Skip to content

Commit ca5979b

Browse files
Jonathan D.A. Jewellclaude
andcommitted
feat: integrate ECHIDNA neurosymbolic proof assistant
Phase 1 Integration: - Add scripts/use-echidna.sh wrapper (list, suggest, complete, verify, repl) - Add 6 justfile recipes for ECHIDNA operations - Create ROADMAP-UPDATED.adoc (simplified 7-year plan) - Create INTEGRATION-STATUS-2026-02-05.adoc (progress report) Architecture Clarity: - ECHIDNA runs as separate tool (not merged) - Operates ON absolute-zero proofs (external assistance) - 27 Admitted proofs identified (target: 0 for v1.0) Next Steps: - Use ECHIDNA to complete Admitted proofs - Multi-prover consensus verification - Container integration Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
1 parent cbeb34a commit ca5979b

4 files changed

Lines changed: 748 additions & 0 deletions

File tree

INTEGRATION-STATUS-2026-02-05.adoc

Lines changed: 210 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,210 @@
1+
// SPDX-License-Identifier: PMPL-1.0-or-later
2+
= Integration Status Report
3+
:toc:
4+
:sectnums:
5+
6+
== Date: 2026-02-05
7+
8+
== Tasks Completed
9+
10+
=== ✅ 1. License Standardization
11+
12+
**absolute-zero**:
13+
* Added LICENSE file (PMPL-1.0-or-later)
14+
* Updated README.adoc (removed AGPL references)
15+
* Fixed SPDX headers in all checkpoint files
16+
* Removed LICENSE-PALIMPS.md stub
17+
* Committed: cbeb34a
18+
19+
**echidna**:
20+
* Updated Cargo.toml license field
21+
* Fixed 67 source file SPDX headers
22+
* Verified consistency across all files
23+
* Committed: 482892e
24+
25+
**Status**: Both repos now consistently use PMPL-1.0-or-later ✅
26+
27+
---
28+
29+
=== ✅ 2. Roadmap Update
30+
31+
**Created**:
32+
* `ROADMAP-UPDATED.adoc` - Clarified architecture
33+
* `PROOF-VS-TEST-SUBJECTS.adoc` - Explained proof systems vs. test languages
34+
* `LICENSE-AUDIT-2026-02-05.adoc` - Documented license migration
35+
36+
**Key clarifications**:
37+
* ECHIDNA is a separate tool (not merged)
38+
* Python/npm are test subjects (not dependencies)
39+
* Proofs remain in Coq/Lean/Z3 (RSR-compliant)
40+
* v1.0 focuses on pure formal verification
41+
42+
**Status**: Architecture documented, roadmap simplified ✅
43+
44+
---
45+
46+
=== ✅ 3. ECHIDNA Integration (Phase 1)
47+
48+
**Infrastructure Setup**:
49+
* Built ECHIDNA from source (cargo build --release)
50+
* Created `scripts/use-echidna.sh` wrapper script
51+
* Added justfile recipes:
52+
- `just echidna-list` - List Admitted proofs
53+
- `just echidna-suggest <file>` - Get tactic suggestions
54+
- `just echidna-complete <file>` - Auto-complete attempts
55+
- `just echidna-verify` - Multi-prover verification
56+
- `just echidna-repl` - Interactive REPL
57+
- `just echidna-check` - Verify installation
58+
59+
**Discovered**: 27 Admitted proofs (not 21 as initially estimated)
60+
61+
**Files with Admitted**:
62+
* CNOCategory.v (3)
63+
* FilesystemCNO.v (6)
64+
* LambdaCNO.v (4)
65+
* MalbolgeCore.v (1)
66+
* LandauerDerivation.v (3)
67+
* StatMech.v (2)
68+
* QuantumCNO.v (5)
69+
* QuantumMechanicsExact.v (3)
70+
71+
**Status**: Integration complete, ready for proof completion ✅
72+
73+
---
74+
75+
== Current State
76+
77+
### Repository Health
78+
79+
**absolute-zero**:
80+
* License: ✅ PMPL-1.0-or-later
81+
* Checkpoint files: ✅ Up to date
82+
* Documentation: ✅ Comprehensive (5 new docs)
83+
* ECHIDNA integration: ✅ Working
84+
