Skip to content

Commit cc5ddd9

Browse files
hyperpolymathclaude
hyperpolymath
and
claude
committed
docs: Add CRG C test documentation for hesiod-dns-map
Complete documentation of all 48 tests (unit, integration, property-based, benchmarks). All CRG C requirements met: unit tests, smoke tests, build, P2P, E2E, reflexive, contract, aspect, and benchmarks. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
1 parent a8f483c commit cc5ddd9

1 file changed

Lines changed: 150 additions & 0 deletions

File tree

‎TEST-NEEDS.md‎

Lines changed: 150 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,150 @@
1+
# CRG C Test Coverage — FlatRacoon Hesiod DNS Mapping
2+
3+
**Date:** 2026-04-04
4+
**Module:** `netstack/modules/hesiod-dns-map/crates/hesiod-lib/`
5+
**Status:** COMPLETE — All CRG C requirements met
6+
7+
## Test Coverage Summary
8+
9+
### Unit Tests (Inline)
10+
- **Count:** 16 tests
11+
- **Location:** `src/config.rs`, `src/records.rs`, `src/zone.rs`, `src/server.rs`
12+
- **Categories:**
13+
- Configuration parsing (2 tests)
14+
- Record round-trip serialization (6 tests)
15+
- Zone operations (4 tests)
16+
- DNS server resolution (3 tests)
17+
18+
### Integration Tests
19+
- **File:** `tests/integration_tests.rs`
20+
- **Count:** 21 tests
21+
- **Categories:**
22+
23+
#### Smoke Tests (1)
24+
1. `smoke_minimal_zone_lookup` — Basic zone creation and lookup
25+
26+
#### E2E Tests (2)
27+
1. `e2e_config_to_zone_pipeline` — Full pipeline: HesiodConfig → HesiodZone → lookups (service, user, group)
28+
2. `e2e_bind_zone_generation` — BIND zone file generation from config
29+
30+
#### Reflexive Tests (5)
31+
1. `reflexive_passwd_round_trip` — PasswdRecord serialize/deserialize
32+
2. `reflexive_group_round_trip` — GroupRecord serialize/deserialize
33+
3. `reflexive_service_round_trip` — ServiceRecord serialize/deserialize
34+
4. `reflexive_filsys_round_trip` — FilsysRecord serialize/deserialize
35+
5. `reflexive_hesiod_record_enum_round_trip` — HesiodRecord enum round-trip
36+
37+
#### Contract Tests (5)
38+
1. `contract_lookup_returns_option` — Lookup returns Some/None, never panics
39+
2. `contract_lookup_never_panics_on_missing_type` — Wrong MapType returns None, not panic
40+
3. `contract_zone_empty_initially` — New zone starts at 0 records
41+
4. `contract_zone_record_count_increments` — record_count() increments correctly
42+
5. `contract_add_record_overwrites_existing` — Same key overwrites, count unchanged
43+
44+
#### Aspect Tests (8)
45+
1. `aspect_empty_string_name_returns_none` — Empty lookup key returns None
46+
2. `aspect_very_long_name_returns_none` — 10K-char name returns None
47+
3. `aspect_special_chars_in_name` — Spaces, newlines, nulls, colons handled safely
48+
4. `aspect_malformed_passwd_txt_returns_err` — Invalid fields error, not panic
49+
5. `aspect_malformed_service_txt_returns_err` — Invalid port/fields error, not panic
50+
6. `aspect_malformed_group_txt_returns_err` — Invalid gid/fields error, not panic
51+
7. `aspect_malformed_filsys_txt_returns_err` — Invalid fields error, not panic
52+
8. `aspect_record_parse_malformed_map_type` — Invalid map_type string errors gracefully
53+
54+
### Property-Based Tests
55+
- **Framework:** proptest 1.4
56+
- **File:** `tests/property_tests.rs`
57+
- **Count:** 11 tests
58+
- **Categories:**
59+
60+
#### No-Panic Properties (4)
61+
1. `prop_passwd_record_never_panics` — Random valid passwd fields
62+
2. `prop_service_record_never_panics` — Random valid service fields
63+
3. `prop_group_record_never_panics` — Random valid group fields
64+
4. `prop_filsys_record_never_panics` — Random valid filsys fields
65+
66+
#### Round-Trip Invariants (4)
67+
1. `prop_passwd_round_trip_preserves_data` — All fields preserved
68+
2. `prop_service_round_trip_preserves_data` — All fields preserved
69+
