diff --git a/PROGRESS.md b/PROGRESS.md index 182f204e..3a258a93 100644 --- a/PROGRESS.md +++ b/PROGRESS.md @@ -23,7 +23,6 @@ This document tracks implementation progress against the documented standard pro | **Runtime Engine (`@objectql/core`)** | ✅ Production | 80% | | **Data Drivers** | ✅ Production | 75% | | **Server Runtime** | ✅ Production | 75% | -| **Presentation Layer** | ⚠️ Partial | 40% | | **Business Process Layer** | ⚠️ Partial | 35% | --- @@ -72,8 +71,6 @@ Drivers (SQL/Mongo/SDK) | **[hook.md](docs/spec/hook.md)** | `hook.ts` | ✅ **Complete** | 6 hook contexts: beforeCreate/afterCreate, beforeUpdate/afterUpdate, beforeDelete/afterDelete, beforeFind/afterFind | | **[action.md](docs/spec/action.md)** | `action.ts` | ✅ **Complete** | `ActionConfig`, `ActionDefinition`, Record/Global action types | | **[permission.md](docs/spec/permission.md)** | `permission.ts` | ✅ **Complete** | Object/Field/Record permissions, RBAC, Row-Level Security, Field Masking, Audit Config | -| **[page.md](docs/spec/page.md)** | `page.ts` | ✅ **Complete** | `PageConfig`, `PageComponent`, Layout types (dashboard, wizard, canvas), Component data sources | -| **[menu.md](docs/spec/menu.md)** | `menu.ts` | ✅ **Complete** | `MenuConfig`, `MenuItem`, Menu types (sidebar, top, context) | | **[query-language.md](docs/spec/query-language.md)** | `query.ts` | ✅ **Complete** | `UnifiedQuery`, `FilterExpression`, Aggregation, Joins, Sorting | | **[app.md](docs/spec/app.md)** | `application.ts` | ✅ **Basic** | `AppConfig` - basic structure implemented | | **[data.md](docs/spec/data.md)** | `field.ts`, `api.ts` | ✅ **Complete** | `AttachmentData`, `ImageAttachmentData`, API response types | @@ -83,9 +80,6 @@ Drivers (SQL/Mongo/SDK) | Spec Document | Expected File | Status | Priority | |--------------|---------------|--------|----------| | **[workflow.md](docs/spec/workflow.md)** | `workflow.ts` | ❌ **Missing** | 🔴 High | -| **[form.md](docs/spec/form.md)** | `form.ts` | ❌ **Missing** | 🟡 Medium | -| **[view.md](docs/spec/view.md)** | `view.ts` | ❌ **Missing** | 🟡 Medium | -| **[report.md](docs/spec/report.md)** | `report.ts` | ❌ **Missing** | 🟢 Low | ### Supporting Infrastructure (Present) @@ -133,7 +127,6 @@ Drivers (SQL/Mongo/SDK) - ✅ **Event System** - beforeCreate, afterUpdate hooks - ✅ **Permission Checking** - RBAC integration - ⚠️ **Workflow Engine** - Not yet implemented -- ⚠️ **Report Generator** - Not yet implemented --- @@ -270,104 +263,9 @@ Drivers (SQL/Mongo/SDK) - ❌ `objectql validate` - Metadata validation (not implemented) - ❌ `objectql introspect` - Database introspection (not implemented) -### 7.2 Studio (`@objectql/studio`) - -**Package:** `packages/tools/studio` -**Status:** ⚠️ **Early Stage** -**Implementation:** **20%** - -**Purpose:** Visual metadata editor (similar to Salesforce Setup) - -**Features:** -- ⚠️ Object designer (basic) -- ❌ Form builder (not implemented) -- ❌ Workflow designer (not implemented) -- ❌ Permission editor (not implemented) - --- -## 8. Presentation Layer (UI Metadata) - -**Status:** ⚠️ **Partially Implemented** -**Overall:** **40%** - -### Page Metadata (`page.md`) - -**Type Definition:** ✅ Complete (`packages/foundation/types/src/page.ts`) -**Runtime Support:** ⚠️ Partial - -**Implemented:** -- ✅ `PageConfig` interface -- ✅ Layout types: dashboard, wizard, canvas, two-column -- ✅ Component types: data_grid, form, chart, metric -- ✅ Data source bindings -- ✅ Component actions - -**Missing:** -- ❌ Page renderer (Object