* Proofs: ⏳ 27 Admitted remaining
85+
86+
**echidna**:
87+
* License: ✅ PMPL-1.0-or-later
88+
* Build: ✅ Success (release mode)
89+
* Binary: ✅ ~/Documents/hyperpolymath-repos/echidna/target/release/echidna
90+
* Integration: ✅ Scripts created
91+
92+
---
93+
94+
## Next Steps (Immediate)
95+
96+
### Week 1: Proof Completion Sprint
97+
98+
1. **Target easy proofs first** (5-10 completable)
99+
```bash
100+
just echidna-complete proofs/coq/common/CNO.v
101+
# Review suggestions, integrate if valid
102+
```
103+
104+
2. **Focus on StatMech.v** (2 Admitted)
105+
- Bennett's theorem
106+
- Logical reversibility
107+
108+
3. **Incremental commits**
109+
- Complete 1-2 proofs per day
110+
- Cross-verify in Lean 4/Z3
111+
- Update STATE.scm progress
112+
113+
### Week 2: Multi-Prover Consensus
114+
115+
```bash
116+
just echidna-verify # Run consensus check
117+
# Fix any disagreements between provers
118+
```
119+
120+
### Week 3-4: Container & CI
121+
122+
* Build verification container
123+
* Automate proof checking
124+
* Pre-commit hooks
125+
126+
---
127+
128+
## Metrics
129+
130+
### Proof Completion
131+
132+
[cols="1,1,1"]
133+
|===
134+
|File |Admitted |Target
135+
136+
|CNOCategory.v |3 |0
137+
|FilesystemCNO.v |6 |0
138+
|LambdaCNO.v |4 |0
139+
|MalbolgeCore.v |1 |0
140+
|LandauerDerivation.v |3 |0
141+
|StatMech.v |2 |0
142+
|QuantumCNO.v |5 |0
143+
|QuantumMechanicsExact.v |3 |0
144+
|**TOTAL** |**27** |**0**
145+
|===
146+
147+
**Current completion**: 73% (estimated, based on ~100 total theorems)
148+
**Target completion**: 100% (v1.0 requirement)
149+
150+
### Integration Quality
151+
152+
* Scripts: ✅ 1 wrapper script
153+
* Justfile recipes: ✅ 6 commands
154+
* Documentation: ✅ 5 documents
155+
* License compliance: ✅ 100%
156+
* Architecture clarity: ✅ Documented
157+
158+
---
159+
160+
## Risk Assessment
161+
162+
### Low Risk ✅
163+
* License migration - Complete
164+
* Documentation - Comprehensive
165+
* ECHIDNA build - Working
166+
167+
### Medium Risk ⚠️
168+
* Proof completion time - 27 proofs may take >2 months
169+
* ECHIDNA accuracy - Need to validate suggestions carefully
170+
* Multi-prover disagreements - May require manual resolution
171+
172+
### Mitigation
173+
* Start with easier proofs (build confidence)
174+
* Always manually review ECHIDNA suggestions
175+
* Use multi-prover consensus (3+ provers)
176+
* Document any proof challenges
177+
178+
---
179+
180+
## Success Criteria (v1.0)
181+
182+
* [x] ✅ License: PMPL-1.0-or-later
183+
* [x] ✅ Documentation: Comprehensive
184+
* [x] ✅ ECHIDNA: Integrated
185+
* [ ] 🎯 Proofs: 27 → 0 Admitted
186+
* [ ] 🎯 Container: Built and verified
187+
* [ ] 🎯 Paper: Written and submitted
188+
* [ ] 🎯 DOI: Assigned
189+
190+
**Current progress**: 3/7 (43%)
191+
**On track for**: v1.0 in 6 months
192+
193+
---
194+
195+
## Conclusion
196+
197+
**Major achievements today (2026-02-05)**:
198+
1. Standardized licenses across 2 repos (130+ files)
199+
2. Clarified architecture (proofs vs. test subjects)
200+
3. Integrated ECHIDNA neurosymbolic tool
201+
4. Simplified roadmap (7-year plan)
202+
5. Created 5 comprehensive documentation files
203+
204+
**Immediate priority**: Complete 27 Admitted proofs using ECHIDNA assistance.
205+
206+
**Status**: On track for v1.0 MVP in 6 months 🎯
207+
208+
---
209+
210+
_Status report compiled 2026-02-05_

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)