Skip to content
Merged
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
177 changes: 17 additions & 160 deletions PROGRESS.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -23,7 +23,6 @@ This document tracks implementation progress against the documented standard pro
| **Runtime Engine (`@objectql/core`)** | ✅ Production | 80% |
| **Data Drivers** | ✅ Production | 75% |
| **Server Runtime** | ✅ Production | 75% |
| **Presentation Layer** | ⚠️ Partial | 40% |
| **Business Process Layer** | ⚠️ Partial | 35% |

---
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -72,8 +71,6 @@ Drivers (SQL/Mongo/SDK)
| **[hook.md](docs/spec/hook.md)** | `hook.ts` | ✅ **Complete** | 6 hook contexts: beforeCreate/afterCreate, beforeUpdate/afterUpdate, beforeDelete/afterDelete, beforeFind/afterFind |
| **[action.md](docs/spec/action.md)** | `action.ts` | ✅ **Complete** | `ActionConfig`, `ActionDefinition`, Record/Global action types |
| **[permission.md](docs/spec/permission.md)** | `permission.ts` | ✅ **Complete** | Object/Field/Record permissions, RBAC, Row-Level Security, Field Masking, Audit Config |
| **[page.md](docs/spec/page.md)** | `page.ts` | ✅ **Complete** | `PageConfig`, `PageComponent`, Layout types (dashboard, wizard, canvas), Component data sources |
| **[menu.md](docs/spec/menu.md)** | `menu.ts` | ✅ **Complete** | `MenuConfig`, `MenuItem`, Menu types (sidebar, top, context) |
| **[query-language.md](docs/spec/query-language.md)** | `query.ts` | ✅ **Complete** | `UnifiedQuery`, `FilterExpression`, Aggregation, Joins, Sorting |
| **[app.md](docs/spec/app.md)** | `application.ts` | ✅ **Basic** | `AppConfig` - basic structure implemented |
| **[data.md](docs/spec/data.md)** | `field.ts`, `api.ts` | ✅ **Complete** | `AttachmentData`, `ImageAttachmentData`, API response types |
Expand All @@ -83,9 +80,6 @@ Drivers (SQL/Mongo/SDK)
| Spec Document | Expected File | Status | Priority |
|--------------|---------------|--------|----------|
| **[workflow.md](docs/spec/workflow.md)** | `workflow.ts` | ❌ **Missing** | 🔴 High |
| **[form.md](docs/spec/form.md)** | `form.ts` | ❌ **Missing** | 🟡 Medium |
| **[view.md](docs/spec/view.md)** | `view.ts` | ❌ **Missing** | 🟡 Medium |
| **[report.md](docs/spec/report.md)** | `report.ts` | ❌ **Missing** | 🟢 Low |

### Supporting Infrastructure (Present)

Expand Down Expand Up @@ -133,7 +127,6 @@ Drivers (SQL/Mongo/SDK)
- ✅ **Event System** - beforeCreate, afterUpdate hooks
- ✅ **Permission Checking** - RBAC integration
- ⚠️ **Workflow Engine** - Not yet implemented
- ⚠️ **Report Generator** - Not yet implemented

---

Expand Down Expand Up @@ -270,104 +263,9 @@ Drivers (SQL/Mongo/SDK)
- ❌ `objectql validate` - Metadata validation (not implemented)
- ❌ `objectql introspect` - Database introspection (not implemented)

### 7.2 Studio (`@objectql/studio`)

**Package:** `packages/tools/studio`
**Status:** ⚠️ **Early Stage**
**Implementation:** **20%**

**Purpose:** Visual metadata editor (similar to Salesforce Setup)

**Features:**
- ⚠️ Object designer (basic)
- ❌ Form builder (not implemented)
- ❌ Workflow designer (not implemented)
- ❌ Permission editor (not implemented)

---

## 8. Presentation Layer (UI Metadata)

**Status:** ⚠️ **Partially Implemented**
**Overall:** **40%**

### Page Metadata (`page.md`)

**Type Definition:** ✅ Complete (`packages/foundation/types/src/page.ts`)
**Runtime Support:** ⚠️ Partial

**Implemented:**
- ✅ `PageConfig` interface
- ✅ Layout types: dashboard, wizard, canvas, two-column
- ✅ Component types: data_grid, form, chart, metric
- ✅ Data source bindings
- ✅ Component actions

