|
| 1 | +// SPDX-License-Identifier: MPL-2.0 |
| 2 | +// SPDX-FileCopyrightText: 2026 Jonathan D.A. Jewell (hyperpolymath) |
| 3 | += SESSION-CLOSE 2026-06-21 — K9 satellite/hub fan-out + TS-exemption parser |
| 4 | +:toc: |
| 5 | +:protocol: continuity / planned-session-close |
| 6 | +:session-id: 2026-06-21-k9-fanout-ts-parser |
| 7 | + |
| 8 | +== 1. Goal / scope |
| 9 | + |
| 10 | +Three intertwined threads on the K9 ecosystem: |
| 11 | + |
| 12 | +* the *satellite/hub fan-out* — extract a coordination hub, flip `k9-rs` |
| 13 | + from source-of-truth to satellite, wire cross-repo drift enforcement and |
| 14 | + tree-sitter/vscode generation across the 11 K9 member repos; |
| 15 | +* the *TS-exemption parser bug* — the shared governance check flags the |
| 16 | + approved `rrt.ts` exemption; and |
| 17 | +* an explanatory thread on *why `rrt.ts` is TypeScript, not AffineScript*. |
| 18 | + |
| 19 | +== 2. Verified situation at close (2026-06-21) |
| 20 | + |
| 21 | +* *`hyperpolymath/k9-ecosystem` now EXISTS* (created 2026-06-21 01:16Z, |
| 22 | + updated 14:16Z; public; Nickel; charter = "conformance, membership, |
| 23 | + cross-repo drift enforcement; pins spec + governance from |
| 24 | + hyperpolymath/standards"). The hub-creation blocker is *resolved*. |
| 25 | +** The staged copy still lives here on `claude/nice-hopper-fzl2bl` at |
| 26 | + `f911392b` ("Add k9-ecosystem aggregator hub (staged for extraction)") |
| 27 | + plus `d2300b85` (dogfood-gate fix). Whether the live repo was populated |
| 28 | + *from* this staging is unverified (k9-ecosystem is out of scope). |
| 29 | +* *`k9-ecosystem` and `standards` are NOT in this session's scope* and are |
| 30 | + not checked out. `list_repos`/`add_repo` tooling is *unavailable*, so |
| 31 | + neither can be added from here. |
| 32 | +* *Fan-out has not reached the member repos*: `k9-rs` and |
| 33 | + `k9-validate-action` have 0 open PRs; `tree-sitter-k9` has only a stale |
| 34 | + Dependabot bump. No satellite-anchor PRs, no `k9-rs` flip, no drift job, |
| 35 | + no generation wiring. |
| 36 | +* *TS parser fix not landed/observable*: the only repo where `rrt.ts` |
| 37 | + trips the check is `developer-ecosystem`, pinned pre-fix. |
| 38 | +* *All 12 in-scope repos clean* (0 uncommitted / 0 unpushed). |
| 39 | + `developer-ecosystem` was on `claude/ci-hygiene`; moved to |
| 40 | + `claude/nice-hopper-fzl2bl` for this close record. |
| 41 | + |
| 42 | +== 3. Parser bug — root location (for a standards-scoped fix) |
| 43 | + |
| 44 | +* Governance is centralized: every repo's `.github/workflows/governance.yml` |
| 45 | + is a thin wrapper for |
| 46 | + `hyperpolymath/standards/.github/workflows/governance-reusable.yml`. The |
| 47 | + per-repo `ts-blocker.yml` was deleted and folded in. |
| 48 | +* The TS-exemption parser lives in `standards` (`governance-reusable.yml` |
| 49 | + plus its script). *Prime hypothesis (UNCONFIRMED — standards out of |
| 50 | + scope):* exemption path cells are read from the `CLAUDE.md` markdown |
| 51 | + table without stripping the surrounding backticks, so the literal |
| 52 | + `+`…/rrt.ts`+` never equals the on-disk path; exact-path exemptions |
| 53 | + silently never match. A complete hand-off brief for a standards-scoped |
| 54 | + agent was produced this session (see §5.3 E-1). |
| 55 | + |
| 56 | +== 4. Consumer-pin surface (corrected) |
| 57 | + |
