Skip to content

Commit 445d4c7

Browse files
Add comprehensive academic proofs and formal verification (#2)
This commit adds exhaustive academic documentation covering the theoretical foundations of the Anvomidav DSL for figure skating choreography notation. ## Formal Specification - grammar.adoc: Complete EBNF grammar, lexical specification, parsing complexity - semantics.adoc: Operational, denotational, and axiomatic semantics - automata-theory.adoc: DFAs, PDAs, timed automata, tree automata ## Type Theory - type-system.adoc: Dependent types, refinement types, effect system, linear types - category-theory-foundations.adoc: CCCs, monads, adjunctions, fibred categories ## Domain Mathematics - rink-geometry.adoc: Coordinate systems, paths, collision detection, topology - temporal-specification.adoc: LTL, MTL, duration calculus, timed CSP - skating-physics.adoc: Mechanics, dynamics, biomechanics - numerical-analysis.adoc: Integration, error analysis, constraint handling ## Verification - rules-specification.adoc: Formal ISU rule encoding - verification-methodology.adoc: Theorem proving, model checking, runtime verification - abstract-interpretation.adoc: Abstract domains, Galois connections, static analysis - computational-complexity.adoc: Time/space bounds, decision problems, FPT ## Proofs - soundness-completeness.adoc: Type soundness, semantic correctness, compiler correctness ## White Papers - anvomidav-overview.adoc: Technical white paper summarizing the language Each document includes theorems, proofs (or proof sketches), definitions, and clearly marked TODO sections for areas requiring further development. Co-authored-by: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
1 parent b9e7026 commit 445d4c7