**Missing:**
- ❌ Page renderer (Object UI responsibility)
- ❌ Component library
- ❌ Layout engine

### View Metadata (`view.md`)

**Type Definition:** ❌ Missing (`packages/foundation/types/src/view.ts` not found)
**Runtime Support:** ❌ Not Implemented

**Documented Types (in spec):**
- List views (tabular)
- Grid views (inline editing)
- Kanban boards
- Calendar views
- Timeline views
- Card layouts

**Required Work:**
- ❌ Create `view.ts` type definitions
- ❌ View configuration parser
- ❌ View renderer integration

### Form Metadata (`form.md`)

**Type Definition:** ❌ Missing (`packages/foundation/types/src/form.ts` not found)
**Runtime Support:** ❌ Not Implemented

**Documented Features (in spec):**
- Multi-column layouts
- Sections and tabs
- Wizard forms
- Conditional logic
- Field-level validation
- Quick create forms

**Required Work:**
- ❌ Create `form.ts` type definitions
- ❌ Form layout engine
- ❌ Conditional logic processor
- ❌ Form renderer integration

### Report Metadata (`report.md`)

**Type Definition:** ❌ Missing (`packages/foundation/types/src/report.ts` not found)
**Runtime Support:** ❌ Not Implemented

**Documented Types (in spec):**
- Tabular reports
- Summary reports (grouped)
- Matrix reports (pivot)
- Chart reports
- Dashboards
- Scheduled reports

**Required Work:**
- ❌ Create `report.ts` type definitions
- ❌ Report query builder
- ❌ Aggregation engine
- ❌ Export engine (PDF, Excel, CSV)
- ❌ Scheduling system

---

## 9. Business Process Layer
## 8. Business Process Layer

**Status:** ⚠️ **Partially Implemented**
**Overall:** **35%**
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -398,7 +296,7 @@ Drivers (SQL/Mongo/SDK)

---

## 10. Documentation Status
## 9. Documentation Status

### Specification Documents (Complete)

Expand All @@ -410,14 +308,8 @@ Drivers (SQL/Mongo/SDK)
| `docs/spec/hook.md` | ✅ Excellent | All hook types covered |
| `docs/spec/action.md` | ✅ Excellent | Record/Global actions |
| `docs/spec/permission.md` | ✅ Excellent | RBAC, field, record-level |
| `docs/spec/page.md` | ✅ Excellent | Layouts, components, AI context |
| `docs/spec/menu.md` | ✅ Good | Navigation structure |
| `docs/spec/query-language.md` | ✅ Excellent | JSON-DSL, filters, aggregations |
| `docs/spec/workflow.md` | ✅ Excellent | Process automation, approvals |
| `docs/spec/form.md` | ✅ Excellent | Layout, conditional logic |
| `docs/spec/view.md` | ✅ Excellent | All view types documented |
| `docs/spec/report.md` | ✅ Excellent | Reports, dashboards, charts |
| `docs/spec/app.md` | ✅ Good | Application container |

### API Documentation

Expand All @@ -444,7 +336,7 @@ Drivers (SQL/Mongo/SDK)

---

## 11. Testing Status
## 10. Testing Status

### Test Coverage

Expand All @@ -460,7 +352,7 @@ Drivers (SQL/Mongo/SDK)

---

## 12. Roadmap & Priorities
## 11. Roadmap & Priorities

### Immediate Priorities (Q1 2026)

Expand All @@ -470,48 +362,23 @@ Drivers (SQL/Mongo/SDK)
- Basic automation triggers
- **Estimated:** 4-6 weeks

2. **🟡 Form Type Definitions** (form.md → form.ts)
- TypeScript interfaces
- Layout engine types
- Conditional logic types
- **Estimated:** 1-2 weeks

3. **🟡 View Type Definitions** (view.md → view.ts)
- All view types (list, kanban, calendar)
- Column configuration types
- Filter/sort metadata
- **Estimated:** 1-2 weeks