UI responsibility) -- ❌ Component library -- ❌ Layout engine - -### View Metadata (`view.md`) - -**Type Definition:** ❌ Missing (`packages/foundation/types/src/view.ts` not found) -**Runtime Support:** ❌ Not Implemented - -**Documented Types (in spec):** -- List views (tabular) -- Grid views (inline editing) -- Kanban boards -- Calendar views -- Timeline views -- Card layouts - -**Required Work:** -- ❌ Create `view.ts` type definitions -- ❌ View configuration parser -- ❌ View renderer integration - -### Form Metadata (`form.md`) - -**Type Definition:** ❌ Missing (`packages/foundation/types/src/form.ts` not found) -**Runtime Support:** ❌ Not Implemented - -**Documented Features (in spec):** -- Multi-column layouts -- Sections and tabs -- Wizard forms -- Conditional logic -- Field-level validation -- Quick create forms - -**Required Work:** -- ❌ Create `form.ts` type definitions -- ❌ Form layout engine -- ❌ Conditional logic processor -- ❌ Form renderer integration - -### Report Metadata (`report.md`) - -**Type Definition:** ❌ Missing (`packages/foundation/types/src/report.ts` not found) -**Runtime Support:** ❌ Not Implemented - -**Documented Types (in spec):** -- Tabular reports -- Summary reports (grouped) -- Matrix reports (pivot) -- Chart reports -- Dashboards -- Scheduled reports - -**Required Work:** -- ❌ Create `report.ts` type definitions -- ❌ Report query builder -- ❌ Aggregation engine -- ❌ Export engine (PDF, Excel, CSV) -- ❌ Scheduling system - ---- - -## 9. Business Process Layer +## 8. Business Process Layer **Status:** ⚠️ **Partially Implemented** **Overall:** **35%** @@ -398,7 +296,7 @@ Drivers (SQL/Mongo/SDK) --- -## 10. Documentation Status +## 9. Documentation Status ### Specification Documents (Complete) @@ -410,14 +308,8 @@ Drivers (SQL/Mongo/SDK) | `docs/spec/hook.md` | ✅ Excellent | All hook types covered | | `docs/spec/action.md` | ✅ Excellent | Record/Global actions | | `docs/spec/permission.md` | ✅ Excellent | RBAC, field, record-level | -| `docs/spec/page.md` | ✅ Excellent | Layouts, components, AI context | -| `docs/spec/menu.md` | ✅ Good | Navigation structure | | `docs/spec/query-language.md` | ✅ Excellent | JSON-DSL, filters, aggregations | | `docs/spec/workflow.md` | ✅ Excellent | Process automation, approvals | -| `docs/spec/form.md` | ✅ Excellent | Layout, conditional logic | -| `docs/spec/view.md` | ✅ Excellent | All view types documented | -| `docs/spec/report.md` | ✅ Excellent | Reports, dashboards, charts | -| `docs/spec/app.md` | ✅ Good | Application container | ### API Documentation @@ -444,7 +336,7 @@ Drivers (SQL/Mongo/SDK) --- -## 11. Testing Status +## 10. Testing Status ### Test Coverage @@ -460,7 +352,7 @@ Drivers (SQL/Mongo/SDK) --- -## 12. Roadmap & Priorities +## 11. Roadmap & Priorities ### Immediate Priorities (Q1 2026) @@ -470,33 +362,15 @@ Drivers (SQL/Mongo/SDK) - Basic automation triggers - **Estimated:** 4-6 weeks -2. **🟡 Form Type Definitions** (form.md → form.ts) - - TypeScript interfaces - - Layout engine types - - Conditional logic types - - **Estimated:** 1-2 weeks - -3. **🟡 View Type Definitions** (view.md → view.ts) - - All view types (list, kanban, calendar) - - Column configuration types - - Filter/sort metadata - - **Estimated:** 1-2 weeks - ### Medium-Term (Q2 2026) -4. **🟢 Report Engine** (report.md → report.ts) - - Report type definitions - - Aggregation engine - - Export system (PDF, Excel) - - **Estimated:** 3-4 weeks - -5. **🟡 GraphQL API** (documented but not