16 files changed

Lines changed: 8527 additions & 0 deletions

File tree

docs/academic/README.adoc

Lines changed: 255 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,255 @@
1+
// SPDX-FileCopyrightText: 2025 hyperpolymath
2+
// SPDX-License-Identifier: MIT OR AGPL-3.0-or-later
3+
4+
= Anvomidav Academic Documentation
5+
:toc: macro
6+
:toc-title: Contents
7+
:toclevels: 2
8+
9+
== Overview
10+
11+
This directory contains comprehensive academic documentation for Anvomidav, providing the mathematical and theoretical foundations required for rigorous academic scrutiny. The documentation covers formal specifications, proofs, and analyses across multiple disciplines.
12+
13+
toc::[]
14+
15+
== Document Index
16+
17+
=== Formal Specification
18+
19+
[cols="2,3,1"]
20+
|===
21+
|Document |Description |Status
22+
23+
|link:formal-specification/grammar.adoc[Grammar Specification]
24+
|Complete EBNF grammar, lexical specification, parsing properties
25+
|Draft
26+
27+
|link:formal-specification/semantics.adoc[Formal Semantics]
28+
|Operational, denotational, and axiomatic semantics
29+
|Draft
30+
31+
|link:formal-specification/automata-theory.adoc[Automata Theory]
32+
|DFAs, PDAs, timed automata for language and execution modeling
33+
|Draft
34+
|===
35+
36+
=== Type Theory
37+
38+
[cols="2,3,1"]
39+
|===
40+
|Document |Description |Status
41+
42+
|link:type-theory/type-system.adoc[Type System]
43+
|Dependent types, refinement types, effect system, soundness proofs
44+
|Draft
45+
46+
|link:type-theory/category-theory-foundations.adoc[Category Theory]
47+
|Categorical semantics, monads, adjunctions, coherence theorems
48+
|Draft
49+
|===
50+
51+
=== Spatial Mathematics
52+
53+
[cols="2,3,1"]
54+
|===
55+
|Document |Description |Status
56+
57+
|link:spatial-mathematics/rink-geometry.adoc[Rink Geometry]
58+
|Coordinate systems, geometric primitives, path calculus, collision detection
59+
|Draft
60+
|===
61+
62+
=== Temporal Logic
63+
64+
[cols="2,3,1"]
65+
|===
66+
|Document |Description |Status
67+
68+
|link:temporal-logic/temporal-specification.adoc[Temporal Specification]
69+
|LTL, MTL, duration calculus, timed automata, music synchronization
70+
|Draft
71+
|===
72+
73+
=== Physics and Kinematics
74+
75+
[cols="2,3,1"]
76+
|===
77+
|Document |Description |Status
78+
79+
|link:physics-kinematics/skating-physics.adoc[Skating Physics]
80+
|Classical mechanics, jump dynamics, spin dynamics, biomechanics
81+
|Draft
82+
83+
|link:physics-kinematics/numerical-analysis.adoc[Numerical Analysis]
84+
|Integration methods, error analysis, constraint handling
85+
|Draft
86+
|===
87+
88+
=== ISU Formalization
89+
90+
[cols="2,3,1"]
91+
|===
92+
|Document |Description |Status
93+
94+
|link:isu-formalization/rules-specification.adoc[ISU Rules Specification]
95+
|Formal encoding of ISU technical rules, scoring, compliance validation
96+
|Draft
97+
|===
98+
99+
=== Formal Verification
100+
101+
[cols="2,3,1"]
102+
|===
103+
|Document |Description |Status
104+
105+
|link:formal-verification/verification-methodology.adoc[Verification Methodology]
106+
|Theorem proving, model checking, abstract interpretation, runtime verification
107+
|Draft
108+
109+
|link:formal-verification/abstract-interpretation.adoc[Abstract Interpretation]
110+
|Abstract domains, Galois connections, static analysis algorithms
111+
|Draft
112+
|===
113+
114+
=== Complexity Analysis
115+
116+
[cols="2,3,1"]
117+
|===
118+
|Document |Description |Status
119+
120+
|link:complexity-analysis/computational-complexity.adoc[Computational Complexity]
121+
|Time/space complexity, decision problems, parameterized complexity
122+
|Draft
123+
|===
124+
125+
=== Proofs
126+
127+
[cols="2,3,1"]
128+
|===
129+
|Document |Description |Status
130+
131+
|link:proofs/soundness-completeness.adoc[Soundness and Completeness]
132+
|Type soundness, semantic correctness, compiler correctness proofs
133+
|Draft
134+
|===
135+
136+
=== White Papers
137+
138+
[cols="2,3,1"]
139+
|===
140+
|Document |Description |Status
141+
142+
|link:white-papers/anvomidav-overview.adoc[Anvomidav Overview]
143+
|Technical white paper summarizing the language and its contributions
144+
|Draft
145+
|===
146+
147+
== Coverage Summary
148+
149+
=== Disciplines Covered
150+
151+
* **Computer Science**: Formal languages, type theory, semantics, complexity
152+
* **Mathematics**: Category theory, temporal logic, topology, algebra
153+
* **Physics**: Classical mechanics, rotational dynamics, biomechanics
154+
* **Engineering**: Numerical methods, constraint satisfaction, optimization
155+
* **Domain Knowledge**: ISU regulations, skating techniques, choreographic notation
156+
157+
=== Proof Status
158+
159+
[cols="3,1,1,1"]
160+
|===
161+
|Category |Paper Proofs |Mechanized |TODO
162+
163+
|Type Soundness |✓ |Planned |Machine verification
164+
|Semantic Correctness |✓ |Planned |Adequacy proof details
165+
|Compiler Correctness |Partial |— |Complete proof
166+
|ISU Compliance |✓ |— |Full rule coverage
167+
|Spatial Safety |✓ |— |Numerical verification
168+
|===
169+
170+
== TODO: Gaps and Future Work
171+
172+
[WARNING]
173+
====
174+
The following areas require additional development:
175+
176+
=== Missing Documents
177+
* [ ] Information theory (encoding efficiency)
178+
* [ ] Statistics (scoring distribution, GOE prediction)
179+
* [ ] Machine learning (AI-assisted choreography)
180+
* [ ] Human-computer interaction (usability studies)
181+
* [ ] Comparative language analysis
182+
183+
=== Incomplete Proofs
184+
* [ ] Machine-checked type soundness (Lean 4/Coq)
185+
* [ ] Complete compiler correctness
186+
* [ ] Numerical error bounds for physics simulation
187+
* [ ] Full ISU rule encoding verification
188+
189+
=== Implementation Gaps
190+
* [ ] Reference implementation
191+
* [ ] Benchmark suite
192+
* [ ] Test case coverage metrics
193+
====
194+
195+
== Usage Guidelines
196+
197+
=== For Researchers
198+
199+
These documents serve as:
200+
1. Reference specifications for implementation
201+
2. Foundation for formal verification
202+
3. Basis for peer review and academic publication
203+
204+
=== For Implementers
205+
206+
Use the specifications to:
207+
1. Implement correct parsers and type checkers
208+
2. Validate physics simulation accuracy
209+
3. Ensure ISU compliance checking correctness
210+
211+
=== For Reviewers
212+
213+
Each document includes:
214+
1. Complete mathematical definitions
215+
2. Theorems with proof sketches
216+
3. TODO sections marking incomplete areas
217+
4. References to foundational literature
218+
219+
== Document Conventions
220+
221+
=== Mathematical Notation
222+
223+
* stem:[\mathsf{Sans\ serif}]: Type/kind names
224+
* stem:[\texttt{Monospace}]: Syntax/code
225+
* stem:[\Gamma \vdash e : \tau]: Typing judgment
226+
* stem:[\langle e, \sigma \rangle \to \langle e', \sigma' \rangle]: Reduction
227+
228+
=== Status Indicators
229+
230+
* **Draft**: Initial version, subject to significant revision
231+
* **Review**: Ready for peer review
232+
* **Stable**: Reviewed and accepted
233+
* **Final**: Published/frozen
234+
235+
== Contributing
236+
237+
See link:../../CONTRIBUTING.md[CONTRIBUTING.md] for contribution guidelines.
238+
239+
Academic contributions should:
240+
1. Follow the document structure established here
241+
2. Include complete proofs or mark TODOs
242+
3. Reference prior work appropriately
243+
4. Use consistent notation
244+
245+
== License
246+
247+
All academic documentation is dual-licensed under:
248+
* MIT License
249+
* AGPL-3.0-or-later
250+
251+
See link:../../LICENSE.txt[LICENSE.txt] for details.
252+
253+
---
254+
255+
_Last Updated: 2025-01-01_

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)