|
50 | 50 | {"actor":"sjarmak","comment":null,"created_at":"2026-03-09T20:23:24Z","event_type":"closed","id":50,"issue_id":"CodeScaleBench-rm3","new_value":"All harnesses pass readiness checks. SG token confirmed from .env.local. Gemini excluded from immediate gate.","old_value":""} |
51 | 51 | {"actor":"sjarmak","comment":null,"created_at":"2026-03-09T20:31:37Z","event_type":"closed","id":51,"issue_id":"CodeScaleBench-aa9","new_value":"All 264 active tasks now emit validation_result.json (v1alpha1). 50 tasks migrated across 6 families: ir_checklist(17), checklist(16), f1_hybrid(7), continuous(5), test_ratio(3), f1(2). Commit be8bff87f.","old_value":""} |
52 | 52 | {"actor":"sjarmak","comment":null,"created_at":"2026-03-09T20:48:20Z","event_type":"updated","id":52,"issue_id":"CodeScaleBench-2kz","new_value":"{\"notes\":\"2026-03-09 triage of zero-reward sentinels:\\n\\n1. element-web-unread-indicators-diverge-fix-001 (Claude MCP, reward=0.0):\\n ROOT CAUSE: Task setup bug in sg_only mode. The sgonly_verifier_wrapper restores /repo_full/ but does NOT re-run before_repo_set_cmd (git checkout of specific test files from a different commit). The test patch for threads.ts:137 expects `thread.addEvents(events, true)` but the restored tree has different context. Test patch fails → 0 tests run → reward=0.0. The agent actually implemented the fix correctly. NOT a harness bug — task-specific sg_only incompatibility for SWE-bench Pro tasks that rely on before_repo_set_cmd + test_patch.\\n FIX: Either (a) make sgonly_verifier_wrapper run before_repo_set_cmd after restore, or (b) mark this task as sg_only-incompatible and only run in baseline mode.\\n\\n2. ccx-onboard-search-212 (OpenHands, reward=0.0):\\n ROOT CAUSE TWO-PHASE:\\n - Phase 1 (trials 1-5): Dockerfile cloned pandas repo into /workspace/, shadowing pip-installed pandas → ModuleNotFoundError. ALREADY FIXED in commit c0c381ba0 (moved WORKDIR to /app).\\n - Phase 2 (trials 6-10, post-fix): Agent setup works, agent runs, but produces incorrect answer. This is a LEGITIMATE AGENT FAILURE — the harness works correctly, OpenHands just doesn't solve this semantic retrieval task.\\n VERDICT: Harness is clean. No action needed.\\n\\nOverall sentinel assessment: 7/8 Claude tasks valid (1 is sg_only task bug), OpenHands harness works (agent just fails the task). No general harness regressions.\"}","old_value":"{\"id\":\"CodeScaleBench-2kz\",\"title\":\"Verify harness fixes by rerunning historical Claude/OpenHands failures\",\"description\":\"Run a focused verification batch to prove the current task-contract and harness hardening eliminates the earlier random patch churn.\\n\\nScope:\\n- Claude Code regression sentinels:\\n - mcp_ccx-onboard-search-207\\n - mcp_ccx-onboard-search-208\\n - mcp_ccx-onboard-search-210\\n - mcp_bustub-hyperloglog-impl-001\\n - mcp_django-sensitive-file-exclusion-001\\n - mcp_flink-window-late-data-fix-001\\n - mcp_element-web-unread-indicators-diverge-fix-001\\n - clickhouse-mergetree-arch-understand-001 (confirm Daytona/local routing now that storage metadata was corrected)\\n- OpenHands regression sentinel:\\n - ccx-onboard-search-212\\n\\nAcceptance criteria:\\n- Produce a small rerun manifest or manifests for the tasks above.\\n- Execute the reruns once accounts are ready.\\n- Confirm whether each task now completes as a valid run without ad hoc task-specific patches.\\n- Record any remaining failures as either harness bugs, task bugs, or infra issues with exact root cause.