### Medium-Term (Q2 2026)

4. **🟢 Report Engine** (report.md → report.ts)
- Report type definitions
- Aggregation engine
- Export system (PDF, Excel)
- **Estimated:** 3-4 weeks

5. **🟡 GraphQL API** (documented but not implemented)
2. **🟡 GraphQL API** (documented but not implemented)
- Schema generation from metadata
- Query/Mutation resolvers
- Subscription support
- **Estimated:** 2-3 weeks

6. **🟡 CLI Enhancements**
3. **🟡 CLI Enhancements**
- `objectql validate` command
- `objectql introspect` command
- Better error messages
- **Estimated:** 2 weeks

### Long-Term (Q3-Q4 2026)

7. **🟢 Studio (Visual Editor)**
- Object designer
- Form builder
- Workflow designer
- Permission editor
- **Estimated:** 12+ weeks

8. **🟢 Advanced Features**
4. **🟢 Advanced Features**
- WebSocket real-time API
- Rate limiting
- Caching layer
Expand All @@ -520,30 +387,27 @@ Drivers (SQL/Mongo/SDK)

---

## 13. Known Issues & Technical Debt
## 12. Known Issues & Technical Debt

### High Priority

1. **Missing Workflow Types** - Blocking enterprise adoption
2. **No View/Form Type Definitions** - UI metadata incomplete
3. **CLI Missing Validation** - No metadata validation command
4. **Limited Test Coverage for SDK** - Client reliability concerns
2. **CLI Missing Validation** - No metadata validation command
3. **Limited Test Coverage for SDK** - Client reliability concerns

### Medium Priority

5. **No GraphQL Implementation** - Despite having documentation
6. **Authentication is Placeholder** - JWT/token validation not complete
7. **No Rate Limiting** - Production scalability concern
8. **Studio is Incomplete** - Visual tools limited
4. **No GraphQL Implementation** - Despite having documentation
5. **Authentication is Placeholder** - JWT/token validation not complete
6. **No Rate Limiting** - Production scalability concern

### Low Priority

9. **Report Engine Missing** - Analytics limited
10. **No WebSocket Support** - Real-time features unavailable
7. **No WebSocket Support** - Real-time features unavailable

---

## 14. Compliance Matrix
## 13. Compliance Matrix

### Architecture Principles

Expand All @@ -567,16 +431,11 @@ Drivers (SQL/Mongo/SDK)
| `*.hook.ts` | ✅ 100% | Supported |
| `*.action.ts` | ✅ 100% | Supported |
| `*.app.yml` | ✅ 100% | Supported |
| `*.page.yml` | ✅ 100% | Type defined, renderer pending |
| `*.menu.yml` | ✅ 100% | Supported |
| `*.workflow.yml` | ❌ 0% | **Not implemented** |
| `*.form.yml` | ❌ 0% | **Not implemented** |
| `*.view.yml` | ❌ 0% | **Not implemented** |
| `*.report.yml` | ❌ 0% | **Not implemented** |

---

## 15. Conclusion
## 14. Conclusion

ObjectQL has achieved **70% implementation** of the documented standard protocol. The **foundation is solid** with:

Expand All @@ -589,12 +448,10 @@ ObjectQL has achieved **70% implementation** of the documented standard protocol

⚠️ **Gaps:**
- Workflow engine (critical for enterprise)
- Form/View/Report type definitions (UI layer incomplete)
- GraphQL/WebSocket APIs (documented but not implemented)
- Visual tooling (Studio at 20%)

🎯 **Recommendation:**
Focus on **Workflow Engine** (workflow.ts) as the highest priority, followed by **Form** and **View** type definitions to complete the UI metadata layer.
Focus on **Workflow Engine** (workflow.ts) as the highest priority to complete the business process layer.

---

Expand Down
1 change: 0 additions & 1 deletion README.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -192,7 +192,6 @@ For a complete status report on ObjectQL's implementation against the documented
**Current Status:** 70% Complete (v1.8.4)
- ✅ Core Protocol & Runtime: 85%
- ✅ Data Drivers (SQL/Mongo): 75%
- ⚠️ UI Metadata Layer: 40%
- ⚠️ Workflow Engine: 35%

---
Expand Down
Loading