Skip to content

Commit 765c1cc

Browse files
hyperpolymathclaude
andcommitted
docs(verification): land E10/E11/E13 Lean4 proof designs
Three Lean4 proof files mirroring ConfidenceLattice.lean style, closing the design phase of Stage 8 trust-pipeline meta-proofs: - ParetoMaximality.lean: 11 PO theorems on dominance algebra + frontier soundness/completeness/dichotomy + best-axis preservation. PO-12 (strong maximality) deferred — needs mathlib Finset.exists_maximal_wrt or hand-rolled WellFoundedRelation; tracking ticket ECHIDNA-PARETO-DESCENT. - IntegrityVerification.lean: 12 PI theorems on the SHAKE-256/512 + BLAKE3 verifier. Hash naming clarification: implementation is SHAKE-256 squeezing 512 bits, not "SHAKE3-512" (no such function in FIPS 202). Collision-resistance theorems (PI-7, PI-9) state the assumption explicitly via typeclass per the zero-axiom policy. - PortfolioCompleteness.lean: 14 PR theorems on reconcile() — every result list maps to exactly one of {CrossChecked, SingleSolver, Inconclusive, AllTimedOut}; verdict matches first completed under consensus; needs_review fires iff no consensus. PROOF-NEEDS.md updated to reflect E10/E11/E13 design landed. Remaining work is `lake build` integration; the existing proofs/lean/lakefile.lean is for the Lean playground, not these verification proofs. Filed under MEDIUM priority (P2, non-blocking). Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
1 parent 5fdff1c commit 765c1cc

4 files changed

Lines changed: 1252 additions & 4 deletions

File tree

PROOF-NEEDS.md

Lines changed: 4 additions & 4 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -34,14 +34,14 @@ following the pattern in repos like `typed-wasm`, `proven`, `echidna`, or `boj-s
3434
|---|------|--------|--------|
3535
| E1 | Confidence scoring lattice (TrustLevel forms valid partial order) | L4 | Covered by ConfidenceLattice.lean |
3636
| E8 | VQL-UT query safety (SEC, deeper layer) | I2 | Partially covered by VqlUt.idr |
37-
| E10 | Pareto frontier maximality | L4 | Not started |
38-
| E11 | SHAKE3-512/BLAKE3 integrity | L4 | Not started |
39-
| E13 | Portfolio cross-checking completeness | L4 | Not started |
37+
| E10 | Pareto frontier maximality | L4 | **Design landed 2026-04-27** (`verification/proofs/lean4/ParetoMaximality.lean` + Creusot mirror at `crates/echidna-core-spark/src/pareto.rs`); 11 of 12 PO theorems closed, strong-maximality (PO-12) deferred — needs mathlib `Finset.exists_maximal_wrt` or hand-rolled `WellFoundedRelation`. Tracking ticket: ECHIDNA-PARETO-DESCENT |
38+
| E11 | SHAKE3-512/BLAKE3 integrity | L4 | **Design landed 2026-04-27** (`verification/proofs/lean4/IntegrityVerification.lean`); 12 PI theorems including verifier soundness/completeness, status exhaustiveness, BLAKE3 cache freshness; collision-resistance theorems (PI-7, PI-9) state assumption explicitly as a typeclass per zero-axiom policy. NB: hash naming clarification — implementation is SHAKE-256 squeezing 512 bits, not "SHAKE3-512" |
39+
| E13 | Portfolio cross-checking completeness | L4 | **Design landed 2026-04-27** (`verification/proofs/lean4/PortfolioCompleteness.lean`); 14 PR theorems covering exhaustiveness, AllTimedOut iff no completed, CrossChecked agreement, Inconclusive disagreement detection, needs_review iff non-consensus, unanimity → CrossChecked |
4040

4141
## Recommended prover
4242
- **Idris2** for ABI-level properties and prover dispatch correctness
4343
- **Lean4** for algebraic properties of the confidence lattice
4444
- **Agda** for metatheoretic properties of proof composition
4545

4646
## Priority
47-
- **MEDIUM** (was HIGH) — Core trust pipeline proofs (E2-E6) are now complete. E10-E13 are P2 and do not block the critical path.
47+
- **MEDIUM** (was HIGH) — Core trust pipeline proofs (E2-E6) are now complete. E10-E13 design + statements landed 2026-04-27; remaining work is `lake build` integration (no Lean toolchain pinned in `verification/proofs/lean4/`; the existing `proofs/lean/lakefile.lean` is for the playground, not these proofs). E10-E13 are P2 and do not block the critical path.

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)