\\n- If clean, note which tasks should remain in the smoke/verification matrix as permanent regression sentinels.\\n\",\"notes\":\"2026-03-09 validation pass:\\\\n- Fixed stale task generators/templates so fresh org + SDLC scaffolded tasks now render and smoke clean without one-off harness patches.\\\\n- Temp scaffold validation: org template path renders, contract-check passes, and baseline/sg_only smoke runs produce reward artifacts as expected; feature/refactor scaffold outputs pass contract-only plus baseline/sg_only no-agent smoke.\\\\n- Curated local smoke subsets all passed via exact-selection flow: baseline (ccx-onboard-search-207, element-web-unread-indicators-diverge-fix-001, clickhouse-mergetree-arch-understand-001), sg_only (same trio), artifact_only (ccx-onboard-search-207, bustub-hyperloglog-impl-001, nodebb-plugin-validate-fix-001).\\\\n- Prepared rerun manifests: configs/claude_historical_failure_rerun_mcp_20260309.json and configs/openhands_historical_failure_rerun_baseline_20260309.json.\\\\n- Infra readiness checked: account_health.py status recommends proceed; check_infra.py now passes in current workspace.\\\\nRemaining: launch rerun manifests only after interactive confirmation, then classify any residual failures and decide permanent sentinel coverage.\\n2026-03-09 launch started after explicit confirmation.\\\\n- Claude MCP rerun batch launched via configs/run_selected_tasks.sh in Daytona mode using accounts account1/account2/account4 (account3 held, account5 reserved for OpenHands). Run dirs are rooted at runs/staging/csb_org_onboarding_sonnet_20260309_142738, runs/staging/csb_sdlc_feature_sonnet_20260309_142738, runs/staging/csb_sdlc_fix_sonnet_20260309_142738, runs/staging/csb_sdlc_secure_sonnet_20260309_142738, runs/staging/csb_sdlc_understand_sonnet_20260309_142738 under config mcp-remote-direct. Initial live tasks confirmed on disk for ccx-onboard-search-207/208/210.\\\\n- OpenHands baseline sentinel launched via configs/openhands_2config.sh in Daytona mode using account5 only. Run dir: runs/staging/openhands_sonnet46_20260309_142733/baseline-local-direct/.../ccx-onboard-search-212__CDJ962t.\\\\n- Remaining Claude tasks will submit as the 3-slot queue drains.\\\\nNext: monitor task completion/invalids, classify any residual failures, and decide which sentinels stay in permanent smoke coverage.\\n2026-03-09 planning clarification:\\n- SOURCEGRAPH_ACCESS_TOKEN is expected to come from .env.local for operator shells or launcher wrappers; a raw check_harness_readiness.py failure without sourcing .env.local should not be treated as a task-contract regression by itself.\\n- Gemini harness validation is out of scope for the immediate rerun batch; readiness for this bead should be judged against the harnesses actually being used for the reruns.\\n- Keep rerun execution/classification here; track any separate harness-readiness or CI-gating adjustments in a dedicated Beads task.\",\"status\":\"in_progress\",\"priority\":1,\"issue_type\":\"task\",\"owner\":\"sjarmak@users.noreply.github.com\",\"created_at\":\"2026-03-09T13:11:58Z\",\"created_by\":\"sjarmak\",\"updated_at\":\"2026-03-09T20:19:06Z\"}"} |
