + "text": "Firstly, in order to accelerate model training, the majority of core computation kernels, i.e., GEMM operations, are implemented in FP8 precision. \nThese GEMM operations accept FP8 tensors as inputs and produce outputs in BF16 or FP32. \nAs depicted in Figure[fig:fp8_framework], all three GEMMs associated with the Linear operator, namely Fprop (forward pass), Dgrad (activation backward pass), and Wgrad (weight backward pass), are executed in FP8. \nThis design theoretically doubles the computational speed compared with the original BF16 method. \nAdditionally, the FP8 WgradGEMM allows activations to be stored in FP8 for use in the backward pass. \nThis significantly reduces memory consumption." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/124", + "self_ref": "#/texts/103", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2966,11 +2534,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "DeepSeek-V3.\nTo further guarantee numerical stability, we store the master weights, weight gradients, and optimizer states in higher precision. \nWhile these high-precision components incur some memory overheads, their impact can be minimized through efficient sharding across multiple DP ranks in our distributed training system.", - "text": "DeepSeek-V3.\nTo further guarantee numerical stability, we store the master weights, weight gradients, and optimizer states in higher precision. \nWhile these high-precision components incur some memory overheads, their impact can be minimized through efficient sharding across multiple DP ranks in our distributed training system." + "orig": "Despite the efficiency advantage of the FP8 format, certain operators still require a higher precision due to their sensitivity to low-precision computations. \nBesides, some low-cost operators can also utilize a higher precision with a negligible overhead to the overall training cost. \nFor this reason, after careful investigations, we maintain the original precision (e.g., BF16 or FP32) for the following components: the embedding module, the output head, MoE gating modules, normalization operators, and attention operators. \nThese targeted retentions of high precision ensure stable training dynamics for DeepSeek-V3.\nTo further guarantee numerical stability, we store the master weights, weight gradients, and optimizer states in higher precision. \nWhile these high-precision components incur some memory overheads, their impact can be minimized through efficient sharding across multiple DP ranks in our distributed training system.", + "text": "Despite the efficiency advantage of the FP8 format, certain operators still require a higher precision due to their sensitivity to low-precision computations. \nBesides, some low-cost operators can also utilize a higher precision with a negligible overhead to the overall training cost. \nFor this reason, after careful investigations, we maintain the original precision (e.g., BF16 or FP32) for the following components: the embedding module, the output head, MoE gating modules, normalization operators, and attention operators. \nThese targeted retentions of high precision ensure stable training dynamics for DeepSeek-V3.\nTo further guarantee numerical stability, we store the master weights, weight gradients, and optimizer states in higher precision. \nWhile these high-precision components incur some memory overheads, their impact can be minimized through efficient sharding across multiple DP ranks in our distributed training system." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/125", + "self_ref": "#/texts/104", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2982,7 +2550,7 @@ "text": "Image: figures/fp8-128accumulatorv4.pdf" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/126", + "self_ref": "#/texts/105", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/10" }, @@ -2994,7 +2562,7 @@ "text": "(a) We propose a fine-grained quantization method to mitigate quantization errors caused by feature outliers; for illustration simplicity, only Fprop is illustrated. \n (b) In conjunction with our quantization strategy, we improve the FP8 GEMM precision by promoting to CUDA Cores at an interval of $N_C=128$ elements MMA for the high-precision accumulation." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/127", + "self_ref": "#/texts/106", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3007,7 +2575,7 @@ "level": 3 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/128", + "self_ref": "#/texts/107", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3019,7 +2587,7 @@ "text": "Based on our mixed precision FP8 framework, we introduce several strategies to enhance low-precision training accuracy, focusing on both the quantization method and the multiplication process." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/129", + "self_ref": "#/texts/108", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3031,31 +2599,19 @@ "text": "Fine-Grained Quantization.\nIn low-precision training frameworks, overflows and underflows are common challenges due to the limited dynamic range of the FP8 format, which is constrained by its reduced exponent bits. \nAs a standard practice, the input distribution is aligned to the representable range of the FP8 format by scaling the maximum absolute value of the input tensor to the maximum representable value of FP8[fp16train]. \nThis method makes low-precision training highly sensitive to activation outliers, which can heavily degrade quantization accuracy.\nTo solve this, we propose a fine-grained quantization method that applies scaling at a more granular level. \nAs illustrated in Figure[fig:fp8_quantization] (a), (1) for activations, we group and scale elements on a 1x128 tile basis (i.e., per token per 128 channels); and (2) for weights, we group and scale elements on a 128x128 block basis (i.e., per 128 input channels per 128 output channels).\nThis approach ensures that the quantization process can better accommodate outliers by adapting the scale according to smaller groups of elements. \nIn Appendix[app:fp8_blockwise], we further discuss the training instability when we group and scale activations on a block basis in the same way as weights quantization." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/130", + "self_ref": "#/texts/109", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], "orig": "One key modification in our method is the introduction of per-group scaling factors along the inner dimension of GEMM operations. \nThis functionality is not directly supported in the standard FP8 GEMM. \nHowever, combined with our precise FP32 accumulation strategy, it can be efficiently implemented.", "text": "One key modification in our method is the introduction of per-group scaling factors along the inner dimension of GEMM operations. \nThis functionality is not directly supported in the standard FP8 GEMM. \nHowever, combined with our precise FP32 accumulation strategy, it can be efficiently implemented." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/131", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Notably, our fine-grained quantization strategy is highly consistent with the idea of microscaling formats", - "text": "Notably, our fine-grained quantization strategy is highly consistent with the idea of microscaling formats" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/132", + "self_ref": "#/texts/110", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3063,11 +2619,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[rouhani2023microscaling], while the Tensor Cores of NVIDIA next-generation GPUs (Blackwell series) have announced the support for microscaling formats with smaller quantization granularity[nvidia_tensor_cores]. \nWe hope our design can serve as a reference for future work to keep pace with the latest GPU architectures.", - "text": "[rouhani2023microscaling], while the Tensor Cores of NVIDIA next-generation GPUs (Blackwell series) have announced the support for microscaling formats with smaller quantization granularity[nvidia_tensor_cores]. \nWe hope our design can serve as a reference for future work to keep pace with the latest GPU architectures." + "orig": "Notably, our fine-grained quantization strategy is highly consistent with the idea of microscaling formats[rouhani2023microscaling], while the Tensor Cores of NVIDIA next-generation GPUs (Blackwell series) have announced the support for microscaling formats with smaller quantization granularity[nvidia_tensor_cores]. \nWe hope our design can serve as a reference for future work to keep pace with the latest GPU architectures.", + "text": "Notably, our fine-grained quantization strategy is highly consistent with the idea of microscaling formats[rouhani2023microscaling], while the Tensor Cores of NVIDIA next-generation GPUs (Blackwell series) have announced the support for microscaling formats with smaller quantization granularity[nvidia_tensor_cores]. \nWe hope our design can serve as a reference for future work to keep pace with the latest GPU architectures." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/133", + "self_ref": "#/texts/111", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3079,19 +2635,7 @@ "text": "Increasing Accumulation Precision.\nLow-precision GEMM operations often suffer from underflow issues, and their accuracy largely depends on high-precision accumulation, which is commonly performed in an FP32 precision[bf16train, fp16train].\nHowever, we observe that the accumulation precision of FP8 GEMM on NVIDIA H800 GPUs is limited to retaining around 14 bits, which is significantly lower than FP32 accumulation precision. \nThis problem will become more pronounced when the inner dimension K is large[switchback], a typical scenario in large-scale model training where the batch size and model width are increased. \nTaking GEMM operations of two random matrices with K = 4096 for example, in our preliminary test, the limited accumulation precision in Tensor Cores results in a maximum relative error of nearly 2%. \nDespite these problems, the limited accumulation precision is still the default option in a few FP8 frameworks[transformerengine], severely constraining the training accuracy." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/134", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "In order to address this issue, we adopt the strategy of promotion to CUDA Cores for higher precision", - "text": "In order to address this issue, we adopt the strategy of promotion to CUDA Cores for higher precision" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/135", + "self_ref": "#/texts/112", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3099,23 +2643,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[Thakkar_CUTLASS_2023]. \nThe process is illustrated in Figure[fig:fp8_quantization] (b). \nTo be specific, during MMA (Matrix Multiply-Accumulate) execution on Tensor Cores, intermediate results are accumulated using the limited bit width. \nOnce an interval of $N_C$ is reached, these partial results will be copied to FP32 registers on CUDA Cores, where full-precision FP32 accumulation is performed.\nAs mentioned before, our fine-grained quantization applies per-group scaling factors along the inner dimension K. \nThese scaling factors can be efficiently multiplied on the CUDA Cores as the dequantization process with minimal additional computational cost.", - "text": "[Thakkar_CUTLASS_2023]. \nThe process is illustrated in Figure[fig:fp8_quantization] (b). \nTo be specific, during MMA (Matrix Multiply-Accumulate) execution on Tensor Cores, intermediate results are accumulated using the limited bit width. \nOnce an interval of $N_C$ is reached, these partial results will be copied to FP32 registers on CUDA Cores, where full-precision FP32 accumulation is performed.\nAs mentioned before, our fine-grained quantization applies per-group scaling factors along the inner dimension K. \nThese scaling factors can be efficiently multiplied on the CUDA Cores as the dequantization process with minimal additional computational cost." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/136", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "It is worth noting that this modification reduces the WGMMA (Warpgroup-level Matrix Multiply-Accumulate) instruction issue rate for a single warpgroup. However, on the H800 architecture, it is typical for two WGMMA to persist concurrently: while one warpgroup performs the promotion operation, the other is able to execute the MMA operation. This design enables overlapping of the two operations, maintaining high utilization of Tensor Cores.\nBased on our experiments, setting", - "text": "It is worth noting that this modification reduces the WGMMA (Warpgroup-level Matrix Multiply-Accumulate) instruction issue rate for a single warpgroup. However, on the H800 architecture, it is typical for two WGMMA to persist concurrently: while one warpgroup performs the promotion operation, the other is able to execute the MMA operation. This design enables overlapping of the two operations, maintaining high utilization of Tensor Cores.\nBased on our experiments, setting" + "orig": "In order to address this issue, we adopt the strategy of promotion to CUDA Cores for higher precision[Thakkar_CUTLASS_2023]. \nThe process is illustrated in Figure[fig:fp8_quantization] (b). \nTo be specific, during MMA (Matrix Multiply-Accumulate) execution on Tensor Cores, intermediate results are accumulated using the limited bit width. \nOnce an interval of $N_C$ is reached, these partial results will be copied to FP32 registers on CUDA Cores, where full-precision FP32 accumulation is performed.\nAs mentioned before, our fine-grained quantization applies per-group scaling factors along the inner dimension K. \nThese scaling factors can be efficiently multiplied on the CUDA Cores as the dequantization process with minimal additional computational cost.", + "text": "In order to address this issue, we adopt the strategy of promotion to CUDA Cores for higher precision[Thakkar_CUTLASS_2023]. \nThe process is illustrated in Figure[fig:fp8_quantization] (b). \nTo be specific, during MMA (Matrix Multiply-Accumulate) execution on Tensor Cores, intermediate results are accumulated using the limited bit width. \nOnce an interval of $N_C$ is reached, these partial results will be copied to FP32 registers on CUDA Cores, where full-precision FP32 accumulation is performed.\nAs mentioned before, our fine-grained quantization applies per-group scaling factors along the inner dimension K. \nThese scaling factors can be efficiently multiplied on the CUDA Cores as the dequantization process with minimal additional computational cost." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/137", + "self_ref": "#/texts/113", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3123,11 +2655,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "$N_C=128$elements, equivalent to 4 WGMMAs, represents the minimal accumulation interval that can significantly improve precision without introducing substantial overhead.", - "text": "$N_C=128$elements, equivalent to 4 WGMMAs, represents the minimal accumulation interval that can significantly improve precision without introducing substantial overhead." + "orig": "It is worth noting that this modification reduces the WGMMA (Warpgroup-level Matrix Multiply-Accumulate) instruction issue rate for a single warpgroup. However, on the H800 architecture, it is typical for two WGMMA to persist concurrently: while one warpgroup performs the promotion operation, the other is able to execute the MMA operation. This design enables overlapping of the two operations, maintaining high utilization of Tensor Cores.\nBased on our experiments, setting $N_C=128$elements, equivalent to 4 WGMMAs, represents the minimal accumulation interval that can significantly improve precision without introducing substantial overhead.", + "text": "It is worth noting that this modification reduces the WGMMA (Warpgroup-level Matrix Multiply-Accumulate) instruction issue rate for a single warpgroup. However, on the H800 architecture, it is typical for two WGMMA to persist concurrently: while one warpgroup performs the promotion operation, the other is able to execute the MMA operation. This design enables overlapping of the two operations, maintaining high utilization of Tensor Cores.\nBased on our experiments, setting $N_C=128$elements, equivalent to 4 WGMMAs, represents the minimal accumulation interval that can significantly improve precision without introducing substantial overhead." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/138", + "self_ref": "#/texts/114", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3139,7 +2671,7 @@ "text": "Mantissa over Exponents. \nIn contrast to the hybrid FP8 format adopted by prior work [transformerengine, fp8lm, hfp8], which uses E4M3 (4-bit exponent and 3-bit mantissa) in Fprop and E5M2 (5-bit exponent and 2-bit mantissa) in Dgrad and Wgrad, we adopt the E4M3format on all tensors for higher precision. \nWe attribute the feasibility of this approach to our fine-grained quantization strategy, i.e., tile and block-wise scaling. \nBy operating on smaller element groups, our methodology effectively shares exponent bits among these grouped elements, mitigating the impact of the limited dynamic range." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/139", + "self_ref": "#/texts/115", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3151,7 +2683,7 @@ "text": "Online Quantization.\nDelayed quantization is employed in tensor-wise quantization frameworks[transformerengine, fp8lm], which maintains a history of the maximum absolute values across prior iterations to infer the current value. \nIn order to ensure accurate scales and simplify the framework, we calculate the maximum absolute value online for each 1x128 activation tile or 128x128weight block. \nBased on it, we derive the scaling factor and then quantize the activation or weight online into the FP8 format." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/140", + "self_ref": "#/texts/116", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3164,7 +2696,7 @@ "level": 3 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/141", + "self_ref": "#/texts/117", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3176,7 +2708,7 @@ "text": "In conjunction with our FP8 training framework, we further reduce the memory consumption and communication overhead by compressing cached activations and optimizer states into lower-precision formats." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/142", + "self_ref": "#/texts/118", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3188,7 +2720,7 @@ "text": "Low-Precision Optimizer States.\nWe adopt the BF16 data format instead of FP32 to track the first and second moments in the AdamW[adamW]optimizer, without incurring observable performance degradation. \nHowever, the master weights (stored by the optimizer) and gradients (used for batch size accumulation) are still retained in FP32 to ensure numerical stability throughout training." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/143", + "self_ref": "#/texts/119", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3200,7 +2732,7 @@ "text": "Low-Precision Activation.\nAs illustrated in Figure[fig:fp8_framework], the Wgrad operation is performed in FP8. \nTo reduce the memory consumption, it is a natural choice to cache activations in FP8 format for the backward pass of the Linear operator.\nHowever, special considerations are taken on several operators for low-cost high-precision training:" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/144", + "self_ref": "#/texts/120", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3212,7 +2744,7 @@ "text": "(1) Inputs of the Linear after the attention operator. These activations are also used in the backward pass of the attention operator, which makes it sensitive to precision. We adopt a customized E5M6 data format exclusively for these activations. Additionally, these activations will be converted from an 1x128 quantization tile to an 128x1tile in the backward pass. To avoid introducing extra quantization error, all the scaling factors are round scaled, i.e., integral power of 2." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/145", + "self_ref": "#/texts/121", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3224,7 +2756,7 @@ "text": "(2) Inputs of the SwiGLU operator in MoE. To further reduce the memory cost, we cache the inputs of the SwiGLU operator and recompute its output in the backward pass. These activations are also stored in FP8 with our fine-grained quantization method, striking a balance between memory efficiency and computational accuracy." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/146", + "self_ref": "#/texts/122", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3236,7 +2768,7 @@ "text": "Low-Precision Communication.\nCommunication bandwidth is a critical bottleneck in the training of MoE models. \nTo alleviate this challenge, we quantize the activation before MoE up-projections into FP8 and then apply dispatch components, which is compatible with FP8 Fprop in MoE up-projections. Like the inputs of the Linear after the attention operator, scaling factors for this activation are integral power of 2.\nA similar strategy is applied to the activation gradient before MoE down-projections. \nFor both the forward and backward combine components, we retain them in BF16 to preserve training precision in critical parts of the training pipeline." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/147", + "self_ref": "#/texts/123", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3249,19 +2781,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/148", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "We deploy", - "text": "We deploy" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/149", + "self_ref": "#/texts/124", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3269,11 +2789,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "DeepSeek-V3 on the H800 cluster, where GPUs within each node are interconnected using NVLink, and all GPUs across the cluster are fully interconnected via IB. \nTo simultaneously ensure both the Service-Level Objective (SLO) for online services and high throughput, we employ the following deployment strategy that separates the prefilling and decodingstages.", - "text": "DeepSeek-V3 on the H800 cluster, where GPUs within each node are interconnected using NVLink, and all GPUs across the cluster are fully interconnected via IB. \nTo simultaneously ensure both the Service-Level Objective (SLO) for online services and high throughput, we employ the following deployment strategy that separates the prefilling and decodingstages." + "orig": "We deploy DeepSeek-V3 on the H800 cluster, where GPUs within each node are interconnected using NVLink, and all GPUs across the cluster are fully interconnected via IB. \nTo simultaneously ensure both the Service-Level Objective (SLO) for online services and high throughput, we employ the following deployment strategy that separates the prefilling and decodingstages.", + "text": "We deploy DeepSeek-V3 on the H800 cluster, where GPUs within each node are interconnected using NVLink, and all GPUs across the cluster are fully interconnected via IB. \nTo simultaneously ensure both the Service-Level Objective (SLO) for online services and high throughput, we employ the following deployment strategy that separates the prefilling and decodingstages." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/150", + "self_ref": "#/texts/125", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3286,19 +2806,7 @@ "level": 3 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/151", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "The minimum deployment unit of the prefilling stage consists of 4 nodes with 32 GPUs. \nThe", - "text": "The minimum deployment unit of the prefilling stage consists of 4 nodes with 32 GPUs. \nThe" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/152", + "self_ref": "#/texts/126", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3306,23 +2814,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "attention part employs 4-way Tensor Parallelism (TP4) with Sequence Parallelism (SP), combined with 8-way Data Parallelism (DP8).\nIts small TP size of 4 limits the overhead of TP communication. \nFor the MoE part, we use 32-way Expert Parallelism (EP32), which ensures that each expert processes a sufficiently large batch size, thereby enhancing computational efficiency. \nFor the MoEall-to-all communication, we use the same method as in training: first transferring tokens across nodes via IB, and then forwarding among the intra-node GPUs via NVLink. \nIn particular, we use 1-way Tensor Parallelism for the dense MLPs in shallow layers to save TP communication.", - "text": "attention part employs 4-way Tensor Parallelism (TP4) with Sequence Parallelism (SP), combined with 8-way Data Parallelism (DP8).\nIts small TP size of 4 limits the overhead of TP communication. \nFor the MoE part, we use 32-way Expert Parallelism (EP32), which ensures that each expert processes a sufficiently large batch size, thereby enhancing computational efficiency. \nFor the MoEall-to-all communication, we use the same method as in training: first transferring tokens across nodes via IB, and then forwarding among the intra-node GPUs via NVLink. \nIn particular, we use 1-way Tensor Parallelism for the dense MLPs in shallow layers to save TP communication." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/153", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "To achieve load balancing among different experts in the", - "text": "To achieve load balancing among different experts in the" + "orig": "The minimum deployment unit of the prefilling stage consists of 4 nodes with 32 GPUs. \nThe attention part employs 4-way Tensor Parallelism (TP4) with Sequence Parallelism (SP), combined with 8-way Data Parallelism (DP8).\nIts small TP size of 4 limits the overhead of TP communication. \nFor the MoE part, we use 32-way Expert Parallelism (EP32), which ensures that each expert processes a sufficiently large batch size, thereby enhancing computational efficiency. \nFor the MoEall-to-all communication, we use the same method as in training: first transferring tokens across nodes via IB, and then forwarding among the intra-node GPUs via NVLink. \nIn particular, we use 1-way Tensor Parallelism for the dense MLPs in shallow layers to save TP communication.", + "text": "The minimum deployment unit of the prefilling stage consists of 4 nodes with 32 GPUs. \nThe attention part employs 4-way Tensor Parallelism (TP4) with Sequence Parallelism (SP), combined with 8-way Data Parallelism (DP8).\nIts small TP size of 4 limits the overhead of TP communication. \nFor the MoE part, we use 32-way Expert Parallelism (EP32), which ensures that each expert processes a sufficiently large batch size, thereby enhancing computational efficiency. \nFor the MoEall-to-all communication, we use the same method as in training: first transferring tokens across nodes via IB, and then forwarding among the intra-node GPUs via NVLink. \nIn particular, we use 1-way Tensor Parallelism for the dense MLPs in shallow layers to save TP communication." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/154", + "self_ref": "#/texts/127", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3330,23 +2826,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "MoE part, we need to ensure that each GPU processes approximately the same number of tokens. \nTo this end, we introduce a deployment strategy of redundant experts, which duplicates high-load experts and deploys them redundantly. \nThe high-load experts are detected based on statistics collected during the online deployment and are adjusted periodically (e.g., every 10 minutes). \nAfter determining the set of redundant experts, we carefully rearrange experts among GPUs within a node based on the observed loads, striving to balance the load across GPUs as much as possible without increasing the cross-node all-to-all communication overhead. \nFor the deployment of DeepSeek-V3, we set 32 redundant experts for the prefilling stage. \nFor each GPU, besides the original 8 experts it hosts, it will also host one additional redundant expert.", - "text": "MoE part, we need to ensure that each GPU processes approximately the same number of tokens. \nTo this end, we introduce a deployment strategy of redundant experts, which duplicates high-load experts and deploys them redundantly. \nThe high-load experts are detected based on statistics collected during the online deployment and are adjusted periodically (e.g., every 10 minutes). \nAfter determining the set of redundant experts, we carefully rearrange experts among GPUs within a node based on the observed loads, striving to balance the load across GPUs as much as possible without increasing the cross-node all-to-all communication overhead. \nFor the deployment of DeepSeek-V3, we set 32 redundant experts for the prefilling stage. \nFor each GPU, besides the original 8 experts it hosts, it will also host one additional redundant expert." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/155", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Furthermore, in the prefilling stage, to improve the throughput and hide the overhead of all-to-all and TP communication, we simultaneously process two micro-batches with similar computational workloads, overlapping the", - "text": "Furthermore, in the prefilling stage, to improve the throughput and hide the overhead of all-to-all and TP communication, we simultaneously process two micro-batches with similar computational workloads, overlapping the" + "orig": "To achieve load balancing among different experts in the MoE part, we need to ensure that each GPU processes approximately the same number of tokens. \nTo this end, we introduce a deployment strategy of redundant experts, which duplicates high-load experts and deploys them redundantly. \nThe high-load experts are detected based on statistics collected during the online deployment and are adjusted periodically (e.g., every 10 minutes). \nAfter determining the set of redundant experts, we carefully rearrange experts among GPUs within a node based on the observed loads, striving to balance the load across GPUs as much as possible without increasing the cross-node all-to-all communication overhead. \nFor the deployment of DeepSeek-V3, we set 32 redundant experts for the prefilling stage. \nFor each GPU, besides the original 8 experts it hosts, it will also host one additional redundant expert.", + "text": "To achieve load balancing among different experts in the MoE part, we need to ensure that each GPU processes approximately the same number of tokens. \nTo this end, we introduce a deployment strategy of redundant experts, which duplicates high-load experts and deploys them redundantly. \nThe high-load experts are detected based on statistics collected during the online deployment and are adjusted periodically (e.g., every 10 minutes). \nAfter determining the set of redundant experts, we carefully rearrange experts among GPUs within a node based on the observed loads, striving to balance the load across GPUs as much as possible without increasing the cross-node all-to-all communication overhead. \nFor the deployment of DeepSeek-V3, we set 32 redundant experts for the prefilling stage. \nFor each GPU, besides the original 8 experts it hosts, it will also host one additional redundant expert." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/156", + "self_ref": "#/texts/128", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3354,23 +2838,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "attention and MoE of one micro-batch with the dispatch and combineof another.", - "text": "attention and MoE of one micro-batch with the dispatch and combineof another." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/157", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Finally, we are exploring a", - "text": "Finally, we are exploring a" + "orig": "Furthermore, in the prefilling stage, to improve the throughput and hide the overhead of all-to-all and TP communication, we simultaneously process two micro-batches with similar computational workloads, overlapping the attention and MoE of one micro-batch with the dispatch and combineof another.", + "text": "Furthermore, in the prefilling stage, to improve the throughput and hide the overhead of all-to-all and TP communication, we simultaneously process two micro-batches with similar computational workloads, overlapping the attention and MoE of one micro-batch with the dispatch and combineof another." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/158", + "self_ref": "#/texts/129", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3378,11 +2850,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "dynamic redundancystrategy for experts, where each GPU hosts more experts (e.g., 16 experts), but only 9 will be activated during each inference step. \nBefore the all-to-all operation at each layer begins, we compute the globally optimal routing scheme on the fly. \nGiven the substantial computation involved in the prefilling stage, the overhead of computing this routing scheme is almost negligible.", - "text": "dynamic redundancystrategy for experts, where each GPU hosts more experts (e.g., 16 experts), but only 9 will be activated during each inference step. \nBefore the all-to-all operation at each layer begins, we compute the globally optimal routing scheme on the fly. \nGiven the substantial computation involved in the prefilling stage, the overhead of computing this routing scheme is almost negligible." + "orig": "Finally, we are exploring a dynamic redundancystrategy for experts, where each GPU hosts more experts (e.g., 16 experts), but only 9 will be activated during each inference step. \nBefore the all-to-all operation at each layer begins, we compute the globally optimal routing scheme on the fly. \nGiven the substantial computation involved in the prefilling stage, the overhead of computing this routing scheme is almost negligible.", + "text": "Finally, we are exploring a dynamic redundancystrategy for experts, where each GPU hosts more experts (e.g., 16 experts), but only 9 will be activated during each inference step. \nBefore the all-to-all operation at each layer begins, we compute the globally optimal routing scheme on the fly. \nGiven the substantial computation involved in the prefilling stage, the overhead of computing this routing scheme is almost negligible." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/159", + "self_ref": "#/texts/130", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3395,19 +2867,7 @@ "level": 3 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/160", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "During decoding, we treat the shared expert as a routed one. \nFrom this perspective, each token will select 9 experts during routing, where the shared expert is regarded as a heavy-load one that will always be selected. \nThe minimum deployment unit of the decoding stage consists of 40 nodes with 320 GPUs. \nThe", - "text": "During decoding, we treat the shared expert as a routed one. \nFrom this perspective, each token will select 9 experts during routing, where the shared expert is regarded as a heavy-load one that will always be selected. \nThe minimum deployment unit of the decoding stage consists of 40 nodes with 320 GPUs. \nThe" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/161", + "self_ref": "#/texts/131", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3415,23 +2875,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "attention part employs TP4 with SP, combined with DP80, while the MoE part uses EP320. \nFor the MoE part, each GPU hosts only one expert, and 64 GPUs are responsible for hosting redundant experts and shared experts.\nAll-to-all communication of the dispatch and combine parts is performed via direct point-to-point transfers over IB to achieve low latency. \nAdditionally, we leverage the IBGDA[nvidia_ibgda]technology to further minimize latency and enhance communication efficiency.", - "text": "attention part employs TP4 with SP, combined with DP80, while the MoE part uses EP320. \nFor the MoE part, each GPU hosts only one expert, and 64 GPUs are responsible for hosting redundant experts and shared experts.\nAll-to-all communication of the dispatch and combine parts is performed via direct point-to-point transfers over IB to achieve low latency. \nAdditionally, we leverage the IBGDA[nvidia_ibgda]technology to further minimize latency and enhance communication efficiency." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/162", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Similar to prefilling, we periodically determine the set of redundant experts in a certain interval, based on the statistical expert load from our online service. \nHowever, we do not need to rearrange experts since each GPU only hosts one expert. \nWe are also exploring the", - "text": "Similar to prefilling, we periodically determine the set of redundant experts in a certain interval, based on the statistical expert load from our online service. \nHowever, we do not need to rearrange experts since each GPU only hosts one expert. \nWe are also exploring the" + "orig": "During decoding, we treat the shared expert as a routed one. \nFrom this perspective, each token will select 9 experts during routing, where the shared expert is regarded as a heavy-load one that will always be selected. \nThe minimum deployment unit of the decoding stage consists of 40 nodes with 320 GPUs. \nThe attention part employs TP4 with SP, combined with DP80, while the MoE part uses EP320. \nFor the MoE part, each GPU hosts only one expert, and 64 GPUs are responsible for hosting redundant experts and shared experts.\nAll-to-all communication of the dispatch and combine parts is performed via direct point-to-point transfers over IB to achieve low latency. \nAdditionally, we leverage the IBGDA[nvidia_ibgda]technology to further minimize latency and enhance communication efficiency.", + "text": "During decoding, we treat the shared expert as a routed one. \nFrom this perspective, each token will select 9 experts during routing, where the shared expert is regarded as a heavy-load one that will always be selected. \nThe minimum deployment unit of the decoding stage consists of 40 nodes with 320 GPUs. \nThe attention part employs TP4 with SP, combined with DP80, while the MoE part uses EP320. \nFor the MoE part, each GPU hosts only one expert, and 64 GPUs are responsible for hosting redundant experts and shared experts.\nAll-to-all communication of the dispatch and combine parts is performed via direct point-to-point transfers over IB to achieve low latency. \nAdditionally, we leverage the IBGDA[nvidia_ibgda]technology to further minimize latency and enhance communication efficiency." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/163", + "self_ref": "#/texts/132", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3439,23 +2887,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "dynamic redundancy strategy for decoding. \nHowever, this requires more careful optimization of the algorithm that computes the globally optimal routing scheme and the fusion with the dispatchkernel to reduce overhead.", - "text": "dynamic redundancy strategy for decoding. \nHowever, this requires more careful optimization of the algorithm that computes the globally optimal routing scheme and the fusion with the dispatchkernel to reduce overhead." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/164", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Additionally, to enhance throughput and hide the overhead of all-to-all communication, we are also exploring processing two micro-batches with similar computational workloads simultaneously in the decoding stage. \nUnlike prefilling,", - "text": "Additionally, to enhance throughput and hide the overhead of all-to-all communication, we are also exploring processing two micro-batches with similar computational workloads simultaneously in the decoding stage. \nUnlike prefilling," + "orig": "Similar to prefilling, we periodically determine the set of redundant experts in a certain interval, based on the statistical expert load from our online service. \nHowever, we do not need to rearrange experts since each GPU only hosts one expert. \nWe are also exploring the dynamic redundancy strategy for decoding. \nHowever, this requires more careful optimization of the algorithm that computes the globally optimal routing scheme and the fusion with the dispatchkernel to reduce overhead.", + "text": "Similar to prefilling, we periodically determine the set of redundant experts in a certain interval, based on the statistical expert load from our online service. \nHowever, we do not need to rearrange experts since each GPU only hosts one expert. \nWe are also exploring the dynamic redundancy strategy for decoding. \nHowever, this requires more careful optimization of the algorithm that computes the globally optimal routing scheme and the fusion with the dispatchkernel to reduce overhead." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/165", + "self_ref": "#/texts/133", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3463,11 +2899,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "attention consumes a larger portion of time in the decoding stage. Therefore, we overlap the attention of one micro-batch with the dispatch+MoE+combine of another.\nIn the decoding stage, the batch size per expert is relatively small (usually within 256 tokens), and the bottleneck is memory access rather than computation. \nSince the MoE part only needs to load the parameters of one expert, the memory access overhead is minimal, so using fewer SMs will not significantly affect the overall performance.\nTherefore, to avoid impacting the computation speed of the attention part, we can allocate only a small portion of SMs to dispatch+MoE+combine.", - "text": "attention consumes a larger portion of time in the decoding stage. Therefore, we overlap the attention of one micro-batch with the dispatch+MoE+combine of another.\nIn the decoding stage, the batch size per expert is relatively small (usually within 256 tokens), and the bottleneck is memory access rather than computation. \nSince the MoE part only needs to load the parameters of one expert, the memory access overhead is minimal, so using fewer SMs will not significantly affect the overall performance.\nTherefore, to avoid impacting the computation speed of the attention part, we can allocate only a small portion of SMs to dispatch+MoE+combine." + "orig": "Additionally, to enhance throughput and hide the overhead of all-to-all communication, we are also exploring processing two micro-batches with similar computational workloads simultaneously in the decoding stage. \nUnlike prefilling, attention consumes a larger portion of time in the decoding stage. Therefore, we overlap the attention of one micro-batch with the dispatch+MoE+combine of another.\nIn the decoding stage, the batch size per expert is relatively small (usually within 256 tokens), and the bottleneck is memory access rather than computation. \nSince the MoE part only needs to load the parameters of one expert, the memory access overhead is minimal, so using fewer SMs will not significantly affect the overall performance.\nTherefore, to avoid impacting the computation speed of the attention part, we can allocate only a small portion of SMs to dispatch+MoE+combine.", + "text": "Additionally, to enhance throughput and hide the overhead of all-to-all communication, we are also exploring processing two micro-batches with similar computational workloads simultaneously in the decoding stage. \nUnlike prefilling, attention consumes a larger portion of time in the decoding stage. Therefore, we overlap the attention of one micro-batch with the dispatch+MoE+combine of another.\nIn the decoding stage, the batch size per expert is relatively small (usually within 256 tokens), and the bottleneck is memory access rather than computation. \nSince the MoE part only needs to load the parameters of one expert, the memory access overhead is minimal, so using fewer SMs will not significantly affect the overall performance.\nTherefore, to avoid impacting the computation speed of the attention part, we can allocate only a small portion of SMs to dispatch+MoE+combine." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/166", + "self_ref": "#/texts/134", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3480,7 +2916,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/167", + "self_ref": "#/texts/135", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3492,7 +2928,7 @@ "text": "Based on our implementation of the all-to-all communication and FP8 training scheme, we propose the following suggestions on chip design to AI hardware vendors." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/168", + "self_ref": "#/texts/136", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3505,19 +2941,7 @@ "level": 3 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/169", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "In", - "text": "In" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/170", + "self_ref": "#/texts/137", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3525,23 +2949,23 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "DeepSeek-V3, we implement the overlap between computation and communication to hide the communication latency during computation. \nThis significantly reduces the dependency on communication bandwidth compared to serial computation and communication. \nHowever, the current communication implementation relies on expensive SMs (e.g., we allocate 20 out of the 132 SMs available in the H800 GPU for this purpose), which will limit the computational throughput.\nMoreover, using SMs for communication results in significant inefficiencies, as tensor cores remain entirely under-utilized.", - "text": "DeepSeek-V3, we implement the overlap between computation and communication to hide the communication latency during computation. \nThis significantly reduces the dependency on communication bandwidth compared to serial computation and communication. \nHowever, the current communication implementation relies on expensive SMs (e.g., we allocate 20 out of the 132 SMs available in the H800 GPU for this purpose), which will limit the computational throughput.\nMoreover, using SMs for communication results in significant inefficiencies, as tensor cores remain entirely under-utilized." + "orig": "In DeepSeek-V3, we implement the overlap between computation and communication to hide the communication latency during computation. \nThis significantly reduces the dependency on communication bandwidth compared to serial computation and communication. \nHowever, the current communication implementation relies on expensive SMs (e.g., we allocate 20 out of the 132 SMs available in the H800 GPU for this purpose), which will limit the computational throughput.\nMoreover, using SMs for communication results in significant inefficiencies, as tensor cores remain entirely under-utilized.", + "text": "In DeepSeek-V3, we implement the overlap between computation and communication to hide the communication latency during computation. \nThis significantly reduces the dependency on communication bandwidth compared to serial computation and communication. \nHowever, the current communication implementation relies on expensive SMs (e.g., we allocate 20 out of the 132 SMs available in the H800 GPU for this purpose), which will limit the computational throughput.\nMoreover, using SMs for communication results in significant inefficiencies, as tensor cores remain entirely under-utilized." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/171", + "self_ref": "#/texts/138", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], "orig": "Currently, the SMs primarily perform the following tasks for all-to-all communication:", "text": "Currently, the SMs primarily perform the following tasks for all-to-all communication:" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/172", + "self_ref": "#/texts/139", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/11" }, @@ -3555,7 +2979,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/173", + "self_ref": "#/texts/140", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/11" }, @@ -3569,7 +2993,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/174", + "self_ref": "#/texts/141", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/11" }, @@ -3583,7 +3007,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/175", + "self_ref": "#/texts/142", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/11" }, @@ -3597,19 +3021,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/176", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "We aspire to see future vendors developing hardware that offloads these communication tasks from the valuable computation unit SM, serving as a GPU co-processor or a network co-processor like NVIDIA SHARP", - "text": "We aspire to see future vendors developing hardware that offloads these communication tasks from the valuable computation unit SM, serving as a GPU co-processor or a network co-processor like NVIDIA SHARP" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/177", + "self_ref": "#/texts/143", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3617,11 +3029,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[nvsharp]. \nFurthermore, to reduce application programming complexity, we aim for this hardware to unify the IB (scale-out) and NVLink (scale-up) networks from the perspective of the computation units. \nWith this unified interface, computation units can easily accomplish operations such as read, write, multicast, and reduceacross the entire IB-NVLink-unified domain via submitting communication requests based on simple primitives.", - "text": "[nvsharp]. \nFurthermore, to reduce application programming complexity, we aim for this hardware to unify the IB (scale-out) and NVLink (scale-up) networks from the perspective of the computation units. \nWith this unified interface, computation units can easily accomplish operations such as read, write, multicast, and reduceacross the entire IB-NVLink-unified domain via submitting communication requests based on simple primitives." + "orig": "We aspire to see future vendors developing hardware that offloads these communication tasks from the valuable computation unit SM, serving as a GPU co-processor or a network co-processor like NVIDIA SHARP[nvsharp]. \nFurthermore, to reduce application programming complexity, we aim for this hardware to unify the IB (scale-out) and NVLink (scale-up) networks from the perspective of the computation units. \nWith this unified interface, computation units can easily accomplish operations such as read, write, multicast, and reduceacross the entire IB-NVLink-unified domain via submitting communication requests based on simple primitives.", + "text": "We aspire to see future vendors developing hardware that offloads these communication tasks from the valuable computation unit SM, serving as a GPU co-processor or a network co-processor like NVIDIA SHARP[nvsharp]. \nFurthermore, to reduce application programming complexity, we aim for this hardware to unify the IB (scale-out) and NVLink (scale-up) networks from the perspective of the computation units. \nWith this unified interface, computation units can easily accomplish operations such as read, write, multicast, and reduceacross the entire IB-NVLink-unified domain via submitting communication requests based on simple primitives." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/178", + "self_ref": "#/texts/144", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3634,7 +3046,7 @@ "level": 3 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/179", + "self_ref": "#/texts/145", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3646,7 +3058,7 @@ "text": "Higher FP8 GEMM Accumulation Precision in Tensor Cores.\nIn the current Tensor Core implementation of the NVIDIA Hopper architecture, FP8 GEMM suffers from limited accumulation precision. After aligning 32 mantissa products by right-shifting based on the maximum exponent, the Tensor Core only uses the highest 14 bits of each mantissa product for addition, and truncates bits exceeding this range. The accumulation of addition results into registers also employs 14-bit precision. Our implementation partially mitigates the limitation by accumulating the addition results of 128 FP8$\\times$FP8 multiplications into registers with FP32 precision in the CUDA core. \nAlthough helpful in achieving successful FP8 training, it is merely a compromise due to the Hopper architecture's hardware deficiency in FP8 GEMM accumulation precision.\nFuture chips need to adopt higher precision." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/180", + "self_ref": "#/texts/146", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3658,7 +3070,7 @@ "text": "Support for Tile- and Block-Wise Quantization.\nCurrent GPUs only support per-tensor quantization, lacking the native support for fine-grained quantization like our tile- and block-wise quantization.\nIn the current implementation, when the $N_C$interval is reached, the partial results will be copied from Tensor Cores to CUDA cores, multiplied by the scaling factors, and added to FP32 registers on CUDA cores.\nAlthough the dequantization overhead is significantly mitigated combined with our precise FP32 accumulation strategy, the frequent data movements between Tensor Cores and CUDA cores still limit the computational efficiency. \nTherefore, we recommend future chips to support fine-grained quantization by enabling Tensor Cores to receive scaling factors and implement MMA with group scaling. \nIn this way, the whole partial sum accumulation and dequantization can be completed directly inside Tensor Cores until the final result is produced, avoiding frequent data movements." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/181", + "self_ref": "#/texts/147", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3670,7 +3082,7 @@ "text": "Support for Online Quantization.\nThe current implementations struggle to effectively support online quantization, despite its effectiveness demonstrated in our research. \nIn the existing process, we need to read 128 BF16 activation values (the output of the previous computation) from HBM (High Bandwidth Memory) for quantization, and the quantized FP8 values are then written back to HBM, only to be read again for MMA. \nTo address this inefficiency, we recommend that future chips integrate FP8 cast and TMA (Tensor Memory Accelerator) access into a single fused operation, so quantization can be completed during the transfer of activations from global memory to shared memory, avoiding frequent memory reads and writes. \nWe also recommend supporting a warp-level cast instruction for speedup, which further facilitates the better fusion of layer normalization and FP8 cast.\nAlternatively, a near-memory computing approach can be adopted, where compute logic is placed near the HBM. \nIn this case, BF16 elements can be cast to FP8 directly as they are read from HBM into the GPU, reducing off-chip memory access by roughly 50%." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/182", + "self_ref": "#/texts/148", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3682,7 +3094,7 @@ "text": "Support for Transposed GEMM Operations.\nThe current architecture makes it cumbersome to fuse matrix transposition with GEMM operations. \nIn our workflow, activations during the forward pass are quantized into 1x128 FP8 tiles and stored. \nDuring the backward pass, the matrix needs to be read out, dequantized, transposed, re-quantized into 128x1tiles, and stored in HBM. \nTo reduce memory operations, we recommend future chips to enable direct transposed reads of matrices from shared memory before MMA operation, for those precisions required in both training and inference. Combined with the fusion of FP8 format conversion and TMA access, this enhancement will significantly streamline the quantization workflow." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/183", + "self_ref": "#/texts/149", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3695,7 +3107,7 @@ "level": 1 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/184", + "self_ref": "#/texts/150", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3708,19 +3120,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/185", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Compared with", - "text": "Compared with" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/186", + "self_ref": "#/texts/151", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3728,23 +3128,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "DeepSeek-V2, we optimize the pre-training corpus by enhancing the ratio of mathematical and programming samples, while expanding multilingual coverage beyond English and Chinese. \nAlso, our data processing pipeline is refined to minimize redundancy while maintaining corpus diversity. \nInspired by [Ding2024FewerTI], we implement the document packing method for data integrity but do not incorporate cross-sample attention masking during training. \nFinally, the training corpus for DeepSeek-V3consists of 14.8T high-quality and diverse tokens in our tokenizer.", - "text": "DeepSeek-V2, we optimize the pre-training corpus by enhancing the ratio of mathematical and programming samples, while expanding multilingual coverage beyond English and Chinese. \nAlso, our data processing pipeline is refined to minimize redundancy while maintaining corpus diversity. \nInspired by [Ding2024FewerTI], we implement the document packing method for data integrity but do not incorporate cross-sample attention masking during training. \nFinally, the training corpus for DeepSeek-V3consists of 14.8T high-quality and diverse tokens in our tokenizer." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/187", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "In the training process of DeepSeekCoder-V2", - "text": "In the training process of DeepSeekCoder-V2" + "orig": "Compared with DeepSeek-V2, we optimize the pre-training corpus by enhancing the ratio of mathematical and programming samples, while expanding multilingual coverage beyond English and Chinese. \nAlso, our data processing pipeline is refined to minimize redundancy while maintaining corpus diversity. \nInspired by [Ding2024FewerTI], we implement the document packing method for data integrity but do not incorporate cross-sample attention masking during training. \nFinally, the training corpus for DeepSeek-V3consists of 14.8T high-quality and diverse tokens in our tokenizer.", + "text": "Compared with DeepSeek-V2, we optimize the pre-training corpus by enhancing the ratio of mathematical and programming samples, while expanding multilingual coverage beyond English and Chinese. \nAlso, our data processing pipeline is refined to minimize redundancy while maintaining corpus diversity. \nInspired by [Ding2024FewerTI], we implement the document packing method for data integrity but do not incorporate cross-sample attention masking during training. \nFinally, the training corpus for DeepSeek-V3consists of 14.8T high-quality and diverse tokens in our tokenizer." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/188", + "self_ref": "#/texts/152", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3752,11 +3140,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[dscodervii], we observe that the Fill-in-Middle(FIM) strategy does not compromise the next-token prediction capability while enabling the model to accurately predict middle text based on contextual cues. \nIn alignment with DeepSeekCoder-V2, we also incorporate the FIM strategy in the pre-training of DeepSeek-V3. \nTo be specific, we employ the Prefix-Suffix-Middle (PSM) framework to structure data as follows:", - "text": "[dscodervii], we observe that the Fill-in-Middle(FIM) strategy does not compromise the next-token prediction capability while enabling the model to accurately predict middle text based on contextual cues. \nIn alignment with DeepSeekCoder-V2, we also incorporate the FIM strategy in the pre-training of DeepSeek-V3. \nTo be specific, we employ the Prefix-Suffix-Middle (PSM) framework to structure data as follows:" + "orig": "In the training process of DeepSeekCoder-V2[dscodervii], we observe that the Fill-in-Middle(FIM) strategy does not compromise the next-token prediction capability while enabling the model to accurately predict middle text based on contextual cues. \nIn alignment with DeepSeekCoder-V2, we also incorporate the FIM strategy in the pre-training of DeepSeek-V3. \nTo be specific, we employ the Prefix-Suffix-Middle (PSM) framework to structure data as follows:", + "text": "In the training process of DeepSeekCoder-V2[dscodervii], we observe that the Fill-in-Middle(FIM) strategy does not compromise the next-token prediction capability while enabling the model to accurately predict middle text based on contextual cues. \nIn alignment with DeepSeekCoder-V2, we also incorporate the FIM strategy in the pre-training of DeepSeek-V3. \nTo be specific, we employ the Prefix-Suffix-Middle (PSM) framework to structure data as follows:" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/189", + "self_ref": "#/texts/153", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3768,7 +3156,7 @@ "text": "\\begin{align}\n\\texttt{<|fim\\_begin|>}f_{\\text{pre}}\\texttt{<|fim\\_hole|>}f_{\\text{suf}}\\texttt{<|fim\\_end|>}f_{\\text{middle}}\\texttt{<|eos\\_token|>} . \\nonumber\n\\end{align}" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/190", + "self_ref": "#/texts/154", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3780,19 +3168,7 @@ "text": "This structure is applied at the document level as a part of the pre-packing process. \nThe FIM strategy is applied at a rate of 0.1, consistent with the PSM framework." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/191", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "The tokenizer for", - "text": "The tokenizer for" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/192", + "self_ref": "#/texts/155", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3800,11 +3176,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "DeepSeek-V3 employs Byte-level BPE[shibata1999byte] with an extended vocabulary of 128K tokens. \nThe pretokenizer and training data for our tokenizer are modified to optimize multilingual compression efficiency. \nIn addition, compared with DeepSeek-V2, the new pretokenizer introduces tokens that combine punctuations and line breaks. \nHowever, this trick may introduce the token boundary bias[tokenboundary]when the model processes multi-line prompts without terminal line breaks, particularly for few-shot evaluation prompts. \nTo address this issue, we randomly split a certain proportion of such combined tokens during training, which exposes the model to a wider array of special cases and mitigates this bias.", - "text": "DeepSeek-V3 employs Byte-level BPE[shibata1999byte] with an extended vocabulary of 128K tokens. \nThe pretokenizer and training data for our tokenizer are modified to optimize multilingual compression efficiency. \nIn addition, compared with DeepSeek-V2, the new pretokenizer introduces tokens that combine punctuations and line breaks. \nHowever, this trick may introduce the token boundary bias[tokenboundary]when the model processes multi-line prompts without terminal line breaks, particularly for few-shot evaluation prompts. \nTo address this issue, we randomly split a certain proportion of such combined tokens during training, which exposes the model to a wider array of special cases and mitigates this bias." + "orig": "The tokenizer for DeepSeek-V3 employs Byte-level BPE[shibata1999byte] with an extended vocabulary of 128K tokens. \nThe pretokenizer and training data for our tokenizer are modified to optimize multilingual compression efficiency. \nIn addition, compared with DeepSeek-V2, the new pretokenizer introduces tokens that combine punctuations and line breaks. \nHowever, this trick may introduce the token boundary bias[tokenboundary]when the model processes multi-line prompts without terminal line breaks, particularly for few-shot evaluation prompts. \nTo address this issue, we randomly split a certain proportion of such combined tokens during training, which exposes the model to a wider array of special cases and mitigates this bias.", + "text": "The tokenizer for DeepSeek-V3 employs Byte-level BPE[shibata1999byte] with an extended vocabulary of 128K tokens. \nThe pretokenizer and training data for our tokenizer are modified to optimize multilingual compression efficiency. \nIn addition, compared with DeepSeek-V2, the new pretokenizer introduces tokens that combine punctuations and line breaks. \nHowever, this trick may introduce the token boundary bias[tokenboundary]when the model processes multi-line prompts without terminal line breaks, particularly for few-shot evaluation prompts. \nTo address this issue, we randomly split a certain proportion of such combined tokens during training, which exposes the model to a wider array of special cases and mitigates this bias." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/193", + "self_ref": "#/texts/156", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3817,7 +3193,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/194", + "self_ref": "#/texts/157", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3829,7 +3205,7 @@ "text": "Model Hyper-Parameters.\nWe set the number of Transformer layers to 61 and the hidden dimension to 7168. \nAll learnable parameters are randomly initialized with a standard deviation of 0.006.\nIn MLA, we set the number of attention heads $n_h$ to 128 and the per-head dimension $d_h$ to 128. \nThe KV compression dimension $d_c$ is set to 512, and the query compression dimension $d_c^{\\prime}$ is set to 1536. \nFor the decoupled queries and key, we set the per-head dimension $d_h^R$ to 64. \nWe substitute all FFNs except for the first three layers with MoE layers. \nEach MoE layer consists of 1 shared expert and 256 routed experts, where the intermediate hidden dimension of each expert is 2048. \nAmong the routed experts, 8 experts will be activated for each token, and each token will be ensured to be sent to at most 4 nodes. \nThe multi-token prediction depth $D$ is set to 1, i.e., besides the exact next token, each token will predict one additional token. \nAs DeepSeek-V2, DeepSeek-V3 also employs additional RMSNorm layers after the compressed latent vectors, and multiplies additional scaling factors at the width bottlenecks. \nUnder this configuration, DeepSeek-V3comprises 671B total parameters, of which 37B are activated for each token." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/195", + "self_ref": "#/texts/158", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3841,7 +3217,7 @@ "text": "Training Hyper-Parameters.\nWe employ the AdamW optimizer[adamW] with hyper-parameters set to $\\beta_1=0.9$, $\\beta_2=0.95$, and $\\mathrm{weight\\_decay}=0.1$. \nWe set the maximum sequence length to 4K during pre-training, and pre-train DeepSeek-V3 on 14.8T tokens. \nAs for the learning rate scheduling, we first linearly increase it from 0 to $2.2 \\times 10^{-4}$ during the first 2K steps. \nThen, we keep a constant learning rate of $2.2 \\times 10^{-4}$ until the model consumes 10T training tokens. \nSubsequently, we gradually decay the learning rate to $2.2 \\times 10^{-5}$ in 4.3T tokens, following a cosine decay curve. \nDuring the training of the final 500B tokens, we keep a constant learning rate of $2.2 \\times 10^{-5}$ in the first 333B tokens, and switch to another constant learning rate of $7.3 \\times 10^{-6}$ in the remaining 167B tokens. \nThe gradient clipping norm is set to 1.0.\nWe employ a batch size scheduling strategy, where the batch size is gradually increased from 3072 to 15360 in the training of the first 469B tokens, and then keeps 15360 in the remaining training. \nWe leverage pipeline parallelism to deploy different layers of a model on different GPUs, and for each layer, the routed experts will be uniformly deployed on 64 GPUs belonging to 8 nodes. \nAs for the node-limited routing, each token will be sent to at most 4 nodes (i.e., $M=4$). \nFor auxiliary-loss-free load balancing, we set the bias update speed $\\gamma$ to 0.001 for the first 14.3T tokens, and to 0.0 for the remaining 500B tokens. \nFor the balance loss, we set $\\alpha$ to 0.0001, just to avoid extreme imbalance within any single sequence. \nThe MTP loss weight $\\lambda$is set to 0.3 for the first 10T tokens, and to 0.1 for the remaining 4.8T tokens." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/196", + "self_ref": "#/texts/159", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3853,7 +3229,7 @@ "text": "Image: figures/needle_in_a_haystack.pdf" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/197", + "self_ref": "#/texts/160", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/12" }, @@ -3865,7 +3241,7 @@ "text": "Evaluation results on the Needle In A Haystack (NIAH) tests. \nDeepSeek-V3 performs well across all context window lengths up to 128K." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/198", + "self_ref": "#/texts/161", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3878,19 +3254,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/199", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "We adopt a similar approach to", - "text": "We adopt a similar approach to" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/200", + "self_ref": "#/texts/162", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3898,23 +3262,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "DeepSeek-V2[dsvii] to enable long context capabilities in DeepSeek-V3. \nAfter the pre-training stage, we apply YaRN[peng2023yarn] for context extension and perform two additional training phases, each comprising 1000 steps, to progressively expand the context window from 4K to 32K and then to 128K.\nThe YaRN configuration is consistent with that used in DeepSeek-V2, being applied exclusively to the decoupled shared key $\\mathbf{k}^R_t$.\nThe hyper-parameters remain identical across both phases, with the scale $s = 40$, $\\alpha = 1$, $\\beta = 32$, and the scaling factor $\\sqrt{t} = 0.1 \\ln{s} + 1$.\nIn the first phase, the sequence length is set to 32K, and the batch size is 1920. \nDuring the second phase, the sequence length is increased to 128K, and the batch size is reduced to 480. \nThe learning rate for both phases is set to $7.3 \\times 10^{-6}$, matching the final learning rate from the pre-training stage.", - "text": "DeepSeek-V2[dsvii] to enable long context capabilities in DeepSeek-V3. \nAfter the pre-training stage, we apply YaRN[peng2023yarn] for context extension and perform two additional training phases, each comprising 1000 steps, to progressively expand the context window from 4K to 32K and then to 128K.\nThe YaRN configuration is consistent with that used in DeepSeek-V2, being applied exclusively to the decoupled shared key $\\mathbf{k}^R_t$.\nThe hyper-parameters remain identical across both phases, with the scale $s = 40$, $\\alpha = 1$, $\\beta = 32$, and the scaling factor $\\sqrt{t} = 0.1 \\ln{s} + 1$.\nIn the first phase, the sequence length is set to 32K, and the batch size is 1920. \nDuring the second phase, the sequence length is increased to 128K, and the batch size is reduced to 480. \nThe learning rate for both phases is set to $7.3 \\times 10^{-6}$, matching the final learning rate from the pre-training stage." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/201", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Through this two-phase extension training,", - "text": "Through this two-phase extension training," + "orig": "We adopt a similar approach to DeepSeek-V2[dsvii] to enable long context capabilities in DeepSeek-V3. \nAfter the pre-training stage, we apply YaRN[peng2023yarn] for context extension and perform two additional training phases, each comprising 1000 steps, to progressively expand the context window from 4K to 32K and then to 128K.\nThe YaRN configuration is consistent with that used in DeepSeek-V2, being applied exclusively to the decoupled shared key $\\mathbf{k}^R_t$.\nThe hyper-parameters remain identical across both phases, with the scale $s = 40$, $\\alpha = 1$, $\\beta = 32$, and the scaling factor $\\sqrt{t} = 0.1 \\ln{s} + 1$.\nIn the first phase, the sequence length is set to 32K, and the batch size is 1920. \nDuring the second phase, the sequence length is increased to 128K, and the batch size is reduced to 480. \nThe learning rate for both phases is set to $7.3 \\times 10^{-6}$, matching the final learning rate from the pre-training stage.", + "text": "We adopt a similar approach to DeepSeek-V2[dsvii] to enable long context capabilities in DeepSeek-V3. \nAfter the pre-training stage, we apply YaRN[peng2023yarn] for context extension and perform two additional training phases, each comprising 1000 steps, to progressively expand the context window from 4K to 32K and then to 128K.\nThe YaRN configuration is consistent with that used in DeepSeek-V2, being applied exclusively to the decoupled shared key $\\mathbf{k}^R_t$.\nThe hyper-parameters remain identical across both phases, with the scale $s = 40$, $\\alpha = 1$, $\\beta = 32$, and the scaling factor $\\sqrt{t} = 0.1 \\ln{s} + 1$.\nIn the first phase, the sequence length is set to 32K, and the batch size is 1920. \nDuring the second phase, the sequence length is increased to 128K, and the batch size is reduced to 480. \nThe learning rate for both phases is set to $7.3 \\times 10^{-6}$, matching the final learning rate from the pre-training stage." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/202", + "self_ref": "#/texts/163", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3922,11 +3274,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "DeepSeek-V3 is capable of handling inputs up to 128K in length while maintaining strong performance. \nFigure[fig:long_context] illustrates that DeepSeek-V3, following supervised fine-tuning, achieves notable performance on the \"Needle In A Haystack\" (NIAH) test, demonstrating consistent robustness across context window lengths up to 128K.", - "text": "DeepSeek-V3 is capable of handling inputs up to 128K in length while maintaining strong performance. \nFigure[fig:long_context] illustrates that DeepSeek-V3, following supervised fine-tuning, achieves notable performance on the \"Needle In A Haystack\" (NIAH) test, demonstrating consistent robustness across context window lengths up to 128K." + "orig": "Through this two-phase extension training, DeepSeek-V3 is capable of handling inputs up to 128K in length while maintaining strong performance. \nFigure[fig:long_context] illustrates that DeepSeek-V3, following supervised fine-tuning, achieves notable performance on the \"Needle In A Haystack\" (NIAH) test, demonstrating consistent robustness across context window lengths up to 128K.", + "text": "Through this two-phase extension training, DeepSeek-V3 is capable of handling inputs up to 128K in length while maintaining strong performance. \nFigure[fig:long_context] illustrates that DeepSeek-V3, following supervised fine-tuning, achieves notable performance on the \"Needle In A Haystack\" (NIAH) test, demonstrating consistent robustness across context window lengths up to 128K." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/203", + "self_ref": "#/texts/164", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3939,7 +3291,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/204", + "self_ref": "#/texts/165", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3952,19 +3304,7 @@ "level": 3 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/205", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "The base model of", - "text": "The base model of" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/206", + "self_ref": "#/texts/166", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3972,11 +3312,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "DeepSeek-V3 is pretrained on a multilingual corpus with English and Chinese constituting the majority, so we evaluate its performance on a series of benchmarks primarily in English and Chinese, as well as on a multilingual benchmark.\nOur evaluation is based on our internal evaluation framework integrated in our HAI-LLM framework. \nConsidered benchmarks are categorized and listed as follows, where underlined benchmarks are in Chinese and double-underlinedbenchmarks are multilingual ones:", - "text": "DeepSeek-V3 is pretrained on a multilingual corpus with English and Chinese constituting the majority, so we evaluate its performance on a series of benchmarks primarily in English and Chinese, as well as on a multilingual benchmark.\nOur evaluation is based on our internal evaluation framework integrated in our HAI-LLM framework. \nConsidered benchmarks are categorized and listed as follows, where underlined benchmarks are in Chinese and double-underlinedbenchmarks are multilingual ones:" + "orig": "The base model of DeepSeek-V3 is pretrained on a multilingual corpus with English and Chinese constituting the majority, so we evaluate its performance on a series of benchmarks primarily in English and Chinese, as well as on a multilingual benchmark.\nOur evaluation is based on our internal evaluation framework integrated in our HAI-LLM framework. \nConsidered benchmarks are categorized and listed as follows, where underlined benchmarks are in Chinese and double-underlinedbenchmarks are multilingual ones:", + "text": "The base model of DeepSeek-V3 is pretrained on a multilingual corpus with English and Chinese constituting the majority, so we evaluate its performance on a series of benchmarks primarily in English and Chinese, as well as on a multilingual benchmark.\nOur evaluation is based on our internal evaluation framework integrated in our HAI-LLM framework. \nConsidered benchmarks are categorized and listed as follows, where underlined benchmarks are in Chinese and double-underlinedbenchmarks are multilingual ones:" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/207", + "self_ref": "#/texts/167", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -3988,7 +3328,7 @@ "text": "Multi-subject multiple-choice datasets include MMLU [mmlu], MMLU-Redux [mmlu_redux], MMLU-Pro [mmlu_pro], MMMLU [mmmlu], C-Eval [ceval], and CMMLU [cmmlu]." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/208", + "self_ref": "#/texts/168", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4000,7 +3340,7 @@ "text": "Language understanding and reasoning datasets include HellaSwag [hellaswag], PIQA [piqa], ARC [arc], and BigBench Hard (BBH) [bbh]." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/209", + "self_ref": "#/texts/169", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4012,7 +3352,7 @@ "text": "Closed-book question answering datasets include TriviaQA [joshi-etal-2017-triviaqa] and NaturalQuestions [naturalquestions]." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/210", + "self_ref": "#/texts/170", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4024,7 +3364,7 @@ "text": "Reading comprehension datasets include RACE [race], DROP [drop], C3 [sun2019investigating], and CMRC [cui-etal-2019-span]." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/211", + "self_ref": "#/texts/171", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4036,7 +3376,7 @@ "text": "Reference disambiguation datasets include CLUEWSC [clue] and WinoGrande [sakaguchi2019winogrande]." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/212", + "self_ref": "#/texts/172", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4048,7 +3388,7 @@ "text": "Language modeling datasets include Pile [pile]." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/213", + "self_ref": "#/texts/173", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4060,7 +3400,7 @@ "text": "Chinese understanding and culture datasets include CCPM [li2021ccpm]." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/214", + "self_ref": "#/texts/174", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4072,7 +3412,7 @@ "text": "Math datasets include GSM8K[gsm8k], MATH[hendrycks2021measuring], MGSM [mgsm], and CMath [wei2023cmath]." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/215", + "self_ref": "#/texts/175", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4084,7 +3424,7 @@ "text": "Code datasets include HumanEval[codex], LiveCodeBench-Base (0801-1101) [livecodebench], MBPP[mbpp], and CRUXEval[gu2024cruxeval]." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/216", + "self_ref": "#/texts/176", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4096,7 +3436,7 @@ "text": "Standardized exams include AGIEval [agieval]. \nNote that AGIEval includes both English and Chinese subsets." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/217", + "self_ref": "#/texts/177", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4108,7 +3448,7 @@ "text": "Following our previous work[dsvi,dsvii], we adopt perplexity-based evaluation for datasets including HellaSwag, PIQA, WinoGrande, RACE-Middle, RACE-High, MMLU, MMLU-Redux, MMLU-Pro, MMMLU, ARC-Easy, ARC-Challenge, C-Eval, CMMLU, C3, and CCPM, and adopt generation-based evaluation for TriviaQA, NaturalQuestions, DROP, MATH, GSM8K, MGSM, HumanEval, MBPP, LiveCodeBench-Base, CRUXEval, BBH, AGIEval, CLUEWSC, CMRC, and CMath. \nIn addition, we perform language-modeling-based evaluation for Pile-test and use Bits-Per-Byte(BPB) as the metric to guarantee fair comparison among models using different tokenizers." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/218", + "self_ref": "#/texts/178", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4120,7 +3460,7 @@ "text": "Comparison among DeepSeek-V3-Base and other representative open-source base models.\n All models are evaluated in our internal framework and share the same evaluation setting.\n Scores with a gap not exceeding 0.3 are considered to be at the same level. \n DeepSeek-V3-Base achieves the best performance on most benchmarks, especially on math and code tasks." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/219", + "self_ref": "#/texts/179", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4133,19 +3473,7 @@ "level": 3 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/220", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "In Table", - "text": "In Table" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/221", + "self_ref": "#/texts/180", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4153,23 +3481,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[tab:main], we compare the base model of DeepSeek-V3 with the state-of-the-art open-source base models, including DeepSeek-V2-Base[dsvii] (our previous release), Qwen2.5 72B Base[qwen2_5], and LLaMA-3.1 405B Base[llama3_1_405b].\nWe evaluate all these models with our internal evaluation framework, and ensure that they share the same evaluation setting. \nNote that due to the changes in our evaluation framework over the past months, the performance of DeepSeek-V2-Base exhibits a slight difference from our previously reported results.\nOverall, DeepSeek-V3-Base comprehensively outperforms DeepSeek-V2-Base and Qwen2.5 72B Base, and surpasses LLaMA-3.1 405B Base in the majority of benchmarks, essentially becoming the strongest open-source model.", - "text": "[tab:main], we compare the base model of DeepSeek-V3 with the state-of-the-art open-source base models, including DeepSeek-V2-Base[dsvii] (our previous release), Qwen2.5 72B Base[qwen2_5], and LLaMA-3.1 405B Base[llama3_1_405b].\nWe evaluate all these models with our internal evaluation framework, and ensure that they share the same evaluation setting. \nNote that due to the changes in our evaluation framework over the past months, the performance of DeepSeek-V2-Base exhibits a slight difference from our previously reported results.\nOverall, DeepSeek-V3-Base comprehensively outperforms DeepSeek-V2-Base and Qwen2.5 72B Base, and surpasses LLaMA-3.1 405B Base in the majority of benchmarks, essentially becoming the strongest open-source model." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/222", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "From a more detailed perspective, we compare", - "text": "From a more detailed perspective, we compare" + "orig": "In Table[tab:main], we compare the base model of DeepSeek-V3 with the state-of-the-art open-source base models, including DeepSeek-V2-Base[dsvii] (our previous release), Qwen2.5 72B Base[qwen2_5], and LLaMA-3.1 405B Base[llama3_1_405b].\nWe evaluate all these models with our internal evaluation framework, and ensure that they share the same evaluation setting. \nNote that due to the changes in our evaluation framework over the past months, the performance of DeepSeek-V2-Base exhibits a slight difference from our previously reported results.\nOverall, DeepSeek-V3-Base comprehensively outperforms DeepSeek-V2-Base and Qwen2.5 72B Base, and surpasses LLaMA-3.1 405B Base in the majority of benchmarks, essentially becoming the strongest open-source model.", + "text": "In Table[tab:main], we compare the base model of DeepSeek-V3 with the state-of-the-art open-source base models, including DeepSeek-V2-Base[dsvii] (our previous release), Qwen2.5 72B Base[qwen2_5], and LLaMA-3.1 405B Base[llama3_1_405b].\nWe evaluate all these models with our internal evaluation framework, and ensure that they share the same evaluation setting. \nNote that due to the changes in our evaluation framework over the past months, the performance of DeepSeek-V2-Base exhibits a slight difference from our previously reported results.\nOverall, DeepSeek-V3-Base comprehensively outperforms DeepSeek-V2-Base and Qwen2.5 72B Base, and surpasses LLaMA-3.1 405B Base in the majority of benchmarks, essentially becoming the strongest open-source model." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/223", + "self_ref": "#/texts/181", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4177,23 +3493,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "DeepSeek-V3-Base with the other open-source base models individually.\n(1) \nCompared with DeepSeek-V2-Base, due to the improvements in our model architecture, the scale-up of the model size and training tokens, and the enhancement of data quality, DeepSeek-V3-Base achieves significantly better performance as expected.\n(2)\nCompared with Qwen2.5 72B Base, the state-of-the-art Chinese open-source model, with only half of the activated parameters, DeepSeek-V3-Base also demonstrates remarkable advantages, especially on English, multilingual, code, and math benchmarks. \nAs for Chinese benchmarks, except for CMMLU, a Chinese multi-subject multiple-choice task, DeepSeek-V3-Base also shows better performance than Qwen2.5 72B. \n(3)\nCompared with LLaMA-3.1 405B Base, the largest open-source model with 11 times the activated parameters, DeepSeek-V3-Base also exhibits much better performance on multilingual, code, and math benchmarks. \nAs for English and Chinese language benchmarks, DeepSeek-V3-Base shows competitive or better performance, and is especially good on BBH, MMLU-series, DROP, C-Eval, CMMLU, and CCPM.", - "text": "DeepSeek-V3-Base with the other open-source base models individually.\n(1) \nCompared with DeepSeek-V2-Base, due to the improvements in our model architecture, the scale-up of the model size and training tokens, and the enhancement of data quality, DeepSeek-V3-Base achieves significantly better performance as expected.\n(2)\nCompared with Qwen2.5 72B Base, the state-of-the-art Chinese open-source model, with only half of the activated parameters, DeepSeek-V3-Base also demonstrates remarkable advantages, especially on English, multilingual, code, and math benchmarks. \nAs for Chinese benchmarks, except for CMMLU, a Chinese multi-subject multiple-choice task, DeepSeek-V3-Base also shows better performance than Qwen2.5 72B. \n(3)\nCompared with LLaMA-3.1 405B Base, the largest open-source model with 11 times the activated parameters, DeepSeek-V3-Base also exhibits much better performance on multilingual, code, and math benchmarks. \nAs for English and Chinese language benchmarks, DeepSeek-V3-Base shows competitive or better performance, and is especially good on BBH, MMLU-series, DROP, C-Eval, CMMLU, and CCPM." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/224", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Due to our efficient architectures and comprehensive engineering optimizations,", - "text": "Due to our efficient architectures and comprehensive engineering optimizations," + "orig": "From a more detailed perspective, we compare DeepSeek-V3-Base with the other open-source base models individually.\n(1) \nCompared with DeepSeek-V2-Base, due to the improvements in our model architecture, the scale-up of the model size and training tokens, and the enhancement of data quality, DeepSeek-V3-Base achieves significantly better performance as expected.\n(2)\nCompared with Qwen2.5 72B Base, the state-of-the-art Chinese open-source model, with only half of the activated parameters, DeepSeek-V3-Base also demonstrates remarkable advantages, especially on English, multilingual, code, and math benchmarks. \nAs for Chinese benchmarks, except for CMMLU, a Chinese multi-subject multiple-choice task, DeepSeek-V3-Base also shows better performance than Qwen2.5 72B. \n(3)\nCompared with LLaMA-3.1 405B Base, the largest open-source model with 11 times the activated parameters, DeepSeek-V3-Base also exhibits much better performance on multilingual, code, and math benchmarks. \nAs for English and Chinese language benchmarks, DeepSeek-V3-Base shows competitive or better performance, and is especially good on BBH, MMLU-series, DROP, C-Eval, CMMLU, and CCPM.", + "text": "From a more detailed perspective, we compare DeepSeek-V3-Base with the other open-source base models individually.\n(1) \nCompared with DeepSeek-V2-Base, due to the improvements in our model architecture, the scale-up of the model size and training tokens, and the enhancement of data quality, DeepSeek-V3-Base achieves significantly better performance as expected.\n(2)\nCompared with Qwen2.5 72B Base, the state-of-the-art Chinese open-source model, with only half of the activated parameters, DeepSeek-V3-Base also demonstrates remarkable advantages, especially on English, multilingual, code, and math benchmarks. \nAs for Chinese benchmarks, except for CMMLU, a Chinese multi-subject multiple-choice task, DeepSeek-V3-Base also shows better performance than Qwen2.5 72B. \n(3)\nCompared with LLaMA-3.1 405B Base, the largest open-source model with 11 times the activated parameters, DeepSeek-V3-Base also exhibits much better performance on multilingual, code, and math benchmarks. \nAs for English and Chinese language benchmarks, DeepSeek-V3-Base shows competitive or better performance, and is especially good on BBH, MMLU-series, DROP, C-Eval, CMMLU, and CCPM." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/225", + "self_ref": "#/texts/182", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4201,11 +3505,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "DeepSeek-V3 achieves extremely high training efficiency. \nUnder our training framework and infrastructures, training DeepSeek-V3on each trillion tokens requires only 180K H800 GPU hours, which is much cheaper than training 72B or 405B dense models.", - "text": "DeepSeek-V3 achieves extremely high training efficiency. \nUnder our training framework and infrastructures, training DeepSeek-V3on each trillion tokens requires only 180K H800 GPU hours, which is much cheaper than training 72B or 405B dense models." + "orig": "Due to our efficient architectures and comprehensive engineering optimizations, DeepSeek-V3 achieves extremely high training efficiency. \nUnder our training framework and infrastructures, training DeepSeek-V3on each trillion tokens requires only 180K H800 GPU hours, which is much cheaper than training 72B or 405B dense models.", + "text": "Due to our efficient architectures and comprehensive engineering optimizations, DeepSeek-V3 achieves extremely high training efficiency. \nUnder our training framework and infrastructures, training DeepSeek-V3on each trillion tokens requires only 180K H800 GPU hours, which is much cheaper than training 72B or 405B dense models." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/226", + "self_ref": "#/texts/183", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4217,7 +3521,7 @@ "text": "Ablation results for the MTP strategy. \n The MTP strategy consistently enhances the model performance on most of the evaluation benchmarks." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/227", + "self_ref": "#/texts/184", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4230,7 +3534,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/228", + "self_ref": "#/texts/185", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4243,19 +3547,7 @@ "level": 3 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/229", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "In Table", - "text": "In Table" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/230", + "self_ref": "#/texts/186", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4263,11 +3555,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[tab:ablation_nextn], we show the ablation results for the MTP strategy. \nTo be specific, we validate the MTP strategy on top of two baseline models across different scales. \nAt the small scale, we train a baseline MoE model comprising 15.7B total parameters on 1.33T tokens. \nAt the large scale, we train a baseline MoE model comprising 228.7B total parameters on 540B tokens. \nOn top of them, keeping the training data and the other architectures the same, we append a 1-depth MTP module onto them and train two models with the MTP strategy for comparison. \nNote that during inference, we directly discard the MTP module, so the inference costs of the compared models are exactly the same. \nFrom the table, we can observe that the MTP strategy consistently enhances the model performance on most of the evaluation benchmarks.", - "text": "[tab:ablation_nextn], we show the ablation results for the MTP strategy. \nTo be specific, we validate the MTP strategy on top of two baseline models across different scales. \nAt the small scale, we train a baseline MoE model comprising 15.7B total parameters on 1.33T tokens. \nAt the large scale, we train a baseline MoE model comprising 228.7B total parameters on 540B tokens. \nOn top of them, keeping the training data and the other architectures the same, we append a 1-depth MTP module onto them and train two models with the MTP strategy for comparison. \nNote that during inference, we directly discard the MTP module, so the inference costs of the compared models are exactly the same. \nFrom the table, we can observe that the MTP strategy consistently enhances the model performance on most of the evaluation benchmarks." + "orig": "In Table[tab:ablation_nextn], we show the ablation results for the MTP strategy. \nTo be specific, we validate the MTP strategy on top of two baseline models across different scales. \nAt the small scale, we train a baseline MoE model comprising 15.7B total parameters on 1.33T tokens. \nAt the large scale, we train a baseline MoE model comprising 228.7B total parameters on 540B tokens. \nOn top of them, keeping the training data and the other architectures the same, we append a 1-depth MTP module onto them and train two models with the MTP strategy for comparison. \nNote that during inference, we directly discard the MTP module, so the inference costs of the compared models are exactly the same. \nFrom the table, we can observe that the MTP strategy consistently enhances the model performance on most of the evaluation benchmarks.", + "text": "In Table[tab:ablation_nextn], we show the ablation results for the MTP strategy. \nTo be specific, we validate the MTP strategy on top of two baseline models across different scales. \nAt the small scale, we train a baseline MoE model comprising 15.7B total parameters on 1.33T tokens. \nAt the large scale, we train a baseline MoE model comprising 228.7B total parameters on 540B tokens. \nOn top of them, keeping the training data and the other architectures the same, we append a 1-depth MTP module onto them and train two models with the MTP strategy for comparison. \nNote that during inference, we directly discard the MTP module, so the inference costs of the compared models are exactly the same. \nFrom the table, we can observe that the MTP strategy consistently enhances the model performance on most of the evaluation benchmarks." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/231", + "self_ref": "#/texts/187", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4280,19 +3572,7 @@ "level": 3 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/232", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "In Table", - "text": "In Table" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/233", + "self_ref": "#/texts/188", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4300,11 +3580,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[tab:ablation_noaux_tc], we show the ablation results for the auxiliary-loss-free balancing strategy.\nWe validate this strategy on top of two baseline models across different scales. \nAt the small scale, we train a baseline MoE model comprising 15.7B total parameters on 1.33T tokens. \nAt the large scale, we train a baseline MoE model comprising 228.7B total parameters on 578B tokens. \nBoth of the baseline models purely use auxiliary losses to encourage load balance, and use the sigmoid gating function with top-K affinity normalization. \nTheir hyper-parameters to control the strength of auxiliary losses are the same as DeepSeek-V2-Lite and DeepSeek-V2, respectively. \nOn top of these two baseline models, keeping the training data and the other architectures the same, we remove all auxiliary losses and introduce the auxiliary-loss-free balancing strategy for comparison. \nFrom the table, we can observe that the auxiliary-loss-free strategy consistently achieves better model performance on most of the evaluation benchmarks.", - "text": "[tab:ablation_noaux_tc], we show the ablation results for the auxiliary-loss-free balancing strategy.\nWe validate this strategy on top of two baseline models across different scales. \nAt the small scale, we train a baseline MoE model comprising 15.7B total parameters on 1.33T tokens. \nAt the large scale, we train a baseline MoE model comprising 228.7B total parameters on 578B tokens. \nBoth of the baseline models purely use auxiliary losses to encourage load balance, and use the sigmoid gating function with top-K affinity normalization. \nTheir hyper-parameters to control the strength of auxiliary losses are the same as DeepSeek-V2-Lite and DeepSeek-V2, respectively. \nOn top of these two baseline models, keeping the training data and the other architectures the same, we remove all auxiliary losses and introduce the auxiliary-loss-free balancing strategy for comparison. \nFrom the table, we can observe that the auxiliary-loss-free strategy consistently achieves better model performance on most of the evaluation benchmarks." + "orig": "In Table[tab:ablation_noaux_tc], we show the ablation results for the auxiliary-loss-free balancing strategy.\nWe validate this strategy on top of two baseline models across different scales. \nAt the small scale, we train a baseline MoE model comprising 15.7B total parameters on 1.33T tokens. \nAt the large scale, we train a baseline MoE model comprising 228.7B total parameters on 578B tokens. \nBoth of the baseline models purely use auxiliary losses to encourage load balance, and use the sigmoid gating function with top-K affinity normalization. \nTheir hyper-parameters to control the strength of auxiliary losses are the same as DeepSeek-V2-Lite and DeepSeek-V2, respectively. \nOn top of these two baseline models, keeping the training data and the other architectures the same, we remove all auxiliary losses and introduce the auxiliary-loss-free balancing strategy for comparison. \nFrom the table, we can observe that the auxiliary-loss-free strategy consistently achieves better model performance on most of the evaluation benchmarks.", + "text": "In Table[tab:ablation_noaux_tc], we show the ablation results for the auxiliary-loss-free balancing strategy.\nWe validate this strategy on top of two baseline models across different scales. \nAt the small scale, we train a baseline MoE model comprising 15.7B total parameters on 1.33T tokens. \nAt the large scale, we train a baseline MoE model comprising 228.7B total parameters on 578B tokens. \nBoth of the baseline models purely use auxiliary losses to encourage load balance, and use the sigmoid gating function with top-K affinity normalization. \nTheir hyper-parameters to control the strength of auxiliary losses are the same as DeepSeek-V2-Lite and DeepSeek-V2, respectively. \nOn top of these two baseline models, keeping the training data and the other architectures the same, we remove all auxiliary losses and introduce the auxiliary-loss-free balancing strategy for comparison. \nFrom the table, we can observe that the auxiliary-loss-free strategy consistently achieves better model performance on most of the evaluation benchmarks." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/234", + "self_ref": "#/texts/189", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4316,7 +3596,7 @@ "text": "Ablation results for the auxiliary-loss-free balancing strategy. \n Compared with the purely auxiliary-loss-based method, the auxiliary-loss-free strategy consistently achieves better model performance on most of the evaluation benchmarks." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/235", + "self_ref": "#/texts/190", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4329,19 +3609,7 @@ "level": 3 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/236", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "The key distinction between auxiliary-loss-free balancing and sequence-wise auxiliary loss lies in their balancing scope: batch-wise versus sequence-wise. \nCompared with the sequence-wise auxiliary loss, batch-wise balancing imposes a more flexible constraint, as it does not enforce in-domain balance on each sequence. \nThis flexibility allows experts to better specialize in different domains. \nTo validate this, we record and analyze the expert load of a 16B auxiliary-loss-based baseline and a 16B auxiliary-loss-free model on different domains in the Pile test set.\nAs illustrated in Figure", - "text": "The key distinction between auxiliary-loss-free balancing and sequence-wise auxiliary loss lies in their balancing scope: batch-wise versus sequence-wise. \nCompared with the sequence-wise auxiliary loss, batch-wise balancing imposes a more flexible constraint, as it does not enforce in-domain balance on each sequence. \nThis flexibility allows experts to better specialize in different domains. \nTo validate this, we record and analyze the expert load of a 16B auxiliary-loss-based baseline and a 16B auxiliary-loss-free model on different domains in the Pile test set.\nAs illustrated in Figure" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/237", + "self_ref": "#/texts/191", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4349,11 +3617,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[fig:expert_load], we observe that the auxiliary-loss-free model demonstrates greater expert specialization patterns as expected.", - "text": "[fig:expert_load], we observe that the auxiliary-loss-free model demonstrates greater expert specialization patterns as expected." + "orig": "The key distinction between auxiliary-loss-free balancing and sequence-wise auxiliary loss lies in their balancing scope: batch-wise versus sequence-wise. \nCompared with the sequence-wise auxiliary loss, batch-wise balancing imposes a more flexible constraint, as it does not enforce in-domain balance on each sequence. \nThis flexibility allows experts to better specialize in different domains. \nTo validate this, we record and analyze the expert load of a 16B auxiliary-loss-based baseline and a 16B auxiliary-loss-free model on different domains in the Pile test set.\nAs illustrated in Figure[fig:expert_load], we observe that the auxiliary-loss-free model demonstrates greater expert specialization patterns as expected.", + "text": "The key distinction between auxiliary-loss-free balancing and sequence-wise auxiliary loss lies in their balancing scope: batch-wise versus sequence-wise. \nCompared with the sequence-wise auxiliary loss, batch-wise balancing imposes a more flexible constraint, as it does not enforce in-domain balance on each sequence. \nThis flexibility allows experts to better specialize in different domains. \nTo validate this, we record and analyze the expert load of a 16B auxiliary-loss-based baseline and a 16B auxiliary-loss-free model on different domains in the Pile test set.\nAs illustrated in Figure[fig:expert_load], we observe that the auxiliary-loss-free model demonstrates greater expert specialization patterns as expected." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/238", + "self_ref": "#/texts/192", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4365,19 +3633,7 @@ "text": "To further investigate the correlation between this flexibility and the advantage in model performance, we additionally design and validate a batch-wise auxiliary loss that encourages load balance on each training batch instead of on each sequence. \nThe experimental results show that, when achieving a similar level of batch-wise load balance, the batch-wise auxiliary loss can also achieve similar model performance to the auxiliary-loss-free method.\nTo be specific, in our experiments with 1B MoE models, the validation losses are: 2.258 (using a sequence-wise auxiliary loss), 2.253 (using the auxiliary-loss-free method), and 2.253 (using a batch-wise auxiliary loss). \nWe also observe similar results on 3B MoE models: the model using a sequence-wise auxiliary loss achieves a validation loss of 2.085, and the models using the auxiliary-loss-free method or a batch-wise auxiliary loss achieve the same validation loss of 2.080." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/239", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "In addition, although the batch-wise load balancing methods show consistent performance advantages, they also face two potential challenges in efficiency: \n(1) load imbalance within certain sequences or small batches, and \n(2) domain-shift-induced load imbalance during inference. \nThe first challenge is naturally addressed by our training framework that uses large-scale expert parallelism and data parallelism, which guarantees a large size of each micro-batch. \nFor the second challenge, we also design and implement an efficient inference framework with redundant expert deployment, as described in Section", - "text": "In addition, although the batch-wise load balancing methods show consistent performance advantages, they also face two potential challenges in efficiency: \n(1) load imbalance within certain sequences or small batches, and \n(2) domain-shift-induced load imbalance during inference. \nThe first challenge is naturally addressed by our training framework that uses large-scale expert parallelism and data parallelism, which guarantees a large size of each micro-batch. \nFor the second challenge, we also design and implement an efficient inference framework with redundant expert deployment, as described in Section" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/240", + "self_ref": "#/texts/193", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4385,11 +3641,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[sec:inference_deployment], to overcome it.", - "text": "[sec:inference_deployment], to overcome it." + "orig": "In addition, although the batch-wise load balancing methods show consistent performance advantages, they also face two potential challenges in efficiency: \n(1) load imbalance within certain sequences or small batches, and \n(2) domain-shift-induced load imbalance during inference. \nThe first challenge is naturally addressed by our training framework that uses large-scale expert parallelism and data parallelism, which guarantees a large size of each micro-batch. \nFor the second challenge, we also design and implement an efficient inference framework with redundant expert deployment, as described in Section [sec:inference_deployment], to overcome it.", + "text": "In addition, although the batch-wise load balancing methods show consistent performance advantages, they also face two potential challenges in efficiency: \n(1) load imbalance within certain sequences or small batches, and \n(2) domain-shift-induced load imbalance during inference. \nThe first challenge is naturally addressed by our training framework that uses large-scale expert parallelism and data parallelism, which guarantees a large size of each micro-batch. \nFor the second challenge, we also design and implement an efficient inference framework with redundant expert deployment, as described in Section [sec:inference_deployment], to overcome it." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/241", + "self_ref": "#/texts/194", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4401,7 +3657,7 @@ "text": "Image: figures/relative_expert_load_multi.pdf" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/242", + "self_ref": "#/texts/195", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/13" }, @@ -4413,7 +3669,7 @@ "text": "Expert load of auxiliary-loss-free and auxiliary-loss-based models on three domains in the Pile test set. \n The auxiliary-loss-free model shows greater expert specialization patterns than the auxiliary-loss-based one.\n The relative expert load denotes the ratio between the actual expert load and the theoretically balanced expert load. \n Due to space constraints, we only present the results of two layers as an example, with the results of all layers provided in Appendix\\ref{app:detailed_expert_load}." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/243", + "self_ref": "#/texts/196", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4426,7 +3682,7 @@ "level": 1 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/244", + "self_ref": "#/texts/197", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4439,7 +3695,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/245", + "self_ref": "#/texts/198", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4451,7 +3707,7 @@ "text": "We curate our instruction-tuning datasets to include 1.5M instances spanning multiple domains, with each domain employing distinct data creation methods tailored to its specific requirements." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/246", + "self_ref": "#/texts/199", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4463,7 +3719,7 @@ "text": "Reasoning Data.For reasoning-related datasets, including those focused on mathematics, code competition problems, and logic puzzles, we generate the data by leveraging an internal DeepSeek-R1 model. \nSpecifically, while the R1-generated data demonstrates strong accuracy, it suffers from issues such as overthinking, poor formatting, and excessive length. \nOur objective is to balance the high accuracy of R1-generated reasoning data and the clarity and conciseness of regularly formatted reasoning data." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/247", + "self_ref": "#/texts/200", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4475,7 +3731,7 @@ "text": "To establish our methodology, we begin by developing an expert model tailored to a specific domain, such as code, mathematics, or general reasoning, using a combined Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) and Reinforcement Learning (RL) training pipeline. \nThis expert model serves as a data generator for the final model. \nThe training process involves generating two distinct types of SFT samples for each instance: the first couples the problem with its original response in the format of , while the second incorporates a system prompt alongside the problem and the R1 response in the format of ." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/248", + "self_ref": "#/texts/201", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4487,7 +3743,7 @@ "text": "The system prompt is meticulously designed to include instructions that guide the model toward producing responses enriched with mechanisms for reflection and verification. \nDuring the RL phase, the model leverages high-temperature sampling to generate responses that integrate patterns from both the R1-generated and original data, even in the absence of explicit system prompts. \nAfter hundreds of RL steps, the intermediate RL model learns to incorporate R1 patterns, thereby enhancing overall performance strategically." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/249", + "self_ref": "#/texts/202", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4499,7 +3755,7 @@ "text": "Upon completing the RL training phase, we implement rejection sampling to curate high-quality SFT data for the final model, where the expert models are used as data generation sources. \nThis method ensures that the final training data retains the strengths of DeepSeek-R1 while producing responses that are concise and effective." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/250", + "self_ref": "#/texts/203", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4511,7 +3767,7 @@ "text": "Non-Reasoning Data.For non-reasoning data, such as creative writing, role-play, and simple question answering, we utilize DeepSeek-V2.5 to generate responses and enlist human annotators to verify the accuracy and correctness of the data." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/251", + "self_ref": "#/texts/204", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4523,7 +3779,7 @@ "text": "SFT Settings. \nWe fine-tune DeepSeek-V3-Base for two epochs using the SFT dataset, using the cosine decay learning rate scheduling that starts at $5 \\times 10^{-6}$ and gradually decreases to $1 \\times 10^{-6}$. \nDuring training, each single sequence is packed from multiple samples. \nHowever, we adopt a sample masking strategy to ensure that these examples remain isolated and mutually invisible." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/252", + "self_ref": "#/texts/205", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4536,7 +3792,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/253", + "self_ref": "#/texts/206", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4549,7 +3805,7 @@ "level": 3 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/254", + "self_ref": "#/texts/207", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4561,7 +3817,7 @@ "text": "We employ a rule-based Reward Model (RM) and a model-based RM in our RL process." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/255", + "self_ref": "#/texts/208", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4573,7 +3829,7 @@ "text": "Rule-Based RM.For questions that can be validated using specific rules, we adopt a rule-based reward system to determine the feedback. \nFor instance, certain math problems have deterministic results, and we require the model to provide the final answer within a designated format (e.g., in a box), allowing us to apply rules to verify the correctness. \nSimilarly, for LeetCode problems, we can utilize a compiler to generate feedback based on test cases. \nBy leveraging rule-based validation wherever possible, we ensure a higher level of reliability, as this approach is resistant to manipulation or exploitation." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/256", + "self_ref": "#/texts/209", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4585,7 +3841,7 @@ "text": "Model-Based RM. \nFor questions with free-form ground-truth answers, we rely on the reward model to determine whether the response matches the expected ground-truth. \nConversely, for questions without a definitive ground-truth, such as those involving creative writing, the reward model is tasked with providing feedback based on the question and the corresponding answer as inputs. \nThe reward model is trained from the DeepSeek-V3SFT checkpoints. \nTo enhance its reliability, we construct preference data that not only provides the final reward but also includes the chain-of-thought leading to the reward. \nThis approach helps mitigate the risk of reward hacking in specific tasks." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/257", + "self_ref": "#/texts/210", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4598,19 +3854,7 @@ "level": 3 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/258", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Similar to", - "text": "Similar to" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/259", + "self_ref": "#/texts/211", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4618,11 +3862,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "DeepSeek-V2[dsvii], we adopt Group Relative Policy Optimization(GRPO)[deepseekmath], which foregoes the critic model that is typically with the same size as the policy model, and estimates the baseline from group scores instead. \nSpecifically, for each question $q$, GRPO samples a group of outputs $\\{o_1, o_2, \\cdots, o_G\\}$ from the old policy model $\\pi_{\\theta_{old}}$ and then optimizes the policy model $\\pi_{\\theta}$ by maximizing the following objective:", - "text": "DeepSeek-V2[dsvii], we adopt Group Relative Policy Optimization(GRPO)[deepseekmath], which foregoes the critic model that is typically with the same size as the policy model, and estimates the baseline from group scores instead. \nSpecifically, for each question $q$, GRPO samples a group of outputs $\\{o_1, o_2, \\cdots, o_G\\}$ from the old policy model $\\pi_{\\theta_{old}}$ and then optimizes the policy model $\\pi_{\\theta}$ by maximizing the following objective:" + "orig": "Similar to DeepSeek-V2[dsvii], we adopt Group Relative Policy Optimization(GRPO)[deepseekmath], which foregoes the critic model that is typically with the same size as the policy model, and estimates the baseline from group scores instead. \nSpecifically, for each question $q$, GRPO samples a group of outputs $\\{o_1, o_2, \\cdots, o_G\\}$ from the old policy model $\\pi_{\\theta_{old}}$ and then optimizes the policy model $\\pi_{\\theta}$ by maximizing the following objective:", + "text": "Similar to DeepSeek-V2[dsvii], we adopt Group Relative Policy Optimization(GRPO)[deepseekmath], which foregoes the critic model that is typically with the same size as the policy model, and estimates the baseline from group scores instead. \nSpecifically, for each question $q$, GRPO samples a group of outputs $\\{o_1, o_2, \\cdots, o_G\\}$ from the old policy model $\\pi_{\\theta_{old}}$ and then optimizes the policy model $\\pi_{\\theta}$ by maximizing the following objective:" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/260", + "self_ref": "#/texts/212", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4634,7 +3878,7 @@ "text": "\\begin{split}\n \\mathcal{J}_{GRPO}(\\theta) &= \\mathbb{E}{[q \\sim P(Q), \\{o_i\\}_{i=1}^G \\sim \\pi_{\\theta_{old}}(O|q)]} \\\\\n & \\frac{1}{G}\\sum_{i=1}^G \\left( \\min \\left( \\frac{\\pi_\\theta(o_i |q)}{\\pi_{\\theta_{old}}(o_i |q)} A_i, \\text{clip} \\left( \\frac{\\pi_\\theta(o_i |q)}{\\pi_{\\theta_{old}}(o_i |q)}, 1 - \\epsilon, 1 + \\epsilon \\right) A_i \\right) - \\beta \\mathbb{D}_{KL}\\left(\\pi_{\\theta} || \\pi_{ref}\\right)\\right) ,\n\\end{split}" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/261", + "self_ref": "#/texts/213", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4646,7 +3890,7 @@ "text": "\\mathbb{D}_{KL}\\left(\\pi_{\\theta} || \\pi_{ref}\\right) = \\frac{\\pi_{ref}(o_i|q)}{\\pi_{\\theta}(o_i|q)}- \\log\\frac{\\pi_{ref}(o_i|q)}{\\pi_{\\theta}(o_i|q)} - 1," }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/262", + "self_ref": "#/texts/214", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4658,7 +3902,7 @@ "text": "where $\\epsilon$ and $\\beta$ are hyper-parameters; \n$\\pi_{ref}$ is the reference model; \nand $A_i$ is the advantage, derived from the rewards $\\{r_1, r_2, \\ldots, r_G\\}$ corresponding to the outputs within each group:" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/263", + "self_ref": "#/texts/215", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4670,7 +3914,7 @@ "text": "A_i = \\frac{r_i - {\\operatorname{mean}(\\{r_1, r_2, \\cdots, r_G\\})}}{{\\operatorname{std}(\\{r_1, r_2, \\cdots, r_G\\})}}." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/264", + "self_ref": "#/texts/216", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4682,7 +3926,7 @@ "text": "We incorporate prompts from diverse domains, such as coding, math, writing, role-playing, and question answering, during the RL process. \nThis approach not only aligns the model more closely with human preferences but also enhances performance on benchmarks, especially in scenarios where available SFT data are limited." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/265", + "self_ref": "#/texts/217", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4695,7 +3939,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/266", + "self_ref": "#/texts/218", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4708,7 +3952,7 @@ "level": 3 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/267", + "self_ref": "#/texts/219", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4720,7 +3964,7 @@ "text": "Evaluation Benchmarks.\nApart from the benchmark we used for base model testing, we further evaluate instructed models on IFEval[IFeval], FRAMES[frames], LongBench v2[bai2024longbench2], GPQA[gpqa], SimpleQA[simpleqa], C-SimpleQA[csimpleqa], SWE-Bench Verified[swe_verified], Aider" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/268", + "self_ref": "#/texts/220", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4732,7 +3976,7 @@ "text": "https://aider.chat" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/269", + "self_ref": "#/texts/221", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4744,7 +3988,7 @@ "text": ", LiveCodeBench[livecodebench] (questions from August 2024 to November 2024), Codeforces" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/270", + "self_ref": "#/texts/222", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4756,7 +4000,7 @@ "text": "https://codeforces.com" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/271", + "self_ref": "#/texts/223", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4768,7 +4012,7 @@ "text": ", Chinese National High School Mathematics Olympiad (CNMO 2024)" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/272", + "self_ref": "#/texts/224", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4780,7 +4024,7 @@ "text": "https://www.cms.org.cn/Home/comp/comp/cid/12.html" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/273", + "self_ref": "#/texts/225", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4792,7 +4036,7 @@ "text": ", and American Invitational Mathematics Examination 2024 (AIME 2024)[AIME2024]." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/274", + "self_ref": "#/texts/226", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4804,7 +4048,7 @@ "text": "Compared Baselines.\nWe conduct comprehensive evaluations of our chat model against several strong baselines, including DeepSeek-V2-0506, DeepSeek-V2.5-0905, Qwen2.5 72B Instruct, LLaMA-3.1 405B Instruct, Claude-Sonnet-3.5-1022, and GPT-4o-0513. \nFor the DeepSeek-V2model series, we select the most representative variants for comparison. \nFor closed-source models, evaluations are performed through their respective APIs." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/275", + "self_ref": "#/texts/227", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4816,7 +4060,7 @@ "text": "Detailed Evaluation Configurations.\nFor standard benchmarks including MMLU, DROP, GPQA, and SimpleQA, we adopt the evaluation prompts from the simple-evals framework" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/276", + "self_ref": "#/texts/228", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4828,7 +4072,7 @@ "text": "https://github.com/openai/simple-evals" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/277", + "self_ref": "#/texts/229", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4840,7 +4084,7 @@ "text": ". \nWe utilize the Zero-Eval prompt format[Lin_ZeroEval_A_Unified_2024] for MMLU-Redux in a zero-shot setting. \nFor other datasets, we follow their original evaluation protocols with default prompts as provided by the dataset creators.\nFor code and math benchmarks, the HumanEval-Mul dataset includes 8 mainstream programming languages (Python, Java, Cpp, C#, JavaScript, TypeScript, PHP, and Bash) in total. \nWe use CoT and non-CoT methods to evaluate model performance on LiveCodeBench, where the data are collected from August 2024 to November 2024. \nThe Codeforces dataset is measured using the percentage of competitors. \nSWE-Bench verified is evaluated using the agentless framework[agentless]. \nWe use the diffformat to evaluate the Aider-related benchmarks. \nFor mathematical assessments, AIME and CNMO 2024 are evaluated with a temperature of 0.7, and the results are averaged over 16 runs, while MATH-500 employs greedy decoding. \nWe allow all models to output a maximum of 8192 tokens for each benchmark." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/278", + "self_ref": "#/texts/230", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4852,7 +4096,7 @@ "text": "Comparison between DeepSeek-V3 and other representative chat models. \n All models are evaluated in a configuration that limits the output length to 8K.\n Benchmarks containing fewer than 1000 samples are tested multiple times using varying temperature settings to derive robust final results.\n DeepSeek-V3 stands as the best-performing open-source model, and also exhibits competitive performance against frontier closed-source models." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/279", + "self_ref": "#/texts/231", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4865,19 +4109,7 @@ "level": 3 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/280", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Table", - "text": "Table" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/281", + "self_ref": "#/texts/232", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4885,11 +4117,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[tab:chat] presents the evaluation results, showcasing that DeepSeek-V3stands as the best-performing open-source model. \nAdditionally, it is competitive against frontier closed-source models like GPT-4o and Claude-3.5-Sonnet.", - "text": "[tab:chat] presents the evaluation results, showcasing that DeepSeek-V3stands as the best-performing open-source model. \nAdditionally, it is competitive against frontier closed-source models like GPT-4o and Claude-3.5-Sonnet." + "orig": "Table[tab:chat] presents the evaluation results, showcasing that DeepSeek-V3stands as the best-performing open-source model. \nAdditionally, it is competitive against frontier closed-source models like GPT-4o and Claude-3.5-Sonnet.", + "text": "Table[tab:chat] presents the evaluation results, showcasing that DeepSeek-V3stands as the best-performing open-source model. \nAdditionally, it is competitive against frontier closed-source models like GPT-4o and Claude-3.5-Sonnet." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/282", + "self_ref": "#/texts/233", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4901,19 +4133,7 @@ "text": "English Benchmarks.\nMMLU is a widely recognized benchmark designed to assess the performance of large language models, across diverse knowledge domains and tasks. \nDeepSeek-V3 demonstrates competitive performance, standing on par with top-tier models such as LLaMA-3.1-405B, GPT-4o, and Claude-Sonnet 3.5, while significantly outperforming Qwen2.5 72B. \nMoreover, DeepSeek-V3 excels in MMLU-Pro, a more challenging educational knowledge benchmark, where it closely trails Claude-Sonnet 3.5. \nOn MMLU-Redux, a refined version of MMLU with corrected labels, DeepSeek-V3 surpasses its peers. \nIn addition, on GPQA-Diamond, a PhD-level evaluation testbed, DeepSeek-V3achieves remarkable results, ranking just behind Claude 3.5 Sonnet and outperforming all other competitors by a substantial margin." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/283", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "In long-context understanding benchmarks such as DROP, LongBench v2, and FRAMES,", - "text": "In long-context understanding benchmarks such as DROP, LongBench v2, and FRAMES," - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/284", + "self_ref": "#/texts/234", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4921,11 +4141,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "DeepSeek-V3 continues to demonstrate its position as a top-tier model. \nIt achieves an impressive 91.6 F1 score in the 3-shot setting on DROP, outperforming all other models in this category. \nOn FRAMES, a benchmark requiring question-answering over 100k token contexts, DeepSeek-V3 closely trails GPT-4o while outperforming all other models by a significant margin. \nThis demonstrates the strong capability of DeepSeek-V3 in handling extremely long-context tasks. \nThe long-context capability of DeepSeek-V3 is further validated by its best-in-class performance on LongBench v2, a dataset that was released just a few weeks before the launch of DeepSeek V3. \nOn the factual knowledge benchmark, SimpleQA, DeepSeek-V3 falls behind GPT-4o and Claude-Sonnet, primarily due to its design focus and resource allocation. \nDeepSeek-V3 assigns more training tokens to learn Chinese knowledge, leading to exceptional performance on the C-SimpleQA. \nOn the instruction-following benchmark, DeepSeek-V3 significantly outperforms its predecessor, DeepSeek-V2-series, highlighting its improved ability to understand and adhere to user-defined format constraints.", - "text": "DeepSeek-V3 continues to demonstrate its position as a top-tier model. \nIt achieves an impressive 91.6 F1 score in the 3-shot setting on DROP, outperforming all other models in this category. \nOn FRAMES, a benchmark requiring question-answering over 100k token contexts, DeepSeek-V3 closely trails GPT-4o while outperforming all other models by a significant margin. \nThis demonstrates the strong capability of DeepSeek-V3 in handling extremely long-context tasks. \nThe long-context capability of DeepSeek-V3 is further validated by its best-in-class performance on LongBench v2, a dataset that was released just a few weeks before the launch of DeepSeek V3. \nOn the factual knowledge benchmark, SimpleQA, DeepSeek-V3 falls behind GPT-4o and Claude-Sonnet, primarily due to its design focus and resource allocation. \nDeepSeek-V3 assigns more training tokens to learn Chinese knowledge, leading to exceptional performance on the C-SimpleQA. \nOn the instruction-following benchmark, DeepSeek-V3 significantly outperforms its predecessor, DeepSeek-V2-series, highlighting its improved ability to understand and adhere to user-defined format constraints." + "orig": "In long-context understanding benchmarks such as DROP, LongBench v2, and FRAMES, DeepSeek-V3 continues to demonstrate its position as a top-tier model. \nIt achieves an impressive 91.6 F1 score in the 3-shot setting on DROP, outperforming all other models in this category. \nOn FRAMES, a benchmark requiring question-answering over 100k token contexts, DeepSeek-V3 closely trails GPT-4o while outperforming all other models by a significant margin. \nThis demonstrates the strong capability of DeepSeek-V3 in handling extremely long-context tasks. \nThe long-context capability of DeepSeek-V3 is further validated by its best-in-class performance on LongBench v2, a dataset that was released just a few weeks before the launch of DeepSeek V3. \nOn the factual knowledge benchmark, SimpleQA, DeepSeek-V3 falls behind GPT-4o and Claude-Sonnet, primarily due to its design focus and resource allocation. \nDeepSeek-V3 assigns more training tokens to learn Chinese knowledge, leading to exceptional performance on the C-SimpleQA. \nOn the instruction-following benchmark, DeepSeek-V3 significantly outperforms its predecessor, DeepSeek-V2-series, highlighting its improved ability to understand and adhere to user-defined format constraints.", + "text": "In long-context understanding benchmarks such as DROP, LongBench v2, and FRAMES, DeepSeek-V3 continues to demonstrate its position as a top-tier model. \nIt achieves an impressive 91.6 F1 score in the 3-shot setting on DROP, outperforming all other models in this category. \nOn FRAMES, a benchmark requiring question-answering over 100k token contexts, DeepSeek-V3 closely trails GPT-4o while outperforming all other models by a significant margin. \nThis demonstrates the strong capability of DeepSeek-V3 in handling extremely long-context tasks. \nThe long-context capability of DeepSeek-V3 is further validated by its best-in-class performance on LongBench v2, a dataset that was released just a few weeks before the launch of DeepSeek V3. \nOn the factual knowledge benchmark, SimpleQA, DeepSeek-V3 falls behind GPT-4o and Claude-Sonnet, primarily due to its design focus and resource allocation. \nDeepSeek-V3 assigns more training tokens to learn Chinese knowledge, leading to exceptional performance on the C-SimpleQA. \nOn the instruction-following benchmark, DeepSeek-V3 significantly outperforms its predecessor, DeepSeek-V2-series, highlighting its improved ability to understand and adhere to user-defined format constraints." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/285", + "self_ref": "#/texts/235", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4937,19 +4157,7 @@ "text": "Code and Math Benchmarks.\nCoding is a challenging and practical task for LLMs, encompassing engineering-focused tasks like SWE-Bench-Verified and Aider, as well as algorithmic tasks such as HumanEval and LiveCodeBench. \nIn engineering tasks, DeepSeek-V3 trails behind Claude-Sonnet-3.5-1022 but significantly outperforms open-source models. \nThe open-source DeepSeek-V3 is expected to foster advancements in coding-related engineering tasks. \nBy providing access to its robust capabilities, DeepSeek-V3 can drive innovation and improvement in areas such as software engineering and algorithm development, empowering developers and researchers to push the boundaries of what open-source models can achieve in coding tasks. \nIn algorithmic tasks, DeepSeek-V3demonstrates superior performance, outperforming all baselines on benchmarks like HumanEval-Mul and LiveCodeBench. \nThis success can be attributed to its advanced knowledge distillation technique, which effectively enhances its code generation and problem-solving capabilities in algorithm-focused tasks." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/286", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "On math benchmarks,", - "text": "On math benchmarks," - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/287", + "self_ref": "#/texts/236", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4957,11 +4165,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "DeepSeek-V3 demonstrates exceptional performance, significantly surpassing baselines and setting a new state-of-the-art for non-o1-like models. \nSpecifically, on AIME, MATH-500, and CNMO 2024, DeepSeek-V3 outperforms the second-best model, Qwen2.5 72B, by approximately 10%in absolute scores, which is a substantial margin for such challenging benchmarks.\nThis remarkable capability highlights the effectiveness of the distillation technique from DeepSeek-R1, which has been proven highly beneficial for non-o1-like models.", - "text": "DeepSeek-V3 demonstrates exceptional performance, significantly surpassing baselines and setting a new state-of-the-art for non-o1-like models. \nSpecifically, on AIME, MATH-500, and CNMO 2024, DeepSeek-V3 outperforms the second-best model, Qwen2.5 72B, by approximately 10%in absolute scores, which is a substantial margin for such challenging benchmarks.\nThis remarkable capability highlights the effectiveness of the distillation technique from DeepSeek-R1, which has been proven highly beneficial for non-o1-like models." + "orig": "On math benchmarks, DeepSeek-V3 demonstrates exceptional performance, significantly surpassing baselines and setting a new state-of-the-art for non-o1-like models. \nSpecifically, on AIME, MATH-500, and CNMO 2024, DeepSeek-V3 outperforms the second-best model, Qwen2.5 72B, by approximately 10%in absolute scores, which is a substantial margin for such challenging benchmarks.\nThis remarkable capability highlights the effectiveness of the distillation technique from DeepSeek-R1, which has been proven highly beneficial for non-o1-like models.", + "text": "On math benchmarks, DeepSeek-V3 demonstrates exceptional performance, significantly surpassing baselines and setting a new state-of-the-art for non-o1-like models. \nSpecifically, on AIME, MATH-500, and CNMO 2024, DeepSeek-V3 outperforms the second-best model, Qwen2.5 72B, by approximately 10%in absolute scores, which is a substantial margin for such challenging benchmarks.\nThis remarkable capability highlights the effectiveness of the distillation technique from DeepSeek-R1, which has been proven highly beneficial for non-o1-like models." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/288", + "self_ref": "#/texts/237", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4973,19 +4181,7 @@ "text": "Chinese Benchmarks.\nQwen and DeepSeek are two representative model series with robust support for both Chinese and English. \nOn the factual benchmark Chinese SimpleQA, DeepSeek-V3 surpasses Qwen2.5-72B by 16.4 points, despite Qwen2.5 being trained on a larger corpus compromising 18T tokens, which are 20% more than the 14.8T tokens that DeepSeek-V3is pre-trained on." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/289", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "On C-Eval, a representative benchmark for Chinese educational knowledge evaluation, and CLUEWSC (Chinese Winograd Schema Challenge),", - "text": "On C-Eval, a representative benchmark for Chinese educational knowledge evaluation, and CLUEWSC (Chinese Winograd Schema Challenge)," - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/290", + "self_ref": "#/texts/238", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -4993,11 +4189,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "DeepSeek-V3and Qwen2.5-72B exhibit similar performance levels, indicating that both models are well-optimized for challenging Chinese-language reasoning and educational tasks.", - "text": "DeepSeek-V3and Qwen2.5-72B exhibit similar performance levels, indicating that both models are well-optimized for challenging Chinese-language reasoning and educational tasks." + "orig": "On C-Eval, a representative benchmark for Chinese educational knowledge evaluation, and CLUEWSC (Chinese Winograd Schema Challenge), DeepSeek-V3and Qwen2.5-72B exhibit similar performance levels, indicating that both models are well-optimized for challenging Chinese-language reasoning and educational tasks.", + "text": "On C-Eval, a representative benchmark for Chinese educational knowledge evaluation, and CLUEWSC (Chinese Winograd Schema Challenge), DeepSeek-V3and Qwen2.5-72B exhibit similar performance levels, indicating that both models are well-optimized for challenging Chinese-language reasoning and educational tasks." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/291", + "self_ref": "#/texts/239", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5009,7 +4205,7 @@ "text": "English open-ended conversation evaluations. \n For AlpacaEval 2.0, we use the length-controlled win rate as the metric." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/292", + "self_ref": "#/texts/240", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5022,19 +4218,7 @@ "level": 3 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/293", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "In addition to standard benchmarks, we also evaluate our models on open-ended generation tasks using LLMs as judges, with the results shown in Table", - "text": "In addition to standard benchmarks, we also evaluate our models on open-ended generation tasks using LLMs as judges, with the results shown in Table" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/294", + "self_ref": "#/texts/241", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5042,23 +4226,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[tab:open]. \nSpecifically, we adhere to the original configurations of AlpacaEval 2.0[alpaca2.0] and Arena-Hard[li2024crowdsourced], which leverage GPT-4-Turbo-1106 as judges for pairwise comparisons. \nOn Arena-Hard, DeepSeek-V3 achieves an impressive win rate of over 86% against the baseline GPT-4-0314, performing on par with top-tier models like Claude-Sonnet-3.5-1022. \nThis underscores the robust capabilities of DeepSeek-V3, especially in dealing with complex prompts, including coding and debugging tasks. \nFurthermore, DeepSeek-V3 achieves a groundbreaking milestone as the first open-source model to surpass 85%on the Arena-Hard benchmark. \nThis achievement significantly bridges the performance gap between open-source and closed-source models, setting a new standard for what open-source models can accomplish in challenging domains.", - "text": "[tab:open]. \nSpecifically, we adhere to the original configurations of AlpacaEval 2.0[alpaca2.0] and Arena-Hard[li2024crowdsourced], which leverage GPT-4-Turbo-1106 as judges for pairwise comparisons. \nOn Arena-Hard, DeepSeek-V3 achieves an impressive win rate of over 86% against the baseline GPT-4-0314, performing on par with top-tier models like Claude-Sonnet-3.5-1022. \nThis underscores the robust capabilities of DeepSeek-V3, especially in dealing with complex prompts, including coding and debugging tasks. \nFurthermore, DeepSeek-V3 achieves a groundbreaking milestone as the first open-source model to surpass 85%on the Arena-Hard benchmark. \nThis achievement significantly bridges the performance gap between open-source and closed-source models, setting a new standard for what open-source models can accomplish in challenging domains." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/295", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Similarly,", - "text": "Similarly," + "orig": "In addition to standard benchmarks, we also evaluate our models on open-ended generation tasks using LLMs as judges, with the results shown in Table[tab:open]. \nSpecifically, we adhere to the original configurations of AlpacaEval 2.0[alpaca2.0] and Arena-Hard[li2024crowdsourced], which leverage GPT-4-Turbo-1106 as judges for pairwise comparisons. \nOn Arena-Hard, DeepSeek-V3 achieves an impressive win rate of over 86% against the baseline GPT-4-0314, performing on par with top-tier models like Claude-Sonnet-3.5-1022. \nThis underscores the robust capabilities of DeepSeek-V3, especially in dealing with complex prompts, including coding and debugging tasks. \nFurthermore, DeepSeek-V3 achieves a groundbreaking milestone as the first open-source model to surpass 85%on the Arena-Hard benchmark. \nThis achievement significantly bridges the performance gap between open-source and closed-source models, setting a new standard for what open-source models can accomplish in challenging domains.", + "text": "In addition to standard benchmarks, we also evaluate our models on open-ended generation tasks using LLMs as judges, with the results shown in Table[tab:open]. \nSpecifically, we adhere to the original configurations of AlpacaEval 2.0[alpaca2.0] and Arena-Hard[li2024crowdsourced], which leverage GPT-4-Turbo-1106 as judges for pairwise comparisons. \nOn Arena-Hard, DeepSeek-V3 achieves an impressive win rate of over 86% against the baseline GPT-4-0314, performing on par with top-tier models like Claude-Sonnet-3.5-1022. \nThis underscores the robust capabilities of DeepSeek-V3, especially in dealing with complex prompts, including coding and debugging tasks. \nFurthermore, DeepSeek-V3 achieves a groundbreaking milestone as the first open-source model to surpass 85%on the Arena-Hard benchmark. \nThis achievement significantly bridges the performance gap between open-source and closed-source models, setting a new standard for what open-source models can accomplish in challenging domains." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/296", + "self_ref": "#/texts/242", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5066,11 +4238,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "DeepSeek-V3 showcases exceptional performance on AlpacaEval 2.0, outperforming both closed-source and open-source models. \nThis demonstrates its outstanding proficiency in writing tasks and handling straightforward question-answering scenarios. \nNotably, it surpasses DeepSeek-V2.5-0905 by a significant margin of 20%, highlighting substantial improvements in tackling simple tasks and showcasing the effectiveness of its advancements.", - "text": "DeepSeek-V3 showcases exceptional performance on AlpacaEval 2.0, outperforming both closed-source and open-source models. \nThis demonstrates its outstanding proficiency in writing tasks and handling straightforward question-answering scenarios. \nNotably, it surpasses DeepSeek-V2.5-0905 by a significant margin of 20%, highlighting substantial improvements in tackling simple tasks and showcasing the effectiveness of its advancements." + "orig": "Similarly, DeepSeek-V3 showcases exceptional performance on AlpacaEval 2.0, outperforming both closed-source and open-source models. \nThis demonstrates its outstanding proficiency in writing tasks and handling straightforward question-answering scenarios. \nNotably, it surpasses DeepSeek-V2.5-0905 by a significant margin of 20%, highlighting substantial improvements in tackling simple tasks and showcasing the effectiveness of its advancements.", + "text": "Similarly, DeepSeek-V3 showcases exceptional performance on AlpacaEval 2.0, outperforming both closed-source and open-source models. \nThis demonstrates its outstanding proficiency in writing tasks and handling straightforward question-answering scenarios. \nNotably, it surpasses DeepSeek-V2.5-0905 by a significant margin of 20%, highlighting substantial improvements in tackling simple tasks and showcasing the effectiveness of its advancements." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/297", + "self_ref": "#/texts/243", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5083,19 +4255,7 @@ "level": 3 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/298", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "We compare the judgment ability of", - "text": "We compare the judgment ability of" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/299", + "self_ref": "#/texts/244", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5103,11 +4263,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "DeepSeek-V3 with state-of-the-art models, namely GPT-4o and Claude-3.5. \nTable[tab:rewardbench] presents the performance of these models in RewardBench [lambert2024rewardbench].\nDeepSeek-V3 achieves performance on par with the best versions of GPT-4o-0806 and Claude-3.5-Sonnet-1022, while surpassing other versions. \nAdditionally, the judgment ability of DeepSeek-V3 can also be enhanced by the voting technique. \nTherefore, we employ DeepSeek-V3along with voting to offer self-feedback on open-ended questions, thereby improving the effectiveness and robustness of the alignment process.", - "text": "DeepSeek-V3 with state-of-the-art models, namely GPT-4o and Claude-3.5. \nTable[tab:rewardbench] presents the performance of these models in RewardBench [lambert2024rewardbench].\nDeepSeek-V3 achieves performance on par with the best versions of GPT-4o-0806 and Claude-3.5-Sonnet-1022, while surpassing other versions. \nAdditionally, the judgment ability of DeepSeek-V3 can also be enhanced by the voting technique. \nTherefore, we employ DeepSeek-V3along with voting to offer self-feedback on open-ended questions, thereby improving the effectiveness and robustness of the alignment process." + "orig": "We compare the judgment ability of DeepSeek-V3 with state-of-the-art models, namely GPT-4o and Claude-3.5. \nTable[tab:rewardbench] presents the performance of these models in RewardBench [lambert2024rewardbench].\nDeepSeek-V3 achieves performance on par with the best versions of GPT-4o-0806 and Claude-3.5-Sonnet-1022, while surpassing other versions. \nAdditionally, the judgment ability of DeepSeek-V3 can also be enhanced by the voting technique. \nTherefore, we employ DeepSeek-V3along with voting to offer self-feedback on open-ended questions, thereby improving the effectiveness and robustness of the alignment process.", + "text": "We compare the judgment ability of DeepSeek-V3 with state-of-the-art models, namely GPT-4o and Claude-3.5. \nTable[tab:rewardbench] presents the performance of these models in RewardBench [lambert2024rewardbench].\nDeepSeek-V3 achieves performance on par with the best versions of GPT-4o-0806 and Claude-3.5-Sonnet-1022, while surpassing other versions. \nAdditionally, the judgment ability of DeepSeek-V3 can also be enhanced by the voting technique. \nTherefore, we employ DeepSeek-V3along with voting to offer self-feedback on open-ended questions, thereby improving the effectiveness and robustness of the alignment process." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/300", + "self_ref": "#/texts/245", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5119,7 +4279,7 @@ "text": "Performances of GPT-4o, Claude-3.5-sonnet and DeepSeek-V3 on RewardBench." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/301", + "self_ref": "#/texts/246", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5132,7 +4292,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/302", + "self_ref": "#/texts/247", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5145,7 +4305,7 @@ "level": 3 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/303", + "self_ref": "#/texts/248", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5157,19 +4317,7 @@ "text": "We ablate the contribution of distillation from DeepSeek-R1 based on DeepSeek-V2.5. \nThe baseline is trained on short CoT data, whereas its competitor uses data generated by the expert checkpoints described above." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/304", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Table", - "text": "Table" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/305", + "self_ref": "#/texts/249", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5177,11 +4325,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[tab:distill] demonstrates the effectiveness of the distillation data, showing significant improvements in both LiveCodeBench and MATH-500 benchmarks. \nOur experiments reveal an interesting trade-off: the distillation leads to better performance but also substantially increases the average response length. \nTo maintain a balance between model accuracy and computational efficiency, we carefully selected optimal settings for DeepSeek-V3in distillation.", - "text": "[tab:distill] demonstrates the effectiveness of the distillation data, showing significant improvements in both LiveCodeBench and MATH-500 benchmarks. \nOur experiments reveal an interesting trade-off: the distillation leads to better performance but also substantially increases the average response length. \nTo maintain a balance between model accuracy and computational efficiency, we carefully selected optimal settings for DeepSeek-V3in distillation." + "orig": "Table[tab:distill] demonstrates the effectiveness of the distillation data, showing significant improvements in both LiveCodeBench and MATH-500 benchmarks. \nOur experiments reveal an interesting trade-off: the distillation leads to better performance but also substantially increases the average response length. \nTo maintain a balance between model accuracy and computational efficiency, we carefully selected optimal settings for DeepSeek-V3in distillation.", + "text": "Table[tab:distill] demonstrates the effectiveness of the distillation data, showing significant improvements in both LiveCodeBench and MATH-500 benchmarks. \nOur experiments reveal an interesting trade-off: the distillation leads to better performance but also substantially increases the average response length. \nTo maintain a balance between model accuracy and computational efficiency, we carefully selected optimal settings for DeepSeek-V3in distillation." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/306", + "self_ref": "#/texts/250", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5193,7 +4341,7 @@ "text": "Our research suggests that knowledge distillation from reasoning models presents a promising direction for post-training optimization. \nWhile our current work focuses on distilling data from mathematics and coding domains, this approach shows potential for broader applications across various task domains. \nThe effectiveness demonstrated in these specific areas indicates that long-CoT distillation could be valuable for enhancing model performance in other cognitive tasks requiring complex reasoning. \nFurther exploration of this approach across different domains remains an important direction for future research." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/307", + "self_ref": "#/texts/251", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5205,7 +4353,7 @@ "text": "The contribution of distillation from DeepSeek-R1. \n The evaluation settings of LiveCodeBench and MATH-500 are the same as in Table\\ref{tab:chat}." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/308", + "self_ref": "#/texts/252", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5218,19 +4366,7 @@ "level": 3 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/309", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Rewards play a pivotal role in RL, steering the optimization process. \nIn domains where verification through external tools is straightforward, such as some coding or mathematics scenarios, RL demonstrates exceptional efficacy.\nHowever, in more general scenarios, constructing a feedback mechanism through hard coding is impractical. \nDuring the development of", - "text": "Rewards play a pivotal role in RL, steering the optimization process. \nIn domains where verification through external tools is straightforward, such as some coding or mathematics scenarios, RL demonstrates exceptional efficacy.\nHowever, in more general scenarios, constructing a feedback mechanism through hard coding is impractical. \nDuring the development of" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/310", + "self_ref": "#/texts/253", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5238,11 +4374,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "DeepSeek-V3, for these broader contexts, we employ the constitutional AI approach[bai2022constitutional], leveraging the voting evaluation results of DeepSeek-V3 itself as a feedback source. \nThis method has produced notable alignment effects, significantly enhancing the performance of DeepSeek-V3 in subjective evaluations. \nBy integrating additional constitutional inputs, DeepSeek-V3can optimize towards the constitutional direction. \nWe believe that this paradigm, which combines supplementary information with LLMs as a feedback source, is of paramount importance. \nThe LLM serves as a versatile processor capable of transforming unstructured information from diverse scenarios into rewards, ultimately facilitating the self-improvement of LLMs. \nBeyond self-rewarding, we are also dedicated to uncovering other general and scalable rewarding methods to consistently advance the model capabilities in general scenarios.", - "text": "DeepSeek-V3, for these broader contexts, we employ the constitutional AI approach[bai2022constitutional], leveraging the voting evaluation results of DeepSeek-V3 itself as a feedback source. \nThis method has produced notable alignment effects, significantly enhancing the performance of DeepSeek-V3 in subjective evaluations. \nBy integrating additional constitutional inputs, DeepSeek-V3can optimize towards the constitutional direction. \nWe believe that this paradigm, which combines supplementary information with LLMs as a feedback source, is of paramount importance. \nThe LLM serves as a versatile processor capable of transforming unstructured information from diverse scenarios into rewards, ultimately facilitating the self-improvement of LLMs. \nBeyond self-rewarding, we are also dedicated to uncovering other general and scalable rewarding methods to consistently advance the model capabilities in general scenarios." + "orig": "Rewards play a pivotal role in RL, steering the optimization process. \nIn domains where verification through external tools is straightforward, such as some coding or mathematics scenarios, RL demonstrates exceptional efficacy.\nHowever, in more general scenarios, constructing a feedback mechanism through hard coding is impractical. \nDuring the development of DeepSeek-V3, for these broader contexts, we employ the constitutional AI approach[bai2022constitutional], leveraging the voting evaluation results of DeepSeek-V3 itself as a feedback source. \nThis method has produced notable alignment effects, significantly enhancing the performance of DeepSeek-V3 in subjective evaluations. \nBy integrating additional constitutional inputs, DeepSeek-V3can optimize towards the constitutional direction. \nWe believe that this paradigm, which combines supplementary information with LLMs as a feedback source, is of paramount importance. \nThe LLM serves as a versatile processor capable of transforming unstructured information from diverse scenarios into rewards, ultimately facilitating the self-improvement of LLMs. \nBeyond self-rewarding, we are also dedicated to uncovering other general and scalable rewarding methods to consistently advance the model capabilities in general scenarios.", + "text": "Rewards play a pivotal role in RL, steering the optimization process. \nIn domains where verification through external tools is straightforward, such as some coding or mathematics scenarios, RL demonstrates exceptional efficacy.\nHowever, in more general scenarios, constructing a feedback mechanism through hard coding is impractical. \nDuring the development of DeepSeek-V3, for these broader contexts, we employ the constitutional AI approach[bai2022constitutional], leveraging the voting evaluation results of DeepSeek-V3 itself as a feedback source. \nThis method has produced notable alignment effects, significantly enhancing the performance of DeepSeek-V3 in subjective evaluations. \nBy integrating additional constitutional inputs, DeepSeek-V3can optimize towards the constitutional direction. \nWe believe that this paradigm, which combines supplementary information with LLMs as a feedback source, is of paramount importance. \nThe LLM serves as a versatile processor capable of transforming unstructured information from diverse scenarios into rewards, ultimately facilitating the self-improvement of LLMs. \nBeyond self-rewarding, we are also dedicated to uncovering other general and scalable rewarding methods to consistently advance the model capabilities in general scenarios." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/311", + "self_ref": "#/texts/254", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5255,19 +4391,7 @@ "level": 3 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/312", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Instead of predicting just the next single token,", - "text": "Instead of predicting just the next single token," - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/313", + "self_ref": "#/texts/255", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5275,11 +4399,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "DeepSeek-V3 predicts the next 2 tokens through the MTP technique. \nCombined with the framework of speculative decoding[speculative_google,speculative_xhm], it can significantly accelerate the decoding speed of the model. \nA natural question arises concerning the acceptance rate of the additionally predicted token. \nBased on our evaluation, the acceptance rate of the second token prediction ranges between 85% and 90% across various generation topics, demonstrating consistent reliability. \nThis high acceptance rate enables DeepSeek-V3to achieve a significantly improved decoding speed, delivering 1.8 times TPS (Tokens Per Second).", - "text": "DeepSeek-V3 predicts the next 2 tokens through the MTP technique. \nCombined with the framework of speculative decoding[speculative_google,speculative_xhm], it can significantly accelerate the decoding speed of the model. \nA natural question arises concerning the acceptance rate of the additionally predicted token. \nBased on our evaluation, the acceptance rate of the second token prediction ranges between 85% and 90% across various generation topics, demonstrating consistent reliability. \nThis high acceptance rate enables DeepSeek-V3to achieve a significantly improved decoding speed, delivering 1.8 times TPS (Tokens Per Second)." + "orig": "Instead of predicting just the next single token, DeepSeek-V3 predicts the next 2 tokens through the MTP technique. \nCombined with the framework of speculative decoding[speculative_google,speculative_xhm], it can significantly accelerate the decoding speed of the model. \nA natural question arises concerning the acceptance rate of the additionally predicted token. \nBased on our evaluation, the acceptance rate of the second token prediction ranges between 85% and 90% across various generation topics, demonstrating consistent reliability. \nThis high acceptance rate enables DeepSeek-V3to achieve a significantly improved decoding speed, delivering 1.8 times TPS (Tokens Per Second).", + "text": "Instead of predicting just the next single token, DeepSeek-V3 predicts the next 2 tokens through the MTP technique. \nCombined with the framework of speculative decoding[speculative_google,speculative_xhm], it can significantly accelerate the decoding speed of the model. \nA natural question arises concerning the acceptance rate of the additionally predicted token. \nBased on our evaluation, the acceptance rate of the second token prediction ranges between 85% and 90% across various generation topics, demonstrating consistent reliability. \nThis high acceptance rate enables DeepSeek-V3to achieve a significantly improved decoding speed, delivering 1.8 times TPS (Tokens Per Second)." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/314", + "self_ref": "#/texts/256", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5292,19 +4416,7 @@ "level": 1 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/315", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "In this paper, we introduce", - "text": "In this paper, we introduce" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/316", + "self_ref": "#/texts/257", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5312,23 +4424,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "DeepSeek-V3, a large MoE language model with 671B total parameters and 37B activated parameters, trained on 14.8T tokens. \nIn addition to the MLA and DeepSeekMoE architectures, it also pioneers an auxiliary-loss-free strategy for load balancing and sets a multi-token prediction training objective for stronger performance.\nThe training of DeepSeek-V3is cost-effective due to the support of FP8 training and meticulous engineering optimizations. \nThe post-training also makes a success in distilling the reasoning capability from the DeepSeek-R1 series of models.\nComprehensive evaluations demonstrate that DeepSeek-V3 has emerged as the strongest open-source model currently available, and achieves performance comparable to leading closed-source models like GPT-4o and Claude-3.5-Sonnet. \nDespite its strong performance, it also maintains economical training costs. \nIt requires only 2.788M H800 GPU hours for its full training, including pre-training, context length extension, and post-training.", - "text": "DeepSeek-V3, a large MoE language model with 671B total parameters and 37B activated parameters, trained on 14.8T tokens. \nIn addition to the MLA and DeepSeekMoE architectures, it also pioneers an auxiliary-loss-free strategy for load balancing and sets a multi-token prediction training objective for stronger performance.\nThe training of DeepSeek-V3is cost-effective due to the support of FP8 training and meticulous engineering optimizations. \nThe post-training also makes a success in distilling the reasoning capability from the DeepSeek-R1 series of models.\nComprehensive evaluations demonstrate that DeepSeek-V3 has emerged as the strongest open-source model currently available, and achieves performance comparable to leading closed-source models like GPT-4o and Claude-3.5-Sonnet. \nDespite its strong performance, it also maintains economical training costs. \nIt requires only 2.788M H800 GPU hours for its full training, including pre-training, context length extension, and post-training." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/317", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "While acknowledging its strong performance and cost-effectiveness, we also recognize that", - "text": "While acknowledging its strong performance and cost-effectiveness, we also recognize that" + "orig": "In this paper, we introduce DeepSeek-V3, a large MoE language model with 671B total parameters and 37B activated parameters, trained on 14.8T tokens. \nIn addition to the MLA and DeepSeekMoE architectures, it also pioneers an auxiliary-loss-free strategy for load balancing and sets a multi-token prediction training objective for stronger performance.\nThe training of DeepSeek-V3is cost-effective due to the support of FP8 training and meticulous engineering optimizations. \nThe post-training also makes a success in distilling the reasoning capability from the DeepSeek-R1 series of models.\nComprehensive evaluations demonstrate that DeepSeek-V3 has emerged as the strongest open-source model currently available, and achieves performance comparable to leading closed-source models like GPT-4o and Claude-3.5-Sonnet. \nDespite its strong performance, it also maintains economical training costs. \nIt requires only 2.788M H800 GPU hours for its full training, including pre-training, context length extension, and post-training.", + "text": "In this paper, we introduce DeepSeek-V3, a large MoE language model with 671B total parameters and 37B activated parameters, trained on 14.8T tokens. \nIn addition to the MLA and DeepSeekMoE architectures, it also pioneers an auxiliary-loss-free strategy for load balancing and sets a multi-token prediction training objective for stronger performance.\nThe training of DeepSeek-V3is cost-effective due to the support of FP8 training and meticulous engineering optimizations. \nThe post-training also makes a success in distilling the reasoning capability from the DeepSeek-R1 series of models.\nComprehensive evaluations demonstrate that DeepSeek-V3 has emerged as the strongest open-source model currently available, and achieves performance comparable to leading closed-source models like GPT-4o and Claude-3.5-Sonnet. \nDespite its strong performance, it also maintains economical training costs. \nIt requires only 2.788M H800 GPU hours for its full training, including pre-training, context length extension, and post-training." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/318", + "self_ref": "#/texts/258", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5336,23 +4436,23 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "DeepSeek-V3 has some limitations, especially on the deployment.\nFirstly, to ensure efficient inference, the recommended deployment unit for DeepSeek-V3 is relatively large, which might pose a burden for small-sized teams.\nSecondly, although our deployment strategy for DeepSeek-V3 has achieved an end-to-end generation speed of more than two times that of DeepSeek-V2, there still remains potential for further enhancement.\nFortunately, these limitations are expected to be naturally addressed with the development of more advanced hardware.", - "text": "DeepSeek-V3 has some limitations, especially on the deployment.\nFirstly, to ensure efficient inference, the recommended deployment unit for DeepSeek-V3 is relatively large, which might pose a burden for small-sized teams.\nSecondly, although our deployment strategy for DeepSeek-V3 has achieved an end-to-end generation speed of more than two times that of DeepSeek-V2, there still remains potential for further enhancement.\nFortunately, these limitations are expected to be naturally addressed with the development of more advanced hardware." + "orig": "While acknowledging its strong performance and cost-effectiveness, we also recognize that DeepSeek-V3 has some limitations, especially on the deployment.\nFirstly, to ensure efficient inference, the recommended deployment unit for DeepSeek-V3 is relatively large, which might pose a burden for small-sized teams.\nSecondly, although our deployment strategy for DeepSeek-V3 has achieved an end-to-end generation speed of more than two times that of DeepSeek-V2, there still remains potential for further enhancement.\nFortunately, these limitations are expected to be naturally addressed with the development of more advanced hardware.", + "text": "While acknowledging its strong performance and cost-effectiveness, we also recognize that DeepSeek-V3 has some limitations, especially on the deployment.\nFirstly, to ensure efficient inference, the recommended deployment unit for DeepSeek-V3 is relatively large, which might pose a burden for small-sized teams.\nSecondly, although our deployment strategy for DeepSeek-V3 has achieved an end-to-end generation speed of more than two times that of DeepSeek-V2, there still remains potential for further enhancement.\nFortunately, these limitations are expected to be naturally addressed with the development of more advanced hardware." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/319", + "self_ref": "#/texts/259", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], "orig": "DeepSeek consistently adheres to the route of open-source models with longtermism, aiming to steadily approach the ultimate goal of AGI (Artificial General Intelligence).\nIn the future, we plan to strategically invest in research across the following directions.", "text": "DeepSeek consistently adheres to the route of open-source models with longtermism, aiming to steadily approach the ultimate goal of AGI (Artificial General Intelligence).\nIn the future, we plan to strategically invest in research across the following directions." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/320", + "self_ref": "#/texts/260", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/14" }, @@ -5366,7 +4466,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/321", + "self_ref": "#/texts/261", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/14" }, @@ -5380,7 +4480,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/322", + "self_ref": "#/texts/262", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/14" }, @@ -5394,7 +4494,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/323", + "self_ref": "#/texts/263", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/14" }, @@ -5408,7 +4508,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/324", + "self_ref": "#/texts/264", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5420,7 +4520,7 @@ "text": "main" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/325", + "self_ref": "#/texts/265", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5433,7 +4533,7 @@ "level": 1 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/326", + "self_ref": "#/texts/266", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5446,7 +4546,7 @@ "level": 1 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/327", + "self_ref": "#/texts/267", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5458,7 +4558,7 @@ "text": "2 Research & Engineering \n Aixin Liu \n Bing Xue \n Bingxuan Wang \n Bochao Wu \n Chengda Lu \n Chenggang Zhao \n Chengqi Deng \n Chenyu Zhang* \n Chong Ruan \n Damai Dai \n Daya Guo \n Dejian Yang \n Deli Chen \n Erhang Li \n Fangyun Lin \n Fucong Dai \n Fuli Luo* \n Guangbo Hao \n Guanting Chen \n Guowei Li \n H. Zhang \n Han Bao* \n Hanwei Xu \n Haocheng Wang* \n Haowei Zhang \n Honghui Ding \n Huajian Xin* \n Huazuo Gao \n Hui Qu \n Jianzhong Guo \n Jiashi Li \n Jiawei Wang* \n Jingchang Chen \n Jingyang Yuan \n Junjie Qiu \n Junlong Li \n Junxiao Song \n Kai Dong \n Kai Hu* \n Kaige Gao \n Kang Guan \n Kexin Huang \n Kuai Yu \n Lean Wang \n Lecong Zhang \n Liang Zhao \n Litong Wang \n Liyue Zhang \n Mingchuan Zhang \n Minghua Zhang \n Minghui Tang \n Panpan Huang \n Peiyi Wang \n Qiancheng Wang \n Qihao Zhu \n Qinyu Chen \n Qiushi Du \n Ruiqi Ge \n Ruisong Zhang \n Ruizhe Pan \n Runji Wang \n Runxin Xu \n Ruoyu Zhang \n Shanghao Lu \n Shangyan Zhou \n Shanhuang Chen \n Shengfeng Ye \n Shirong Ma \n Shiyu Wang \n Shuiping Yu \n Shunfeng Zhou \n Shuting Pan \n Tao Yun \n Tian Pei \n Wangding Zeng \n Wanjia Zhao* \n Wen Liu \n Wenfeng Liang \n Wenjun Gao \n Wenqin Yu \n Wentao Zhang \n Xiao Bi \n Xiaodong Liu \n Xiaohan Wang \n Xiaokang Chen \n Xiaokang Zhang \n Xiaotao Nie \n Xin Cheng \n Xin Liu \n Xin Xie \n Xingchao Liu \n Xingkai Yu \n Xinyu Yang \n Xinyuan Li \n Xuecheng Su \n Xuheng Lin \n Y.K. Li \n Y.Q. Wang \n Y.X. Wei \n Yang Zhang \n Yanhong Xu \n Yao Li \n Yao Zhao \n Yaofeng Sun \n Yaohui Wang \n Yi Yu \n Yichao Zhang \n Yifan Shi \n Yiliang Xiong \n Ying He \n Yishi Piao \n Yisong Wang \n Yixuan Tan \n Yiyang Ma* \n Yiyuan Liu \n Yongqiang Guo \n Yu Wu \n Yuan Ou \n Yuduan Wang \n Yue Gong \n Yuheng Zou \n Yujia He \n Yunfan Xiong \n Yuxiang Luo \n Yuxiang You \n Yuxuan Liu \n Yuyang Zhou \n Z.F. Wu \n Z.Z. Ren \n Zehui Ren \n Zhangli Sha \n Zhe Fu \n Zhean Xu \n Zhenda Xie \n Zhengyan Zhang \n Zhewen Hao \n Zhibin Gou \n Zhicheng Ma \n Zhigang Yan \n Zhihong Shao \n Zhiyu Wu \n Zhuoshu Li \n Zihui Gu \n Zijia Zhu \n Zijun Liu* \n Zilin Li \n Ziwei Xie \n Ziyang Song \n Ziyi Gao \n Zizheng Pan" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/328", + "self_ref": "#/texts/268", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5470,7 +4570,7 @@ "text": "Data Annotation \n Bei Feng \n Hui Li \n J.L. Cai \n Jiaqi Ni \n Lei Xu \n Meng Li \n Ning Tian \n R.J. Chen \n R.L. Jin \n Ruyi Chen \n S.S. Li \n Shuang Zhou \n Tianyu Sun \n X.Q. Li \n Xiangyue Jin \n Xiaojin Shen \n Xiaosha Chen \n Xiaowen Sun \n Xiaoxiang Wang \n Xinnan Song \n Xinyi Zhou \n Y.X. Zhu \n Yanhong Xu \n Yanping Huang \n Yaohui Li \n Yi Zheng \n Yuchen Zhu \n Yunxian Ma \n Zhen Huang \n Zhipeng Xu \n Zhongyu Zhang" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/329", + "self_ref": "#/texts/269", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5482,7 +4582,7 @@ "text": "Business & Compliance \n Dongjie Ji \n Jian Liang \n Jin Chen \n Leyi Xia \n Miaojun Wang \n Mingming Li \n Peng Zhang \n Shaoqing Wu \n Shengfeng Ye \n T. Wang \n W.L. Xiao \n Wei An \n Xianzu Wang \n Xinxia Shan \n Ying Tang \n Yukun Zha \n Yuting Yan \n Zhen Zhang" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/330", + "self_ref": "#/texts/270", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5494,7 +4594,7 @@ "text": "Within each role, authors are listed alphabetically by the first name. \nNames marked with * denote individuals who have departed from our team." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/331", + "self_ref": "#/texts/271", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5507,7 +4607,7 @@ "level": 1 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/332", + "self_ref": "#/texts/272", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5519,7 +4619,7 @@ "text": "Image: figures/fp8-v.s.-bf16.pdf" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/333", + "self_ref": "#/texts/273", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/15" }, @@ -5531,7 +4631,7 @@ "text": "Loss curves comparison between BF16 and FP8 training. \n Results are smoothed by Exponential Moving Average (EMA) with a coefficient of 0.9." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/334", + "self_ref": "#/texts/274", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5544,7 +4644,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/335", + "self_ref": "#/texts/275", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5556,7 +4656,7 @@ "text": "We validate our FP8 mixed precision framework with a comparison to BF16 training on top of two baseline models across different scales. At the small scale, we train a baseline MoE model comprising approximately 16B total parameters on 1.33T tokens. \nAt the large scale, we train a baseline MoE model comprising approximately 230B total parameters on around 0.9T tokens. We show the training curves in Figure[fig:fp8_vs_bf16] and demonstrate that the relative error remains below 0.25%with our high-precision accumulation and fine-grained quantization strategies." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/336", + "self_ref": "#/texts/276", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5569,7 +4669,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/337", + "self_ref": "#/texts/277", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5581,7 +4681,7 @@ "text": "Although our tile-wise fine-grained quantization effectively mitigates the error introduced by feature outliers, it requires different groupings for activation quantization, i.e., 1x128 in forward pass and 128x1 for backward pass. \nA similar process is also required for the activation gradient. \nA straightforward strategy is to apply block-wise quantization per 128x128 elements like the way we quantize the model weights.\nIn this way, only transposition is required for backward.\nTherefore, we conduct an experiment where all tensors associated with Dgrad are quantized on a block-wise basis. \nThe results reveal that the Dgrad operation which computes the activation gradients and back-propagates to shallow layers in a chain-like manner, is highly sensitive to precision. \nSpecifically, block-wise quantization of activation gradients leads to model divergence on an MoE model comprising approximately 16B total parameters, trained for around 300B tokens. \nWe hypothesize that this sensitivity arises because activation gradients are highly imbalanced among tokens, resulting in token-correlated outliers[int4train]. \nThese outliers cannot be effectively managed by a block-wise quantization approach." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/338", + "self_ref": "#/texts/278", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5594,7 +4694,7 @@ "level": 1 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/339", + "self_ref": "#/texts/279", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5606,7 +4706,7 @@ "text": "We record the expert load of the 16B auxiliary-loss-based baseline and the auxiliary-loss-free model on the Pile test set. \nThe auxiliary-loss-free model tends to have greater expert specialization across all layers, as demonstrated in Figure[fig:detailed_expert_load]." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/340", + "self_ref": "#/texts/280", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/16" }, @@ -5618,7 +4718,7 @@ "text": "[Layers 1-7]" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/341", + "self_ref": "#/texts/281", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5630,7 +4730,7 @@ "text": "Image: figures/relative_expert_load_multi_1-6.pdf" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/342", + "self_ref": "#/texts/282", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/17" }, @@ -5642,7 +4742,7 @@ "text": "[Layers 7-13]" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/343", + "self_ref": "#/texts/283", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5654,7 +4754,7 @@ "text": "Image: figures/relative_expert_load_multi_7-12.pdf" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/344", + "self_ref": "#/texts/284", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/18" }, @@ -5666,7 +4766,7 @@ "text": "[Layers 13-19]" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/345", + "self_ref": "#/texts/285", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5678,7 +4778,7 @@ "text": "Image: figures/relative_expert_load_multi_13-18.pdf" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/346", + "self_ref": "#/texts/286", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/19" }, @@ -5690,7 +4790,7 @@ "text": "[Layers 19-25]" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/347", + "self_ref": "#/texts/287", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5702,7 +4802,7 @@ "text": "Image: figures/relative_expert_load_multi_19-24.pdf" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/348", + "self_ref": "#/texts/288", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/20" }, @@ -5714,7 +4814,7 @@ "text": "[Layers 25-27]" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/349", + "self_ref": "#/texts/289", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -5726,7 +4826,7 @@ "text": "Image: figures/relative_expert_load_multi_25-26.pdf" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/350", + "self_ref": "#/texts/290", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/20" }, @@ -5762,7 +4862,7 @@ "width": 2270.0, "height": 1327.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -5777,7 +4877,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/37" + "$ref": "#/texts/30" } ], "references": [], @@ -5789,7 +4889,7 @@ "width": 2024.0, "height": 1628.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -5804,7 +4904,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/66" + "$ref": "#/texts/56" } ], "references": [], @@ -5816,7 +4916,7 @@ "width": 2340.0, "height": 1042.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -5831,7 +4931,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/92" + "$ref": "#/texts/79" } ], "references": [], @@ -5843,7 +4943,7 @@ "width": 1718.0, "height": 180.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -5858,7 +4958,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/98" + "$ref": "#/texts/83" } ], "references": [], @@ -5870,7 +4970,7 @@ "width": 2778.0, "height": 444.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -5885,7 +4985,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/115" + "$ref": "#/texts/97" } ], "references": [], @@ -5897,7 +4997,7 @@ "width": 1019.0, "height": 294.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -5912,7 +5012,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/125" + "$ref": "#/texts/104" } ], "references": [], @@ -5924,7 +5024,7 @@ "width": 962.0, "height": 488.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -5939,7 +5039,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/196" + "$ref": "#/texts/159" } ], "references": [], @@ -5951,7 +5051,7 @@ "width": 2333.0, "height": 1220.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -5966,7 +5066,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/241" + "$ref": "#/texts/194" } ], "references": [], @@ -5978,7 +5078,7 @@ "width": 1785.0, "height": 878.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -5993,7 +5093,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/332" + "$ref": "#/texts/272" } ], "references": [], @@ -6005,7 +5105,7 @@ "width": 1353.0, "height": 377.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -6020,7 +5120,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/341" + "$ref": "#/texts/281" } ], "references": [], @@ -6032,7 +5132,7 @@ "width": 1785.0, "height": 2606.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -6047,7 +5147,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/343" + "$ref": "#/texts/283" } ], "references": [], @@ -6059,7 +5159,7 @@ "width": 1785.0, "height": 2606.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -6074,7 +5174,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/345" + "$ref": "#/texts/285" } ], "references": [], @@ -6086,7 +5186,7 @@ "width": 1785.0, "height": 2606.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -6101,7 +5201,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/347" + "$ref": "#/texts/287" } ], "references": [], @@ -6113,7 +5213,7 @@ "width": 1785.0, "height": 2606.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -6128,7 +5228,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/349" + "$ref": "#/texts/289" } ], "references": [], @@ -6140,7 +5240,7 @@ "width": 1785.0, "height": 878.