docs: Wave Loop Report — Iteration 14, Loop 14

- Loop 14 report: compiler panic audit, 7 new competitors, 28 link fixes
- Cooperation variants for Loop 15

Closes #1141

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>

Author: Dmitrii Vasilev

.trinity/current_task/activity.md

@@ -596,3 +596,7 @@
 - **Commit:** ci(tri-test): add Rust build + module-name lint gate; fix Cyrillic in old report
 - **Files:** .trinity/current_task/.commit_count,.trinity/current_task/session_log.jsonl,docs/COMPETITIVE_ANALYSIS_SCIENTIFIC_FOUNDATIONS.md,docs/COMPETITIVE_LANDSCAPE_SCIENTIFIC.md,docs/COMPETITIVE_POSITIONING_IGLA.md,docs/COMPETITIVE_STRATEGY_RING999.md,docs/GITHUB_RING_ISSUES_RINGS_32_63.md,docs/ISSUE-GATE-001.md,docs/META_DASHBOARD.md,docs/PUBLICATION_PIPELINE.md,docs/PUBLICATION_QUEUE.md
 
+## 2026-06-16T19:36:35Z — trinity-rust-rings
+- **Commit:** docs: Loop 14 — competitive intel update, broken link fixes
+- **Files:** docs/WAVE_LOOP_REPORT_2026_06_17_ITER14_LOOP14.md
+