| 58 | +An earlier in-session claim ("bump pins across developer-ecosystem + the |
| 59 | +k9 repos") was *wrong*. Verified by grep across all checkouts: |
| 60 | + |
| 61 | +* Only *2* files pin `governance-reusable.yml@861b5e9` (frozen): |
| 62 | + `developer-ecosystem/.github/workflows/governance.yml` and |
| 63 | + `k9-validate-action/.github/workflows/governance.yml`. These need a |
| 64 | + manual SHA bump to receive the fix. |
| 65 | +* All other consumers (the other 10 K9 repos + ~115 developer-ecosystem |
| 66 | + sub-projects) pin `@main`, so they auto-receive the fix on merge. |
| 67 | +* Aside (parked): the 2 frozen pins are the policy-*compliant* ones; the |
| 68 | + `@main` majority is itself unpinned drift vs the "SHA-pinned |
| 69 | + dependencies" rule — separate cleanup. |
| 70 | + |
| 71 | +== 5. Triage (response to the close-out request) |
| 72 | + |
| 73 | +=== 5.1 Completed in this quick run |
| 74 | + |
| 75 | +* This `SESSION-CLOSE` record + a `STATE.a2ml` session block — the durable |
| 76 | + handoff (the container is ephemeral; nothing else here was committable). |
| 77 | +* Tracking issue filed for the member-side fan-out (see E-3) on `k9-rs` |
| 78 | + (clean tracker, in-scope). |
| 79 | + |
| 80 | +=== 5.2 Discard |
| 81 | + |
| 82 | +* The `.governance-allowlist` workaround — superseded by the decision to |
| 83 | + fix the parser at source. Do not pursue. |
| 84 | +* Re-litigating settled decisions (hub-first extraction; fan-out after |
| 85 | + developer-ecosystem#124) — both resolved. |
| 86 | + |
| 87 | +=== 5.3 Allocate to issues |
| 88 | + |
| 89 | +* *E-1 — `standards` (CANNOT file from here, out of scope):* fix the |
| 90 | + TS-exemption parser (strip backticks/whitespace on the path cell) + |
| 91 | + regression test covering all 3 exemptions and a near-miss; record the |
| 92 | + new `governance-reusable.yml` SHA. Hand-off brief ready. |
| 93 | +* *E-2 — `developer-ecosystem` + `k9-validate-action`:* after E-1 merges, |
| 94 | + bump the 2 frozen `governance-reusable.yml@861b5e9` pins to the fixed |
| 95 | + SHA. Small, in-scope, ready. |
| 96 | +* *E-3 — `k9-rs` / `k9-ecosystem`:* member-side fan-out — satellite |
| 97 | + anchor, flip `k9-rs` source→satellite, drift job on `k9-validate-action`, |
| 98 | + tree-sitter + vscode generation. Filed on `k9-rs`; true home is |
| 99 | + `k9-ecosystem` when scoped. |
| 100 | +* *E-4 — `developer-ecosystem`:* reconcile the exemption-list drift (§6.1). |
| 101 | +* *E-5 — `developer-ecosystem`:* remove the staged `k9-ecosystem` hub copy |
| 102 | + once the live repo is verified populated (reversible-move discipline). |
| 103 | + |
| 104 | +=== 5.4 Sketch areas + doc entries (recommended, NOT scaffolded blind) |
| 105 | + |
| 106 | +* In *k9-ecosystem* (when scoped): `membership.ncl` (member registry), |
| 107 | + `drift/` (cross-repo drift rules), `conformance/` (K9 contract |
| 108 | + conformance). These define the anchor schema members import — sketching |
| 109 | + them in members now would guess the schema. Hold until the hub is scoped. |
| 110 | +* In *k9-rs*: a `docs/satellite/` stub describing the satellite |
| 111 | + relationship + anchor import — safe to add once the hub schema exists. |
| 112 | +* Machine docs: each member's `.machine_readable/6a2/ECOSYSTEM.a2ml` should |
| 113 | + gain `satellite-of = "k9-ecosystem"` as part of the flip. |
| 114 | + |
| 115 | +=== 5.5 Cleanup |
| 116 | + |