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] } diff --git a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2412.19437_main.tex.md b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2412.19437_main.tex.md index 2e553d14f7..b95689f0ba 100644 --- a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2412.19437_main.tex.md +++ b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2412.19437_main.tex.md @@ -14,25 +14,19 @@ Benchmark performance of DeepSeek-V3 and its counterparts. ## Introduction -In recent years, Large Language Models - -(LLMs) have been undergoing rapid iteration and evolution[gpt4o,claude35sonnet,gemini1\_5], progressively diminishing the gap towards Artificial General Intelligence(AGI). +In recent years, Large Language Models(LLMs) have been undergoing rapid iteration and evolution[gpt4o,claude35sonnet,gemini1\_5], progressively diminishing the gap towards Artificial General Intelligence(AGI). Beyond closed-source models, open-source models, including DeepSeek series[dsvi,dsvii,dscodervi,dscodervii], LLaMA series[llama,llama2,llama3,llama3\_1\_405b], Qwen series[qwen,qwen1\_5,qwen2\_5], and Mistral series[mistral,mixtral8x22b], are also making significant strides, endeavoring to close the gap with their closed-source counterparts. To further push the boundaries of open-source model capabilities, we scale up our models and introduce DeepSeek-V3, a large Mixture-of-Experts(MoE) model with 671B parameters, of which 37B are activated for each token. With a forward-looking perspective, we consistently strive for strong model performance and economical costs. -Therefore, in terms of architecture, - -DeepSeek-V3 still adopts Multi-head Latent Attention(MLA)[dsvii] for efficient inference and DeepSeekMoE[deepseekmoe] for cost-effective training. +Therefore, in terms of architecture, DeepSeek-V3 still adopts Multi-head Latent Attention(MLA)[dsvii] for efficient inference and DeepSeekMoE[deepseekmoe] for cost-effective training. These two architectures have been validated in DeepSeek-V2[dsvii], demonstrating their capability to maintain robust model performance while achieving efficient training and inference. Beyond the basic architecture, we implement two additional strategies to further enhance the model capabilities. Firstly, DeepSeek-V3 pioneers an auxiliary-loss-free strategy[noaux\_tc] for load balancing, with the aim of minimizing the adverse impact on model performance that arises from the effort to encourage load balancing. Secondly, DeepSeek-V3employs a multi-token prediction training objective, which we have observed to enhance the overall performance on evaluation benchmarks. In order to achieve efficient training, we support the FP8 mixed precision training and implement comprehensive optimizations for the training framework. -Low-precision training has emerged as a promising solution for efficient training - -[bf16train, fp16train, fp8lm, llm.int8], its evolution being closely tied to advancements in hardware capabilities[fp8format, hifp8format, microscaling]. +Low-precision training has emerged as a promising solution for efficient training[bf16train, fp16train, fp8lm, llm.int8], its evolution being closely tied to advancements in hardware capabilities[fp8format, hifp8format, microscaling]. In this work, we introduce an FP8 mixed precision training framework and, for the first time, validate its effectiveness on an extremely large-scale model. Through the support for FP8 computation and storage, we achieve both accelerated training and reduced GPU memory usage. As for the training framework, we design the DualPipe algorithm for efficient pipeline parallelism, which has fewer pipeline bubbles and hides most of the communication during training through computation-communication overlap. @@ -41,18 +35,14 @@ In addition, we also develop efficient cross-node all-to-all communication kerne Furthermore, we meticulously optimize the memory footprint, making it possible to train DeepSeek-V3without using costly tensor parallelism. Combining these efforts, we achieve high training efficiency. -During pre-training, we train - -DeepSeek-V3 on 14.8T high-quality and diverse tokens. +During pre-training, we train DeepSeek-V3 on 14.8T high-quality and diverse tokens. The pre-training process is remarkably stable. Throughout the entire training process, we did not encounter any irrecoverable loss spikes or have to roll back. Next, we conduct a two-stage context length extension for DeepSeek-V3. In the first stage, the maximum context length is extended to 32K, and in the second stage, it is further extended to 128K. Following this, we conduct post-training, including Supervised Fine-Tuning(SFT) and Reinforcement Learning(RL) on the base model of DeepSeek-V3, to align it with human preferences and further unlock its potential. During the post-training stage, we distill the reasoning capability from the DeepSeek-R1 series of models, and meanwhile carefully maintain the balance between model accuracy and generation length. -We evaluate - -DeepSeek-V3 on a comprehensive array of benchmarks. +We evaluate DeepSeek-V3 on a comprehensive array of benchmarks. Despite its economical training costs, comprehensive evaluations reveal that DeepSeek-V3-Base has emerged as the strongest open-source base model currently available, especially in code and math. Its chat version also outperforms other open-source models and achieves performance comparable to leading closed-source models, including GPT-4o and Claude-3.5-Sonnet, on a series of standard and open-ended benchmarks. @@ -64,9 +54,7 @@ Its chat version also outperforms other open-source models and achieves performa Training costs of DeepSeek-V3, assuming the rental price of H800 is $2 per GPU hour. -Lastly, we emphasize again the economical training costs of - -DeepSeek-V3, summarized in Table[tab:cost], achieved through our optimized co-design of algorithms, frameworks, and hardware. +Lastly, we emphasize again the economical training costs of DeepSeek-V3, summarized in Table[tab:cost], achieved through our optimized co-design of algorithms, frameworks, and hardware. During the pre-training stage, training DeepSeek-V3 on each trillion tokens requires only 180K H800 GPU hours, i.e., 3.7 days on our cluster with 2048 H800 GPUs. Consequently, our pre-training stage is completed in less than two months and costs 2664K GPU hours. Combined with 119K GPU hours for the context length extension and 5K GPU hours for post-training, DeepSeek-V3 costs only 2.788M GPU hours for its full training. @@ -120,9 +108,7 @@ Lastly, we conclude this work, discuss existing limitations of DeepSeek-V3, and ## Architecture -We first introduce the basic architecture of - -DeepSeek-V3, featured by Multi-head Latent Attention(MLA)[dsvii] for efficient inference and DeepSeekMoE[deepseekmoe] for economical training. +We first introduce the basic architecture of DeepSeek-V3, featured by Multi-head Latent Attention(MLA)[dsvii] for efficient inference and DeepSeekMoE[deepseekmoe] for economical training. Then, we present a Multi-Token Prediction (MTP) training objective, which we have observed to enhance the overall performance on evaluation benchmarks. For other minor details not explicitly mentioned, DeepSeek-V3 adheres to the settings of DeepSeek-V2[dsvii]. @@ -135,18 +121,14 @@ Illustration of the basic architecture of DeepSeek-V3. ### Basic Architecture -The basic architecture of - -DeepSeek-V3 is still within the Transformer[transformer] framework. +The basic architecture of DeepSeek-V3 is still within the Transformer[transformer] framework. For efficient inference and economical training, DeepSeek-V3 also adopts MLA and DeepSeekMoE, which have been thoroughly validated by DeepSeek-V2. Compared with DeepSeek-V2, an exception is that we additionally introduce an auxiliary-loss-free load balancing strategy[noaux\_tc] for DeepSeekMoE to mitigate the performance degradation induced by the effort to ensure load balance. Figure[fig:basic\_arch] illustrates the basic architecture of DeepSeek-V3, and we will briefly review the details of MLA and DeepSeekMoE in this section. #### Multi-Head Latent Attention -For attention, - -DeepSeek-V3 adopts the MLA architecture. +For attention, DeepSeek-V3 adopts the MLA architecture. Let $d$ denote the embedding dimension, $n\_h$ denote the number of attention heads, $d\_h$ denote the dimension per head, and $\mathbf{h}\_{t} \in \mathbb{R}^{d}$ denote the attention input for the $t$-th token at a given attention layer. The core of MLA is the low-rank joint compression for attention keys and values to reduce Key-Value (KV) cache during inference: @@ -181,9 +163,7 @@ $d\_c^{\prime} (\ll d\_h n\_h)$ denotes the query compression dimension; $W^{DQ} \in \mathbb{R}^{d\_c^{\prime} \times d}, W^{UQ} \in \mathbb{R}^{d\_h n\_h \times d\_c^{\prime}}$ are the down-projection and up-projection matrices for queries, respectively; and $W^{QR} \in \mathbb{R}^{d\_h^R n\_h \times d\_c^{\prime}}$is the matrix to produce the decoupled queries that carry RoPE. -Ultimately, the attention queries ( - -$\mathbf{q}\_{t, i}$), keys ($\mathbf{k}\_{j, i}$), and values ($\mathbf{v}\_{j, i}^{C}$) are combined to yield the final attention output $\mathbf{u}\_{t}$: +Ultimately, the attention queries ($\mathbf{q}\_{t, i}$), keys ($\mathbf{k}\_{j, i}$), and values ($\mathbf{v}\_{j, i}^{C}$) are combined to yield the final attention output $\mathbf{u}\_{t}$: $$\begin{align} \mathbf{o}_{t, i} &= \sum_{j=1}^{t} \operatorname{Softmax}_j(\frac{\mathbf{q}_{t, i}^T \mathbf{k}_{j, i}}{\sqrt{d_{h} + d_{h}^{R}}}) \mathbf{v}_{j, i}^{C}, \\ @@ -273,9 +253,7 @@ Illustration of our Multi-Token Prediction (MTP) implementation. ### Multi-Token Prediction -Inspired by - -[meta\_mtp], we investigate and set a Multi-Token Prediction (MTP) objective for DeepSeek-V3, which extends the prediction scope to multiple future tokens at each position. +Inspired by [meta\_mtp], we investigate and set a Multi-Token Prediction (MTP) objective for DeepSeek-V3, which extends the prediction scope to multiple future tokens at each position. On the one hand, an MTP objective densifies the training signals and may improve data efficiency. On the other hand, MTP may enable the model to pre-plan its representations for better prediction of future tokens. Figure[fig:nextn] illustrates our implementation of MTP. @@ -328,14 +306,10 @@ Across different nodes, InfiniBand(IB) interconnects are utilized to facilitate ### Training Framework -The training of - -DeepSeek-V3 is supported by the HAI-LLM framework, an efficient and lightweight training framework crafted by our engineers from the ground up. +The training of DeepSeek-V3 is supported by the HAI-LLM framework, an efficient and lightweight training framework crafted by our engineers from the ground up. On the whole, DeepSeek-V3 applies 16-way Pipeline Parallelism (PP)[qi2023zero], 64-way Expert Parallelism (EP)[gshard] spanning 8 nodes, and ZeRO-1 Data Parallelism (DP)[zero]. -In order to facilitate efficient training of - -DeepSeek-V3, we implement meticulous engineering optimizations. +In order to facilitate efficient training of DeepSeek-V3, we implement meticulous engineering optimizations. Firstly, we design the DualPipe algorithm for efficient pipeline parallelism. Compared with existing PP methods, DualPipe has fewer pipeline bubbles. More importantly, it overlaps the computation and communication phases across forward and backward processes, thereby addressing the challenge of heavy communication overhead introduced by cross-node expert parallelism. @@ -352,15 +326,11 @@ Overlapping strategy for a pair of individual forward and backward chunks (the b Orange denotes forward, green denotes "backward for input", blue denotes "backward for weights", purple denotes PP communication, and red denotes barriers. Both all-to-all and PP communication can be fully hidden. -For - -DeepSeek-V3, the communication overhead introduced by cross-node expert parallelism results in an inefficient computation-to-communication ratio of approximately 1:1. +For DeepSeek-V3, the communication overhead introduced by cross-node expert parallelism results in an inefficient computation-to-communication ratio of approximately 1:1. To tackle this challenge, we design an innovative pipeline parallelism algorithm called DualPipe, which not only accelerates model training by effectively overlapping forward and backward computation-communication phases, but also reduces the pipeline bubbles. The key idea of DualPipe is to overlap the computation and communication within a pair of individual forward and backward chunks. -To be specific, we divide each chunk into four components: - -attention, all-to-all dispatch, MLP, and all-to-all combine. +To be specific, we divide each chunk into four components: attention, all-to-all dispatch, MLP, and all-to-all combine. Specially, for a backward chunk, both attention and MLP are further split into two parts, backward for input and backward for weights, like in ZeroBubble[zerobubble]. In addition, we have a PP communication component. As illustrated in Figure[fig:transformer-overlap], for a pair of forward and backward chunks, we rearrange these components and manually adjust the ratio of GPU SMs dedicated to communication versus computation. @@ -378,9 +348,7 @@ Example DualPipe scheduling for 8 PP ranks and 20 micro-batches in two direction Two cells enclosed by a shared black border have mutually overlapped computation and communication. In addition, even in more general scenarios without a heavy communication burden, DualPipe still exhibits efficiency advantages. -In Table - -[tab:dualpipe-bubble], we summarize the pipeline bubbles and memory usage across different PP methods. +In Table[tab:dualpipe-bubble], we summarize the pipeline bubbles and memory usage across different PP methods. As shown in the table, compared with ZB1P[zerobubble] and 1F1B[pipedream], DualPipe significantly reduces the pipeline bubbles while only increasing the peak activation memory by $\frac{1}{PP}$ times. Although DualPipe requires keeping two copies of the model parameters, this does not significantly increase the memory consumption since we use a large EP size during training. Compared with Chimera[chimera], DualPipe only requires that the pipeline stages and micro-batches be divisible by 2, without requiring micro-batches to be divisible by pipeline stages. @@ -405,14 +373,10 @@ To effectively leverage the different bandwidths of IB and NVLink, we limit each For each token, when its routing decision is made, it will first be transmitted via IB to the GPUs with the same in-node index on its target nodes. Once it reaches the target nodes, we will endeavor to ensure that it is instantaneously forwarded via NVLink to specific GPUs that host their target experts, without being blocked by subsequently arriving tokens. In this way, communications via IB and NVLink are fully overlapped, and each token can efficiently select an average of 3.2 experts per node without incurring additional overhead from NVLink. -This implies that, although - -DeepSeek-V3 selects only 8 routed experts in practice, it can scale up this number to a maximum of 13 experts (4 nodes $\times$3.2 experts/node) while preserving the same communication cost. +This implies that, although DeepSeek-V3 selects only 8 routed experts in practice, it can scale up this number to a maximum of 13 experts (4 nodes $\times$3.2 experts/node) while preserving the same communication cost. Overall, under such a communication strategy, only 20 SMs are sufficient to fully utilize the bandwidths of IB and NVLink. -In detail, we employ the warp specialization technique - -[warp-spec]and partition 20 SMs into 10 communication channels. +In detail, we employ the warp specialization technique[warp-spec]and partition 20 SMs into 10 communication channels. During the dispatching process, (1) IB sending, (2) IB-to-NVLink forwarding, and (3) NVLink receiving are handled by respective warps. The number of warps allocated to each communication task is dynamically adjusted according to the actual workload across all SMs. Similarly, during the combining process, (1) NVLink sending, (2) NVLink-to-IB forwarding and accumulation, and (3) IB receiving and accumulation are also handled by dynamically adjusted warps. @@ -444,9 +408,7 @@ Image: figures/fp8-frameworkv3.pdf The overall mixed precision framework with FP8 data format. For clarification, only the Linear operator is illustrated. -Inspired by recent advances in low-precision training - -[fp8lm, llm.int8, 8-bit-numerical], we propose a fine-grained mixed precision framework utilizing the FP8 data format for training DeepSeek-V3. +Inspired by recent advances in low-precision training[fp8lm, llm.int8, 8-bit-numerical], we propose a fine-grained mixed precision framework utilizing the FP8 data format for training DeepSeek-V3. While low-precision training holds great promise, it is often limited by the presence of outliers in activations, weights, and gradients[massiveoutlier, understandoutlier, scalefp8train]. Although significant progress has been made in inference quantization[xiao2023smoothquant, frantar2022gptq], there are relatively few studies demonstrating successful application of low-precision techniques in large-scale language model pre-training[scalefp8train]. To address this challenge and effectively extend the dynamic range of the FP8 format, we introduce a fine-grained quantization strategy: tile-wise grouping with $1\times N\_c$ elements or block-wise grouping with $N\_c\times N\_c$ elements. @@ -463,9 +425,7 @@ The overall framework is illustrated in Figure[fig:fp8\_framework]. Firstly, in order to accelerate model training, the majority of core computation kernels, i.e., GEMM operations, are implemented in FP8 precision. These GEMM operations accept FP8 tensors as inputs and produce outputs in BF16 or FP32. -As depicted in Figure - -[fig:fp8\_framework], all three GEMMs associated with the Linear operator, namely Fprop (forward pass), Dgrad (activation backward pass), and Wgrad (weight backward pass), are executed in FP8. +As depicted in Figure[fig:fp8\_framework], all three GEMMs associated with the Linear operator, namely Fprop (forward pass), Dgrad (activation backward pass), and Wgrad (weight backward pass), are executed in FP8. This design theoretically doubles the computational speed compared with the original BF16 method. Additionally, the FP8 WgradGEMM allows activations to be stored in FP8 for use in the backward pass. This significantly reduces memory consumption. @@ -473,9 +433,7 @@ This significantly reduces memory consumption. Despite the efficiency advantage of the FP8 format, certain operators still require a higher precision due to their sensitivity to low-precision computations. Besides, some low-cost operators can also utilize a higher precision with a negligible overhead to the overall training cost. For this reason, after careful investigations, we maintain the original precision (e.g., BF16 or FP32) for the following components: the embedding module, the output head, MoE gating modules, normalization operators, and attention operators. -These targeted retentions of high precision ensure stable training dynamics for - -DeepSeek-V3. +These targeted retentions of high precision ensure stable training dynamics for DeepSeek-V3. To further guarantee numerical stability, we store the master weights, weight gradients, and optimizer states in higher precision. While these high-precision components incur some memory overheads, their impact can be minimized through efficient sharding across multiple DP ranks in our distributed training system. @@ -503,9 +461,7 @@ One key modification in our method is the introduction of per-group scaling fact This functionality is not directly supported in the standard FP8 GEMM. However, combined with our precise FP32 accumulation strategy, it can be efficiently implemented. -Notably, our fine-grained quantization strategy is highly consistent with the idea of microscaling formats - -[rouhani2023microscaling], while the Tensor Cores of NVIDIA next-generation GPUs (Blackwell series) have announced the support for microscaling formats with smaller quantization granularity[nvidia\_tensor\_cores]. +Notably, our fine-grained quantization strategy is highly consistent with the idea of microscaling formats[rouhani2023microscaling], while the Tensor Cores of NVIDIA next-generation GPUs (Blackwell series) have announced the support for microscaling formats with smaller quantization granularity[nvidia\_tensor\_cores]. We hope our design can serve as a reference for future work to keep pace with the latest GPU architectures. Increasing Accumulation Precision. @@ -515,9 +471,7 @@ This problem will become more pronounced when the inner dimension K is large[swi Taking GEMM operations of two random matrices with K = 4096 for example, in our preliminary test, the limited accumulation precision in Tensor Cores results in a maximum relative error of nearly 2%. Despite these problems, the limited accumulation precision is still the default option in a few FP8 frameworks[transformerengine], severely constraining the training accuracy. -In order to address this issue, we adopt the strategy of promotion to CUDA Cores for higher precision - -[Thakkar\_CUTLASS\_2023]. +In order to address this issue, we adopt the strategy of promotion to CUDA Cores for higher precision[Thakkar\_CUTLASS\_2023]. The process is illustrated in Figure[fig:fp8\_quantization] (b). To be specific, during MMA (Matrix Multiply-Accumulate) execution on Tensor Cores, intermediate results are accumulated using the limited bit width. Once an interval of $N\_C$ is reached, these partial results will be copied to FP32 registers on CUDA Cores, where full-precision FP32 accumulation is performed. @@ -525,9 +479,7 @@ As mentioned before, our fine-grained quantization applies per-group scaling fac These scaling factors can be efficiently multiplied on the CUDA Cores as the dequantization process with minimal additional computational cost. It is worth noting that this modification reduces the WGMMA (Warpgroup-level Matrix Multiply-Accumulate) instruction issue rate for a single warpgroup. However, on the H800 architecture, it is typical for two WGMMA to persist concurrently: while one warpgroup performs the promotion operation, the other is able to execute the MMA operation. This design enables overlapping of the two operations, maintaining high utilization of Tensor Cores. -Based on our experiments, setting - -$N\_C=128$elements, equivalent to 4 WGMMAs, represents the minimal accumulation interval that can significantly improve precision without introducing substantial overhead. +Based on our experiments, setting $N\_C=128$elements, equivalent to 4 WGMMAs, represents the minimal accumulation interval that can significantly improve precision without introducing substantial overhead. Mantissa over Exponents. In contrast to the hybrid FP8 format adopted by prior work [transformerengine, fp8lm, hfp8], which uses E4M3 (4-bit exponent and 3-bit mantissa) in Fprop and E5M2 (5-bit exponent and 2-bit mantissa) in Dgrad and Wgrad, we adopt the E4M3format on all tensors for higher precision. @@ -564,38 +516,28 @@ For both the forward and backward combine components, we retain them in BF16 to ### Inference and Deployment -We deploy - -DeepSeek-V3 on the H800 cluster, where GPUs within each node are interconnected using NVLink, and all GPUs across the cluster are fully interconnected via IB. +We deploy DeepSeek-V3 on the H800 cluster, where GPUs within each node are interconnected using NVLink, and all GPUs across the cluster are fully interconnected via IB. To simultaneously ensure both the Service-Level Objective (SLO) for online services and high throughput, we employ the following deployment strategy that separates the prefilling and decodingstages. #### Prefilling The minimum deployment unit of the prefilling stage consists of 4 nodes with 32 GPUs. -The - -attention part employs 4-way Tensor Parallelism (TP4) with Sequence Parallelism (SP), combined with 8-way Data Parallelism (DP8). +The attention part employs 4-way Tensor Parallelism (TP4) with Sequence Parallelism (SP), combined with 8-way Data Parallelism (DP8). Its small TP size of 4 limits the overhead of TP communication. For the MoE part, we use 32-way Expert Parallelism (EP32), which ensures that each expert processes a sufficiently large batch size, thereby enhancing computational efficiency. For the MoEall-to-all communication, we use the same method as in training: first transferring tokens across nodes via IB, and then forwarding among the intra-node GPUs via NVLink. In particular, we use 1-way Tensor Parallelism for the dense MLPs in shallow layers to save TP communication. -To achieve load balancing among different experts in the - -MoE part, we need to ensure that each GPU processes approximately the same number of tokens. +To achieve load balancing among different experts in the MoE part, we need to ensure that each GPU processes approximately the same number of tokens. To this end, we introduce a deployment strategy of redundant experts, which duplicates high-load experts and deploys them redundantly. The high-load experts are detected based on statistics collected during the online deployment and are adjusted periodically (e.g., every 10 minutes). After determining the set of redundant experts, we carefully rearrange experts among GPUs within a node based on the observed loads, striving to balance the load across GPUs as much as possible without increasing the cross-node all-to-all communication overhead. For the deployment of DeepSeek-V3, we set 32 redundant experts for the prefilling stage. For each GPU, besides the original 8 experts it hosts, it will also host one additional redundant expert. -Furthermore, in the prefilling stage, to improve the throughput and hide the overhead of all-to-all and TP communication, we simultaneously process two micro-batches with similar computational workloads, overlapping the +Furthermore, in the prefilling stage, to improve the throughput and hide the overhead of all-to-all and TP communication, we simultaneously process two micro-batches with similar computational workloads, overlapping the attention and MoE of one micro-batch with the dispatch and combineof another. -attention and MoE of one micro-batch with the dispatch and combineof another. - -Finally, we are exploring a - -dynamic redundancystrategy for experts, where each GPU hosts more experts (e.g., 16 experts), but only 9 will be activated during each inference step. +Finally, we are exploring a dynamic redundancystrategy for experts, where each GPU hosts more experts (e.g., 16 experts), but only 9 will be activated during each inference step. Before the all-to-all operation at each layer begins, we compute the globally optimal routing scheme on the fly. Given the substantial computation involved in the prefilling stage, the overhead of computing this routing scheme is almost negligible. @@ -604,24 +546,18 @@ Given the substantial computation involved in the prefilling stage, the overhead During decoding, we treat the shared expert as a routed one. From this perspective, each token will select 9 experts during routing, where the shared expert is regarded as a heavy-load one that will always be selected. The minimum deployment unit of the decoding stage consists of 40 nodes with 320 GPUs. -The - -attention part employs TP4 with SP, combined with DP80, while the MoE part uses EP320. +The attention part employs TP4 with SP, combined with DP80, while the MoE part uses EP320. For the MoE part, each GPU hosts only one expert, and 64 GPUs are responsible for hosting redundant experts and shared experts. All-to-all communication of the dispatch and combine parts is performed via direct point-to-point transfers over IB to achieve low latency. Additionally, we leverage the IBGDA[nvidia\_ibgda]technology to further minimize latency and enhance communication efficiency. Similar to prefilling, we periodically determine the set of redundant experts in a certain interval, based on the statistical expert load from our online service. However, we do not need to rearrange experts since each GPU only hosts one expert. -We are also exploring the - -dynamic redundancy strategy for decoding. +We are also exploring the dynamic redundancy strategy for decoding. However, this requires more careful optimization of the algorithm that computes the globally optimal routing scheme and the fusion with the dispatchkernel to reduce overhead. Additionally, to enhance throughput and hide the overhead of all-to-all communication, we are also exploring processing two micro-batches with similar computational workloads simultaneously in the decoding stage. -Unlike prefilling, - -attention consumes a larger portion of time in the decoding stage. Therefore, we overlap the attention of one micro-batch with the dispatch+MoE+combine of another. +Unlike prefilling, attention consumes a larger portion of time in the decoding stage. Therefore, we overlap the attention of one micro-batch with the dispatch+MoE+combine of another. In the decoding stage, the batch size per expert is relatively small (usually within 256 tokens), and the bottleneck is memory access rather than computation. Since the MoE part only needs to load the parameters of one expert, the memory access overhead is minimal, so using fewer SMs will not significantly affect the overall performance. Therefore, to avoid impacting the computation speed of the attention part, we can allocate only a small portion of SMs to dispatch+MoE+combine. @@ -632,9 +568,7 @@ Based on our implementation of the all-to-all communication and FP8 training sch #### Communication Hardware -In - -DeepSeek-V3, we implement the overlap between computation and communication to hide the communication latency during computation. +In DeepSeek-V3, we implement the overlap between computation and communication to hide the communication latency during computation. This significantly reduces the dependency on communication bandwidth compared to serial computation and communication. However, the current communication implementation relies on expensive SMs (e.g., we allocate 20 out of the 132 SMs available in the H800 GPU for this purpose), which will limit the computational throughput. Moreover, using SMs for communication results in significant inefficiencies, as tensor cores remain entirely under-utilized. @@ -646,9 +580,7 @@ Currently, the SMs primarily perform the following tasks for all-to-all communic - Executing reduce operations for all-to-all combine. - Managing fine-grained memory layout during chunked data transferring to multiple experts across the IB and NVLink domain. -We aspire to see future vendors developing hardware that offloads these communication tasks from the valuable computation unit SM, serving as a GPU co-processor or a network co-processor like NVIDIA SHARP - -[nvsharp]. +We aspire to see future vendors developing hardware that offloads these communication tasks from the valuable computation unit SM, serving as a GPU co-processor or a network co-processor like NVIDIA SHARP[nvsharp]. Furthermore, to reduce application programming complexity, we aim for this hardware to unify the IB (scale-out) and NVLink (scale-up) networks from the perspective of the computation units. With this unified interface, computation units can easily accomplish operations such as read, write, multicast, and reduceacross the entire IB-NVLink-unified domain via submitting communication requests based on simple primitives. @@ -684,16 +616,12 @@ To reduce memory operations, we recommend future chips to enable direct transpos ### Data Construction -Compared with - -DeepSeek-V2, we optimize the pre-training corpus by enhancing the ratio of mathematical and programming samples, while expanding multilingual coverage beyond English and Chinese. +Compared with DeepSeek-V2, we optimize the pre-training corpus by enhancing the ratio of mathematical and programming samples, while expanding multilingual coverage beyond English and Chinese. Also, our data processing pipeline is refined to minimize redundancy while maintaining corpus diversity. Inspired by [Ding2024FewerTI], we implement the document packing method for data integrity but do not incorporate cross-sample attention masking during training. Finally, the training corpus for DeepSeek-V3consists of 14.8T high-quality and diverse tokens in our tokenizer. -In the training process of DeepSeekCoder-V2 - -[dscodervii], we observe that the Fill-in-Middle(FIM) strategy does not compromise the next-token prediction capability while enabling the model to accurately predict middle text based on contextual cues. +In the training process of DeepSeekCoder-V2[dscodervii], we observe that the Fill-in-Middle(FIM) strategy does not compromise the next-token prediction capability while enabling the model to accurately predict middle text based on contextual cues. In alignment with DeepSeekCoder-V2, we also incorporate the FIM strategy in the pre-training of DeepSeek-V3. To be specific, we employ the Prefix-Suffix-Middle (PSM) framework to structure data as follows: @@ -704,9 +632,7 @@ $$\begin{align} This structure is applied at the document level as a part of the pre-packing process. The FIM strategy is applied at a rate of 0.1, consistent with the PSM framework. -The tokenizer for - -DeepSeek-V3 employs Byte-level BPE[shibata1999byte] with an extended vocabulary of 128K tokens. +The tokenizer for DeepSeek-V3 employs Byte-level BPE[shibata1999byte] with an extended vocabulary of 128K tokens. The pretokenizer and training data for our tokenizer are modified to optimize multilingual compression efficiency. In addition, compared with DeepSeek-V2, the new pretokenizer introduces tokens that combine punctuations and line breaks. However, this trick may introduce the token boundary bias[tokenboundary]when the model processes multi-line prompts without terminal line breaks, particularly for few-shot evaluation prompts. @@ -751,9 +677,7 @@ DeepSeek-V3 performs well across all context window lengths up to 128K. ### Long Context Extension -We adopt a similar approach to - -DeepSeek-V2[dsvii] to enable long context capabilities in DeepSeek-V3. +We adopt a similar approach to DeepSeek-V2[dsvii] to enable long context capabilities in DeepSeek-V3. After the pre-training stage, we apply YaRN[peng2023yarn] for context extension and perform two additional training phases, each comprising 1000 steps, to progressively expand the context window from 4K to 32K and then to 128K. The YaRN configuration is consistent with that used in DeepSeek-V2, being applied exclusively to the decoupled shared key $\mathbf{k}^R\_t$. The hyper-parameters remain identical across both phases, with the scale $s = 40$, $\alpha = 1$, $\beta = 32$, and the scaling factor $\sqrt{t} = 0.1 \ln{s} + 1$. @@ -761,18 +685,14 @@ In the first phase, the sequence length is set to 32K, and the batch size is 192 During the second phase, the sequence length is increased to 128K, and the batch size is reduced to 480. The learning rate for both phases is set to $7.3 \times 10^{-6}$, matching the final learning rate from the pre-training stage. -Through this two-phase extension training, - -DeepSeek-V3 is capable of handling inputs up to 128K in length while maintaining strong performance. +Through this two-phase extension training, DeepSeek-V3 is capable of handling inputs up to 128K in length while maintaining strong performance. Figure[fig:long\_context] illustrates that DeepSeek-V3, following supervised fine-tuning, achieves notable performance on the "Needle In A Haystack" (NIAH) test, demonstrating consistent robustness across context window lengths up to 128K. ### Evaluations #### Evaluation Benchmarks -The base model of - -DeepSeek-V3 is pretrained on a multilingual corpus with English and Chinese constituting the majority, so we evaluate its performance on a series of benchmarks primarily in English and Chinese, as well as on a multilingual benchmark. +The base model of DeepSeek-V3 is pretrained on a multilingual corpus with English and Chinese constituting the majority, so we evaluate its performance on a series of benchmarks primarily in English and Chinese, as well as on a multilingual benchmark. Our evaluation is based on our internal evaluation framework integrated in our HAI-LLM framework. Considered benchmarks are categorized and listed as follows, where underlined benchmarks are in Chinese and double-underlinedbenchmarks are multilingual ones: @@ -847,16 +767,12 @@ Comparison among DeepSeek-V3-Base and other representative open-source base mode #### Evaluation Results -In Table - -[tab:main], we compare the base model of DeepSeek-V3 with the state-of-the-art open-source base models, including DeepSeek-V2-Base[dsvii] (our previous release), Qwen2.5 72B Base[qwen2\_5], and LLaMA-3.1 405B Base[llama3\_1\_405b]. +In Table[tab:main], we compare the base model of DeepSeek-V3 with the state-of-the-art open-source base models, including DeepSeek-V2-Base[dsvii] (our previous release), Qwen2.5 72B Base[qwen2\_5], and LLaMA-3.1 405B Base[llama3\_1\_405b]. We evaluate all these models with our internal evaluation framework, and ensure that they share the same evaluation setting. Note that due to the changes in our evaluation framework over the past months, the performance of DeepSeek-V2-Base exhibits a slight difference from our previously reported results. Overall, DeepSeek-V3-Base comprehensively outperforms DeepSeek-V2-Base and Qwen2.5 72B Base, and surpasses LLaMA-3.1 405B Base in the majority of benchmarks, essentially becoming the strongest open-source model. -From a more detailed perspective, we compare - -DeepSeek-V3-Base with the other open-source base models individually. +From a more detailed perspective, we compare DeepSeek-V3-Base with the other open-source base models individually. (1) Compared with DeepSeek-V2-Base, due to the improvements in our model architecture, the scale-up of the model size and training tokens, and the enhancement of data quality, DeepSeek-V3-Base achieves significantly better performance as expected. (2) @@ -866,9 +782,7 @@ As for Chinese benchmarks, except for CMMLU, a Chinese multi-subject multiple-ch Compared with LLaMA-3.1 405B Base, the largest open-source model with 11 times the activated parameters, DeepSeek-V3-Base also exhibits much better performance on multilingual, code, and math benchmarks. As for English and Chinese language benchmarks, DeepSeek-V3-Base shows competitive or better performance, and is especially good on BBH, MMLU-series, DROP, C-Eval, CMMLU, and CCPM. -Due to our efficient architectures and comprehensive engineering optimizations, - -DeepSeek-V3 achieves extremely high training efficiency. +Due to our efficient architectures and comprehensive engineering optimizations, DeepSeek-V3 achieves extremely high training efficiency. Under our training framework and infrastructures, training DeepSeek-V3on each trillion tokens requires only 180K H800 GPU hours, which is much cheaper than training 72B or 405B dense models. | 2*Benchmark (Metric) | 2*# Shots | Small MoE | Small MoE | Large MoE | Large MoE | @@ -896,9 +810,7 @@ Ablation results for the MTP strategy. #### Ablation Studies for Multi-Token Prediction -In Table - -[tab:ablation\_nextn], we show the ablation results for the MTP strategy. +In Table[tab:ablation\_nextn], we show the ablation results for the MTP strategy. To be specific, we validate the MTP strategy on top of two baseline models across different scales. At the small scale, we train a baseline MoE model comprising 15.7B total parameters on 1.33T tokens. At the large scale, we train a baseline MoE model comprising 228.7B total parameters on 540B tokens. @@ -908,9 +820,7 @@ From the table, we can observe that the MTP strategy consistently enhances the m #### Ablation Studies for the Auxiliary-Loss-Free Balancing Strategy -In Table - -[tab:ablation\_noaux\_tc], we show the ablation results for the auxiliary-loss-free balancing strategy. +In Table[tab:ablation\_noaux\_tc], we show the ablation results for the auxiliary-loss-free balancing strategy. We validate this strategy on top of two baseline models across different scales. At the small scale, we train a baseline MoE model comprising 15.7B total parameters on 1.33T tokens. At the large scale, we train a baseline MoE model comprising 228.7B total parameters on 578B tokens. @@ -946,9 +856,7 @@ The key distinction between auxiliary-loss-free balancing and sequence-wise auxi Compared with the sequence-wise auxiliary loss, batch-wise balancing imposes a more flexible constraint, as it does not enforce in-domain balance on each sequence. This flexibility allows experts to better specialize in different domains. To validate this, we record and analyze the expert load of a 16B auxiliary-loss-based baseline and a 16B auxiliary-loss-free model on different domains in the Pile test set. -As illustrated in Figure - -[fig:expert\_load], we observe that the auxiliary-loss-free model demonstrates greater expert specialization patterns as expected. +As illustrated in Figure[fig:expert\_load], we observe that the auxiliary-loss-free model demonstrates greater expert specialization patterns as expected. To further investigate the correlation between this flexibility and the advantage in model performance, we additionally design and validate a batch-wise auxiliary loss that encourages load balance on each training batch instead of on each sequence. The experimental results show that, when achieving a similar level of batch-wise load balance, the batch-wise auxiliary loss can also achieve similar model performance to the auxiliary-loss-free method. @@ -959,9 +867,7 @@ In addition, although the batch-wise load balancing methods show consistent perf (1) load imbalance within certain sequences or small batches, and (2) domain-shift-induced load imbalance during inference. The first challenge is naturally addressed by our training framework that uses large-scale expert parallelism and data parallelism, which guarantees a large size of each micro-batch. -For the second challenge, we also design and implement an efficient inference framework with redundant expert deployment, as described in Section - -[sec:inference\_deployment], to overcome it. +For the second challenge, we also design and implement an efficient inference framework with redundant expert deployment, as described in Section [sec:inference\_deployment], to overcome it. Image: figures/relative\_expert\_load\_multi.pdf @@ -1020,9 +926,7 @@ This approach helps mitigate the risk of reward hacking in specific tasks. #### Group Relative Policy Optimization -Similar to - -DeepSeek-V2[dsvii], we adopt Group Relative Policy Optimization(GRPO)[deepseekmath], which foregoes the critic model that is typically with the same size as the policy model, and estimates the baseline from group scores instead. +Similar to DeepSeek-V2[dsvii], we adopt Group Relative Policy Optimization(GRPO)[deepseekmath], which foregoes the critic model that is typically with the same size as the policy model, and estimates the baseline from group scores instead. Specifically, for each question $q$, GRPO samples a group of outputs $\{o\_1, o\_2, \cdots, o\_G\}$ from the old policy model $\pi\_{\theta\_{old}}$ and then optimizes the policy model $\pi\_{\theta}$ by maximizing the following objective: $$\begin{split} @@ -1118,9 +1022,7 @@ Comparison between DeepSeek-V3 and other representative chat models. #### Standard Evaluation -Table - -[tab:chat] presents the evaluation results, showcasing that DeepSeek-V3stands as the best-performing open-source model. +Table[tab:chat] presents the evaluation results, showcasing that DeepSeek-V3stands as the best-performing open-source model. Additionally, it is competitive against frontier closed-source models like GPT-4o and Claude-3.5-Sonnet. English Benchmarks. @@ -1130,9 +1032,7 @@ Moreover, DeepSeek-V3 excels in MMLU-Pro, a more challenging educational knowled On MMLU-Redux, a refined version of MMLU with corrected labels, DeepSeek-V3 surpasses its peers. In addition, on GPQA-Diamond, a PhD-level evaluation testbed, DeepSeek-V3achieves remarkable results, ranking just behind Claude 3.5 Sonnet and outperforming all other competitors by a substantial margin. -In long-context understanding benchmarks such as DROP, LongBench v2, and FRAMES, - -DeepSeek-V3 continues to demonstrate its position as a top-tier model. +In long-context understanding benchmarks such as DROP, LongBench v2, and FRAMES, DeepSeek-V3 continues to demonstrate its position as a top-tier model. It achieves an impressive 91.6 F1 score in the 3-shot setting on DROP, outperforming all other models in this category. On FRAMES, a benchmark requiring question-answering over 100k token contexts, DeepSeek-V3 closely trails GPT-4o while outperforming all other models by a significant margin. This demonstrates the strong capability of DeepSeek-V3 in handling extremely long-context tasks. @@ -1149,9 +1049,7 @@ By providing access to its robust capabilities, DeepSeek-V3 can drive innovation In algorithmic tasks, DeepSeek-V3demonstrates superior performance, outperforming all baselines on benchmarks like HumanEval-Mul and LiveCodeBench. This success can be attributed to its advanced knowledge distillation technique, which effectively enhances its code generation and problem-solving capabilities in algorithm-focused tasks. -On math benchmarks, - -DeepSeek-V3 demonstrates exceptional performance, significantly surpassing baselines and setting a new state-of-the-art for non-o1-like models. +On math benchmarks, DeepSeek-V3 demonstrates exceptional performance, significantly surpassing baselines and setting a new state-of-the-art for non-o1-like models. Specifically, on AIME, MATH-500, and CNMO 2024, DeepSeek-V3 outperforms the second-best model, Qwen2.5 72B, by approximately 10%in absolute scores, which is a substantial margin for such challenging benchmarks. This remarkable capability highlights the effectiveness of the distillation technique from DeepSeek-R1, which has been proven highly beneficial for non-o1-like models. @@ -1159,9 +1057,7 @@ Chinese Benchmarks. Qwen and DeepSeek are two representative model series with robust support for both Chinese and English. On the factual benchmark Chinese SimpleQA, DeepSeek-V3 surpasses Qwen2.5-72B by 16.4 points, despite Qwen2.5 being trained on a larger corpus compromising 18T tokens, which are 20% more than the 14.8T tokens that DeepSeek-V3is pre-trained on. -On C-Eval, a representative benchmark for Chinese educational knowledge evaluation, and CLUEWSC (Chinese Winograd Schema Challenge), - -DeepSeek-V3and Qwen2.5-72B exhibit similar performance levels, indicating that both models are well-optimized for challenging Chinese-language reasoning and educational tasks. +On C-Eval, a representative benchmark for Chinese educational knowledge evaluation, and CLUEWSC (Chinese Winograd Schema Challenge), DeepSeek-V3and Qwen2.5-72B exhibit similar performance levels, indicating that both models are well-optimized for challenging Chinese-language reasoning and educational tasks. | Model | Arena-Hard | AlpacaEval 2.0 | |------------------------|--------------|------------------| @@ -1178,26 +1074,20 @@ English open-ended conversation evaluations. #### Open-Ended Evaluation -In addition to standard benchmarks, we also evaluate our models on open-ended generation tasks using LLMs as judges, with the results shown in Table - -[tab:open]. +In addition to standard benchmarks, we also evaluate our models on open-ended generation tasks using LLMs as judges, with the results shown in Table[tab:open]. Specifically, we adhere to the original configurations of AlpacaEval 2.0[alpaca2.0] and Arena-Hard[li2024crowdsourced], which leverage GPT-4-Turbo-1106 as judges for pairwise comparisons. On Arena-Hard, DeepSeek-V3 achieves an impressive win rate of over 86% against the baseline GPT-4-0314, performing on par with top-tier models like Claude-Sonnet-3.5-1022. This underscores the robust capabilities of DeepSeek-V3, especially in dealing with complex prompts, including coding and debugging tasks. Furthermore, DeepSeek-V3 achieves a groundbreaking milestone as the first open-source model to surpass 85%on the Arena-Hard benchmark. This achievement significantly bridges the performance gap between open-source and closed-source models, setting a new standard for what open-source models can accomplish in challenging domains. -Similarly, - -DeepSeek-V3 showcases exceptional performance on AlpacaEval 2.0, outperforming both closed-source and open-source models. +Similarly, DeepSeek-V3 showcases exceptional performance on AlpacaEval 2.0, outperforming both closed-source and open-source models. This demonstrates its outstanding proficiency in writing tasks and handling straightforward question-answering scenarios. Notably, it surpasses DeepSeek-V2.5-0905 by a significant margin of 20%, highlighting substantial improvements in tackling simple tasks and showcasing the effectiveness of its advancements. #### DeepSeek-V3 as a Generative Reward Model -We compare the judgment ability of - -DeepSeek-V3 with state-of-the-art models, namely GPT-4o and Claude-3.5. +We compare the judgment ability of DeepSeek-V3 with state-of-the-art models, namely GPT-4o and Claude-3.5. Table[tab:rewardbench] presents the performance of these models in RewardBench [lambert2024rewardbench]. DeepSeek-V3 achieves performance on par with the best versions of GPT-4o-0806 and Claude-3.5-Sonnet-1022, while surpassing other versions. Additionally, the judgment ability of DeepSeek-V3 can also be enhanced by the voting technique. @@ -1223,9 +1113,7 @@ Performances of GPT-4o, Claude-3.5-sonnet and DeepSeek-V3 on RewardBench. We ablate the contribution of distillation from DeepSeek-R1 based on DeepSeek-V2.5. The baseline is trained on short CoT data, whereas its competitor uses data generated by the expert checkpoints described above. -Table - -[tab:distill] demonstrates the effectiveness of the distillation data, showing significant improvements in both LiveCodeBench and MATH-500 benchmarks. +Table[tab:distill] demonstrates the effectiveness of the distillation data, showing significant improvements in both LiveCodeBench and MATH-500 benchmarks. Our experiments reveal an interesting trade-off: the distillation leads to better performance but also substantially increases the average response length. To maintain a balance between model accuracy and computational efficiency, we carefully selected optimal settings for DeepSeek-V3in distillation. @@ -1249,9 +1137,7 @@ The contribution of distillation from DeepSeek-R1. Rewards play a pivotal role in RL, steering the optimization process. In domains where verification through external tools is straightforward, such as some coding or mathematics scenarios, RL demonstrates exceptional efficacy. However, in more general scenarios, constructing a feedback mechanism through hard coding is impractical. -During the development of - -DeepSeek-V3, for these broader contexts, we employ the constitutional AI approach[bai2022constitutional], leveraging the voting evaluation results of DeepSeek-V3 itself as a feedback source. +During the development of DeepSeek-V3, for these broader contexts, we employ the constitutional AI approach[bai2022constitutional], leveraging the voting evaluation results of DeepSeek-V3 itself as a feedback source. This method has produced notable alignment effects, significantly enhancing the performance of DeepSeek-V3 in subjective evaluations. By integrating additional constitutional inputs, DeepSeek-V3can optimize towards the constitutional direction. We believe that this paradigm, which combines supplementary information with LLMs as a feedback source, is of paramount importance. @@ -1260,9 +1146,7 @@ Beyond self-rewarding, we are also dedicated to uncovering other general and sca #### Multi-Token Prediction Evaluation -Instead of predicting just the next single token, - -DeepSeek-V3 predicts the next 2 tokens through the MTP technique. +Instead of predicting just the next single token, DeepSeek-V3 predicts the next 2 tokens through the MTP technique. Combined with the framework of speculative decoding[speculative\_google,speculative\_xhm], it can significantly accelerate the decoding speed of the model. A natural question arises concerning the acceptance rate of the additionally predicted token. Based on our evaluation, the acceptance rate of the second token prediction ranges between 85% and 90% across various generation topics, demonstrating consistent reliability. @@ -1270,9 +1154,7 @@ This high acceptance rate enables DeepSeek-V3to achieve a significantly improved ## Conclusion, Limitations, and Future Directions -In this paper, we introduce - -DeepSeek-V3, a large MoE language model with 671B total parameters and 37B activated parameters, trained on 14.8T tokens. +In this paper, we introduce DeepSeek-V3, a large MoE language model with 671B total parameters and 37B activated parameters, trained on 14.8T tokens. In addition to the MLA and DeepSeekMoE architectures, it also pioneers an auxiliary-loss-free strategy for load balancing and sets a multi-token prediction training objective for stronger performance. The training of DeepSeek-V3is cost-effective due to the support of FP8 training and meticulous engineering optimizations. The post-training also makes a success in distilling the reasoning capability from the DeepSeek-R1 series of models. @@ -1280,9 +1162,7 @@ Comprehensive evaluations demonstrate that DeepSeek-V3 has emerged as the strong Despite its strong performance, it also maintains economical training costs. It requires only 2.788M H800 GPU hours for its full training, including pre-training, context length extension, and post-training. -While acknowledging its strong performance and cost-effectiveness, we also recognize that - -DeepSeek-V3 has some limitations, especially on the deployment. +While acknowledging its strong performance and cost-effectiveness, we also recognize that DeepSeek-V3 has some limitations, especially on the deployment. Firstly, to ensure efficient inference, the recommended deployment unit for DeepSeek-V3 is relatively large, which might pose a burden for small-sized teams. Secondly, although our deployment strategy for DeepSeek-V3 has achieved an end-to-end generation speed of more than two times that of DeepSeek-V2, there still remains potential for further enhancement. Fortunately, these limitations are expected to be naturally addressed with the development of more advanced hardware. diff --git a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2501.00089_main.tex.itxt b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2501.00089_main.tex.itxt index 60cf7a7350..8359e78461 100644 --- a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2501.00089_main.tex.itxt +++ b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2501.00089_main.tex.itxt @@ -8,156 +8,113 @@ S ... 3400 N Charles St, Baltimore, MD 21218 item-6 at level 1: text: Galaxy appearances reveal the ph ... rs interpret machine learning results. item-7 at level 1: text: Galaxies (573), Astronomy image ... , Convolutional neural networks (1938) item-8 at level 1: section_header: Introduction - item-9 at level 1: paragraph: Galaxies have spectacularly info ... e simple morphological classifications - item-10 at level 1: text: [1926ApJ....64..321H,1959HDP.... ... lution with their detailedappearances. - item-11 at level 1: paragraph: Deep neural networks that exploi ... nstrain their physical characteristics - item-12 at level 1: text: [2019ApJ...887..251W,2020ApJ...9 ... imagingbut what about us astronomers? - item-13 at level 1: paragraph: Two major challenges arise when ... ng in uninterpretable mess of features - item-14 at level 1: text: [superposition]. Second, each ne ... ind the patterns that ML models learn. - item-15 at level 1: paragraph: Fortunately, there exists a stra ... s from a larger set of basis functions - item-16 at level 1: text: [Olshausen1996,NIPS2006_2d71b2ae ... ics of how deep neural networks learn. - item-17 at level 1: paragraph: We introduce a novel, interpreta ... from a high-dimensional pixel space ( - item-18 at level 1: text: $n \sim 10^5$ pixels) into a low ... ro extra computational cost or memory. - item-19 at level 1: paragraph: We train the SFNet to predict ga ... o the methodology described in Section - item-20 at level 1: text: [sec:methodology]. In Section[se ... r conclusions in Section[sec:summary]. - item-21 at level 1: section: group figure - item-22 at level 2: picture - item-22 at level 3: caption: Image: SFNet_ResNet18-TopK.pdf - item-23 at level 2: text: Our SFNet architecture, which re ... together (i.e. a residual connection). - item-24 at level 1: caption: Image: SFNet_ResNet18-TopK.pdf - item-25 at level 1: section_header: Methodology - item-26 at level 1: paragraph: We select galaxies from the SDSS Main Galaxy Sample - item-27 at level 1: text: [2002AJ....124.1810S,sdssdr7] th ... e comprises 250,207 galaxies in total. - item-28 at level 1: paragraph: Our SFNet implementation is shown in Figure - item-29 at level 1: text: [fig:SFNet-architecture]. We use ... features are localized in pixel space. - item-30 at level 1: paragraph: The resnet18 backbone of the mod ... ialized to ImageNet-pretrained weights - item-31 at level 1: text: [5206848], and we update model p ... om/jwuphysics/sparse-feature-networks. - item-32 at level 1: section_header: Results - item-33 at level 1: paragraph: Motivated by previous works that ... imaging with their physical properties - item-34 at level 1: text: [2019MNRAS.484.4683W,2020arXiv20 ... }$ and $A_{\tt Z\,256}$, respectively. - item-35 at level 1: section_header: Emission line fluxes - item-36 at level 1: paragraph: We train a SFNet to predict the spectral line fluxes for [ - item-37 at level 1: text: N2], H$\alpha$, [O3], and H$\bet ... physical state, and dust attenuation. - item-38 at level 1: paragraph: The eight most frequently activated features explain 99.99 - item-39 at level 1: text: % of the variance in the dataset ... eatures SL17, SL138, SL157, and SL322. - item-40 at level 1: paragraph: In Figure - item-41 at level 1: text: [fig:bpt-interpretation], we sho ... al interpretations for these features. - item-42 at level 1: section: group figure - item-43 at level 2: picture - item-43 at level 3: caption: Image: 17-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf - item-44 at level 2: picture - item-44 at level 3: caption: Image: 138-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf - item-45 at level 2: picture - item-45 at level 3: caption: Image: 157-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf - item-46 at level 2: picture - item-46 at level 3: caption: Image: 322-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf - item-47 at level 2: text: SFNet learned features when trai ... magenta (low) to bright yellow (high). - item-48 at level 1: caption: Image: 17-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf - item-49 at level 1: caption: Image: 138-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf - item-50 at level 1: caption: Image: 157-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf - item-51 at level 1: caption: Image: 322-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf - item-52 at level 1: text: lcll[t!] + item-9 at level 1: text: Galaxies have spectacularly info ... lution with their detailedappearances. + item-10 at level 1: text: Deep neural networks that exploi ... imagingbut what about us astronomers? + item-11 at level 1: text: Two major challenges arise when ... ind the patterns that ML models learn. + item-12 at level 1: text: Fortunately, there exists a stra ... ics of how deep neural networks learn. + item-13 at level 1: text: We introduce a novel, interpreta ... ro extra computational cost or memory. + item-14 at level 1: text: We train the SFNet to predict ga ... r conclusions in Section[sec:summary]. + item-15 at level 1: section: group figure + item-16 at level 2: picture + item-16 at level 3: caption: Image: SFNet_ResNet18-TopK.pdf + item-17 at level 2: text: Our SFNet architecture, which re ... together (i.e. a residual connection). + item-18 at level 1: caption: Image: SFNet_ResNet18-TopK.pdf + item-19 at level 1: section_header: Methodology + item-20 at level 1: text: We select galaxies from the SDSS ... e comprises 250,207 galaxies in total. + item-21 at level 1: text: Our SFNet implementation is show ... features are localized in pixel space. + item-22 at level 1: text: The resnet18 backbone of the mod ... om/jwuphysics/sparse-feature-networks. + item-23 at level 1: section_header: Results + item-24 at level 1: text: Motivated by previous works that ... }$ and $A_{\tt Z\,256}$, respectively. + item-25 at level 1: section_header: Emission line fluxes + item-26 at level 1: text: We train a SFNet to predict the ... physical state, and dust attenuation. + item-27 at level 1: text: The eight most frequently activa ... eatures SL17, SL138, SL157, and SL322. + item-28 at level 1: text: In Figure[fig:bpt-interpretation ... al interpretations for these features. + item-29 at level 1: section: group figure + item-30 at level 2: picture + item-30 at level 3: caption: Image: 17-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf + item-31 at level 2: picture + item-31 at level 3: caption: Image: 138-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf + item-32 at level 2: picture + item-32 at level 3: caption: Image: 157-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf + item-33 at level 2: picture + item-33 at level 3: caption: Image: 322-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf + item-34 at level 2: text: SFNet learned features when trai ... magenta (low) to bright yellow (high). + item-35 at level 1: caption: Image: 17-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf + item-36 at level 1: caption: Image: 138-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf + item-37 at level 1: caption: Image: 157-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf + item-38 at level 1: caption: Image: 322-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf + item-39 at level 1: text: lcll[t!] 4 - item-53 at level 1: text: Image features learned by a SFNe ... es that are most frequently activated. - item-54 at level 1: text: Feature + item-40 at level 1: text: Image features learned by a SFNe ... es that are most frequently activated. + item-41 at level 1: text: Feature $f_{\rm activated}$ ... blue, edge-on disks low metallicity - item-55 at level 1: section_header: Gas metallicity - item-56 at level 1: paragraph: We separately train a SFNet to predict the gas-phase metallicity, - item-57 at level 1: text: $Z_{\rm gas} = 12 + $log(O/H), d ... erpretability]for further discussion). - item-58 at level 1: paragraph: In the bottom two rows of Table - item-59 at level 1: text: [tab:features], we describe the ... morphological features that it learns. - item-60 at level 1: section_header: Discussion - item-61 at level 1: section_header: Physical laws from galaxy images - item-62 at level 1: paragraph: Because the SFNet learns a linea ... prediction, we can write down a simple - item-63 at level 1: text: equation between learned galaxy ... led by their activated feature index). - item-64 at level 1: section: group figure - item-65 at level 2: picture - item-65 at level 3: caption: Image: equations.pdf - item-66 at level 2: text: Linear relationships between gal ... image cutout from the validation set. - item-67 at level 1: caption: Image: equations.pdf - item-68 at level 1: paragraph: These linear relations are so si ... at we can directly interpret them. The - item-69 at level 1: text: Z61 and Z256 features used to pr ... sociated with harder ionizing spectra. - item-70 at level 1: paragraph: The model is only able to learn ... ay between multiple physical processes - item-71 at level 1: text: [2015ARAA..53...51S,2017MNRAS.47 ... ionships that govern galaxy evolution. - item-72 at level 1: section_header: Performance versus interpretability - item-73 at level 1: paragraph: Previous works have found that a ... star-forming galaxies with an accuracy - item-74 at level 1: text: [2021ApJ...914..142H,2022arXiv22 ... accuracy of 0.85 and F1 score of 0.72. - item-75 at level 1: footnote: If we use all non-zero SFNet fea ... uces noiseanother benefit of sparsity. - item-76 at level 1: text: In comparison, the highly tuned ... ble to state-of-the-art ML algorithms. - item-77 at level 1: paragraph: In Section - item-78 at level 1: text: [ssec:metallicity], we estimate ... nce in order to gain interpretability. - item-79 at level 1: section_header: Comparison to PCA - item-80 at level 1: paragraph: While the SFNet produces interpr ... ing eigenvalues). -By selecting the top - item-81 at level 1: text: $k$principal components, we can ... a smaller space of sparse activations. - item-82 at level 1: section: group figure - item-83 at level 2: picture - item-83 at level 3: caption: Image: pca-comparison.pdf - item-84 at level 2: text: SFNet comparison against a CNN w ... sparsity or number of PCA components). - item-85 at level 1: caption: Image: pca-comparison.pdf - item-86 at level 1: paragraph: We test whether this smaller set ... inear regression model using the first - item-87 at level 1: text: $k$ principal components from de ... standard error on the prediction RMSE. - item-88 at level 1: footnote: We use the same training/validat ... reported in Section\ref{sec:results}. - item-89 at level 1: text: The results are shown in Figure[ ... values are given in Table[tab:dimred]. - item-90 at level 1: text: l cc cc[t!] + item-42 at level 1: section_header: Gas metallicity + item-43 at level 1: text: We separately train a SFNet to p ... erpretability]for further discussion). + item-44 at level 1: text: In the bottom two rows of Table[ ... morphological features that it learns. + item-45 at level 1: section_header: Discussion + item-46 at level 1: section_header: Physical laws from galaxy images + item-47 at level 1: text: Because the SFNet learns a linea ... led by their activated feature index). + item-48 at level 1: section: group figure + item-49 at level 2: picture + item-49 at level 3: caption: Image: equations.pdf + item-50 at level 2: text: Linear relationships between gal ... image cutout from the validation set. + item-51 at level 1: caption: Image: equations.pdf + item-52 at level 1: text: These linear relations are so si ... sociated with harder ionizing spectra. + item-53 at level 1: text: The model is only able to learn ... ionships that govern galaxy evolution. + item-54 at level 1: section_header: Performance versus interpretability + item-55 at level 1: text: Previous works have found that a ... accuracy of 0.85 and F1 score of 0.72. + item-56 at level 1: footnote: If we use all non-zero SFNet fea ... uces noiseanother benefit of sparsity. + item-57 at level 1: text: In comparison, the highly tuned ... ble to state-of-the-art ML algorithms. + item-58 at level 1: text: In Section[ssec:metallicity], we ... nce in order to gain interpretability. + item-59 at level 1: section_header: Comparison to PCA + item-60 at level 1: text: While the SFNet produces interpr ... a smaller space of sparse activations. + item-61 at level 1: section: group figure + item-62 at level 2: picture + item-62 at level 3: caption: Image: pca-comparison.pdf + item-63 at level 2: text: SFNet comparison against a CNN w ... sparsity or number of PCA components). + item-64 at level 1: caption: Image: pca-comparison.pdf + item-65 at level 1: text: We test whether this smaller set ... standard error on the prediction RMSE. + item-66 at level 1: footnote: We use the same training/validat ... reported in Section\ref{sec:results}. + item-67 at level 1: text: The results are shown in Figure[ ... values are given in Table[tab:dimred]. + item-68 at level 1: text: l cc cc[t!] 5 - item-91 at level 1: text: Comparison of performance using ... th PCA-based dimensionality reduction. - item-92 at level 1: text: 2cRMSE: Metallicity + item-69 at level 1: text: Comparison of performance using ... th PCA-based dimensionality reduction. + item-70 at level 1: text: 2cRMSE: Metallicity 2cRMSE: Sp ... $ 0.0921 $0.2389 \pm 0.0012$ 0.2396 - item-93 at level 1: paragraph: For both metallicity and spectral line fluxes, - item-94 at level 1: text: $>95\%$ of the variance is expla ... features extracted via a typical CNN. - item-95 at level 1: footnote: The non-monotonic decrease in RM ... vant for predicting galaxy properties. - item-96 at level 1: text: We turn our attention to spectra ... ificantly worse performance at $k=2$). - item-97 at level 1: paragraph: Our experiment shows that we can ... ding optimal summary statistics; e.g., - item-98 at level 1: text: Charnock_2018). -By forcing a CNN ... ures and produce accurate predictions. - item-99 at level 1: section_header: Comparison to GalaxyZoo features - item-100 at level 1: paragraph: Do regular CNNs also learn inter ... ned to classify GalaxyZoo morphologies - item-101 at level 1: text: [2008MNRAS.389.1179L,2023JOSS... ... e combination of morphology and color. - item-102 at level 1: paragraph: Using morphological features fro ... ining/validation datasets from Section - item-103 at level 1: text: [ssec:metallicity], and independ ... and $Z_{\rm gas}$as training targets. - item-104 at level 1: paragraph: First, we fit a linear model to ... ce on the validation dataset (error of - item-105 at level 1: text: $0.183$dex). When we fit on the ... es can reconstruct galaxy metallicity. - item-106 at level 1: paragraph: Second, we fit an gradient-boost ... the training dataset, and achieve only - item-107 at level 1: text: $0.180$dex error on the validati ... (comparable to the SFNet performance). - item-108 at level 1: paragraph: Our experiments confirm that the ... idation set, but that these features ( - item-109 at level 1: text: i) cannot be linearly combined t ... is both performant and interpretable. - item-110 at level 1: paragraph: Finally, we check whether the SF ... es using the Zoobot features, finding - item-111 at level 1: text: $R^2$ values of $0.253$ and $0.1 ... nt morphological features than Zoobot. - item-112 at level 1: section_header: Limitations of previous interpretability methods - item-113 at level 1: paragraph: The ML discipline generally focu ... tion-based interpretability algorithms - item-114 at level 1: text: [erhan2009_visualizing,zeiler201 ... problem than a classification problem. - item-115 at level 1: footnote: While there is promise in improv ... mplification of richer (astro)physics. - item-116 at level 1: paragraph: Moreover, interpretation for cla ... astronomers might ask questions like, - item-117 at level 1: text: which morphological features in ... classification problems is different. - item-118 at level 1: paragraph: Other interpretability methods like saliency mapping - item-119 at level 1: text: [simonyan2014deepinsideconvoluti ... rpretable ML in the physical sciences. - item-120 at level 1: section_header: Conclusions - item-121 at level 1: paragraph: We present a novel method for le ... sparse feature network (SFNet; Figure - item-122 at level 1: text: [fig:SFNet-architecture]) maps g ... ures (see Figure[fig:pca-comparison]). - item-123 at level 1: paragraph: We do - item-124 at level 1: text: not imply that astrophysics can ... ned features and predicted quantities. - item-125 at level 1: paragraph: This work represents important p ... results by incorporating a simple top- - item-126 at level 1: text: $k$ sparsity layer into a resnet ... activating features [olah2017feature]. - item-127 at level 1: section_header: Acknowledgments. - item-128 at level 1: text: We thank Christian Jespersen, Ch ... Christine Ye for useful conversations. - item-129 at level 1: section_header: Why are deep neural networks so hard to decipher? - item-130 at level 1: section_header: Superposition and polysemanticity - item-131 at level 1: paragraph: Modern deep neural networks are ... ms by which deep neural networks learn - item-132 at level 1: text: [olah2020zoom,rai2024practicalre ... trained neural networks have learned. - item-133 at level 1: paragraph: However, it is challenging to de ... ena: superposition and polysemanticity - item-134 at level 1: text: [superposition]. - item-135 at level 1: list: group list - item-136 at level 2: list_item: Superposition is where semantic ... rons (in one or even multiple layers). - item-137 at level 2: list_item: Polysemanticity means that any g ... ight bleed from nearby saturated star. - item-138 at level 1: text: So rather than a one-to-one mapp ... networks, even in just a single layer. - item-139 at level 1: section_header: Sparse autoencoders and SFNets - item-140 at level 1: paragraph: Originally motivated by biological vision systems - item-141 at level 1: text: [OLSHAUSEN19973311,NIPS2007_4daa ... s represented by deep neural networks. - item-142 at level 1: paragraph: Previous works with SAEs have ty ... ct the meanings of learned activations - item-143 at level 1: text: [bricken2023monosemanticity]. -SA ... rk activations into a few sparse ones. - item-144 at level 1: paragraph: Our work builds on insights from ... ing to produce interpretable features. - item-145 at level 1: text: main - item-146 at level 1: text: aasjournal \ No newline at end of file + item-71 at level 1: text: For both metallicity and spectra ... features extracted via a typical CNN. + item-72 at level 1: footnote: The non-monotonic decrease in RM ... vant for predicting galaxy properties. + item-73 at level 1: text: We turn our attention to spectra ... ificantly worse performance at $k=2$). + item-74 at level 1: text: Our experiment shows that we can ... ures and produce accurate predictions. + item-75 at level 1: section_header: Comparison to GalaxyZoo features + item-76 at level 1: text: Do regular CNNs also learn inter ... e combination of morphology and color. + item-77 at level 1: text: Using morphological features fro ... and $Z_{\rm gas}$as training targets. + item-78 at level 1: text: First, we fit a linear model to ... es can reconstruct galaxy metallicity. + item-79 at level 1: text: Second, we fit an gradient-boost ... (comparable to the SFNet performance). + item-80 at level 1: text: Our experiments confirm that the ... is both performant and interpretable. + item-81 at level 1: text: Finally, we check whether the SF ... nt morphological features than Zoobot. + item-82 at level 1: section_header: Limitations of previous interpretability methods + item-83 at level 1: text: The ML discipline generally focu ... problem than a classification problem. + item-84 at level 1: footnote: While there is promise in improv ... mplification of richer (astro)physics. + item-85 at level 1: text: Moreover, interpretation for cla ... classification problems is different. + item-86 at level 1: text: Other interpretability methods l ... rpretable ML in the physical sciences. + item-87 at level 1: section_header: Conclusions + item-88 at level 1: text: We present a novel method for le ... ures (see Figure[fig:pca-comparison]). + item-89 at level 1: text: We do not imply that astrophysic ... ned features and predicted quantities. + item-90 at level 1: text: This work represents important p ... activating features [olah2017feature]. + item-91 at level 1: section_header: Acknowledgments. + item-92 at level 1: text: We thank Christian Jespersen, Ch ... Christine Ye for useful conversations. + item-93 at level 1: section_header: Why are deep neural networks so hard to decipher? + item-94 at level 1: section_header: Superposition and polysemanticity + item-95 at level 1: text: Modern deep neural networks are ... trained neural networks have learned. + item-96 at level 1: text: However, it is challenging to de ... n and polysemanticity [superposition]. + item-97 at level 1: list: group list + item-98 at level 2: list_item: Superposition is where semantic ... rons (in one or even multiple layers). + item-99 at level 2: list_item: Polysemanticity means that any g ... ight bleed from nearby saturated star. + item-100 at level 1: text: So rather than a one-to-one mapp ... networks, even in just a single layer. + item-101 at level 1: section_header: Sparse autoencoders and SFNets + item-102 at level 1: text: Originally motivated by biologic ... s represented by deep neural networks. + item-103 at level 1: text: Previous works with SAEs have ty ... rk activations into a few sparse ones. + item-104 at level 1: paragraph: Our work builds on insights from ... ing to produce interpretable features. + item-105 at level 1: text: main + item-106 at level 1: text: aasjournal \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2501.00089_main.tex.json b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2501.00089_main.tex.json index c162c094f5..472abe1b6f 100644 --- a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2501.00089_main.tex.json +++ b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2501.00089_main.tex.json @@ -55,10 +55,10 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/13" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/14" + "$ref": "#/groups/0" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/15" + "$ref": "#/texts/14" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/16" @@ -73,10 +73,10 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/19" }, { - "$ref": "#/groups/0" + "$ref": "#/texts/20" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/20" + "$ref": "#/texts/21" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/22" @@ -90,6 +90,9 @@ { "$ref": "#/texts/25" }, + { + "$ref": "#/groups/1" + }, { "$ref": "#/texts/26" }, @@ -102,9 +105,6 @@ { "$ref": "#/texts/29" }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/30" - }, { "$ref": "#/texts/31" }, @@ -130,19 +130,19 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/38" }, { - "$ref": "#/groups/1" + "$ref": "#/texts/39" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/39" + "$ref": "#/groups/2" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/40" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/41" + "$ref": "#/texts/42" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/42" + "$ref": "#/texts/43" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/44" @@ -166,10 +166,10 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/50" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/51" + "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/52" + "$ref": "#/texts/51" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/53" @@ -181,10 +181,10 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/55" }, { - "$ref": "#/groups/2" + "$ref": "#/texts/56" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/56" + "$ref": "#/texts/57" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/58" @@ -229,10 +229,10 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/71" }, { - "$ref": "#/groups/3" + "$ref": "#/texts/72" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/72" + "$ref": "#/texts/73" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/74" @@ -268,10 +268,7 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/84" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/85" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/86" + "$ref": "#/groups/4" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/87" @@ -293,123 +290,6 @@ }, { "$ref": "#/texts/93" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/94" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/95" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/96" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/97" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/98" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/99" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/100" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/101" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/102" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/103" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/104" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/105" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/106" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/107" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/108" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/109" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/110" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/111" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/112" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/113" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/114" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/115" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/116" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/117" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/118" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/119" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/120" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/121" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/122" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/groups/4" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/125" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/126" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/127" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/128" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/129" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/130" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/131" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/132" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/133" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -427,7 +307,7 @@ "$ref": "#/pictures/0" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/21" + "$ref": "#/texts/15" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -453,7 +333,7 @@ "$ref": "#/pictures/4" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/43" + "$ref": "#/texts/30" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -470,7 +350,7 @@ "$ref": "#/pictures/5" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/57" + "$ref": "#/texts/41" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -487,7 +367,7 @@ "$ref": "#/pictures/6" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/73" + "$ref": "#/texts/52" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -501,10 +381,10 @@ }, "children": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/123" + "$ref": "#/texts/85" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/124" + "$ref": "#/texts/86" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -618,10 +498,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "Galaxies have spectacularly information-rich appearances. For a hundred years, astronomers have categorized galaxies on the basis of morphology and colors seen in optical imaging, and they have noted correlations between galaxies' physical properties and these simple morphological classifications", - "text": "Galaxies have spectacularly information-rich appearances. For a hundred years, astronomers have categorized galaxies on the basis of morphology and colors seen in optical imaging, and they have noted correlations between galaxies' physical properties and these simple morphological classifications" + "orig": "Galaxies have spectacularly information-rich appearances. For a hundred years, astronomers have categorized galaxies on the basis of morphology and colors seen in optical imaging, and they have noted correlations between galaxies' physical properties and these simple morphological classifications [1926ApJ....64..321H,1959HDP....53..373Z,1961hag..book.....S,2008MNRAS.389.1179L,2020IAUS..353..205M]. However, until very recently, there has been no way to connect the physics of galaxy formation and evolution with their detailedappearances.", + "text": "Galaxies have spectacularly information-rich appearances. For a hundred years, astronomers have categorized galaxies on the basis of morphology and colors seen in optical imaging, and they have noted correlations between galaxies' physical properties and these simple morphological classifications [1926ApJ....64..321H,1959HDP....53..373Z,1961hag..book.....S,2008MNRAS.389.1179L,2020IAUS..353..205M]. However, until very recently, there has been no way to connect the physics of galaxy formation and evolution with their detailedappearances." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/9", @@ -632,8 +512,8 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[1926ApJ....64..321H,1959HDP....53..373Z,1961hag..book.....S,2008MNRAS.389.1179L,2020IAUS..353..205M]. However, until very recently, there has been no way to connect the physics of galaxy formation and evolution with their detailedappearances.", - "text": "[1926ApJ....64..321H,1959HDP....53..373Z,1961hag..book.....S,2008MNRAS.389.1179L,2020IAUS..353..205M]. However, until very recently, there has been no way to connect the physics of galaxy formation and evolution with their detailedappearances." + "orig": "Deep neural networks that exploit pixel-scale information from images can now robustly predict galaxy properties; optical images of galaxies contain enough information to constrain their physical characteristics [2019ApJ...887..251W,2020ApJ...900..142W,2021arXiv211101154B]. In fact, entire galaxy spectra can be estimated directly from image cutouts of individual galaxies [2020arXiv200912318W,2021ApJ...914..142H,Doorenbos+2022,Doorenbos+2024,2024MNRAS.531.4990P]. This last discovery highlights the promise of machine learning (ML) in the physical sciences. By leveraging deep learning models such as convolutional neural networks (CNNs), we can derive valuable physical constraints from plentiful galaxy images [2023PASA...40....1H,2024MNRAS.531.4990P].\nSo machines are capable of learning physics from galaxy imagingbut what about us astronomers?", + "text": "Deep neural networks that exploit pixel-scale information from images can now robustly predict galaxy properties; optical images of galaxies contain enough information to constrain their physical characteristics [2019ApJ...887..251W,2020ApJ...900..142W,2021arXiv211101154B]. In fact, entire galaxy spectra can be estimated directly from image cutouts of individual galaxies [2020arXiv200912318W,2021ApJ...914..142H,Doorenbos+2022,Doorenbos+2024,2024MNRAS.531.4990P]. This last discovery highlights the promise of machine learning (ML) in the physical sciences. By leveraging deep learning models such as convolutional neural networks (CNNs), we can derive valuable physical constraints from plentiful galaxy images [2023PASA...40....1H,2024MNRAS.531.4990P].\nSo machines are capable of learning physics from galaxy imagingbut what about us astronomers?" }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/10", @@ -642,10 +522,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "Deep neural networks that exploit pixel-scale information from images can now robustly predict galaxy properties; optical images of galaxies contain enough information to constrain their physical characteristics", - "text": "Deep neural networks that exploit pixel-scale information from images can now robustly predict galaxy properties; optical images of galaxies contain enough information to constrain their physical characteristics" + "orig": "Two major challenges arise when we try to interpret physics from deep neural networks. First, each neuron in the network represents a non-linear combination of features, resulting in uninterpretable mess of features [superposition]. Second, each neuron can also be activated in multiple independent contexts, and can thus take on multiple meanings [geva2021transformerfeedforwardlayerskeyvalue]. In other words, neuron values are not one-to-one with learned concepts. Superposition and polysemanticity allow neural networks to increase their capacity for storing features [olah2020zoom,superposition,10136140]; these phenomena are topics of cutting-edge ML research, and we present an extended discussion in Appendix[appendix]. Unfortunately, they also obscure the interpretation and contribution of any specific neuron, preventing us from understanding the physics behind the patterns that ML models learn.", + "text": "Two major challenges arise when we try to interpret physics from deep neural networks. First, each neuron in the network represents a non-linear combination of features, resulting in uninterpretable mess of features [superposition]. Second, each neuron can also be activated in multiple independent contexts, and can thus take on multiple meanings [geva2021transformerfeedforwardlayerskeyvalue]. In other words, neuron values are not one-to-one with learned concepts. Superposition and polysemanticity allow neural networks to increase their capacity for storing features [olah2020zoom,superposition,10136140]; these phenomena are topics of cutting-edge ML research, and we present an extended discussion in Appendix[appendix]. Unfortunately, they also obscure the interpretation and contribution of any specific neuron, preventing us from understanding the physics behind the patterns that ML models learn." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/11", @@ -656,8 +536,8 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[2019ApJ...887..251W,2020ApJ...900..142W,2021arXiv211101154B]. In fact, entire galaxy spectra can be estimated directly from image cutouts of individual galaxies [2020arXiv200912318W,2021ApJ...914..142H,Doorenbos+2022,Doorenbos+2024,2024MNRAS.531.4990P]. This last discovery highlights the promise of machine learning (ML) in the physical sciences. By leveraging deep learning models such as convolutional neural networks (CNNs), we can derive valuable physical constraints from plentiful galaxy images [2023PASA...40....1H,2024MNRAS.531.4990P].\nSo machines are capable of learning physics from galaxy imagingbut what about us astronomers?", - "text": "[2019ApJ...887..251W,2020ApJ...900..142W,2021arXiv211101154B]. In fact, entire galaxy spectra can be estimated directly from image cutouts of individual galaxies [2020arXiv200912318W,2021ApJ...914..142H,Doorenbos+2022,Doorenbos+2024,2024MNRAS.531.4990P]. This last discovery highlights the promise of machine learning (ML) in the physical sciences. By leveraging deep learning models such as convolutional neural networks (CNNs), we can derive valuable physical constraints from plentiful galaxy images [2023PASA...40....1H,2024MNRAS.531.4990P].\nSo machines are capable of learning physics from galaxy imagingbut what about us astronomers?" + "orig": "Fortunately, there exists a strategy to combat these issues in ML. Sparse coding represents data using a small number of active elements from a larger set of basis functions [Olshausen1996,NIPS2006_2d71b2ae], making it easier to inspect the individual features that contribute to ML model predictions [olah2017feature]. Recently, sparse ML algorithms have been used in the artificial intelligence community to disentangle the internal activations of large language models [radford2019language], and mitigate the problems of superposition and polysemanticity [makhzani2014ksparseautoencoders,cunningham2023sparseautoencodershighlyinterpretable,2024arXiv240800657O,templeton2024scaling]. Therefore, sparse coding can reveal the mechanics of how deep neural networks learn.", + "text": "Fortunately, there exists a strategy to combat these issues in ML. Sparse coding represents data using a small number of active elements from a larger set of basis functions [Olshausen1996,NIPS2006_2d71b2ae], making it easier to inspect the individual features that contribute to ML model predictions [olah2017feature]. Recently, sparse ML algorithms have been used in the artificial intelligence community to disentangle the internal activations of large language models [radford2019language], and mitigate the problems of superposition and polysemanticity [makhzani2014ksparseautoencoders,cunningham2023sparseautoencodershighlyinterpretable,2024arXiv240800657O,templeton2024scaling]. Therefore, sparse coding can reveal the mechanics of how deep neural networks learn." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/12", @@ -666,10 +546,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "Two major challenges arise when we try to interpret physics from deep neural networks. First, each neuron in the network represents a non-linear combination of features, resulting in uninterpretable mess of features", - "text": "Two major challenges arise when we try to interpret physics from deep neural networks. First, each neuron in the network represents a non-linear combination of features, resulting in uninterpretable mess of features" + "orig": "We introduce a novel, interpretable CNN for images: a Sparse Feature Network (SFNet).\nCNNs encode image data from a high-dimensional pixel space ($n \\sim 10^5$ pixels) into a lower-dimensional latent space ($d \\sim 10^3$ features). \nTo disentangle the learned features, we enforce a $k$-sparse constraint while training our ML model: only $k \\ll d$ features are allowed to have non-zero activations for each image example. By keeping just the top $k$ activating features, sparse algorithms are forced to consolidate features into the fewest possible neurons.\nOur SFNet activates $k$ features per image in its penultimate layer, and makes predictions by using a linear combination of the sparse activations. \nSince we only add a top-$k$constraint to a standard CNN architecture, this modification incurs zero extra computational cost or memory.", + "text": "We introduce a novel, interpretable CNN for images: a Sparse Feature Network (SFNet).\nCNNs encode image data from a high-dimensional pixel space ($n \\sim 10^5$ pixels) into a lower-dimensional latent space ($d \\sim 10^3$ features). \nTo disentangle the learned features, we enforce a $k$-sparse constraint while training our ML model: only $k \\ll d$ features are allowed to have non-zero activations for each image example. By keeping just the top $k$ activating features, sparse algorithms are forced to consolidate features into the fewest possible neurons.\nOur SFNet activates $k$ features per image in its penultimate layer, and makes predictions by using a linear combination of the sparse activations. \nSince we only add a top-$k$constraint to a standard CNN architecture, this modification incurs zero extra computational cost or memory." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/13", @@ -680,8 +560,8 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[superposition]. Second, each neuron can also be activated in multiple independent contexts, and can thus take on multiple meanings [geva2021transformerfeedforwardlayerskeyvalue]. In other words, neuron values are not one-to-one with learned concepts. Superposition and polysemanticity allow neural networks to increase their capacity for storing features [olah2020zoom,superposition,10136140]; these phenomena are topics of cutting-edge ML research, and we present an extended discussion in Appendix[appendix]. Unfortunately, they also obscure the interpretation and contribution of any specific neuron, preventing us from understanding the physics behind the patterns that ML models learn.", - "text": "[superposition]. Second, each neuron can also be activated in multiple independent contexts, and can thus take on multiple meanings [geva2021transformerfeedforwardlayerskeyvalue]. In other words, neuron values are not one-to-one with learned concepts. Superposition and polysemanticity allow neural networks to increase their capacity for storing features [olah2020zoom,superposition,10136140]; these phenomena are topics of cutting-edge ML research, and we present an extended discussion in Appendix[appendix]. Unfortunately, they also obscure the interpretation and contribution of any specific neuron, preventing us from understanding the physics behind the patterns that ML models learn." + "orig": "We train the SFNet to predict galaxy properties from image cutouts according to the methodology described in Section[sec:methodology]. In Section[sec:results], we show that the SFNet achieves robust performance while learning interpretable features. We discuss these results further in Section[sec:discussion], and state our conclusions in Section[sec:summary].", + "text": "We train the SFNet to predict galaxy properties from image cutouts according to the methodology described in Section[sec:methodology]. In Section[sec:results], we show that the SFNet achieves robust performance while learning interpretable features. We discuss these results further in Section[sec:discussion], and state our conclusions in Section[sec:summary]." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/14", @@ -690,22 +570,22 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "caption", "prov": [], - "orig": "Fortunately, there exists a strategy to combat these issues in ML. Sparse coding represents data using a small number of active elements from a larger set of basis functions", - "text": "Fortunately, there exists a strategy to combat these issues in ML. Sparse coding represents data using a small number of active elements from a larger set of basis functions" + "orig": "Image: SFNet_ResNet18-TopK.pdf", + "text": "Image: SFNet_ResNet18-TopK.pdf" }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/15", "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" + "$ref": "#/groups/0" }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[Olshausen1996,NIPS2006_2d71b2ae], making it easier to inspect the individual features that contribute to ML model predictions [olah2017feature]. Recently, sparse ML algorithms have been used in the artificial intelligence community to disentangle the internal activations of large language models [radford2019language], and mitigate the problems of superposition and polysemanticity [makhzani2014ksparseautoencoders,cunningham2023sparseautoencodershighlyinterpretable,2024arXiv240800657O,templeton2024scaling]. Therefore, sparse coding can reveal the mechanics of how deep neural networks learn.", - "text": "[Olshausen1996,NIPS2006_2d71b2ae], making it easier to inspect the individual features that contribute to ML model predictions [olah2017feature]. Recently, sparse ML algorithms have been used in the artificial intelligence community to disentangle the internal activations of large language models [radford2019language], and mitigate the problems of superposition and polysemanticity [makhzani2014ksparseautoencoders,cunningham2023sparseautoencodershighlyinterpretable,2024arXiv240800657O,templeton2024scaling]. Therefore, sparse coding can reveal the mechanics of how deep neural networks learn." + "orig": "Our SFNet architecture, which resembles a resnet18 modified with a penultimate Top-k layer to ensure interpretable, sparse image features. A 3x3 conv, 128, /2 block denotes a $3\\times 3$ 2D convolution layer with 128 channels that downsamples the image size by a factor of 2. Each convolution layer is followed by batch normalization and then a ReLU activation function. Arrows show how inputs flow through the network, and when two inputs are sent as inputs to the same layer, they are concatenated together (i.e. a residual connection).", + "text": "Our SFNet architecture, which resembles a resnet18 modified with a penultimate Top-k layer to ensure interpretable, sparse image features. A 3x3 conv, 128, /2 block denotes a $3\\times 3$ 2D convolution layer with 128 channels that downsamples the image size by a factor of 2. Each convolution layer is followed by batch normalization and then a ReLU activation function. Arrows show how inputs flow through the network, and when two inputs are sent as inputs to the same layer, they are concatenated together (i.e. a residual connection)." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/16", @@ -714,10 +594,11 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "section_header", "prov": [], - "orig": "We introduce a novel, interpretable CNN for images: a Sparse Feature Network (SFNet).\nCNNs encode image data from a high-dimensional pixel space (", - "text": "We introduce a novel, interpretable CNN for images: a Sparse Feature Network (SFNet).\nCNNs encode image data from a high-dimensional pixel space (" + "orig": "Methodology", + "text": "Methodology", + "level": 1 }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/17", @@ -728,8 +609,8 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "$n \\sim 10^5$ pixels) into a lower-dimensional latent space ($d \\sim 10^3$ features). \nTo disentangle the learned features, we enforce a $k$-sparse constraint while training our ML model: only $k \\ll d$ features are allowed to have non-zero activations for each image example. By keeping just the top $k$ activating features, sparse algorithms are forced to consolidate features into the fewest possible neurons.\nOur SFNet activates $k$ features per image in its penultimate layer, and makes predictions by using a linear combination of the sparse activations. \nSince we only add a top-$k$constraint to a standard CNN architecture, this modification incurs zero extra computational cost or memory.", - "text": "$n \\sim 10^5$ pixels) into a lower-dimensional latent space ($d \\sim 10^3$ features). \nTo disentangle the learned features, we enforce a $k$-sparse constraint while training our ML model: only $k \\ll d$ features are allowed to have non-zero activations for each image example. By keeping just the top $k$ activating features, sparse algorithms are forced to consolidate features into the fewest possible neurons.\nOur SFNet activates $k$ features per image in its penultimate layer, and makes predictions by using a linear combination of the sparse activations. \nSince we only add a top-$k$constraint to a standard CNN architecture, this modification incurs zero extra computational cost or memory." + "orig": "We select galaxies from the SDSS Main Galaxy Sample [2002AJ....124.1810S,sdssdr7] that have emission line signal-to-noise ratios greater than 3 for [N2] $\\lambda6584$, H$\\alpha$ $\\lambda6564$, [O3] $\\lambda5007$, and H$\\beta$ $\\lambda4861$, where each line is designated by its rest wavelength in Angstroms. In addition to galaxy line fluxes, we compile physical properties derived from fitting spectral energy distribution models to SDSS photometry and spectra [2003MNRAS.346.1055K,2004MNRAS.351.1151B,2004ApJ...613..898T]. For all galaxies, we obtain $gri$-band $144\\times 144$ image cutouts resampled at $0.262$ arcsec per pixel resolution from the Legacy Survey website [2019AJ....157..168D]. Our SDSS sample comprises 250,207 galaxies in total.", + "text": "We select galaxies from the SDSS Main Galaxy Sample [2002AJ....124.1810S,sdssdr7] that have emission line signal-to-noise ratios greater than 3 for [N2] $\\lambda6584$, H$\\alpha$ $\\lambda6564$, [O3] $\\lambda5007$, and H$\\beta$ $\\lambda4861$, where each line is designated by its rest wavelength in Angstroms. In addition to galaxy line fluxes, we compile physical properties derived from fitting spectral energy distribution models to SDSS photometry and spectra [2003MNRAS.346.1055K,2004MNRAS.351.1151B,2004ApJ...613..898T]. For all galaxies, we obtain $gri$-band $144\\times 144$ image cutouts resampled at $0.262$ arcsec per pixel resolution from the Legacy Survey website [2019AJ....157..168D]. Our SDSS sample comprises 250,207 galaxies in total." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/18", @@ -738,10 +619,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "We train the SFNet to predict galaxy properties from image cutouts according to the methodology described in Section", - "text": "We train the SFNet to predict galaxy properties from image cutouts according to the methodology described in Section" + "orig": "Our SFNet implementation is shown in Figure[fig:SFNet-architecture]. We use a CNN architecture identical to the resnet18 [he2015deepresiduallearningimage], except that we insert a top-$k$ operation before the final linear layer. \nThis additional top-$k$ layer guarantees that each prediction is a linear combination of $k$ sparse features.\nWe use $d=512$ latent features (after the average pooling layer) and set $k=4$. Later, in Section[ssec:comparison-pca], we vary $k \\in \\{2, 3, 4, 6, 8\\}$. Thus, the SFNet learns a representation of each galaxy using just a few features out of a library of 512 possible features.\nCritically, the features activate directly after the convolution layers, so that morphological features are localized in pixel space.", + "text": "Our SFNet implementation is shown in Figure[fig:SFNet-architecture]. We use a CNN architecture identical to the resnet18 [he2015deepresiduallearningimage], except that we insert a top-$k$ operation before the final linear layer. \nThis additional top-$k$ layer guarantees that each prediction is a linear combination of $k$ sparse features.\nWe use $d=512$ latent features (after the average pooling layer) and set $k=4$. Later, in Section[ssec:comparison-pca], we vary $k \\in \\{2, 3, 4, 6, 8\\}$. Thus, the SFNet learns a representation of each galaxy using just a few features out of a library of 512 possible features.\nCritically, the features activate directly after the convolution layers, so that morphological features are localized in pixel space." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/19", @@ -752,8 +633,8 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[sec:methodology]. In Section[sec:results], we show that the SFNet achieves robust performance while learning interpretable features. We discuss these results further in Section[sec:discussion], and state our conclusions in Section[sec:summary].", - "text": "[sec:methodology]. In Section[sec:results], we show that the SFNet achieves robust performance while learning interpretable features. We discuss these results further in Section[sec:discussion], and state our conclusions in Section[sec:summary]." + "orig": "The resnet18 backbone of the model is initialized to ImageNet-pretrained weights [5206848], and we update model parameters by minimizing the root mean squared error. We randomly designate 20% of objects for validation, and train on the remainder. Random flips are applied for data augmentation. We train for 20 epochs using the ranger optimizer [wright2021ranger21synergisticdeeplearning] and an initial learning rate of 0.1 with a flat+cosine annealing schedule. All code and the trained models presented here can be found in our public Github repository: https://github.com/jwuphysics/sparse-feature-networks.", + "text": "The resnet18 backbone of the model is initialized to ImageNet-pretrained weights [5206848], and we update model parameters by minimizing the root mean squared error. We randomly designate 20% of objects for validation, and train on the remainder. Random flips are applied for data augmentation. We train for 20 epochs using the ranger optimizer [wright2021ranger21synergisticdeeplearning] and an initial learning rate of 0.1 with a flat+cosine annealing schedule. All code and the trained models presented here can be found in our public Github repository: https://github.com/jwuphysics/sparse-feature-networks." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/20", @@ -762,22 +643,23 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "caption", + "label": "section_header", "prov": [], - "orig": "Image: SFNet_ResNet18-TopK.pdf", - "text": "Image: SFNet_ResNet18-TopK.pdf" + "orig": "Results", + "text": "Results", + "level": 1 }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/21", "parent": { - "$ref": "#/groups/0" + "$ref": "#/body" }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "Our SFNet architecture, which resembles a resnet18 modified with a penultimate Top-k layer to ensure interpretable, sparse image features. A 3x3 conv, 128, /2 block denotes a $3\\times 3$ 2D convolution layer with 128 channels that downsamples the image size by a factor of 2. Each convolution layer is followed by batch normalization and then a ReLU activation function. Arrows show how inputs flow through the network, and when two inputs are sent as inputs to the same layer, they are concatenated together (i.e. a residual connection).", - "text": "Our SFNet architecture, which resembles a resnet18 modified with a penultimate Top-k layer to ensure interpretable, sparse image features. A 3x3 conv, 128, /2 block denotes a $3\\times 3$ 2D convolution layer with 128 channels that downsamples the image size by a factor of 2. Each convolution layer is followed by batch normalization and then a ReLU activation function. Arrows show how inputs flow through the network, and when two inputs are sent as inputs to the same layer, they are concatenated together (i.e. a residual connection)." + "orig": "Motivated by previous works that connect galaxy imaging with their physical properties [2019MNRAS.484.4683W,2020arXiv200912318W,2021MNRAS.506.3313G,2021ApJ...914..142H], we train the SFNet to predict spectroscopic line fluxes (Section[ssec:ionization]) and gas-phase metallicity ([ssec:metallicity]) directly from image cutouts.\nWe identify the learned features using their sparse activation index, e.g., SL17 for the 17th feature of a SFNet trained to predict spectral lines fluxes, or Z256 for the 256th feature of a SFNet trained to predict gas-phase metallicity. Feature activations are scaled between 0 and 1, and we refer to these example activation strengths as $A_{\\tt SL\\,17}$ and $A_{\\tt Z\\,256}$, respectively.", + "text": "Motivated by previous works that connect galaxy imaging with their physical properties [2019MNRAS.484.4683W,2020arXiv200912318W,2021MNRAS.506.3313G,2021ApJ...914..142H], we train the SFNet to predict spectroscopic line fluxes (Section[ssec:ionization]) and gas-phase metallicity ([ssec:metallicity]) directly from image cutouts.\nWe identify the learned features using their sparse activation index, e.g., SL17 for the 17th feature of a SFNet trained to predict spectral lines fluxes, or Z256 for the 256th feature of a SFNet trained to predict gas-phase metallicity. Feature activations are scaled between 0 and 1, and we refer to these example activation strengths as $A_{\\tt SL\\,17}$ and $A_{\\tt Z\\,256}$, respectively." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/22", @@ -788,9 +670,9 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "section_header", "prov": [], - "orig": "Methodology", - "text": "Methodology", - "level": 1 + "orig": "Emission line fluxes", + "text": "Emission line fluxes", + "level": 2 }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/23", @@ -799,10 +681,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "We select galaxies from the SDSS Main Galaxy Sample", - "text": "We select galaxies from the SDSS Main Galaxy Sample" + "orig": "We train a SFNet to predict the spectral line fluxes for [N2], H$\\alpha$, [O3], and H$\\beta$. These lines can diagnose a galaxy's global ionization state; for example, the line ratios [N2]/H$\\alpha$ against [O3]/H$\\beta$ comprise the BPT diagram [1981PASP...93....5B], which is commonly used to differentiate activate galactic nuclei (AGN) from star-forming galaxies. Other physical processes can also affect these line strengths, including stellar evolution/age, AGN, gas metallicity, gas physical state, and dust attenuation.", + "text": "We train a SFNet to predict the spectral line fluxes for [N2], H$\\alpha$, [O3], and H$\\beta$. These lines can diagnose a galaxy's global ionization state; for example, the line ratios [N2]/H$\\alpha$ against [O3]/H$\\beta$ comprise the BPT diagram [1981PASP...93....5B], which is commonly used to differentiate activate galactic nuclei (AGN) from star-forming galaxies. Other physical processes can also affect these line strengths, including stellar evolution/age, AGN, gas metallicity, gas physical state, and dust attenuation." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/24", @@ -813,8 +695,8 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[2002AJ....124.1810S,sdssdr7] that have emission line signal-to-noise ratios greater than 3 for [N2] $\\lambda6584$, H$\\alpha$ $\\lambda6564$, [O3] $\\lambda5007$, and H$\\beta$ $\\lambda4861$, where each line is designated by its rest wavelength in Angstroms. In addition to galaxy line fluxes, we compile physical properties derived from fitting spectral energy distribution models to SDSS photometry and spectra [2003MNRAS.346.1055K,2004MNRAS.351.1151B,2004ApJ...613..898T]. For all galaxies, we obtain $gri$-band $144\\times 144$ image cutouts resampled at $0.262$ arcsec per pixel resolution from the Legacy Survey website [2019AJ....157..168D]. Our SDSS sample comprises 250,207 galaxies in total.", - "text": "[2002AJ....124.1810S,sdssdr7] that have emission line signal-to-noise ratios greater than 3 for [N2] $\\lambda6584$, H$\\alpha$ $\\lambda6564$, [O3] $\\lambda5007$, and H$\\beta$ $\\lambda4861$, where each line is designated by its rest wavelength in Angstroms. In addition to galaxy line fluxes, we compile physical properties derived from fitting spectral energy distribution models to SDSS photometry and spectra [2003MNRAS.346.1055K,2004MNRAS.351.1151B,2004ApJ...613..898T]. For all galaxies, we obtain $gri$-band $144\\times 144$ image cutouts resampled at $0.262$ arcsec per pixel resolution from the Legacy Survey website [2019AJ....157..168D]. Our SDSS sample comprises 250,207 galaxies in total." + "orig": "The eight most frequently activated features explain 99.99% of the variance in the dataset, but there is significant correlation between them. The four most frequently activated features can still explain 91.6% of the variance; therefore, we restrict our investigation to these top four activations that correspond to features SL17, SL138, SL157, and SL322.", + "text": "The eight most frequently activated features explain 99.99% of the variance in the dataset, but there is significant correlation between them. The four most frequently activated features can still explain 91.6% of the variance; therefore, we restrict our investigation to these top four activations that correspond to features SL17, SL138, SL157, and SL322." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/25", @@ -823,10 +705,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "Our SFNet implementation is shown in Figure", - "text": "Our SFNet implementation is shown in Figure" + "orig": "In Figure[fig:bpt-interpretation], we show galaxy image examples for the strongest activations, and where they appear in a BPT diagram. The four features reside in overlapping regions of the [O3]/H$\\beta$ versus [N2]/H$\\alpha$ space, but they all peak in distinct locations. For example, the locus of points for SL17 appear to be at higher [N2]/H$\\alpha$ and [O3]/H$\\beta$, indicating harder ionizing radiation and higher gas density [2019ARAA..57..511K]. Meanwhile, the opposite appears to be true for SL138 (or at least, for non-AGN with high $A_{\\tt SL\\,138}$). Additional features contain information about metallicity and stellar populations. In Table[tab:features], we offer physical interpretations for these features.", + "text": "In Figure[fig:bpt-interpretation], we show galaxy image examples for the strongest activations, and where they appear in a BPT diagram. The four features reside in overlapping regions of the [O3]/H$\\beta$ versus [N2]/H$\\alpha$ space, but they all peak in distinct locations. For example, the locus of points for SL17 appear to be at higher [N2]/H$\\alpha$ and [O3]/H$\\beta$, indicating harder ionizing radiation and higher gas density [2019ARAA..57..511K]. Meanwhile, the opposite appears to be true for SL138 (or at least, for non-AGN with high $A_{\\tt SL\\,138}$). Additional features contain information about metallicity and stellar populations. In Table[tab:features], we offer physical interpretations for these features." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/26", @@ -835,10 +717,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", + "label": "caption", "prov": [], - "orig": "[fig:SFNet-architecture]. We use a CNN architecture identical to the resnet18 [he2015deepresiduallearningimage], except that we insert a top-$k$ operation before the final linear layer. \nThis additional top-$k$ layer guarantees that each prediction is a linear combination of $k$ sparse features.\nWe use $d=512$ latent features (after the average pooling layer) and set $k=4$. Later, in Section[ssec:comparison-pca], we vary $k \\in \\{2, 3, 4, 6, 8\\}$. Thus, the SFNet learns a representation of each galaxy using just a few features out of a library of 512 possible features.\nCritically, the features activate directly after the convolution layers, so that morphological features are localized in pixel space.", - "text": "[fig:SFNet-architecture]. We use a CNN architecture identical to the resnet18 [he2015deepresiduallearningimage], except that we insert a top-$k$ operation before the final linear layer. \nThis additional top-$k$ layer guarantees that each prediction is a linear combination of $k$ sparse features.\nWe use $d=512$ latent features (after the average pooling layer) and set $k=4$. Later, in Section[ssec:comparison-pca], we vary $k \\in \\{2, 3, 4, 6, 8\\}$. Thus, the SFNet learns a representation of each galaxy using just a few features out of a library of 512 possible features.\nCritically, the features activate directly after the convolution layers, so that morphological features are localized in pixel space." + "orig": "Image: 17-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf", + "text": "Image: 17-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf" }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/27", @@ -847,10 +729,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "caption", "prov": [], - "orig": "The resnet18 backbone of the model is initialized to ImageNet-pretrained weights", - "text": "The resnet18 backbone of the model is initialized to ImageNet-pretrained weights" + "orig": "Image: 138-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf", + "text": "Image: 138-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf" }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/28", @@ -859,10 +741,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", + "label": "caption", "prov": [], - "orig": "[5206848], and we update model parameters by minimizing the root mean squared error. We randomly designate 20% of objects for validation, and train on the remainder. Random flips are applied for data augmentation. We train for 20 epochs using the ranger optimizer [wright2021ranger21synergisticdeeplearning] and an initial learning rate of 0.1 with a flat+cosine annealing schedule. All code and the trained models presented here can be found in our public Github repository: https://github.com/jwuphysics/sparse-feature-networks.", - "text": "[5206848], and we update model parameters by minimizing the root mean squared error. We randomly designate 20% of objects for validation, and train on the remainder. Random flips are applied for data augmentation. We train for 20 epochs using the ranger optimizer [wright2021ranger21synergisticdeeplearning] and an initial learning rate of 0.1 with a flat+cosine annealing schedule. All code and the trained models presented here can be found in our public Github repository: https://github.com/jwuphysics/sparse-feature-networks." + "orig": "Image: 157-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf", + "text": "Image: 157-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf" }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/29", @@ -871,23 +753,22 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "section_header", + "label": "caption", "prov": [], - "orig": "Results", - "text": "Results", - "level": 1 + "orig": "Image: 322-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf", + "text": "Image: 322-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf" }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/30", "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" + "$ref": "#/groups/1" }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "Motivated by previous works that connect galaxy imaging with their physical properties", - "text": "Motivated by previous works that connect galaxy imaging with their physical properties" + "orig": "SFNet learned features when trained to predict optical emission lines. We show how each feature correlates with optical line ratios (BPT diagrams; left) and examples of the top nine image activations (right). For the BPT diagrams, colors denote scaled activation strength, ranging from black (zero) to dark magenta (low) to bright yellow (high).", + "text": "SFNet learned features when trained to predict optical emission lines. We show how each feature correlates with optical line ratios (BPT diagrams; left) and examples of the top nine image activations (right). For the BPT diagrams, colors denote scaled activation strength, ranging from black (zero) to dark magenta (low) to bright yellow (high)." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/31", @@ -898,8 +779,8 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[2019MNRAS.484.4683W,2020arXiv200912318W,2021MNRAS.506.3313G,2021ApJ...914..142H], we train the SFNet to predict spectroscopic line fluxes (Section[ssec:ionization]) and gas-phase metallicity ([ssec:metallicity]) directly from image cutouts.\nWe identify the learned features using their sparse activation index, e.g., SL17 for the 17th feature of a SFNet trained to predict spectral lines fluxes, or Z256 for the 256th feature of a SFNet trained to predict gas-phase metallicity. Feature activations are scaled between 0 and 1, and we refer to these example activation strengths as $A_{\\tt SL\\,17}$ and $A_{\\tt Z\\,256}$, respectively.", - "text": "[2019MNRAS.484.4683W,2020arXiv200912318W,2021MNRAS.506.3313G,2021ApJ...914..142H], we train the SFNet to predict spectroscopic line fluxes (Section[ssec:ionization]) and gas-phase metallicity ([ssec:metallicity]) directly from image cutouts.\nWe identify the learned features using their sparse activation index, e.g., SL17 for the 17th feature of a SFNet trained to predict spectral lines fluxes, or Z256 for the 256th feature of a SFNet trained to predict gas-phase metallicity. Feature activations are scaled between 0 and 1, and we refer to these example activation strengths as $A_{\\tt SL\\,17}$ and $A_{\\tt Z\\,256}$, respectively." + "orig": "lcll[t!]\n4", + "text": "lcll[t!]\n4" }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/32", @@ -908,11 +789,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "section_header", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "Emission line fluxes", - "text": "Emission line fluxes", - "level": 2 + "orig": "Image features learned by a SFNet to independently predict optical spectral line fluxes and metallicity. We only show features that are most frequently activated.", + "text": "Image features learned by a SFNet to independently predict optical spectral line fluxes and metallicity. We only show features that are most frequently activated." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/33", @@ -921,10 +801,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "We train a SFNet to predict the spectral line fluxes for [", - "text": "We train a SFNet to predict the spectral line fluxes for [" + "orig": "Feature \n $f_{\\rm activated}$ \n Morphology \n Physical interpretation\nSL17 62.9% very blue, compact or merging extreme star formation, hard ionizing radiation \nSL138 87.0% low surface brightness, face-on low gas density, soft ionizing radiation \nSL157 95.8% red, elliptical old stellar populations, high mass, high metallicity \nSL322 62.9% blue, irregular low mass, low metallicity, star-forming \nZ61 99.6% red, face-on, bright core high metallicity \nZ256 87.9% blue, edge-on disks low metallicity", + "text": "Feature \n $f_{\\rm activated}$ \n Morphology \n Physical interpretation\nSL17 62.9% very blue, compact or merging extreme star formation, hard ionizing radiation \nSL138 87.0% low surface brightness, face-on low gas density, soft ionizing radiation \nSL157 95.8% red, elliptical old stellar populations, high mass, high metallicity \nSL322 62.9% blue, irregular low mass, low metallicity, star-forming \nZ61 99.6% red, face-on, bright core high metallicity \nZ256 87.9% blue, edge-on disks low metallicity" }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/34", @@ -933,10 +813,11 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", + "label": "section_header", "prov": [], - "orig": "N2], H$\\alpha$, [O3], and H$\\beta$. These lines can diagnose a galaxy's global ionization state; for example, the line ratios [N2]/H$\\alpha$ against [O3]/H$\\beta$ comprise the BPT diagram [1981PASP...93....5B], which is commonly used to differentiate activate galactic nuclei (AGN) from star-forming galaxies. Other physical processes can also affect these line strengths, including stellar evolution/age, AGN, gas metallicity, gas physical state, and dust attenuation.", - "text": "N2], H$\\alpha$, [O3], and H$\\beta$. These lines can diagnose a galaxy's global ionization state; for example, the line ratios [N2]/H$\\alpha$ against [O3]/H$\\beta$ comprise the BPT diagram [1981PASP...93....5B], which is commonly used to differentiate activate galactic nuclei (AGN) from star-forming galaxies. Other physical processes can also affect these line strengths, including stellar evolution/age, AGN, gas metallicity, gas physical state, and dust attenuation." + "orig": "Gas metallicity", + "text": "Gas metallicity", + "level": 2 }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/35", @@ -945,10 +826,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "The eight most frequently activated features explain 99.99", - "text": "The eight most frequently activated features explain 99.99" + "orig": "We separately train a SFNet to predict the gas-phase metallicity, $Z_{\\rm gas} = 12 + $log(O/H), directly from images. We remove all objects with invalid estimates for metallicity, stellar mass, and star formation rate, leaving 117,223 galaxies from the SDSS Main Galaxy Sample. The scatter of metallicity is $0.207$dex, and our trained SFNet can predict it to within $0.087$dex using only two image features, Z61 and Z256, which are activated 99.6% and 87.9% of the time respectively. If we also incorporate the third and fourth most frequent activations (40.2% and 11.9%, respectively), then we can achieve $0.086$dex error. This level of performance suggests that our SFNet is extremely accurate (see Section[ssec:performance-interpretability]for further discussion).", + "text": "We separately train a SFNet to predict the gas-phase metallicity, $Z_{\\rm gas} = 12 + $log(O/H), directly from images. We remove all objects with invalid estimates for metallicity, stellar mass, and star formation rate, leaving 117,223 galaxies from the SDSS Main Galaxy Sample. The scatter of metallicity is $0.207$dex, and our trained SFNet can predict it to within $0.087$dex using only two image features, Z61 and Z256, which are activated 99.6% and 87.9% of the time respectively. If we also incorporate the third and fourth most frequent activations (40.2% and 11.9%, respectively), then we can achieve $0.086$dex error. This level of performance suggests that our SFNet is extremely accurate (see Section[ssec:performance-interpretability]for further discussion)." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/36", @@ -959,8 +840,8 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "% of the variance in the dataset, but there is significant correlation between them. The four most frequently activated features can still explain 91.6% of the variance; therefore, we restrict our investigation to these top four activations that correspond to features SL17, SL138, SL157, and SL322.", - "text": "% of the variance in the dataset, but there is significant correlation between them. The four most frequently activated features can still explain 91.6% of the variance; therefore, we restrict our investigation to these top four activations that correspond to features SL17, SL138, SL157, and SL322." + "orig": "In the bottom two rows of Table[tab:features], we describe the two main features used to predict metallicity. Z61 is associated with galaxies with prominent red bulges and is linked to higher metallicity. It activates strongly for red ellipticals or face-on disk galaxies (often with two loosely wound spiral arms; see, e.g., 2019MNRAS.487.1808M for more on the correlations between galaxy properties and spiral arm pitch angle). Feature Z256 is associated with blue, edge-on disk galaxies and lower metallicity. \n[2004ApJ...613..898T] noted that metal-poor galaxies tended to have highly inclined disk morphologies, and attributed this effect to observational bias. SDSS spectroscopic fibers collect light from lower-$Z_{\\rm gas}$outskirts of disk galaxies observed edge-on, but would miss those regions for the same galaxies observed face-on. Our SFNet now captures this same observational bias, affecting the library of morphological features that it learns.", + "text": "In the bottom two rows of Table[tab:features], we describe the two main features used to predict metallicity. Z61 is associated with galaxies with prominent red bulges and is linked to higher metallicity. It activates strongly for red ellipticals or face-on disk galaxies (often with two loosely wound spiral arms; see, e.g., 2019MNRAS.487.1808M for more on the correlations between galaxy properties and spiral arm pitch angle). Feature Z256 is associated with blue, edge-on disk galaxies and lower metallicity. \n[2004ApJ...613..898T] noted that metal-poor galaxies tended to have highly inclined disk morphologies, and attributed this effect to observational bias. SDSS spectroscopic fibers collect light from lower-$Z_{\\rm gas}$outskirts of disk galaxies observed edge-on, but would miss those regions for the same galaxies observed face-on. Our SFNet now captures this same observational bias, affecting the library of morphological features that it learns." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/37", @@ -969,10 +850,11 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "section_header", "prov": [], - "orig": "In Figure", - "text": "In Figure" + "orig": "Discussion", + "text": "Discussion", + "level": 1 }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/38", @@ -981,10 +863,11 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", + "label": "section_header", "prov": [], - "orig": "[fig:bpt-interpretation], we show galaxy image examples for the strongest activations, and where they appear in a BPT diagram. The four features reside in overlapping regions of the [O3]/H$\\beta$ versus [N2]/H$\\alpha$ space, but they all peak in distinct locations. For example, the locus of points for SL17 appear to be at higher [N2]/H$\\alpha$ and [O3]/H$\\beta$, indicating harder ionizing radiation and higher gas density [2019ARAA..57..511K]. Meanwhile, the opposite appears to be true for SL138 (or at least, for non-AGN with high $A_{\\tt SL\\,138}$). Additional features contain information about metallicity and stellar populations. In Table[tab:features], we offer physical interpretations for these features.", - "text": "[fig:bpt-interpretation], we show galaxy image examples for the strongest activations, and where they appear in a BPT diagram. The four features reside in overlapping regions of the [O3]/H$\\beta$ versus [N2]/H$\\alpha$ space, but they all peak in distinct locations. For example, the locus of points for SL17 appear to be at higher [N2]/H$\\alpha$ and [O3]/H$\\beta$, indicating harder ionizing radiation and higher gas density [2019ARAA..57..511K]. Meanwhile, the opposite appears to be true for SL138 (or at least, for non-AGN with high $A_{\\tt SL\\,138}$). Additional features contain information about metallicity and stellar populations. In Table[tab:features], we offer physical interpretations for these features." + "orig": "Physical laws from galaxy images", + "text": "Physical laws from galaxy images", + "level": 2 }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/39", @@ -993,10 +876,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "caption", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "Image: 17-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf", - "text": "Image: 17-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf" + "orig": "Because the SFNet learns a linear projection from these activations to the final prediction, we can write down a simple equation between learned galaxy features and the physical quantity of interest. In Figure[fig:equations], we present linear equations for predicting gas metallicity and spectral line ratios by using the aforementioned galaxy image features.\nThe maximally activating galaxy examples are shown in the equations (each labeled by their activated feature index).", + "text": "Because the SFNet learns a linear projection from these activations to the final prediction, we can write down a simple equation between learned galaxy features and the physical quantity of interest. In Figure[fig:equations], we present linear equations for predicting gas metallicity and spectral line ratios by using the aforementioned galaxy image features.\nThe maximally activating galaxy examples are shown in the equations (each labeled by their activated feature index)." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/40", @@ -1007,20 +890,20 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "caption", "prov": [], - "orig": "Image: 138-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf", - "text": "Image: 138-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf" + "orig": "Image: equations.pdf", + "text": "Image: equations.pdf" }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/41", "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" + "$ref": "#/groups/2" }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "caption", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "Image: 157-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf", - "text": "Image: 157-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf" + "orig": "Linear relationships between galaxy properties and image features learned by the SFNet. We show how the gas metallicity, [N2]/H$\\alpha$, and [O3]/H$\\beta$ depend on SFNet feature activations, where SFNet features are represented using the top-activating galaxy image cutout from the validation set.", + "text": "Linear relationships between galaxy properties and image features learned by the SFNet. We show how the gas metallicity, [N2]/H$\\alpha$, and [O3]/H$\\beta$ depend on SFNet feature activations, where SFNet features are represented using the top-activating galaxy image cutout from the validation set." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/42", @@ -1029,22 +912,22 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "caption", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "Image: 322-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf", - "text": "Image: 322-bpt_scatter_examples_3x3.pdf" + "orig": "These linear relations are so simple that we can directly interpret them. The Z61 and Z256 features used to predict $Z_{\\rm gas}$ directly correspond to higher and lower metallicity. Interestingly, both can be activated at the same timeand in fact, both are non-zero for the majority of galaxies in the validation set, demonstrating the physical interplay between these morphological features and metallicity. For predicting spectral lines, features SL17 and SL157 positively correlate with both [N2]/H$\\alpha$ and [O3]/H$\\beta$; we might interpret these morphological features as indicators of spectral hardness and low ionization (nuclear) emission-line regions, respectively. Meanwhile, S322 correlates with [O3]/H$\\beta$ but anticorrelates with [N2]/H$\\alpha$, suggesting that it is associated with harder ionizing spectra.", + "text": "These linear relations are so simple that we can directly interpret them. The Z61 and Z256 features used to predict $Z_{\\rm gas}$ directly correspond to higher and lower metallicity. Interestingly, both can be activated at the same timeand in fact, both are non-zero for the majority of galaxies in the validation set, demonstrating the physical interplay between these morphological features and metallicity. For predicting spectral lines, features SL17 and SL157 positively correlate with both [N2]/H$\\alpha$ and [O3]/H$\\beta$; we might interpret these morphological features as indicators of spectral hardness and low ionization (nuclear) emission-line regions, respectively. Meanwhile, S322 correlates with [O3]/H$\\beta$ but anticorrelates with [N2]/H$\\alpha$, suggesting that it is associated with harder ionizing spectra." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/43", "parent": { - "$ref": "#/groups/1" + "$ref": "#/body" }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "SFNet learned features when trained to predict optical emission lines. We show how each feature correlates with optical line ratios (BPT diagrams; left) and examples of the top nine image activations (right). For the BPT diagrams, colors denote scaled activation strength, ranging from black (zero) to dark magenta (low) to bright yellow (high).", - "text": "SFNet learned features when trained to predict optical emission lines. We show how each feature correlates with optical line ratios (BPT diagrams; left) and examples of the top nine image activations (right). For the BPT diagrams, colors denote scaled activation strength, ranging from black (zero) to dark magenta (low) to bright yellow (high)." + "orig": "The model is only able to learn physical laws by leveraging galaxy morphology present within the optical image cutouts. However, galaxy evolution is governed by the complex interplay between multiple physical processes [2015ARAA..53...51S,2017MNRAS.471.2687B], which are not always imprinted in galaxy morphology, or perhaps not at the scales or wavelengths probed by our imaging surveys. Nonetheless, CNNs are surprisingly powerful at predicting the spectroscopic tracers of galaxy evolution. [2019AA...624A.102D] and [2019MNRAS.484.4683W] showed that galaxies' stellar masses can be estimated directly from image cutouts, and [2021MNRAS.501.4359Z] suggest that CNNs are sensitive to small-scale morphological perturbations due to dust in galaxies. Even information outside of the image cutout can be indirectly probed; [2020ApJ...900..142W] measure impact of galaxy environment on CNN-predicted gas properties, suggesting that the well-known density-morphology relation [1980ApJ...236..351D]can be implicitly learned via ML models.\nIn summary, SFNets can learn a limited (but still powerful) set of physical relationships that govern galaxy evolution.", + "text": "The model is only able to learn physical laws by leveraging galaxy morphology present within the optical image cutouts. However, galaxy evolution is governed by the complex interplay between multiple physical processes [2015ARAA..53...51S,2017MNRAS.471.2687B], which are not always imprinted in galaxy morphology, or perhaps not at the scales or wavelengths probed by our imaging surveys. Nonetheless, CNNs are surprisingly powerful at predicting the spectroscopic tracers of galaxy evolution. [2019AA...624A.102D] and [2019MNRAS.484.4683W] showed that galaxies' stellar masses can be estimated directly from image cutouts, and [2021MNRAS.501.4359Z] suggest that CNNs are sensitive to small-scale morphological perturbations due to dust in galaxies. Even information outside of the image cutout can be indirectly probed; [2020ApJ...900..142W] measure impact of galaxy environment on CNN-predicted gas properties, suggesting that the well-known density-morphology relation [1980ApJ...236..351D]can be implicitly learned via ML models.\nIn summary, SFNets can learn a limited (but still powerful) set of physical relationships that govern galaxy evolution." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/44", @@ -1053,10 +936,11 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", + "label": "section_header", "prov": [], - "orig": "lcll[t!]\n4", - "text": "lcll[t!]\n4" + "orig": "Performance versus interpretability", + "text": "Performance versus interpretability", + "level": 2 }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/45", @@ -1067,8 +951,8 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "Image features learned by a SFNet to independently predict optical spectral line fluxes and metallicity. We only show features that are most frequently activated.", - "text": "Image features learned by a SFNet to independently predict optical spectral line fluxes and metallicity. We only show features that are most frequently activated." + "orig": "Previous works have found that a CNN trained on optical image cutouts can successfully classify AGN from star-forming galaxies with an accuracy [2021ApJ...914..142H,2022arXiv221207881G,Doorenbos+2024]. We test how well the interpretable SFNet from Section[ssec:ionization] can also identify AGN. By optimizing a linear support vector machine (SVM) classifier on SL17, SL138, SL157, and SL322 from the training dataset, we can classify AGN with a validation accuracy of 0.85 and F1 score of 0.72.", + "text": "Previous works have found that a CNN trained on optical image cutouts can successfully classify AGN from star-forming galaxies with an accuracy [2021ApJ...914..142H,2022arXiv221207881G,Doorenbos+2024]. We test how well the interpretable SFNet from Section[ssec:ionization] can also identify AGN. By optimizing a linear support vector machine (SVM) classifier on SL17, SL138, SL157, and SL322 from the training dataset, we can classify AGN with a validation accuracy of 0.85 and F1 score of 0.72." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/46", @@ -1077,10 +961,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", + "label": "footnote", "prov": [], - "orig": "Feature \n $f_{\\rm activated}$ \n Morphology \n Physical interpretation\nSL17 62.9% very blue, compact or merging extreme star formation, hard ionizing radiation \nSL138 87.0% low surface brightness, face-on low gas density, soft ionizing radiation \nSL157 95.8% red, elliptical old stellar populations, high mass, high metallicity \nSL322 62.9% blue, irregular low mass, low metallicity, star-forming \nZ61 99.6% red, face-on, bright core high metallicity \nZ256 87.9% blue, edge-on disks low metallicity", - "text": "Feature \n $f_{\\rm activated}$ \n Morphology \n Physical interpretation\nSL17 62.9% very blue, compact or merging extreme star formation, hard ionizing radiation \nSL138 87.0% low surface brightness, face-on low gas density, soft ionizing radiation \nSL157 95.8% red, elliptical old stellar populations, high mass, high metallicity \nSL322 62.9% blue, irregular low mass, low metallicity, star-forming \nZ61 99.6% red, face-on, bright core high metallicity \nZ256 87.9% blue, edge-on disks low metallicity" + "orig": "If we use all non-zero SFNet features, then the best-fit linear SVM validates at 0.83 accuracy and 0.70 F1 score, i.e., it performs worse. This suggests that restricting to the four most frequent feature activations reduces noiseanother benefit of sparsity.", + "text": "If we use all non-zero SFNet features, then the best-fit linear SVM validates at 0.83 accuracy and 0.70 F1 score, i.e., it performs worse. This suggests that restricting to the four most frequent feature activations reduces noiseanother benefit of sparsity." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/47", @@ -1089,11 +973,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "section_header", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "Gas metallicity", - "text": "Gas metallicity", - "level": 2 + "orig": "In comparison, the highly tuned CNN from [2022arXiv221207881G] achieves an accuracy of 0.89 and F1 score of 0.75, and the conditional diffusion model by [Doorenbos+2024] results in an accuracy of 0.82 and F1 score of 0.73 (although we note that they use a slightly different AGN classification scheme). Our experiments demonstrate that a linear combinationof our interpretable features can distinguish AGN from star-forming galaxies at a level comparable to state-of-the-art ML algorithms.", + "text": "In comparison, the highly tuned CNN from [2022arXiv221207881G] achieves an accuracy of 0.89 and F1 score of 0.75, and the conditional diffusion model by [Doorenbos+2024] results in an accuracy of 0.82 and F1 score of 0.73 (although we note that they use a slightly different AGN classification scheme). Our experiments demonstrate that a linear combinationof our interpretable features can distinguish AGN from star-forming galaxies at a level comparable to state-of-the-art ML algorithms." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/48", @@ -1102,10 +985,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "We separately train a SFNet to predict the gas-phase metallicity,", - "text": "We separately train a SFNet to predict the gas-phase metallicity," + "orig": "In Section[ssec:metallicity], we estimate gas metallicity to within 0.087dex using a linear combination of two features (and 0.086dex using four features).\nFor comparison, a typical CNN only achieves $0.085$dex error [2019MNRAS.484.4683W]; note that the systematic scatter is $\\sim 0.03$dex. Again, this suggests that SFNets do not sacrifice performance in order to gain interpretability.", + "text": "In Section[ssec:metallicity], we estimate gas metallicity to within 0.087dex using a linear combination of two features (and 0.086dex using four features).\nFor comparison, a typical CNN only achieves $0.085$dex error [2019MNRAS.484.4683W]; note that the systematic scatter is $\\sim 0.03$dex. Again, this suggests that SFNets do not sacrifice performance in order to gain interpretability." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/49", @@ -1114,269 +997,14 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", - "prov": [], - "orig": "$Z_{\\rm gas} = 12 + $log(O/H), directly from images. We remove all objects with invalid estimates for metallicity, stellar mass, and star formation rate, leaving 117,223 galaxies from the SDSS Main Galaxy Sample. The scatter of metallicity is $0.207$dex, and our trained SFNet can predict it to within $0.087$dex using only two image features, Z61 and Z256, which are activated 99.6% and 87.9% of the time respectively. If we also incorporate the third and fourth most frequent activations (40.2% and 11.9%, respectively), then we can achieve $0.086$dex error. This level of performance suggests that our SFNet is extremely accurate (see Section[ssec:performance-interpretability]for further discussion).", - "text": "$Z_{\\rm gas} = 12 + $log(O/H), directly from images. We remove all objects with invalid estimates for metallicity, stellar mass, and star formation rate, leaving 117,223 galaxies from the SDSS Main Galaxy Sample. The scatter of metallicity is $0.207$dex, and our trained SFNet can predict it to within $0.087$dex using only two image features, Z61 and Z256, which are activated 99.6% and 87.9% of the time respectively. If we also incorporate the third and fourth most frequent activations (40.2% and 11.9%, respectively), then we can achieve $0.086$dex error. This level of performance suggests that our SFNet is extremely accurate (see Section[ssec:performance-interpretability]for further discussion)." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/50", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "In the bottom two rows of Table", - "text": "In the bottom two rows of Table" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/51", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", - "prov": [], - "orig": "[tab:features], we describe the two main features used to predict metallicity. Z61 is associated with galaxies with prominent red bulges and is linked to higher metallicity. It activates strongly for red ellipticals or face-on disk galaxies (often with two loosely wound spiral arms; see, e.g., 2019MNRAS.487.1808M for more on the correlations between galaxy properties and spiral arm pitch angle). Feature Z256 is associated with blue, edge-on disk galaxies and lower metallicity. \n[2004ApJ...613..898T] noted that metal-poor galaxies tended to have highly inclined disk morphologies, and attributed this effect to observational bias. SDSS spectroscopic fibers collect light from lower-$Z_{\\rm gas}$outskirts of disk galaxies observed edge-on, but would miss those regions for the same galaxies observed face-on. Our SFNet now captures this same observational bias, affecting the library of morphological features that it learns.", - "text": "[tab:features], we describe the two main features used to predict metallicity. Z61 is associated with galaxies with prominent red bulges and is linked to higher metallicity. It activates strongly for red ellipticals or face-on disk galaxies (often with two loosely wound spiral arms; see, e.g., 2019MNRAS.487.1808M for more on the correlations between galaxy properties and spiral arm pitch angle). Feature Z256 is associated with blue, edge-on disk galaxies and lower metallicity. \n[2004ApJ...613..898T] noted that metal-poor galaxies tended to have highly inclined disk morphologies, and attributed this effect to observational bias. SDSS spectroscopic fibers collect light from lower-$Z_{\\rm gas}$outskirts of disk galaxies observed edge-on, but would miss those regions for the same galaxies observed face-on. Our SFNet now captures this same observational bias, affecting the library of morphological features that it learns." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/52", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "section_header", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Discussion", - "text": "Discussion", - "level": 1 - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/53", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "section_header", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Physical laws from galaxy images", - "text": "Physical laws from galaxy images", - "level": 2 - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/54", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Because the SFNet learns a linear projection from these activations to the final prediction, we can write down a simple", - "text": "Because the SFNet learns a linear projection from these activations to the final prediction, we can write down a simple" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/55", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", - "prov": [], - "orig": "equation between learned galaxy features and the physical quantity of interest. In Figure[fig:equations], we present linear equations for predicting gas metallicity and spectral line ratios by using the aforementioned galaxy image features.\nThe maximally activating galaxy examples are shown in the equations (each labeled by their activated feature index).", - "text": "equation between learned galaxy features and the physical quantity of interest. In Figure[fig:equations], we present linear equations for predicting gas metallicity and spectral line ratios by using the aforementioned galaxy image features.\nThe maximally activating galaxy examples are shown in the equations (each labeled by their activated feature index)." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/56", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "caption", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Image: equations.pdf", - "text": "Image: equations.pdf" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/57", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/groups/2" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Linear relationships between galaxy properties and image features learned by the SFNet. We show how the gas metallicity, [N2]/H$\\alpha$, and [O3]/H$\\beta$ depend on SFNet feature activations, where SFNet features are represented using the top-activating galaxy image cutout from the validation set.", - "text": "Linear relationships between galaxy properties and image features learned by the SFNet. We show how the gas metallicity, [N2]/H$\\alpha$, and [O3]/H$\\beta$ depend on SFNet feature activations, where SFNet features are represented using the top-activating galaxy image cutout from the validation set." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/58", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "These linear relations are so simple that we can directly interpret them. The", - "text": "These linear relations are so simple that we can directly interpret them. The" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/59", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Z61 and Z256 features used to predict $Z_{\\rm gas}$ directly correspond to higher and lower metallicity. Interestingly, both can be activated at the same timeand in fact, both are non-zero for the majority of galaxies in the validation set, demonstrating the physical interplay between these morphological features and metallicity. For predicting spectral lines, features SL17 and SL157 positively correlate with both [N2]/H$\\alpha$ and [O3]/H$\\beta$; we might interpret these morphological features as indicators of spectral hardness and low ionization (nuclear) emission-line regions, respectively. Meanwhile, S322 correlates with [O3]/H$\\beta$ but anticorrelates with [N2]/H$\\alpha$, suggesting that it is associated with harder ionizing spectra.", - "text": "Z61 and Z256 features used to predict $Z_{\\rm gas}$ directly correspond to higher and lower metallicity. Interestingly, both can be activated at the same timeand in fact, both are non-zero for the majority of galaxies in the validation set, demonstrating the physical interplay between these morphological features and metallicity. For predicting spectral lines, features SL17 and SL157 positively correlate with both [N2]/H$\\alpha$ and [O3]/H$\\beta$; we might interpret these morphological features as indicators of spectral hardness and low ionization (nuclear) emission-line regions, respectively. Meanwhile, S322 correlates with [O3]/H$\\beta$ but anticorrelates with [N2]/H$\\alpha$, suggesting that it is associated with harder ionizing spectra." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/60", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "The model is only able to learn physical laws by leveraging galaxy morphology present within the optical image cutouts. However, galaxy evolution is governed by the complex interplay between multiple physical processes", - "text": "The model is only able to learn physical laws by leveraging galaxy morphology present within the optical image cutouts. However, galaxy evolution is governed by the complex interplay between multiple physical processes" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/61", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", - "prov": [], - "orig": "[2015ARAA..53...51S,2017MNRAS.471.2687B], which are not always imprinted in galaxy morphology, or perhaps not at the scales or wavelengths probed by our imaging surveys. Nonetheless, CNNs are surprisingly powerful at predicting the spectroscopic tracers of galaxy evolution. [2019AA...624A.102D] and [2019MNRAS.484.4683W] showed that galaxies' stellar masses can be estimated directly from image cutouts, and [2021MNRAS.501.4359Z] suggest that CNNs are sensitive to small-scale morphological perturbations due to dust in galaxies. Even information outside of the image cutout can be indirectly probed; [2020ApJ...900..142W] measure impact of galaxy environment on CNN-predicted gas properties, suggesting that the well-known density-morphology relation [1980ApJ...236..351D]can be implicitly learned via ML models.\nIn summary, SFNets can learn a limited (but still powerful) set of physical relationships that govern galaxy evolution.", - "text": "[2015ARAA..53...51S,2017MNRAS.471.2687B], which are not always imprinted in galaxy morphology, or perhaps not at the scales or wavelengths probed by our imaging surveys. Nonetheless, CNNs are surprisingly powerful at predicting the spectroscopic tracers of galaxy evolution. [2019AA...624A.102D] and [2019MNRAS.484.4683W] showed that galaxies' stellar masses can be estimated directly from image cutouts, and [2021MNRAS.501.4359Z] suggest that CNNs are sensitive to small-scale morphological perturbations due to dust in galaxies. Even information outside of the image cutout can be indirectly probed; [2020ApJ...900..142W] measure impact of galaxy environment on CNN-predicted gas properties, suggesting that the well-known density-morphology relation [1980ApJ...236..351D]can be implicitly learned via ML models.\nIn summary, SFNets can learn a limited (but still powerful) set of physical relationships that govern galaxy evolution." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/62", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "section_header", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Performance versus interpretability", - "text": "Performance versus interpretability", - "level": 2 - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/63", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Previous works have found that a CNN trained on optical image cutouts can successfully classify AGN from star-forming galaxies with an accuracy", - "text": "Previous works have found that a CNN trained on optical image cutouts can successfully classify AGN from star-forming galaxies with an accuracy" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/64", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", - "prov": [], - "orig": "[2021ApJ...914..142H,2022arXiv221207881G,Doorenbos+2024]. We test how well the interpretable SFNet from Section[ssec:ionization] can also identify AGN. By optimizing a linear support vector machine (SVM) classifier on SL17, SL138, SL157, and SL322 from the training dataset, we can classify AGN with a validation accuracy of 0.85 and F1 score of 0.72.", - "text": "[2021ApJ...914..142H,2022arXiv221207881G,Doorenbos+2024]. We test how well the interpretable SFNet from Section[ssec:ionization] can also identify AGN. By optimizing a linear support vector machine (SVM) classifier on SL17, SL138, SL157, and SL322 from the training dataset, we can classify AGN with a validation accuracy of 0.85 and F1 score of 0.72." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/65", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "footnote", - "prov": [], - "orig": "If we use all non-zero SFNet features, then the best-fit linear SVM validates at 0.83 accuracy and 0.70 F1 score, i.e., it performs worse. This suggests that restricting to the four most frequent feature activations reduces noiseanother benefit of sparsity.", - "text": "If we use all non-zero SFNet features, then the best-fit linear SVM validates at 0.83 accuracy and 0.70 F1 score, i.e., it performs worse. This suggests that restricting to the four most frequent feature activations reduces noiseanother benefit of sparsity." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/66", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", - "prov": [], - "orig": "In comparison, the highly tuned CNN from [2022arXiv221207881G] achieves an accuracy of 0.89 and F1 score of 0.75, and the conditional diffusion model by [Doorenbos+2024] results in an accuracy of 0.82 and F1 score of 0.73 (although we note that they use a slightly different AGN classification scheme). Our experiments demonstrate that a linear combinationof our interpretable features can distinguish AGN from star-forming galaxies at a level comparable to state-of-the-art ML algorithms.", - "text": "In comparison, the highly tuned CNN from [2022arXiv221207881G] achieves an accuracy of 0.89 and F1 score of 0.75, and the conditional diffusion model by [Doorenbos+2024] results in an accuracy of 0.82 and F1 score of 0.73 (although we note that they use a slightly different AGN classification scheme). Our experiments demonstrate that a linear combinationof our interpretable features can distinguish AGN from star-forming galaxies at a level comparable to state-of-the-art ML algorithms." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/67", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "In Section", - "text": "In Section" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/68", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", - "prov": [], - "orig": "[ssec:metallicity], we estimate gas metallicity to within 0.087dex using a linear combination of two features (and 0.086dex using four features).\nFor comparison, a typical CNN only achieves $0.085$dex error [2019MNRAS.484.4683W]; note that the systematic scatter is $\\sim 0.03$dex. Again, this suggests that SFNets do not sacrifice performance in order to gain interpretability.", - "text": "[ssec:metallicity], we estimate gas metallicity to within 0.087dex using a linear combination of two features (and 0.086dex using four features).\nFor comparison, a typical CNN only achieves $0.085$dex error [2019MNRAS.484.4683W]; note that the systematic scatter is $\\sim 0.03$dex. Again, this suggests that SFNets do not sacrifice performance in order to gain interpretability." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/69", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "section_header", + "label": "section_header", "prov": [], "orig": "Comparison to PCA", "text": "Comparison to PCA", "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/70", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "While the SFNet produces interpretable features by imposing a sparsity constraint during the training process, other techniques are frequently used to reduce the number of learned features.\nHere we compare SFNet features against another common approach: dimensionality reduction of learned model features via principal components analysis (PCA). \nGiven feature activations in the penultimate layer of a regularly trained CNN, we can obtain the principal components by computing eigenvectors of the dense activation's covariance matrix. They are listed in descending order of how much variance is accounted for by each principal component (i.e., ordered by descending eigenvalues).\nBy selecting the top", - "text": "While the SFNet produces interpretable features by imposing a sparsity constraint during the training process, other techniques are frequently used to reduce the number of learned features.\nHere we compare SFNet features against another common approach: dimensionality reduction of learned model features via principal components analysis (PCA). \nGiven feature activations in the penultimate layer of a regularly trained CNN, we can obtain the principal components by computing eigenvectors of the dense activation's covariance matrix. They are listed in descending order of how much variance is accounted for by each principal component (i.e., ordered by descending eigenvalues).\nBy selecting the top" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/71", + "self_ref": "#/texts/50", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1384,11 +1012,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "$k$principal components, we can project dense feature activations into a smaller space of sparse activations.", - "text": "$k$principal components, we can project dense feature activations into a smaller space of sparse activations." + "orig": "While the SFNet produces interpretable features by imposing a sparsity constraint during the training process, other techniques are frequently used to reduce the number of learned features.\nHere we compare SFNet features against another common approach: dimensionality reduction of learned model features via principal components analysis (PCA). \nGiven feature activations in the penultimate layer of a regularly trained CNN, we can obtain the principal components by computing eigenvectors of the dense activation's covariance matrix. They are listed in descending order of how much variance is accounted for by each principal component (i.e., ordered by descending eigenvalues).\nBy selecting the top $k$principal components, we can project dense feature activations into a smaller space of sparse activations.", + "text": "While the SFNet produces interpretable features by imposing a sparsity constraint during the training process, other techniques are frequently used to reduce the number of learned features.\nHere we compare SFNet features against another common approach: dimensionality reduction of learned model features via principal components analysis (PCA). \nGiven feature activations in the penultimate layer of a regularly trained CNN, we can obtain the principal components by computing eigenvectors of the dense activation's covariance matrix. They are listed in descending order of how much variance is accounted for by each principal component (i.e., ordered by descending eigenvalues).\nBy selecting the top $k$principal components, we can project dense feature activations into a smaller space of sparse activations." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/72", + "self_ref": "#/texts/51", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1400,7 +1028,7 @@ "text": "Image: pca-comparison.pdf" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/73", + "self_ref": "#/texts/52", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/3" }, @@ -1412,19 +1040,7 @@ "text": "SFNet comparison against a CNN with dimensionality-reduced features. Using the SFNet model (blue) and a dense CNN with top principal components as features (red), we report RMSE values (lower is better) for models trained to predict metallicity (left) and spectral line fluxes (right) for several values of $k$ (i.e., sparsity or number of PCA components)." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/74", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "We test whether this smaller set of principal components are as robust as the SFNet features.\nWe train a multivariate linear regression model using the first", - "text": "We test whether this smaller set of principal components are as robust as the SFNet features.\nWe train a multivariate linear regression model using the first" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/75", + "self_ref": "#/texts/53", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1432,11 +1048,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "$k$ principal components from dense CNN activations as features, again using the same training and validation split, to predict both the metallicity and spectral line strengths.\nFor comparison, we have also re-trained the SFNet using $k \\in \\{2, 3, 4, 6, 8\\}$. We independently re-train the SFNet three times in order to estimate the mean and standard error on the prediction RMSE.", - "text": "$k$ principal components from dense CNN activations as features, again using the same training and validation split, to predict both the metallicity and spectral line strengths.\nFor comparison, we have also re-trained the SFNet using $k \\in \\{2, 3, 4, 6, 8\\}$. We independently re-train the SFNet three times in order to estimate the mean and standard error on the prediction RMSE." + "orig": "We test whether this smaller set of principal components are as robust as the SFNet features.\nWe train a multivariate linear regression model using the first $k$ principal components from dense CNN activations as features, again using the same training and validation split, to predict both the metallicity and spectral line strengths.\nFor comparison, we have also re-trained the SFNet using $k \\in \\{2, 3, 4, 6, 8\\}$. We independently re-train the SFNet three times in order to estimate the mean and standard error on the prediction RMSE.", + "text": "We test whether this smaller set of principal components are as robust as the SFNet features.\nWe train a multivariate linear regression model using the first $k$ principal components from dense CNN activations as features, again using the same training and validation split, to predict both the metallicity and spectral line strengths.\nFor comparison, we have also re-trained the SFNet using $k \\in \\{2, 3, 4, 6, 8\\}$. We independently re-train the SFNet three times in order to estimate the mean and standard error on the prediction RMSE." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/76", + "self_ref": "#/texts/54", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1448,7 +1064,7 @@ "text": "We use the same training/validation split and re-initialize the model each time for each value of $k$. Because we repeat the training process from scratch, the RMSE values presented in this section slightly differ from the ones reported in Section\\ref{sec:results}." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/77", + "self_ref": "#/texts/55", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1460,7 +1076,7 @@ "text": "The results are shown in Figure[fig:pca-comparison], and specific RMSE values are given in Table[tab:dimred]." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/78", + "self_ref": "#/texts/56", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1472,7 +1088,7 @@ "text": "l cc cc[t!]\n5" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/79", + "self_ref": "#/texts/57", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1484,7 +1100,7 @@ "text": "Comparison of performance using a SFNet and a CNN with PCA-based dimensionality reduction." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/80", + "self_ref": "#/texts/58", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1496,19 +1112,7 @@ "text": "2cRMSE: Metallicity \n 2cRMSE: Spectral Lines\n \n \n (lr)2-3(lr)4-5 \n $k$ \n SFNet \n PCA \n SFNet \n PCA\n2 $0.0858 \\pm 0.0004$ 0.1753 $0.2418 \\pm 0.0002$ 0.2806 \n3 $0.0862 \\pm 0.0011$ 0.2032 $0.2395 \\pm 0.0014$ 0.2646 \n4 $0.0862 \\pm 0.0013$ 0.1034 $0.2383 \\pm 0.0003$ 0.2646 \n6 $0.0875 \\pm 0.0007$ 0.1020 $0.2394 \\pm 0.0009$ 0.2419 \n8 $0.0852 \\pm 0.0004$ 0.0921 $0.2389 \\pm 0.0012$ 0.2396" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/81", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "For both metallicity and spectral line fluxes,", - "text": "For both metallicity and spectral line fluxes," - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/82", + "self_ref": "#/texts/59", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1516,11 +1120,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "$>95\\%$ of the variance is explained using the top $k=8$ principal components.\nFor metallicity (left panel of Figure[fig:pca-comparison]), we find that the CNN + PCA performs poorly on the validation set for all values of $k$. Meanwhile, the SFNet can reconstruct metallicity with only $k=2$ explainable features, reinforcing our results found in Section[ssec:metallicity]. \nWe interpret this as evidence that the metallicity cannot be linearly combined using a small number of principal components of features extracted via a typical CNN.", - "text": "$>95\\%$ of the variance is explained using the top $k=8$ principal components.\nFor metallicity (left panel of Figure[fig:pca-comparison]), we find that the CNN + PCA performs poorly on the validation set for all values of $k$. Meanwhile, the SFNet can reconstruct metallicity with only $k=2$ explainable features, reinforcing our results found in Section[ssec:metallicity]. \nWe interpret this as evidence that the metallicity cannot be linearly combined using a small number of principal components of features extracted via a typical CNN." + "orig": "For both metallicity and spectral line fluxes, $>95\\%$ of the variance is explained using the top $k=8$ principal components.\nFor metallicity (left panel of Figure[fig:pca-comparison]), we find that the CNN + PCA performs poorly on the validation set for all values of $k$. Meanwhile, the SFNet can reconstruct metallicity with only $k=2$ explainable features, reinforcing our results found in Section[ssec:metallicity]. \nWe interpret this as evidence that the metallicity cannot be linearly combined using a small number of principal components of features extracted via a typical CNN.", + "text": "For both metallicity and spectral line fluxes, $>95\\%$ of the variance is explained using the top $k=8$ principal components.\nFor metallicity (left panel of Figure[fig:pca-comparison]), we find that the CNN + PCA performs poorly on the validation set for all values of $k$. Meanwhile, the SFNet can reconstruct metallicity with only $k=2$ explainable features, reinforcing our results found in Section[ssec:metallicity]. \nWe interpret this as evidence that the metallicity cannot be linearly combined using a small number of principal components of features extracted via a typical CNN." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/83", + "self_ref": "#/texts/60", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1532,7 +1136,7 @@ "text": "The non-monotonic decrease in RMSE with increasing $k$ suggests that PCAwhile able to reduce dimensionalitydoes not optimally distill morphological features into the ones most relevant for predicting galaxy properties." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/84", + "self_ref": "#/texts/61", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1544,19 +1148,7 @@ "text": "We turn our attention to spectral line fluxes (right panel of Figure[fig:pca-comparison]), and find that performance is poor for small values of $k$, but if we use 8 principal components, then the RMSE becomes comparable to that of the SFNet.\nThe SFNet can accurately estimate spectral line fluxes using only $k=4$ features (with significantly worse performance at $k=2$)." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/85", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Our experiment shows that we can reduce the dimensionality of CNN feature activations via PCA, but the ensuing principal components are not always robust features for recovering the training targets (e.g., for metallicity).\nThese difficulties may arise from superposition and polysemanticity, which cause the most important features to be entangled and spread across multiple CNN activations in highly non-linear ways.\nSince typical CNNs are not optimized with any sparsity constraint in mind, there is no guarantee that a linear combination of the learned features should be interpretable (although there are non-linear methods for finding optimal summary statistics; e.g.,", - "text": "Our experiment shows that we can reduce the dimensionality of CNN feature activations via PCA, but the ensuing principal components are not always robust features for recovering the training targets (e.g., for metallicity).\nThese difficulties may arise from superposition and polysemanticity, which cause the most important features to be entangled and spread across multiple CNN activations in highly non-linear ways.\nSince typical CNNs are not optimized with any sparsity constraint in mind, there is no guarantee that a linear combination of the learned features should be interpretable (although there are non-linear methods for finding optimal summary statistics; e.g.," - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/86", + "self_ref": "#/texts/62", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1564,11 +1156,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "Charnock_2018).\nBy forcing a CNN to be sparse during the training process, we find that SFNets can learn robust features and produce accurate predictions.", - "text": "Charnock_2018).\nBy forcing a CNN to be sparse during the training process, we find that SFNets can learn robust features and produce accurate predictions." + "orig": "Our experiment shows that we can reduce the dimensionality of CNN feature activations via PCA, but the ensuing principal components are not always robust features for recovering the training targets (e.g., for metallicity).\nThese difficulties may arise from superposition and polysemanticity, which cause the most important features to be entangled and spread across multiple CNN activations in highly non-linear ways.\nSince typical CNNs are not optimized with any sparsity constraint in mind, there is no guarantee that a linear combination of the learned features should be interpretable (although there are non-linear methods for finding optimal summary statistics; e.g., Charnock_2018).\nBy forcing a CNN to be sparse during the training process, we find that SFNets can learn robust features and produce accurate predictions.", + "text": "Our experiment shows that we can reduce the dimensionality of CNN feature activations via PCA, but the ensuing principal components are not always robust features for recovering the training targets (e.g., for metallicity).\nThese difficulties may arise from superposition and polysemanticity, which cause the most important features to be entangled and spread across multiple CNN activations in highly non-linear ways.\nSince typical CNNs are not optimized with any sparsity constraint in mind, there is no guarantee that a linear combination of the learned features should be interpretable (although there are non-linear methods for finding optimal summary statistics; e.g., Charnock_2018).\nBy forcing a CNN to be sparse during the training process, we find that SFNets can learn robust features and produce accurate predictions." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/87", + "self_ref": "#/texts/63", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1581,19 +1173,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/88", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Do regular CNNs also learn interpretable features?\nWe compare the SFNet against Zoobot, a CNN trained to classify GalaxyZoo morphologies", - "text": "Do regular CNNs also learn interpretable features?\nWe compare the SFNet against Zoobot, a CNN trained to classify GalaxyZoo morphologies" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/89", + "self_ref": "#/texts/64", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1601,23 +1181,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[2008MNRAS.389.1179L,2023JOSS....8.5312W,Walmsley+2024]. We consider the resnet18 variant of Zoobot, which has the same architecture as our SFNet modulo the top-$k$ sparsity constraint (Figure[fig:SFNet-architecture]). Zoobot predicts citizen scientist vote fractions for GalaxyZoo morphological labels. We hypothesize that Zoobot's 512-dimensional features directly after the pooling layer suffer from superposition and polysemanticity, and thereby produce an uninterpretable combination of morphology and color.", - "text": "[2008MNRAS.389.1179L,2023JOSS....8.5312W,Walmsley+2024]. We consider the resnet18 variant of Zoobot, which has the same architecture as our SFNet modulo the top-$k$ sparsity constraint (Figure[fig:SFNet-architecture]). Zoobot predicts citizen scientist vote fractions for GalaxyZoo morphological labels. We hypothesize that Zoobot's 512-dimensional features directly after the pooling layer suffer from superposition and polysemanticity, and thereby produce an uninterpretable combination of morphology and color." + "orig": "Do regular CNNs also learn interpretable features?\nWe compare the SFNet against Zoobot, a CNN trained to classify GalaxyZoo morphologies [2008MNRAS.389.1179L,2023JOSS....8.5312W,Walmsley+2024]. We consider the resnet18 variant of Zoobot, which has the same architecture as our SFNet modulo the top-$k$ sparsity constraint (Figure[fig:SFNet-architecture]). Zoobot predicts citizen scientist vote fractions for GalaxyZoo morphological labels. We hypothesize that Zoobot's 512-dimensional features directly after the pooling layer suffer from superposition and polysemanticity, and thereby produce an uninterpretable combination of morphology and color.", + "text": "Do regular CNNs also learn interpretable features?\nWe compare the SFNet against Zoobot, a CNN trained to classify GalaxyZoo morphologies [2008MNRAS.389.1179L,2023JOSS....8.5312W,Walmsley+2024]. We consider the resnet18 variant of Zoobot, which has the same architecture as our SFNet modulo the top-$k$ sparsity constraint (Figure[fig:SFNet-architecture]). Zoobot predicts citizen scientist vote fractions for GalaxyZoo morphological labels. We hypothesize that Zoobot's 512-dimensional features directly after the pooling layer suffer from superposition and polysemanticity, and thereby produce an uninterpretable combination of morphology and color." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/90", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Using morphological features from Zoobot, we train a regression model to predict galaxy metallicity. This experiment allows us to assess whether traditional CNNs can also be used to learn astrophysical relationships between image features and galaxy properties. We use the same training/validation datasets from Section", - "text": "Using morphological features from Zoobot, we train a regression model to predict galaxy metallicity. This experiment allows us to assess whether traditional CNNs can also be used to learn astrophysical relationships between image features and galaxy properties. We use the same training/validation datasets from Section" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/91", + "self_ref": "#/texts/65", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1625,23 +1193,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[ssec:metallicity], and independently test two models that use Zoobot-extracted features as inputs and $Z_{\\rm gas}$as training targets.", - "text": "[ssec:metallicity], and independently test two models that use Zoobot-extracted features as inputs and $Z_{\\rm gas}$as training targets." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/92", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "First, we fit a linear model to the training dataset, and find poor performance on the validation dataset (error of", - "text": "First, we fit a linear model to the training dataset, and find poor performance on the validation dataset (error of" + "orig": "Using morphological features from Zoobot, we train a regression model to predict galaxy metallicity. This experiment allows us to assess whether traditional CNNs can also be used to learn astrophysical relationships between image features and galaxy properties. We use the same training/validation datasets from Section[ssec:metallicity], and independently test two models that use Zoobot-extracted features as inputs and $Z_{\\rm gas}$as training targets.", + "text": "Using morphological features from Zoobot, we train a regression model to predict galaxy metallicity. This experiment allows us to assess whether traditional CNNs can also be used to learn astrophysical relationships between image features and galaxy properties. We use the same training/validation datasets from Section[ssec:metallicity], and independently test two models that use Zoobot-extracted features as inputs and $Z_{\\rm gas}$as training targets." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/93", + "self_ref": "#/texts/66", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1649,23 +1205,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "$0.183$dex). When we fit on the validation dataseti.e., if we attempt to memorize the answersthe error remains very high ($0.181$dex). This result demonstrates that no linear combination of Zoobot features can reconstruct galaxy metallicity.", - "text": "$0.183$dex). When we fit on the validation dataseti.e., if we attempt to memorize the answersthe error remains very high ($0.181$dex). This result demonstrates that no linear combination of Zoobot features can reconstruct galaxy metallicity." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/94", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Second, we fit an gradient-boosted decision tree (XGBoost) model to the training dataset, and achieve only", - "text": "Second, we fit an gradient-boosted decision tree (XGBoost) model to the training dataset, and achieve only" + "orig": "First, we fit a linear model to the training dataset, and find poor performance on the validation dataset (error of $0.183$dex). When we fit on the validation dataseti.e., if we attempt to memorize the answersthe error remains very high ($0.181$dex). This result demonstrates that no linear combination of Zoobot features can reconstruct galaxy metallicity.", + "text": "First, we fit a linear model to the training dataset, and find poor performance on the validation dataset (error of $0.183$dex). When we fit on the validation dataseti.e., if we attempt to memorize the answersthe error remains very high ($0.181$dex). This result demonstrates that no linear combination of Zoobot features can reconstruct galaxy metallicity." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/95", + "self_ref": "#/texts/67", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1673,23 +1217,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "$0.180$dex error on the validation dataset. However, when we cheat by fitting on the validation dataset, we can lower the error down to $0.085$dex (comparable to the SFNet performance).", - "text": "$0.180$dex error on the validation dataset. However, when we cheat by fitting on the validation dataset, we can lower the error down to $0.085$dex (comparable to the SFNet performance)." + "orig": "Second, we fit an gradient-boosted decision tree (XGBoost) model to the training dataset, and achieve only $0.180$dex error on the validation dataset. However, when we cheat by fitting on the validation dataset, we can lower the error down to $0.085$dex (comparable to the SFNet performance).", + "text": "Second, we fit an gradient-boosted decision tree (XGBoost) model to the training dataset, and achieve only $0.180$dex error on the validation dataset. However, when we cheat by fitting on the validation dataset, we can lower the error down to $0.085$dex (comparable to the SFNet performance)." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/96", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Our experiments confirm that the Zoobot features indeed contain enough information to memorize the validation set, but that these features (", - "text": "Our experiments confirm that the Zoobot features indeed contain enough information to memorize the validation set, but that these features (" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/97", + "self_ref": "#/texts/68", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1697,23 +1229,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "i) cannot be linearly combined to reconstruct galaxy metallicity, and (ii) cannot generalize across the random training/validation split. We surmise that regular CNN features are not interpretable. Meanwhile, our SFNet is both performant and interpretable.", - "text": "i) cannot be linearly combined to reconstruct galaxy metallicity, and (ii) cannot generalize across the random training/validation split. We surmise that regular CNN features are not interpretable. Meanwhile, our SFNet is both performant and interpretable." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/98", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Finally, we check whether the SFNet can capture information not found within the 512-dimensional Zoobot feature vector. We optimize a ridge regression model to predict SFNet feature values using the Zoobot features, finding", - "text": "Finally, we check whether the SFNet can capture information not found within the 512-dimensional Zoobot feature vector. We optimize a ridge regression model to predict SFNet feature values using the Zoobot features, finding" + "orig": "Our experiments confirm that the Zoobot features indeed contain enough information to memorize the validation set, but that these features (i) cannot be linearly combined to reconstruct galaxy metallicity, and (ii) cannot generalize across the random training/validation split. We surmise that regular CNN features are not interpretable. Meanwhile, our SFNet is both performant and interpretable.", + "text": "Our experiments confirm that the Zoobot features indeed contain enough information to memorize the validation set, but that these features (i) cannot be linearly combined to reconstruct galaxy metallicity, and (ii) cannot generalize across the random training/validation split. We surmise that regular CNN features are not interpretable. Meanwhile, our SFNet is both performant and interpretable." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/99", + "self_ref": "#/texts/69", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1721,11 +1241,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "$R^2$ values of $0.253$ and $0.107$ for the two primary SFNet features, Z61 and Z256, respectively. These low coefficients of determination suggest that our SFNet extracts different morphological features than Zoobot.", - "text": "$R^2$ values of $0.253$ and $0.107$ for the two primary SFNet features, Z61 and Z256, respectively. These low coefficients of determination suggest that our SFNet extracts different morphological features than Zoobot." + "orig": "Finally, we check whether the SFNet can capture information not found within the 512-dimensional Zoobot feature vector. We optimize a ridge regression model to predict SFNet feature values using the Zoobot features, finding $R^2$ values of $0.253$ and $0.107$ for the two primary SFNet features, Z61 and Z256, respectively. These low coefficients of determination suggest that our SFNet extracts different morphological features than Zoobot.", + "text": "Finally, we check whether the SFNet can capture information not found within the 512-dimensional Zoobot feature vector. We optimize a ridge regression model to predict SFNet feature values using the Zoobot features, finding $R^2$ values of $0.253$ and $0.107$ for the two primary SFNet features, Z61 and Z256, respectively. These low coefficients of determination suggest that our SFNet extracts different morphological features than Zoobot." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/100", + "self_ref": "#/texts/70", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1738,19 +1258,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/101", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "The ML discipline generally focuses on classification problems, which has led to rapid development of classification-based interpretability algorithms", - "text": "The ML discipline generally focuses on classification problems, which has led to rapid development of classification-based interpretability algorithms" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/102", + "self_ref": "#/texts/71", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1758,11 +1266,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[erhan2009_visualizing,zeiler2013visualizingunderstandingconvolutionalnetworks,simonyan2014deepinsideconvolutionalnetworks,8099837]. For example, Gradient-weighted Class Activation Mapping (GradCAM; gradcam) enables researchers to interrogate the model to reveal the pixels that are most important for each class prediction. However, GradCAM and its variations are reliant on classification labels.\nFor example, galaxy morphologies and other properties exist along a continuum rather than in distinct categories. Even identifying AGN via the BPT diagram, which we explore in Section[ssec:ionization], is more accurately posed as a regression problem than a classification problem.", - "text": "[erhan2009_visualizing,zeiler2013visualizingunderstandingconvolutionalnetworks,simonyan2014deepinsideconvolutionalnetworks,8099837]. For example, Gradient-weighted Class Activation Mapping (GradCAM; gradcam) enables researchers to interrogate the model to reveal the pixels that are most important for each class prediction. However, GradCAM and its variations are reliant on classification labels.\nFor example, galaxy morphologies and other properties exist along a continuum rather than in distinct categories. Even identifying AGN via the BPT diagram, which we explore in Section[ssec:ionization], is more accurately posed as a regression problem than a classification problem." + "orig": "The ML discipline generally focuses on classification problems, which has led to rapid development of classification-based interpretability algorithms [erhan2009_visualizing,zeiler2013visualizingunderstandingconvolutionalnetworks,simonyan2014deepinsideconvolutionalnetworks,8099837]. For example, Gradient-weighted Class Activation Mapping (GradCAM; gradcam) enables researchers to interrogate the model to reveal the pixels that are most important for each class prediction. However, GradCAM and its variations are reliant on classification labels.\nFor example, galaxy morphologies and other properties exist along a continuum rather than in distinct categories. Even identifying AGN via the BPT diagram, which we explore in Section[ssec:ionization], is more accurately posed as a regression problem than a classification problem.", + "text": "The ML discipline generally focuses on classification problems, which has led to rapid development of classification-based interpretability algorithms [erhan2009_visualizing,zeiler2013visualizingunderstandingconvolutionalnetworks,simonyan2014deepinsideconvolutionalnetworks,8099837]. For example, Gradient-weighted Class Activation Mapping (GradCAM; gradcam) enables researchers to interrogate the model to reveal the pixels that are most important for each class prediction. However, GradCAM and its variations are reliant on classification labels.\nFor example, galaxy morphologies and other properties exist along a continuum rather than in distinct categories. Even identifying AGN via the BPT diagram, which we explore in Section[ssec:ionization], is more accurately posed as a regression problem than a classification problem." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/103", + "self_ref": "#/texts/72", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1774,19 +1282,7 @@ "text": "While there is promise in improving the semantic content of some classification labels \\citep[e.g.,][]{2022arXiv221014760B}, categorization is often an oversimplification of richer (astro)physics." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/104", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Moreover, interpretation for classification tasks (with fully separable classes) serves a different purpose than interpretation for regression tasks. Specifically, astronomers might ask questions like,", - "text": "Moreover, interpretation for classification tasks (with fully separable classes) serves a different purpose than interpretation for regression tasks. Specifically, astronomers might ask questions like," - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/105", + "self_ref": "#/texts/73", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1794,23 +1290,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "which morphological features in this galaxy scale with its gas-phase metallicity? Astronomers are generally less interested in asking questions like, which morphological features in this image scale with the probability that it is a galaxy rather than a star? Regression tasks can be interpreted by understanding how output quantities scale with input features (see, e.g., our equations in Figure[fig:equations]), but classification problemswherein predictions are selected via the softmax operationonly require the dominant class to be marginally higher than every other class. \nTherefore, interpretability for regression and classification problems is different.", - "text": "which morphological features in this galaxy scale with its gas-phase metallicity? Astronomers are generally less interested in asking questions like, which morphological features in this image scale with the probability that it is a galaxy rather than a star? Regression tasks can be interpreted by understanding how output quantities scale with input features (see, e.g., our equations in Figure[fig:equations]), but classification problemswherein predictions are selected via the softmax operationonly require the dominant class to be marginally higher than every other class. \nTherefore, interpretability for regression and classification problems is different." + "orig": "Moreover, interpretation for classification tasks (with fully separable classes) serves a different purpose than interpretation for regression tasks. Specifically, astronomers might ask questions like, which morphological features in this galaxy scale with its gas-phase metallicity? Astronomers are generally less interested in asking questions like, which morphological features in this image scale with the probability that it is a galaxy rather than a star? Regression tasks can be interpreted by understanding how output quantities scale with input features (see, e.g., our equations in Figure[fig:equations]), but classification problemswherein predictions are selected via the softmax operationonly require the dominant class to be marginally higher than every other class. \nTherefore, interpretability for regression and classification problems is different.", + "text": "Moreover, interpretation for classification tasks (with fully separable classes) serves a different purpose than interpretation for regression tasks. Specifically, astronomers might ask questions like, which morphological features in this galaxy scale with its gas-phase metallicity? Astronomers are generally less interested in asking questions like, which morphological features in this image scale with the probability that it is a galaxy rather than a star? Regression tasks can be interpreted by understanding how output quantities scale with input features (see, e.g., our equations in Figure[fig:equations]), but classification problemswherein predictions are selected via the softmax operationonly require the dominant class to be marginally higher than every other class. \nTherefore, interpretability for regression and classification problems is different." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/106", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Other interpretability methods like saliency mapping", - "text": "Other interpretability methods like saliency mapping" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/107", + "self_ref": "#/texts/74", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1818,11 +1302,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[simonyan2014deepinsideconvolutionalnetworks] cannot learn the non-linear patterns of multiple pixels at oncewhich is exactly what makes deep learning models so powerful. \nDespite these limitations, saliency and GradCAM-like techniques are widely adopted in astronomy [2019ApJ...882L..12P,2020ApJ...900..142W,2021MNRAS.501.4579B,2024ApJ...967..152A]. \nOur results demonstrate that sparse algorithms provide a powerful alternative for interpretable ML in the physical sciences.", - "text": "[simonyan2014deepinsideconvolutionalnetworks] cannot learn the non-linear patterns of multiple pixels at oncewhich is exactly what makes deep learning models so powerful. \nDespite these limitations, saliency and GradCAM-like techniques are widely adopted in astronomy [2019ApJ...882L..12P,2020ApJ...900..142W,2021MNRAS.501.4579B,2024ApJ...967..152A]. \nOur results demonstrate that sparse algorithms provide a powerful alternative for interpretable ML in the physical sciences." + "orig": "Other interpretability methods like saliency mapping [simonyan2014deepinsideconvolutionalnetworks] cannot learn the non-linear patterns of multiple pixels at oncewhich is exactly what makes deep learning models so powerful. \nDespite these limitations, saliency and GradCAM-like techniques are widely adopted in astronomy [2019ApJ...882L..12P,2020ApJ...900..142W,2021MNRAS.501.4579B,2024ApJ...967..152A]. \nOur results demonstrate that sparse algorithms provide a powerful alternative for interpretable ML in the physical sciences.", + "text": "Other interpretability methods like saliency mapping [simonyan2014deepinsideconvolutionalnetworks] cannot learn the non-linear patterns of multiple pixels at oncewhich is exactly what makes deep learning models so powerful. \nDespite these limitations, saliency and GradCAM-like techniques are widely adopted in astronomy [2019ApJ...882L..12P,2020ApJ...900..142W,2021MNRAS.501.4579B,2024ApJ...967..152A]. \nOur results demonstrate that sparse algorithms provide a powerful alternative for interpretable ML in the physical sciences." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/108", + "self_ref": "#/texts/75", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1835,19 +1319,7 @@ "level": 1 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/109", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "We present a novel method for learning the relationship between the physical properties and interpretable morphologies of galaxies. Our sparse feature network (SFNet; Figure", - "text": "We present a novel method for learning the relationship between the physical properties and interpretable morphologies of galaxies. Our sparse feature network (SFNet; Figure" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/110", + "self_ref": "#/texts/76", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1855,23 +1327,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[fig:SFNet-architecture]) maps galaxy features onto galaxies' physical properties such as spectroscopic line fluxes and gas-phase metallicity. We identify features that correspond to hard ionizing radiation (starbursts), low gas density, old stellar populations/high metallicities, and star-forming regions/low metallicity (e.g., Table[tab:features] and Figure[fig:bpt-interpretation]). Critically, our method does not substantially sacrifice ML performance in order to gain interpretability. We can write down equations (Figure[fig:equations]) that reveal the robust linear connection between galaxy properties and their appearances. \nOptimizing a SFNet yields more robust and interpretable features than training a CNN and then using PCA to consolidate the dense features: we find that a linear combination of $k$ interpretable morphological features produces more accurate predictions than by using the top $k$ principal components of a regular CNN's features (see Figure[fig:pca-comparison]).", - "text": "[fig:SFNet-architecture]) maps galaxy features onto galaxies' physical properties such as spectroscopic line fluxes and gas-phase metallicity. We identify features that correspond to hard ionizing radiation (starbursts), low gas density, old stellar populations/high metallicities, and star-forming regions/low metallicity (e.g., Table[tab:features] and Figure[fig:bpt-interpretation]). Critically, our method does not substantially sacrifice ML performance in order to gain interpretability. We can write down equations (Figure[fig:equations]) that reveal the robust linear connection between galaxy properties and their appearances. \nOptimizing a SFNet yields more robust and interpretable features than training a CNN and then using PCA to consolidate the dense features: we find that a linear combination of $k$ interpretable morphological features produces more accurate predictions than by using the top $k$ principal components of a regular CNN's features (see Figure[fig:pca-comparison])." + "orig": "We present a novel method for learning the relationship between the physical properties and interpretable morphologies of galaxies. Our sparse feature network (SFNet; Figure[fig:SFNet-architecture]) maps galaxy features onto galaxies' physical properties such as spectroscopic line fluxes and gas-phase metallicity. We identify features that correspond to hard ionizing radiation (starbursts), low gas density, old stellar populations/high metallicities, and star-forming regions/low metallicity (e.g., Table[tab:features] and Figure[fig:bpt-interpretation]). Critically, our method does not substantially sacrifice ML performance in order to gain interpretability. We can write down equations (Figure[fig:equations]) that reveal the robust linear connection between galaxy properties and their appearances. \nOptimizing a SFNet yields more robust and interpretable features than training a CNN and then using PCA to consolidate the dense features: we find that a linear combination of $k$ interpretable morphological features produces more accurate predictions than by using the top $k$ principal components of a regular CNN's features (see Figure[fig:pca-comparison]).", + "text": "We present a novel method for learning the relationship between the physical properties and interpretable morphologies of galaxies. Our sparse feature network (SFNet; Figure[fig:SFNet-architecture]) maps galaxy features onto galaxies' physical properties such as spectroscopic line fluxes and gas-phase metallicity. We identify features that correspond to hard ionizing radiation (starbursts), low gas density, old stellar populations/high metallicities, and star-forming regions/low metallicity (e.g., Table[tab:features] and Figure[fig:bpt-interpretation]). Critically, our method does not substantially sacrifice ML performance in order to gain interpretability. We can write down equations (Figure[fig:equations]) that reveal the robust linear connection between galaxy properties and their appearances. \nOptimizing a SFNet yields more robust and interpretable features than training a CNN and then using PCA to consolidate the dense features: we find that a linear combination of $k$ interpretable morphological features produces more accurate predictions than by using the top $k$ principal components of a regular CNN's features (see Figure[fig:pca-comparison])." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/111", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "We do", - "text": "We do" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/112", + "self_ref": "#/texts/77", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1879,23 +1339,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "not imply that astrophysics can or should be automated by machines. As we discuss in Section [sec:discussion], astronomers are still necessary for interpreting image features. While the SFNet can highlight what ML algorithms are capable of learning, they cannot replace domain experts, who are essential for scrutinizing the physical interplay between learned features and predicted quantities.", - "text": "not imply that astrophysics can or should be automated by machines. As we discuss in Section [sec:discussion], astronomers are still necessary for interpreting image features. While the SFNet can highlight what ML algorithms are capable of learning, they cannot replace domain experts, who are essential for scrutinizing the physical interplay between learned features and predicted quantities." + "orig": "We do not imply that astrophysics can or should be automated by machines. As we discuss in Section [sec:discussion], astronomers are still necessary for interpreting image features. While the SFNet can highlight what ML algorithms are capable of learning, they cannot replace domain experts, who are essential for scrutinizing the physical interplay between learned features and predicted quantities.", + "text": "We do not imply that astrophysics can or should be automated by machines. As we discuss in Section [sec:discussion], astronomers are still necessary for interpreting image features. While the SFNet can highlight what ML algorithms are capable of learning, they cannot replace domain experts, who are essential for scrutinizing the physical interplay between learned features and predicted quantities." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/113", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "This work represents important progress toward developing explainable deep learning algorithms for the physical sciences. While we find strong results by incorporating a simple top-", - "text": "This work represents important progress toward developing explainable deep learning algorithms for the physical sciences. While we find strong results by incorporating a simple top-" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/114", + "self_ref": "#/texts/78", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1903,11 +1351,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "$k$ sparsity layer into a resnet18, we have not comprehensively varied the optimization procedure or model hyperparameters. However, we have tested a few values of $k$ and found that the SFNet performance is robust. Additional sparsity constraints, such as decorrelation layers (e.g. zero-phase component analysis or Cholesky whitening) or regularization terms (e.g., L1 norm) in the loss function, may encourage the SFNet to learn improved features. Using a CNN architecture with a smaller receptive field (i.e., by eschewing pooling layers), which guarantees that learned features are localized to a small number of pixels, may also enhance interpretability of SFNets. To aid the physical interpretation of features, we could also deploy an activation maximization model to specifically hone in on activating features [olah2017feature].", - "text": "$k$ sparsity layer into a resnet18, we have not comprehensively varied the optimization procedure or model hyperparameters. However, we have tested a few values of $k$ and found that the SFNet performance is robust. Additional sparsity constraints, such as decorrelation layers (e.g. zero-phase component analysis or Cholesky whitening) or regularization terms (e.g., L1 norm) in the loss function, may encourage the SFNet to learn improved features. Using a CNN architecture with a smaller receptive field (i.e., by eschewing pooling layers), which guarantees that learned features are localized to a small number of pixels, may also enhance interpretability of SFNets. To aid the physical interpretation of features, we could also deploy an activation maximization model to specifically hone in on activating features [olah2017feature]." + "orig": "This work represents important progress toward developing explainable deep learning algorithms for the physical sciences. While we find strong results by incorporating a simple top-$k$ sparsity layer into a resnet18, we have not comprehensively varied the optimization procedure or model hyperparameters. However, we have tested a few values of $k$ and found that the SFNet performance is robust. Additional sparsity constraints, such as decorrelation layers (e.g. zero-phase component analysis or Cholesky whitening) or regularization terms (e.g., L1 norm) in the loss function, may encourage the SFNet to learn improved features. Using a CNN architecture with a smaller receptive field (i.e., by eschewing pooling layers), which guarantees that learned features are localized to a small number of pixels, may also enhance interpretability of SFNets. To aid the physical interpretation of features, we could also deploy an activation maximization model to specifically hone in on activating features [olah2017feature].", + "text": "This work represents important progress toward developing explainable deep learning algorithms for the physical sciences. While we find strong results by incorporating a simple top-$k$ sparsity layer into a resnet18, we have not comprehensively varied the optimization procedure or model hyperparameters. However, we have tested a few values of $k$ and found that the SFNet performance is robust. Additional sparsity constraints, such as decorrelation layers (e.g. zero-phase component analysis or Cholesky whitening) or regularization terms (e.g., L1 norm) in the loss function, may encourage the SFNet to learn improved features. Using a CNN architecture with a smaller receptive field (i.e., by eschewing pooling layers), which guarantees that learned features are localized to a small number of pixels, may also enhance interpretability of SFNets. To aid the physical interpretation of features, we could also deploy an activation maximization model to specifically hone in on activating features [olah2017feature]." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/115", + "self_ref": "#/texts/79", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1920,7 +1368,7 @@ "level": 5 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/116", + "self_ref": "#/texts/80", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1932,7 +1380,7 @@ "text": "We thank Christian Jespersen, Charlie O'Neill, Joshua Peek, and Christine Ye for useful conversations." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/117", + "self_ref": "#/texts/81", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1945,7 +1393,7 @@ "level": 1 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/118", + "self_ref": "#/texts/82", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1958,19 +1406,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/119", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Modern deep neural networks are composed of many layers, each with many neurons. \nAI and ML researchers are actively seeking to understand the semantic meanings captured by these neurons.\nMechanistic interpretability is a subfield within AI/ML that aims to clarify the mechanisms by which deep neural networks learn", - "text": "Modern deep neural networks are composed of many layers, each with many neurons. \nAI and ML researchers are actively seeking to understand the semantic meanings captured by these neurons.\nMechanistic interpretability is a subfield within AI/ML that aims to clarify the mechanisms by which deep neural networks learn" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/120", + "self_ref": "#/texts/83", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -1978,23 +1414,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[olah2020zoom,rai2024practicalreviewmechanisticinterpretability], usually in simplified settings (since studying all neurons in all layers at once is infeasible).\nGiven the rise of AI/ML techniques in the physical sciences, it is also vital to understand how and what our trained neural networks have learned.", - "text": "[olah2020zoom,rai2024practicalreviewmechanisticinterpretability], usually in simplified settings (since studying all neurons in all layers at once is infeasible).\nGiven the rise of AI/ML techniques in the physical sciences, it is also vital to understand how and what our trained neural networks have learned." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/121", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "However, it is challenging to decipher what features are represented by specific neurons, primarily due to two phenomena: superposition and polysemanticity", - "text": "However, it is challenging to decipher what features are represented by specific neurons, primarily due to two phenomena: superposition and polysemanticity" + "orig": "Modern deep neural networks are composed of many layers, each with many neurons. \nAI and ML researchers are actively seeking to understand the semantic meanings captured by these neurons.\nMechanistic interpretability is a subfield within AI/ML that aims to clarify the mechanisms by which deep neural networks learn [olah2020zoom,rai2024practicalreviewmechanisticinterpretability], usually in simplified settings (since studying all neurons in all layers at once is infeasible).\nGiven the rise of AI/ML techniques in the physical sciences, it is also vital to understand how and what our trained neural networks have learned.", + "text": "Modern deep neural networks are composed of many layers, each with many neurons. \nAI and ML researchers are actively seeking to understand the semantic meanings captured by these neurons.\nMechanistic interpretability is a subfield within AI/ML that aims to clarify the mechanisms by which deep neural networks learn [olah2020zoom,rai2024practicalreviewmechanisticinterpretability], usually in simplified settings (since studying all neurons in all layers at once is infeasible).\nGiven the rise of AI/ML techniques in the physical sciences, it is also vital to understand how and what our trained neural networks have learned." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/122", + "self_ref": "#/texts/84", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2002,11 +1426,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[superposition].", - "text": "[superposition]." + "orig": "However, it is challenging to decipher what features are represented by specific neurons, primarily due to two phenomena: superposition and polysemanticity [superposition].", + "text": "However, it is challenging to decipher what features are represented by specific neurons, primarily due to two phenomena: superposition and polysemanticity [superposition]." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/123", + "self_ref": "#/texts/85", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/4" }, @@ -2020,7 +1444,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/124", + "self_ref": "#/texts/86", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/4" }, @@ -2034,7 +1458,7 @@ "marker": "" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/125", + "self_ref": "#/texts/87", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2046,7 +1470,7 @@ "text": "So rather than a one-to-one mapping of neurons to features, or vice versa, there is actually a many-to-many mapping. Multiple learned features can be distributed and superposed across many different neurons. Superposition and polysemanticity encapsulate why it is so challenging to understand neural networks, even in just a single layer." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/126", + "self_ref": "#/texts/88", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2059,19 +1483,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/127", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Originally motivated by biological vision systems", - "text": "Originally motivated by biological vision systems" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/128", + "self_ref": "#/texts/89", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2079,23 +1491,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[OLSHAUSEN19973311,NIPS2007_4daa3db3], sparse dictionary learning has emerged as a viable method for understanding (and consolidating) learned features into a small number of neurons. \nAlgorithms such as sparse autoencoders [makhzani2014ksparseautoencoders,cunningham2023sparseautoencodershighlyinterpretable] are capable of explaining learned features in large language models [bricken2023monosemanticity,templeton2024scaling,2024arXiv240800657O] and deep convolutional neural networks [gorton2024missingcurvedetectorsinceptionv1].\nThese recent works have demonstrated that sparse algorithms can disentangle the features represented by deep neural networks.", - "text": "[OLSHAUSEN19973311,NIPS2007_4daa3db3], sparse dictionary learning has emerged as a viable method for understanding (and consolidating) learned features into a small number of neurons. \nAlgorithms such as sparse autoencoders [makhzani2014ksparseautoencoders,cunningham2023sparseautoencodershighlyinterpretable] are capable of explaining learned features in large language models [bricken2023monosemanticity,templeton2024scaling,2024arXiv240800657O] and deep convolutional neural networks [gorton2024missingcurvedetectorsinceptionv1].\nThese recent works have demonstrated that sparse algorithms can disentangle the features represented by deep neural networks." + "orig": "Originally motivated by biological vision systems [OLSHAUSEN19973311,NIPS2007_4daa3db3], sparse dictionary learning has emerged as a viable method for understanding (and consolidating) learned features into a small number of neurons. \nAlgorithms such as sparse autoencoders [makhzani2014ksparseautoencoders,cunningham2023sparseautoencodershighlyinterpretable] are capable of explaining learned features in large language models [bricken2023monosemanticity,templeton2024scaling,2024arXiv240800657O] and deep convolutional neural networks [gorton2024missingcurvedetectorsinceptionv1].\nThese recent works have demonstrated that sparse algorithms can disentangle the features represented by deep neural networks.", + "text": "Originally motivated by biological vision systems [OLSHAUSEN19973311,NIPS2007_4daa3db3], sparse dictionary learning has emerged as a viable method for understanding (and consolidating) learned features into a small number of neurons. \nAlgorithms such as sparse autoencoders [makhzani2014ksparseautoencoders,cunningham2023sparseautoencodershighlyinterpretable] are capable of explaining learned features in large language models [bricken2023monosemanticity,templeton2024scaling,2024arXiv240800657O] and deep convolutional neural networks [gorton2024missingcurvedetectorsinceptionv1].\nThese recent works have demonstrated that sparse algorithms can disentangle the features represented by deep neural networks." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/129", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Previous works with SAEs have typically operated on large, pretrained models and sought to extract the meanings of learned activations", - "text": "Previous works with SAEs have typically operated on large, pretrained models and sought to extract the meanings of learned activations" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/130", + "self_ref": "#/texts/90", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2103,11 +1503,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[bricken2023monosemanticity].\nSAEs are tasked with reconstructing the uninterpretable mess of neuron activations from a specific network layer by learning a set of new sparse activations.\nHowever, SAEs only have two layers, which limits their ability to accurately distill the dense network activations into a few sparse ones.", - "text": "[bricken2023monosemanticity].\nSAEs are tasked with reconstructing the uninterpretable mess of neuron activations from a specific network layer by learning a set of new sparse activations.\nHowever, SAEs only have two layers, which limits their ability to accurately distill the dense network activations into a few sparse ones." + "orig": "Previous works with SAEs have typically operated on large, pretrained models and sought to extract the meanings of learned activations [bricken2023monosemanticity].\nSAEs are tasked with reconstructing the uninterpretable mess of neuron activations from a specific network layer by learning a set of new sparse activations.\nHowever, SAEs only have two layers, which limits their ability to accurately distill the dense network activations into a few sparse ones.", + "text": "Previous works with SAEs have typically operated on large, pretrained models and sought to extract the meanings of learned activations [bricken2023monosemanticity].\nSAEs are tasked with reconstructing the uninterpretable mess of neuron activations from a specific network layer by learning a set of new sparse activations.\nHowever, SAEs only have two layers, which limits their ability to accurately distill the dense network activations into a few sparse ones." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/131", + "self_ref": "#/texts/91", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2119,7 +1519,7 @@ "text": "Our work builds on insights from the mechanistic interpretability community.\nInstead of tasking a SAE to interpret learned features from a trained deep CNN, we devise a neural network architecture that is not only expressive like a regular CNN, but also employs sparse dictionary learning to produce interpretable features." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/132", + "self_ref": "#/texts/92", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2131,7 +1531,7 @@ "text": "main" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/133", + "self_ref": "#/texts/93", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -2155,7 +1555,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/20" + "$ref": "#/texts/14" } ], "references": [], @@ -2167,7 +1567,7 @@ "width": 1476.0, "height": 360.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -2182,7 +1582,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/39" + "$ref": "#/texts/26" } ], "references": [], @@ -2194,7 +1594,7 @@ "width": 1152.0, "height": 612.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -2209,7 +1609,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/40" + "$ref": "#/texts/27" } ], "references": [], @@ -2221,7 +1621,7 @@ "width": 1152.0, "height": 612.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -2236,7 +1636,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/41" + "$ref": "#/texts/28" } ], "references": [], @@ -2248,7 +1648,7 @@ "width": 1152.0, "height": 612.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -2263,7 +1663,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/42" + "$ref": "#/texts/29" } ], "references": [], @@ -2275,7 +1675,7 @@ "width": 1152.0, "height": 612.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -2290,7 +1690,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/56" + "$ref": "#/texts/40" } ], "references": [], @@ -2302,7 +1702,7 @@ "width": 1584.0, "height": 504.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] }, @@ -2317,7 +1717,7 @@ "prov": [], "captions": [ { - "$ref": "#/texts/72" + "$ref": "#/texts/51" } ], "references": [], @@ -2329,7 +1729,7 @@ "width": 742.0, "height": 360.0 }, - "uri": "" + "uri": "" }, "annotations": [] } diff --git a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2501.00089_main.tex.md b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2501.00089_main.tex.md index 6ec7c1db93..bd5d7dbee8 100644 --- a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2501.00089_main.tex.md +++ b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/2501.00089_main.tex.md @@ -17,34 +17,22 @@ Galaxies (573), Astronomy image processing (2306), Convolutional neural networks ## Introduction -Galaxies have spectacularly information-rich appearances. For a hundred years, astronomers have categorized galaxies on the basis of morphology and colors seen in optical imaging, and they have noted correlations between galaxies' physical properties and these simple morphological classifications +Galaxies have spectacularly information-rich appearances. For a hundred years, astronomers have categorized galaxies on the basis of morphology and colors seen in optical imaging, and they have noted correlations between galaxies' physical properties and these simple morphological classifications [1926ApJ....64..321H,1959HDP....53..373Z,1961hag..book.....S,2008MNRAS.389.1179L,2020IAUS..353..205M]. However, until very recently, there has been no way to connect the physics of galaxy formation and evolution with their detailedappearances. -[1926ApJ....64..321H,1959HDP....53..373Z,1961hag..book.....S,2008MNRAS.389.1179L,2020IAUS..353..205M]. However, until very recently, there has been no way to connect the physics of galaxy formation and evolution with their detailedappearances. - -Deep neural networks that exploit pixel-scale information from images can now robustly predict galaxy properties; optical images of galaxies contain enough information to constrain their physical characteristics - -[2019ApJ...887..251W,2020ApJ...900..142W,2021arXiv211101154B]. In fact, entire galaxy spectra can be estimated directly from image cutouts of individual galaxies [2020arXiv200912318W,2021ApJ...914..142H,Doorenbos+2022,Doorenbos+2024,2024MNRAS.531.4990P]. This last discovery highlights the promise of machine learning (ML) in the physical sciences. By leveraging deep learning models such as convolutional neural networks (CNNs), we can derive valuable physical constraints from plentiful galaxy images [2023PASA...40....1H,2024MNRAS.531.4990P]. +Deep neural networks that exploit pixel-scale information from images can now robustly predict galaxy properties; optical images of galaxies contain enough information to constrain their physical characteristics [2019ApJ...887..251W,2020ApJ...900..142W,2021arXiv211101154B]. In fact, entire galaxy spectra can be estimated directly from image cutouts of individual galaxies [2020arXiv200912318W,2021ApJ...914..142H,Doorenbos+2022,Doorenbos+2024,2024MNRAS.531.4990P]. This last discovery highlights the promise of machine learning (ML) in the physical sciences. By leveraging deep learning models such as convolutional neural networks (CNNs), we can derive valuable physical constraints from plentiful galaxy images [2023PASA...40....1H,2024MNRAS.531.4990P]. So machines are capable of learning physics from galaxy imagingbut what about us astronomers? -Two major challenges arise when we try to interpret physics from deep neural networks. First, each neuron in the network represents a non-linear combination of features, resulting in uninterpretable mess of features - -[superposition]. Second, each neuron can also be activated in multiple independent contexts, and can thus take on multiple meanings [geva2021transformerfeedforwardlayerskeyvalue]. In other words, neuron values are not one-to-one with learned concepts. Superposition and polysemanticity allow neural networks to increase their capacity for storing features [olah2020zoom,superposition,10136140]; these phenomena are topics of cutting-edge ML research, and we present an extended discussion in Appendix[appendix]. Unfortunately, they also obscure the interpretation and contribution of any specific neuron, preventing us from understanding the physics behind the patterns that ML models learn. +Two major challenges arise when we try to interpret physics from deep neural networks. First, each neuron in the network represents a non-linear combination of features, resulting in uninterpretable mess of features [superposition]. Second, each neuron can also be activated in multiple independent contexts, and can thus take on multiple meanings [geva2021transformerfeedforwardlayerskeyvalue]. In other words, neuron values are not one-to-one with learned concepts. Superposition and polysemanticity allow neural networks to increase their capacity for storing features [olah2020zoom,superposition,10136140]; these phenomena are topics of cutting-edge ML research, and we present an extended discussion in Appendix[appendix]. Unfortunately, they also obscure the interpretation and contribution of any specific neuron, preventing us from understanding the physics behind the patterns that ML models learn. -Fortunately, there exists a strategy to combat these issues in ML. Sparse coding represents data using a small number of active elements from a larger set of basis functions - -[Olshausen1996,NIPS2006\_2d71b2ae], making it easier to inspect the individual features that contribute to ML model predictions [olah2017feature]. Recently, sparse ML algorithms have been used in the artificial intelligence community to disentangle the internal activations of large language models [radford2019language], and mitigate the problems of superposition and polysemanticity [makhzani2014ksparseautoencoders,cunningham2023sparseautoencodershighlyinterpretable,2024arXiv240800657O,templeton2024scaling]. Therefore, sparse coding can reveal the mechanics of how deep neural networks learn. +Fortunately, there exists a strategy to combat these issues in ML. Sparse coding represents data using a small number of active elements from a larger set of basis functions [Olshausen1996,NIPS2006\_2d71b2ae], making it easier to inspect the individual features that contribute to ML model predictions [olah2017feature]. Recently, sparse ML algorithms have been used in the artificial intelligence community to disentangle the internal activations of large language models [radford2019language], and mitigate the problems of superposition and polysemanticity [makhzani2014ksparseautoencoders,cunningham2023sparseautoencodershighlyinterpretable,2024arXiv240800657O,templeton2024scaling]. Therefore, sparse coding can reveal the mechanics of how deep neural networks learn. We introduce a novel, interpretable CNN for images: a Sparse Feature Network (SFNet). -CNNs encode image data from a high-dimensional pixel space ( - -$n \sim 10^5$ pixels) into a lower-dimensional latent space ($d \sim 10^3$ features). +CNNs encode image data from a high-dimensional pixel space ($n \sim 10^5$ pixels) into a lower-dimensional latent space ($d \sim 10^3$ features). To disentangle the learned features, we enforce a $k$-sparse constraint while training our ML model: only $k \ll d$ features are allowed to have non-zero activations for each image example. By keeping just the top $k$ activating features, sparse algorithms are forced to consolidate features into the fewest possible neurons. Our SFNet activates $k$ features per image in its penultimate layer, and makes predictions by using a linear combination of the sparse activations. Since we only add a top-$k$constraint to a standard CNN architecture, this modification incurs zero extra computational cost or memory. -We train the SFNet to predict galaxy properties from image cutouts according to the methodology described in Section - -[sec:methodology]. In Section[sec:results], we show that the SFNet achieves robust performance while learning interpretable features. We discuss these results further in Section[sec:discussion], and state our conclusions in Section[sec:summary]. +We train the SFNet to predict galaxy properties from image cutouts according to the methodology described in Section[sec:methodology]. In Section[sec:results], we show that the SFNet achieves robust performance while learning interpretable features. We discuss these results further in Section[sec:discussion], and state our conclusions in Section[sec:summary]. Image: SFNet\_ResNet18-TopK.pdf @@ -54,41 +42,27 @@ Our SFNet architecture, which resembles a resnet18 modified with a penultimate T ## Methodology -We select galaxies from the SDSS Main Galaxy Sample - -[2002AJ....124.1810S,sdssdr7] that have emission line signal-to-noise ratios greater than 3 for [N2] $\lambda6584$, H$\alpha$ $\lambda6564$, [O3] $\lambda5007$, and H$\beta$ $\lambda4861$, where each line is designated by its rest wavelength in Angstroms. In addition to galaxy line fluxes, we compile physical properties derived from fitting spectral energy distribution models to SDSS photometry and spectra [2003MNRAS.346.1055K,2004MNRAS.351.1151B,2004ApJ...613..898T]. For all galaxies, we obtain $gri$-band $144\times 144$ image cutouts resampled at $0.262$ arcsec per pixel resolution from the Legacy Survey website [2019AJ....157..168D]. Our SDSS sample comprises 250,207 galaxies in total. - -Our SFNet implementation is shown in Figure +We select galaxies from the SDSS Main Galaxy Sample [2002AJ....124.1810S,sdssdr7] that have emission line signal-to-noise ratios greater than 3 for [N2] $\lambda6584$, H$\alpha$ $\lambda6564$, [O3] $\lambda5007$, and H$\beta$ $\lambda4861$, where each line is designated by its rest wavelength in Angstroms. In addition to galaxy line fluxes, we compile physical properties derived from fitting spectral energy distribution models to SDSS photometry and spectra [2003MNRAS.346.1055K,2004MNRAS.351.1151B,2004ApJ...613..898T]. For all galaxies, we obtain $gri$-band $144\times 144$ image cutouts resampled at $0.262$ arcsec per pixel resolution from the Legacy Survey website [2019AJ....157..168D]. Our SDSS sample comprises 250,207 galaxies in total. -[fig:SFNet-architecture]. We use a CNN architecture identical to the resnet18 [he2015deepresiduallearningimage], except that we insert a top-$k$ operation before the final linear layer. +Our SFNet implementation is shown in Figure[fig:SFNet-architecture]. We use a CNN architecture identical to the resnet18 [he2015deepresiduallearningimage], except that we insert a top-$k$ operation before the final linear layer. This additional top-$k$ layer guarantees that each prediction is a linear combination of $k$ sparse features. We use $d=512$ latent features (after the average pooling layer) and set $k=4$. Later, in Section[ssec:comparison-pca], we vary $k \in \{2, 3, 4, 6, 8\}$. Thus, the SFNet learns a representation of each galaxy using just a few features out of a library of 512 possible features. Critically, the features activate directly after the convolution layers, so that morphological features are localized in pixel space. -The resnet18 backbone of the model is initialized to ImageNet-pretrained weights - -[5206848], and we update model parameters by minimizing the root mean squared error. We randomly designate 20% of objects for validation, and train on the remainder. Random flips are applied for data augmentation. We train for 20 epochs using the ranger optimizer [wright2021ranger21synergisticdeeplearning] and an initial learning rate of 0.1 with a flat+cosine annealing schedule. All code and the trained models presented here can be found in our public Github repository: https://github.com/jwuphysics/sparse-feature-networks. +The resnet18 backbone of the model is initialized to ImageNet-pretrained weights [5206848], and we update model parameters by minimizing the root mean squared error. We randomly designate 20% of objects for validation, and train on the remainder. Random flips are applied for data augmentation. We train for 20 epochs using the ranger optimizer [wright2021ranger21synergisticdeeplearning] and an initial learning rate of 0.1 with a flat+cosine annealing schedule. All code and the trained models presented here can be found in our public Github repository: https://github.com/jwuphysics/sparse-feature-networks. ## Results -Motivated by previous works that connect galaxy imaging with their physical properties - -[2019MNRAS.484.4683W,2020arXiv200912318W,2021MNRAS.506.3313G,2021ApJ...914..142H], we train the SFNet to predict spectroscopic line fluxes (Section[ssec:ionization]) and gas-phase metallicity ([ssec:metallicity]) directly from image cutouts. +Motivated by previous works that connect galaxy imaging with their physical properties [2019MNRAS.484.4683W,2020arXiv200912318W,2021MNRAS.506.3313G,2021ApJ...914..142H], we train the SFNet to predict spectroscopic line fluxes (Section[ssec:ionization]) and gas-phase metallicity ([ssec:metallicity]) directly from image cutouts. We identify the learned features using their sparse activation index, e.g., SL17 for the 17th feature of a SFNet trained to predict spectral lines fluxes, or Z256 for the 256th feature of a SFNet trained to predict gas-phase metallicity. Feature activations are scaled between 0 and 1, and we refer to these example activation strengths as $A\_{\tt SL\,17}$ and $A\_{\tt Z\,256}$, respectively. ### Emission line fluxes -We train a SFNet to predict the spectral line fluxes for [ +We train a SFNet to predict the spectral line fluxes for [N2], H$\alpha$, [O3], and H$\beta$. These lines can diagnose a galaxy's global ionization state; for example, the line ratios [N2]/H$\alpha$ against [O3]/H$\beta$ comprise the BPT diagram [1981PASP...93....5B], which is commonly used to differentiate activate galactic nuclei (AGN) from star-forming galaxies. Other physical processes can also affect these line strengths, including stellar evolution/age, AGN, gas metallicity, gas physical state, and dust attenuation. -N2], H$\alpha$, [O3], and H$\beta$. These lines can diagnose a galaxy's global ionization state; for example, the line ratios [N2]/H$\alpha$ against [O3]/H$\beta$ comprise the BPT diagram [1981PASP...93....5B], which is commonly used to differentiate activate galactic nuclei (AGN) from star-forming galaxies. Other physical processes can also affect these line strengths, including stellar evolution/age, AGN, gas metallicity, gas physical state, and dust attenuation. +The eight most frequently activated features explain 99.99% of the variance in the dataset, but there is significant correlation between them. The four most frequently activated features can still explain 91.6% of the variance; therefore, we restrict our investigation to these top four activations that correspond to features SL17, SL138, SL157, and SL322. -The eight most frequently activated features explain 99.99 - -% of the variance in the dataset, but there is significant correlation between them. The four most frequently activated features can still explain 91.6% of the variance; therefore, we restrict our investigation to these top four activations that correspond to features SL17, SL138, SL157, and SL322. - -In Figure - -[fig:bpt-interpretation], we show galaxy image examples for the strongest activations, and where they appear in a BPT diagram. The four features reside in overlapping regions of the [O3]/H$\beta$ versus [N2]/H$\alpha$ space, but they all peak in distinct locations. For example, the locus of points for SL17 appear to be at higher [N2]/H$\alpha$ and [O3]/H$\beta$, indicating harder ionizing radiation and higher gas density [2019ARAA..57..511K]. Meanwhile, the opposite appears to be true for SL138 (or at least, for non-AGN with high $A\_{\tt SL\,138}$). Additional features contain information about metallicity and stellar populations. In Table[tab:features], we offer physical interpretations for these features. +In Figure[fig:bpt-interpretation], we show galaxy image examples for the strongest activations, and where they appear in a BPT diagram. The four features reside in overlapping regions of the [O3]/H$\beta$ versus [N2]/H$\alpha$ space, but they all peak in distinct locations. For example, the locus of points for SL17 appear to be at higher [N2]/H$\alpha$ and [O3]/H$\beta$, indicating harder ionizing radiation and higher gas density [2019ARAA..57..511K]. Meanwhile, the opposite appears to be true for SL138 (or at least, for non-AGN with high $A\_{\tt SL\,138}$). Additional features contain information about metallicity and stellar populations. In Table[tab:features], we offer physical interpretations for these features. Image: 17-bpt\_scatter\_examples\_3x3.pdf @@ -126,22 +100,16 @@ Z256 87.9% blue, edge-on disks low metallicity ### Gas metallicity -We separately train a SFNet to predict the gas-phase metallicity, - -$Z\_{\rm gas} = 12 + $log(O/H), directly from images. We remove all objects with invalid estimates for metallicity, stellar mass, and star formation rate, leaving 117,223 galaxies from the SDSS Main Galaxy Sample. The scatter of metallicity is $0.207$dex, and our trained SFNet can predict it to within $0.087$dex using only two image features, Z61 and Z256, which are activated 99.6% and 87.9% of the time respectively. If we also incorporate the third and fourth most frequent activations (40.2% and 11.9%, respectively), then we can achieve $0.086$dex error. This level of performance suggests that our SFNet is extremely accurate (see Section[ssec:performance-interpretability]for further discussion). - -In the bottom two rows of Table +We separately train a SFNet to predict the gas-phase metallicity, $Z\_{\rm gas} = 12 + $log(O/H), directly from images. We remove all objects with invalid estimates for metallicity, stellar mass, and star formation rate, leaving 117,223 galaxies from the SDSS Main Galaxy Sample. The scatter of metallicity is $0.207$dex, and our trained SFNet can predict it to within $0.087$dex using only two image features, Z61 and Z256, which are activated 99.6% and 87.9% of the time respectively. If we also incorporate the third and fourth most frequent activations (40.2% and 11.9%, respectively), then we can achieve $0.086$dex error. This level of performance suggests that our SFNet is extremely accurate (see Section[ssec:performance-interpretability]for further discussion). -[tab:features], we describe the two main features used to predict metallicity. Z61 is associated with galaxies with prominent red bulges and is linked to higher metallicity. It activates strongly for red ellipticals or face-on disk galaxies (often with two loosely wound spiral arms; see, e.g., 2019MNRAS.487.1808M for more on the correlations between galaxy properties and spiral arm pitch angle). Feature Z256 is associated with blue, edge-on disk galaxies and lower metallicity. +In the bottom two rows of Table[tab:features], we describe the two main features used to predict metallicity. Z61 is associated with galaxies with prominent red bulges and is linked to higher metallicity. It activates strongly for red ellipticals or face-on disk galaxies (often with two loosely wound spiral arms; see, e.g., 2019MNRAS.487.1808M for more on the correlations between galaxy properties and spiral arm pitch angle). Feature Z256 is associated with blue, edge-on disk galaxies and lower metallicity. [2004ApJ...613..898T] noted that metal-poor galaxies tended to have highly inclined disk morphologies, and attributed this effect to observational bias. SDSS spectroscopic fibers collect light from lower-$Z\_{\rm gas}$outskirts of disk galaxies observed edge-on, but would miss those regions for the same galaxies observed face-on. Our SFNet now captures this same observational bias, affecting the library of morphological features that it learns. ## Discussion ### Physical laws from galaxy images -Because the SFNet learns a linear projection from these activations to the final prediction, we can write down a simple - -equation between learned galaxy features and the physical quantity of interest. In Figure[fig:equations], we present linear equations for predicting gas metallicity and spectral line ratios by using the aforementioned galaxy image features. +Because the SFNet learns a linear projection from these activations to the final prediction, we can write down a simple equation between learned galaxy features and the physical quantity of interest. In Figure[fig:equations], we present linear equations for predicting gas metallicity and spectral line ratios by using the aforementioned galaxy image features. The maximally activating galaxy examples are shown in the equations (each labeled by their activated feature index). Image: equations.pdf @@ -150,28 +118,20 @@ Image: equations.pdf Linear relationships between galaxy properties and image features learned by the SFNet. We show how the gas metallicity, [N2]/H$\alpha$, and [O3]/H$\beta$ depend on SFNet feature activations, where SFNet features are represented using the top-activating galaxy image cutout from the validation set. -These linear relations are so simple that we can directly interpret them. The - -Z61 and Z256 features used to predict $Z\_{\rm gas}$ directly correspond to higher and lower metallicity. Interestingly, both can be activated at the same timeand in fact, both are non-zero for the majority of galaxies in the validation set, demonstrating the physical interplay between these morphological features and metallicity. For predicting spectral lines, features SL17 and SL157 positively correlate with both [N2]/H$\alpha$ and [O3]/H$\beta$; we might interpret these morphological features as indicators of spectral hardness and low ionization (nuclear) emission-line regions, respectively. Meanwhile, S322 correlates with [O3]/H$\beta$ but anticorrelates with [N2]/H$\alpha$, suggesting that it is associated with harder ionizing spectra. - -The model is only able to learn physical laws by leveraging galaxy morphology present within the optical image cutouts. However, galaxy evolution is governed by the complex interplay between multiple physical processes +These linear relations are so simple that we can directly interpret them. The Z61 and Z256 features used to predict $Z\_{\rm gas}$ directly correspond to higher and lower metallicity. Interestingly, both can be activated at the same timeand in fact, both are non-zero for the majority of galaxies in the validation set, demonstrating the physical interplay between these morphological features and metallicity. For predicting spectral lines, features SL17 and SL157 positively correlate with both [N2]/H$\alpha$ and [O3]/H$\beta$; we might interpret these morphological features as indicators of spectral hardness and low ionization (nuclear) emission-line regions, respectively. Meanwhile, S322 correlates with [O3]/H$\beta$ but anticorrelates with [N2]/H$\alpha$, suggesting that it is associated with harder ionizing spectra. -[2015ARAA..53...51S,2017MNRAS.471.2687B], which are not always imprinted in galaxy morphology, or perhaps not at the scales or wavelengths probed by our imaging surveys. Nonetheless, CNNs are surprisingly powerful at predicting the spectroscopic tracers of galaxy evolution. [2019AA...624A.102D] and [2019MNRAS.484.4683W] showed that galaxies' stellar masses can be estimated directly from image cutouts, and [2021MNRAS.501.4359Z] suggest that CNNs are sensitive to small-scale morphological perturbations due to dust in galaxies. Even information outside of the image cutout can be indirectly probed; [2020ApJ...900..142W] measure impact of galaxy environment on CNN-predicted gas properties, suggesting that the well-known density-morphology relation [1980ApJ...236..351D]can be implicitly learned via ML models. +The model is only able to learn physical laws by leveraging galaxy morphology present within the optical image cutouts. However, galaxy evolution is governed by the complex interplay between multiple physical processes [2015ARAA..53...51S,2017MNRAS.471.2687B], which are not always imprinted in galaxy morphology, or perhaps not at the scales or wavelengths probed by our imaging surveys. Nonetheless, CNNs are surprisingly powerful at predicting the spectroscopic tracers of galaxy evolution. [2019AA...624A.102D] and [2019MNRAS.484.4683W] showed that galaxies' stellar masses can be estimated directly from image cutouts, and [2021MNRAS.501.4359Z] suggest that CNNs are sensitive to small-scale morphological perturbations due to dust in galaxies. Even information outside of the image cutout can be indirectly probed; [2020ApJ...900..142W] measure impact of galaxy environment on CNN-predicted gas properties, suggesting that the well-known density-morphology relation [1980ApJ...236..351D]can be implicitly learned via ML models. In summary, SFNets can learn a limited (but still powerful) set of physical relationships that govern galaxy evolution. ### Performance versus interpretability -Previous works have found that a CNN trained on optical image cutouts can successfully classify AGN from star-forming galaxies with an accuracy - -[2021ApJ...914..142H,2022arXiv221207881G,Doorenbos+2024]. We test how well the interpretable SFNet from Section[ssec:ionization] can also identify AGN. By optimizing a linear support vector machine (SVM) classifier on SL17, SL138, SL157, and SL322 from the training dataset, we can classify AGN with a validation accuracy of 0.85 and F1 score of 0.72. +Previous works have found that a CNN trained on optical image cutouts can successfully classify AGN from star-forming galaxies with an accuracy [2021ApJ...914..142H,2022arXiv221207881G,Doorenbos+2024]. We test how well the interpretable SFNet from Section[ssec:ionization] can also identify AGN. By optimizing a linear support vector machine (SVM) classifier on SL17, SL138, SL157, and SL322 from the training dataset, we can classify AGN with a validation accuracy of 0.85 and F1 score of 0.72. If we use all non-zero SFNet features, then the best-fit linear SVM validates at 0.83 accuracy and 0.70 F1 score, i.e., it performs worse. This suggests that restricting to the four most frequent feature activations reduces noiseanother benefit of sparsity. In comparison, the highly tuned CNN from [2022arXiv221207881G] achieves an accuracy of 0.89 and F1 score of 0.75, and the conditional diffusion model by [Doorenbos+2024] results in an accuracy of 0.82 and F1 score of 0.73 (although we note that they use a slightly different AGN classification scheme). Our experiments demonstrate that a linear combinationof our interpretable features can distinguish AGN from star-forming galaxies at a level comparable to state-of-the-art ML algorithms. -In Section - -[ssec:metallicity], we estimate gas metallicity to within 0.087dex using a linear combination of two features (and 0.086dex using four features). +In Section[ssec:metallicity], we estimate gas metallicity to within 0.087dex using a linear combination of two features (and 0.086dex using four features). For comparison, a typical CNN only achieves $0.085$dex error [2019MNRAS.484.4683W]; note that the systematic scatter is $\sim 0.03$dex. Again, this suggests that SFNets do not sacrifice performance in order to gain interpretability. ### Comparison to PCA @@ -179,9 +139,7 @@ For comparison, a typical CNN only achieves $0.085$dex error [2019MNRAS.484.4683 While the SFNet produces interpretable features by imposing a sparsity constraint during the training process, other techniques are frequently used to reduce the number of learned features. Here we compare SFNet features against another common approach: dimensionality reduction of learned model features via principal components analysis (PCA). Given feature activations in the penultimate layer of a regularly trained CNN, we can obtain the principal components by computing eigenvectors of the dense activation's covariance matrix. They are listed in descending order of how much variance is accounted for by each principal component (i.e., ordered by descending eigenvalues). -By selecting the top - -$k$principal components, we can project dense feature activations into a smaller space of sparse activations. +By selecting the top $k$principal components, we can project dense feature activations into a smaller space of sparse activations. Image: pca-comparison.pdf @@ -190,9 +148,7 @@ Image: pca-comparison.pdf SFNet comparison against a CNN with dimensionality-reduced features. Using the SFNet model (blue) and a dense CNN with top principal components as features (red), we report RMSE values (lower is better) for models trained to predict metallicity (left) and spectral line fluxes (right) for several values of $k$ (i.e., sparsity or number of PCA components). We test whether this smaller set of principal components are as robust as the SFNet features. -We train a multivariate linear regression model using the first - -$k$ principal components from dense CNN activations as features, again using the same training and validation split, to predict both the metallicity and spectral line strengths. +We train a multivariate linear regression model using the first $k$ principal components from dense CNN activations as features, again using the same training and validation split, to predict both the metallicity and spectral line strengths. For comparison, we have also re-trained the SFNet using $k \in \{2, 3, 4, 6, 8\}$. We independently re-train the SFNet three times in order to estimate the mean and standard error on the prediction RMSE. We use the same training/validation split and re-initialize the model each time for each value of $k$. Because we repeat the training process from scratch, the RMSE values presented in this section slightly differ from the ones reported in Section\ref{sec:results}. @@ -220,9 +176,7 @@ Comparison of performance using a SFNet and a CNN with PCA-based dimensionality 6 $0.0875 \pm 0.0007$ 0.1020 $0.2394 \pm 0.0009$ 0.2419 8 $0.0852 \pm 0.0004$ 0.0921 $0.2389 \pm 0.0012$ 0.2396 -For both metallicity and spectral line fluxes, - -$>95\%$ of the variance is explained using the top $k=8$ principal components. +For both metallicity and spectral line fluxes, $>95\%$ of the variance is explained using the top $k=8$ principal components. For metallicity (left panel of Figure[fig:pca-comparison]), we find that the CNN + PCA performs poorly on the validation set for all values of $k$. Meanwhile, the SFNet can reconstruct metallicity with only $k=2$ explainable features, reinforcing our results found in Section[ssec:metallicity]. We interpret this as evidence that the metallicity cannot be linearly combined using a small number of principal components of features extracted via a typical CNN. @@ -233,72 +187,46 @@ The SFNet can accurately estimate spectral line fluxes using only $k=4$ features Our experiment shows that we can reduce the dimensionality of CNN feature activations via PCA, but the ensuing principal components are not always robust features for recovering the training targets (e.g., for metallicity). These difficulties may arise from superposition and polysemanticity, which cause the most important features to be entangled and spread across multiple CNN activations in highly non-linear ways. -Since typical CNNs are not optimized with any sparsity constraint in mind, there is no guarantee that a linear combination of the learned features should be interpretable (although there are non-linear methods for finding optimal summary statistics; e.g., - -Charnock\_2018). +Since typical CNNs are not optimized with any sparsity constraint in mind, there is no guarantee that a linear combination of the learned features should be interpretable (although there are non-linear methods for finding optimal summary statistics; e.g., Charnock\_2018). By forcing a CNN to be sparse during the training process, we find that SFNets can learn robust features and produce accurate predictions. ### Comparison to GalaxyZoo features Do regular CNNs also learn interpretable features? -We compare the SFNet against Zoobot, a CNN trained to classify GalaxyZoo morphologies - -[2008MNRAS.389.1179L,2023JOSS....8.5312W,Walmsley+2024]. We consider the resnet18 variant of Zoobot, which has the same architecture as our SFNet modulo the top-$k$ sparsity constraint (Figure[fig:SFNet-architecture]). Zoobot predicts citizen scientist vote fractions for GalaxyZoo morphological labels. We hypothesize that Zoobot's 512-dimensional features directly after the pooling layer suffer from superposition and polysemanticity, and thereby produce an uninterpretable combination of morphology and color. - -Using morphological features from Zoobot, we train a regression model to predict galaxy metallicity. This experiment allows us to assess whether traditional CNNs can also be used to learn astrophysical relationships between image features and galaxy properties. We use the same training/validation datasets from Section - -[ssec:metallicity], and independently test two models that use Zoobot-extracted features as inputs and $Z\_{\rm gas}$as training targets. - -First, we fit a linear model to the training dataset, and find poor performance on the validation dataset (error of - -$0.183$dex). When we fit on the validation dataseti.e., if we attempt to memorize the answersthe error remains very high ($0.181$dex). This result demonstrates that no linear combination of Zoobot features can reconstruct galaxy metallicity. - -Second, we fit an gradient-boosted decision tree (XGBoost) model to the training dataset, and achieve only +We compare the SFNet against Zoobot, a CNN trained to classify GalaxyZoo morphologies [2008MNRAS.389.1179L,2023JOSS....8.5312W,Walmsley+2024]. We consider the resnet18 variant of Zoobot, which has the same architecture as our SFNet modulo the top-$k$ sparsity constraint (Figure[fig:SFNet-architecture]). Zoobot predicts citizen scientist vote fractions for GalaxyZoo morphological labels. We hypothesize that Zoobot's 512-dimensional features directly after the pooling layer suffer from superposition and polysemanticity, and thereby produce an uninterpretable combination of morphology and color. -$0.180$dex error on the validation dataset. However, when we cheat by fitting on the validation dataset, we can lower the error down to $0.085$dex (comparable to the SFNet performance). +Using morphological features from Zoobot, we train a regression model to predict galaxy metallicity. This experiment allows us to assess whether traditional CNNs can also be used to learn astrophysical relationships between image features and galaxy properties. We use the same training/validation datasets from Section[ssec:metallicity], and independently test two models that use Zoobot-extracted features as inputs and $Z\_{\rm gas}$as training targets. -Our experiments confirm that the Zoobot features indeed contain enough information to memorize the validation set, but that these features ( +First, we fit a linear model to the training dataset, and find poor performance on the validation dataset (error of $0.183$dex). When we fit on the validation dataseti.e., if we attempt to memorize the answersthe error remains very high ($0.181$dex). This result demonstrates that no linear combination of Zoobot features can reconstruct galaxy metallicity. -i) cannot be linearly combined to reconstruct galaxy metallicity, and (ii) cannot generalize across the random training/validation split. We surmise that regular CNN features are not interpretable. Meanwhile, our SFNet is both performant and interpretable. +Second, we fit an gradient-boosted decision tree (XGBoost) model to the training dataset, and achieve only $0.180$dex error on the validation dataset. However, when we cheat by fitting on the validation dataset, we can lower the error down to $0.085$dex (comparable to the SFNet performance). -Finally, we check whether the SFNet can capture information not found within the 512-dimensional Zoobot feature vector. We optimize a ridge regression model to predict SFNet feature values using the Zoobot features, finding +Our experiments confirm that the Zoobot features indeed contain enough information to memorize the validation set, but that these features (i) cannot be linearly combined to reconstruct galaxy metallicity, and (ii) cannot generalize across the random training/validation split. We surmise that regular CNN features are not interpretable. Meanwhile, our SFNet is both performant and interpretable. -$R^2$ values of $0.253$ and $0.107$ for the two primary SFNet features, Z61 and Z256, respectively. These low coefficients of determination suggest that our SFNet extracts different morphological features than Zoobot. +Finally, we check whether the SFNet can capture information not found within the 512-dimensional Zoobot feature vector. We optimize a ridge regression model to predict SFNet feature values using the Zoobot features, finding $R^2$ values of $0.253$ and $0.107$ for the two primary SFNet features, Z61 and Z256, respectively. These low coefficients of determination suggest that our SFNet extracts different morphological features than Zoobot. ### Limitations of previous interpretability methods -The ML discipline generally focuses on classification problems, which has led to rapid development of classification-based interpretability algorithms - -[erhan2009\_visualizing,zeiler2013visualizingunderstandingconvolutionalnetworks,simonyan2014deepinsideconvolutionalnetworks,8099837]. For example, Gradient-weighted Class Activation Mapping (GradCAM; gradcam) enables researchers to interrogate the model to reveal the pixels that are most important for each class prediction. However, GradCAM and its variations are reliant on classification labels. +The ML discipline generally focuses on classification problems, which has led to rapid development of classification-based interpretability algorithms [erhan2009\_visualizing,zeiler2013visualizingunderstandingconvolutionalnetworks,simonyan2014deepinsideconvolutionalnetworks,8099837]. For example, Gradient-weighted Class Activation Mapping (GradCAM; gradcam) enables researchers to interrogate the model to reveal the pixels that are most important for each class prediction. However, GradCAM and its variations are reliant on classification labels. For example, galaxy morphologies and other properties exist along a continuum rather than in distinct categories. Even identifying AGN via the BPT diagram, which we explore