From 74242d33abe38b1e5ae4720ad4a944829c011fcc Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Claude Date: Mon, 8 Dec 2025 20:19:11 +0000 Subject: [PATCH] Add STATE.scm checkpoint for AI conversation continuity Introduces comprehensive project state documentation following the state.scm specification (Guile Scheme S-expressions). Includes: - Current position: v0.1.0-dev with foundation complete - Route to MVP v1.0: 6 milestones (integration, containers, security, WordPress production, observability, documentation) - Issues catalog: 7 tracked issues (eBPF toolchain, testing, proxy) - Questions for maintainer: 15 architectural/scope decisions needed - Long-term roadmap: v1.0 through v3.0 (MVP to Platform) - Critical next actions: 7 immediate priorities This enables Claude Code sessions to resume from this checkpoint with full project context preserved. --- STATE.scm | 483 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 483 insertions(+) create mode 100644 STATE.scm diff --git a/STATE.scm b/STATE.scm new file mode 100644 index 0000000..fa47239 --- /dev/null +++ b/STATE.scm @@ -0,0 +1,483 @@ +;;; STATE.scm — Project Wharf Checkpoint +;;; SPDX-License-Identifier: MIT +;;; Author: Jonathan D. A. Jewell (@hyperpolymath) +;;; +;;; Checkpoint/restore system for AI conversation continuity. +;;; Load with: guile -c '(load "STATE.scm")' + +(define state + '( + + ;;; ========================================================================= + ;;; METADATA + ;;; ========================================================================= + (metadata + (format-version . "1.0") + (schema-version . "2025-12-08") + (created-at . "2025-12-08T00:00:00Z") + (last-updated . "2025-12-08T00:00:00Z") + (generator . "claude-opus-4-5")) + + ;;; ========================================================================= + ;;; USER CONTEXT + ;;; ========================================================================= + (user + (name . "hyperpolymath") + (roles . ("core-maintainer" "architect" "security-engineer")) + (preferences + (languages . ("rust" "nickel" "scheme" "bash")) + (tools . ("cargo" "just" "podman" "nebula" "guix")) + (values . ("security-first" "zero-trust" "reversibility" "offline-administration")))) + + ;;; ========================================================================= + ;;; SESSION CONTEXT + ;;; ========================================================================= + (session + (conversation-id . "wharf-mvp-planning-2025-12-08") + (started-at . "2025-12-08T00:00:00Z") + (checkpoint-reason . "initial-state-documentation")) + + ;;; ========================================================================= + ;;; CURRENT FOCUS + ;;; ========================================================================= + (focus + (current-project . "wharf-mvp-v1") + (current-phase . "integration-and-testing") + (deadline . #f) + (blocking-projects . ("ebpf-toolchain" "container-builds"))) + + ;;; ========================================================================= + ;;; CURRENT POSITION — Where We Are Now + ;;; ========================================================================= + (current-position + (version . "0.1.0-dev") + (maturity . "early-development") + (summary . "Foundation complete with core security architecture implemented. + Database proxy, file integrity, and CMS adapters exist but need + integration testing and production hardening.") + + (completed-components + ("wharf-core library with SQL AST parsing and BLAKE3 integrity") + ("wharf-cli with init/build/moor/state/sec subcommands") + ("yacht-agent runtime with database proxy and header airlock") + ("WordPress db.php drop-in adapter") + ("Nebula mesh networking configuration") + ("DNS zone templates (simple/shared/standard/maximalist)") + ("Nickel configuration schemas for policies") + ("eBPF XDP firewall loader with nftables fallback") + ("FIDO2/WebAuthn authentication framework") + ("Comprehensive documentation (README, SECURITY, ARCHITECTURE)")) + + (partial-components + ("Container Dockerfiles exist but not fully tested") + ("Database policy engine needs real-world validation") + ("Prometheus metrics are placeholder stubs") + ("Other CMS adapters (Drupal, Joomla, Moodle) are scaffolded only")) + + (missing-components + ("Integration test suite") + ("End-to-end deployment testing") + ("Production container images") + ("Monitoring dashboards") + ("Operational runbooks"))) + + ;;; ========================================================================= + ;;; ROUTE TO MVP v1.0 — The Path Forward + ;;; ========================================================================= + (mvp-route + (target-version . "1.0.0") + (definition . "Secure, production-ready WordPress hosting with offline + administration via Wharf and read-only Yacht runtime.") + + (milestones + ((name . "M1: Core Integration") + (status . "in-progress") + (completion . 