| 53 | +{"actor":"sjarmak","comment":null,"created_at":"2026-03-09T21:03:16Z","event_type":"updated","id":53,"issue_id":"CodeScaleBench-2kz","new_value":"{\"notes\":\"2026-03-09 OpenHands verification subset launched:\\n- 9 tasks x 2 configs (baseline + MCP) = 18 runs via Daytona\\n- Covers ALL 9 verifier families: checklist, continuous, diff_similarity, f1, ir_checklist, oracle_checks, repo_state_heuristic, semantic_similarity, test_ratio\\n- Also includes sgonly_verifier_wrapper.sh fix for SWE-bench Pro before_repo_set_cmd\\n- Run dir: runs/staging/openhands_sonnet46_20260309_205917\\n- Accounts: 1,2,4,5 (account3 held)\\n- Monitoring for completion and reward extraction\"}","old_value":"{\"id\":\"CodeScaleBench-2kz\",\"title\":\"Verify harness fixes by rerunning historical Claude/OpenHands failures\",\"description\":\"Run a focused verification batch to prove the current task-contract and harness hardening eliminates the earlier random patch churn.\\n\\nScope:\\n- Claude Code regression sentinels:\\n - mcp_ccx-onboard-search-207\\n - mcp_ccx-onboard-search-208\\n - mcp_ccx-onboard-search-210\\n - mcp_bustub-hyperloglog-impl-001\\n - mcp_django-sensitive-file-exclusion-001\\n - mcp_flink-window-late-data-fix-001\\n - mcp_element-web-unread-indicators-diverge-fix-001\\n - clickhouse-mergetree-arch-understand-001 (confirm Daytona/local routing now that storage metadata was corrected)\\n- OpenHands regression sentinel:\\n - ccx-onboard-search-212\\n\\nAcceptance criteria:\\n- Produce a small rerun manifest or manifests for the tasks above.\\n- Execute the reruns once accounts are ready.\\n- Confirm whether each task now completes as a valid run without ad hoc task-specific patches.\\n- Record any remaining failures as either harness bugs, task bugs, or infra issues with exact root cause.\\n- If clean, note which tasks should remain in the smoke/verification matrix as permanent regression sentinels.\\n\",\"notes\":\"2026-03-09 triage of zero-reward sentinels:\\n\\n1. element-web-unread-indicators-diverge-fix-001 (Claude MCP, reward=0.0):\\n ROOT CAUSE: Task setup bug in sg_only mode. The sgonly_verifier_wrapper restores /repo_full/ but does NOT re-run before_repo_set_cmd (git checkout of specific test files from a different commit). The test patch for threads.ts:137 expects `thread.addEvents(events, true)` but the restored tree has different context. Test patch fails → 0 tests run → reward=0.0. The agent actually implemented the fix correctly. NOT a harness bug — task-specific sg_only incompatibility for SWE-bench Pro tasks that rely on before_repo_set_cmd + test_patch.\\n FIX: Either (a) make sgonly_verifier_wrapper run before_repo_set_cmd after restore, or (b) mark this task as sg_only-incompatible and only run in baseline mode.\\n\\n2. ccx-onboard-search-212 (OpenHands, reward=0.0):\\n ROOT CAUSE TWO-PHASE:\\n - Phase 1 (trials 1-5): Dockerfile cloned pandas repo into /workspace/, shadowing pip-installed pandas → ModuleNotFoundError. ALREADY FIXED in commit c0c381ba0 (moved WORKDIR to /app).\\n - Phase 2 (trials 6-10, post-fix): Agent setup works, agent runs, but produces incorrect answer. This is a LEGITIMATE AGENT FAILURE — the harness works correctly, OpenHands just doesn't solve this semantic retrieval task.\\n VERDICT: Harness is clean. No action needed.\\n\\nOverall sentinel assessment: 7/8 Claude tasks valid (1 is sg_only task bug), OpenHands harness works (agent just fails the task). No general harness regressions.\",\"status\":\"in_progress\",\"priority\":1,\"issue_type\":\"task\",\"owner\":\"sjarmak@users.noreply.github.com\",\"created_at\":\"2026-03-09T13:11:58Z\",\"created_by\":\"sjarmak\",\"updated_at\":\"2026-03-09T20:48:21Z\"}"} |
