@@ -175,15 +175,23 @@ complex unification, CES algebra operations, the uncertainty pipeline,
175175` pyphi.landscape ` , and the macro-construction intermediate cache. The open
176176remainder, each with its gate verdict:
177177
178- - ** Anytime certified Φ bracket** * (open build)* . Gate ** discharged** : the
179- empirical S(o) Eq. 15 upper bound on Σφ_r is proved a certified bound when
180- keyed on unit states (` experiments/so_certificate_experiments/FINDINGS.md ` ; index-keying
181- is proven unsound by a witnessed violation, so state-keying is mandatory).
182- Scope correction from the proof: with a complete distinction set an exact
183- identity computes Σφ_r in O(|D|·n), superseding the bracket there — its
184- genuine scope is partial or truncated distinction sets. The build is the
185- two-sided bracket in ` pyphi/formalism/iit4/bounds.py ` , its lower endpoint
186- rising as the landed relations ` strongest() ` streams relations (Tier 2).
178+ - ** Anytime certified Φ bracket** * (resolved negative — not built)* . The
179+ partial-distinction bracket was designed, built, and confirmed by experiment
180+ (` experiments/certified_bracket_experiments/FINDINGS.md ` ): the Approach-A
181+ bracket is ** sound** (0 violations over 5570 truncation points on 624
182+ systems) but ** useless for early-stopping** — median fraction of distinctions
183+ that must be computed before the interval closes to within 2× of the true Φ
184+ is 1.000, because a single un-evaluated distinction inflates the width from a
185+ median 0.21× to 34.7× via the exponential incidence term ` g(|𝒵(o)|) ` . It
186+ closes only when the CES is complete, where the exact state-keyed identity
187+ (` experiments/so_certificate_experiments/FINDINGS.md ` ; index-keying proven
188+ unsound, so state-keying is mandatory) already gives Σφ_r in O(|D|·n) and
189+ supersedes it. Approach B (density-budget LP) is not pursued — the looseness
190+ is in the incidence count, which a mass budget cannot cap. No
191+ ` bounds.py ` change. * Still open, distinct from the bracket:* exposing the
192+ measured ** complete** -distinction state-keyed certificate (~ 100–1000× tighter
193+ than the shipped ` GENERAL ` bound) as a certified measured bound in
194+ ` bounds.py ` .
187195- ** ii-gated grain scheduling** * (open build; 2026-cap arm only)* . The GID arm
188196 is dead: ` min(ii_c, ii_e) ≥ φ_s ` is ** refuted** under the 2023/GID measure
189197 (` experiments/ii_phi_inequality_experiments/FINDINGS.md ` ; minimal n=2 witness, margin
0 commit comments