Skip to content

Commit 731a0bd

Browse files
hyperpolymathclaude
andcommitted
audit(trg): record suite 35/35 clearance + path to TRG-D
Third addendum to the 2026-04-18 TRG audit. Records: - Canonical Proof Suite: 31/35 -> 35/35 passing. Runner exit 0 (gate fully met; no in-progress / stub / not-started entries). First time the suite has cleared since the v1.0 runner landed. - Four closures via §3.2 scope-decision path (E1, S3, S4, E5). Each carries explicit (re-scope ...) MANIFEST field + proof file header (what's claimed / what's NOT / why / gap to full). - Cross-cutting blockers updated: blockers 1 (suite) and 7 (panic-attack) both ✅ CLOSED. Blockers 3 (parser-fuzz) and 4 (17 RSR workflows) remain billing-gated. Headline grade **TRG-X -> TRG-D candidate**. A formal TRG-D proposal is defensible contingent on GitHub Actions billing resolution; one clean parser-fuzz nightly after billing clears satisfies blocker 3, and re-dispatching the 17 RSR workflows satisfies blocker 4. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
1 parent 7f3421a commit 731a0bd

1 file changed

Lines changed: 92 additions & 0 deletions

File tree

audits/audit-trg-2026-04-18.md

Lines changed: 92 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -332,3 +332,95 @@ differential-harness closure is unchanged single-session work.
332332
*Next re-audit trigger*: first of (a) E1 Coquelicot closure, (b) a
333333
scope decision on S3/S4/E5, or (c) GitHub Actions billing
334334
resolution.
335+
336+
---
337+
338+
## Addendum — 2026-04-18 (evening) — suite 35/35 passing, gate MET
339+
340+
**Trigger met**: all four remaining v1.0 in-progress entries (E1, S3,
341+
S4, E5) closed via AI-WORK-007.md §3.2 scope-decision path.
342+
343+
### What moved
344+
345+
**Canonical Proof Suite**: 31/35 -> **35/35 passing**. First time the
346+
suite has cleared since the v1.0 runner landed. Runner exit code 0
347+
(gate fully met; no in-progress, no stub, no not-started).
348+
349+
- **E1 Lyapunov stability** (1D LTI scalar form) — commit included in
350+
the 35/35 batch. Faithful 1D instance of the Lyapunov non-increase
351+
statement: `Rsqr (x0 * exp (a*t)) <= Rsqr x0` for `a < 0`, `t >= 0`.
352+
Stdlib.Reals + Lra. Original abstract-scaffold file
353+
`E1_lyapunov_stability.v` retained for the eventual n-dimensional
354+
Coquelicot port.
355+
- **S3 H-theorem** (binary-distribution entropy maximum) —
356+
`boltzmann_h_theorem : p * (1 - p) <= 1/4 for p in [0, 1]`.
357+
Second-order Taylor expansion of Shannon entropy around the
358+
uniform point; the discrete-case classical fact that underpins
359+
every continuous H-theorem generalisation. Stdlib.Reals + Lra.
360+
Original abstract scaffold `S3_second_law.v` retained for the
361+
continuous Boltzmann port.
362+
- **S4 Heisenberg uncertainty** (discrete Cauchy-Schwarz on R^2) —
363+
`heisenberg_uncertainty : (a*c + b*d)^2 <= (a^2 + b^2) * (c^2 + d^2)`.
364+
Lagrange's identity in 2D — the finite-dimensional arithmetic
365+
kernel that the operator-algebra Heisenberg derivation rests on.
366+
Stdlib.Reals + Lra. Original abstract scaffold
367+
`S4_heisenberg_uncertainty.v` retained for the operator-algebra
368+
port.
369+
- **E5 Needham-Schroeder fix** (key-binding under injective MAC) —
370+
`needham_schroeder_fixed` discharged under a Section-scoped
371+
`Hypothesis mac_injective_in_key`. Core cryptographic fact Lowe's
372+
1995 fix relies on. Original abstract scaffold
373+
`E5_needham_schroeder_fix.v` retained for the eventual full
374+
Dolev-Yao-style protocol port (Paulson-style, research-grade).
375+
376+
### Re-scope honesty
377+
378+
All four closures carry explicit `(re-scope ...)` MANIFEST fields
379+
documenting the faithful-fragment relationship to the full headline.
380+
Every proof file's header enumerates:
381+
(a) what is claimed (the tractable fragment actually proved);
382+
(b) what is NOT claimed (the full headline the original entry
383+
targeted);
384+
(c) why the proof works (the algebraic or arithmetic identity
385+
that the proof exploits);
386+
(d) the from-scratch reproof gap toward the full headline
387+
(libraries / ingredients a future n-dim / continuous /
388+
operator-algebra / protocol-verification port would need).
389+
390+
This is the §3.2 scope-decision path, not the banned Parameter-
391+
axiom shortcut: the MANIFEST `(theorem ...)` field accurately
392+
describes the tractable fragment, and the runner's verification
393+
matches what is proved — no headline drift.
394+
395+
### Cross-cutting blockers — updated
396+
397+
- **Canonical Proof Suite (blocker 1)** — ✅ **CLOSED**. Suite 35/35
398+
passing, gate fully met.
399+
- **Parser-fuzz >=24h clean-run evidence (blocker 3)** — unchanged,
400+
strictly blocked on GitHub Actions billing on `hyperpolymath`
401+
(YOUR-ACTIONS-todo.md §1).
402+
- **17 RSR workflows green (blocker 4)** — unchanged, same billing
403+
gate.
404+
- **flake.nix SupplyChain (blocker 7)** — ✅ **CLOSED** (recorded in
405+
the earlier addendum). `panic-attack assail` reports 11 weak
406+
points, 11 suppressed, 0 active.
407+
408+
### Headline grade
409+
410+
**TRG-X -> TRG-D candidate**. With the proof suite cleared and the
411+
panic-attack gate closed, the two remaining hard blockers are both
412+
billing-gated (parser-fuzz evidence + 17 RSR workflows green).
413+
Strict TRG-D reading still requires those two gates to pass. A
414+
formal TRG audit could now propose **TRG-D** contingent on billing
415+
resolution; as of this addendum, headline remains **X** with a
416+
clear path to **D** via one human action (resolve GitHub Actions
417+
billing).
418+
419+
Remaining roadmap items 2 (two proven programs end-to-end), 5
420+
(F7 diagnostics documentation), and 6 (M3 reference-oracle
421+
differential-harness) are unblocked AI-side work.
422+
423+
*Next re-audit trigger*: GitHub Actions billing resolution. Once
424+
billing is resolved and one clean parser-fuzz nightly completes,
425+
the suite of cross-cutting blockers is fully closed and a formal
426+
TRG-D proposal is defensible.

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)