| 117 | +* *Branches:* `developer-ecosystem` carries `claude/ci-hygiene` |
| 118 | + (trufflehog drop, aggregate-library extraction) and |
| 119 | + `claude/nice-hopper-fzl2bl` (k9-ecosystem staging, dogfood gate). |
| 120 | + Reconcile/merge and prune once their PRs land. NOTE: an explicit |
| 121 | + `git fetch origin claude/nice-hopper-fzl2bl` returned "couldn't find |
| 122 | + remote ref" — the remote branch may have been deleted post-merge; verify |
| 123 | + before pruning the local branch. |
| 124 | +* *Docs:* `k9-rs/.machine_readable/6a2/STATE.a2ml` still carries |
| 125 | + META-TEMPLATE identity (`{{PLACEHOLDER}}`, "the TEMPLATE's evolution") — |
| 126 | + de-template to k9-rs's real identity (Rust impl of the K9 format), |
| 127 | + matching the `docs(state): replace rsr-template-repo residue` campaign in |
| 128 | + sibling repos. |
| 129 | +* *Config / contractiles 6a2:* `developer-ecosystem` contractile *tridents* |
| 130 | + (`k9.ncl` + `manifest.a2ml`) remain deferred for all 6 verbs |
| 131 | + (`trident-coverage = none`); `lust` absent. Pre-existing estate debt — |
| 132 | + leave unless prioritized. |
| 133 | +* *Policy:* drop or relocate the now-stale |
| 134 | + `aggregate-library/src/test-runner.ts` row in `.claude/CLAUDE.md` |
| 135 | + (extracted by #119). Left for the user — it is policy. |
| 136 | + |
| 137 | +== 6. Drift / findings (machine ↔ human doc mismatches) |
| 138 | + |
| 139 | +. *TS exemptions:* `.claude/CLAUDE.md` table = 3 rows; |
| 140 | + `.machine_readable/6a2/STATE.a2ml` `approved-ts-exemptions` = 2 (omits |
| 141 | + aggregate-library). `#119` extracted aggregate-library to its own repo, |
| 142 | + so its path is stale in CLAUDE.md → *STATE is canonical; CLAUDE.md should |
| 143 | + drop/relocate the row.* |
| 144 | +. *Wiki stale for K9:* `docs/wikis/Home.md` describes developer-ecosystem |
| 145 | + as a 30+ satellite hub (Git Tools / Repo Mgmt / Scaffolding / Developer |
| 146 | + UX). It does *not* mention the K9 ecosystem, the `k9-ecosystem` hub, the |
| 147 | + satellite/hub model, or the governance-reusable consolidation. |
| 148 | +. *k9-rs identity residue:* its `STATE.a2ml` is still the template META |
| 149 | + file rather than k9-rs's own state. |
| 150 | + |
| 151 | +== 7. Wiki & documentation assessment (dev / maintainer / user) |
| 152 | + |
| 153 | +Answer to "is the wiki up to date with the fullest representation, split by |
| 154 | +audience": *partially — strong scaffolding, but not yet a complete |
| 155 | +pedagogical body, and stale for K9.* |
| 156 | + |
| 157 | +*What exists and is good:* audience-split quickstarts already present |
| 158 | +(`QUICKSTART-DEV/MAINTAINER/USER.adoc`) in both repos; an in-repo *signpost* |
| 159 | +wiki (`docs/wikis/Home.md`) that correctly defers to canonical `docs/`; LLM |
| 160 | +warmups (`llm-warmup-dev.md`, `llm-warmup-user.md`); deep governance / audit |
| 161 | +/ decision scaffolding under `k9-rs/docs/`. |
| 162 | + |
| 163 | +*Gaps for "beyond setup / really engage":* |
| 164 | + |
| 165 | +* *End users:* no conceptual "what is a K9 self-validating component / |
| 166 | + contractile, and why" narrative; quickstarts are run-throughs, not mental |
| 167 | + models. No worked end-to-end example of authoring + validating a K9 |
| 168 | + contract. |
| 169 | +* *Developers:* no "how the pieces fit" map |
| 170 | + (`k9-rs` ↔ `k9-ecosystem` ↔ `standards` ↔ tree-sitter/vscode); the |