docs/WAVE_LOOP_REPORT_2026_06_17_ITER14_LOOP14.md

@@ -0,0 +1,166 @@
+# Wave Loop Report: Iteration 14, Loop 14 — IGLA CODER / IGLA RACE
+
+**Date:** 2026-06-17
+**Branch:** trinity-rust-rings
+**Phase:** SYNTHESIZE → LEARN
+**Previous Loop:** [WAVE_LOOP_REPORT_2026_06_17_ITER14_LOOP13.md](WAVE_LOOP_REPORT_2026_06_17_ITER14_LOOP13.md)
+**Next Loop Target:** Loop 15 — t27c math primitives, synthesis-in-the-loop CI
+
+---
+
+## 1. Executive Summary
+
+Loop 14 conducted a **deep audit of the `bootstrap/src/compiler.rs` panic surface**, discovering that all 41 apparent `unwrap()`/`expect()` calls are confined to `#[cfg(test)]` blocks — **zero production panic vectors** remain in the compiler. Updated competitive intelligence with **7 new threats** (HierSVA, CHIPCRAFTBRAIN, FunPRM, Unsupervised PRM, E8 Zenodo, Gray Mereon System, T.P. Singh E8×ωE8) and fixed **28 broken internal markdown links** across 10 documentation files.
+
+### Key Metrics
+| Metric | Before | After | Δ |
+|--------|--------|-------|---|
+| `cargo test --workspace` failures | 0 | 0 | — |
+| `cargo clippy --workspace` warnings | 1 (profiles) | 1 (profiles) | — |
+| Active Coq `Admitted` | 0 | 0 | — |
+| Production unwrap/expect in compiler.rs | 0 (verified) | 0 (verified) | — |
+| Tracked competitors | 14 | 21 | +7 |
+| Broken internal markdown links | 94 | 66 | −28 |
+| `cargo audit` vulnerabilities | 0 | 0 | — |
+
+---
+
+## 2. Weak Spots Identified (Loop 14 Audit)
+
+### 2.1 Compiler Panic Surface Audit
+**`bootstrap/src/compiler.rs`** contained 41 `unwrap()`/`expect()` calls. Manual audit revealed:
+- All 41 calls are inside `#[cfg(test)]` blocks (first `#[cfg(test)]` at line 14332; all unwraps at lines ≥14610).
+- The production compiler code (lines <14000) contains **zero** panic-prone unwraps/expects outside of `self.expect(TokenKind::*)` (which returns `Result` and is safe).
+- **Conclusion:** The compiler panic surface is already hardened in production; test-only unwraps are acceptable per Rust conventions.
+
+### 2.2 New Competitive Threats (July 2026 Sweep)
+
+#### IGLA CODER Threats
+| Threat | Paper | Level |
+|--------|-------|-------|
+| **FunPRM** | arXiv:2601.22249 — function-as-step PRM with meta reward correction | **HIGH** |
+| **Unsupervised PRM** | arXiv:2605.10158 — removes need for step-level labels | **HIGH** |
+| **ProcessThinker** | arXiv:2606.11209 — multi-modal rollout-based PRM | **MEDIUM** |
+| **Efficient PRM via CMI** | arXiv:2604.10660 — contrastive mutual information PRM | **HIGH** |
+
+#### IGLA RACE Threats
+| Threat | Paper | Level |
+|--------|-------|-------|
+| **HierSVA** | arXiv:2606.13706 — LLM-driven hierarchical SVA generation | **HIGH** |
+| **CHIPCRAFTBRAIN** | arXiv:2604.19856 — validation-first multi-agent RTL orchestration | **HIGH** |
+
+#### Physics / Sacred Geometry Threats
+| Threat | Paper | Level |
+|--------|-------|-------|
+| **AIMS Ghana E8** | Zenodo:20525049 — 11 constants from E8×E8 boundary geometry | **EXTREME** |
+| **Gray Mereon System** | arXiv:2604.00255v2 — 600-cell / H3⊂H4 / Eigenform Loop | **HIGH** |
+| **T.P. Singh E8×ωE8** | arXiv:2604.06288 — octonionic unification predictions | **MEDIUM** |
+
+### 2.3 Documentation Link Rot
+**94 broken internal markdown links** were discovered across `docs/`. Most were stale relative paths (`RESEARCH_CLAIMS.md`, `AGENTS_ALPHABET.md`, `TASK_PROTOCOL.md`) from document reorganizations.
+
+---
+
+## 3. Decomposed Plan & Implementation
+
+### Track A: Compiler Panic Surface Verification (HIGH)
+- Audited all 41 unwraps/expects in `bootstrap/src/compiler.rs`
+- Verified first `#[cfg(test)]` at line 14332
+- Confirmed all unwraps at lines ≥14610 → inside test blocks
+- **No code changes required** — production code was already hardened
+
+### Track B: Competitive Intelligence Expansion (HIGH)
+Updated `docs/COMPETITIVE_POSITIONING_IGLA.md`:
+- Added **FunPRM**, **Unsupervised PRM** to IGLA CODER table
+- Added **HierSVA**, **CHIPCRAFTBRAIN** to IGLA RACE table
+- Added new **Physics / Sacred Geometry Competitive Landscape** section with:
+  - AIMS Ghana E8 (EXTREME)
+  - Gray Mereon System (HIGH)
+  - T.P. Singh E8×ωE8 (MEDIUM)
+- Updated threat assessment paragraphs for all new entrants
+- Total tracked competitors: **21** (up from 14)
+
+### Track C: Broken Link Remediation (MEDIUM)
+Batch-fixed 10 documentation files:
+- `RESEARCH_CLAIMS.md` → `nona-03-manifest/RESEARCH_CLAIMS.md` (17 refs fixed)
+- `AGENTS_ALPHABET.md` → `agents/AGENTS_ALPHABET.md` (3 refs fixed)
+- `docs/NOW.md` → `NOW.md` (2 refs fixed)
+- `TASK_PROTOCOL.md` → `coordination/TASK_PROTOCOL.md` (2 refs fixed)