70) + (tasks + ("Finalize database proxy with real MySQL/MariaDB testing") + ("Verify BLAKE3 integrity checks in production scenarios") + ("Complete rsync/SSH mooring workflow end-to-end") + ("Test FIDO2 hardware key authentication flow"))) + + ((name . "M2: Container Production") + (status . "pending") + (completion . 30) + (tasks + ("Build and test yacht-agent distroless container") + ("Build PHP/OpenLiteSpeed container with WordPress") + ("Validate podman pod deployment (yacht.yaml)") + ("Create container registry workflow"))) + + ((name . "M3: Security Hardening") + (status . "pending") + (completion . 40) + (tasks + ("Validate eBPF XDP firewall in production kernel") + ("Test nftables fallback path") + ("Security audit of database proxy SQL filtering") + ("Fuzz testing for SQL injection bypass attempts") + ("Header airlock validation against OWASP headers"))) + + ((name . "M4: WordPress Production") + (status . "pending") + (completion . 50) + (tasks + ("Test db.php drop-in with real WordPress installation") + ("Verify wp-admin blocking (Dark Matter pattern)") + ("Test plugin/theme read-only enforcement") + ("Validate file integrity monitoring with WordPress updates"))) + + ((name . "M5: Observability") + (status . "pending") + (completion . 10) + (tasks + ("Implement real Prometheus metrics (not stubs)") + ("Create Grafana dashboard for yacht monitoring") + ("Structured JSON logging throughout") + ("Health check endpoints for container orchestration"))) + + ((name . "M6: Documentation & Release") + (status . "pending") + (completion . 20) + (tasks + ("Operational deployment guide") + ("Troubleshooting runbook") + ("Quick-start tutorial") + ("Security model documentation") + ("Release packaging and versioning"))))) + + ;;; ========================================================================= + ;;; ISSUES & BLOCKERS + ;;; ========================================================================= + (issues + (critical + ((id . "ISSUE-001") + (title . "eBPF build requires special toolchain") + (description . "Building wharf-ebpf requires nightly Rust and bpf-linker. + This is fragile and may break with Rust updates.") + (impact . "Blocks M3: Security Hardening for eBPF path") + (workaround . "Use nftables fallback mode")) + + ((id . "ISSUE-002") + (title . "No integration test suite") + (description . "Unit tests exist but no end-to-end integration tests. + Cannot verify full mooring workflow works.") + (impact . "Risk of regressions, blocks confident v1.0 release"))) + + (high + ((id . "ISSUE-003") + (title . "Database proxy untested with real CMS load") + (description . "SQL AST parser works in isolation but hasn't been + stress-tested with real WordPress query patterns.") + (impact . "May have edge cases that break WordPress functionality")) + + ((id . "ISSUE-004") + (title . "Container images not automated") + (description . "Dockerfiles exist but no CI/CD pipeline builds and + pushes images automatically.") + (impact . "Manual build process, inconsistent images"))) + + (medium + ((id . "ISSUE-005") + (title . "Prometheus metrics are stubs") + (description . "Metrics endpoints return placeholder data, not real + instrumentation.") + (impact . "No production observability")) + + ((id . "ISSUE-006") + (title . "Only WordPress adapter is production-ready") + (description . "Drupal, Joomla, Moodle adapters are scaffolded but + not tested or validated.") + (impact . "Limits initial CMS support to WordPress only")) + + ((id . "ISSUE-007") + (title . "No automated backup/restore testing") + (description . "Reversibility framework exists but hasn't been + tested with real disaster recovery scenarios.") + (impact . "Cannot guarantee data recovery")))) + + ;;; ========================================================================= + ;;; QUESTIONS FOR USER + ;;; ========================================================================= + (questions + (architecture + ("Q1: Should MVP target Docker