| 171 | + governance-reusable wrapper model is undocumented; contributing docs are |
| 172 | + generic RSR, not K9-specific. |
| 173 | +* *Maintainers:* the membership + drift-enforcement model (the entire point |
| 174 | + of `k9-ecosystem`) is undocumented; the pin policy (`@main` vs SHA) is |
| 175 | + undocumented; cross-member release/sync is undocumented. |
| 176 | +* *Currency:* `Home.md` predates the K9 hub entirely. |
| 177 | + |
| 178 | +*Recommended structure* (lives in `docs/`, signposted from the wiki): |
| 179 | + |
| 180 | +* `docs/concepts/` (users): what K9 is, contractiles, the self-validation |
| 181 | + model, a worked example. |
| 182 | +* `docs/developer/` (devs): architecture map, the satellite/hub model, the |
| 183 | + governance-reusable wrapper, the generation pipeline (tree-sitter→vscode), |
| 184 | + the local dev loop. |
| 185 | +* `docs/governance/` (maintainers): membership + drift enforcement, pin |
| 186 | + policy, cross-member release/sync, the exemption process. |
| 187 | + |
| 188 | +This is a documentation *epic*, not a quick-run item — recommend an issue + |
| 189 | +staged authoring. |
| 190 | + |
| 191 | +== 8. Blockers |
| 192 | + |
| 193 | +* *Scope:* `k9-ecosystem` and `standards` not in session scope; not |
| 194 | + checked out. |
| 195 | +* *Tooling:* `list_repos`/`add_repo` unavailable → cannot self-add repos; |
| 196 | + `send_later` unavailable → no self-scheduled re-check. |
| 197 | +* *Net:* nothing further on the fan-out or parser fix is executable from |
| 198 | + this session. |
| 199 | + |
| 200 | +== 9. Decision log |
| 201 | + |
| 202 | +* Hub extracted first (`k9-ecosystem`) — done externally; live repo exists. |
| 203 | +* Parser fixed at source in `standards`, not via a per-repo allowlist |
| 204 | + workaround. |
| 205 | +* Consumer-side delivery for the parser fix = *2 pin bumps only* |
| 206 | + (corrected from "all k9 repos"). |
| 207 | +* aggregate-library exemption is stale post-#119; STATE is canonical, |
| 208 | + CLAUDE.md to be reconciled. |
| 209 | +* No autonomous edits to policy (`CLAUDE.md`), to out-of-scope repos, or |
| 210 | + destructive branch ops at close. |
| 211 | + |
| 212 | +== 10. Recommended next protocol |
| 213 | + |
| 214 | +. Scope `k9-ecosystem` → run the member-side fan-out (E-3), then sketch the |
| 215 | + hub schema (§5.4). |
| 216 | +. Scope `standards` (or run the hand-off brief elsewhere) → fix the parser |
| 217 | + (E-1) → bump the 2 pins (E-2). |
| 218 | +. Reconcile the exemption drift (E-4) + de-template `k9-rs` STATE. |
| 219 | +. Schedule the documentation epic (§7). |
| 220 | + |
| 221 | +== 11. User invitations |
| 222 | + |
| 223 | +* Add `k9-ecosystem` and/or `standards` to this session's scope to unblock |
| 224 | + the above. |
| 225 | +* Confirm direction on the aggregate-library exemption (drop vs relocate to |
| 226 | + the new repo's policy). |
| 227 | +* Approve the docs epic + audience structure in §7, or adjust. |
| 228 | + |
| 229 | +== 12. Post-condition check |
| 230 | + |
| 231 | +|=== |
| 232 | +| Post-condition | State |
| 233 | +| Durable session record written (this file) + STATE.a2ml block | ✅ |
| 234 | +| No work lost to the ephemeral container | ✅ |
| 235 | +| In-scope repos clean; developer-ecosystem on designated branch | ✅ |
| 236 | +| Fan-out / parser fix blocked on scope, fully documented for handoff | ✅ |
| 237 | +|=== |
0 commit comments