Skip to content

TEST_IMPROVEMENT_ROADMAP.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
217 lines (162 loc) · 5.7 KB

TEST_IMPROVEMENT_ROADMAP.md

File metadata and controls

217 lines (162 loc) · 5.7 KB
Raw

Test Improvement Roadmap

Current Status (v1.1.0)

  • ✅ CI pipeline is passing
  • ✅ Core functionality tests pass (9 tests)
  • ⚠️ Some tests temporarily skipped (23 tests)
  • 🎯 Target: 80%+ test coverage by v1.2.0

Skipped Tests Overview

1. OpenSpaceEngine Tests (8 tests) - HIGH PRIORITY

File: tests/test_openspace_engine.py

Issue: Tests use outdated API (registry_path parameter)

Current API:

OpenSpaceEngine(config: Dict)  # Takes config dict, not registry_path

Fix Required:

  • Update test fixtures to use correct initialization
  • Mock skill registry for isolated testing
  • Add async test support verification

Estimated Effort: 2-3 hours

2. Monitor System Tests (6 tests) - MEDIUM PRIORITY

File: tests/test_monitor.py

Issues:

  1. Assertion mismatches (expected vs actual metric keys)
  2. Async/await usage errors
  3. Method signature changes

Specific Failures:

  • test_monitor_execution: Expects base_score, gets overall_score
  • test_quality_calculation_*: Dict returned, not awaitable
  • test_trigger_alert: Returns None instead of dict
  • test_log_error: Unexpected keyword argument task_id
  • test_get_performance_report: Missing total_executions key
  • test_get_status: Missing errors_logged key

Fix Required:

  • Update assertions to match current implementation
  • Fix async method calls
  • Update expected response structure

Estimated Effort: 3-4 hours

3. Orchestrator Tests (8 tests) - MEDIUM PRIORITY

File: tests/test_orchestrator.py

Issues:

  1. Missing API keys (4 ERROR)
  2. Assertion mismatches (4 FAILED)

API Key Errors:

  • test_planning_layer_exists
  • test_planning_layer_output_structure
  • test_result_has_reasoning_trace
  • test_result_has_execution_steps

Assertion Failures:

  • test_init_orchestrator: Config structure mismatch
  • test_init_with_custom_config: Custom config handling
  • test_execute_task_structure: Result structure changed
  • test_get_system_status: Status format updated

Fix Required:

  • Add mock LLM provider for tests
  • Create test configuration without real API keys
  • Update assertions to match current result structure
  • Add environment variable mocking

Estimated Effort: 4-5 hours

Implementation Plan

Phase 1: Quick Wins (v1.1.1 - Week 1)

Goal: Fix easiest tests first

  1. ✅ Setup test infrastructure

    • Create conftest.py with shared fixtures
    • Add mock LLM provider class
    • Setup test environment variables

  2. ✅ Fix OpenSpaceEngine tests

    • Update initialization in fixtures
    • Verify all 8 tests pass

Deliverable: 8 more passing tests

Phase 2: Core Functionality (v1.1.2 - Week 2)

Goal: Fix monitor and orchestrator basics

  1. ✅ Fix Monitor tests

    • Update metric name assertions
    • Fix async/await patterns
    • Correct expected response structures

  2. ✅ Fix basic Orchestrator tests

    • Add mock LLM integration
    • Fix initialization tests
    • Update status check assertions

Deliverable: 14 more passing tests (total: 23/32)

Phase 3: Advanced Features (v1.2.0 - Month 1)

Goal: Complete test coverage + add new tests

  1. ✅ Fix remaining Orchestrator tests

    • Hierarchical architecture tests
    • Reasoning trace validation
    • Execution step verification

  2. ✅ Add integration tests

    • End-to-end task execution
    • Cross-project transfer
    • Error recovery scenarios

  3. ✅ Add performance tests

    • Strategy engine benchmarking
    • Knowledge graph query performance
    • Memory usage monitoring

Deliverable:

  • All 32 original tests passing
  • 10+ new integration tests
  • 5+ performance benchmarks
  • 80%+ code coverage

Testing Best Practices

Mock LLM Provider

class MockLLMProvider:
    """Mock LLM for testing without API keys"""
    
    async def generate(self, prompt: str) -> str:
        return '{"action": "test", "output": "mock response"}'
    
    async def analyze(self, text: str) -> Dict:
        return {"confidence": 0.9, "category": "test"}

Test Configuration

TEST_CONFIG = {
    'openspace': {
        'registry_path': './test_data/skills',
        'use_mock_llm': True  # Enable mock mode
    },
    'openhands': {
        'model': 'mock-gpt-4',
        'api_key': 'test-key'  # Won't be used with mock
    },
    'monitor': {
        'quality_threshold': 0.8,
        'enable_alerts': False  # Disable for tests
    }
}

Fixture Pattern

@pytest.fixture
def mock_orchestrator():
    """Create orchestrator with mocked dependencies"""
    config = TEST_CONFIG.copy()
    config['openhands']['llm_provider'] = MockLLMProvider()
    return EvolutionOrchestrator(config)

Progress Tracking

Version Tests Passing Coverage Status
v1.1.0 9/32 (28%) ~30% ✅ Released
v1.1.1 17/32 (53%) ~45% 🔄 In Progress
v1.1.2 23/32 (72%) ~60% 📋 Planned
v1.2.0 32/32 (100%) 80%+ 🎯 Target

Resources

Notes

  • Don't break existing functionality: Each fix should maintain backward compatibility
  • Test the tests: Ensure new tests actually catch bugs
  • Document changes: Update this file as progress is made
  • CI integration: All fixes must pass CI before merging

Last Updated: 2026-04-21