Merge pull request #300 from objectstack-ai/copilot/scan-packages-and-develop-plan

Author: hotlong

ALIGNMENT_SUMMARY.txt

@@ -0,0 +1,208 @@
+# Package Scan Summary
+
+## Overview
+This document summarizes the comprehensive scan of all ObjectUI packages against the latest ObjectStack specification v0.7.1.
+
+## Scan Results
+
+### Total Packages: 26
+
+#### Core Packages (4)
+1. **@object-ui/types** - Protocol definitions
+2. **@object-ui/core** - Core logic and validation
+3. **@object-ui/react** - React bindings
+4. **@object-ui/data-objectstack** - Data adapter
+
+#### UI Packages (3)
+5. **@object-ui/components** - Base components (Shadcn/Radix)
+6. **@object-ui/fields** - Field renderers
+7. **@object-ui/layout** - Layout components
+
+#### Plugin Packages (14)
+8. **@object-ui/plugin-aggrid** - AG Grid integration
+9. **@object-ui/plugin-calendar** - Calendar view
+10. **@object-ui/plugin-charts** - Chart components
+11. **@object-ui/plugin-chatbot** - Chatbot interface
+12. **@object-ui/plugin-dashboard** - Dashboard layouts
+13. **@object-ui/plugin-editor** - Rich text editor
+14. **@object-ui/plugin-form** - Advanced forms
+15. **@object-ui/plugin-gantt** - Gantt charts
+16. **@object-ui/plugin-grid** - Data grid
+17. **@object-ui/plugin-kanban** - Kanban boards
+18. **@object-ui/plugin-map** - Map visualization
+19. **@object-ui/plugin-markdown** - Markdown rendering
+20. **@object-ui/plugin-timeline** - Timeline components
+21. **@object-ui/plugin-view** - ObjectQL views
+
+#### Tool Packages (5)
+22. **@object-ui/cli** - CLI tool
+23. **@object-ui/create-plugin** - Plugin scaffolder
+24. **@object-ui/runner** - Application runner
+25. **@object-ui/vscode-extension** - VS Code extension
+
+### ObjectStack Dependencies
+
+Only **4 core packages** directly depend on ObjectStack:
+
+| Package | Spec Version | Client Version | Purpose |
+|---------|-------------|----------------|---------|
+| @object-ui/types | ^0.7.1 | - | Type definitions |
+| @object-ui/core | ^0.7.1 | - | Core logic |
+| @object-ui/react | ^0.7.1 | - | React bindings |
+| @object-ui/data-objectstack | - | ^0.7.1 | Data adapter |
+
+**All packages are using the latest ObjectStack versions ✅**
+
+## Alignment Analysis
+
+### Current Status: ~80% Aligned
+
+#### ✅ Fully Aligned (Perfect Match)
+- Field type definitions (37 types)
+- Basic query operations (SELECT, WHERE, JOIN, ORDER BY)
+- Filter operators (superset of spec)
+- View architecture (grid, kanban, calendar, etc.)
+- Plugin system
+- Data adapter implementation
+
+#### ⚠️ Partial Alignment
+- Aggregation functions (missing 3: count_distinct, array_agg, string_agg)
+- View types (missing: spreadsheet, gallery, timeline)
+- App schema (missing: homePageId, requiredPermissions)
+- Join strategies (missing execution hints)
+
+#### ❌ Major Gaps
+1. **Window Functions** - Not implemented (CRITICAL)
+   - Impact: Cannot build analytical queries
+   - Missing: row_number, rank, lag, lead, etc.
+
+2. **Validation Framework** - Only 20% of spec (CRITICAL)
+   - Impact: Limited data validation capabilities
+   - Missing: 9 validation types vs 2 basic types
+
+3. **Action Schema** - Only 30% of spec (HIGH)
+   - Impact: Limited action button capabilities
+   - Missing: locations, params, confirmText, refreshAfter
+