or Podman as primary container runtime?") + ("Q2: Is Kubernetes support required for v1.0 or can it wait for v1.2?") + ("Q3: What's the target Linux kernel version? (affects eBPF vs nftables default)")) + + (scope + ("Q4: Is WordPress-only acceptable for MVP, or must other CMSs work?") + ("Q5: Should multi-site (multiple WordPress per yacht) be in v1.0 or v1.2?") + ("Q6: What's the priority: self-hosted or managed platform first?")) + + (security + ("Q7: Is FIDO2 hardware key mandatory or should password auth be fallback?") + ("Q8: What compliance frameworks matter? (SOC2, GDPR, HIPAA)") + ("Q9: Should the Dark Matter pattern block wp-admin at nginx or eBPF level?")) + + (operations + ("Q10: What CI/CD platform? (GitLab CI exists, want GitHub Actions too?)") + ("Q11: Preferred container registry? (Docker Hub, GitHub, self-hosted)") + ("Q12: What monitoring stack? (Prometheus+Grafana assumed, alternatives?)")) + + (community + ("Q13: What's the timeline pressure? Is there a launch event or deadline?") + ("Q14: Are there beta testers lined up for early validation?") + ("Q15: Priority for contribution onboarding vs solo development?"))) + + ;;; ========================================================================= + ;;; PROJECT CATALOG + ;;; ========================================================================= + (projects + ;; Core Components + ((name . "wharf-core") + (status . "in-progress") + (completion . 75) + (category . "library") + (phase . "stabilization") + (dependencies . ()) + (blockers . ()) + (next . ("Add comprehensive unit tests" "Document public API"))) + + ((name . "wharf-cli") + (status . "in-progress") + (completion . 70) + (category . "binary") + (phase . "feature-complete") + (dependencies . ("wharf-core")) + (blockers . ()) + (next . ("Integration tests" "Error message improvements"))) + + ((name . "yacht-agent") + (status . "in-progress") + (completion . 65) + (category . "binary") + (phase . "integration") + (dependencies . ("wharf-core")) + (blockers . ("real-world database proxy testing")) + (next . ("MySQL stress testing" "Implement real metrics"))) + + ((name . "wharf-ebpf") + (status . "blocked") + (completion . 40) + (category . "kernel-module") + (phase . "development") + (dependencies . ()) + (blockers . ("requires nightly rust" "bpf-linker toolchain fragile")) + (next . ("Stabilize build process" "Test on production kernels"))) + + ;; Infrastructure + ((name . "container-images") + (status . "in-progress") + (completion . 30) + (category . "infrastructure") + (phase . "development") + (dependencies . ("yacht-agent")) + (blockers . ("no CI/CD automation")) + (next . ("Test distroless builds" "Create registry workflow"))) + + ((name . "nebula-mesh") + (status . "in-progress") + (completion . 60) + (category . "infrastructure") + (phase . "integration") + (dependencies . ()) + (blockers . ()) + (next . ("End-to-end connectivity testing" "Certificate rotation testing"))) + + ;; CMS Adapters + ((name . "wordpress-adapter") + (status . "in-progress") + (completion . 70) + (category . "adapter") + (phase . "testing") + (dependencies . ("yacht-agent")) + (blockers . ()) + (next . ("Production WordPress testing" "Plugin compatibility matrix"))) + + ((name . "drupal-adapter") + (status . "paused") + (completion . 15) + (category . "adapter") + (phase . "scaffolding") + (dependencies . ("wordpress-adapter")) + (blockers . ("wordpress-adapter must be stable first")) + (next . ("Defer until post-MVP"))) + + ;; Observability + ((name . "monitoring-stack") + (status . "pending") + (completion . 10) + (category . "observability") + (phase . "planning") + (dependencies . ("yacht-agent")) + (blockers . ()) + (next . ("Implement real Prometheus metrics" "Create Grafana dashboards"))) + + ;; Documentation + ((name . "operational-docs") + (status . "pending") + (completion . 