Skip to content

Commit 2c8f866

Browse files
hyperpolymathclaude
andcommitted
audit(trg): record M2 close delta + reconfirm X headline
Appends a 2026-04-18 (late afternoon) delta section to the TRG audit: - Suite moved 30/35 → 31/35 via M2 Lagrange closure (commit cc7c693). - v1.0 baseline moved 8/15 → 9/15. - Four v1.0 entries remain in-progress: E1, S3, S4, E5. - E1 Coquelicot-tractable but single-multi-day sprint (not session-scoped); coq-coquelicot 3.4.4 now installed on the dev machine. - S3 / S4 / E5 need scope decisions (research-grade otherwise). - Three cross-cutting blockers unchanged (Parser-fuzz billing, 17 RSR workflows billing, flake.nix Nix-install). Headline grade **TRG-X** unchanged. Three of four remaining gaps are human-owned; the fourth (E1) is an AI-workable multi-day port. Updated next-re-audit trigger: E1 closure / S3-S4-E5 scope decision / billing resolution. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
1 parent cc7c693 commit 2c8f866

1 file changed

Lines changed: 76 additions & 0 deletions

File tree

audits/audit-trg-2026-04-18.md

Lines changed: 76 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -247,3 +247,79 @@ This audit's companion classifier registers:
247247
entries close to passing, or (b) the GitHub Actions billing blocker
248248
is resolved and evidence collection begins for the parser-fuzz
249249
≥24h gate.
250+
251+
---
252+
253+
## Addendum — 2026-04-18 (late afternoon) — delta re-audit
254+
255+
**Trigger met**: canonical-proof-suite moved +1 passing since the
256+
snapshot above.
257+
258+
### What moved
259+
260+
**Canonical Proof Suite**: 30/35 → **31/35 passing** (v1.1-proposed
261+
manifest; 8/15 → **9/15** at v1.0 baseline).
262+
263+
- **M2 Lagrange's theorem** — CLOSED, commit `cc7c693`. Prover
264+
switch idris2 → rocq. Layer B via `mathcomp.fingroup.cardSg`;
265+
headline `lagrangeTheorem (G H : {group gT}) : H \subset G ->
266+
#|H| %| #|G|` discharged by `exact: cardSg. Qed.`. Module header
267+
carries honest-progress note (library lift, not from-first-
268+
principles in this file); Idris2 companion at `M2-lagrange.idr`
269+
retained as partial ground-up scaffold.
270+
271+
### What did not move
272+
273+
Four v1.0 entries remain in-progress; none tractable this session
274+
under the §3.1 Scaffold-Intent rule ("closure requires importing or
275+
building the missing analytic layer, not renaming hypotheses"):
276+
277+
- **E1 Lyapunov**`coq-coquelicot` installed in this session
278+
(`3.4.4`). Faithful closure is a single multi-day sprint
279+
(~800-1500 LOC on top of Coquelicot.Hierarchy + ODE) per
280+
AI-WORK-007.md §3.2. A 1D scalar V̇ ≤ 0 inequality was trialled
281+
and rejected — the §3.1 rule forbids closing the headline under
282+
a weaker statement of the same name for v1.0 entries.
283+
- **S3 Boltzmann H-theorem**, **S4 Heisenberg uncertainty** — no
284+
opam-packaged analytic layer exists for either. Both require
285+
multi-week original formalisation or explicit scope re-decisions
286+
(Tier 1 alternatives: monotonicity of Shannon entropy under
287+
doubly stochastic maps for S3; variance-product bound on
288+
discrete random variables for S4). No decision has been made;
289+
owner action tracked in AI-WORK-007.md §3.2.
290+
- **E5 Needham-Schroeder fixed protocol** — Larry Paulson's
291+
canonical proof is Isabelle; the Rocq port is not turn-key.
292+
Same scope-decision gate as S3/S4.
293+
294+
### Cross-cutting blockers unchanged
295+
296+
- **Parser-fuzz ≥24h clean-run evidence** — strictly blocked on
297+
GitHub Actions billing on `hyperpolymath` (YOUR-ACTIONS-todo.md
298+
§1). No change since the main audit body.
299+
- **17 RSR workflows green** — same billing gate.
300+
- **flake.nix SupplyChain finding** — strictly blocked on Nix
301+
install on the dev machine (YOUR-ACTIONS-todo.md §1b). No
302+
change since the main audit body.
303+
304+
### Headline grade
305+
306+
**TRG-X** unchanged. The M2 close is a one-entry move on a
307+
seven-gap chain; three of the remaining four gaps need
308+
human-owned actions (billing, Nix install, scope decisions for
309+
S3/S4/E5) and one (E1) needs a multi-day Coquelicot port.
310+
311+
### Updated roadmap
312+
313+
Items 1, 3, 4, 6 from the main roadmap remain the decisive levers.
314+
Item 1 is now at 31/35; closing requires:
315+
- E1 Coquelicot port — AI-workable multi-day sprint.
316+
- S3 / S4 / E5 — scope decision (owner) then multi-week or
317+
re-scoped closure (AI).
318+
319+
Items 3 + 4 stay blocked on billing; item 5 substrate remains in
320+
place (docs-only refactor pending); item 6 M3 reference-oracle
321+
differential-harness closure is unchanged single-session work.
322+
323+
*Next re-audit trigger*: first of (a) E1 Coquelicot closure, (b) a
324+
scope decision on S3/S4/E5, or (c) GitHub Actions billing
325+
resolution.

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)