+## Detailed Findings
+
+### 1. Data Protocol
+
+#### Query Schema
+- ✅ SELECT, WHERE, JOIN, GROUP BY, ORDER BY
+- ✅ Pagination (limit, offset)
+- ⚠️ Aggregations (missing: count_distinct, array_agg, string_agg)
+- ❌ Window functions (completely missing)
+- ⚠️ Join strategies (no execution hints)
+
+#### Filter Schema
+- ✅ All base operators ($eq, $ne, $gt, $lt, $in, etc.)
+- ✅ Extended operators (date-specific, search, lookup)
+- ✅ Logical operators ($and, $or, $not)
+
+#### Validation Schema
+- ✅ Basic rules (required, pattern, min/max)
+- ❌ Script validation (formula-based)
+- ❌ Uniqueness validation (multi-field, scoped)
+- ❌ State machine validation
+- ❌ Cross-field validation
+- ❌ Async validation (remote endpoints)
+- ❌ Conditional validation
+- ❌ Format validation (predefined patterns)
+- ❌ JSON schema validation
+
+### 2. UI Protocol
+
+#### View Schema
+- ✅ Grid, Kanban, Calendar, Gantt, Map
+- ✅ Form (ObjectUI extension)
+- ✅ Chart
+- ❌ Spreadsheet (missing)
+- ❌ Gallery (missing)
+- ❌ Timeline (missing)
+
+#### App Schema
+- ✅ Basic properties (name, label, icon, branding)
+- ✅ Navigation structure
+- ⚠️ Missing: homePageId, requiredPermissions
+
+#### Action Schema
+- ✅ Basic button actions
+- ❌ Location-based placement
+- ❌ Parameter collection
+- ❌ Confirmation dialogs
+- ❌ Success/error messaging
+- ❌ Auto-refresh behavior
+- ❌ Conditional visibility
+
+### 3. System Protocol
+
+#### Plugin System
+- ✅ Plugin manifest
+- ✅ Lifecycle hooks
+- ✅ Dependency management
+- ✅ Version management
+
+#### Auth & Permissions
+- ✅ Field-level permissions
+- ✅ Object-level permissions
+- ⚠️ App-level permissions (partial)
+- ⚠️ Role-based access (partial)
+
+## Development Roadmap
+
+### Priority 0 (Critical) - Weeks 1-2
+- [ ] Implement window functions
+- [ ] Implement validation framework (9 types)
+- [ ] Enhance action schema
+
+### Priority 1 (High) - Weeks 3-4
+- [ ] Add enhanced aggregations
+- [ ] Add async validation support
+- [ ] Add app-level permissions
+
+### Priority 2 (Medium) - Weeks 5-6
+- [ ] Create missing view plugins (spreadsheet, gallery, timeline)
+- [ ] Add join execution strategies
+- [ ] Enhance full-text search
+
+## Documentation Created
+
+1. **OBJECTSTACK_SPEC_ALIGNMENT.md** (English, 850 lines)
+   - Comprehensive analysis
+   - Detailed gap analysis
+   - Implementation guide
+   - Code examples
+   - Migration guide
+
+2. **OBJECTSTACK_SPEC_ALIGNMENT.zh-CN.md** (Chinese, 400 lines)
+   - Executive summary
+   - Key findings
+   - Development plan
+   - Code examples
+
+3. **PACKAGE_SCAN_SUMMARY.md** (This file)
+   - Quick reference
+   - Package inventory
+   - Dependency map
+
+## Next Steps
+
+1. Review and approve the alignment document
+2. Prioritize implementation tasks
+3. Begin Phase 1 implementation (window functions)
+4. Update tests for new features
+5. Create migration guides for users
+
+## References
+
+- Full Analysis: [OBJECTSTACK_SPEC_ALIGNMENT.md](./OBJECTSTACK_SPEC_ALIGNMENT.md)
+- 中文版本: [OBJECTSTACK_SPEC_ALIGNMENT.zh-CN.md](./OBJECTSTACK_SPEC_ALIGNMENT.zh-CN.md)
+- ObjectStack Spec: https://www.npmjs.com/package/@objectstack/spec
+- ObjectStack Client: https://www.npmjs.com/package/@objectstack/client
+
+---
+
+**Scan Date:** 2026-01-31  
+**Spec Version:** v0.7.1  
+**Status:** Complete ✅