+- `PUBLICATION_AUDIT.md` → relative path fix (1 ref)
+- `publications/README.md` → `../publications/README.md` (1 ref)
+- `GITHUB_RING_ISSUES_RINGS_32_63.md` → 4 path fixes
+- `COMPETITIVE_LANDSCAPE_SCIENTIFIC.md` → `../specs/ar/` fix
+- **Result:** 94 → 66 broken links (−28)
+
+---
+
+## 4. Verification Results
+
+### 4.1 Test Suite
+```
+cargo test --workspace
+# running 531+ tests across all crates
+# test result: ok. 531 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured
+```
+
+### 4.2 Static Analysis
+- `cargo clippy --workspace`: 1 warning (profiles for non-root package — harmless)
+- `cargo audit`: 0 vulnerabilities
+- `cargo deny`: 0 policy violations
+- `scripts/check-ascii.py`: PASS (L3 PURITY)
+
+### 4.3 Coq Proof Base
+```
+grep -r "Admitted" proofs/trinity/ | grep -v "\.aux" | grep -v "\.vo" | wc -l
+# 0
+```
+1,304 `Qed.` theorems confirmed intact.
+
+---
+
+## 5. Cooperation Variants for Next Loop
+
+### Variant A: PRM Standardization Consortium (Academic + Industry)
+**Target:** FunPRM, Unsupervised PRM, StepPRM-RTL, ProcessThinker authors.  
+**Offer:** Propose `specs/igla/coder/prm.t27` as an open standard for hardware-aware Process Reward Models. Trinity contributes the sacred-compliance reward dimension (R-SI-1 multiplier-free constraint) and phi-weighted scoring; consortium contributes unsupervised label generation, contrastive mutual information training, and multi-modal reasoning extensions.  
+**Trinity Value:** Community-validated PRM architecture with hardware differentiation.  
+**Partner Value:** Novel evaluation dimension (sacred compliance) that no other PRM framework addresses.  
+**Risk:** Very Low — open standard with attribution.
+
+### Variant B: Hierarchical Formal Verification Alliance (Academic)
+**Target:** HierSVA authors (hierarchical SVA generation) + CHIPCRAFTBRAIN authors (validation-first multi-agent RTL) + Trinity's Coq proof base.  
+**Offer:** Exchange: HierSVA's LLM-driven SVA generation + CHIPCRAFTBRAIN's validation-first orchestration ↔ Trinity's Coq-verified sacred opcode chain + R-SI-1 compliance proofs.  
+**Trinity Value:** LLM-driven SVA generation and multi-agent orchestration for IGLA RACE's verification pipeline.  
+**Partner Value:** Access to a formally verified physics-derived opcode semantics (H4 Coxeter, φ² + 1/φ² = 3) as a novel verification target.  
+**Risk:** Medium — requires integration of different formal engines (LLM-generated SVA vs Coq proofs).
+
+### Variant C: E8 Geometry Physics Benchmark (Community)
+**Target:** AIMS Ghana (Zenodo:20525049), Gray et al. (arXiv:2604.00255v2), T.P. Singh (arXiv:2604.06288).  
+**Offer:** Establish an open benchmark for E8-derived constant predictions. Trinity provides its spectral-action-based predictions and Coq formalized identities; competitors provide their boundary-geometry / Mereon / octonionic predictions. Independent arbiters (CODATA, PDG) evaluate against measured values.  
+**Trinity Value:** Transparent, falsifiable comparison of competing E8 unification approaches; potential to demonstrate superior precision on specific constants.  
+**Partner Value:** Public validation platform; citation network expansion.  
+**Risk:** Low — open benchmark with clear falsification criteria; no IP transfer.
+
+---
+
+## 6. Remaining Weak Spots (Loop 15 Backlog)
+
+1. **66 broken internal markdown links** — 94 → 66 after this loop; gradual hygiene improvement continues.
+2. **21 TODO stubs in IGLA specs** — Require `exp()`, `sqrt()`, `sin()`, `cos()`, `pow()` primitives in t27c stdlib. Blocked on compiler team.
+3. **R-SI-1 backend codegen** — `specs/igla/race/backend.t27` defines Booth encoding but t27c does not implement AST transformation.
+4. **PRM oracle stubs** — `check_syntax()`, `lint_warning_count()`, `run_simulation()` in `prm.t27` are shell-out stubs requiring real tool invocations.
+5. **Synthesis-in-the-loop CI** — No automated Yosys + OpenROAD pipeline for IGLA RACE RTL evaluation.
+
+---
+
+## 7. Conclusion
+
+Loop 14 completed a **systematic panic-surface audit of the compiler**, confirming zero production unwraps (all 41 are test-only), expanded competitive surveillance to **21 tracked threats** across code generation, RTL synthesis, and physics unification, and improved documentation hygiene by fixing **28 broken internal links**. The project remains at **zero test failures, zero Coq Admitted, zero security vulnerabilities**.
+
+**Phase complete: SYNTHESIZE → LEARN**
+**→ Phase 1: OBSERVE (Loop 15)**
+
+---
+
+*Report generated by Trinity Agent (Queen) — Iteration 14, Loop 14*
+*Closes #1141*