implemented) +2. **🟡 GraphQL API** (documented but not implemented) - Schema generation from metadata - Query/Mutation resolvers - Subscription support - **Estimated:** 2-3 weeks -6. **🟡 CLI Enhancements** +3. **🟡 CLI Enhancements** - `objectql validate` command - `objectql introspect` command - Better error messages @@ -504,14 +378,7 @@ Drivers (SQL/Mongo/SDK) ### Long-Term (Q3-Q4 2026) -7. **🟢 Studio (Visual Editor)** - - Object designer - - Form builder - - Workflow designer - - Permission editor - - **Estimated:** 12+ weeks - -8. **🟢 Advanced Features** +4. **🟢 Advanced Features** - WebSocket real-time API - Rate limiting - Caching layer @@ -520,30 +387,27 @@ Drivers (SQL/Mongo/SDK) --- -## 13. Known Issues & Technical Debt +## 12. Known Issues & Technical Debt ### High Priority 1. **Missing Workflow Types** - Blocking enterprise adoption -2. **No View/Form Type Definitions** - UI metadata incomplete -3. **CLI Missing Validation** - No metadata validation command -4. **Limited Test Coverage for SDK** - Client reliability concerns +2. **CLI Missing Validation** - No metadata validation command +3. **Limited Test Coverage for SDK** - Client reliability concerns ### Medium Priority -5. **No GraphQL Implementation** - Despite having documentation -6. **Authentication is Placeholder** - JWT/token validation not complete -7. **No Rate Limiting** - Production scalability concern -8. **Studio is Incomplete** - Visual tools limited +4. **No GraphQL Implementation** - Despite having documentation +5. **Authentication is Placeholder** - JWT/token validation not complete +6. **No Rate Limiting** - Production scalability concern ### Low Priority -9. **Report Engine Missing** - Analytics limited -10. **No WebSocket Support** - Real-time features unavailable +7. **No WebSocket Support** - Real-time features unavailable --- -## 14. Compliance Matrix +## 13. Compliance Matrix ### Architecture Principles @@ -567,16 +431,11 @@ Drivers (SQL/Mongo/SDK) | `*.hook.ts` | ✅ 100% | Supported | | `*.action.ts` | ✅ 100% | Supported | | `*.app.yml` | ✅ 100% | Supported | -| `*.page.yml` | ✅ 100% | Type defined, renderer pending | -| `*.menu.yml` | ✅ 100% | Supported | | `*.workflow.yml` | ❌ 0% | **Not implemented** | -| `*.form.yml` | ❌ 0% | **Not implemented** | -| `*.view.yml` | ❌ 0% | **Not implemented** | -| `*.report.yml` | ❌ 0% | **Not implemented** | --- -## 15. Conclusion +## 14. Conclusion ObjectQL has achieved **70% implementation** of the documented standard protocol. The **foundation is solid** with: @@ -589,12 +448,10 @@ ObjectQL has achieved **70% implementation** of the documented standard protocol ⚠️ **Gaps:** - Workflow engine (critical for enterprise) -- Form/View/Report type definitions (UI layer incomplete) - GraphQL/WebSocket APIs (documented but not implemented) -- Visual tooling (Studio at 20%) 🎯 **Recommendation:** -Focus on **Workflow Engine** (workflow.ts) as the highest priority, followed by **Form** and **View** type definitions to complete the UI metadata layer. +Focus on **Workflow Engine** (workflow.ts) as the highest priority to complete the business process layer. --- diff --git a/README.md b/README.md index be10aa4f..91f98f82 100644 --- a/README.md +++ b/README.md @@ -192,7 +192,6 @@ For a complete status report on ObjectQL's implementation against the documented **Current Status:** 70% Complete (v1.8.4) - ✅ Core Protocol & Runtime: 85% - ✅ Data Drivers (SQL/Mongo): 75% -- ⚠️ UI Metadata Layer: 40% - ⚠️ Workflow Engine: 35% ---