20) + (category . "documentation") + (phase . "planning") + (dependencies . ("wharf-cli" "yacht-agent")) + (blockers . ("need stable workflows to document")) + (next . ("Deployment guide" "Troubleshooting runbook")))) + + ;;; ========================================================================= + ;;; LONG-TERM ROADMAP + ;;; ========================================================================= + (roadmap + ((version . "1.0") + (codename . "MVP") + (theme . "Secure WordPress Hosting") + (status . "in-progress") + (features + ("Offline Wharf controller with FIDO2") + ("Read-only Yacht runtime") + ("Database proxy with SQL AST filtering") + ("File integrity via BLAKE3") + ("Nebula mesh networking") + ("eBPF/nftables firewall") + ("WordPress production support") + ("Basic monitoring"))) + + ((version . "1.1") + (codename . "Observatory") + (theme . "Observability & Reliability") + (status . "planned") + (features + ("Grafana dashboard templates") + ("Alertmanager integration") + ("Structured JSON logging") + ("Log aggregation (Loki/ELK)") + ("SSL certificate monitoring") + ("Backup verification") + ("Disaster recovery testing"))) + + ((version . "1.2") + (codename . "Fleet") + (theme . "Multi-tenancy & Scale") + (status . "planned") + (features + ("Multiple WordPress sites per yacht") + ("Site isolation with namespaces") + ("Resource quotas (CPU, memory, I/O)") + ("Terraform provisioning modules") + ("Load balancer integration") + ("CDN integration (Cloudflare, Fastly)") + ("Rolling updates with zero downtime"))) + + ((version . "2.0") + (codename . "Graphene") + (theme . "Graph Intelligence") + (status . "future") + (features + ("ArangoDB as MySQL alternative") + ("Graph-based security analysis") + ("Attack pattern detection") + ("Anomaly detection ML") + ("WP-Arango plugin"))) + + ((version . "2.1") + (codename . "Crew") + (theme . "Team Collaboration") + (status . "future") + (features + ("Role-Based Access Control (RBAC)") + ("Multi-operator SSH key management") + ("SSO integration (OIDC, SAML)") + ("Change approval workflows") + ("Content staging/preview") + ("Team notifications (Slack, Discord)"))) + + ((version . "2.2") + (codename . "Intelligence") + (theme . "Content Intelligence") + (status . "future") + (features + ("AI-assisted content analysis") + ("SEO integration") + ("Broken link detection") + ("Image optimization") + ("Accessibility audits") + ("Security scanning (secrets, malware)"))) + + ((version . "3.0") + (codename . "Platform") + (theme . "Managed Service") + (status . "future") + (features + ("Web dashboard for fleet management") + ("Self-service site provisioning") + ("Customer portal") + ("Third-party API") + ("Billing and metering") + ("White-label support") + ("Compliance reporting (SOC2, GDPR, HIPAA)")))) + + ;;; ========================================================================= + ;;; CRITICAL NEXT ACTIONS + ;;; ========================================================================= + (critical-next + ("Set up integration test framework with real MySQL and WordPress") + ("Validate database proxy with WordPress query patterns under load") + ("Build and test yacht-agent distroless container image") + ("Create end-to-end mooring workflow test (wharf -> yacht)") + ("Implement real Prometheus metrics (replace stubs)") + ("Write deployment quick-start guide") + ("Answer architecture questions to finalize MVP scope")) + + ;;; ========================================================================= + ;;; VELOCITY & HISTORY + ;;; ========================================================================= + (history + (checkpoints + ((date . "2025-12-08") + (event . "Initial STATE.scm creation") + (overall-completion . 45) + (notes . "Foundation complete, integration phase beginning")))) + + )) ;; end state + +;;; ========================================================================= +;;; QUERY HELPERS +;;; ========================================================================= + +(define (get-section name) + "Retrieve a section from state by name." + (assoc name (cdr state))) + +(define (display-focus) + "Show current focus." + (let ((focus (get-section 'focus))) + (display "Current Focus:\n") + (display " Project: ") (display (cdr (assoc 'current-project (cdr focus)))) (newline) + (display " Phase: ") (display (cdr (assoc 'current-phase (cdr focus)))) (newline))) + +(define (display-critical-next) + "Show critical next actions." + (let ((actions (cdr (get-section 'critical-next)))) + (display "Critical Next Actions:\n") + (for-each (lambda (action) + (display " - ") + (display action) + (newline)) + actions))) + +(define (display-questions) + "Show questions requiring answers." + (let ((questions (cdr (get-section 'questions)))) + (display "Questions for User:\n") + (for-each (lambda (category) + (display "\n") + (display (car category)) + (display ":\n") + (for-each (lambda (q) + (display " ") + (display q) + (newline)) + (cdr category))) + questions))) + +;;; EOF