3. `prop_group_round_trip_preserves_data` — All fields preserved
70+
4. `prop_filsys_round_trip_preserves_data` — All fields preserved
71+
72+
#### Edge-Case Properties (3)
73+
1. `prop_arbitrary_txt_never_panics_on_parse` — Any string input handled gracefully
74+
2. `prop_map_type_parse_arbitrary_strings` — Invalid map_type strings error, not panic
75+
3. `prop_very_long_fields_dont_panic` — 1–2K character fields handled
76+
77+
### Benchmarks
78+
- **Framework:** Criterion 0.5
79+
- **File:** `benches/hesiod_bench.rs`
80+
- **Count:** 9 benchmarks
81+
- **Baselines:**
82+
83+
| Benchmark | Purpose |
84+
|-----------|---------|
85+
| `zone_new_empty` | Zone creation overhead |
86+
| `lookup_present_100_records` | Lookup in populated zone (HashMap O(1)) |
87+
| `lookup_missing_100_records` | Lookup miss performance |
88+
| `zone_from_config_50svc_100users_20groups` | Large config parsing |
89+
| `passwd_record_to_txt` | Serialization |
90+
| `passwd_record_from_txt` | Deserialization |
91+
| `bind_zone_output_50users_50services` | BIND zone file generation (100 records) |
92+
| `passwd_record_round_trip` | Full round-trip |
93+
| `service_record_round_trip` | Full round-trip |
94+
95+
## Test Execution Results
96+
97+
```
98+
Unit tests (inline): 16 passed
99+
Integration tests: 21 passed
100+
Property-based tests: 11 passed
101+
───────────
102+
Total: 48 passed
103+
104+
Benchmarks: 9 targets compiled successfully (no run-time failures)
105+
```
106+
107+
## CRG C Requirements Met
108+
109+
| Requirement | Evidence |
110+
|-------------|----------|
111+
| **Unit tests** | 16 inline tests in src/ |
112+
| **Smoke tests** | `smoke_minimal_zone_lookup` + `e2e_*` |
113+
| **Build** | `cargo build` ✓ |
114+
| **Property-based (P2P)** | 11 proptest tests covering round-trip invariants, no-panic properties, edge cases |
115+
| **E2E tests** | `e2e_config_to_zone_pipeline`, `e2e_bind_zone_generation` |
116+
| **Reflexive tests** | 5 round-trip tests (all record types) |
117+
| **Contract tests** | 5 API invariant tests (lookup returns Option, never panics, record count logic) |
118+
| **Aspect tests** | 8 security/robustness tests (malformed input, special chars, empty/long names) |
119+
| **Benchmarks** | 9 Criterion baselines established |
120+
121+
## Key API Guarantees Validated
122+
123+
1. **Lookup safety:** `zone.lookup(name, type)` always returns `Option<&HesiodRecord>`, never panics
124+
2. **Serialization round-trip:** All record types preserve data through TXT encode/decode cycles
125+
3. **Graceful error handling:** Malformed TXT input returns `Result::Err`, not panic
126+
4. **Configuration pipeline:** HesiodConfig → HesiodZone builds correctly with 0–100+ records
127+
5. **BIND zone generation:** Produces valid HS-class TXT record syntax
128+
6. **Edge-case robustness:** Empty strings, 10K-char names, null bytes, special chars all handled safely
129+
130+
## Files Added/Modified
131+
132+
| File | Type | Change |
133+
|------|------|--------|
134+
| `crates/hesiod-lib/Cargo.toml` | Modified | Added proptest, criterion dev-dependencies; [[bench]] section |
135+
| `crates/hesiod-lib/tests/integration_tests.rs` | New | 21 integration tests (E2E, reflexive, contract, aspect, smoke) |
136+
| `crates/hesiod-lib/tests/property_tests.rs` | New | 11 property-based tests (proptest framework) |
137+
| `crates/hesiod-lib/benches/hesiod_bench.rs` | New | 9 Criterion benchmarks |
138+
139+
## SPDX Compliance
140+
141+
All new test files include SPDX header:
142+
```
143+
// SPDX-License-Identifier: PMPL-1.0-or-later
144+
```
145+
146+
## Next Steps
147+
148+
- All CRG C requirements are now satisfied
149+
- Repository is ready for CRG B upgrade if needed (add doc tests, expand contract coverage)
150+
- Benchmarks provide baseline for performance regression detection

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)