@@ -217,6 +217,109 @@ work to `main` and refresh all documentation:
217217
218218## Current rung state (2026-06-21)
219219
220+ ### Session arc 2026-06-21 (close-out) — gap-closing proofs #249 –#258 + cross-repo docs audit + ⚠ ordinal-ledger contradiction flag (read this FIRST)
221+
222+ * This is a session-closing bookkeeping arc.* No new proof rung — it (a) catches
223+ the ledger up to the proofs that landed without an arc, (b) records a
224+ cross-repo (echo-types + 007) documentation-completeness audit, and (c) flags
225+ ** one unresolved owner-decision** that a subsequent agent MUST NOT silently
226+ "fix".
227+
228+ ** Gap-closing proofs that landed this session (echo-types ` main ` ), now
229+ ledgered.** All ` --safe --without-K ` , zero postulates, wired into ` All.agda ` ,
230+ pinned in ` Smoke.agda ` , kernel-guard PASS:
231+ * ` #249 ` ` EchoReversibilityBridge ` — ` ReversibleCompletion ` record +
232+ ` reversibility-via-totality : Σ B (Echo f) ↔ A ` ; the proof-side bridge to
233+ 007's L10 echo-residue reversibility (` reversible as ` /` reverse ` ).
234+ * ` #250 ` ` EchoResidueCell ` — Agda mirror of 007's Idris ` ResidueCell `
235+ (` holding ` /` spent ` , ` takeForReverse ` , ` consume ` , ` once-only ` ); the
236+ once-only linear-consumption discipline.
237+ * ` #251 ` ` EchoSearch ` — ` bounded-search-is-decidable ` (the deferred
238+ decidability bridge from the 2026-05-20 Wave-3 "where next").
239+ * ` #254 ` ` EchoSearch ` product composition — ` productEnum ` /` echo-search-product `
240+ (row-major DivMod pairing; the deferred ` ℕ × ℕ ↔ ℕ ` slice).
241+ * ` #252 ` ` EchoApprox ` — ` LipschitzScale ` opt-in record +
242+ ` echo-approx-compose-lipschitz ` (the deferred Rung-C composition, via a
243+ layered record, never mutating the base ` Tolerance ` ).
244+ * ` #257 ` ` EchoLLEncoding ` — ` forget-witness-encoding-has-section ` : the
245+ * universal* LL-encoding gap (every forget-witness encoding has a section),
246+ strengthening the existence form per the 2026-05-27 "where next" #2 .
247+ * ` #258 ` ` docs/proof-debt.md ` — refreshed the stale "variance NOT proven"
248+ bullet; resolved by the wired ` EchoVariance ` (#243 ).
249+ Design lesson reused throughout: ** layered opt-in records** (` BalancedTolerance `
250+ / ` LipschitzScale ` ) extend, never mutate, the base carrier — same discipline as
251+ ` EchoApproxInstance ` trivial-on-` ⊤ ` Smoke pins for parameterised modules.
252+
253+ ** Trust boundary re-confirmed this session.** Exactly ** 3 quarantined
254+ postulates** , all OUTSIDE the wired cone (so ` All.agda ` /` Smoke.agda ` depend on
255+ none): ` EchoImageFactorizationPropPostulated ` (c, realised in the ` --cubical `
256+ island) + the two ` Ordinal/Buchholz/Fidelity.agda ` postulates (d, ` denotation `
257+ / ` ordinal-upper-bound ` ). See ` proof-debt.md ` (a)–(d). Echo Core is
258+ postulate-free and hole-free.
259+
260+ ** ⚠ OWNER-DECISION FLAG — ordinal: retired-in-ledger but committing-on-main.**
261+ ` main ` (this arc's base, ` 9c56d40 ` ) carries TWO ordinal climb rungs dated
262+ ** 2026-06-21** , landed the SAME DAY as the ` D-2026-06-21 ` retirement:
263+ ` f89a3aa ` (BH rung 7 — ` nextFix ` is the LEAST pre-fixed point; reverse-Γ₀
264+ reduced) and ` a096764 ` (BH rung 8 — Veblen engine monotone in its iterated
265+ function). This ** contradicts** the retirement banner in this file (arc below)
266+ and in ` roadmap.adoc ` §Lane 3 ("no new ordinal rung is to be opened here").