in Section[ssec:ionization], is more accurately posed as a regression problem than a classification problem. While there is promise in improving the semantic content of some classification labels \citep[e.g.,][]{2022arXiv221014760B}, categorization is often an oversimplification of richer (astro)physics. -Moreover, interpretation for classification tasks (with fully separable classes) serves a different purpose than interpretation for regression tasks. Specifically, astronomers might ask questions like, - -which morphological features in this galaxy scale with its gas-phase metallicity? Astronomers are generally less interested in asking questions like, which morphological features in this image scale with the probability that it is a galaxy rather than a star? Regression tasks can be interpreted by understanding how output quantities scale with input features (see, e.g., our equations in Figure[fig:equations]), but classification problemswherein predictions are selected via the softmax operationonly require the dominant class to be marginally higher than every other class. +Moreover, interpretation for classification tasks (with fully separable classes) serves a different purpose than interpretation for regression tasks. Specifically, astronomers might ask questions like, which morphological features in this galaxy scale with its gas-phase metallicity? Astronomers are generally less interested in asking questions like, which morphological features in this image scale with the probability that it is a galaxy rather than a star? Regression tasks can be interpreted by understanding how output quantities scale with input features (see, e.g., our equations in Figure[fig:equations]), but classification problemswherein predictions are selected via the softmax operationonly require the dominant class to be marginally higher than every other class. Therefore, interpretability for regression and classification problems is different. -Other interpretability methods like saliency mapping - -[simonyan2014deepinsideconvolutionalnetworks] cannot learn the non-linear patterns of multiple pixels at oncewhich is exactly what makes deep learning models so powerful. +Other interpretability methods like saliency mapping [simonyan2014deepinsideconvolutionalnetworks] cannot learn the non-linear patterns of multiple pixels at oncewhich is exactly what makes deep learning models so powerful. Despite these limitations, saliency and GradCAM-like techniques are widely adopted in astronomy [2019ApJ...882L..12P,2020ApJ...900..142W,2021MNRAS.501.4579B,2024ApJ...967..152A]. Our results demonstrate that sparse algorithms provide a powerful alternative for interpretable ML in the physical sciences. ## Conclusions -We present a novel method for learning the relationship between the physical properties and interpretable morphologies of galaxies. Our sparse feature network (SFNet; Figure - -[fig:SFNet-architecture]) maps galaxy features onto galaxies' physical properties such as spectroscopic line fluxes and gas-phase metallicity. We identify features that correspond to hard ionizing radiation (starbursts), low gas density, old stellar populations/high metallicities, and star-forming regions/low metallicity (e.g., Table[tab:features] and Figure[fig:bpt-interpretation]). Critically, our method does not substantially sacrifice ML performance in order to gain interpretability. We can write down equations (Figure[fig:equations]) that reveal the robust linear connection between galaxy properties and their appearances. +We present a novel method for learning the relationship between the physical properties and interpretable morphologies of galaxies. Our sparse feature network (SFNet; Figure[fig:SFNet-architecture]) maps galaxy features onto galaxies' physical properties such as spectroscopic line fluxes and gas-phase metallicity. We identify features that correspond to hard ionizing radiation (starbursts), low gas density, old stellar populations/high metallicities, and star-forming regions/low metallicity (e.g., Table[tab:features] and Figure[fig:bpt-interpretation]). Critically, our method does not substantially sacrifice ML performance in order to gain interpretability. We can write down equations (Figure[fig:equations]) that reveal the robust linear connection between galaxy properties and their appearances. Optimizing a SFNet yields more robust and interpretable features than training a CNN and then using PCA to consolidate the dense features: we find that a linear combination of $k$ interpretable morphological features produces more accurate predictions than by using the top $k$ principal components of a regular CNN's features (see Figure[fig:pca-comparison]). -We do - -not imply that astrophysics can or should be automated by machines. As we discuss in Section [sec:discussion], astronomers are still necessary for interpreting image features. While the SFNet can highlight what ML algorithms are capable of learning, they cannot replace domain experts, who are essential for scrutinizing the physical interplay between learned features and predicted quantities. +We do not imply that astrophysics can or should be automated by machines. As we discuss in Section [sec:discussion], astronomers are still necessary for interpreting image features. While the SFNet can highlight what ML algorithms are capable of learning, they cannot replace domain experts, who are essential for scrutinizing the physical interplay between learned features and predicted quantities. -This work represents important progress toward developing explainable deep learning algorithms for the physical sciences. While we find strong results by incorporating a simple top- - -$k$ sparsity layer into a resnet18, we have not comprehensively varied the optimization procedure or model hyperparameters. However, we have tested a few values of $k$ and found that the SFNet performance is robust. Additional sparsity constraints, such as decorrelation layers (e.g. zero-phase component analysis or Cholesky whitening) or regularization terms (e.g., L1 norm) in the loss function, may encourage the SFNet to learn improved features. Using a CNN architecture with a smaller receptive field (i.e., by eschewing pooling layers), which guarantees that learned features are localized to a small number of pixels, may also enhance interpretability of SFNets. To aid the physical interpretation of features, we could also deploy an activation maximization model to specifically hone in on activating features [olah2017feature]. +This work represents important progress toward developing explainable deep learning algorithms for the physical sciences. While we find strong results by incorporating a simple top-$k$ sparsity layer into a resnet18, we have not comprehensively varied the optimization procedure or model hyperparameters. However, we have tested a few values of $k$ and found that the SFNet performance is robust. Additional sparsity constraints, such as decorrelation layers (e.g. zero-phase component analysis or Cholesky whitening) or regularization terms (e.g., L1 norm) in the loss function, may encourage the SFNet to learn improved features. Using a CNN architecture with a smaller receptive field (i.e., by eschewing pooling layers), which guarantees that learned features are localized to a small number of pixels, may also enhance interpretability of SFNets. To aid the physical interpretation of features, we could also deploy an activation maximization model to specifically hone in on activating features [olah2017feature]. ###### Acknowledgments. @@ -310,14 +238,10 @@ We thank Christian Jespersen, Charlie O'Neill, Joshua Peek, and Christine Ye for Modern deep neural networks are composed of many layers, each with many neurons. AI and ML researchers are actively seeking to understand the semantic meanings captured by these neurons. -Mechanistic interpretability is a subfield within AI/ML that aims to clarify the mechanisms by which deep neural networks learn - -[olah2020zoom,rai2024practicalreviewmechanisticinterpretability], usually in simplified settings (since studying all neurons in all layers at once is infeasible). +Mechanistic interpretability is a subfield within AI/ML that aims to clarify the mechanisms by which deep neural networks learn [olah2020zoom,rai2024practicalreviewmechanisticinterpretability], usually in simplified settings (since studying all neurons in all layers at once is infeasible). Given the rise of AI/ML techniques in the physical sciences, it is also vital to understand how and what our trained neural networks have learned. -However, it is challenging to decipher what features are represented by specific neurons, primarily due to two phenomena: superposition and polysemanticity - -[superposition]. +However, it is challenging to decipher what features are represented by specific neurons, primarily due to two phenomena: superposition and polysemanticity [superposition]. - Superposition is where semantic concepts (i.e., features) become distributed across many neurons. For example, a single feature like three-armed spiral galaxy can be spread out across multiple neurons (in one or even multiple layers). - Polysemanticity means that any given neuron can also have multiple separate meanings. These semantic concepts may not even be correlated with each other! For example, a specific neuron in a regularly trained CNN might activate on features such as three-armed spiral galaxy and $r$-band light bleed from nearby saturated star. @@ -326,15 +250,11 @@ So rather than a one-to-one mapping of neurons to features, or vice versa, there ### Sparse autoencoders and SFNets -Originally motivated by biological vision systems - -[OLSHAUSEN19973311,NIPS2007\_4daa3db3], sparse dictionary learning has emerged as a viable method for understanding (and consolidating) learned features into a small number of neurons. +Originally motivated by biological vision systems [OLSHAUSEN19973311,NIPS2007\_4daa3db3], sparse dictionary learning has emerged as a viable method for understanding (and consolidating) learned features into a small number of neurons. Algorithms such as sparse autoencoders [makhzani2014ksparseautoencoders,cunningham2023sparseautoencodershighlyinterpretable] are capable of explaining learned features in large language models [bricken2023monosemanticity,templeton2024scaling,2024arXiv240800657O] and deep convolutional neural networks [gorton2024missingcurvedetectorsinceptionv1]. These recent works have demonstrated that sparse algorithms can disentangle the features represented by deep neural networks. -Previous works with SAEs have typically operated on large, pretrained models and sought to extract the meanings of learned activations - -[bricken2023monosemanticity]. +Previous works with SAEs have typically operated on large, pretrained models and sought to extract the meanings of learned activations [bricken2023monosemanticity]. SAEs are tasked with reconstructing the uninterpretable mess of neuron activations from a specific network layer by learning a set of new sparse activations. However, SAEs only have two layers, which limits their ability to accurately distill the dense network activations into a few sparse ones. diff --git a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/arXiv-2501.01300v2_main.tex.itxt b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/arXiv-2501.01300v2_main.tex.itxt index f40394957b..a9c65d1972 100644 --- a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/arXiv-2501.01300v2_main.tex.itxt +++ b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/arXiv-2501.01300v2_main.tex.itxt @@ -23,90 +23,78 @@ S.Sharma et al. item-13 at level 1: text: _set:nn stm / mktitle nologo item-14 at level 1: section_header: Introduction item-15 at level 1: text: Lattice studies in the recent ye ... g resonances in the open charm sector. - item-16 at level 1: paragraph: Until now, lattice QCD predictio ... s at the chiral crossover temperature, - item-17 at level 1: text: ${T_{pc}=(156.5\pm1.5)}$ MeV [Ho ... charmed baryonic and mesonic sectors. - item-18 at level 1: paragraph: The chiral crossover also exhibi ... e of charm quark degrees of freedom at - item-19 at level 1: text: $T_{pc}$, arising due to the dis ... nd mesons across the chiral crossover. - item-20 at level 1: section_header: Calculating generalized susceptibilities on the lattice - item-21 at level 1: text: To project out the relevant degr ... ate derivatives of the total pressure, - item-22 at level 1: formula: P=\frac{T}{V}\ln Z(T,V,\hat{\mu} ... u}_Q,\hat{\mu}_S,\hat{\mu}_C) + item-16 at level 1: text: Until now, lattice QCD predictio ... charmed baryonic and mesonic sectors. + item-17 at level 1: text: The chiral crossover also exhibi ... nd mesons across the chiral crossover. + item-18 at level 1: section_header: Calculating generalized susceptibilities on the lattice + item-19 at level 1: text: To project out the relevant degr ... ate derivatives of the total pressure, + item-20 at level 1: formula: P=\frac{T}{V}\ln Z(T,V,\hat{\mu} ... u}_Q,\hat{\mu}_S,\hat{\mu}_C) \; , - item-23 at level 1: text: which contains contributions fro ... ber combinations one is interested in, - item-24 at level 1: formula: {\chi^{BQSC}_{klmn}=\dfrac{\part ... bigg|_{\overrightarrow{\mu}=0}\text{,} - item-25 at level 1: text: where $\vec{\mu}=(\mu_B, \mu_Q, ... the zero subscript will be suppressed. - item-26 at level 1: paragraph: Generalized susceptibilities up ... generated by the HotQCD collaboration - item-27 at level 1: text: [Bollweg:2021vqf] for the physic ... e random noise method [Mitra:2022vtf]. - item-28 at level 1: paragraph: Lattice cutoff effects cancel to ... f various generalized susceptibilities - item-29 at level 1: text: [Bazavov:2023xzm]. These ratios, ... e given in a forthcoming publication. - item-30 at level 1: section_header: Boltzmann Approximation - item-31 at level 1: section: group figure - item-32 at level 2: picture - item-32 at level 3: caption: Image: BQSC-1003.pdf - item-33 at level 2: picture - item-33 at level 3: caption: Image: D-BQSC-0004-1003.pdf - item-34 at level 2: text: Comparison of QM-HRG and PDG-HRG ... present $T_{pc}$ with its uncertainty. - item-35 at level 1: caption: Image: BQSC-1003.pdf - item-36 at level 1: caption: Image: D-BQSC-0004-1003.pdf - item-37 at level 1: section_header: Charmed Hadrons - item-38 at level 1: text: Hadron resonance gas model (HRG) ... e the following forms [Allton:2005gk]: - item-39 at level 1: formula: \begin{gather} + item-21 at level 1: text: which contains contributions fro ... ber combinations one is interested in, + item-22 at level 1: formula: {\chi^{BQSC}_{klmn}=\dfrac{\part ... bigg|_{\overrightarrow{\mu}=0}\text{,} + item-23 at level 1: text: where $\vec{\mu}=(\mu_B, \mu_Q, ... the zero subscript will be suppressed. + item-24 at level 1: text: Generalized susceptibilities up ... e random noise method [Mitra:2022vtf]. + item-25 at level 1: text: Lattice cutoff effects cancel to ... e given in a forthcoming publication. + item-26 at level 1: section_header: Boltzmann Approximation + item-27 at level 1: section: group figure + item-28 at level 2: picture + item-28 at level 3: caption: Image: BQSC-1003.pdf + item-29 at level 2: picture + item-29 at level 3: caption: Image: D-BQSC-0004-1003.pdf + item-30 at level 2: text: Comparison of QM-HRG and PDG-HRG ... present $T_{pc}$ with its uncertainty. + item-31 at level 1: caption: Image: BQSC-1003.pdf + item-32 at level 1: caption: Image: D-BQSC-0004-1003.pdf + item-33 at level 1: section_header: Charmed Hadrons + item-34 at level 1: text: Hadron resonance gas model (HRG) ... e the following forms [Allton:2005gk]: + item-35 at level 1: formula: \begin{gather} \begin{aligned} ... ext{ .} \end{aligned} \end{gather} - item-40 at level 1: paragraph: In above equations, at a given t ... C-mesons/baryons) with masses given by - item-41 at level 1: text: ${m_i}$; degeneracy factors of t ... \chi_2^C\approx\chi_n^C$, for $n$even. - item-42 at level 1: paragraph: Charm fluctuations calculated in ... predicted via Quark-Model calculations - item-43 at level 1: text: [Ebert:2009ua, Ebert:2011kk, Che ... jym,Chen:2017gnu] have confirmed this. - item-44 at level 1: section_header: Charm Quarks - item-45 at level 1: text: Charm quarks offer an advantage ... uark pressure, $P^C_{q}$, is given by, - item-46 at level 1: formula: P^C_{q}(T,\overrightarrow{\mu})& ... at{\mu}_B+\hat{\mu}_C\bigg) \text { ,} - item-47 at level 1: text: where $m_q^C$is the pole mass of ... quark, and the degeneracy factor is 6. - item-48 at level 1: section_header: Enhancement of charmed hadrons - item-49 at level 1: section: group figure - item-50 at level 2: picture - item-50 at level 3: caption: Image: P_B.pdf - item-51 at level 2: picture - item-51 at level 3: caption: Image: P_M.pdf - item-52 at level 2: text: Shown are partial charmed baryon ... present $T_{pc}$ with its uncertainty. - item-53 at level 1: caption: Image: P_B.pdf - item-54 at level 1: caption: Image: P_M.pdf - item-55 at level 1: text: To investigate the nature of cha ... sure based on Ref.[Mukherjee:2015mxc], - item-56 at level 1: formula: \begin{align} + item-36 at level 1: text: In above equations, at a given t ... \chi_2^C\approx\chi_n^C$, for $n$even. + item-37 at level 1: text: Charm fluctuations calculated in ... jym,Chen:2017gnu] have confirmed this. + item-38 at level 1: section_header: Charm Quarks + item-39 at level 1: text: Charm quarks offer an advantage ... uark pressure, $P^C_{q}$, is given by, + item-40 at level 1: formula: P^C_{q}(T,\overrightarrow{\mu})& ... at{\mu}_B+\hat{\mu}_C\bigg) \text { ,} + item-41 at level 1: text: where $m_q^C$is the pole mass of ... quark, and the degeneracy factor is 6. + item-42 at level 1: section_header: Enhancement of charmed hadrons + item-43 at level 1: section: group figure + item-44 at level 2: picture + item-44 at level 3: caption: Image: P_B.pdf + item-45 at level 2: picture + item-45 at level 3: caption: Image: P_M.pdf + item-46 at level 2: text: Shown are partial charmed baryon ... present $T_{pc}$ with its uncertainty. + item-47 at level 1: caption: Image: P_B.pdf + item-48 at level 1: caption: Image: P_M.pdf + item-49 at level 1: text: To investigate the nature of cha ... sure based on Ref.[Mukherjee:2015mxc], + item-50 at level 1: formula: \begin{align} P_C(T,\vec{\mu})= ... ^C_{q}(T,\vec{\mu}) \, . \end{align} - item-57 at level 1: text: In our recent works [Bazavov:202 ... neralized susceptibilities as follows, - item-58 at level 1: formula: \begin{align} + item-51 at level 1: text: In our recent works [Bazavov:202 ... neralized susceptibilities as follows, + item-52 at level 1: formula: \begin{align} P^C_{q}&=9(\chi^{ ... 22}-4\chi^{BC}_{13} \; . \end{align} - item-59 at level 1: text: Note that in the validity regime ... chi^4_C-\chi^{BC}_{13}$, respectively. - item-60 at level 1: paragraph: Continuum estimates for charmed ... meson partial pressures shown in Fig. - item-61 at level 1: text: [fig:enhan] are obtained by mult ... ictions quoted in Fig. [fig:barCmesC]. - item-62 at level 1: section_header: Charm degrees of freedom in QGP - item-63 at level 1: section: group figure - item-64 at level 2: picture - item-64 at level 3: caption: Image: P_q.pdf - item-65 at level 2: picture - item-65 at level 3: caption: Image: m_q.pdf - item-66 at level 2: text: Shown is the partial pressure co ... present $T_{pc}$ with its uncertainty. - item-67 at level 1: caption: Image: P_q.pdf - item-68 at level 1: caption: Image: m_q.pdf - item-69 at level 1: text: Fig. [fig:Pq] [Left] shows that ... dron-like excitations will go to zero. - item-70 at level 1: paragraph: Departure of charmed hadronic pr ... charmed hadrons start dissociating at - item-71 at level 1: text: $T_{pc}$, whereas the ground sta ... d baryons missing from the PDG record. - item-72 at level 1: paragraph: In the coexistence phase of charmed hadron and quark-like excitations, - item-73 at level 1: text: $m^C_q$ in Eq. [eq:Qc] becomes t ... l become the pole mass of charm quark. - item-74 at level 1: section_header: Conclusions - item-75 at level 1: text: In this work, for the first time ... omplete than the charmed meson sector. - item-76 at level 1: paragraph: We showed that above chiral cros ... citations. At the highest temperature, - item-77 at level 1: text: $T \sim 176$ MeV, studied by us, ... can exist in Quark Gluon Plasma (QGP). - item-78 at level 1: section_header: Acknowledgments - item-79 at level 1: paragraph: This work was supported by The D ... f Nuclear Physics through Contract No. - item-80 at level 1: text: DE-SC0012704 and the Topical Col ... lefeld HPC.NRW team for their support. - item-81 at level 1: paragraph: All computations in this work were performed using - item-82 at level 1: text: SIMULATeQCD code [HotQCD:2023ghu ... HotQCD Collaboration [Clarke:2023sfy]. - item-83 at level 1: text: cas-model2-names - item-84 at level 1: text: refs \ No newline at end of file + item-53 at level 1: text: Note that in the validity regime ... chi^4_C-\chi^{BC}_{13}$, respectively. + item-54 at level 1: text: Continuum estimates for charmed ... ictions quoted in Fig. [fig:barCmesC]. + item-55 at level 1: section_header: Charm degrees of freedom in QGP + item-56 at level 1: section: group figure + item-57 at level 2: picture + item-57 at level 3: caption: Image: P_q.pdf + item-58 at level 2: picture + item-58 at level 3: caption: Image: m_q.pdf + item-59 at level 2: text: Shown is the partial pressure co ... present $T_{pc}$ with its uncertainty. + item-60 at level 1: caption: Image: P_q.pdf + item-61 at level 1: caption: Image: m_q.pdf + item-62 at level 1: text: Fig. [fig:Pq] [Left] shows that ... dron-like excitations will go to zero. + item-63 at level 1: text: Departure of charmed hadronic pr ... d baryons missing from the PDG record. + item-64 at level 1: text: In the coexistence phase of char ... l become the pole mass of charm quark. + item-65 at level 1: section_header: Conclusions + item-66 at level 1: text: In this work, for the first time ... omplete than the charmed meson sector. + item-67 at level 1: text: We showed that above chiral cros ... can exist in Quark Gluon Plasma (QGP). + item-68 at level 1: section_header: Acknowledgments + item-69 at level 1: text: This work was supported by The D ... lefeld HPC.NRW team for their support. + item-70 at level 1: text: All computations in this work we ... HotQCD Collaboration [Clarke:2023sfy]. + item-71 at level 1: text: cas-model2-names + item-72 at level 1: text: refs \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/arXiv-2501.01300v2_main.tex.json b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/arXiv-2501.01300v2_main.tex.json index 2caa780d5a..b153893b69 100644 --- a/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/arXiv-2501.01300v2_main.tex.json +++ b/tests/data/groundtruth/docling_v2/arXiv-2501.01300v2_main.tex.json @@ -91,26 +91,26 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/25" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/26" + "$ref": "#/groups/0" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/27" + "$ref": "#/texts/26" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/28" + "$ref": "#/texts/27" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/29" }, - { - "$ref": "#/groups/0" - }, { "$ref": "#/texts/30" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/31" }, + { + "$ref": "#/texts/32" + }, { "$ref": "#/texts/33" }, @@ -130,13 +130,13 @@ "$ref": "#/texts/38" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/39" + "$ref": "#/groups/1" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/40" + "$ref": "#/texts/39" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/41" + "$ref": "#/texts/40" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/42" @@ -147,26 +147,26 @@ { "$ref": "#/texts/44" }, - { - "$ref": "#/groups/1" - }, { "$ref": "#/texts/45" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/46" }, + { + "$ref": "#/texts/47" + }, { "$ref": "#/texts/48" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/49" + "$ref": "#/groups/2" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/50" + "$ref": "#/texts/49" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/51" + "$ref": "#/texts/50" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/52" @@ -180,15 +180,15 @@ { "$ref": "#/texts/55" }, - { - "$ref": "#/groups/2" - }, { "$ref": "#/texts/56" }, { "$ref": "#/texts/57" }, + { + "$ref": "#/texts/58" + }, { "$ref": "#/texts/59" }, @@ -200,42 +200,6 @@ }, { "$ref": "#/texts/62" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/63" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/64" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/65" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/66" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/67" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/68" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/69" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/70" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/71" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/72" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/73" - }, - { - "$ref": "#/texts/74" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -256,7 +220,7 @@ "$ref": "#/pictures/1" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/32" + "$ref": "#/texts/28" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -276,7 +240,7 @@ "$ref": "#/pictures/3" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/47" + "$ref": "#/texts/41" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -296,7 +260,7 @@ "$ref": "#/pictures/5" }, { - "$ref": "#/texts/58" + "$ref": "#/texts/51" } ], "content_layer": "body", @@ -494,10 +458,10 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", + "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "Until now, lattice QCD predictions of missing resonances have been based solely on the ratios of generalized charm susceptibilities. This approach, however, could not provide a quantitative measure of enhancement in individual quantum number channels. The reason lattice QCD studies had to resort to ratios of generalized susceptibilities rather then the susceptibilities themselves is because\ncontrolling the cutoff effects in the latter is challenging due to the relatively large charm quark mass. In this study, for the first time, we use our continuum extrapolated lattice QCD results to explicitly determine enhancement factors at the chiral crossover temperature,", - "text": "Until now, lattice QCD predictions of missing resonances have been based solely on the ratios of generalized charm susceptibilities. This approach, however, could not provide a quantitative measure of enhancement in individual quantum number channels. The reason lattice QCD studies had to resort to ratios of generalized susceptibilities rather then the susceptibilities themselves is because\ncontrolling the cutoff effects in the latter is challenging due to the relatively large charm quark mass. In this study, for the first time, we use our continuum extrapolated lattice QCD results to explicitly determine enhancement factors at the chiral crossover temperature," + "orig": "Until now, lattice QCD predictions of missing resonances have been based solely on the ratios of generalized charm susceptibilities. This approach, however, could not provide a quantitative measure of enhancement in individual quantum number channels. The reason lattice QCD studies had to resort to ratios of generalized susceptibilities rather then the susceptibilities themselves is because\ncontrolling the cutoff effects in the latter is challenging due to the relatively large charm quark mass. In this study, for the first time, we use our continuum extrapolated lattice QCD results to explicitly determine enhancement factors at the chiral crossover temperature, ${T_{pc}=(156.5\\pm1.5)}$ MeV [HotQCD:2018pds, Borsanyi:2020fev], for both the charmed baryonic and mesonic sectors.", + "text": "Until now, lattice QCD predictions of missing resonances have been based solely on the ratios of generalized charm susceptibilities. This approach, however, could not provide a quantitative measure of enhancement in individual quantum number channels. The reason lattice QCD studies had to resort to ratios of generalized susceptibilities rather then the susceptibilities themselves is because\ncontrolling the cutoff effects in the latter is challenging due to the relatively large charm quark mass. In this study, for the first time, we use our continuum extrapolated lattice QCD results to explicitly determine enhancement factors at the chiral crossover temperature, ${T_{pc}=(156.5\\pm1.5)}$ MeV [HotQCD:2018pds, Borsanyi:2020fev], for both the charmed baryonic and mesonic sectors." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/16", @@ -508,8 +472,8 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "${T_{pc}=(156.5\\pm1.5)}$ MeV [HotQCD:2018pds, Borsanyi:2020fev], for both the charmed baryonic and mesonic sectors.", - "text": "${T_{pc}=(156.5\\pm1.5)}$ MeV [HotQCD:2018pds, Borsanyi:2020fev], for both the charmed baryonic and mesonic sectors." + "orig": "The chiral crossover also exhibits deconfining feature in the charm quark sector, i.e. charm quarks as new degrees of freedom start appearing at or close to the pseudo-critical temperature of chiral symmetry restoration (Bazavov et al. (2024)). Clearly the appearance of charm quark degrees of freedom at $T_{pc}$, arising due to the disappearance of some hadronic states, will also liberate light quark degrees of freedom, although in the chiral limit this may not directly be related to the universal aspects of the chiral phase transition. The partial charm hadronic pressures start to deviate from the HRG model prediction, but not all charmed\nhadrons dissociate at $T_{pc}$. Furthermore, recent lattice QCD studies provide compelling evidence for the survival of charmed hadrons above the chiral crossover temperature [Bazavov:2023xzm, Sharma:2024ucs, Sharma:2024edf]. In this paper, we investigate the gradual deconfinement of charmed hadrons by analyzing continuum extrapolated proxies for partial pressures of charmed baryons and mesons across the chiral crossover.", + "text": "The chiral crossover also exhibits deconfining feature in the charm quark sector, i.e. charm quarks as new degrees of freedom start appearing at or close to the pseudo-critical temperature of chiral symmetry restoration (Bazavov et al. (2024)). Clearly the appearance of charm quark degrees of freedom at $T_{pc}$, arising due to the disappearance of some hadronic states, will also liberate light quark degrees of freedom, although in the chiral limit this may not directly be related to the universal aspects of the chiral phase transition. The partial charm hadronic pressures start to deviate from the HRG model prediction, but not all charmed\nhadrons dissociate at $T_{pc}$. Furthermore, recent lattice QCD studies provide compelling evidence for the survival of charmed hadrons above the chiral crossover temperature [Bazavov:2023xzm, Sharma:2024ucs, Sharma:2024edf]. In this paper, we investigate the gradual deconfinement of charmed hadrons by analyzing continuum extrapolated proxies for partial pressures of charmed baryons and mesons across the chiral crossover." }, { "self_ref": "#/texts/17", @@ -518,30 +482,6 @@ }, "children": [], "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "The chiral crossover also exhibits deconfining feature in the charm quark sector, i.e. charm quarks as new degrees of freedom start appearing at or close to the pseudo-critical temperature of chiral symmetry restoration (Bazavov et al. (2024)). Clearly the appearance of charm quark degrees of freedom at", - "text": "The chiral crossover also exhibits deconfining feature in the charm quark sector, i.e. charm quarks as new degrees of freedom start appearing at or close to the pseudo-critical temperature of chiral symmetry restoration (Bazavov et al. (2024)). Clearly the appearance of charm quark degrees of freedom at" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/18", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "text", - "prov": [], - "orig": "$T_{pc}$, arising due to the disappearance of some hadronic states, will also liberate light quark degrees of freedom, although in the chiral limit this may not directly be related to the universal aspects of the chiral phase transition. The partial charm hadronic pressures start to deviate from the HRG model prediction, but not all charmed\nhadrons dissociate at $T_{pc}$. Furthermore, recent lattice QCD studies provide compelling evidence for the survival of charmed hadrons above the chiral crossover temperature [Bazavov:2023xzm, Sharma:2024ucs, Sharma:2024edf]. In this paper, we investigate the gradual deconfinement of charmed hadrons by analyzing continuum extrapolated proxies for partial pressures of charmed baryons and mesons across the chiral crossover.", - "text": "$T_{pc}$, arising due to the disappearance of some hadronic states, will also liberate light quark degrees of freedom, although in the chiral limit this may not directly be related to the universal aspects of the chiral phase transition. The partial charm hadronic pressures start to deviate from the HRG model prediction, but not all charmed\nhadrons dissociate at $T_{pc}$. Furthermore, recent lattice QCD studies provide compelling evidence for the survival of charmed hadrons above the chiral crossover temperature [Bazavov:2023xzm, Sharma:2024ucs, Sharma:2024edf]. In this paper, we investigate the gradual deconfinement of charmed hadrons by analyzing continuum extrapolated proxies for partial pressures of charmed baryons and mesons across the chiral crossover." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/19", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", "label": "section_header", "prov": [], "orig": "Calculating generalized susceptibilities on the lattice", @@ -549,7 +489,7 @@ "level": 1 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/20", + "self_ref": "#/texts/18", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -561,7 +501,7 @@ "text": "To project out the relevant degrees of freedom in the charm sector, one calculates the generalized susceptibilities, ${\\chi^{BQSC}_{klmn}}$, of the conserved charges: baryon number, $B$, electric charge, $Q$, strangeness, $S$, and charm, $C$. This involves taking appropriate derivatives of the total pressure," }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/21", + "self_ref": "#/texts/19", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -573,7 +513,7 @@ "text": "P=\\frac{T}{V}\\ln Z(T,V,\\hat{\\mu}_B,\\hat{\\mu}_Q,\\hat{\\mu}_S,\\hat{\\mu}_C)\n \\; ," }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/22", + "self_ref": "#/texts/20", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -585,7 +525,7 @@ "text": "which contains contributions from the total charm pressure, $P_C$. These derivatives are taken with respect to the chemical potentials, ${\\hat{\\mu}_X = \\mu_X/T}$, ${\\forall X \\in \\{B, Q, S, C\\}}$, of the quantum number combinations one is interested in," }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/23", + "self_ref": "#/texts/21", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -597,7 +537,7 @@ "text": "{\\chi^{BQSC}_{klmn}=\\dfrac{\\partial^{(k+l+m+n)}\\;\\;[P\\;(\\hat{\\mu}_B,\\hat{\\mu}_Q,\\hat{\\mu}_S,\\hat{\\mu}_C)\\;/T^4]}{\\partial\\hat{\\mu}^{k}_B\\;\\;\\partial\\hat{\\mu}^{l}_Q\\;\\;\\partial\\hat{\\mu}^{m}_S\\;\\;\\partial\\hat{\\mu}^{n}_C}}\\bigg|_{\\overrightarrow{\\mu}=0}\\text{,}" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/24", + "self_ref": "#/texts/22", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -609,19 +549,7 @@ "text": "where $\\vec{\\mu}=(\\mu_B, \\mu_Q, \\mu_S, \\mu_C)$. \nNote that ${\\chi^{BQSC}_{klmn}}$ will be non-zero only for ${(k+l+m+n) \\in \\text{even}}$. In the following, if the subscript corresponding to a conserved charge is zero in the\nleft hand side of Eq. [eq:chi], then both the corresponding superscript as well the zero subscript will be suppressed." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/25", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Generalized susceptibilities up to fourth order have been calculated on the (2+1)-flavor HISQ (Highly Improved Staggered Quark) gauge configurations generated by the HotQCD collaboration", - "text": "Generalized susceptibilities up to fourth order have been calculated on the (2+1)-flavor HISQ (Highly Improved Staggered Quark) gauge configurations generated by the HotQCD collaboration" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/26", + "self_ref": "#/texts/23", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -629,23 +557,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[Bollweg:2021vqf] for the physical strange to light quark mass ratio, ${m_s/m_{l}}=27$. The temperature scale was set using the $f_K$ scale [Bollweg:2021vqf]. \nThe charm-quark sector has been treated in the quenched approximation. We use HISQ action with epsilon term for charm quark to remove $\\mathcal{O}((am_c)^4)$ tree-level lattice artifacts [Follana:2006rc]. This setup is known to have small discretization effects for charm quark related observables [Follana:2006rc,MILC:2010pul]. The calculation of $\\chi^{BQSC}_{klmn}$ involves derivatives of the pressure and on the lattice this is achieved by the unbiased stochastic estimation of various traces consisting of inversions and derivatives of the fermion matrices ($D$) using the random noise method [Mitra:2022vtf].", - "text": "[Bollweg:2021vqf] for the physical strange to light quark mass ratio, ${m_s/m_{l}}=27$. The temperature scale was set using the $f_K$ scale [Bollweg:2021vqf]. \nThe charm-quark sector has been treated in the quenched approximation. We use HISQ action with epsilon term for charm quark to remove $\\mathcal{O}((am_c)^4)$ tree-level lattice artifacts [Follana:2006rc]. This setup is known to have small discretization effects for charm quark related observables [Follana:2006rc,MILC:2010pul]. The calculation of $\\chi^{BQSC}_{klmn}$ involves derivatives of the pressure and on the lattice this is achieved by the unbiased stochastic estimation of various traces consisting of inversions and derivatives of the fermion matrices ($D$) using the random noise method [Mitra:2022vtf]." + "orig": "Generalized susceptibilities up to fourth order have been calculated on the (2+1)-flavor HISQ (Highly Improved Staggered Quark) gauge configurations generated by the HotQCD collaboration [Bollweg:2021vqf] for the physical strange to light quark mass ratio, ${m_s/m_{l}}=27$. The temperature scale was set using the $f_K$ scale [Bollweg:2021vqf]. \nThe charm-quark sector has been treated in the quenched approximation. We use HISQ action with epsilon term for charm quark to remove $\\mathcal{O}((am_c)^4)$ tree-level lattice artifacts [Follana:2006rc]. This setup is known to have small discretization effects for charm quark related observables [Follana:2006rc,MILC:2010pul]. The calculation of $\\chi^{BQSC}_{klmn}$ involves derivatives of the pressure and on the lattice this is achieved by the unbiased stochastic estimation of various traces consisting of inversions and derivatives of the fermion matrices ($D$) using the random noise method [Mitra:2022vtf].", + "text": "Generalized susceptibilities up to fourth order have been calculated on the (2+1)-flavor HISQ (Highly Improved Staggered Quark) gauge configurations generated by the HotQCD collaboration [Bollweg:2021vqf] for the physical strange to light quark mass ratio, ${m_s/m_{l}}=27$. The temperature scale was set using the $f_K$ scale [Bollweg:2021vqf]. \nThe charm-quark sector has been treated in the quenched approximation. We use HISQ action with epsilon term for charm quark to remove $\\mathcal{O}((am_c)^4)$ tree-level lattice artifacts [Follana:2006rc]. This setup is known to have small discretization effects for charm quark related observables [Follana:2006rc,MILC:2010pul]. The calculation of $\\chi^{BQSC}_{klmn}$ involves derivatives of the pressure and on the lattice this is achieved by the unbiased stochastic estimation of various traces consisting of inversions and derivatives of the fermion matrices ($D$) using the random noise method [Mitra:2022vtf]." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/27", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Lattice cutoff effects cancel to a large extent in the ratios of various generalized susceptibilities", - "text": "Lattice cutoff effects cancel to a large extent in the ratios of various generalized susceptibilities" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/28", + "self_ref": "#/texts/24", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -653,11 +569,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[Bazavov:2023xzm]. These ratios, even though calculated on lattices with a finite lattice spacing, $a$, are close to\nthe continuum limit results. Therefore, in this work we use generalized susceptibilities normalized by $\\chi^C_4$ calculated on lattices with a fixed temporal extent, $N_\\tau=8$, where $N_\\tau=(aT)^{-1}$. In order to understand the cut-off effects due to heavier charm quark, we used two different Lines of Constant Physics (LCPs) to tune the bare charm quark mass $am_c$. The first LCP (LCP$_{[a]}$) corresponds to keeping the spin-averaged charmonium mass, ${(3m_{J/\\psi}+m_{\\eta_{c\\bar{c}}})/4}$, fixed to its physical value [Sharma:2022ztl]. The second LCP (LCP$_{[b]}$) is defined by the physical (PDG) charm to strange quark mass ratio, $m_c/m_s=11.76$ [ParticleDataGroup:2022pth]. Further details of the charm-quark mass tuning and parametrization can be found in [Sharma:2024ucs]. Here we use ratios of generalized susceptibilities calculated on lattices with temporal extent $N_\\tau=8$ on LCP$_{[b]}$ because of their relatively smaller errors. To convert generalized susceptibilities normalized by $\\chi^C_4$ into absolute numbers we use continuum extrapolated results for $\\chi^C_4$. Details of the continuum extrapolation will be given in a forthcoming publication.", - "text": "[Bazavov:2023xzm]. These ratios, even though calculated on lattices with a finite lattice spacing, $a$, are close to\nthe continuum limit results. Therefore, in this work we use generalized susceptibilities normalized by $\\chi^C_4$ calculated on lattices with a fixed temporal extent, $N_\\tau=8$, where $N_\\tau=(aT)^{-1}$. In order to understand the cut-off effects due to heavier charm quark, we used two different Lines of Constant Physics (LCPs) to tune the bare charm quark mass $am_c$. The first LCP (LCP$_{[a]}$) corresponds to keeping the spin-averaged charmonium mass, ${(3m_{J/\\psi}+m_{\\eta_{c\\bar{c}}})/4}$, fixed to its physical value [Sharma:2022ztl]. The second LCP (LCP$_{[b]}$) is defined by the physical (PDG) charm to strange quark mass ratio, $m_c/m_s=11.76$ [ParticleDataGroup:2022pth]. Further details of the charm-quark mass tuning and parametrization can be found in [Sharma:2024ucs]. Here we use ratios of generalized susceptibilities calculated on lattices with temporal extent $N_\\tau=8$ on LCP$_{[b]}$ because of their relatively smaller errors. To convert generalized susceptibilities normalized by $\\chi^C_4$ into absolute numbers we use continuum extrapolated results for $\\chi^C_4$. Details of the continuum extrapolation will be given in a forthcoming publication." + "orig": "Lattice cutoff effects cancel to a large extent in the ratios of various generalized susceptibilities [Bazavov:2023xzm]. These ratios, even though calculated on lattices with a finite lattice spacing, $a$, are close to\nthe continuum limit results. Therefore, in this work we use generalized susceptibilities normalized by $\\chi^C_4$ calculated on lattices with a fixed temporal extent, $N_\\tau=8$, where $N_\\tau=(aT)^{-1}$. In order to understand the cut-off effects due to heavier charm quark, we used two different Lines of Constant Physics (LCPs) to tune the bare charm quark mass $am_c$. The first LCP (LCP$_{[a]}$) corresponds to keeping the spin-averaged charmonium mass, ${(3m_{J/\\psi}+m_{\\eta_{c\\bar{c}}})/4}$, fixed to its physical value [Sharma:2022ztl]. The second LCP (LCP$_{[b]}$) is defined by the physical (PDG) charm to strange quark mass ratio, $m_c/m_s=11.76$ [ParticleDataGroup:2022pth]. Further details of the charm-quark mass tuning and parametrization can be found in [Sharma:2024ucs]. Here we use ratios of generalized susceptibilities calculated on lattices with temporal extent $N_\\tau=8$ on LCP$_{[b]}$ because of their relatively smaller errors. To convert generalized susceptibilities normalized by $\\chi^C_4$ into absolute numbers we use continuum extrapolated results for $\\chi^C_4$. Details of the continuum extrapolation will be given in a forthcoming publication.", + "text": "Lattice cutoff effects cancel to a large extent in the ratios of various generalized susceptibilities [Bazavov:2023xzm]. These ratios, even though calculated on lattices with a finite lattice spacing, $a$, are close to\nthe continuum limit results. Therefore, in this work we use generalized susceptibilities normalized by $\\chi^C_4$ calculated on lattices with a fixed temporal extent, $N_\\tau=8$, where $N_\\tau=(aT)^{-1}$. In order to understand the cut-off effects due to heavier charm quark, we used two different Lines of Constant Physics (LCPs) to tune the bare charm quark mass $am_c$. The first LCP (LCP$_{[a]}$) corresponds to keeping the spin-averaged charmonium mass, ${(3m_{J/\\psi}+m_{\\eta_{c\\bar{c}}})/4}$, fixed to its physical value [Sharma:2022ztl]. The second LCP (LCP$_{[b]}$) is defined by the physical (PDG) charm to strange quark mass ratio, $m_c/m_s=11.76$ [ParticleDataGroup:2022pth]. Further details of the charm-quark mass tuning and parametrization can be found in [Sharma:2024ucs]. Here we use ratios of generalized susceptibilities calculated on lattices with temporal extent $N_\\tau=8$ on LCP$_{[b]}$ because of their relatively smaller errors. To convert generalized susceptibilities normalized by $\\chi^C_4$ into absolute numbers we use continuum extrapolated results for $\\chi^C_4$. Details of the continuum extrapolation will be given in a forthcoming publication." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/29", + "self_ref": "#/texts/25", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -670,7 +586,7 @@ "level": 1 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/30", + "self_ref": "#/texts/26", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -682,7 +598,7 @@ "text": "Image: BQSC-1003.pdf" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/31", + "self_ref": "#/texts/27", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -694,7 +610,7 @@ "text": "Image: D-BQSC-0004-1003.pdf" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/32", + "self_ref": "#/texts/28", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/0" }, @@ -706,7 +622,7 @@ "text": "Comparison of QM-HRG and PDG-HRG predictions for charmed baryons [Left] and charmed mesons [Right]. $\\Delta=100 |1-\\text{QM-HRG}/\\text{PDG-HRG}|_{T_{pc}}$. The yellow bands represent $T_{pc}$ with its uncertainty." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/33", + "self_ref": "#/texts/29", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -719,7 +635,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/34", + "self_ref": "#/texts/30", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -731,7 +647,7 @@ "text": "Hadron resonance gas model (HRG) has been successful in describing the particle abundance ratios measured in the heavy-ion experiments. It describes a non-interacting gas of hadron resonances, and therefore can be used to calculate the hadronic pressure below ${T_{pc}}$ [ANDRONIC2019759]. In the Boltzmann approximation, the dimensionless partial pressures from the charmed meson, ${P^C_{M}},$ and the charmed baryon, ${P^C_{B}}$, sectors take the following forms [Allton:2005gk]:" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/35", + "self_ref": "#/texts/31", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -743,19 +659,7 @@ "text": "\\begin{gather}\n\t\\begin{aligned}\n\t\t{P^C_{M}(T,\\overrightarrow{\\mu})}&{=\\dfrac{1}{2\\pi^2}\\sum_{i\\in \\text{C-mesons}}g_i \\bigg(\\dfrac{m_i}{T}\\bigg)^2K_2(m_i/T)}\\\\\n\t\t\t&{\\text{cosh}(Q_i\\hat{\\mu}_Q+S_i\\hat{\\mu}_S+C_i\\hat{\\mu}_C)} \\text{ ,}\\\\\n\t\t{P^C_{B}(T,\\overrightarrow{\\mu})}&={\\dfrac{1}{2\\pi^2}\\sum_{i\\in \\text{C-baryons}}g_i \\bigg(\\dfrac{m_i}{T}\\bigg)^2K_2(m_i/T)}\\\\\n\t\t\t&{\\text{cosh}(B_i\\hat{\\mu}_B+Q_i\\hat{\\mu}_Q+S_i\\hat{\\mu}_S+C_i\\hat{\\mu}_C)} \\text{ .}\n\t\t\n\t\\end{aligned}\n\\end{gather}" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/36", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "In above equations, at a given temperature, the summation is over all charmed mesons/baryons (C-mesons/baryons) with masses given by", - "text": "In above equations, at a given temperature, the summation is over all charmed mesons/baryons (C-mesons/baryons) with masses given by" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/37", + "self_ref": "#/texts/32", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -763,23 +667,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "${m_i}$; degeneracy factors of the states with equal mass and same quantum numbers are represented by ${g_i}$; ${K_2(x)}$ is a modified Bessel function, which for a large argument can be approximated by\n${K_2(x)}\\sim\\sqrt{\\pi/2x}\\;e^{-x}\\;[1+\\mathbb{O}(x^{-1})]$. Consequently, if a charmed state under consideration is much heavier than the relevant temperature scale, such that ${m_i\\gg T}$, then the contribution to ${P_C}$ from that particular state will be exponentially suppressed, e.g., the singly-charmed\n${\\Lambda}_c^{+}$ baryon has a PDG mass of about $2286$MeV, whereas the doubly-charmed ${\\Xi_{cc}^{++}}$ baryon's mass as tabulated in PDG records is about $3621$ MeV, hence at ${T_{pc}}$, the contribution to ${P^C_{B}}$ from ${\\Xi_{cc}^{++}}$ will be suppressed by a factor of $10^{-4}$ in relation to ${\\Lambda}_c^{+}$ contribution. Therefore, in the validity regime of Boltzmann approximation, substituting Eq. [eq:McBc] in Eq. [eq:chi] implies $P_C(T,\\vec{\\mu})\\approx\\chi_2^C\\approx\\chi_n^C$, for $n$even.", - "text": "${m_i}$; degeneracy factors of the states with equal mass and same quantum numbers are represented by ${g_i}$; ${K_2(x)}$ is a modified Bessel function, which for a large argument can be approximated by\n${K_2(x)}\\sim\\sqrt{\\pi/2x}\\;e^{-x}\\;[1+\\mathbb{O}(x^{-1})]$. Consequently, if a charmed state under consideration is much heavier than the relevant temperature scale, such that ${m_i\\gg T}$, then the contribution to ${P_C}$ from that particular state will be exponentially suppressed, e.g., the singly-charmed\n${\\Lambda}_c^{+}$ baryon has a PDG mass of about $2286$MeV, whereas the doubly-charmed ${\\Xi_{cc}^{++}}$ baryon's mass as tabulated in PDG records is about $3621$ MeV, hence at ${T_{pc}}$, the contribution to ${P^C_{B}}$ from ${\\Xi_{cc}^{++}}$ will be suppressed by a factor of $10^{-4}$ in relation to ${\\Lambda}_c^{+}$ contribution. Therefore, in the validity regime of Boltzmann approximation, substituting Eq. [eq:McBc] in Eq. [eq:chi] implies $P_C(T,\\vec{\\mu})\\approx\\chi_2^C\\approx\\chi_n^C$, for $n$even." + "orig": "In above equations, at a given temperature, the summation is over all charmed mesons/baryons (C-mesons/baryons) with masses given by ${m_i}$; degeneracy factors of the states with equal mass and same quantum numbers are represented by ${g_i}$; ${K_2(x)}$ is a modified Bessel function, which for a large argument can be approximated by\n${K_2(x)}\\sim\\sqrt{\\pi/2x}\\;e^{-x}\\;[1+\\mathbb{O}(x^{-1})]$. Consequently, if a charmed state under consideration is much heavier than the relevant temperature scale, such that ${m_i\\gg T}$, then the contribution to ${P_C}$ from that particular state will be exponentially suppressed, e.g., the singly-charmed\n${\\Lambda}_c^{+}$ baryon has a PDG mass of about $2286$MeV, whereas the doubly-charmed ${\\Xi_{cc}^{++}}$ baryon's mass as tabulated in PDG records is about $3621$ MeV, hence at ${T_{pc}}$, the contribution to ${P^C_{B}}$ from ${\\Xi_{cc}^{++}}$ will be suppressed by a factor of $10^{-4}$ in relation to ${\\Lambda}_c^{+}$ contribution. Therefore, in the validity regime of Boltzmann approximation, substituting Eq. [eq:McBc] in Eq. [eq:chi] implies $P_C(T,\\vec{\\mu})\\approx\\chi_2^C\\approx\\chi_n^C$, for $n$even.", + "text": "In above equations, at a given temperature, the summation is over all charmed mesons/baryons (C-mesons/baryons) with masses given by ${m_i}$; degeneracy factors of the states with equal mass and same quantum numbers are represented by ${g_i}$; ${K_2(x)}$ is a modified Bessel function, which for a large argument can be approximated by\n${K_2(x)}\\sim\\sqrt{\\pi/2x}\\;e^{-x}\\;[1+\\mathbb{O}(x^{-1})]$. Consequently, if a charmed state under consideration is much heavier than the relevant temperature scale, such that ${m_i\\gg T}$, then the contribution to ${P_C}$ from that particular state will be exponentially suppressed, e.g., the singly-charmed\n${\\Lambda}_c^{+}$ baryon has a PDG mass of about $2286$MeV, whereas the doubly-charmed ${\\Xi_{cc}^{++}}$ baryon's mass as tabulated in PDG records is about $3621$ MeV, hence at ${T_{pc}}$, the contribution to ${P^C_{B}}$ from ${\\Xi_{cc}^{++}}$ will be suppressed by a factor of $10^{-4}$ in relation to ${\\Lambda}_c^{+}$ contribution. Therefore, in the validity regime of Boltzmann approximation, substituting Eq. [eq:McBc] in Eq. [eq:chi] implies $P_C(T,\\vec{\\mu})\\approx\\chi_2^C\\approx\\chi_n^C$, for $n$even." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/38", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Charm fluctuations calculated in the framework of lattice QCD can receive enhanced contributions due the existence of not-yet-discovered open-charm states. It is possible to compare this enhancement to the HRG calculations performed with two data sets. The first scenario, denoted by PDG-HRG, is based on the experimentally established states tabulated in the PDG records. The second scenario, denoted by QM-HRG, in addition to PDG states, takes into account states predicted via Quark-Model calculations", - "text": "Charm fluctuations calculated in the framework of lattice QCD can receive enhanced contributions due the existence of not-yet-discovered open-charm states. It is possible to compare this enhancement to the HRG calculations performed with two data sets. The first scenario, denoted by PDG-HRG, is based on the experimentally established states tabulated in the PDG records. The second scenario, denoted by QM-HRG, in addition to PDG states, takes into account states predicted via Quark-Model calculations" - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/39", + "self_ref": "#/texts/33", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -787,11 +679,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[Ebert:2009ua, Ebert:2011kk, Chen:2022asf]. In the validity regime of HRG, $\\chi^{nm}_{BC}\\approx P^C_{B}$, and $P^C_{M} = P_C-P^C_{B}$. Fig. [fig:barCmesC] [Left] shows that the QM-HRG predicts a $92\\%$ enhancement of the partial charmed baryon pressure at $T_{pc}$ compared to the PDG-HRG expectation, whereas the predicted enhancement in the partial charmed meson pressure is only $15\\%$. These results suggest that, based on the QM-HRG predictions, the charmed baryonic sector is significantly more incomplete than the charmed mesonic sector. In recent years, the \n experimental\n discovery of various $\\Lambda_C$ and $\\Omega_C$ resonances, in particular by LHCb and Belle collaborations [Belle:2016tai,LHCb:2017uwr,LHCb:2017jym,Chen:2017gnu] have confirmed this.", - "text": "[Ebert:2009ua, Ebert:2011kk, Chen:2022asf]. In the validity regime of HRG, $\\chi^{nm}_{BC}\\approx P^C_{B}$, and $P^C_{M} = P_C-P^C_{B}$. Fig. [fig:barCmesC] [Left] shows that the QM-HRG predicts a $92\\%$ enhancement of the partial charmed baryon pressure at $T_{pc}$ compared to the PDG-HRG expectation, whereas the predicted enhancement in the partial charmed meson pressure is only $15\\%$. These results suggest that, based on the QM-HRG predictions, the charmed baryonic sector is significantly more incomplete than the charmed mesonic sector. In recent years, the \n experimental\n discovery of various $\\Lambda_C$ and $\\Omega_C$ resonances, in particular by LHCb and Belle collaborations [Belle:2016tai,LHCb:2017uwr,LHCb:2017jym,Chen:2017gnu] have confirmed this." + "orig": "Charm fluctuations calculated in the framework of lattice QCD can receive enhanced contributions due the existence of not-yet-discovered open-charm states. It is possible to compare this enhancement to the HRG calculations performed with two data sets. The first scenario, denoted by PDG-HRG, is based on the experimentally established states tabulated in the PDG records. The second scenario, denoted by QM-HRG, in addition to PDG states, takes into account states predicted via Quark-Model calculations [Ebert:2009ua, Ebert:2011kk, Chen:2022asf]. In the validity regime of HRG, $\\chi^{nm}_{BC}\\approx P^C_{B}$, and $P^C_{M} = P_C-P^C_{B}$. Fig. [fig:barCmesC] [Left] shows that the QM-HRG predicts a $92\\%$ enhancement of the partial charmed baryon pressure at $T_{pc}$ compared to the PDG-HRG expectation, whereas the predicted enhancement in the partial charmed meson pressure is only $15\\%$. These results suggest that, based on the QM-HRG predictions, the charmed baryonic sector is significantly more incomplete than the charmed mesonic sector. In recent years, the \n experimental\n discovery of various $\\Lambda_C$ and $\\Omega_C$ resonances, in particular by LHCb and Belle collaborations [Belle:2016tai,LHCb:2017uwr,LHCb:2017jym,Chen:2017gnu] have confirmed this.", + "text": "Charm fluctuations calculated in the framework of lattice QCD can receive enhanced contributions due the existence of not-yet-discovered open-charm states. It is possible to compare this enhancement to the HRG calculations performed with two data sets. The first scenario, denoted by PDG-HRG, is based on the experimentally established states tabulated in the PDG records. The second scenario, denoted by QM-HRG, in addition to PDG states, takes into account states predicted via Quark-Model calculations [Ebert:2009ua, Ebert:2011kk, Chen:2022asf]. In the validity regime of HRG, $\\chi^{nm}_{BC}\\approx P^C_{B}$, and $P^C_{M} = P_C-P^C_{B}$. Fig. [fig:barCmesC] [Left] shows that the QM-HRG predicts a $92\\%$ enhancement of the partial charmed baryon pressure at $T_{pc}$ compared to the PDG-HRG expectation, whereas the predicted enhancement in the partial charmed meson pressure is only $15\\%$. These results suggest that, based on the QM-HRG predictions, the charmed baryonic sector is significantly more incomplete than the charmed mesonic sector. In recent years, the \n experimental\n discovery of various $\\Lambda_C$ and $\\Omega_C$ resonances, in particular by LHCb and Belle collaborations [Belle:2016tai,LHCb:2017uwr,LHCb:2017jym,Chen:2017gnu] have confirmed this." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/40", + "self_ref": "#/texts/34", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -804,7 +696,7 @@ "level": 2 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/41", + "self_ref": "#/texts/35", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -816,7 +708,7 @@ "text": "Charm quarks offer an advantage over the light quarks because for temperatures a few times $T_{pc}$, the Boltzmann approximation works for an ideal massive quark-antiquark gas [Allton:2005gk,BAZAVOV2014210]. Therefore, in this approximation, the dimensionless partial charm quark pressure, $P^C_{q}$, is given by," }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/42", + "self_ref": "#/texts/36", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -828,7 +720,7 @@ "text": "P^C_{q}(T,\\overrightarrow{\\mu})&=&\\dfrac{3}{\\pi^2}\\bigg(\\dfrac{m_q^C}{T}\\bigg)^2K_2(m_q^C/T)\\cdot \\nonumber \\\\\n\t&&\\text{cosh}\\bigg(\\dfrac{2}{3}\\hat{\\mu}_Q+\\dfrac{1}{3}\\hat{\\mu}_B+\\hat{\\mu}_C\\bigg) \\text { ,}" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/43", + "self_ref": "#/texts/37", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -840,7 +732,7 @@ "text": "where $m_q^C$is the pole mass of the charm quark, and the degeneracy factor is 6." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/44", + "self_ref": "#/texts/38", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -853,7 +745,7 @@ "level": 1 }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/45", + "self_ref": "#/texts/39", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -865,7 +757,7 @@ "text": "Image: P_B.pdf" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/46", + "self_ref": "#/texts/40", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -877,7 +769,7 @@ "text": "Image: P_M.pdf" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/47", + "self_ref": "#/texts/41", "parent": { "$ref": "#/groups/1" }, @@ -889,7 +781,7 @@ "text": "Shown are partial charmed baryon pressure [Left] and partial charmed meson pressure [Right] along with the respective QM-HRG, PDG-HRG and 1S1P-HRG (see text) predictions. The yellow bands represent $T_{pc}$ with its uncertainty." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/48", + "self_ref": "#/texts/42", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -901,7 +793,7 @@ "text": "To investigate the nature of charm degrees of freedom above $T_{pc}$, we extend the simple hadron gas model allowing the presence of partial charm quark pressure based on Ref.[Mukherjee:2015mxc]," }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/49", + "self_ref": "#/texts/43", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -913,7 +805,7 @@ "text": "\\begin{align}\n\tP_C(T,\\vec{\\mu})=P^C_{M}(T,\\vec{\\mu})+P^C_{B}(T,\\vec{\\mu})+P^C_{q}(T,\\vec{\\mu}) \\, .\n\t\n\\end{align}" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/50", + "self_ref": "#/texts/44", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -925,7 +817,7 @@ "text": "In our recent works [Bazavov:2023xzm, Sharma:2024ucs, Sharma:2024edf], we show that this model successfully passes numerous validity tests and satisfies various constraints [Bazavov:2023xzm]. In this quasi-particle model, the partial pressures of quark-, baryon- and meson-like excitations for $\\vec{\\mu}=0$can be expressed in terms of the generalized susceptibilities as follows," }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/51", + "self_ref": "#/texts/45", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -937,7 +829,7 @@ "text": "\\begin{align}\n\tP^C_{q}&=9(\\chi^{BC}_{13}-\\chi^{BC}_{22})/2\\; , \n\t \t\\\\\n\tP^C_{B}&=(3\\chi^{BC}_{22}-\\chi^{BC}_{13})/2\\; , \n\t\\\\\n\tP^C_{M}&=\\chi^{C}_{4}+3\\chi^{BC}_{22}-4\\chi^{BC}_{13} \\; .\n\t\n\\end{align}" }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/52", + "self_ref": "#/texts/46", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -949,19 +841,7 @@ "text": "Note that in the validity regime of HRG, $\\chi^{BC}_{22}\\approx\\chi^{BC}_{13}$. Hence, in this phase the partial pressure contribution from quark-like excitations, $P^C_q$ is, by construction, zero, and $P^C_B$ and $P^C_M$ reduce to $\\chi^{BC}_{13}$ and $\\chi^4_C-\\chi^{BC}_{13}$, respectively." }, { - "self_ref": "#/texts/53", - "parent": { - "$ref": "#/body" - }, - "children": [], - "content_layer": "body", - "label": "paragraph", - "prov": [], - "orig": "Continuum estimates for charmed baryon and meson partial pressures shown in Fig.", - "text": "Continuum estimates for charmed baryon and meson partial pressures shown in Fig." - }, - { - "self_ref": "#/texts/54", + "self_ref": "#/texts/47", "parent": { "$ref": "#/body" }, @@ -969,11 +849,11 @@ "content_layer": "body", "label": "text", "prov": [], - "orig": "[fig:enhan] are obtained by multiplying continuum extrapolated $\\chi^C_4$ values to ratios $P^C_B/P_C$ and $P^C_M/P_C$ shown in our previous work [Bazavov:2023xzm]. As mentioned earlier, these ratios, despite being calculated on a finite temporal lattice extent, are largely cut-off independent. For $T