| 54 | +{"actor":"sjarmak","comment":null,"created_at":"2026-03-09T21:20:01Z","event_type":"updated","id":54,"issue_id":"CodeScaleBench-2kz","new_value":"{\"notes\":\"2026-03-09 OpenHands verification results — SYSTEMATIC FAILURE:\\n\\nAll 17/18 completed tasks show the same error pattern:\\n- OpenHands LocalRuntime fails to start: tenacity.RetryError during _wait_until_alive\\n- Error location: openhands/runtime/impl/local/local_runtime.py:393\\n- The action execution server (jupyter-kernelgateway + ipykernel) cannot bind/connect\\n- Agent never actually executes any actions → no output files → verifier scores 0.0\\n- OpenHands version: 1.4.0\\n\\n2 false-positive non-zero scores:\\n- element-web MCP (1.0): Tests passed on pre-existing code because agent made no changes — verifier scored the unmodified state which happened to pass some tests\\n- django-rate-limit (0.05): Same pattern — verifier scored partial on existing repo state\\n\\nROOT CAUSE: OpenHands LocalRuntime is incompatible with Daytona sandbox networking. The LocalRuntime expects to bind localhost ports for its action execution server (jupyter-kernelgateway), but Daytona sandbox networking may not support this.\\n\\nPOSSIBLE FIXES:\\n1. Switch to DockerRuntime inside Daytona (nested Docker) — unlikely to work\\n2. Configure OpenHands to use a different port/socket binding\\n3. Run OpenHands tasks on local Docker instead of Daytona\\n4. Downgrade OpenHands to a version with compatible runtime\\n5. Debug the specific RuntimeError inside _wait_until_alive\\n\\nsgonly_verifier_wrapper.sh fix VERIFIED WORKING: before_repo_set_cmd correctly ran on the element-web MCP task (git reset + checkout visible in verifier log).\\n\\n1/18 task still running (element-web baseline — SWEAP image build on Daytona is slow).\"}","old_value":"{\"id\":\"CodeScaleBench-2kz\",\"title\":\"Verify harness fixes by rerunning historical Claude/OpenHands failures\",\"description\":\"Run a focused verification batch to prove the current task-contract and harness hardening eliminates the earlier random patch churn.\\n\\nScope:\\n- Claude Code regression sentinels:\\n - mcp_ccx-onboard-search-207\\n - mcp_ccx-onboard-search-208\\n - mcp_ccx-onboard-search-210\\n - mcp_bustub-hyperloglog-impl-001\\n - mcp_django-sensitive-file-exclusion-001\\n - mcp_flink-window-late-data-fix-001\\n - mcp_element-web-unread-indicators-diverge-fix-001\\n - clickhouse-mergetree-arch-understand-001 (confirm Daytona/local routing now that storage metadata was corrected)\\n- OpenHands regression sentinel:\\n - ccx-onboard-search-212\\n\\nAcceptance criteria:\\n- Produce a small rerun manifest or manifests for the tasks above.\\n- Execute the reruns once accounts are ready.\\n- Confirm whether each task now completes as a valid run without ad hoc task-specific patches.\\n- Record any remaining failures as either harness bugs, task bugs, or infra issues with exact root cause.\\n- If clean, note which tasks should remain in the smoke/verification matrix as permanent regression sentinels.\\n\",\"notes\":\"2026-03-09 OpenHands verification subset launched:\\n- 9 tasks x 2 configs (baseline + MCP) = 18 runs via Daytona\\n- Covers ALL 9 verifier families: checklist, continuous, diff_similarity, f1, ir_checklist, oracle_checks, repo_state_heuristic, semantic_similarity, test_ratio\\n- Also includes sgonly_verifier_wrapper.sh fix for SWE-bench Pro before_repo_set_cmd\\n- Run dir: runs/staging/openhands_sonnet46_20260309_205917\\n- Accounts: 1,2,4,5 (account3 held)\\n- Monitoring for completion and reward extraction\",\"status\":\"in_progress\",\"priority\":1,\"issue_type\":\"task\",\"owner\":\"sjarmak@users.noreply.github.com\",\"created_at\":\"2026-03-09T13:11:58Z\",\"created_by\":\"sjarmak\",\"updated_at\":\"2026-03-09T21:03:17Z\"}"} |
0 commit comments