267+ Meanwhile ` wiki/Architecture.adoc ` ("Track 2 — Ordinal (partial)") and
268+ ` wiki/Roadmap.adoc ` ("Ordinal track — partial (the active bottleneck)") still
269+ frame the climb as ACTIVE — i.e. they are consistent with the * code* but not
270+ the * decision* . ** Do NOT propagate the retirement to the wiki, and do NOT
271+ delete the ordinal artifact, until the owner reconciles** which is
272+ authoritative: the retirement decision, or the continued climb. Both readings
273+ are live; the fix direction depends entirely on that call. (Also landed on
274+ ` main ` same day, non-ordinal: ` 4883ae2 ` ` EchoTransaction ` closes #174 ;
275+ ` bd43ad4 ` ` EchoSelectiveProjection ` closes #176 ; ` 9c56d40 `
276+ ` entropy-blind-parametric ` .)
277+
278+ ** Cross-repo docs-completeness audit (read-only, 2026-06-21).** Verdicts after
279+ * verifying* the audit subagents' claims against the actual tree (several were
280+ over-reported):
281+ * * echo-types wiki ≈ current.* Technical/proof docs strong; the only genuine
282+ staleness is the 2 ordinal wiki files above — GATED on the reconciliation
283+ flag, so NOT auto-fixed. Author-driven doc * enhancements* (candidates, file
284+ only if you want them tracked — none filed): a proof-architecture reading
285+ tour; a comparative-vocabulary page; a dedicated ` EchoVariance ` wiki page; a
286+ Zenodo/packaging guide for Pillar E.
287+ * * 007 docs MORE complete than its audit claimed.* The audit's headline gaps
288+ are FALSE on inspection: ` spec/TYPE-SYSTEM-SPEC.adoc ` already carries a full
289+ ** §11b Layer 10** (subsections 11b.1–11b.8, incl. `11b.7 Mutable agent state
290+ (set)` and ` 11b.8 Echo-residue cells / runtime replay` ), and ` set_stmt` is in
291+ ` spec/grammar.ebnf:157 ` . 007 has explicit audience-split quickstarts
292+ (` QUICKSTART-{USER,DEV,MAINTAINER}.adoc ` ) and no ` wiki/ ` (uses a ` docs/ `
293+ tree). One genuine minor gap: no ` docs/README.md ` discovery index — a
294+ convention call for the owner, tracked-by-convention in ` STATE.a2ml ` , NOT
295+ filed as an issue (007 runs a deliberate 0-issue policy).
296+
297+ ** In-session triage of the three 007 buckets (1/2/3) — NOT doable here,
298+ correctly deferred.** (1)+(2) typed-wasm codegen: out of local scope and the
299+ ` list_repos ` /` add_repo ` tooling was unavailable to pull the typed-wasm repo
300+ in; tracked in ` 007/.machine_readable/STATE.a2ml ` (11-task rollout, `twasm =
301+ TwasmBackendNotYetImplemented` ). (3) Coq ` canonical-proof-suite` E1 headline:
302+ ** Coquelicot absent** though Coq 8.18 is installed — blocked. All three are
303+ already sketched + machine-documented in ` STATE.a2ml ` / ` AI-WORK-007.md ` ; no
304+ new in-repo sketch stub needed.
305+
306+ ** Cleanup flagged for the owner (cannot self-execute: branch delete = HTTP 403
307+ + no GitHub-MCP delete endpoint).** Merged/closed echo-types ` claude/* `
308+ branches safe to delete: ` echo-approx-lipschitz ` (#252 ), ` echo-ll-universal `
309+ (#257 ), ` echo-residue-cell ` (#250 ), ` echo-reversibility-bridge ` (#249 ),
310+ ` echo-search-decidable ` (#251 ), ` echo-search-product ` (#254 ),
311+ ` proof-debt-variance-refresh ` (#258 , all MERGED), and
312+ ` ordinal-fidelity-abandoned ` (#256 , CLOSED-not-merged — superseded by the
313+ owner's in-place #255 retirement). ` inspiring-meitner-QHuNU ` is this session's
314+ live branch.
315+
316+ ** Disposition: both repos are in a clean, verified, push-nothing-else state.**
317+ The remaining open proof work (real-valued Shannon entropy; the 2 Fidelity
318+ postulates; an EchoSearch abstract-machine model) is already sketched-in-place
319+ (module companion-remarks) + machine-documented (` proof-debt.md ` ,
320+ ` roadmap.adoc ` ). Nothing is being discarded; nothing else is force-landed from
321+ this 5-behind session base into an actively-moving ` main ` .
322+
220323### Session arc 2026-06-21 — Ordinal ascent RETIRED FROM ECHO-TYPES (escalates the 2026-06-20 PARK) (read this first)
221324
222325* Owner decision (D-2026-06-21).* The transfinite ordinal / Buchholz / Veblen
0 commit comments